Reactive Fibre Reinforced Glass Ionomer Cements
Reactive Fibre Reinforced Glass Ionomer Cements
Reactive Fibre Reinforced Glass Ionomer Cements
Abstract
The mechanical properties of glass ionomer cements used in restorative dentistry reinforced by chopped glass fibres were
investigated. Reactive glass fibres with a composition in the system SiO2–Al2O3–CaF2–Na3AlF6 and a thickness of 26 mm were
drawn by a bushing process. The manufacturing parameters were optimized with respect to maximum strength of the glass fibre
reinforced ionomer cements. Powder to liquid ratio, pre-treatment of the glass, grain size distribution and fibre volume fraction were
varied. Glass fibre and cement were characterized by X-ray diffraction, transmission electron microscopy and energy dispersive
spectroscopy techniques, respectively. The highest flexural strength of the reinforced cement (15.6 MPa) was found by compounding
20 vol% reactive fibres and extending the initial dry gelation period up to 30 min. Microscopic examination of the fractured cements
indicated a distinct reactive layer at the fibre surface. A pronounced fibre pull out mode gives rise to an additional work-of-fracture
contributed by pulling the fibres out of the fracture surface.
r 2003 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Glass ionomer cement; Glass fibres; Reinforcement; Fibre drawing; Mechanical strength
0142-9612/03/$ - see front matter r 2003 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0142-9612(03)00130-3
2902 U. Lohbauer et al. / Biomaterials 24 (2003) 2901–2907
Compared to other restorative materials like amalgam powders were measured using light scattering with a
or polymer composites, however, GICs suffer from laser (Cilass 715, Cilas Corp., Marcoussis, France), and
lower strength, wear resistance and fracture toughness the surface area was determined by standard nitrogen
[3,14–16]. Reinforcement of GIC has therefore become a adsorption method (BET, ASAPs 2000 Nitrogen,
matter of increasing research efforts. In former experi- Micromeritics Corp., Norcross, USA). The crystalline
ments various alumina, zirconia, silicon carbide, carbon phase composition was determined by X-ray diffraction
fibres, or metal particles were used with encouraging using monochromated CuKa radiation (D 5000s, Sie-
results [2]. Fibre length and volume fraction are thereby mens Corp., Mannheim, Germany). The microstructure
key microstructural parameters determining the result- of the quenched glass and the fibre was examined in an
ing cement properties [17]. A strengthening effect, due to analytical transmission electron microscope (Philips CM
fibre pull-out or crack bridging during fracture process 30 T, Philips, USA) and by energy dispersive spectro-
is mainly influenced by the matrix–fibre interface scopy (EDS). The TEM work was performed using
coupling [18]. Fibre reinforcement with reactive glass 300 KV acceleration voltage. The specimens were pre-
fibres is one attempt to achieve proper fibre embedding pared by focused ion beam (FIB) technique.
in the matrix cement. Short glass fibre reinforcement Thirty grams of the glass frit were melted in a
was studied by Kawano et al. [19] and Kobayashi et al. platinum crucible with a hole in the bottom. The glass
[20] with a glass composition in the system CaO–P2O5– melt flowing through the hole with a diameter of 1.5 mm
SiO2–Al2O3. They used phosphate glasses, since im- was pulled into a fibre and, after rapid air cooling-
proved self-adhesion to human dentine is described [21]. wound onto a rotating drum with a diameter of 150 mm.
The aim of the present work is to incorporate high The rate of mass flow of the glass melt out of the
strength reactive glass fibres into the GIC matrix. bushing is dependent on geometrical factors of the
Depending on the interfacial coupling of fibre-to-matrix, bushing and the viscosity of the glass [26,27]. The two
theoretical models predict a significant increase of the parameters that were varied to adjust an optimum
work-of-fracture when continuous fibres are aligned thickness of the chopped fibre were temperature and
with the primary loading direction so that effective load drawing speed. Finally a temperature of 1120 C and a
transfer from the matrix to the fibre can be induced. In drawing speed of 3 m/s were selected. The glass frit was
the case of short fibres dispersed with random orienta- heated up to 1300 C before drawing and maintained
tion in the matrix the situation is more complex [22,23]. there for 1 h in order to homogenize the melt.
