Scientific American201908
Scientific American201908
Scientific American201908
46
FRINGE PHYSICS PAGE
58
How they decide whether to back off or brawl Wild ways to propel our species to the stars
SEA
CHANGE
The contest to control
the fast-melting Arctic
S
PLU
THREE-BODY
PROBLEM AUGUST 2019
Can an ancient math ScientificAmerican.com
VO LU M E 3 2 1 , N U M B E R 2
SP
EC I
AL REPO
RT
58
FU
C
TI
U
T
RE
C
R
OF THE A
26 Arctic Ambitions
28 Divide or Conquer
Five nations are using science
to assert rights to vast,
overlapping portions of
the Arctic Ocean seafloor.
By Mark Fischetti
34 Setting Boundaries
By Katie Peek
37 A New Reality
Climate change is dramatically
altering life at the top of the
world. By Mark Fischetti
38 Land of Change
By Katie Peek
40 Is Confrontation
Inevitable?
Political tensions are rising, but
cooperation could still prevail.
By Kathrin Stephen
44 The Busy North
By Katie Peek PHYSIC S
58 The Good Kind of Crazy
A N I M A L B E H AV I O R Traditional rockets won’t get us
46 When Animals Fight to the stars. With NASA backing,
Conventional wisdom holds that some scientists are pushing against
the ability to assess a rival’s fighting the edges of physics to find out
ability is universal in the animal what far-fetched ideas will.
kingdom. Recent research has By Sarah Scoles
shown otherwise. By Gareth Arnott M AT H E M AT I C S ON tHE C OVE R
and Robert W. Elwood 66 The Three-Body Problem Sea ice breaks apart on June 6, 2019, in the
Amundsen Gulf, far into the Arctic Ocean
MEDICINE Mathematicians know they can above Canada’s Northwest Territories. The
52 Darwin’s Cancer Fix never fully “solve” this ancient thawing seas have inspired Arctic states and
Principles of evolution and natural puzzle. That hasn’t stopped other countries to vie for seafloor rights to oil
selection drive a radical new drug them from studying it—and and natural gas deposits, shipping lanes and
even military positioning in the high north.
approach and prevention strategies. making intriguing discoveries Photograph by NASA Earth Observing
By James DeGregori and along the way. System Data and Information System
Robert Gatenby By Richard Montgomery (https://worldview.earthdata.nasa.gov)
10 Forum
A wild fix for climate change that just might work.
By Rob Jackson and Pep Canadell
12 Advances
What makes great white sharks afraid. Reporting sexual
harassment comes at a cost. Predicting space weather
8 blackouts. A breathing bag that could save lives.
24 Ventures
We must match the breakneck speed of 20th-century
world-changing technologies. By Wade Roush
76 Recommended
Air pollution kills. A dream of the periodic table of ele-
ments. The Ebola saga continues. By Andrea Gawrylewski
77 The Intersection
Kids shouldn’t necessarily learn to code. By Zeynep Tufekci
12 78 Anti Gravity
Can we do physics with math alone? By Steve Mirsky
ON THE WEB
Scientific American (ISSN 0036-8733), Volume 321, Number 2, August 2019, published monthly by Scientific American, a division of Springer Nature America, Inc., 1 New York Plaza, Suite 4600, New York, N.Y. 10004-1562.
Periodicals postage paid at New York, N.Y., and at additional mailing offices. Canada Post International Publications Mail (Canadian Distribution) Sales Agreement No. 40012504. Canadian BN No. 127387652RT; TVQ1218059275
TQ0001. Publication Mail Agreement #40012504. Return undeliverable mail to Scientific American, P.O. Box 819, Stn Main, Markham, ON L3P 8A2. Individual Subscription rates: 1 year $49.99 (USD), Canada $59.99 (USD),
International $69.99 (USD). Institutional Subscription rates: Schools and Public Libraries: 1 year $84 (USD), Canada $89 (USD), International $96 (USD). Businesses and Colleges/Universities: 1 year $399 (USD), Canada
$405 (USD), International $411 (USD). Postmaster: Send address changes to Scientific American, Box 3187, Harlan, Iowa 51537. Reprints inquiries: (212) 451-8415. To request single copies or back issues, call
(800) 333-1199. Subscription inquiries: U.S. and Canada (800) 333-1199; other (515) 248-7684. Send e-mail to [email protected].
Printed in U.S.A. Copyright © 2019 by Scientific American, a division of Springer Nature America, Inc. All rights reserved.
Scientific American is part of Springer Nature, which owns or has commercial relations with thousands of scientific publications (many of them can be found at www.springernature.com/us). Scientific American maintains
a strict policy of editorial independence in reporting developments in science to our readers. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
What’s Next and other so-called greenhouse gases are affecting climate is the
story of our shared human experience globally. We at Scientific
American look at various impacts nearly daily online and in ev-
for the Arctic? ery print issue. In this edition, we present a special report and
cover story, “Future of the Arctic,” starting on page 26.
Coordinated by senior editor Mark Fischetti, the package
In 1894 John William Strutt, Lord looks at the geopolitical consequences of a fast-melting re-
Rayleigh—who later went on to gar- gion: how different countries are vying for control (“Di-
ner the 1904 Nobel Prize in Physics— vide or Conquer,” by Fischetti), how rapid environ-
penned an appreciation in Scientific mental alterations are transforming life at the pu-
American about the work of John Tyn- tative top of the world (“A New Reality,” by
dall, an Irish physics professor, mathe- Fischetti), and what to do about rising politi-
matician, geologist, atmospheric scientist, cal tensions (“Is Confrontation Inevitable?”
public lecturer and mountaineer. by political scientist and scientific group
“The most important work,” Strutt wrote, leader Kathrin Stephen).
“that we owe to Tyndall in connection with Not all change is so far-reaching,
heat is the investigation of the absorption by of course. On a more prosaic note,
gaseous bodies of invisible radiation.” Tyndall’s I’ll soon become dean of the Col-
work showed the power of gases such as water lege of Communication at Boston
vapor and “carbonic acid”—today known as car- University, my alma mater. I love
bon dioxide—to absorb heat and later speculated Scientific American and am hugely grateful
on such gases’ effect on climate. Strutt himself re- for the privilege of my 18 years here, with the past
peated some of the experiments. As he wrote in his decade as its editor in chief (and first woman in the role since
1894 article: “When we replace the air by a stream of its founding in 1845). At the same time, I feel passionate about
coal gas, the galvanometer indicates an augmentation of heat, supporting young minds to help shape a better future for us all.
so that we have before us a demonstration that coal gas when In other words, I’ll be pursuing essentially the same mission of
heated does radiate more than equally hot air, from which we learning and sharing that knowledge—but from a different van-
conclude that it would exercise more absorption than air.” tage point. I’ll remain a contributor to Scientific American.
Today it is not a stretch to say that the way carbon dioxide More next month.
BOARD OF ADVISERS
Leslie C. Aiello Drew Endy Alison Gopnik Satyajit Mayor Daniela Rus
President, Wenner-Gren Foundation Professor of Bioengineering, Professor of Psychology and Senior Professor, Andrew (1956) and Erna Viterbi Professor
for Anthropological Research Stanford University Affiliate Professor of Philosophy, National Center for Biological Sciences, of Electrical Engineering and Computer
Robin E. Bell Nita A. Farahany University of California, Berkeley Tata Institute of Fundamental Research Science and Director, CSAIL, M.I.T.
Research Professor, Lamont-Doherty Professor of Law and Philosophy, Lene Vestergaard Hau John P. Moore Eugenie C. Scott
Earth Observatory, Columbia University Director, Duke Initiative for Mallinckrodt Professor of Physics and Professor of Microbiology and Chair, Advisory Council,
Emery N. Brown Science & Society, Duke University of Applied Physics, Harvard University Immunology, Weill Medical College
Edward Hood Taplin Professor of Medical National Center for Science Education
Edward W. Felten Hopi E. Hoekstra of Cornell University
Engineering and of Computational Neuro- Director, Center for Information Terry Sejnowski
Alexander Agassiz Professor of Zoology, Priyamvada Natarajan
science, M.I.T., and Warren M. Zapol Prof- Technology Policy, Princeton University Professor and Laboratory Head of
Harvard University Professor of Astronomy and Physics,
essor of Anesthesia, Harvard Medical Computational Neurobiology Laboratory,
Jonathan Foley Ayana Elizabeth Johnson Yale University
School Salk Institute for Biological Studies
Executive Director and William R. and Founder and CEO, Ocean Collectiv Donna J. Nelson
Vinton G. Cerf Gretchen B. Kimball Chair, California
Chief Internet Evangelist, Google Christof Koch Professor of Chemistry, Meg Urry
Academy of Sciences
Emmanuelle Charpentier President and CSO, University of Oklahoma Israel Munson Professor of Physics
Jennifer Francis and Astronomy, Yale University
Scientific Director, Max Planck Institute Allen Institute for Brain Science Robert E. Palazzo
Senior Scientist,
for Infection Biology, and Founding
Woods Hole Research Center
Morten L. Kringelbach Dean, University of Alabama at Michael E. Webber
and Acting Director, Max Planck Unit Associate Professor and Birmingham College of Arts and Sciences Co-director, Clean Energy Incubator,
for the Science of Pathogens Kaigham J. Gabriel
Senior Research Fellow, The Queen’s Rosalind Picard and Associate Professor,
President and Chief Executive Officer,
George M. Church College, University of Oxford Professor and Director, Department of Mechanical Engineering,
Charles Stark Draper Laboratory
Director, Center for Computational Robert S. Langer Affective Computing, M.I.T. Media Lab University of Texas at Austin
Genetics, Harvard Medical School Harold “Skip” Garner
Executive Director and Professor, Primary David H. Koch Institute Professor, Carolyn Porco George M. Whitesides
Rita Colwell Department of Chemical Engineering, Leader, Cassini Imaging Science Team,
Care Research Network and Center for Professor of Chemistry and Chemical
Distinguished University Professor, M.I.T. and Director, CICLOPS, Space Science
University of Maryland College Park Bioinformatics and Genetics, Edward Via Biology, Harvard University
College of Osteopathic Medicine Meg Lowman Institute
and Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School Amie Wilkinson
of Public Health Michael S. Gazzaniga Director and Founder, TREE Foundation, Lisa Randall
Rachel Carson Fellow, Ludwig Maximilian Professor of Physics, Harvard University Professor of Mathematics,
Kate Crawford Director, Sage Center for the Study of
University Munich, and Research Martin Rees University of Chicago
Director of Research and Co-founder, Mind, University of California,
AI Now Institute, and Distinguished Santa Barbara Professor, University of Science Malaysia Astronomer Royal and Professor Anton Zeilinger
Research Professor, New York University, Carlos Gershenson John Maeda of Cosmology and Astrophysics, Professor of Quantum Optics, Quantum
and Principal Researcher, Research Professor, National Global Head, Computational Design + Institute of Astronomy, Nanophysics, Quantum Information,
Microsoft Research New York City Autonomous University of Mexico Inclusion, Automattic, Inc. University of Cambridge University of Vienna
ORGAN REPAIRS
The forgotten compound that can
repair damaged tissue PAGE 56
DENGUE DEBACLE
A vaccination program
gone wrong PAGE 38
HOW EELS GET ELECTRIC
Insights into their shocking
attack mechanisms PAGE 62
“Inspiration for the Inspiration for that experiment came
from Charles Mason and Jeremiah Dix-
Cavendish experiment on’s work to settle the boundary between
came from Charles Pennsylvania and Maryland. Cavendish
found that the plumb bobs they were us-
Mason and Jeremiah ing for the survey were affected by the Al-
Dixon’s work to settle legheny Mountains.
