Legal Drafting Course: Introduction To Legal Writing
Legal Drafting Course: Introduction To Legal Writing
com/legaldrafting
LEGAL
DRAFTING
COURSE
MODULE I
INTRODUCTION TO
LEGAL WRITING
STUDY MATERIAL
Course
An initiative by
Instructor
MS. CHHAYA
Human Hands Together
BHARDWAJ
Lecturer
She has received various awards like the United Nations Fellowship (2017) to
attend the Regional Course in International Law, Asia-Pacific. In 2018, she was
awarded with the Local Pathways Fellowship by United Nations Sustainable
Development Solutions Network for her work in environmental education and
youth empowerment. In 2019, she was awarded with Junior Scholars’
Scholarship by Asian Society of International Law to attend the 7th AsianSIL
Biennial Conference on International Law. She has received Best Research Paper
award from institutions like the Law Commission of India for her research in
environmental and international law.
MODULE I
INTRODUCTION TO LEGAL WRITING
htiw noitiacossa ni
LEGAL An initiative by
COURSE
HumanHandsTogether.com/legaldrafting
MS. ANIMA SHUKLA
Associate,
MODULE 1
INTRODUCTION TO LEGAL WRITING
htiw noitiacossa ni
LEGAL An initiative by
COURSE
HumanHandsTogether.com/legaldrafting
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
1|Page
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
INTRODUCTION
Legal writing in India is different because Indians are at least bi-lingual, law
students do not take legal writing seriously and it is not the most thought
about skill in law. Legal writing is a way of communication in order to fit in
the requirements of targeted audience. It is also different from a normal form
of communication because it is formal, structured and conscious mode of
writing, with a clear objective to avoid ambiguity. Another important objective
of legal writing is to be precise, accurate and brief.
This course will allow you to identify the important pieces of legal writing and
to put together these important pieces in words clearly, precisely and briefly.
This course begins with identifying the kinds of legal writing and then moves
towards the foundational aspects of legal writing. It will further contain
foundations of legal writing and allow you to develop clarity, brevity and
precision. Further, this course will allow you how to develop simple but
powerful sentences in order to be concise and legally correct. While developing
these skills, the course emphasizes on self-awareness and self-assessment by
indulging into self-assessment tools.
This quiz will allow you to understand your present understanding and skill
of legal writing.
Exercise 1- Kindly put the following facts together, in order to include them
in a part of legal document-
2|Page
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
4. They were having dinner at the Bigger Burgerz, New Delhi on 13th July,
2010.
5. Kamala ate one burger at Bigger Burgerz and started vomiting.
6. After a couple minutes, she became unconscious and fainted.
7. She was hospitalized as a result of the incident.
After you have arranged these facts together, kindly answer the following
questions-
The most important information is “Kamala ate at Bigger Burgerz and started
vomiting.”
One of the most precise and clear way to arrange the abovementioned facts
is-
On 13th July, 2010, Kamala 29-year-old women ate at Bigger Burgerz, New
Delhi and started vomiting. Later, she was hospitalized as a result of this
incident.
3|Page
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
writing is an inclusive legal skill which is aimed at honing not only the writing
skills, but reading, analytical and synthesis skills as well.
Legal writing is known by various names like contract drafting, brief writing,
memorandums. However, all categories of legal writing are linked through
the following three commonalities:
1. Simplicity
Whenever you proceed with any forms of legal writing you should make sure
that it should be simple to understand and it should be written keeping the
audience in mind. A standard method of IRAC should be used in the same
and the work should be free from ambiguity as it brings brevity and clarity.
Legal writings in broad sense refer to the analysis of fact patterns and
presentations of arguments in legal memos and briefs. Certain positions might
entail the drafting of predictive memos, which anticipate the arguments of
opposing counsel. Even other positions may require you to research a legal
question, analysis of relevant legal precedents.
Legal writing can be broadly categorized in two categories. First is within law
school writing or Academic Legal Writing that deals with contract drafting,
plaint drafting, petitions drafting, research paper drafting, etc. Another major
categorization is outside law school writing which broadly deals with three
perspectives which are Predictive Legal Analysis, Persuasive Legal Analysis
and last is Legal drafting.
