Muda, Mura and Muri: Lean Manufacturing
Muda, Mura and Muri: Lean Manufacturing
Muda Reduction
Most definitions of lean manufacturing in the West refer to the
reduction of the 7 wastes as the main aim of lean
manufacturing. However, few definitions of lean differentiate
between the different types of waste and seem to purely
focus on Muda. TPS, however, sees waste as being all three,
Muda, Mura and Muri, something that many lean practitioners
here in the west seem to have forgotten.
Whilst focusing on the 7 Mudas can make some highly
significant savings, we tend to fail to see the big picture and
make inappropriate processes and products more and more
“efficient”, removing time and cost, but not in a sustainable
manner. Because we fail to see the Mura and Muri within our
systems we start to put Muda back into the processes.
We fail to tackle for instance the unevenness (Mura) in our
demand. When sales tries to offer promotions to sell more
products, this creates higher demand in a short space of time,
requiring the process to have to change to meet this demand,
often through increases in inventory, and other wastes that
undo the improvements made in the processes when
focusing purely on eliminating Muda. Mura can be tackled
through implementing the philosophy of Just In Time (JIT).
I have heard arguments that to tackle Muda automatically
causes you to tackle the Mura and Muri in the system. To
some extent this is correct, tackling a problem and using the
five whys to get to root cause should get you to the Mura and
Muri in the system, however without a holistic view of the
whole system they are often overlooked or not even
recognized as the causes by inexperienced practitioners.
Most people will agree that the best way to tackle a problem
is to remove the root cause, therefore in my mind the focus of
any waste reduction program should be on removing both
Mura and Muri, this will automatically remove much of the
Muda (seven wastes) in the workplace.
Muda in Manufacturing
Muda Definition
TPS splits Muda into seven wastes, although over the years
many have been added. But basically any action that does
not physically change the shape of the product or service and
can be done at a more economical rate or with less resource
should be considered as being one of the seven wastes!
Studies done many times over show that in most industries
less than 5% of actions are value adding, 95% of what we do
is not adding value to the product and is a cost to the
business.
7 Wastes | Source
7 Muda Slideshow
Click thumbnail to view full-size
Muda Transport | Source