Mark Arnold via e-mail
MIND READER the boundary between
A new brain-machine interface detects what the user wants
Pennsylvania and Folger states that one of the significant
problems in doing quantum gravity experi-
Maryland.” ments is “the need for large superpositions
mark arnold via e-mail that last for seconds at a time and stay close
enough together so that gravity can entan-
gle them.” Achieving that scenario, such as
S
PLU
QUANTUM
and Sebastian Bonhoeffer, both then at the with one proposed experiment involving
GRAVITY University of Oxford, working with virolo- micron-wide diamond spheres, is difficult
IN A LAB
Could new experiments
pull it off? PAGE 48 gist George Shaw and others, published in a laboratory because the earth’s gravity is
April 2019 analyses and conclusions in the same 1995 enormous as compared with micron-sized
issue of Nature that were essentially iden- objects. And if you let objects fall in a vacu-
tical to those in the report by Perelson and um, as in the proposed diamond sphere ex-
THE BODY ELECTRIC his colleague David Ho. Their contribu- periment, the required length of the shaft
I enjoyed reading “Shock and Awe,” Ken- tions should not be overlooked. grows as the square of the duration.
neth C. Catania’s article on the electric eel. Strogatz’s statement that calculus “led It seems like such experiments could
I’m curious about what was done to deter- to triple-combination therapy [for HIV]” be carried out in an almost zero-g envi-
mine how the eel is protected from shock- also does not truly reflect the events of the ronment such as the International Space
ing itself. My guess is that the nervous sys- time. The various mathematical calcula- Station or even in a small test satellite.
tem is somehow insulated or shielded. tions did not drive the development of Then the duration could easily run to a
Bruce Rogers via e-mail multidrug combination therapy, although day or more, and the experiment could be
they did eventually guide how the drugs done multiple times.
CATANIA REPLIES: Rogers is in good might best be used. The key factor in effec- Robert H. Beeman Coral Springs, Fla.
company: lots of people are curious about tively suppressing HIV replication in vivo
why these eels don’t shock themselves— was the clinical development of protease Why does gravity have to exist at the
including me. No one seems to know the inhibitors in the decade preceding the two quantum level?
details, but I think Rogers is on the right 1995 papers. Bill Yancey St. Augustine, Fla.
track. It seems inevitable there are paths The complex series of events that took
of very low resistance, along with areas of place in the early 1990s, along with the FOLGER REPLIES: I had considered open-
electrical insulation, within the animals contributions made by many people, have ing my article with an anecdote similar to
(we do know the latter exists around their been thoroughly summarized in review Arnold’s: In the early 1770s British scientist
electrocytes—the biological batteries). But articles. Yet contemporaneous coverage by Nevil Maskelyne trekked to Schiehallion, a
I can say this much: the eels are just bare- the media has skewed public perceptions mountain in Scotland. Maskelyne wanted
ly protecting themselves. Sometimes an eel of what happened in the critical period to see if the mountain’s mass would deflect a
that has curled itself to amplify the electri- when HIV infection transitioned from be- plum bob and then use the result to estimate
cal effect on its prey ends up activating its ing almost always fatal to becoming a the earth’s density. The result, as calculated
own fins with each high-voltage volley. So manageable, chronic disease. Strogatz’s from Maskelyne’s data by mathematician
the experience is at least mildly shocking, article reinforces the oversimplification of Charles Hutton, was less than 20 percent
even to the eel. these important historical events. off today’s accepted value. Maskelyne’s
John P. Moore Weill Cornell Medicine work shows how ingenious Cavendish was:
HISTORY OF HIV TREATMENT and a member of Scientific American’s he didn’t need to use a mountain as a test
In “Outsmarting a Virus with Math,” Ste- Board of Advisers mass—only the heavy spheres in his shed.
ven Strogatz writes about the mathematics Regarding Beeman’s suggestion: Phys-
of HIV replication in humans (excerpted MASON-DIXON GRAVITAS icists have proposed a space mission
from his book Infinite Powers). He rightly “Quantum Gravity in the Lab,” by Tim Fol- to test quantum superpositions, called
praises immunologist Alan Perelson’s cal- ger, mentions the late 18th-century experi- MAQRO. But it hasn’t been funded yet.
culus skills in dissecting clinical data from ment in which British scientist Henry Cav- In answer to Yancey: If gravity doesn’t
antiviral drug trials. But Martin Nowak endish measured the mass of the earth. exist at the quantum level, then why does
REGENERATION NEWS
SENIOR EDITOR, MIND / BRAIN Gary Stix ASSOCIATE EDITOR, TECHNOLOGY Sophie Bushwick
In “A Shot at Regeneration,” Kevin Strange SENIOR EDITOR, SPACE / PHYSICS Lee Billings ASSOCIATE EDITOR, SUSTAINABILITY Andrea Thompson
ASSOCIATE EDITOR, HEALTH AND MEDICINE Tanya Lewis
and Viravuth Yin discuss the compound
DIGITAL CONTENT
MSI-1436, which removes limits to the SENIOR EDITOR, MULTIMEDIA Steve Mirsky ENGAGEMENT EDITOR Sunya Bhutta
SENIOR EDITOR, COLLECTIONS Andrea Gawrylewski
body’s ability to regenerate cells by block-
ART
ing the enzyme protein tyrosine phos- ART DIRECTOR Jason Mischka SENIOR GRAPHICS EDITOR Jen Christiansen
phatase 1B (PTP1B). The article speaks of PHOTOGRAPHY EDITOR Monica Bradley ART DIRECTOR, ONLINE Ryan Reid
ASSOCIATE GRAPHICS EDITOR Amanda Montañez ASSISTANT PHOTO EDITOR Liz Tormes
research being directed toward muscular
dystrophy. I am wondering if application COPY AND PRODUC TION
SENIOR COPY EDITOR Daniel C. Schlenoff SENIOR COPY EDITOR Aaron Shattuck
research on MSI-1436 would be appro- MANAGING PRODUCTION EDITOR Richard Hunt PREPRESS AND QUALITY MANAGER Silvia De Santis
cord injuries. PRODUCT MANAGER Ian Kelly SENIOR WEB PRODUCER Jessica Ramirez
CONTRIBUTOR S
Chris Sfhofield via e-mail
EDITORIAL David Biello, Lydia Denworth, W. Wayt Gibbs, Ferris Jabr,
Anna Kuchment, Robin Lloyd, Melinda Wenner Moyer, George Musser,
Christie Nicholson, John Rennie, Ricki L. Rusting
STRANGE REPLIES: PTP1B is expressed ART Edward Bell, Bryan Christie, Lawrence R. Gendron, Nick Higgins, Katie Peek
in virtually all tissue and cell types, where
EDITORIAL ADMINISTRATOR Ericka Skirpan SENIOR SECRETARY Maya Harty
it functions to inhibit receptor tyrosine
kinase (RTK) signaling. RTKs activate
PRESIDENT
multiple cellular processes that must work Dean Sanderson
together in a coordinated manner for re- EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT Michael Florek
generation to occur. By inhibiting PTP1B,
CLIENT MARKETING SOLUTIONS
MSI-1436 thus enhances the activity of VICE PRESIDENT, COMMERCIAL Andrew Douglas
PUBLISHER AND VICE PRESIDENT Jeremy A. Abbate
diverse, RTK-regulated cellular pathways MARKETING DIRECTOR, INSTITUTIONAL PARTNERSHIPS AND CUSTOMER DEVELOPMENT Jessica Cole
required for tissue regeneration. Given PROGRAMMATIC PRODUCT MANAGER Zoya Lysak
DIRECTOR, INTEGRATED MEDIA Jay Berfas
this arrangement, we suspect MSI-1436 DIRECTOR, INTEGRATED MEDIA Matt Bondlow
MANAGER, GLOBAL MEDIA ALLIANCES Brendan Grier
may have various disease indications SENIOR ADMINISTRATOR, EXECUTIVE SERVICES May Jung
whereby stimulating tissue repair and re- CONSUMER MARKETING
generation would be therapeutically valu- HEAD, MARKETING AND PRODUCT MANAGEMENT Richard Zinken
MARKETING MANAGER Chris Monello
able. But a great deal of very careful sci- SENIOR COMMERCIAL OPERATIONS COORDINATOR Christine Kaelin
ence must be carried out before we know ANCILL ARY PRODUC TS
for certain. Our work to date has been fo- ASSOCIATE VICE PRESIDENT, BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT Diane McGarvey
CUSTOM PUBLISHING EDITOR Lisa Pallatroni
cused on heart and skeletal muscle injury. RIGHTS AND PERMISSIONS MANAGER Felicia Ruocco
C O R P O R AT E
BIPARTISAN CLIMATE ACTION HEAD, COMMUNICATIONS, USA Rachel Scheer
“Feverish Planet,” by Tanya Lewis [Advanc- PRINT PRODUC TION
es, March 2019], covers the direct health PRODUCTION CONTROLLER Madelyn Keyes-Milch ADVERTISING PRODUCTION CONTROLLER Dan Chen
Gun Research
Needs More
Firepower
A new bill promises millions of dollars
for lifesaving studies, and scientists
should use it wisely
By the Editors
When bullets fired from a passing car sliced through the St.
Louis night one Sunday in June, they hit two children, killing
three-year-old Kenndei Powell and seriously wounding anoth-
er little girl, age six. Police in the Missouri city were not imme-
diately able to identify or find the shooter, and Powell joined
the grim ranks of the 36,000 people killed by guns every year in
the U.S., on average. An additional 100,000 are injured. county or state to laws in another, for instance. But none has
That adds up to 136,000 Americans harmed or killed annual- had the power of large investigations that look at the effects of
ly by gun violence. Worse, the death side of this sad ledger is various kinds of interventions across the entire country and that
growing, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Pre- involve tens of thousands of people. This is the kind of science
vention, in an upward trend that began in 2015. While mass that showed us the safety and health advantages of using seat
shootings in Sutherland Springs, Tex., or Parkland, Fla., dominate belts, quitting smoking and reducing air pollution.
headlines, people such as the St. Louis children, cut down singly Experts have identified many areas where our firearms igno-
or by twos or threes, make up the bulk of the victims. Guns are a rance is killing us, gaps that scientists should now move to fill.
clear and present danger in this country, where there are about For one, we cannot answer basic questions about people who
393 million civilian-owned firearms—more than enough to put commit gun violence—the percentage of them who legally pos-
one in the hands of every man, woman and child and amounting sessed the guns they used, for example, or how those firearms
to the highest rate of gun ownership in the world by far. were acquired. Studies of possession and acquisition patterns
The tremendous toll makes gun violence a huge public health would give us a sober assessment of whether existing permit-
problem. Yet unlike other pressing health threats, Americans have ting, licensing or background-check laws are actually being
few ideas about the most effective prevention strategies because used to disarm dangerous people—including those who intend
there has been almost no large-scale research on the issue. to harm themselves through suicide.
