Psychological Theories
Psychological Theories
Psychological Theories
There are four basic ideas when it comes to psychological theories of crime. These general
assumptions are that crime is a result of:
Criticisms
Amy is wondering if psychological theories of crime could explain why her friend Rory
ended up a criminal, whereas she ended up a law-abiding citizen. There certainly seems to be
a lot of psychological differences between the two of them. Could that explain the differences
in their behavior?
Though there is much support for psychological theories, there are also some criticisms. For
one thing, opponents point out that psychological theories can't explain why some people are
criminals and others aren't. For example, not everyone with mental illness ends up a criminal,
and not everyone who was abused ends up a criminal. But, Rory, who was abused and has a
psychological disorder, ended up a criminal. Psychological theories can't tell us why that is
true.
Another issue with psychological theories of crime is that they are difficult to test. Amy can't
open up Rory's head and see his psychological issues carved on his brain. All a person can
see are the symptoms of a psychological problem, not the underlying issue. This could lead to
misdiagnoses, and even lead to some people faking psychological disorders in order to get a
lighter sentence.
Finally, treatment plans based on psychological theories are not always effective. There is
still a high rate of criminals who commit crimes even after being treated for psychological
issues. Thus, even though psychological theories might be correct in judging why people
become criminals, they haven't yet figured out how to prevent people from becoming or
continuing to be criminals.
Lesson Summary