The Use of Smartwatches For Health Monitoring in Home-Based Dementia Care
The Use of Smartwatches For Health Monitoring in Home-Based Dementia Care
The Use of Smartwatches For Health Monitoring in Home-Based Dementia Care
net/publication/280946621
CITATIONS READS
36 3,046
3 authors:
Brynjar F Landmark
Inland Hospital Trust
44 PUBLICATIONS 895 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Continuity in long-term home health care. Perspectives of managers, patients and their next of kin View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Costas Boletsis on 14 August 2015.
1 Introduction
Dementia is one of the most significant problems facing social welfare systems
[11, 10]. There are an estimated 35.6 million people with dementia worldwide.
This number will nearly double every 20 years, to an estimated 65.7 million in
2030, and 115.4 million in 2050 [1].
People with dementia experience progressive cognitive impairments that typ-
ically commence with short term memory problems, but can encompass lan-
guage deficits, difficulties initiating tasks, planning, monitoring and regulating
behaviour, visuospatial difficulties, agnosia and apraxia [5, 11]. Dementia, being
2 Costas Boletsis, Simon McCallum, and Brynjar Fowels Landmark
Fig. 1. The continuum of normal ageing and Alzheimer’s cognitive decline [19].
In this paper, we test the assumption that the use of smartwatches (i.e. comput-
erised wristwatches) for monitoring physical health aspects of dementia patients
can benefit formal home-based care, by providing the physician with additional,
important information about significant events that may have happened dur-
ing the day, and which may not be recollected by the dementia patient in a
later session, or witnessed by the visiting nurse. The contribution of this work
is summarised as follows:
2 Related work
Cahill et al. [5] provide an overview of the dementia care and the effect of tech-
nology on the dementia treatment. This study provides a detailed report of the
dementia’s clinical aspects and stresses the need for further technological ad-
vances. It also documents the user requirements and user needs that the new
technological systems and devices should fulfil, in order to support formal care-
givers, promote patients’ independence and maximise quality of life.
In the same context, Topo [20] maps out the academic space to document the
relationship between technology and dementia, by performing a literature review
of studies which focus on technology supporting people with dementia and their
4 Costas Boletsis, Simon McCallum, and Brynjar Fowels Landmark
caregivers. The review analyses 46 studies with original data, as to their goals,
the technology used, the treatment environment and the experimental designs.
The review of Topo documents the academic work in the researched field and,
at the same time, acts as a source of valuable methodological information and
issues, which can be of great significance for future related projects.
Through the studies of Cahill et al. [5] and Topo [20], valuable information
about the technical, financial, social, and design features of a future dementia-
related technological system can be obtained. The basic user requirements, user
needs, as well as experimental and formal health-care logistics are satisfied
by the technology of the smartwatch, as supported in the studies of Raghu-
nath & Narayanaswami [14] and Shin et al. [17]. The study of Raghunath &
Narayanaswami [14] is an early exploration of the smartwatch’s technical fea-
tures, revealing its potential as a promising interface paradigm. Shin et al. [17]
put the previous knowledge into practice, by utilising a smartwatch device for
monitoring the location of dementia patients (in case of wandering) and for de-
tecting the user’ steps, in order to further analyse the patients’ activities. The
step detection algorithm of the smartwatch showed a promising 94% accuracy,
highlighting the need for the extraction of more physical data from the smart-
watch use and for “a more comprehensive analysis of a patient’s activities...”
[17]. Basis B1 (developed by Basis Science Inc.) is a smartwatch that can track
accurately several activity states (i.e. sleeping, walking, being active). The Basis
B1 smartwatch was used in a sleep-related study of Patel et al. [13], where it
was shown that the sleep analysis algorithm of the smartwatch demonstrated
excellent agreement with polysomnography data for sleep duration and sleep
staging.
not always easy [5, 9]. Today, there is a wide range of different technologies that
can be adapted and used for people with dementia, to help them maintain their
independence and improve their health status and quality of life. People react
differently to different assistive technologies and there are no quick fix solutions
in dementia care, nor do solutions necessarily have to be highly technical [5].
