1 6 Propagation Error
1 6 Propagation Error
06
Propagation of Errors
Here the upper equation is an approximation that can also serve as an upper
bound for the error. Please note that the rule is the same for addition and
subtraction of quantities.
Example:
Suppose we have measured the starting position as x1 = 9.3+-0.2 m and
the finishing position as x2 = 14.4+-0.3 m. Then the displacement is:
01.06.1
01.06.2 Chapter 01.06
Again the upper line is an approximation and the lower line is the exact
result for independent random uncertainties in the individual variables. And
again please note that for the purpose of error calculation there is no
difference between multiplication and division.
Example:
We have measured a displacement of x = 5.1+-0.4 m during a time of t =
0.4+-0.1 s. What is the average velocity and the error in the average
velocity?
If you compare this to the above rule for multiplication of two quantities,
you see that this is just the special case of that rule for the uncertainty in
c, c = 0.
Propagation of Errors 01.06.3
Example:
If an object is released from rest and is in free fall, and if you measure the
velocity of this object at some point to be v = - 3.8+-0.3 m/s, how long
has it been in free fall?
4. Polynomial functions
What if there is a dependence of the result on the measured quantity X that
is not described by simple multiplications or additions? We will state the
general answer for R as a general function of one or more variables below,
but will first cover the special case that R is a polynomial function of one
variable X.
You see that this rule is quite simple and holds for positive or negative
numbers n, which can even be non-integers.
5. General functions
And finally, we can express the uncertainty in R for general functions of one
or more observables. If R is a function of X and Y, written as R(X,Y), then
the uncertainty in R is obtained by taking the partial derivatives of R with
respect to each variable, multiplication with the uncertainty in that variable,
and addition of these individual terms in quadrature.
01.06.4 Chapter 01.06
If a calculation is made with numbers that are not exact, then the calculation itself will have
an error. How do the errors in each individual number propagate through the calculations.
Example 1
Find the bounds for the propagation error in adding two numbers. For example if one is
calculating X Y where
X 1.5 0.05 ,
Y 3.4 0.04 .
Solution
By looking at the numbers, the maximum possible value of X and Y are
X 1.55 and Y 3.44
Hence
X Y 1.55 3.44 4.99
is the maximum value of X Y .
The minimum possible value of X and Y are
X 1.45 and Y 3.36 .
Hence
X Y 1.45 3.36
4.81
is the minimum value of X Y .
Hence
4.81 X Y 4.99.
One can find similar intervals of the bound for the other arithmetic operations of
X Y , X * Y , and X / Y . What if the evaluations we are making are function evaluations
instead? How do we find the value of the propagation error in such cases.
If f is a function of several variables X 1 , X 2 , X 3 ,.......,X n 1 , X n , then the maximum
possible value of the error in f is
f f f f
f X 1 X 2 ....... X n 1 X n
X 1 X 2 X n 1 X n
Example 2
The strain in an axial member of a square cross-section is given by
F
2
h E
where
F =axial force in the member, N
h = length or width of the cross-section, m
E =Young’s modulus, Pa
Propagation of Errors 01.06.5
Given
F 72 0.9 N
h 4 0.1 mm
E 70 1.5 GPa
Find the maximum possible error in the measured strain.
Solution
72
3 2
(4 10 ) (70 10 9 )
64.286 10 6
64.286
F h E
F h E
1
2
F h E
2F
3
h h E
F
2 2
E h E
1 2F F
2 F 3 h 2 2 E
h E h E h E
1 2 72
3 2
0.9 3 3
0.0001
(4 10 ) (70 10 )
9
(4 10 ) (70 10 9 )
72
3 2
1.5 10 9
(4 10 ) (70 10 9 ) 2
8.0357 10 7 3.2143 10 6 1.3776 10 6
5.3955 10 6
5.3955
Hence
(64.286 5.3955 )
implying that the axial strain, is between 58.8905 and 69.6815
Example 3
Subtraction of numbers that are nearly equal can create unwanted inaccuracies. Using the
formula for error propagation, show that this is true.
Solution
Let
z x y
Then
z z
z x y
x y
01.06.6 Chapter 01.06
(1)x (1)y
x y
So the absolute relative change is
z x y
z x y
As x and y become close to each other, the denominator becomes small and hence create
large relative errors.
For example if
x 2 0.001
y 2.003 0.001
z 0.001 0.001
z | 2 2.003 |
= 0.6667
= 66.67%
Additional information: