Mander Sap2000 Vs Exel

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 6

UNIVERSIDAD

TÉCNICA DE
AMBATO

FACULTAD DE INGENIERÍA CIVIL Y


MECÁNICA

CARRERA DE INGENIERÍA CIVIL


OPTATIVA III

NOMBRE:
MARIO FLORES

SEMESTRE:
NOVENO “B”

DOCENTE:
ING.: CRISTIAN MEDINA

FECHA:
24/06/2019
1.- M-C Manual (exel) 10 punts
ec 0.001 ec 0.0012 ec 0.0015 ec 0.0026 ec 0.0029 ec 0.0034 ec 0.0041 ec 0.0045 ec 0.0049 ec 0.0051
c asum. (cm) 6.49003566 c asum. (cm) 5.91334591 c asum. (cm) 5.29868394 c asum. (cm) 5.2844734 c asum. (cm) 5.4732729 c asum. (cm) 5.81090909 c asum. (cm) 6.19256212 c asum. (cm) 6.42819318 c asum. (cm) 6.64295302 c asum. (cm) 25.1983096
ITERACIÓN OK ITERACIÓN OK ITERACIÓN OK ITERACIÓN OK ITERACIÓN OK ITERACIÓN OK ITERACIÓN OK ITERACIÓN OK ITERACIÓN OK ITERACIÓN ITERAR
εs 0.0037 εs 0.0049 εs 0.0071 εs 0.0123 εs 0.0132 εs 0.0143 εs 0.0160 εs 0.0167 εs 0.0174 εs 0.0010
εs' 0.0003 εs' 0.0002 εs' 0.0002 εs' 0.0003 εs' 0.0004 εs' 0.0006 εs' 0.0010 ε s' 0.0012 ε s' 0.0014 ε s' 0.0041
fs (Kg/cm2) 4200 fs (Kg/cm2) 4200 fs (Kg/cm2) 4200 fs (Kg/cm2) 4320.5444 fs (Kg/cm2) 4366.7568 fs (Kg/cm2) 4422.50746 fs (Kg/cm2) 4507.08563 fs (Kg/cm2) 4541.35359 fs (Kg/cm2) 4575.29586 fs (Kg/cm2) 2100
fs' (Kg/cm2) 630 fs' (Kg/cm2) 420 fs' (Kg/cm2) 420 fs' (Kg/cm2) 630 fs' (Kg/cm2) 840 fs' (Kg/cm2) 1260 fs' (Kg/cm2) 2100 fs' (Kg/cm2) 2520 fs' (Kg/cm2) 2940 fs' (Kg/cm2) 4200
fc (Kg/cm2) 180.11 fc (Kg/cm2) 203.27 fc (Kg/cm2) 226.85 fc (Kg/cm2) 228.09 fc (Kg/cm2) 216.72 fc (Kg/cm2) 195.36 fc (Kg/cm2) 166.31 fc (Kg/cm2) 151.53 fc (Kg/cm2) 138.28 fc (Kg/cm2) 0.00
Ts (Kg) 32340.0 Ts (Kg) 32340.0 Ts (Kg) 32340.0 Ts (Kg) 33268.2 Ts (Kg) 33624.0 Ts (Kg) 34053.3 Ts (Kg) 34704.6 Ts (Kg) 34968.4 Ts (Kg) 35229.8 Ts (Kg) 16170.0
Cs' (Kg) 2532.6 Cs' (Kg) 1688.4 Cs' (Kg) 1688.4 Cs' (Kg) 2532.6 Cs' (Kg) 3376.8 Cs' (Kg) 5065.2 Cs' (Kg) 8442 Cs' (Kg) 10130.4 Cs' (Kg) 11818.8 Cs' (Kg) 16884
Cc (Kg) 29807.40 Cc (Kg) 30651.60 Cc (Kg) 30651.60 Cc (Kg) 30735.59 Cc (Kg) 30247.23 Cc (Kg) 28948.37 Cc (Kg) 26262.56 Cc (Kg) 24838.02 Cc (Kg) 23423.52 Cc (Kg) 0.00
EQUILIBRIO 0.00 EQUILIBRIO 0.00 EQUILIBRIO 0.00 EQUILIBRIO 0.00 EQUILIBRIO 0.00 EQUILIBRIO 39.74 EQUILIBRIO 0.00 EQUILIBRIO 0.00 EQUILIBRIO -12.55 EQUILIBRIO -714.00
M (TON.m) 8.907 M (TON.m) 8.986 M (TON.m) 9.071 M (TON.m) 9.333 M (TON.m) 9.406 M (TON.m) 9.477 M (TON.m) 9.602 M (TON.m) 9.640 M (TON.m) 9.680 M (TON.m) 3.168
φ (1/m) 0.01540824 φ (1/m) 0.02029308 φ (1/m) 0.02830892 φ (1/m) 0.04920074 φ (1/m) 0.05298475 φ (1/m) 0.05851064 φ (1/m) 0.06620846 φ (1/m) 0.07000412 φ (1/m) 0.07376238 φ (1/m) 0.02023945

