Mix Design Procedures and Test Results of Fiber Reinforced Concrete (FRC) 4.1. General
Mix Design Procedures and Test Results of Fiber Reinforced Concrete (FRC) 4.1. General
4.1. General
The strengths of FRC are tested by making four different concrete mixtures
(identified as A, B, C and D). Mix design procedures are calculated step by step
according to ACI method. And then, FRC are cast into cube mold of cast irons. All
specimens are submerged in a tank of fresh water for a period before testing. Finally,
they are tested for 7 days, 14 days and 28 days compressive strength.
1088 ×106
Volume of Coarse Aggregate = = 391.37×10³
2.78× 1000
cm³/m³
4.65 ×10 6
Volume of ViscoCrete-6100 = = 4.39×10³ cm³/m³
1.06× 1000
2.91 ×106
Volume of Polypropylene fiber = . =3.2×10³ cm³/m³
0.91× 1000
44
2× 106
Volume of air content = = 20×10³ cm³/m³
100
=239.44×10³ cm³/m³
= 629.73 kg/m³
566.67× 106
Volume of Cement = = 179.9×10³ cm³/m³
3.15 ×1000
1088 ×106
Volume of Coarse Aggregate = = 391.37×10³
2.78× 1000
cm³/m³
4.53 ×10 6
Volume of ViscoCrete-6100 = = 4.28×10³ cm³/m³
1.06× 1000
8.5 ×106
Volume of Polypropylene fiber = . = 9.34×10³
0.91× 1000
2× 106 3
cm³/m³ Volume of air content = = 20× 10 cm³/m³
100
Total volume of above materials = 753.6×103 cm³/m³
Volume of fine aggregate (SSD) =106 −(753.6 ×103 )
= 246.39×103 cm³/m³
246.39× 103 × 2.63× 1000
Weight of fine aggregate (OD) =
106
46
=648.03 kg/m³
160
Step 6 : Cement Content = 0.3 = 533.33 kg/m³
So, ViscoCrete-6100 = 533.33×0.008= 4.27 kg/m³
Polypropylene fiber (40 mm) = 533.33×0.005= 2.67 kg/m³
Step 7 : Fineness Modulus of Sand = 2.02
Maximum aggregate size = 20 mm (3/4")
Volume of rodded coarse aggregate in SSD = 1600 kg/m³
Volume of coarse aggregate according to Table A.3 = 0.68
47
1088 ×106
Volume of Coarse Aggregate = = 391.37×10 3
2.78× 1000
cm³/m³
4.27 × 106
Volume of ViscoCrete-6100 = = 4.03×10 3 m³/cm³
1.06× 1000
2.67 ×106
Volume of Polypropylene fiber = . = 2.93×10³ cm³/m³
0.91× 1000
2× 106 3
Volume of air content = = 20× 10 cm³/m³
100
Total volume of above materials = 743.61×103 cm³/m³
Volume of fine aggregate (SSD) =106 −(743.61 ×103 )
= 256.39×103 cm³/m³
256.39× 103 × 2.63× 1000
Weight of fine aggregate (OD) =
106
=674.31 kg/m³
523.33× 106
Volume of Cement = = 166.14×10³ cm³/m³
3.15 ×1000
1088 ×106
Volume of Coarse Aggregate = = 391.37×10³
2.78× 1000
cm³/m³
49
419 ×10 6
Volume of ViscoCrete-6100 = = 3.95×10³ cm³/m³
1.06× 1000
7.85 ×106
Volume of Polypropylene fiber = . = 8.63×10³
0.91× 1000
2× 106 3
cm³/m³ Volume of air content = = 20× 10 cm³/m³
100
Total volume of above materials = 743.13×103 cm³/m³
Volume of fine aggregate (SSD) =106 −(743.13 ×103 )
= 256.87×103 cm³/m³
256.87 ×103 ×2.63 ×1000
Weight of fine aggregate (OD) =
106
=675.57 kg/m³
The summary of the mix proportion for one Cubic Meter of fresh concrete are
shown in Table 4.2 and the unit weight of fresh FRC for all mix design is in average
145 lb/ft³.
Table 4.2 Summary of Fresh Concrete for Batch Weight Per Cubic Meter (kg/m³)
Mixture A and C Mixture B and D
No. Item (ViscoCrete-6100, (ViscoCrete-6100,
0.8% and Fiber 0.5%) 0.8% and Fiber 1.5%)
The tamping rod is of steel 16 mm diameter and 600 mm long, and rounded at one
end. Equipment are shown in Figure 4.1.
(e) Stopwatch: one that measures elapsed time to the nearest second or less.
(f) Screeding Rod: The rod used for screeding shall be the tamping rod.
