Chapter 11: Personality Assessment - An Overview What Is Personality?
Chapter 11: Personality Assessment - An Overview What Is Personality?
What is personality?
• Unique constellation of psychological states and traits (Cohen & Swerdlik, 2010)
Trait v. State
• Trait
– relatively enduring
• State
– interaction
Culturally-Relevant Issues
• Values system
• Acculturation v. Identity
• Relation to group
– Individualistic v. Collectivistic
• Translation issues
Examples
• Woodworth Personal Data Sheet (1919)
– WWI
– Items measuring presence of symptoms
• Mooney Problem Checklist (1950)
– Students
– Emotional functioning
• Symptom Checklist 90-R (Derogatis, 1994)
– Adolescents and adults
Limitations
• Face validity
• Self-report
• Statistical analyses
Theoretical Approach
• Based on theory
• Intended to assess personality type
Examples
• Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (1943, 1960)
– Jungian typology - preferences
– I-E (sensing-intuitive) T-F thinking (judging perceptive)
• Edwards Personality Preference Scale (Edwards, 1953)
– Murray's (1938) theory of relative needs
– Ipsative scale
Ipsative Samples
• Which of the two items best describes your interests?
– I like to arrange flowers
– I like to solve computer software problems
Examples (cont)
• Self-Directed Search (Holland et al., 1994)
– Vocational personality
Limitations
• Ipsative scales are relative
• Interpretations appear arbitrary
Data Reduction
• Factor analysis
• Identify observed dimensions of personality
Examples
• 16 PF Personality Factors (Cattell)
• Guilford-Zimmerman Temperament Survey (1976)
• NEO Personality Inventory-Revised (Costa & McRae, 1992)
– “The Big Five”
Limitations
• Subjective identification of factors
• Emphasis on grouping of variables
• Focus of common variance
Criterion Groups
• Use of reference groups
• Compare criterion (trait) and control groups (non-trait)
Empirical Criterion Keying
• Scoring key
• Divergent validity
• Items
Examples
• Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory - 2 MMPI - 2 (1989)
• California Personality Inventory CPI (Gough, 1987)
Objective Methods
• Self-report short-answer items
• Structured scoring system
• Emphasize reliability and validity
Examples
• MMPI-A (Adolescent) Butcher et al, 1992
– Assessing psychopathology
– Teenagers
• State Trait Anxiety Inventory STAI (Spielberger, 1985)
– State Anxiety
– Trait Anxiety
MMPI-2
• 1989 major restandardization
• 567 items - True, False, Cannot Say responses - no repeated items
• 14% of items changed, 107 new items
Scales
• Multidimensional since scales overlap
• Six validity scales
• Ten Clinical Scales
• Supplementary Scales
T scores
• Uniform T-scores: M = 50, SD = 10
– Higher T-score indicates
• Score of 65 (70 - 2 standard deviations) is statistically significant
– Profile is interpreted as a whole
Psychometric Properties
• Reliability
• Validity
– Convergence
– Discriminant
Limitations
• Self-report
• Impression management
• Response style
– Social desirability: seen in a favorable light
• Faking good
• Faking bad
– Malingering