Production Operation Management: Zara Case Study Solutions
Production Operation Management: Zara Case Study Solutions
Prepared by:
Mohammad Farid
1941
F.Y.BBA
Case’s Questions and Solutions
Question 1:
According to Richard Hyman, Vertical integration has gone out of fashion in the consumer
economy. Zara is a spectacular exception to the rule. Explain how Zara used its vertically
integrated supply chain to its advantage. What are the drawbacks of having a highly vertically
integrated supply chain for a fashion retailing company? Explain
Answer 1:
Zara has the competitive advantage of vertical integration to be sustainable.
Zara’s success is based on its vertically integrated supply chain system that
achieves a speed of response to market demand in the fast moving fashion
clothing sector.
Zara’s cycles of design, production, and distribution are substantially faster
than any of its main competitors. (6months-3weeks)
The strength of Zara lies in having the new design product on the retail
counter within 2 weeks time. This is due to its very closely integrated supply
network.
For its own production, 40% of fabric requirements are supplied by Comidex
a wholly owned subsidiary of Inditex.
Finished products are ironed, labelled, bagged in boxes or on hangers ready for
retail display, and then transferred by monorail to the Spain distribution center.
Each retail store submits its orders twice a week and receives shipments twice a
week. Orders are dispatched within eight hours of receipt and are delivered
within few days.
Zara's compressed product cycles have induced changes in customers retail
buying behavior (more frequent visits/faster purchase decisions)
Zara's vertical integration works for Zara because it fits with other aspects of its
strategy: mid-market pricing, high-fashion orientation, and constantly changing
product range.
Zara is playing both roles of the manufacturer and the retailer and hence is
capable of making more profits than any of its close competitors.
Disadvantages:
Question 2:
In the light of Zara’s global expansion in far-off locations like Asia and America, what
modifications according to you, the company has to bring in its supply chain and why?
Answer 2:
o Decentralization of its supply chain.
o Having multiple vertical integrations
o Outsource some of its operations to other countries which helps in cost
cutting.
o Come up with advertisements to create awareness of the brand when
expanding in other countries.
o Use cheaper means of transport and also make air cargo agreements in
bulk to minimize the transportation costs and speed delivery.
o Efficient packaging of inventory.
Question 3:
Most of the supply chain management efforts by organizations now-a-days are aimed at
minimizing costs rather than on maximizing revenues. However Zara's supply chain management
practices are an exception. Do you think Zara should continue with these practices or should aim
at reducing costs so as to maximize profits? Take a stand and justify.
Answer 3:
Today Zara is moving ahead and is progressing to attaining a larger global market by
expanding to both the American continent as well as the Asian region. In this aspect and
looking at the future of the growth of Zara it is suggested that Zara should continue with
its vertically integrated supply chain management but at the same time should resort to
outsourcing and utilization of the multiple vertical integrated supply chain.
The fewer the number of firms, the greater are the transaction costs and bigger the
advantages of Vertical Integration.
The greater are information asymmetries, the more likely is opportunistic behavior and
the greater the advantages of Vertical Integration. This will be effective in the European
Markets.