All that could change this year. In an appropriations bill this We also need information on the best ways to stop under-
spring, the U.S. House of Representatives included $50 million ground gun markets, where weapons are often sold to people
to be used for such studies by the cdc and the National Insti- who cannot obtain them from a licensed gun shop. The way to
tutes of Health—the first time in decades that this kind of sup- get a solid answer is through research that traces guns in a large
port has been given. If the U.S. Senate concurs and the bill number of cities with regulations of varying strictness. There is
becomes law, researchers need to jump at this opportunity. also a crying need to evaluate violence-prevention policies and
Congress created the research gap in the first place, so it is programs based on data about individuals who participate in
right for Congress to fix it. In 1996, after a series of studies large randomized controlled trials—the scientific gold standard
linked gun ownership to increased violence and crime and for determining causes and effects.
prompted an antiresearch campaign from the National Rifle None of this research infringes on Second Amendment
Association of America (NRA), legislators inserted language rights to firearm ownership. It does, however, promote other,
into the cdc’s budget bill that said no money could be used to unalienable rights set out in our Declaration of Independence—
“promote gun control.” Congress also zeroed out the agency’s “Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness”—and helps to stop
budget for firearms research. The message was clear, and feder- them from being taken away at gunpoint.
ally supported science in this area ground to a halt.
JOIN T HE CONVERSAT ION ONLINE
Since then, dozens of small-scale studies have been carried Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
out—research comparing the effects of licensing laws in one or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
A Crazy-Sounding
landfills and rice paddies; emerges from the digestive systems of
cattle and from the manure piles they leave behind; and more.
The good news about methane is that it remains in the atmo-
Climate Fix sphere for a far shorter time than CO2 does. The bad news is that
methane is vastly more efficient at trapping heat—more than 80
times more, in the first 20 years after its release—which makes
We should convert methane, a more it, pound for pound, a bigger problem than carbon.
We want to remove methane from the air and then use porous
powerful greenhouse gas, into CO2 materials called zeolites to turn it into carbon dioxide. Zeolites
By Rob Jackson and Pep Canadell can trap copper, iron and other metals that can act as catalysts
to replace methane’s four hydrogen atoms with two oxygens.
Carbon dioxide in the atmosphere blew past 415 parts per Because a methane molecule holds more energy than carbon
million this past May. The last time levels were this high, two dioxide, the reaction typically runs to completion if you can
or three million years ago, the oceans rose tens of meters, jump-start it. Furthermore, by releasing the carbon dioxide back
something likely to happen again as Earth’s ice melts over the into the air instead of capturing it, you make the process less
next 1,000 years. expensive and lengthen the life of the zeolites.
To replace bad news with action, we need hope—a vision for Researchers around the world are already studying zeolites
restoring the atmosphere. Think about the Endangered Species and other materials to convert methane to methanol, a valuable
Act: it does not stop at saving plants and animals from extinc- feedstock for the chemical industry. Making methanol is a halfway
tion; it helps them recover. When we see gray whales breaching point in our reaction, tacking one oxygen atom onto each meth-
on their way to Alaska every spring, grizzly bears ambling across ane molecule. No one seems to have considered finishing the job
a Yellowstone meadow, bald eagles and peregrine falcons riding by making carbon dioxide in the same way because carbon diox-
updrafts, we are celebrating a planet restored. Our goal for the ide is not valuable like methanol. We should consider it now.
atmosphere should be the same. Another surprise about our proposal is that you could restore
the atmosphere by removing “only” three billion met-
ric tons of methane. Doing so would generate a few
months’ worth of industrial carbon dioxide emissions
but eliminate up to one sixth of overall warming. That
is a good trade by any measure.
What we propose will not be easy to accomplish.
Methane is uncommon: whereas the atmosphere cur-
rently holds more than 400 molecules of carbon dioxide
for every million molecules of air, methane accounts for
only two or so out of a million. That makes pulling it
from the atmosphere harder than keeping it from enter-
ing in the first place. We will need other things to work
as well. To give companies, governments and individu-
als financial incentives to do this, there has to be a price
on carbon or a policy mandate to pay for removing
methane. We also need research on the large arrays
needed to capture methane from air. And of course, we
need to fix methane leaks and limit emissions from oth-
er human sources. But we cannot eliminate those emis-
sions entirely, so we would have to continue removing
As leaders of the Global Carbon Project, we have spent our methane from the atmosphere indefinitely.
careers working to reduce greenhouse gas pollution. Today we Restoration of all the gases in the atmosphere to preindustri-
are making what may at first seem like a counterintuitive pro- al levels may seem unlikely today, but we believe it will occur
posal: we want to increase carbon dioxide emissions temporar- eventually. Such a goal provides a positive framework for change
ily to cleanse the atmosphere of a much more powerful green- at a time when climate action is sorely needed. Stabilizing glob-
house gas. al warming at 1.5 or two degrees Celsius is not enough. We need
Stick with us here. the planet to recover.
We are not saying increasing CO2 is a good thing in and of
JOIN T HE CONVERSAT ION ONLINE
itself. The gas that concerns us is methane, which leaks from Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
wells and pipelines; bubbles up when organic matter rots in or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
A N I M A L B E H AV I O R
Scaredy-
Sharks
Even great whites may have
something to fear
expanding,” thanks to intensive conserva- has some support: Jorgensen and his col- “There’s no reason to believe that orcas
tion efforts, says ecologist Chris Lowe of leagues monitored the movements of a weren’t [hunting] both seals and sharks
California State University, Long Beach, group of great white sharks that were hun- 300 or 400 years ago, before people really
who was not involved with the new study. dreds of kilometers away from the Farallon started exploiting those animals.”
The sharks’ willingness to give up good Islands when orcas arrived. Sometime after —Jason G. Goldman
U.S. AUSTRALIA
Washington became the first
first In what some experts view as a
state to allow human bodies setback for climate change action,
to be composted. The process, Australians voted to retain Prime
which turns a body into soil Minister Scott Morrison and his
over several weeks, is seen by right-wing Liberal-National
some as a greener alternative coalition. The opposition Labor
to cremation or burial. party had pledged, if elected, to
cut greenhouse gas emissions by
45 percent of 2005 levels by 2030.
BOTSWANA
The country’s government lifted
a five-year-old
five-year-old ban on hunting
elephants for sport, after a committee
found a “negative impact of the INDIAN OCEAN
hunting suspension on livelihoods.” Seafloor
Seafl oor mapping revealed the largest underwater eruption ever
observed, at a submarine volcano between continental Africa
For more details, visit
and Madagascar. Starting last year, it created a mound towering
www.ScientificAmerican.com/aug2019/advances 800 meters above the seabed in just six months, researchers say.
© 2019 Scientific American
Damming Africa
Evidence Asia
Human infrastructure
restricts many of Free-flowing rivers
the world’s longest rivers Australia Connected to oceans
Not connected to oceans
Rivers are terrestrial arteries for the Non-free-flowing rivers
Europe
nutrients, sediment and freshwater that Connected to oceans
sustain healthy, diverse ecosystems. Their Not connected to oceans
influence extends in multiple dimensions— North America
not only along their length but below-
ground to aquifers and periodically into
nearby floodplains. South America
They also provide vital services for peo-
ple by fertilizing agricultural land and feed- 0 10 20 30 40 50
ing key fisheries and by acting as transpor-
Graphics by Melissa Thomas Baum, Buckyball Design
tation corridors. But in efforts to ease ship
passage, protect communities from flood-
ing, and siphon off water for drinking and dams or levees) to water consumption— Conversely, most rivers shorter than 100
irrigation, humans have increasingly con- along a river’s various dimensions. Rivers kilometers appeared to flow freely—but the
strained and fractured these crucial water- whose indices meet a certain threshold for data on them are less comprehensive, and
his colleagues previously found that adults buddies—suggesting they could tell the two nents of laughter the infants are detecting
from 24 societies around the world can types apart, according to a study published remains to be seen, but prior work by Bry-
distinguish simultaneous “co-laughter” in March in Scientific Reports. ant’s team provides hints. Laughs between
between friends from that between The researchers then showed the friends tend to include greater fluctuations
strangers. The findings suggested that this babies short videos of two people acting in pitch and intensity, for example.
Flow regulation
Fragmentation
E C O LO G Y T E C H
spring migration. “We need forward-think-
Flight Lights ing methods to protect not only large birds
that are inherently at greater risk from pow-
Ultraviolet illumination helps er lines but also millions of smaller migrato-
birds avoid power lines ry birds,” says Anne Lacy of the Internation-
al Crane Foundation.
Human activities are killing wildlife at Half of all avian species can see ultravio-
unprecedented rates, with causes ranging let light. So James Dwyer, a wildlife biolo-
from environmental pollution to the built gist at utility consulting firm EDM Interna- tool for use in hotspots where endangered
environment. For some bird species, night- tional in Fort Collins, Colo., had the idea of bird species nest and feed.
time collisions with power lines are driving using near-visible UV light to illuminate The researchers did not observe any neg-
substantial population declines. But now power lines. EDM’s engineering team and ative impacts on other species: insects did
scientists have come up with a clever way the Dawson Public Power District devel- not swarm toward the lights, nor did bats
to make the cables easier for birds to spot, oped such light systems and installed them or nighthawks do so in pursuit of a meal.
without being unsightly to humans. on a tower supporting a power line at And Dwyer says birds are unlikely to con-
Industry and U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service Rowe Sanctuary. Over a 38-night period, fuse such near-ground UV illumination with
guidelines recommend that utility compa- crane collisions decreased by 98 percent natural cues such as starlight.
nies mark their power lines with plastic when the lights were on, the researchers “I don’t want utilities to build lines
attachments to increase visibility, but birds reported in a study published online in May wherever they want because there’s
are still dying. Biologists reported that 300 in Ornithological Applications. a new tool,” says biologist Robert Harms
Richard Loughery, director of environ- of the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, who
RANDY GREEN Alamy
N
A
N
In
E
Amplitudes
C
O
(volts per kilometer)
10.00 – 25.44
SCIENCE
C
3.00 – 10.00
I
T 1.00 – 3.00
We Trust
N
0.60 – 1.00
A
L
0.30 – 0.60
T
0.05 – 0.30
Climate Science
A
Polarization axis
Vs. Blind Faith
fields in the underlying rock. The fields’
Magnetic storms induce high geoelectric fields fields’
amplitude and direction (polarization axis) can help inform utility companies about
where power grid interference and damage might occur. Join the nation’s
largest association of
GEOPHYSIC S freethinkers, atheists
& agnostics working
Stormy Space Weather to keep religion
New map reveals the risk of blackouts from geomagnetic storms out of government
and social policy.
A massive geomagnetic storm stunned instead, possibly threatening the grid.
