Study On Poly Bag Manufacturing
Study On Poly Bag Manufacturing
net/publication/261498630
CITATION READS
1 9,551
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Ruwan Chandra Gopura on 27 April 2014.
Abstract- The material prices of poly bags increase with [8]. They presented the simulation tool SLX [9] and the
high degree of fluctuation and forecasters see no end to visualization tool Skopeo [10], which were both utilized to
this trend. Further, legal restrictions imposed on certain perform a prototype federation of a manufacturing plant.
types of polythene products adversely affect the demand.
In the light of the above, entrepreneurs of the poly bag In this study, initially a typical poly bag manufacturing
manufacturing face many challenges. In this study, an system is analyzed [11] to find out risks and bottlenecks of
analysis and a simulation of a poly bag manufacturing the system. In the preliminary analysis, risk and bottleneck
system were carried out to improve the productivity to analyses were carried out. A risk prioritization method was
face the underlying challenges. This paper presents also proposed in the risk analysis. The risks were prioritized
analysis, modeling and simulation methods of the system. based on their effects for the system. Then a mathematical
In addition, a risk prioritization method was proposed at model of the poly bag manufacturing system was developed
the preliminary analysis and also a simulation tool was
developed. with reasonable assumptions to obtain the optimum
throughput time of a given type of a poly bag under available
I. INTRODUCTION plant capabilities and to minimize the material wastage of the
current production setup. The system was simulated using the
The poly bag products are indispensable in day-to-day life. models described in section IV-E. The production schedule
Poly bag manufacturing industry faces major challenges since for maximum productivity was generated for the input
the material prices of poly bags increase with high degree of customer orders. For simulation, a graphical user interface
fluctuation and imposed legal restrictions on certain types of (GUI) driven simulation tool was developed using MATLAB
polythene products which result in a grave decline in demand. 7.2 software [12].
Under these circumstances, it is important to identify and
analyze the problems of the poly bag manufacturing systems, II. THE POLY BAG MANUFACTURING SYSTEM
so that solutions can be recommend for the posed challenges.
High density polyethylene (HDPE), low density In this study, we selected a typical poly bag manufacturing
polyethylene (LDPE), linear low density polyethylene system [11] of which the main process was film blowing.
(LLDPE), and polypropylene (PP) are basically used as raw Figure 1 shows a simplified schematic diagram of film
materials for the poly bag manufacturing [1]. The main blowing process [1], [2]. In film blowing, single screw
process of polybag manufacturing is film blowing [1], [2]. It extruder melts the polymer and pumps it into a tubular die
was followed by subsequent processes namely cutting, and air was blown into the center of the extruded tube causing
sealing, printing, quality checking, and packing. The majority an expansion in the radial direction. Radial and downstream
of the research in the area of poly bag manufacturing was extension stops at the freeze line (due to crystallization). Nip
focused in a single process- the film blowing process [3]-[5]. rolls collect the film and seal the top of the bubble to maintain
In the film blowing, a significant work has been carried out to pressure inside. Simplified production process flow diagram
show how polymer rheology interacts with the process [5]. of the selected system is shown in Fig. 2 [11]. The films
Relatively, little work has been done in modeling and produced in the film blowing is printed and inspected. Then
simulation of film blowing process. However, researches poly bag making was carried out by cutting and sealing of the
have been tried out the simulation of manufacturing processes films. Quality checking (QC) and inspection mark the end of
[6]-[8]. Brown et al. [6] implemented performance modeling poly bag manufacturing process. Subsequently packing
capability (simulation, capacity analysis, and cost analysis) at operation is carried out.
factories of Siemens Semiconductor for both wafer The network diagram of the selected poly bag
fabrication and back-end operations. Graul et al. [7] presented manufacturing system is shown in Fig. 3. Poly bag
a concept and a framework to capture and maintain the manufacturing system of the factory is a multi-channel multi-
multiple descriptions and its applicability in modeling and phase system with buffer storages of work in progress (WIP)
simulation of manufacturing systems. They described a at three places, namely after extrusion of film, after printing,
knowledge-based approach to support the integration of and prior to QC. Although the film extrusion process is a
multiple descriptions with collected data from legacy status continuous process, there is no online feeding mechanism in
for the use in the design and generation of valid simulation the printing machine and therefore, the film manufactured is
models. An overview of current tendencies in the accumulated on the film storage area until it is fed to printing
manufacturing area, Schumann et al. introduces a method to machines depending on the urgency of the orders and the
integrate high level architecture and existing simulation tools availability of printing machines. In case of frequently
manufacturing and the business of the system were identified
and they were prioritized according to their effects to the
system. Then weights were given from scale of 10 according
to the priority of risks. The risk bar-chat was drawn from the
weight values of risks to indicate the effects of risk.
1. Risk Prioritization
Fig. 1: Simplified film blowing process In the risk prioritization, the qualitative effect of each risk
for the production and the business of the factory were
calculated under few criteria: productivity, performance,
output, and profit. Since the most of the data obtained were
qualitative, a five-point Likert scale was used to find
quantitative value of each criterion. The five-point Likert
Fig. 2: Simplified production process flow diagram scale is shown in Fig. 4. Then the weighted averages of the
quantitative values were calculated using equation (1).