53
(a) Dampen the bucket and place it on a level, rigid, horizontal surface free of
vibration and another disturbance. Dampen the cone and place it in the
positioning device, making sure it is level. The concrete mix is filled in the
cone by three layers, each approximately one third of the volume of the
cone. Avoid compacting the concrete, but lightly level each layer with a
scoop or trowel to minimize the entrapment of large voids. Strike off the
surface of the top layer by means of a screeding and rolling motion of the
tamping rod. Protruding fibers which inhibit screeding may be removed by
hand. One third of the volume of the cone corresponds to a depth of 5.875
in. (149 mm); two thirds of the volume corresponds to a depth of 9.375 in.
(237 mm).
(b) Start the vibrator. Simultaneously start the stopwatch and insert the
vibrating element centrally and vertically into the top of the sample in the
cone. Let it descend at a rate such that it touches the bottom of the bucket
in 3±1 s. Maintain the vibrating element approximately vertical and in
contact with the bottom of the bucket. Avoid touching the cone with the
vibrator. Stop the stopwatch when the cone becomes empty which occurs
when an opening becomes visible at the bottom of the cone. Complete the
portion of the test from the start of filling the cone through allowing the
vibrating element to descend time of 2 min. If the cone becomes plugged
during the test, or fails to empty because of an excess of material that has
54
fallen through during filling, disregard the result and make a new test on
another portion of the sample.
(c) Record the time in seconds.
The properties of FRC are tested with slump test and time of flow test
according to ASTM for mixtures A, B, C and D. Slump test and time of flow test are
described with Figure 4.1 and 4.2. The summary test results of FRC are shown in
Table 4.3 with the recommendation limits of ASTM.
Table 4.3. Comparison of Test Results of FRC in Fresh State and ASTM
Recommendations Limits
The compressive strength test results of mixture A is shown in Table 4.4 and
these are plotted in Figure 4.6. The average compressive strengths of mixture A are
achieved 6419 psi (or) 44.3 MPa at 7 days, 7095 psi (or) 48.9 MPa and 8108 psi (or)
55.9 MPa at 28 days respectively.
Average Compressive
Curing
Water/Cement Compressive Compressive Strength
No. Period
Ratio Strength (psi) Strength (MPa)
(Days)
(psi)
1 7 0.27 6351.58
3 7 0.27 6419.15
4 14 0.27 7027.28
6 14 0.27 7094.85
7 28 0.27 8243.54
9 28 0.27 8108.40
57
9000
Compressive Strength (psi)
8000
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
7 14 28
Duration (Days)
1 7 0.27 6351.58
2 7 0.27 6689.43 6509 44.9
3 7 0.27 6486.72
4 14 0.27 7432.70
5 14 0.27 7297.56 7365 50.8
6 14 0.27 7365.13
7 28 0.27 8648.96
8 28 0.27 8513.82 8581 59.2
9 28 0.27 8581.39
58
9000
8000
Compressive Strength (psi)
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
7 14 28
Duration (Days)
9000
The compressive strength test results of mixture D is shown in Table 4.7 and
these are plotted in Figure 4.9. The average compressive strength of mixture D are
achieved 6554 psi (or) 45.2 MPa at 7 days, 7771 psi (or) 53.6 MPa at 14 days and
8717 psi (or) 60.1 MPa respectively.
1 7 0.3 6486.72
2 7 0.3 6621.86 6554 45.2
3 7 0.3 6554.29
4 14 0.3 7702.89
5 14 0.3 7838.12 7771
53.6
6 14 0.3 7770.55
7 28 0.3 8784.10
8 28 0.3 8648.96 8717
60.1
9 28 0.3 8716.53
60
9000
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
7 14 28
Duration (Days)
9000
8000
Compressive Strength (psi)
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
7 14 28
Duration (Days) A B C D
The 28 days compressive strength results for FRC mixtures are 8108 psi, 8581
psi, 8334 psi and 8717 psi for mixtures A, B, C and D respectively. In all mixtures,
the mixture D has the highest compressive strength at 28 days and required strength
according to ACI Committee Report is achieved 7250 psi (or) 50 MPa. Moreover, the
mixture D has the highest percentage increase in all concrete mixtures. In mixture D,
water cement ratio 0.3, ViscoCrete-6100, 0.8% by weight of cement and
polypropylene fiber 1.5% by weight of cement are used. And then, water is reduced
21.5% in mix design according to ASTM recommendations. In this research, design
strength is 7250 psi (or) 50 MPa. According to ACI Committee Report, required
target strength for 7250 psi (or) 50 MPa is 8650 psi (or) 59.6 MPa at 28 days.
Required target strength is achieved in mixture D with 28 days compressive strength
of 8717 psi (or) 60.1 MPa.
In this paper, mixture B and D are the target strength. So, materials costs for
1 m³ of fiber reinforced concrete are calculated with mixture B and D. Materials costs
are shown in Table 4.9 and total materials costs for 1 m³ of fiber reinforced concrete
are shown in Table 4.10.
Cost (Kyats)
Ingredients Mixture B Mixture D
Water 0.27 0.3
Cement 62350 57550
Fine Aggregate 1750 1850
Coarse Aggregate 4850 4850
ViscoCrete-6100 18150 16800
Polypropylene
32300 29850
Fibers
Total 119400 110950