The nature of dementia may make people cautious and suspicious of try-
ing new devices [5]. Therefore certain user requirements should be taken into
consideration, according to Cahill et al. [5]:
– the new device/product should fulfil the individual and formal caregiver
needs,
– the design of the product is important, focusing on its familiarity and the
fact that no new learning should be required on the part of the person with
a dementia,
– a comprehensive assessment of needs should take place ideally at home with
a health service professional fully trained in dementia care,
– pre-testing is critical to ensure that the chosen device/product is reliable
and effective, and
– it is important to find a product that suits the individual and is not complex
or stigmatising.
In this study, we propose the use of smartwaches for monitoring the physical
functions of dementia patients. A smartwatch has many attractive features as a
form factor for a wearable computer. It has the advantage of always being with
the user, having a ubiquitous and non-intrusive presence, its design - being a
wristwatch - is quite familiar, and its use is not complex or stigmatising [14].
Fig. 2. The back side (left) and the front side (right) of Basis B1.
The Basis B1 band is built around five sensors that act in concert and si-
multaneously in real time to provide a view of a persons health immediately
and over extended periods of time: optical blood flow sensor, 3D accelerometer,
body temperature, ambient temperature reading, and galvanic skin response [2].
Rather than make assumptions from limited metrics, Basis uses all five of its
sensors and its analysis to estimate the current state of the user [2].
Since the Basis is not a medical device, there is the issue of the validity and
accuracy of the physical health data. In this study, we do not deal with the
correlation between the “gold standard” medical devices and the Basis B1; we
examine the smartwatch’s feasibility for providing additional, potentially useful
physical information about the dementia patient.
3.5 Results
The usability study gave us valuable insight on the smartwatch’s use by frail
elderly.
– The smartwatch did not cause any discomfort or anxiety to the participant,
as it acquired the role of a regular watch. Consequently, the smartwatch was
used only as a time indicator and the participant was able to read the numer-
icals on the display. The charging of the device was taking place during the
doctor’s or nurse’s visit and the smartwatch was removed during the process.
8 Costas Boletsis, Simon McCallum, and Brynjar Fowels Landmark
– A discovered issue was that almost no walking steps and activity were
recorded, due to the use of the walking frame by the participant. Further-
more, for short periods of time there were disruptions in the smartwatch’s
functionality (Fig. 3, Fig. 5). Apart from those minor issues - which did
not affect the final measurements - the sensors were functioning properly,
getting the additional measurements, i.e. heart rate, skin temperature, and
perspiration.
The project’s physician was able to extract useful information regarding the
participant’s daily activities and physical state from the devices measurements.
The analysis of the measurements is patient-specific and the patient’s medical
background plays an important part in the process. However, the range of in-
formation (direct or indirect) that can be obtained from the smartwatch are
indicative of its potential for use with dementia patients. The main observations
from the Basis’ use are presented hereafter.
– The patient was up many times in the night, which the advanced dementia
patient cannot recall the next morning. Night disturbances are part of the
behavioural disturbances of dementia and are difficult to quantify (Fig. 3).
– Steps are not registered when using a walking frame, however the patients
heart rate increased at any effort, revealing patterns of activities, such as
toilet visits (Fig. 3). This is a common problem in patients with this degree
of disability, who are not able to notify their surroundings; it is all up to
the caretakers to recognise the change in behaviour or frequency. Changes in
this pattern, together with temperature/perspiration, may alert caretakers
to e.g. recognise a urine infection and take a urine sample to the physician.
– The total registered sleeping time for the participant was 12-16 hours (Fig.