Quebec in 1989, triggering blackouts across Fields greater than one volt per kilome-
the province. The storm—a disturbance in ter can interfere with a grid’s operation, and For a free sample of
Earth’s magnetic fifield
eld caused by a blast of much stronger fifields
elds can cause blackouts. FFRF’s newspaper,
charged particles from the sun—created The team found that the most hazardous Freethought Today
electric currents that raced through under- area is in Virginia, where fifields
elds can be as
ground power lines and overloaded the strong as 25.44 volts per kilometer during
grid. Now new research suggests the intense magnetic storms. Major cities,
specificc regions
composition of rock in specifi including New York, Boston and Washing-
influence
could infl uence the risks from such “super- ton, D.C., can also experience relatively
storms,” which occur about once a century. powerful fifields.
elds. These areas have meta-
SOURCE: “EXTREME-VALUE GEOELECTRIC AMPLITUDE AND POLARIZATION ACROSS THE NORTHEAST
Geomagnetic storms induce a local morphic rock (which has been changed by Call 1-800-335-4021
electric fifield
eld in the ground, producing cur- intense heat or pressure) and igneous rock
ffrf.us/reason
UNITED STATES,” BY JEFFREY J. LOVE ET AL., IN SPACE WEATHER, VOL. 17, NO. 3; MARCH 2019
NEUROSCIENCE TECH
functional MR elastography (fMRE), it od in humans. “We’ve got very nice data
Magnetic involves sending vibrations through tissue
and using magnetic resonance to measure
now showing that it works,” Patz says. If
everything pans out, the technique could
Vibes their speed. They move faster through
stiffer material, producing “elastograms,”
represent an important advance in brain
imaging. “We’d be in a much better posi
Faster imaging method makes or maps of tissue rigidity, that may corre tion to conduct ‘effective connectivity’
brain scans more responsive spond to brain activity. This is the first time analyses, where you try to figure out how
fMRE has been used to measure such information flows in brain circuits,” says
The invention of functional magnetic reso activity, the researchers say. neuroscientist Jonathan Roiser of Universi
nance imaging (fMRI) nearly 30 years In a study published in April in Science ty College London, who was not involved
ago revolutionized neuroscience by letting Advances, Patz, Sinkus and their colleagues in the work.
researchers visualize brain activity associat applied mild shocks to mice’s hind limbs to Patz’s colleague Alexandra Golby, a
ed with behavior. The technology is spatial induce signals in the brain, turning the neurosurgeon, hopes to use fMRE to iden
ly precise, but its main limitation is speed; stimulation on and off at various rates. tify critical areas to avoid during brain sur
fMRI measures blood oxygen level changes, Comparing fMRE scans taken during on geries. In about 30 percent of patients with
which take about six seconds—a snail’s and off periods allowed them to produce tumors, the mass blocks the changes in
pace as compared with brain signals them images showing which areas changed in blood oxygenation that fMRI measures,
selves. Other methods, such as electro stiffness as a result of the stimulation. The Patz says—“so [Golby] wanted a method
encephalography (EEG), are fast but impre researchers think certain brain cells soften that works differently.” The technique
cise and cannot detect deeper brain signals. when an associated neuron fires, meaning might ultimately help researchers under
Now physicists Samuel Patz of Harvard stiffness changes would correspond to stand and diagnose brain disorders involv
Medical School and Ralph Sinkus of King’s neural activity. By varying the stimulation ing circuit dysfunctions, such as schizo
College London and their colleagues have switching rate, they demonstrated that phrenia. “It could reveal a lot of informa
adapted existing tissueimaging technolo fMRE can detect brain signals at least tion that might be valuable for disease
gy to overcome fMRI’s speed limitation every 100 milliseconds. diagnosis [and] progression,” Patz says.
and tested it in mouse brains. Known as The team is currently testing the meth —Simon Makin
any species, bird or otherwise, that has similar structures. —Jim Daley
If You Give a pediatric allergy at King’s College London and senior author of
both LEAP and EAT. The “dual allergen exposure hypothesis”
holds that we become tolerant to foods by introducing them oral-
Baby a Peanut ly to the gut immune system. In contrast, if a child’s first exposure
is through food molecules that enter through eczema-damaged
skin, those molecules can instigate an allergic response. Research
Feeding infants allergenic foods may be with mice strongly supports this idea, whereas in humans the ev-
the key to preventing allergies idence is more circumstantial. Lack points out that peanut aller-
gy is more prevalent in countries where peanuts or peanut butter
By Claudia Wallis is popular and widespread in the environment, mustard seed al-
lergy is common in mustard-loving France and buckwheat aller-
Few things are more subject to change and passing fancies than gy occurs in soba-loving Japan. “Parents are eating these foods,
dietary advice. And that can be true even when the advice comes then touching or kissing their babies,” Lack suggests, “and the
from trusted health authorities. A dozen years ago the standard molecules penetrate through the skin.”
recommendation to new parents worried about their child devel- A modern emphasis on hygiene may also contribute, Lack
oping an allergy to peanuts, eggs or other common dietary aller- notes: “We bathe infants and shower young children all the time,
gens was to avoid those items like the plague until the child was very often once a day or more, which you could argue breaks down
two or three years old. But in 2008 the American Academy of the skin barrier.” Researchers are examining whether applying
Pediatrics (AAP) dropped that guidance, after studies showed it barrier creams such as CeraVe can help stave off food allergies.
did not help. And in its latest report, issued in April, the AAP Eight foods account for 90 percent of food allergies: cow’s
completed the reversal—at least where peanuts are concerned. It milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat and soybeans.
recommended that high-risk children (those with severe eczema Some scientists believe this is so because these foods contain pro-
or an allergy to eggs) be systematically fed “infant-safe” peanut teins that are unusually stable to digestion, heating and changes in
products as early as four to six months of age to prevent this com- pH and are therefore more likely to cause an immune response.
mon and sometimes life-threatening allergy. Children with mild Early dietary exposure is now the confirmed preventive strat-
or moderate eczema should receive them at around six months. egy for peanuts and, pending more research, perhaps the other
These are not whimsical changes. They match advice from a foods, although this is more easily said than done. In EAT, parents
federal panel of experts and reflect the results of large random- had to get their babies to swallow at least four grams per week of
ized studies—with the inevitable cute acronyms. One called LEAP each of the allergenic edibles, and many found it to be challeng-
(Learning Early About Peanut Allergy), published in 2015, found ing. As Lack observes, “It’s just not part of our culture to feed sol-
that feeding peanut products to high-risk infants between four ids to very young babies.”
The Big breakneck pace set over the preceding 100 years—a period Gor-
don calls “the special century.”
Since 1970 the only notable outlier has been the exponential
Slowdown increase in computing power, which has trickled down to con-
sumers in the form of the Internet and our ever present mobile
devices. But in most other ways, Gordon argues, the lives of peo-
Major technological shifts are fewer and ple in developed nations look and feel the same in 2019 as they
farther between than they once were did in 1979 or 1989.
This is good in one small way, though bad in most of the ways
By Wade Roush
that count. Rapid and incessant change can be disorienting, and
On June 22, 1927, Charles Lindbergh flew into Dayton, Ohio, when things evolve at a more measured pace, people and insti-
for dinner at Orville Wright’s house. It had been just a month tutions do have more time to breathe and adapt. But speaking
since the young aviator’s first ever solo nonstop crossing of the as a Gen Xer, deceleration isn’t what I was taught to expect. And
Atlantic, and he felt he ought to pay his respects to the celebrat- in many areas of technology, the forward movement today feels
ed pioneer of flight. tragically slow, even nonexistent.
Forty-two years later, on July 16, 1969, Apollo 11 astronaut Neil Consider consumer robotics. There’s enormous potential for
Armstrong was allowed to bring a personal guest to the Kennedy robots to help us with housework, education, entertainment
Space Center to witness the launch of nasa’s towering Saturn V and medical care. But home robotics companies seem to keep
rocket. Armstrong invited his hero, Charles Lindbergh. folding: social robot maker Jibo closed in March after raising
That’s how fast technology advanced in the 20th century. almost $73 million in venture capital, and in April robot toy
One man, Lindbergh, could be the living link between the pilot maker Anki shut down after raising at least $182 million. The
of the first powered flight and the commander of the first mis- only commercially successful home robot, iRobot’s Roomba vac-
sion to another world. uum cleaner, hit the market in 2002.
In our century, for better or worse, progress isn’t what it used Or consider access to space. In 2007 the XPRIZE Foundation
to be. Northwestern University economist Robert Gordon argues offered $30 million in prizes, funded by Google, to commercial
that by 1970, all the key technologies of modern life were in teams that would compete to land a robotic rover on the moon.
place: sanitation, electricity, mechanized agriculture, highways, When it became obvious that no team would be able to meet the
air travel, telecommunications, and the like. After that, innova- original deadline, the foundation extended the contest four times
tion and economic growth simply couldn’t keep going at the and finally pulled the plug in 2018. Although five teams had built
rovers, all had trouble raising enough money to buy launch con-
tracts. Companies such as Seattle-based Spaceflight Industries are
pioneering low-cost ride sharing into space for very small satellites,
but the cost per kilogram for getting large satellites and probes into
orbit is still, pardon the pun, sky-high. (Israel-based SpaceIL got its
Beresheet craft into lunar orbit in April, well after the competi-
tion’s cancellation, but it crashed after an error during descent.)
Our century’s one signature technology achievement is the
iPhone. And at this point, we’ve had smartphones in our pock-
ets long enough to begin to appreciate their dangers. Mean-
while the list of potentially world-changing technologies that
get lots of press ink but remain stubbornly in the prototype
phase is very long. Self-driving cars, flying cars, augmented-real-
ity glasses, gene therapy, nuclear fusion. Need I continue?
Granted, these are all hard problems. But historically, solving
the really big problems—rural electrification, for example—has
required sustained, large-scale investments, often with private
markets and taxpayers splitting the burden. In this century, we
urgently need to undo some of the consequences of the last great
boom by developing affordable zero- and negative-emissions tech-
nologies. That’s another hard problem—and to solve it, we’ll need
to recapture some of what made the “special century” so special.
J O I N T H E C O N V E R S AT I O N O N L I N E
Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
ARCTIC
FU
C
TI
U
T
RE
C
R
OF THE A
IN BRIEF
ALEXANDER RYUMIN Getty Images
Five countries that border the Arctic Ocean are Arctic landscapes and seascapes are changing Russia is expanding its Arctic military presence,
claiming rights to large, overlapping sections of dramatically. Rising air and water temperatures, while NATO holds large Arctic exercises, signs
the seafloor. Three say the North Pole is theirs. shrinking ice and thawing permafrost are causing that aggression could mount. Yet conflict is not
Diplomats could slowly work out boundaries all kinds of living things—from algae and trees to necessarily inevitable: countries may decide they
based on geologic evidence unless rising geopoliti- fish and caribou—to expand their range, change have more to gain by cooperatively developing
cal tension makes the science moot. migrations or, in some cases, struggle to survive. the changing region.
FU
C
TI
U
T
RE
C
R
OF THE A
DIVIDE
OR
CONQUER
Five nations are asserting rights
to vast, overlapping portions
of the Arctic Ocean seafloor
By Mark Fischetti
Illustration by Peter Horvath
na had to be watched closely. For the first time in 23 years, the matters, in 1982 more than 160 countries agreed to the United
meeting ended without the participants signing a declaration of Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). It estab-
cooperation. All the posturing could make boundary negotia- lished that a nation bordering any of the earth’s oceans has an
tions contentious, with opposing sides disregarding the science exclusive economic zone, or EEZ, reaching from its shoreline 200
instead of compromising over it. Even worse, headstrong lead- nautical miles (370.4 kilometers) out to sea. It has all rights to
ers might simply run out of patience with the CLCS’s review resources in and under the water. Areas beyond that line are
and take what they think is theirs. international waters—free to all, belonging to none.