ΣQL × 10 (1)
Weight =
QVH × N
where QL, QVH, N are quantitative value from Likert scale,
quantitative value of “Very High” in Likert scale and
numbers of criteria, respectively.
TABLE VIII
PRODUCTION SCHEDULE (ALL TIMES ARE IN MINUTES)
Production Film blowing Printing Bag making QC and Throughput Bags print in machine
Order
start time time time time handling time time one colour two colour
1 0 84.96 416.00 15.07 460.00 976.03 1000 1000
2 977.00 23.43 120.00 8.50 146.47 298.40 600 600
3 1276.00 11.24 150.00 4.69 88.80 254.73 0 750
4 1531.00 28.13 888.89 9.15 125.11 1051.27 0 1500
four menu items in the menu bar: input, output, simulation, allocation in accordance with the product type causes to
and help. In the input menu four sub-menus are available: increase the manufacturing productivity. QC conceded a
load parameter, edit parameter, customer order, and exit. considerably large production time. Therefore, a work study
Load parameter and edit parameter sub-menus are for loading should be carried out in QC process and a suitable training
and updating the input parameter of the simulation. Customer program should be carried out for the staff of the QC division
orders can be checked and updated from the customer orders accordingly. The following points will be interesting topics
sub-menu. Few snap shots of developed GUI are shown in for future study in this area: incorporating a pricing system
Fig. 7 and Fig. 8. and optimizing the profit of the company rather than the
production times, develop a material price forecasting system
CONCLUSION
and generating the optimum inventory schedule for a given
This paper presented an analysis, a modeling and time horizon, adaptation of wastage recycling into the
simulation of a poly bag manufacturing system. A graphical simulation tool.
user interface driven simulation tool was also developed for
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
the simulation. In the simulation, system simulation and
Monte Carlo simulation were performed to calculate the The authors would like to extend their sincere gratitude to
optimum throughput time of a given type of a poly bag under Thermo Plastic (Pvt) Ltd, Sri Lanka, Hemantha Munasinghe,
available capabilities of the plant and to minimize the Asiri Amarasena, and Dr. (Mrs.) Nirosha Agalawatta.
material wastage under the current production setup. In
REFERENCES
addition, a method of calculating production schedule was
developed for the system. [1] Available:http://plastics.turkavkaz.ru/processes/extrusion/blown-film-
From the system simulation results, it can be seen that the extrusion/ [Accessed on 12 November 2008]
[2] I. Thomas and E. D. Butler. “Film Extrusion Manual: Process,
maximum contribution for the minimum throughput time is Materials, Properties. 2nd Edition”, 2005.
from the film accumulation time on the roller. That varies [3] X. L. Luo and R. I. Tanner, “A Computer Study of Film Blowing”,
about 90%-97% according to the product. Instead of that Article, 2005.
[4] V. Sidiropoulos, J. J. Tian and J. Vlachopoulos, “Computer Simulation
generally, QC time, handling and packing time, and printing of Film Blowing”, Journal of Plastic Film & Sheeting. vol. 12, no. 2,
time contribute about 2%-6%, 0.30%-0.8%, and 0.3%-2%, pp. 107-129, 1996.
respectively for the minimum throughput time in almost all of [5] I. A. Muslet and M. R. Kamal, “Computer Simulation of the Film
product that used for the simulation. Bag making gives the Blowing Process Incorporating Crystallization and Viscoelasticity”,
Journal of Rheology, vol. 48, Issue 3, pp. 525-534, 2004.
lowest contribution for the minimum throughput time. The [6] S. Brown, F. Chance, J. W. Fowler and J. Robinson, “A Centralized
contributions of the printing time, film blowing time, and bag Approach to Factory Simulation”, Future Fab International, 1997.
making time for the minimum manufacturing time are about [7] M. Graul, F. Boydstun, M. Harris, R. Mayer and O. Bagaturova,
“Integrated Framework for Modeling & Simulation of Complex
79%-94%, 3%-16%, and 2%-6%, respectively. Production Systems”, Knowledge Based Systems, Inc, 2003.
According to the results of the preliminary analysis and the [8] M. Schumann, E. Bluemel, T. Schulze, S. Strassburger and K. C. Ritter,
simulation of the selected poly bag manufacturing system the “Using HLA for Factory Simulation”, in Proc. of Fall Simulation
suggestions and recommendations for a better system can be Interoperability Workshop, 1998.
[9] J. O. Henriksen, “An introduction to SLX”, in Proc. of The Winter
categorized under production planning, inventory control, Simulation Conference, 1997, pp. 559-566.
wastage minimizing, and resource allocation. Proper [10] K. C. Ritter, “Skopeo-Animation”, http://simos2.cs.uni-magdeburg.de/
production planning can be carried out to eliminate the line skopeo/ [Accessed on 05 July 2008]
balancing and idling problems. Proper inventory control [11] Available: http://www.thermosl.com [Accessed on 12 November 2008]
[12] Available: http://www.mathworks.com/products/ [Accessed on 10
method should be applied to improve the inventory control to November 2008]
face the challenges in periodic fluctuations in material prices [13] J. Wang, “Process Bottleneck Analysis and Production Scheduling of
though the randomness component of the material price Process Industry”. PhD Dissertation, Tsinghua University, Beijing,
China, 2008.
fluctuation cannot be determined. The proper resource