4|Page
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
[1.5.1] Within Law School - Academic Legal Writing - e.g. contracts, drafts,
briefs, petitions, research papers, etc.
This is an ability that will prove necessary in every law students’ future career.
Once you are accepted into any of these opportunities, you will need to write
essays and assignments and in some cases a dissertation or thesis, which will
place new and challenging demands on your writing skills. Also, while in law
schools and while interning with various institutions such as law firms, LPO’s
there are plethora of writing works which a law student needs to do such as
contracts, drafts, briefs, petitions, research papers, etc.
CONTRACT DRAFTING
5|Page
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
rights and duties on the parties and if these obligations in the agreement are
not fulfilled then stringent action could be taken by the courts on the party.
The Indian Contract Act, 1872 codifies the way we enter into a contract,
execute a contract, implement provisions of a contract and effects of breach
of a contract.
There are essentially six elements of a contract that make it a legal and
binding document. In order for a contract to be enforceable, it must contain:
3. CONSIDERATION, money or
something of interest being exchanged 4. CAPACITY of parties in terms of age
between the parties. However, there are and mental capacity.
several instances when a court will declare
a contract unenforceable because
consideration was lacking:
• When one party is already legally bound 5. THE INTENT of both parties to carry
to perform, out their promise.
• When consideration is more like a gift,
• When consideration is made as a result of
a past event, or 6. LEGALLY ENFORCEABLE terms
and conditions, also called object of the
• When consideration is based on an
contract.
illusory promise
Drafting a contract in a layman’s term is writing out the terms and details
of the contract/agreement, so that those that sign the contract (parties to
contract) can fully understand the terms of the agreement. A contract can
be drafted by anyone, but for a secure and reliable contract it is important
to have it drafted by a lawyer. Contracts can be written, oral, or implied
also. However, it is always preferable to enter into written contracts as it is
always difficult to prove the terms of an oral or implied contract than those
of a written one.
6|Page
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
With an oral
The process of contract, the
writing down the parties may have
contract’s terms different Some types of If you have to go
and signing the recollections of contracts must be to court to
contract forces what they agreed in writing to be enforce a contract
both parties to on (just as two enforced. The or get damages, a
think about and be witnesses to a car Indian Copyright written contract
precise about the accident will Act, 1957 will mean less
obligations they are disagree over requires a dispute about the
undertaking. With what happened). copyright contract’s terms
an oral contract, it A written assignment or as the burden of
is too easy for both agreement exclusive license proof lies with
parties to say “yes” eliminates to be in writing. you.
and then have disputes over
who promised
second thoughts.
what.
7|Page
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
DRAFTS:
Case briefing is a tool used by Law Students in their law school, its purpose
is to have students identifying the rules of law found in court cases and
analyze how courts apply these rules of law to the facts of a case in an
objective and rational manner. Case briefing needs analytic skills and
heightens understanding of the role of courts in defining, interpreting, and
applying law. This appendix explains one way to brief cases. There are no
standards for case briefing, but the structure below is common and will serve
you well, both in studying the law now and in using the law in the future.
8|Page
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
There are several basic components of a brief present in almost all brief style.
But there is a standard form: -
Facts
Issues
Holding
Rationale
Purpose of Briefs: -
Facts: -
Most important part of any brief is fats. State the facts of the case in your own
words. Indicate which facts are important and on which the issues are laid
down. Do not just repeat the judge’s words. At times a sign of how well you
understand a particular is your ability to identify the relative importance of
9|Page
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
facts. Some cases may have many extraneous facts that do not need to be in
your brief. Most certainly, some facts will be more important than others. Your
task is to frame the problem by describing the facts that count, the ones that
matter.
Issues: -
Issue spotting is the skill of recognizing in the facts a pattern that implies a
certain type of issue. For instance, facts that describe two people both
claiming ownership rights over a chair should spotlight an issue of ownership
of personal property. In reading cases, often the parties and the court do this
work for you. Ask yourself what legal questions are posed by the appealing
party. The appealing party is alleging that an error of law was made. What is
that error? What question is the court answering? Sometimes a court will see
the issue differently than the parties and present a different twist on the issue.
State the issue cleanly and crisply. Avoid stating it in technical or procedural
terms. Some believe that beginning your issue statement with “Whether” will
allow you to focus your statement.