The convention left a door open. Article 76 says a state can
LOMONOSOV IS MINE establish sovereign rights to exploit seabed beyond 200 nauti-
For centuries nation-states saw the oceans as wild. In the 1600s cal miles if it can present detailed geologic evidence proving
they began to assert rights over the first three miles (4.8 kilome- that its continental shelf—the gently sloping seafloor that
ters) of seawater, based on the longest distance of a cannon shot. stretches from shore far out into the ocean before dropping into
That practice held until the 20th century, when countries started the deep sea—extends beyond the 200-nautical-mile line. Here
to unilaterally claim rights out to various distances, threatening a nation would have exclusive rights to resources on and under
the long-standing concept of freedom of the high seas. To settle the seabed but not in the water column above it (fishing and
plate tectonics has ended them. from the deep seafloor. The ridge is a gigantic relic from mil-
Following the formulas can lead to modest overlaps, but lions of years ago, when the neighboring North American and
another Article 76 provision creates a larger problem. It says a Eurasian continents began pivoting away from each other,
country can claim a wide band of seabed along an underwater twisting and deforming the expanding Arctic Ocean floor. The
ridge that extends from the country’s continental shelf, howev- ridge’s common heritage means Denmark, Russia and Canada
If the Arctic Five countries’ says. And there really is no other way to
make a claim. The federal government
claims are upheld, only a small could publish a document declaring “this
area of seabed is ours,” but the world
bit of the Arctic Ocean seabed would not recognize it. In a boundary
negotiation, Saltus says, a country “would
may remain open to the rest of want the CLCS determination in its pock-
et.” In effect, the U.S. recognizes the
region being a global commons. U.S. rhetoric is also making the Arctic
more politically complicated. In June the
U.S. Department of Defense released its
latest Arctic Strategy, which says that
tiations with Denmark and Canada? The long section of the although there has been a great deal of cooperation among Arc-
Lomonosov Ridge that Russia did include might be more than tic nations, it now anticipates an “era of strategic competition”
enough to exploit. and “a potential avenue for . . . aggression.”
Canada has taken a similar approach, outlining the Lomono- Russia’s actions could be interpreted as such. Ever since the
sov Ridge from its shores outward, stopping just beyond the country stormed into Ukraine, “the relationship has been
North Pole and overlapping Russia’s outline in that region. Den- strained between NATO and Russia,” says Rob Huebert, a polit-
mark, however, claims the ridge from Greenland across the ical science professor at the University of Calgary and a former
entire ocean right up to Russia’s EEZ. “We are not considering associate director of what is now the Center for Military, Securi-
whether any other states would have claims to the same area,” ty and Strategic Studies there. The Arctic coast offers Russia a
says Denmark’s lead scientist Finn Mørk, a geophysicist at the critical strategic position for military power, notably nuclear
Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland. It is up to nego- war deterrence, because it is home to important nuclear subma-
tiators, he says, to work out the overlaps—and who, in the end, rine bases. “You can’t separate the politics of the Arctic from the
can wave a flag from the North Pole. greater geopolitics” of the world, Huebert says, maintaining
that Putin “sees the expansion of NATO as a core threat, and he
POLITICS OR SCIENCE? will not allow that to happen.” He says Russian jets now buzz
Given the vaGueness of Article 76, the three declarations for the Sweden and Finland because those countries are considering
Lomonosov Ridge might all be legitimate, scientifically. But joining NATO. In March, Sweden hosted an enormous military
ultimately which nation secures rights to which territory is not exercise in its northernmost region with thousands of NATO
up to the scientists: it is up to diplomats or, potentially, militar- troops. Because of Russia’s Arctic buildup, U.S. Army General
ies. And rising geopolitical tension could overtake the orderly, Curtis Scaparrotti told a Senate panel that same month that the
science-based process. U.S. military has to do more up north as well.
First of all, the U.S. submission to the CLCS will add to the Russia may have another reason, beyond military strategy
overlaps, complicating negotiations. The extent of overlap will or oil and gas, for controlling big swaths of the Arctic seas. “It
not be revealed until the documents are handed in, which will is about nationalism,” says Andrew Holland, chief operating
Iceland
Norway
Norway
Russia
Greenland
(Denmark)
North Pole
Lomonosov Ridge
Canada
Chukchi Plateau
Russia
U.S.
CHUKCHI CONUNDRUM
Resolving seafloor claims involves
political and scientific trade-offs.
Pliable Plateau
Russia and the U.S. could say the
Chukchi Plateau is a “natural prolonga
tion” of their shelf, depending on how
experts interpret the way continents have
separated over millions of years. But in
1990 the former Soviet Union and the
U.S. negotiated a maritime boundary
between their exclusive economic zones
Chukchi Plateau (EEZs); Russia elongated that boundary
in its submission for extended continen
tal shelf and did not cross it. The U.S.
says it will honor the boundary, too.
Economic Impasse
The U.S. and Canada disagree on their
EEZ border. Canada extends the 141st
meridian land boundary ( orange line);
the U.S. traces a line equidistant to the
meandering coasts ( red). The triangular
seafloor in between holds an estimated
U.S.-Russia 1.7 billion cubic meters of natural gas.
maritime
U.S. EEZ Canada EEZ
boundary
Seafloor depth (meters)
Alaska
Yukon SOURCES: IBRU, DURHAM UNIVERSITY ( claim areas);
141st meridian UNITED NATIONS CONVENTION ON THE LAW OF THE
SEA ( claim areas); MARINEREGIONS.ORG ( EEZs); GLOBAL
SELF-CONSISTENT, HIERARCHICAL, HIGH-RESOLUTION
GEOGRAPHY DATABASE ( coastlines); INTERNATIONAL
BATHYMETRIC CHART OF THE ARCTIC OCEAN,
VERSION 3.0 ( seafloor depths)
END GAME
althouGh lead scientists from the Arctic Five
did not want to say much on the record about
future boundary negotiations involving over-
laps, some of them seem uneasy with the pace
of the CLCS process. Nine of them—including
Mosher from Canada, Mayer and Saltus from
the U.S., Mørk from Denmark, and Petrov and
Firsov from Russia—are working to set a com-
mon base of slope for the entire Arctic Ocean,
LOMONOSOV RIDGE (white band in center) extends across the Arctic Ocean seafloor and they are drafting a paper for a peer-re-
from Canada and Greenland (part of Denmark) (left) to Russia (right). All three states viewed journal. That would make a statement
say they have rights to exploit it because it is part of their underwater continent. that the countries have calculated their foot of
slope within the base of slope—the basis for
the formulas—in the same way. Seeing such an
prevent oil spills and peacefully resolve differences. It also says agreement, perhaps the CLCS would speed up its reviews.
the countries will block any larger international attempt to gov- If the CLCS signs off on the Arctic Five submissions as is, only
ern the Arctic, as well as any other nation that might show up a small bit of the Arctic Ocean seabed may be left unclaimed.
and try to drill for oil or gas without permission. No other coun- This space, known simply as the Area, might amount to two mod-
tries, and no Arctic indigenous peoples, were involved. est parcels far out at sea, Saltus says. The rest of the world may
If squabbling among members of the Arctic Five does not not be happy with that outcome. Sometimes the Arctic nations
jeopardize orderly resolution of seafloor claims, two other wild think the Arctic Ocean is their backyard, Carrera explains, but
cards could. China’s economic ambitions are one of them. In many other countries, as well as indigenous peoples, see it as a
2013 President Xi Jinping unveiled the country’s Belt and Road global commons. They believe they have a right to explore it for
Initiative, intended to create an economic network among resources and to conduct research there.
numerous nations by building extensive infrastructure in them Some of them think the world should formally establish the
all. China now heads projects in more than 60 countries worth Arctic Ocean as a commons. They cite the Antarctic Treaty Sys-
hundreds of billions of dollars. Some world leaders worry that tem as a model. In force since 1961, it sets aside all the land and
China’s real plan is to command an enormous alliance across all ice shelves as a scientific preserve and bans military activity. It
of Asia. Part of the initiative is known as the Polar Silk Road, also protects more than 20 million square kilometers of the
intended to develop Chinese shipping routes across the Arctic Southern Ocean around the continent. But no one lives in the
and business deals with countries along those corridors. In 2017 Antarctic. There are no coastal states. It is more remote and
MARTIN JAKOBSSON Science Source
Xi held individual summits with the heads of Arctic nations. more frozen. There is little insight about resources, and it offers
Not to be outdone, Putin, who has his own Eurasian vision, met no strategic advantage. As the Arctic warms, the once solitary
one on one with leaders of Finland, Sweden, Norway and Ice- home of indigenous peoples who lived off its wildness instead of
land during the fifth International Arctic Forum, held in April trying to master it will be diced up and developed like the rest
in St. Petersburg. of the world to its south. Whether science or politics drives that
The second wild card is Greenland, which has been a territo- development, it is underway.
C
TI
U
T
RE
C
R
OF THE A
A NEW
REALITY
Climate change is
dramatically altering life
at the top of the world
By Mark Fischetti
Illustration by Peter Horvath
bles. In Siberia, warming earth is forcing underground methane seeps to breach the
surface and explode, leaving craters up to 40 meters wide.
Across the Arctic, striking change is the new normal, as is incursion by countries and businesses.
LAND
Construction, oil and natural gas extraction, shipping and tourism are all on the rise. Climate and
human activity are leaving a mark on nature and on the four million people who live in the region. OF
As interactions widen, science will be important for informing agreements and policies, espe- CHANGE
cially concerning disaster preparedness, environmental protection, economic opportunity, food
security, human health and community resilience. Indigenous peoples may be among the most
valuable experts. For years they have closely tracked shifting temperatures and receding ice cov-
er, trekked mountains and forests, followed caribou herds, fished seas and maintained biodiver-
sity. Their communities and cultures are also the ones most affected by coming development.
Some indigenous leaders say the Arctic should be governed by cooperative organizations and
rules that transcend political boundaries. For example, land and marine spatial planning across
large expanses could lay out rights for people, environmental protection and means for construc-
tive dialogue. Ultimately, they say, sustainable use of the future Arctic depends on a healthy envi-
ronment and a healthy community.
Physical Changes
Air, sea and land are transforming 1950s 2010s 2050–2099
rapidly. Each characteristic is mapped
across the longest time interval for
which comprehensive data exist.
Hotter Air
Average winter air temperatures
at the surface in the 2010s have
been much warmer than in
the 1950s. The second half of
this century will be hotter still,
according to midrange projections.
Warmer Ocean
Summer sea-surface temperatures
have risen considerably and are
predicted to continue upward.
Nature Responds
Life in all forms is adjusting to
changing conditions.
Tundra Is Greening
Satellite imagery shows how
much greener or browner land
areas appeared in 2017 versus
1982, based on vegetation cover.
2004 2015
Local Population
Fish Are Migrating Birds Are Shifting Polar Bears Are Dying Caribou Are Wavering
Polar cod rely on sea ice to spawn. Thick-billed murres nest in vast coastal Struggling polar bears are the Of the 23 tracked herds of
As oceans warm, their numbers colonies and are important prey for icon for a melting Arctic. Their caribou (reindeer), 16 are losing
are falling, whereas Atlantic cod humans and animals. Their numbers are demise is widespread. population, five are gaining and
are moving in from the south. waxing in some places, waning in others. two are holding steady.