ec Ф ( 1 / m) M ( Tn *m)
0 0 0.000
0.001 0.01540824 8.907
0.0012 0.02029308 8.986
0.002 0.02830892 9.071
0.0025 0.04920074 9.333
0.003 0.05298475 9.406
0.0035 0.05851064 9.477
0.0041 0.06620846 9.602
0.0045 0.07000412 9.640
0.0049 0.07376238 9.680
0.005 0.07376238 0
da t o s de l a s e c c io n
b(cm) 30
H(cm) 35
rlibre(cm) 3
Asinf (cm2) 4.02 ʹ ‫ ׎‬͸ͳ
As sup(cm2) 7.7 ͷ‫ ׎‬ͶͳͶ
Ab(cm2) 0.785 ͳ‫ͲͳͲ ׎‬
n# 2 2 ramales
Ce 0.8
s(cm) 7.5
F´c (kg/cm2) 240 23.55 Mpa
fy(kg/cm2) 4200 412.17 Mpa
b´(cm) 24 b-2veces recubrimiento
pv 0.009
fl(Mpa) 1.438
f´cc(Mpa) 32.277 328.902 kg/cm2

2.- Modelo SAP200 de la viga

¿ 2 ∅ 16

¿ 5 ∅ 14
1.3.-Modelo Mander (concreto no confinado) SAP 2000

1.4.-Modelo Mander (concreto confinado) SAP 2000


1.5.- Datos M-C SAP 200

Con c r e t e St r a in St e e l St r a in Cur va t ur e Mo me n t Con c r e t e St r a in St e e l St r a in Cu r v a t u r e Mo me n t