Holding: -
It is the most important part of a brief which includes several questions, like
what is the ruling by the court? who won? This element should be written
while answering the above questions. You must understand the procedural
setting enough to know what happens as a result of the decision. For instance,
if the court rules “in favor of the appellants,” what does this mean? More
importantly, you need to find the holding on the issue itself. How did the court
decide the issue? What rule of law is provided by the case? It should also
include understanding the rule behind holding a particular case.
Rationale: -
All the sections of the brief should not necessarily be evenly distributed.
Generally, the rationale section is the longest section. In the rationale section
you explain why the court ruled the way that it did. This means that you need
10 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
to describe the court’s reasoning, sometimes even quoting the court’s choice
of words. You also must explain which facts the court depended upon and
which ones it discounted or ignored. You should also note what prior decisions
it looked at and whether it chose to follow them, overrule them, or differentiate
them. The court might also interpret or cite particular statutes or other laws
in reaching its decision. Finally, notice whether the court relies upon public
policy to reach its decision.
PETITIONS
Gather Information
•Before beginning with any petition the drafter should collect all the necessary
information to strengthen your case. A sound information is necessary for a
sound argument. Visit libraries, talk with experts, watch related video, listen to
audio, search the internet etc. This information will form the background of your
petition. Prepare a list of individuals and authorities to whom your petition will
address.
•While searching the about the information for your petition, you will realize the
relevance or irrelevance of your petition. It is here that you need to decide if your
petition is justified? And if it so, is it reasonable in eyes of the others? Can you
convince others? Is your goal achievable? This is important because your
decision requires conviction. If you are not convinced enough, you cannot
convince others.
Plan it out
11 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Effective Title – A petition with an effective title is the first and foremost attempt to
make an impression on the recipient. It is the first thing that will be looked at and it is
the first thing you should work on.
Follow the Format – After the title, there are certain formal structures which are to be
included. These are - Current Date, Recipients Name, Recipients Address and Salutation.
Please refer to the petition letter format and template for further assistance.
12 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Opening Statement – Influence the recipient in the opening itself. Your title has to
be sustained by an appropriate opening statement. The initial sentences should state
the purpose of the letter clearly. You can start with a simple request or state the issue
with an appealing request. You can use quotes or phrases towards this effect. It can be
emotional charged statement, a factual one or a mix of both.
Drafting – Before starting drafting use the information of the outline and divide into
short paragraphs. Since it is a draft write whatever comes in your mind irrespective of
grammar, paragraph structure, punctuation, spelling etc. sentence and. Then read it
aloud to yourself. How does it sound? Go through the contents again and refer them with
the outline and your objective. The major objective of drafting is to have a concise matter
for the final letter and to make sure that your thoughts and ideas are conveyed in a
cohesive manner.
Be Direct – As your letter is a request you cannot dangle here and there. You have to
come to the point in the beginning itself. But it doesn’t’t mean you have to be blunt, by
direct means that you have to be specific about the issue at hand.
Be Specific - While there are many examples, the letter focuses on one story that really
13 |embodies
P a g e the need for change. If an appeal or request depends on particular facts which
Be Factual – A petition has to be factual and avoid dramatizing the issue. You don’t
need to tell a tale. You have to describe in a factual manner. Emotionally laced words
can be irritating and burdening on the recipient. For example – ‘I was denied a ticket in
the first class. It was discriminatory and there was nothing that I could do about it.’
Give Solid Reasons – Provide solid reasons so that they have a strong effect. Lame
excuses will not bear any fruit but an improvised weak appeal can get the work done.
Explain to the reader why your appeal is important? Why should they get involved? Why
should they agree with you?
14 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Using Graphics – Graphics can enhance the effect of your objective. Images are easily
conceived and require less effort so you can use them provided they are apt and not
confusing. Use pictures which are in context of the issue, it will grab the immediate
attention of the reader. Eye-catching and emotional images work the best.
Using Letterhead – Letterhead’s are symbols of authority and carry a mandate and they
tend to impress the reader. It gives more value to the letter. It will be taken more seriously
and is considered of being reputed especially when it comes from a well-established
NGO.
Typed – A formal letter is always typed or printed, same is the case with a petition letter.