C
TI
U
T
RE
C
R
OF THE A
IS
CONFRONTATION
INEVITABLE?
Political tension is increasing,
but cooperation could still prevail
By Kathrin Stephen
Illustration by Peter Horvath
The Tu-160s continued toward the U.K., then circled back home, but their appearance
was worrisome. The U.S. and Russian bombers can carry nuclear weapons, and less than
two months earlier both countries announced they would withdraw from the Intermedi-
ate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty because they were no longer interested in abiding by its
rules. Although the U.S. and Norwegian planes did not enter Russian airspace, Russia
could have interpreted the exercises as a signal from NATO that it can deliver nuclear
weapons close to the Russian border. Perhaps the Russian military felt it needed to remind
the allies that it has ample airpower, too.
It is reasonable to look at what is happening in the Arctic and worry that tensions are rising.
Easier physical access because of global warming has placed the region high on the political
agendas of the eight states with land or marine territory above the Arctic Circle: Russia, Fin-
land, Sweden, Norway, Iceland, Denmark (via Greenland), Canada and the U.S. Other influen-
tial players such as the U.K., Japan and China are paying closer attention to the new benefits a
thawing Arctic Ocean offers. The Arctic could hold as much as 13 percent of the world’s as yet
undiscovered oil and 30 percent of its natural gas, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. Na-
have good reasons to cooperate. And some of the moves they are
nd
Ru
Arctic Circle
tate
Yamal LNG (liquefied natural gas) project, which is only partly off-
ark
shore and close to the coast, cost $27 billion. Russia was loath to
nm
De
gather deep scientific data on fisheries and to design a sustain- Geologic Structures of the Arctic Basin. Edited by Alexey Piskarev, Victor Poselov and
able and orderly commercial utilization of them. Valery Kaminsky. Springer International Publishing, 2019.
Arctic Council: https://arctic-council.org
International Arctic Forum, St. Petersburg, Russia, April 9–10, 2019: https://forumarctica.ru/en
in assessing the likelihood of future conflict, it is United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea: www.un.org/depts/los
important to remember that the Arctic region has historically
FROM OUR ARCHIVES
been a place of international cooperation: Arctic countries, some
The Aeroplane in Arctic Exploration. Burt M. McConnell; September 30, 1916.
non-Arctic states and representatives of Arctic indigenous na- The Arctic Ocean. P. A. Gordienko; May 1961.
tions have been working together peacefully for many years. In The Dinosaurs of Arctic Alaska. Anthony R. Fiorillo; December 2004.
1991 the eight states with Arctic territory and their native peoples
s c i e n t if i c a m e r i c a n . c o m /m a g a zi n e /s a
adopted the Arctic Environmental Protection Strategy, which
Six provinces may con- Oil (90 billion Natural gas (Equivalent
tain 75 percent of the barrels total) to 412 billion barrels of oil)
undiscovered oil; four
provinces may contain West Siberian Basin 1
70 percent of the natural 1 Arctic Alaska
gas equivalent.
2 Amerasia Basin
3 East Greenland Rift Basins 2
*Common practice uses circles scaled by area, but that can create an inaccurate visual impression of relative values.
Here circles are scaled with their radius = (population value)2/3.
†Indigenous and/or urban data not available.
SOURCES: U.S. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY (oil and gas data); GREG FISKE Woods Hole Research Center, WITH DATA FROM SPACEQUEST.COM ( shipping data); THE
INDIGENOUS WORLD 2019, EDITED BY DAVID N. BERGER ET AL. INTERNATIONAL WORK GROUP FOR INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS, 2019 ( Sami and Inuit populations);
STATISTICS FINLAND; STATISTICS SWEDEN; STATISTICS NORWAY; STATISTICS ICELAND; STATISTICS GREENLAND; STATISTICS CANADA; U.S. CENSUS
BUREAU; RUSSIAN FEDERAL STATE STATISTICS SERVICE; ARCTIC PORTAL (Northwest and Northeast Passages); INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR STRATEGIC
STUDIES (military installations); HERITAGE FOUNDATION (military installations); GEONAMES GAZETTEER ( populated places, airports); WORLD PORT INDEX ( ports)
Iceland
4 Greenland Sea
Kara 3
Sea
Svalbard
(Norway)
Barents
Novaya Sea 3
Zemlya Franz Josef
Land (Russia)
Northern Norway
Iceland
Northern Sweden†
Northern Finland
Greenland
Greenland
(Denmark)
assage
west pP
Northern European Russia† North
5
Ellesmere
Laptev Baffin Bay
Island
Sea
Northern Canada
Northern Siberia
New Siberian
Islands Alaska (U.S.)
East Siberian
Sea
No
Hudson Bay
rth
ern
S
ea
Beaufort
Rou
Sea
te
2
No
Chukchi
rth
eas
Sea
t Pa
ssa
ge
1 2
AArct
ic Cir U.S. Canada
cllee
WHEN AN
I giraffe, Western showdown music warbling on the soundtrack. “The old bull
n a scene from the 2013 bbc documentary series AfricA, a giraffe approaches
from a distance, ambling across the golden sand of the Kalahari. “A young male,”
narrator David Attenborough announces. The newcomer heads toward another
won’t tolerate a rival,” Attenborough warns, as the giraffes begin to clash. “Pushing
and shoving, they size each other up. The young rival seems to think he has
a chance and attacks.” Moments later he slams his powerful neck into the old male’s, and
the fight is on—a bloody battle for territory. “The stakes are high,” Attenborough explains.
“To lose means exile in the desert.”
Wildlife documentaries commonly include such footage of terms. But relatively few of these species have actually been
shown to make these kinds of assessments. In fact, our own
research suggests that many creatures use different information
when deciding whether or not to compete.
DISPLAY OF FORCE
animals typically perform ritualized displays prior to engaging
in combat. For example, male deer stags competing for access to
females will engage in elaborate “roaring contests” and strut
mates. Sometimes these contests are mild and cause no physical side by side in “parallel walks.” Researchers have commonly in-
harm. Other times they are violent and end in severe injury or terpreted these behaviors as means by which each of the oppo-
death. Ultimately they result in unequal distribution of resourc- nents can provide information for the other to assess. If the dis-
es, have major effects on reproductive fitness and thus drive evo- play can settle the contest, there would be no need to engage in
lution. A creature that gathers information can benefit by avoid- a fight in which injury or even death is likely. It is better to spend
ing potentially lethal fights with bigger, stronger opponents. energy for a short time so that the opponent that perceives itself
We humans are remarkably skilled at assessing the fighting as the weaker of the two can withdraw, so the thinking goes. We
ability of others and quickly learn to not pick fights with individu- call this phenomenon mutual assessment, and it is central to a
als larger than ourselves. In laboratory tests, human subjects are game theory model of fighting known as sequential assessment.
able to accurately gauge the power of males after briefly viewing Game theory is a branch of applied mathematics that was
photographs of their torsos or faces or listening to their voices. The initially developed by economists to model human strategic
judgment is spontaneous—members of both sexes reach it in less decision-making. Biologists were quick to spot the utility of
than 50 milliseconds. This ability reflects the importance of mak- game theory for evolutionary biology, with John Maynard Smith
ing accurate assessments of opponents during human evolution. and George Price being the first to use this framework for study-
Are nonhuman animals as good as we are at evaluating ing animal contests. The sequential assessment model proposes
rivals? Documentaries such as the ones Attenborough narrates that contests should be easily settled by displays if the oppo-
so eloquently often describe the animals’ motivations in such nents differ widely in prowess, with fights occurring only when
PRECEDING PAGES: VINCE BURTON Alamy
IN BRIEF
Scientists long thought that in competitions for Studies carried out in the past decade, however, Exactly what determines which strategy an animal
resources, all animals have the capacity to gauge have revealed that many species use different strat- uses is uncertain, but cognitive ability may play a
the fighting ability of their opponents in relation to egies in deciding whether to fight or retreat. Most key role, the idea being that mutual assessment is
themselves—a strategy called mutual assessment. seem able to assess only themselves and not rivals. more cognitively challenging than other tactics.
the opponent. These animals were either unable to gather the population of animals engaging in contests using self-assess-
information, or the information was too costly to gather, or they ment rules, in which the loser gathers no information about the
chose not to use information that would most likely enable them winner’s ability. The results showed a negative relationship
to make optimal fight decisions. In any case, they were exhibit- between size difference and contest duration—the more the
ing self-assessment rather than mutual assessment. opponents differed in size, the shorter the contest—exactly the
Some of these early examples of self-assessment came from same relationship predicted for mutual assessment. The reason
expect to see a positive correlation between average size and defenders, whereas defenders were influenced by the way the
duration. In contrast, with sequential assessment the decision is attackers fought. Thus, within the same contest one role seemed to
based on relative size difference, and with size matching there is use self-assessment, whereas the other used mutual assessment.
no difference regardless of the absolute pairs. We would thus The existence of all these forms of assessment raises an intrigu-
expect to see no link between average pair size and contest dura- ing question: What determines which decision-making strategy
ALEX MUSTARD Nature Picture Library ( 3 )
tion if the opponents are using sequential assessment. an animal employs? One possible factor is cognitive ability. Some
We can also use the nature of escalation and de-escalation of experts have argued that just knowing one’s own state is simple
the contests to discriminate between the two decision strategies. but that integrating or comparing it with the state of the oppo-
Animals using cumulative assessment should exhibit phases of nent is more cognitively challenging. This idea remains to be sys-
escalation interspersed by phases of lower-cost activities. Those tematically tested, but a quick survey of taxa that differ in their
using sequential assessment, on the other hand, should progress cognitive sophistication provides tentative support for it. For
linearly from low- to high-cost activities. instance, sea anemones have a simple neural network, and analy-
R FIX
CANCER
W
Principles of evolution and
natural selection drive a radical
new approach to drugs
and prevention strategies
By James DeGregori and Robert Gatenby
I
Illustration by Maria Corte
S
Most of them will be treated by
highly skilled and experienced
oncologists, who have access to 52 drugs
approved to treat this condition. Yet eventual-
ly more than three quarters of these men will
succumb to their illness.
IN BRIEF
Medical efforts to defeat cancer typically focus A new concept emphasizes that cancer growth The evolutionary approach, tested in animals and
on malignant mutations within a cell and adminis- is stimulated by changes outside the cell, alterations humans with advanced prostate cancer, sharply
ter large doses of toxic drugs in an attempt to in the surrounding tissue that accelerate the evolu- limits the natural selection of cancer cells through
eradicate the disease. tion of cancerous traits. a more judicious use of chemotherapy.