Fibres below a critical length (which is determined by The drawn glass fibre was cut into short fibres by a
the ratio of the fibre strength to the shear strength of the rotating guillotine. The critical fibre length 2xc ; which is
matrix–fibre interface) are less effective in reinforcement supposed to provide maximum load transfer by means
whereas using longer fibres nothing is gained by the of elastic strain and frictional pull out, was calculated
extra length [22,24]. For the system under investigation by [22]
a critical fibre length of approximately 550 mm was d sf
estimated from fibre and matrix properties. In this 2xc ¼ ; ð1Þ
4 sm
investigation, a model glass frit of the system SiO2–
Al2O3–CaF2–Na3AlF6 was used to prepare glass fibres where d is the fibre diameter, sf the fibre strength and
by a bushing process. The study deals with fluoride sm the shear strength at the matrix–fibre interface.
glasses, since an increased fluorine content was shown to Ashby et al. reported a correlation between interface
result in a rise of strength [25]. The influence of different shear strength and matrix yield strength:
processing conditions on the mechanical strength of the smðShearÞ E1=2smðyieldÞ [22]. The strength smðyieldÞ was
fibre reinforced glass ionomer cement (FRGIC) was derived from the flexural matrix strength of the used
analysed. base cement system. The tensile strength of the fibres
was measured in an universal testing machine (Z 2.5,
Zwick, Germany) according to ENV 1007-4 standard.
2. Experimental procedure The fibre length and diameter distributions were
measured using light microscopy, Fig. 2.
2.1. Glass fibres
2.2. Glass ionomer cements
The following glass composition was selected for fibre
processing: SiO2:33.3, Al2O3:16.7, CaO:14, NaF:3.3, The GIC matrices were prepared by mixing a glass
AlF3:3.3, Na3AlF6:16.2 [wt%]. The oxide powder powder with an aqueous polycarbonic acid. The mean
mixture was melted at 1400 C for 1 h and subsequently particle size of the glass powders are listed in Table 1.
quenched in water of room temperature. The glass frit The milled glass powder was treated in various ways to
was milled to obtain different grain sizes of 6.8 and reduce surface reactivity and to increase working time
2.4 mm, respectively. The grain size distributions of the [28,29]. A combination of acid treatment and annealing
U. Lohbauer et al. / Biomaterials 24 (2003) 2901–2907 2903
Table 1
Test specifications and results of the cement optimizing tests
Glass charge Grain size [mm] BET surface area Acid washing/heat Working time [sec] Powder/liquid Compressive strength
(d10 =d50 =d90 ) [m2/g] treatment ratio [MPa] (S.D.)
Glass charge Fibre fraction BET surface area Base glass Working time [sec] Powder/liquid Compressive strength
[vol.%] [m2/g]a ratio [MPa] (S.D.)
F1 20 1.624 G4 n.m. 4 134 (4)
F2 40 1.249 G4 n.m. 5.4 98 (4)
F3 60 0.873 G4 n.m. 5.4 82 (6)
a
Calculated cylindrical fibre surface area: 0.1225 m2/g.
procedure was applied, as shown in Table 1 (G5–G7). ing tests. The 4-point-bending-test was applied on GICs
The optimum powder to liquid ratio was found for the and FRGICs with optimized parameters. The data were
processing conditions which finally resulted in the GIC statistically treated by an ANOVA test with a Bonfer-
with the highest compressive strength, Table 1 (G1–G4). roni post-hoc routine (po0:05). For fractographic
The medium grain size was decreased for G8 and G9. analysis the fractured FRGIC specimens were examined
For all cements an aqueous solution of 40–45 wt% under a SEM (Leitz ISIs SR50, Akashi, Japan).
polyacrylic–maleic acid solution containing 8–10 wt%
tartaric acid was used as suspension liquid. The
FRGICs were prepared by adding a percentage of fibres
to the glass powder. The optimum fibre loading was 3. Results and discussion
determined by measurements of the compressive
strength of the composite materials. The GIC and 3.1. Reactive glass fibre
FRGIC were all hand mixed and manufactured in a
suitable mould according to ISO standard. The speci- Due to a 1 h homogenisation of the glass melt and due
mens for compressive strength testing had a diameter of to the knowledge of fluorine as a volatile, the loss of
4 mm and a height of 6 mm (ISO 9917-1:2002). The fluorine was determined from previous work to 53.4%.
bending bars were produced with the dimensions Based on a calculated content of 1.26 g fluorine in 10 g
25 2 2 mm3 (ISO 4049). The specimens were all oxide powder prior to melting, a remaining content of
stored for 24 h in distilled water at 37 C after an initial 0.67 g in 10 g glass fibres was detected, using the ion-
dry gelation period. Table 1 summarizes the specimen selective electrode (ISE) method [30].
compositions, test specifications and results of strength However, the XRD patterns of the glass still show a
measurements. distinct, crystalline peak of calcium fluoride (CaF2) as
the only crystalline phase. The broadness of the peak
suggests the presence of small CaF2 crystals.
2.3. Strength measurements and fractography Fig. 1 shows a TEM image of the glass. TEM and
EDS examination exhibit a droplet phase (A) in the
Fracture strength under compressive and bending glass that is rich in fluorine and calcium. The droplet
loading of the GICs and FRGICs was determined by phase can also be seen to contain nanoscale crystals (B).
measuring the critical fracture strength of at least 15 Other authors assumed the presence of CaF2 crystals in
specimens each set. All specimens were loaded in an the droplet phase [9,10]. Small crystals (B) may also be
universal testing machine (Z 2.5, Zwick, Germany) with seen in the glass. EDS spectra (A–C) were taken and the
a crosshead speed of 0.75 mm/min. The compressive same elements, calcium, fluorine, aluminium, silicon and
strength measurement was used for the cement optimiz- sodium were detected in all regions. The amorphous
2904 U. Lohbauer et al. / Biomaterials 24 (2003) 2901–2907
(C)
(A)
(A)
(B)
(B) 500 µm
(C)
Fig. 2. Short glass fibres cut in length of 580 mm (F1–F6).
Acknowledgements
References
Fig. 5. Reactive surface layer at the fibre–matrix interface (F5). [1] Wilson AD, Kent BE, Clinton D, Miller RP. The formation
and microstructure of dental silicate cements. J Mater Sci
1972;7:220–38.
At the interface between matrix and fibre, a distinct [2] Wilson AD, McLean JW. Glass-ionomer cement. Berlin: Quin-
reactive layer has been formed during the setting tessence, 1988.
[3] Saito S, Tosaki S, Hirota K. Characteristics of glass-ionomer
process. Wilson stated in his work [2] that the interface cements. In: Davidson CL, MjoR. IA, editors. Advances in glass-
between the silica gel layer around the unreacted glass ionomer cements. Berlin: Quintessence Publishing Co, 1999.
core of glass particles in cements tends to be weak. On [4] Wasson EA, Nicholson JW. New aspects of the setting of glass-
this site fracture was observed as illustrated in Fig. 5. ionomer cements. J Dent Res 1993;72:481–3.
[5] Wasson EA, Nicholson JW. Studies on the setting chemistry of
The fracture surface of the fibre reinforced cements
glass-ionomer cements. Clin Mater 1991;7:289–93.
showed clear evidence of extended fibre pull-out. The [6] Forsten L. Fluoride release and uptake by glass-ionomers
absorbed energy due to pull-out gives rise for an and related materials and its clinical effect. Biomaterials
increase in fracture toughness. A further increase in 1998;19:503–8.
toughness and failure strength of the FRGIC can be [7] Griffin SG, Hill RG. Influence of glass composition on the
expected by embedding strong fibres in a weak matrix properties of glass polyalkenoate cements Part IV: influence of
fluorine content. Biomaterials 2000;21:693–8.
material. Defined interface properties of matrix–fibre [8] Williams JA, Billington RW, Pearson GJ. The glass ionomer
lead to a high profit in work-of-fracture and high cement: the sources of soluble fluoride. Biomaterials
toughness, respectively [17,37]. 2002;23:2191–200.
[9] Barry TI, Clinton DJ, Wilson AD. The structure of a glass-
ionomer cement and its relationship to the setting process. J Dent
Res 1979;58:1072–9.
4. Conclusions [10] Wood D, Hill R. Structure–property relationships in ionomer
glasses. Clin Mater 1991;7:301–12.
[11] Vogel W. Glaschemie. Berlin: Springer, 1992.
Short reactive glass fibres with a length of 580 mm [12] De Maeyer EAP, Verbeek RMH, Vercruysee CWJ. Reactivity of
were prepared from a glass frit of the system SiO2– fluoride-containing calcium aluminosilicate glasses used in dental
Al2O3–CaF2–Na3AlF6. The fibres were used for re- glass-ionomer cement. J Dent Res 1998;77:2005–11.