0 0 0 0 -9.67E-03 0.0398 0.1845 12.4335
-1.88E-05 5.59E-05 0.0002785 0.274 -0.0102 0.0412 0.1918 12.5142
-4.63E-05 1.40E-04 0.0006963 0.6806 -0.0107 0.0427 0.1991 12.5787
-8.31E-05 2.53E-04 0.001253 1.2239 -0.0112 0.0442 0.2067 12.6158
-1.29E-04 3.93E-04 0.00195 1.904 -0.0117 0.0457 0.2143 12.6534
-1.85E-04 5.62E-04 0.002785 2.7204 -0.0122 0.0473 0.2221 12.6912
-2.50E-04 7.58E-04 0.00376 3.6729 -0.0128 0.0489 0.2301 12.7281
-3.24E-04 9.82E-04 0.004874 4.7577 -0.0133 0.0505 0.2381 12.7713
-4.12E-04 1.23E-03 0.006127 5.9457 -0.0139 0.0521 0.2464 12.8177
-5.13E-04 1.50E-03 0.00752 7.2414 -0.0144 0.0538 0.2547 12.8644
-6.25E-04 1.80E-03 0.009052 8.6639 -0.015 0.0555 0.2632 12.9117
-7.18E-04 2.16E-03 0.01072 9.6467 -0.0156 0.0572 0.2718 12.9605
-7.52E-04 2.61E-03 0.01253 9.7101 -0.0171 0.0581 0.2806 12.8546
-7.84E-04 3.10E-03 0.01448 9.7636 -0.0187 0.0577 0.2851 12.6634
-8.13E-04 3.63E-03 0.01657 9.8093 -0.0213 0.0587 0.2986 12.4971
-8.43E-04 4.20E-03 0.0188 9.8464 -0.0246 0.0579 0.3078 12.1994
-8.72E-04 4.80E-03 0.02117 9.8773 -0.0276 0.0573 0.3171 11.9617
-9.01E-04 5.44E-03 0.02367 9.9037 -0.0309 0.0566 0.3266 11.7292
-9.30E-04 6.12E-03 0.02632 9.9266 -0.0356 0.0545 0.3362 11.3445
-9.60E-04 6.84E-03 0.02911 9.9453 -0.0402 0.0525 0.3459 11.0093
-9.91E-04 7.59E-03 0.03203 9.9608 -0.0446 0.0507 0.3558 10.7304
-1.02E-03 8.38E-03 0.03509 9.9738 -0.0498 0.0483 0.3658 10.4007
-1.06E-03 9.21E-03 0.0383 9.9841 -0.0555 0.0453 0.376 10.0457
-1.10E-03 0.0101 0.04164 10.0005 -0.061 0.0425 0.3863 9.7422
-1.16E-03 0.0109 0.04512 10.152 -0.0658 0.0405 0.3968 9.4811
-1.23E-03 0.0118 0.04874 10.3019 -0.0705 0.0387 0.4073 9.2405
-1.31E-03 0.0128 0.0525 10.4585 -0.0753 0.0368 0.4181 9.016
-1.40E-03 0.0137 0.0564 10.615 -0.0799 0.0351 0.4289 8.8229
-1.49E-03 0.0147 0.06044 10.7735 -0.0848 0.0331 0.4399 8.6117
-1.59E-03 0.0157 0.06462 10.9345 -0.0896 0.0313 0.4511 8.424
-1.71E-03 0.0168 0.06893 11.0983 -0.0945 0.0295 0.4623 8.2493
-1.82E-03 0.0178 0.07339 11.2635 -0.0956 0.029 0.4652 8.2108
-1.98E-03 0.0189 0.07799 11.4025 -0.1287 1.38E-03 0.4853 0.3978
-2.28E-03 0.0199 0.08272 11.4165 -0.1318 1.35E-03 0.497 0.377
-2.62E-03 0.0209 0.08759 11.4194 -0.135 1.33E-03 0.5089 0.3586
-2.93E-03 0.0219 0.09261 11.4692 -0.1383 1.31E-03 0.5208 0.3413
-3.23E-03 0.023 0.09776 11.5547 -0.1415 1.29E-03 0.5329 0.3251
-4.16E-03 0.0235 0.1031 11.3967 -0.1448 1.27E-03 0.5452 0.3099
-4.84E-03 0.0242 0.1085 11.3921 -0.1482 1.26E-03 0.5576 0.2956
-5.22E-03 0.0253 0.1141 11.5424 -0.1516 1.24E-03 0.5701 0.2822
-5.59E-03 0.0265 0.1198 11.6672 -0.155 1.22E-03 0.5828 0.2695
-5.92E-03 0.0277 0.1256 11.738 -0.1584 1.21E-03 0.5956 0.2576
-6.27E-03 0.029 0.1316 11.8109 -0.1619 1.19E-03 0.6086 0.2463
-6.63E-03 0.0303 0.1377 11.8852 -0.1654 1.18E-03 0.6217 0.2356
-7.01E-03 0.0316 0.144 11.9608 -0.169 1.17E-03 0.6349 0.2256
-7.40E-03 0.0329 0.1504 12.0376 -0.1726 1.15E-03 0.6483 0.2161
-7.82E-03 0.0342 0.1569 12.1154 -0.1762 1.14E-03 0.6618 0.2071
-8.25E-03 0.0356 0.1636 12.194 -0.1799 1.13E-03 0.6754 0.1986
-8.71E-03 0.037 0.1705 12.2734 -0.1836 1.12E-03 0.6892 0.1905
-9.18E-03 0.0384 0.1774 12.3532 -0.1873 1.11E-03 0.7031 0.1829
1.6.-Comparación de exel vs SAP200

1.7.-Conclusines
Se han asumido varios parámetros para que la gráfica manual obtenga una gráfica
similar a la del SAP pero este programa usa métodos infinitos y un análisis mas
profundo que el método manual por ende difiere en parte los resultados de ambas
gráficas

You might also like