Conventional Therapy
Cancer cells Initial tumor Maximum Tumor cannot be controlled
Chemotherapy- tolerated dose
sensitive of chemotherapy
Chemotherapy-
resistant
Time
Adaptive Therapy
Initial tumor Maximum effective dose Tumor size maintained with continued therapy
of chemotherapy
for new traits that were better tuned to the new surroundings. inherent advantage to the cell and can, in fact, be disadvanta-
Similar Darwinian dynamics should apply to the evolution of geous if it makes that cell less able to use the resources of the
cancers in our body. Even though we trained as a molecular biol- tissue immediately around it.
ogist (DeGregori) and a physician (Gatenby), evolution and ecol- We were also inspired by the punctuated equilibrium theory
ogy have always fascinated both of us. Our extensive reading in of paleontologists Niles Eldredge and Stephen Jay Gould, who
these areas, while initially driven by what we thought was curi- noted that species often maintain stable traits through millions
osity unrelated to our day jobs, revealed unappreciated parallels of years of fossil records, only to suddenly evolve rapidly in
between the driving forces of evolution and our observations of response to a dramatic environmental change. This concept stim-
cancer development and cancer patients’ responses to therapy. ulated our ideas about the way that some tissues could be initial-
For instance, cancer researchers typically believed that a ly unfavorable to cell mutations, but changes in those tissues,
cancer-causing mutation would always confer an advantage to a such as damage and inflammation in a smoker’s lungs, could
cell that acquired it, but we recognized a classic evolutionary stimulate evolutionary change—sometimes leading to cancer.
principle at work: A mutation does not automatically help or We first saw this dynamic at work with aging-associated
hinder an organism. Instead its effects are dependent on fea- changes in bone marrow that led to the development of leuke-
tures of the local environment. In Darwin’s finches, there is no mias. Working with groups of young and old mice in DeGrego-
“better” beak shape per se, but certain beaks improve survival ri’s Colorado lab, Curtis Henry, now at Emory University, and
under certain conditions. Similarly, we reasoned that a muta- Andriy Marusyk, now at the Moffitt Cancer Center, created the
tion that turns on a cancer-causing gene does not provide an same cancer-causing mutations in a few of the mice’s bone mar-
FROM PREVENTION TO THERAPY stant evolutionary cycle that produces the development of
in addition to primary prevention, an evolutionary understand- drug-resistant pathogens. But this lesson has not yet taken hold
ing can help make therapies for existing cancers more effective in the cancer field.
oo d l r
ke
w
oc ome e ed will
na rs. S nst th hat
’t
on ntist
ts scie ges
HY
S IC
he G
S
f
r
s t
it i o
ad he st aga out
T ot
s h
pu ics to
a
ing find
i w
T ind o
P u
r e
a
p hys coles te
of ra h S
cen
t
Fa
D i well
Lo
Sa V in n c e
r
By n b y S pe
K razy
o y
at i yb
l u s t r ra ph
Il g
ot o
Ph
an equal force in the opposite direction. When you times better than current technology, swooping in to
push into the wall of a swimming pool, thrust is what push on the sluggish status quo. In start-up-world-
pushes you back. speak, this would be called “disruption.”
Fuel, though, is heavy and inefficient. To get truly As an example, Derleth cites the work of Philip
huge thrust, a vehicle would need to carry so much gas Lubin of the University of California, Santa Barbara. A
that it would never get off the ground. For missions to few years ago Lubin proposed a project nicknamed
other solar systems or even travel within our solar sys- Starchip Enterprise: a tiny satellite equipped with a
tem at a much quicker pace, chemical fuel is just not “light sail” (a new iteration of an idea that predates the
going to cut it. “There’s only so much energy in those project). From Earth orbit, powerful lasers would
propellants,” says John Brophy of nasa’s Jet Propulsion shoot toward the sail. When they hit, the sail would
Laboratory (JPL). He leads another NIAC-funded proj- reflect the light, and its momentum would thrust the
ect called A Breakthrough Propulsion Architecture for spacecraft forward. NIAC awarded Lubin grants in
Interstellar Precursor Missions. “It doesn’t matter how 2015 and 2016, and he now works with a project from
smart you are, how big a nozzle you make, you can’t the Breakthrough Initiatives to send a laser-powered
beat that problem,” Brophy notes. light sail to the closest star. This is the good kind of
A few deep-space projects, like nasa’s Dawn mission crazy, which NIAC likes. “It’s just crazy enough that it
to the asteroid belt, have instead used electric propul- might work,” Derleth says. “NIAC is for going up to the
sion. Such systems typically use electric power to accel- edge of science fiction but not crossing over.” He adds,
erate charged particles, which can then shoot from the “We do our best to not cross over.”
rocket at speeds up to 20 times faster than traditional But the gap between science and fiction is fraction-
fuels. But these, too, have been stuck in a rut. “It turns al, at these low “technology readiness levels” (TRLs), a
out that almost all the electric thrusters that have been rating system nasa uses to assess how mature an inno-
invented were invented in the 1950s and 1960s,” says vation is. The solar panels on its Mars InSight lander
Dan M. Goebel, a senior research scientist at JPL. “It’s rate a TRL 9, meaning already out in space, working.
like there almost hasn’t been a new idea since then.” NIAC, though, seeks TRLs 1, 2 and, sometimes, 3—ear-
NIAC, though, is all about new ideas. The program ly-stage projects that need more baking before they
functions as nasa’s venture capital arm, in that it sup- are deployed in the real world.
ports technologies that might pan out, big-time. “Cra- Around 200 groups typically submit NIAC Phase I
zy” stuff, according to Jason Derleth, NIAC’s program proposals every year, and the agency okays just 15 to 18.
executive. “What I mean by ‘crazy’ is something no- With $125,000 apiece, scientists get nine months to do
body is thinking about,” Derleth says. Something 10 “a quick turn of the crank to see if something is really
ty of the genuine thrust claim on the Mach Effect lasers, Brophy’s lasers will shoot from orbit, beaming
thruster,” Tajmar says. “But further research is needed light to panels that—like solar panels—turn it into elec-
to definitely confirm that.” Woodward says he believes tric power. That electricity feeds into a propulsion sys-
the setup was not configured correctly. The team tem pumped full of lithium. The voltage whacks elec-
plans to present new data later this year, and Tajmar trons off the lithium atoms, leaving them with a posi-
says that even if the thrust returns, he does not think tive charge. An electric field then accelerates them and
the underlying theory is correct. routes them out the back of the spacecraft. Brophy
Millis tends to agree—both that teams could be wants it to travel 20 times faster than the Dawn space-
seeing a false positive and that, if not, the device is not craft’s ionic propulsion system—whose development he
necessarily demonstrating the Mach effect. In some led—for a speed of around 200 kilometers per second.
ways, though, the underlying theory matters less than But the project is still a moonshot. The team is not
the empirical demonstration. As Lance Williams said sure it can point the laser accurately enough or that it
during the 2016 propulsion workshop, “If you can lev- can assemble such a big laser array in space or make
itate a cannonball in front of us, we don’t care what light-converting panels that generate the necessary
the theory is.” 6,000 volts. “That’s why it’s a perfect NIAC study,”
“Skeptical doubt is healthy, and the only way to Brophy says. “[NIAC experiments are] intentionally
resolve doubt is irrefutable evidence,” says Millis, who right at the ragged edge of whether they are feasible
recently spent three months at Tajmar’s lab chasing or infeasible.”
that evidence. “Despite the replications, [the thrust] And some are trying to break away from the electric
still might turn out to be a common measurement arti- trajectory altogether. Another NIAC project is targeting
fact,” he says. “Then again, it may be a genuine new an antimatter engine by “cooling down” positrons,
phenomenon.” Although the science is far from settled, which have the same mass as electrons but the opposite
MEGA’s Phase I results impressed nasa enough that charge. In their natural state, these antimatter particles
the agency gave the group a Phase II grant in 2018. are hotter than the surface of the sun, making them hard
to work with and store. But cooled down, they can be
LASERS, ANTIMATTER AND NUKES kept and controlled and—as this project does—smashed
woodward and Fearn’s experiment is the most exotic of into electrons. The resulting gamma rays could fuel a
NIAC’s propulsion grants. And not all the other fusion reaction that then propels the spacecraft.
researchers who have NIAC funding agree that “exotic” Another idea braids a beam of neutrons and a beam
is the way to go. of laser photons so that the particles do not spread out,
Brophy’s A Breakthrough Propulsion Architecture or diffract, as they travel through space. The neutron
for Interstellar Precursor Missions is pinning its hopes beam corrals the photons by refracting them, or bend-
on lasers. Similar in some ways to Lubin’s light-sail ing their path, and the laser beam’s electric field “traps”
M AT H E M AT I C S
The
Three-Body
Problem
Although mathematicians know they can never fully “solve” this
B
centuries-old quandary, tackling smaller pieces of it has yielded
some intriguing discoveries
By Richard Montgomery
Illustration by Chris Buzelli
IN BRIEF
One of the oldest quandaries in mathematics and Isaac Newton first posed this problem, along with the Mathematicians have nonetheless continued to chip
physics is called the three-body problem—the simpler “two-body problem.” Later, in the case of away at the question, discovering interesting solu-
question of how three bodies, mutually attracted three bodies, the question was found to be practically tions to specific cases. By studying the three-body
by gravity, will move in the future if their current “unsolvable”—it is essentially impossible to find problem, researchers have uncovered fascinating
positions and velocities are known. a formula to exactly predict their orbits. new principles of mathematics.
Breath is life. But pollution-laden air is “quietly poisoning us,” Gardiner writes in her arresting account of one of the biggest environmental threats
to human health, one that claims seven million premature deaths a year worldwide. Through a world tour of air-pollution hotspots, Gardiner, a jour-
nalist, personalizes the damage pollutants do with vivid portraits of residents living alongside dirty ports in Los Angeles, women inhaling acrid
smoke from cooking fires in rural India and the “sour taste” left in her mouth by London’s diesel-clogged air. She lays out solutions, such as the land-
mark Clean Air Act and China’s concerted move away from coal, although she is clear-eyed about potential hurdles and the recent push to undo
critical safeguards. “This is not an insoluble puzzle. . . . We know how to fix it,” Gardiner says. The question is, Will we? —Andrea Thompson
Mendeleyev’s Dream: Range: Why Generalists Crisis in the Red Zone: The Story
The Quest for the Elements Triumph in a Specialized World of the Deadliest Ebola Outbreak in
by Paul Strathern. Pegasus Books, 2019 ($27.95) by David Epstein. Riverhead Books, 2019 ($28) History, and of the Outbreaks to Come
by Richard Preston. Random House, 2019 ($28)
The structure of the periodic How does someone become
table of elements came to the world’s greatest chess In 1976, from somewhere in
Dmitri Mendeleyev in a dream. player, violinist, chemist or pro the rain forest in what is now
The Russian scientist had been golfer? Conventional wisdom the Democratic Republic of
struggling for three nights holds that focusing on one en- the Congo, an unknown virus
and three days to find a pattern organizing the deavor early in life and pouring thousands of prac- jumped from an animal into a
63 known chemical elements, when he finally fell tice hours into it is the only way to excel. Sports human. That strain of virus quickly spread and in-
into a frustrated doze at his desk. When he awoke, journalist Epstein challenges that assumption in fected hundreds of people and then vanished for
he wrote down what had come to him while sleep- a book that studies artists, athletes, scientists and decades. Writer Preston weaves this thrilling tale
ing: a table listing the elements according to both musicians who did not follow a fixed path to suc- of the reemergence of the Ebola virus in 2013, told
their atomic weight and their chemical properties, cess. One surprising example is eight-time Wim- in the words of those in the thick of the health cri-
PRASHANTH VISHWANATHAN Getty Images
which repeated at periodic intervals. Writer Strath- bledon champion Roger Federer, who bounced sis. It reads like fiction: In one ward in Sierra Leone
ern tells the story of this monumental discovery, as around several sports before settling on tennis. during the latest outbreak, disease researcher Lina
well as the history of chemistry leading to this point, Generalists, Epstein finds, often find their direction Moses ran in flip-flops among the hospital wings,
to show how science has progressed from believing later and dabble in many areas rather than homing helping with one emergency after another. At
the world was made of the elements earth, air, fire in on any given pursuit. He argues that approach- night, shaky and feverish with malaria, she would
and water to our present-day knowledge of 118 ele- ing a field with an outsider’s unfamiliarity may lie on her bed and cry, looking at the photos of her
ments and counting. —Clara Moskowitz lead to brilliant breakthroughs. —Jim Daley daughters in the locket around her neck. She lived.