Print your letter with fonts such as Arial or Times New Roman. Don’t use fancy fonts
which may not be legible to the reader. Use the proper size of font to suit the need in lieu
of paper size. You can also print on the envelope for added effect.
15 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Research paper writing consists of several stages. The first stage consists of
choosing a relevant topic and making a thesis statement that shows the
objectives and goals of your investigation. It is followed by the research and
experimental stage during which a student studies the matter, works with
relevant literature, and collects data for the written part of this project. Then
you have to write the paper itself. The last stage is less stressful as you already
have all the necessary information and only need to analyze and present it in
a proper manner, however, it requires knowing and following the basic
principles of academic writing.
16 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Research (on a certain issue) findings also help protect the public; so that
they can begin to understand what the problem is, how it works, and what
it can do for them.
Research protects from wrong information and save time and money.
Research (on a certain issue) findings also help protect the public; so that
they can begin to understand what the problem is, how it works, and what
17 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Step 1: Understand the assignment and set a schedule one of the biggest problems
students face before beginning a research paper. Also, the major problem is that
they don’t understand the assignment. Therefore, to begin with research paper
writing one should first research on the topic itself and gather some specific details.
Some specific details you should know are:
• Number and types of sources that are allowed. (websites, books, articles)
• Whether specific aspects of the paper have different due dates or is it due in full
on a specific date.
• Set a schedule according to the due dates and how long it will take you to complete
18 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Step 2: Finding a Topic and Question Once you have figured out what the
assignment is about, it is time to choose a specific topic or question to research. Some
things to consider when choosing a topic:
• Is this topic appropriate? – You may want to have the professor approve it.
• Choose a topic that not only interests you, but will also be interesting to the reader.
• You may want to choose a question that your paper will answer. That way, when
you are researching, you are looking for something specific.
• The answer that you find to this question may ultimately become your thesis
statement. Example: Topic - Pay equality in the workforce. Question- Do women
still get paid less than men do for completing the same amount of work? Thesis -
Step 3: Begin Research After you have decided the direction you want to take for the
paper, it will now be time to begin researching the topic.
NOTE: Just because you have chosen a topic and question does not mean you have
to stick with that one for the rest of the paper! After you have started researching, you
may find information that makes you want to change your focus. It is fine if you
change your question, but make sure your paper answers the new question and not
the old one.
• Keep records and copies of all of the information you obtain. Get all of the
bibliographical information while you are researching so you do not have to go back.
Make sure you also make note of where you found the information in case you have
to retrieve it later.
19 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Such information includes: Title of the article or book, date it was published or copy
written, author(s) and publishing company, pages used.
• Try to put information into your own words. It is helpful to paraphrase the
information in your own words while you are taking notes to avoid plagiarism later. If
you do take quotes directly from the source, make sure you make a note of that
• You should also be making notes about specific conclusions that you are drawing
from the material.
• Look specifically for details that support your thesis or question. Sometimes
background information is also necessary.
Step 4: Construct an Outline Once you have collected all of the research, it may be
helpful to organize your thoughts with an outline. To construct an outline, you must
group your notes together and match information that fits together. An outline should
be formatted in this manner:
I. Introduction
II. Main heading/idea of paragraph a. Supporting detail b. Supporting detail c.
Supporting detail.
20 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Step 5: Write a Draft Now that you have organized your research material, the next
step will be writing the first draft. Keep in mind that you will write multiple drafts,
so do not put excessive pressure on the first one. Some things to keep in mind when
writing a draft:
• Try to write with your own voice. Don’t just spit out researched information. Add
your own conclusions and thoughts.
• Remember to cite your sources when you use them, even in a draft.
• Try to keep your information as organized as possible. That will help the reader
understand what you are trying to say.
• Once you have written a draft, proofread it! Have a peer respond to it or bring it to
the Writing Center to have a tutor help you with it.
Step 6: Write a Final Draft After you have revised your initial drafts, you should
compose a final draft. This draft should have very few errors, have a clear organization,
and be formatted correctly. Before you hand in your paper, you should make sure you
have the following elements:
1) A cover page stating the course information, the title of your paper, and your name.
2) The final, revised, copy of your paper with any formatting necessary (Footnotes,
page numbers, citations, etc.).
3) A works cited page listing the bibliographical information for each of your sources.