U. Lohbauer et al. / Biomaterials 24 (2003) 2901–2907 2907
[13] Eichmiller FC, Marjenhoff WA. Fluoride releasing dental [26] Burgman JA, Hunia EM. The effect of fibre diameter, environ-
restorative materials. Oper Dent 1999;23:218–28. mental moisture, and cooling time during fibre formation
[14] Mount GJ. Glass ionomers: a review on their current status. Oper on the strength of E glass fibres. Glass Technol 1970;11:
Dent 1999;24:114–24. 147–52.
[15] Pelka M, Ebert J, Schneider H, Kr.amer N, Petschelt A. [27] Loewenstein KL. The manufacturing technology of continuous
Comparision of two- and three-body wear of glass-ionomers glass fibres. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers, 1993.
and composites. Eur J Oral Sci 1996;104:132–7. [28] Neve AD, Piddock V, Combe EC. The effect of glass heat
[16] Xie D, Brantley WA, Culbertson BM, Wang G. Mechanical treatment on the properties of a novel polyalkenoate cement. Clin
properties and microstructures of glass-ionomer cements. Dent Mater 1993;12:113–5.
Mater 2000;16:129–38. [29] Schmitt W, Purmann R, Jochum P, Gasser O. US Patent A.
[17] Xu HHK, Eichmiller FC, Barndt PR. Effects of fiber length and 1,376.835; 1983.
volume fraction on the reinforcement of calcium phosphate [30] McCabe JF, Carrick TE, Sidhu SK. Determining low levels of
cement. J Mater Sci Mater Med 2001;12:57–65. fluoride released from resin based dental materials. Eur J Oral Sci
[18] Evans AG, Zwez D. The physics and mechanics of fibre- 2002;110:380–4.
reinforced brittle matrix composites. J Mater Sci 1994;29:3857–96. [31] Billington RW, Williams JA, Pearson GJ. Variation in powder/
[19] Kawano F, Kon M, Kobayashi M, Miyai K. Reinforcement effect liquid ratio of a restorative glass-ionomer cement used in dental
of short glass fibers with CaO–P2O5–SiO2–Al2O3 glass on strength practice. Br Dent J 1990;22:164–7.
of glass ionomer cements. J Dent 2001;29:377–80. [32] DeBarra E, Hill R. Influence of poly (acrylic acid) content on the
[20] Kobayashi M, Kon M, Miyai K, Asaoka K. Strengthening fracture behaviour of glass polyalkenoate cements. J Mater Sci
of glass-ionomer cement by compounding short fibres with 1998;33:5487–97.
CaO–P2O5–SiO2–Al2O3 glass. Biomaterials 2000;21:2051–8. [33] Griffin SG, Hill RG. Influence of poly (acrylic acid) molar mass
[21] Shimada Y, Kondo Y, Inokoshi S, Tagami J, Antonucci M. on the fracture properties of glass polyalkenoate cements. J Mater
Demineralizing effect of dental cements on human dentin. Sci 1998;33:5383–96.
Quintessence Int 1999;30:267–73. [34] Gasser O. Evolution of the glass system. Taken from: Glass
[22] Ashby MF, Jones DRH. Engineering materials 2, 2nd ed. Oxford: ionomers: the next generation. Proceedings of the Second
Butterworth-Heinemann, 1998. International Symposium on Glass Ionomers. Philadelphia,
[23] Chou TW. Fiber reinforcements, general theory of composites of 1994.
comprehensive composite materials, vol. 1. Dundee: Pergamon [35] Takigawa T. Study on glass ionomer cement, influence of powder.
Press, 2000. J Conserv Dent 1982;25:812–3.
[24] Xu HHK, Eichmiller FC, Barndt PR. Effects of fiber length and [36] McKinnis CL, Sutton JW. The glass melting process: II, glass
volume fraction on the reinforcement of calcium phosphate structure and the effect of melting history on glass properties.
cement. J Mater Sci Mater Med 2001;12:57–65. J Am Ceram Soc 1959;42:250–3.
[25] Griffin S, Hill RG. Glass composition influence on glass [37] Lucksanasombool P, Higgs WAJ, Higgs RJED, Swain MV.
polyalkenoate cement mechanical properties. J Non-Cryst Sol Toughness of glass fibres reinforced glass-ionomer cements.
1996;196:255–9. J Mater Sci 2002;37:101–8.