Should Kids machine language. It was fun, like solving puzzles—and I got my
first job as a software developer in my first year in college. Things
haven’t changed that much: software developers still make good
Learn to Code? money and are in high demand. So what’s with the “maybe not”?
Programming was fun for me. But what about the child who’s
not so enthusiastic? Should he or she be made to learn program-
Not necessarily! ming because it could lead to a job someday? I would hold off: it’s
By Zeynep Tufekci unlikely we will be programming computers the same way in the
decades ahead that we do now. Machine learning, for example,
The government is behind it. In his 2016 State of the Union which is what we mostly mean when we talk about AI, is very dif-
address, President Barack Obama said that the U.S. should offer ferent than giving the computer detailed, step-by-step instruc-
“every student the hands-on computer science and math classes tions. Instead we feed machine-learning algorithms large
that make them job-ready on day one.” Soon after, he launched a amounts of data, and the programs themselves construct the
$4-billion Computer Science For All initiative. models that do the work.
Technology companies are enthusiastic. Amazon wants to To give a striking example, Google Translate used to involve
teach coding to 10 million kids a year through its Amazon Future 500,000 lines of code. Nowadays it’s just about 500 lines in a
Engineer program. Facebook, Microsoft, Google and others have machine-learning language. The key challenge isn’t knowing a
similar projects of varying scale and scope. Many parents are programming language: it’s having enough data and understand-
eager, too. According to Code.org, a nonprofit aiming to increase ing how the computer-constructed models work mathematically
computer science education, 90 percent of parents want their so we can fine-tune and test them.
children to study computer science in school. That explains the What matters, then, for the future of this kind of computer
popularity of many kid-oriented tutorials and computer pro- work? The technical side is mostly math: statistics, linear algebra,
gramming languages, such as Scratch and Hour of Code. probability, calculus. Math remains a significant skill and is use-
So should you sign your kid up for a programming camp? ful for many professions besides programming. It’s essential for
Insist they take computer science classes? Maybe, maybe not. I everyday life, too. And algorithmic thinking doesn’t have to come
learned coding as a child, and it has served me very well. I pur- from computer coding. Some math and an appropriate learning
chased a home computer with money I earned bagging groceries experience via cooking, sewing, knitting—all of which involve
and learned the Basic programming language, as well as some algorithms of a sort—can be valuable.
More important for the future, though, is the fact that, by
itself, computer programming encourages closed-world building.
That’s partly what made it so much fun for me: it’s magical to put
together something (tedious) instruction by instruction and then
go play in the world one has built. Unfortunately, that is the far-
thest from what the tech industry does these days. Programmers
are now creating tools that interact with the messy, challenging
reality of life. If anything, their affinity for building insular worlds
might have hindered their understanding of how the tools would
actually function. What we need now are people who know his-
tory, sociology, psychology, math and computers and who are
comfortable analyzing complex, open and chaotic systems.
So should you let an interested child enroll in a coding camp?
Of course. Should kids play around with Scratch or do an Hour of
Code tutorial to see if that captivates their interest? Absolutely.
But no worries if they want instead to learn how to make cup-
cakes, sew pillows or pajamas, or climb trees.
We need to make sure youngsters do not think of the world as
forcing them to choose between math and science on the one
hand and social sciences and humanities on the other. The most
interesting, and perhaps most challenging, questions facing us
will be right at that intersection—not in the tiny, closed worlds we
like to build for fun.
J O I N T H E C O N V E R S AT I O N O N L I N E
Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
Do the Math mathematicians are very busy admiring the architecture. The
physicists are admiring the animals. Which is actually more
important isn’t to me the interesting question. The interesting
It sure comes in handy for doing physics question is, Why do they fit so well?”
By Steve Mirsky Mathematician Karen Uhlenbeck, professor emeritus at the
University of Texas at Austin, had a different take: “There’s this
Early in his new book, physics historian Graham Farmelo quotes picture [that] there’s a perfect world out there, and it has laws,
Nima Arkani-Hamed, a theoretical physicist at the Institute for and we’re going to discover these laws. [But we’re] just a bunch
Advanced Study (IAS) in Princeton, N.J.: “We can eavesdrop on of human beings muddling along in a world that’s very hard to
nature not only by paying attention to experiments but also by understand. I mean, it’s deceptive that the world looks so clear
trying to understand how their results can be explained with and beautiful and well put together. Because the minute you
the deepest mathematics. You could say that the universe speaks look at it with a different wavelength, it looks completely differ-
to us in numbers.” Relax, he doesn’t mean numerology. ent. So our picture of the world as completely made and perfect—
That quote provides the book’s title: The Universe Speaks in and all we need to do is find the rules for it—doesn’t fit with my
Numbers. Of course, there’s a subtitle, too: How Modern Math feeling. It’s a kind of a muddle-y place, and you look at a piece of
Reveals Nature’s Deepest Secrets. The book also deals with the it, and we try to straighten it out, and we put together ideas in
thorny question of whether the revelations of math truly are our mind, and we somehow make rules and order, and we create
nature’s deepest secrets or whether they’re merely some secrets mathematics as a language in response to external stimuli.”
that we can glimpse via math. That discussion can lead to phys- Dyson immediately attempted a reconciliation: “I don’t dis-
ics conference fistfights. agree with you. We’re exploring a universe which is full of myster-
The IAS hosted a symposium on Farmelo’s subject on May 29. ies ... what to me is still amazing is that we understand so much.”
In brief opening remarks, IAS director Robbert Dijkgraaf said, These conversations always remind of the very short Robert
“There are many anecdotes about the relationship between phys- Frost poem: “We dance round in a ring and suppose,/But the
ics and mathematics.” He then quoted Richard Feynman—“not Secret sits in the middle and knows.” I would have loved to ask
known as a lover of abstract mathematics”—as having said, “‘If all Frost how he knew the secret was sitting.
mathematics disappeared today, physics would be set back
JOIN T HE CONVERSAT ION ONLINE
exactly one week.’” After the laughs (possibly from only the phys- Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
icists and not the mathematicians in the audience) subsided, or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
AUG US T
1969 Drifting
Genes
“The survival and preferential mul-
to be undertaken within a few days
by C. J. Zimmerman, a skilled pilot,
who will follow the steamer ‘Adriat-
the seasonal shift of ocean currents,
at which time the warm equatorial
countercurrent displaces the cool
tiplication of types better adapted ic’ two or three hours after she has Peruvian current. The resulting
to the environment (natural selec- sailed for England, and overtaking change in temperature of the ocean
tion) is the basis of evolution. Into her will drop a mail pouch into the water would, he thinks, kill quanti-
this process, however, enters anoth- sea just ahead of her bow [see illus- ties of plankton, and the decay of
er kind of variation that is so com- tration]. This experiment will be 1969 this organic matter would give rise
pletely independent of natural se- closely followed by the post office to the phenomena observed.”
lection that it can even promote the authorities and the steamship men.” the low oxygen content of warmer el
predominance of genes that oppose the delivery was successful, but the Niño waters suffocates many organisms.
adaptation rather than favoring it. technique was perilous as compared
with regular airmail delivery. Solar
Called genetic drift, this type of
variation is a random, statistical
fluctuation in the frequency of a Dead Water
1869 Furnace
“The materials of our sun are,
gene as it appears in a population “Mariners who frequent the coast doubtless, capable of producing
from one generation to the next. of Peru are familiar with a curious 1919 greater heat, pound for pound, than
My colleagues and I have for the phenomenon that occasionally pre- the substances usually employed by
past 15 years been investigating vails there—notably in the harbor us for the same purpose. Recent re-
genetic drift in the populations of of Callao near Lima—commonly searches in chemistry would seem
the cities and villages in the Parma known as the ‘painter.’ The water to point to a more elementary con-
Valley in Italy. We have examined becomes discolored and emits a dition of matter in the stars and
parish books, studied marriage nauseous smell, apparently due to nebulae than any with which we
records in the Vatican archives, sulfuretted hydrogen. The white are acquainted on the earth. Who
made surveys of blood types, devel- paint of vessels becomes coated can say but that the production of
oped mathematical theories and with a chocolate-colored slime. In 1869 our terrestrial elements was accom-
finally simulated some of the re- a paper recently presented to the panied by displays of light and heat
gion’s populations on a computer. Geographical Society of Lima, Sen- similar in intensity to those now
We have found that genetic drift or J. A. de Lavalle y Garcia con- witnessed in the sun and stars?
can affect evolution significantly. cludes that the primary cause is This theory has great support in
—Luigi Luca Cavalli-Sforza” the constantly accumulating facts
which the spectroscope is bringing
Drifting Continents to our attention.”
“More evidence has been adduced
to support the concept of continen- Coal Economics
tal drift. Walter Sproll and Robert S. “All agree that coal is absurdly, ex-
Dietz of the Atlantic Oceanographic tortionately, cruelly high; but all do
Laboratories of the Environmental not agree as to the cause of present
Sciences Service Administration re- high prices, or as to how it may be
port they have succeeded in dem- cheapened. The free traders say the
onstrating that Antarctica and Aus- high price is dependent on the pres-
tralia, now separated by 2,000 ent tariff, while some protectionists
miles of ocean, were once a single say it is owing to extortionate
land mass. Concentrating on the freights and high prices demanded
1,000-fathom isobath (a line around by miners. We say it is a combina-
each continent at that depth), tion of all the causes assigned. We
SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, VOL. CXXI, NO. 8; AUGUST 23, 1919
Different virus types (macrodiversity) Variation within one virus type (microdiversity)
Hotspots
More than 195,000 virus
Variety of Virus Populations populations are concentrated in Variety within Each Population
The number of different virus populations, as well five ocean zones. Two zones are Greater variety of individuals within each
as the relative abundance of those populations, diversity hotspots: the Arctic virus type is a sign of changeable environmental
varies significantly across oceans. This macro (all depths) and surface waters conditions and the degree of new species
diversity strongly affects the health of bacteria, in temperate and tropical formation. Each vertical line shows variation
which are the foundation of the marine food latitudes. Water temperature within the 100 most abundant populations.
web. Each vertical line shows the macrodiversity seems to be the key factor Darker lines represent greater overlap among
in a given water sample; darker lines represent driving the concentrations. sample sets.
greater overlap among sample sets.
Temperate
and Tropical
Epipelagic waters
(depth 0–150 meters)
TO POLE,” BY ANN C. GREGORY ET AL., IN CELL, VOL. 177, NO. 5; MAY 16, 2019
SOURCE: “MARINE DNA VIRAL MACRO- AND MICRODIVERSITY FROM POLE
Mesopelagic waters
(150–1,000 meters)
Bathypelagic waters
(below 2,000 meters)
All depths
Limited data Antarctic