21 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
You write a predictive memorandum for the benefit of another lawyer (usually
your senior) who has asked you to address a specific question and expects an
answer to that question. Your reader may have a general familiarity with the
law you are discussing but may not be familiar with specific cases (or, if
applicable, statutory provisions) that you have found to be relevant to the
analysis. Therefore, as you write, keep asking yourself: will the reader be able
to follow my analysis? Have I organized my analysis to track all the steps in
the IRAC paradigm (Issue-Rule-Application/Analysis-Conclusion)?
22 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
State the facts- State the facts very clear and simple terms, there
should be no ambiguity in the same. Also, only relevant facts
should be addressed, don’t necessarily increase the length of the
opinion by stating irrelevant facts.
Analysis- Analysis is analyzing in detail the facts you are using and
its relevancy to your issue or the question you are addressing.
Answer the query- Also, make sure that you answer each and every
query.
Usual disclaimers.
Steps to write –
Legal letter/Notices– Legal letters and notices are a very powerful document
which is send by an attorney on behalf of his client to another person or court.
23 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
Legal analysis is based on a legal matter with which it plays a direct part but
are based on presenting hypothetical interpretations. When the matter of
legal analysis is based specifically on an existing matter that requires the
arguing of a legal point, this is called persuasive analysis. Writing an
argument helps writer to perceive his or her case to define, refine and interpret
the cases that court must decide and also helps in expressing facts and
combining them into legal arguments. Motions, petitions or briefs aimed at
persuading the adjudicating authority to decide favorably or to convince the
opposing party to resolve the dispute amicably.
To obtain information
24 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
To dismiss cases
To trim Cases down
CREAC.- C = state your conclusion. R = state the rule. E = explain the rule and
case law. A = analyze the facts according to the law. C = restate the conclusion.
25 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
7. Argument should take up the vast majority of the brief, but obvious
responses should be identified and addressed. Anticipate and address
counter-arguments.
8. Never misstate the record. And never misquote a source. When quoting
from cases explain the relevance of the quote.
9. Know the Parties- Identify the parties at the beginning of the motion
10. Know Your Judge- It is very important to know judge’s preferences. Some
judges stick to traditional procedural formalities whereas some judges
entertain motions that are persuasive and help in better understanding
the key issues involved in the motion to compel.
[1.5.3.3] Legal Drafting – Creation of binding legal text like acts, rules
and regulations; private documents like wills, testaments and trusts;
public texts like notices, instructions, orders; transactional documents
like contracts, deeds, etc.
Legal drafting is a structured process to write any document that is full of law
and legal jargons. This exercise can be challenging to both beginners and
experienced legal drafters. Legal notices and letters are easier to draft that
contracts, acts and legislations because a letter or a notice may not
necessarily contain a requirement or section to explain basic terminologies.
But the objective of all these legal documents remain the same that is to
become a legally binding document on the date intended by the parties.
Acts, rules and legislations are created by the acts of legislatures in a country,
legislations are the broadest circle that covers acts, rules and regulations. An
act is law passed by the legislatures. Rules regulations and codes passed by
the legislatures due to power given under a specific act. Rules and regulations
26 | P a g e
HUMAN HANDS TOGETHER
are also known as subsidiary legislations that help in the implementation and
governance through the act.
Wills and testaments on the other hand are a different set of legal drafting. It
may vary from a simple statement or declaration to a long detailed legal
document. A will can be made by any person of sound mind who is above 18
years of age and who intends to give away his property to another person.
There are no prescribed formats to write a will in India. Therefore the simplest
of statements on the simplest of papers signed appropriately can qualify as a
will or testaments.
27 | P a g e
ABOUT COURSE INSTRUCTORS
Advocate-on-Record,
Of-Counsel Attorney,
Advocate,
Associate,
Advocate,
Lecturer,
Associate,
7
20 INSTITUTIONS PARTICIPATED IN INAUGURAL BATCH
COURSE
The Course Instructor cleared even the simplest of
the thing which we thought we knew .
REVIEW
It was such a great session Lokesh sir has explained
each and everything very properly thank you HHT &
desperately wait for next session . inspired did you feel ? 5/5
58.6%
HumanHandsTogether.com/legaldrafting