4); the registered data sums up naps and total daytime snoozing in a man-
ner the caretakers are not able to evaluate accurately. The majority of the
Fig. 3. An indicative day’s measurements, showing the disrupted sleep pattern and the
heart rate increases of the participant.
The use of smartwatches for health monitoring in home-based dementia care 9
Fig. 4. A day’s measurements, presenting the total sleeping time in a 24-hour period.
– When the home care nurse arrives for morning assistance (around 10:00-
11:00 am), the Basis monitor can indicate when the patient woke up. In
many instances, the patient had been awake for three hours before assistance
arrived. The arrival hours may be adjusted to the patients need.
Fig. 5. An instance of the participant waking up at 7:00 am, but getting out of bed at
11:00 am (perspiration drops), when the home care nurse arrives.
4 Discussion
It is true that home-based care cannot be provided to the patient on a 24/7 basis.
However, a smartwatch monitoring device, like the Basis B1, can provide formal
care with user’s health information, for those hours that are not covered by the
caretakers’ visit. Especially for cognitive impaired, elderly patients - where the
self-reporting method can be unreliable or even impossible - such devices can
10 Costas Boletsis, Simon McCallum, and Brynjar Fowels Landmark
5 Conclusion
The study - even though constrained by certain limitations - assisted in acquiring
meaningful data that would be difficult or even impossible to otherwise acquire.
The ultimate outcome of the study is the promising potential that a smart-
watch device can have for dementia patients in home-based care. Additional
features like an alert notification system (setting patient-personalised measure-
ments’ “thresholds”), GPS functionality (addressing the wandering problem),
and a local database with limited access (for secure access and storing of sen-
sitive health information) could be implemented as part of a future certified,
medical, smartwatch device.
References
1. Alzheimer’s Disease International: Dementia statistics (2014), http://www.alz.
co.uk/research/statistics, Accessed: 2014-12-26
2. Basis Science Inc.: Basis B1 Band Presents the Whole Picture - in Real Time,
All the Time (2011), http://www.mybasis.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/
BasisTechnologyOverview1014111.pdf, Accessed: 2014-12-22
3. Beauvais, B.S., Rialle, V., Sablier, J.: Myvigi: An android application to detect
fall and wandering. In: UBICOMM 2012, The Sixth International Conference on
Mobile Ubiquitous Computing, Systems, Services and Technologies. pp. 156–160
(2012)
4. Boletsis, C., McCallum, S.: Connecting the player to the doctor: util-
ising serious games for cognitive training & screening. In: NordiCHI’14
Workshop on Designing Self-Care for Everyday Life (2014), https:
//designingselfcareforeverydaylife.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/
connecting-the-player-to-the-doctor.pdf, Accessed: 2015-01-28
5. Cahill, S., Macijauskiene, J., Nygrd, A., Faulkner, J., Hagen, I.: Technology in
dementia care. Technology and Disability 19(2), 55–60 (2007)
6. Comas-Herrera, A., Northey, S., Wittenberg, R., Knapp, M., Bhattacharyya, S.,
Burns, A.: Future costs of dementia-related long-term care: exploring future sce-
narios. International Psychogeriatrics 23, 20–30 (2011)
7. Fonteyn, M., Bauer-Wu, S.: Using qualitative evaluation in a feasibility study to
improve and refine a complementary therapy intervention prior to subsequent re-
search. Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice 11(4), 247 – 252 (2005)
8. Jönsson, L., Eriksdotter-Jönhagen, M., Kilander, L., Soininen, H., Hallikainen, M.,
Waldemar, G., Nygaard, H., Andreasen, N., Winblad, B., Wimo, A.: Determinants
of costs of care for patients with Alzheimer’s disease. International Journal of
Geriatric Psychiatry 21(5), 449–459 (2006)
12 Costas Boletsis, Simon McCallum, and Brynjar Fowels Landmark
9. Marshall, M.: ASTRID: A Social and Technological Response to Meeting the Needs
of Individuals with Dementia and Their Carers. Hawker Publications (2000)
10. McCallum, S.: Gamification and serious games for personalized health. Studies in
Health Technology and Informatics 177, 85–96 (2012)
11. Norwegian Ministry of Health and Care Services: Dementia Plan 2015: making the
most of good days. Norwegian Ministry of Health and Care Services (2007)
12. Paganelli, F., Giuli, D.: An ontology-based system for context-aware and config-
urable services to support home-based continuous care. Information Technology in
Biomedicine, IEEE Transactions on 15(2), 324–333 (2011)
13. Patel, S., Ahmed, T., Lee, J., Ruoff, L., Unadkat, T.: Validation of
Basis Science Advanced Sleep Analysis: Estimation of Sleep Stages and
Sleep Duration (2014), http://www.mybasis.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/
Validation-of-Basis-Science-Advanced-Sleep-Analysis.pdf, Accessed: 2014-
12-22
14. Raghunath, M.T., Narayanaswami, C.: User interfaces for applications on a wrist
watch. Personal Ubiquitous Computing 6(1), 17–30 (2002)
15. Schwarzmeier, A., Besser, J., Weigel, R., Fischer, G., Kissinger, D.: A compact
back-plaster sensor node for dementia and Alzheimer patient care. In: Sensors
Applications Symposium (SAS), 2014 IEEE. pp. 75–78 (2014)
16. Schwenk, M., Hauer, K., Dutzi, I., Mohler, J., Najafi, B.: Predicting in-hospital
falls in geriatric patients with dementia using one body-worn sensor. Journal of
the American Geriatrics Society 62, S146–S147 (2014)
17. Shin, D.M., Shin, D., Shin, D.: Smart watch and monitoring system for dementia
patients. In: Grid and Pervasive Computing, Lecture Notes in Computer Science,
vol. 7861, pp. 577–584. Springer (2013)
18. Smith, S., Lamping, D., Banerjee, S., Harwood, R., Foley, B., Smith, P., Cook, J.,
Murray, J., Prince, M., Levin, E., Mann, A., Knapp, M.: Measurement of health-
related quality of life for people with dementia: development of a new instrument
(DEMQOL) and an evaluation of current methodology. Health Technology Assess-
ment 9(10), 1–93 (2005)
19. Sperling, R.A., Aisen, P.S., Beckett, L.A., Bennett, D.A., Craft, S., Fagan, A.M.,
Iwatsubo, T., Jack, C.R., Kaye, J., Montine, T.J., Park, D.C., Reiman, E.M.,
Rowe, C.C., Siemers, E., Stern, Y., Yaffe, K., Carrillo, M.C., Thies, B., Morrison-
Bogorad, M., Wagster, M.V., Phelps, C.H.: Toward defining the preclinical stages
of Alzheimer’s disease: Recommendations from the National Institute on Aging-
Alzheimer’s Association workgroups on diagnostic guidelines for Alzheimer’s dis-
ease. Alzheimer’s & Dementia 7(3), 280–292 (2011)
20. Topo, P.: Technology studies to meet the needs of people with dementia and their
caregivers: A literature review. Journal of Applied Gerontology 28(1), 5–37 (2009)
21. Wimo, A., Jnsson, L., Gustavsson, A., McDaid, D., Ersek, K., Georges, J., Gulcsi,
L., Karpati, K., Kenigsberg, P., Valtonen, H.: The economic impact of dementia in
europe in 2008 - cost estimates from the eurocode project. International Journal
of Geriatric Psychiatry 26(8), 825–832 (2011)
22. Woolham, J.: Assistive Technology in Dementia Care: Developing the Role of Tech-
nology in the Care and Rehabilitation of People with Dementia - Current Trends
and Perspectives. Hawker Publications (2006)
23. World Health Organization: Dementia - a public health priority (2014), http:
//www.who.int/mental_health/neurology/dementia/en/, Accessed: 2014-12-27