105 ICDRM 2019 Proceedings
105 ICDRM 2019 Proceedings
105 ICDRM 2019 Proceedings
ABSTRACT
Among the urban disasters, fire incident is one of the most disastrous which causes property losses and
sometimes death and injury within a short time. High density of population and structures make the urban
areas more vulnerable to fire hazard than the others and results in huge economic loss. Like many other cities,
fire incidents are very common in Dhaka city. Worldwide, fire service or fire station provides predominantly
emergency fire-fighting and fire protection services for a specific geographic area and to ensure better urban
safety, ensuring optimum fire-fighting capacity is mandatory. In this paper, the overall fire-fighting capacity
of twelve fire stations of Dhaka Metropolitan Area (DMA) has been evaluated along with three study area
for detail fire-fighting capacity assessment. The capacity has been evaluated from two perspectives: spatial
and non-spatial parameters. The spatial parameters include the issues related with the location of the station
and the non-spatial parameters include the capacity of staffs, equipment and vehicles. The nature of
equipment and vehicles also needs to conform to the land use characteristics and built structures. The capacity
has been evaluated compared with different practicing national and international standards. Besides, a
comparative scenario of fire-fighting capacity has been depicted among three other cities. The result of the
research will help to understand the present capacity of fire stations of DMA and will help the respective
authority to identify the sectors where improvement should be done to ensure better fire safety.
Introduction
Fire-fighting capacity means the ability to fight against any fire incident. To ensure urban resiliency optimum
fire-fighting capacity is one of the most important issue. The trend of urban fire is closely related to the level
of urbanization of an area (Wang et.al, 2011) and due to rapid urbanization, the Greater Dhaka district (Dhaka,
Gajipur, Munshigonj, Manikgonj, Narayangonj and Narsingdi) is experiencing more fire incidents compared
with other part of the country (Figure 1). Among the total reported fire incidences in Bangladesh, 18.17%,
15.36%, 15.96% and 16.14% incidents were occurred in greater Dhaka district in the year of 2010, 2011,
2012 and 2013 respectively (FSCD, 2013).
15815
14682
15000
10000
0
2010 2011 2012 2013
Year
Bangladesh Dhaka
Figure 1. Yearly trend of fire incidents of Bangladesh and Greater Dhaka district, BFSCD, 2014
Worldwide, fire station plays the vital role in ensuring fire safety (Hacıoğlu, 2010). In Bangladesh, the
1
Post-graduate, Department of Urban and Regional Planning, Bangladesh University of Engineering and
Technology, Dhaka-1000, Bangladesh
2
Professor, Department of Urban and Regional Planning, Bangladesh University of Engineering and
Technology, Dhaka-1000, Bangladesh
Email of Corresponding Author – [email protected]
Page | 611
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
governing authority of Fire Stations – Fire Service and Civil Defence (FSCD) Directorate is the first
respondent in all natural and manmade calamities and remains alert round the clock to fight fire and surface
rescue operations. At present, in Dhaka, Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defence (BFSCD) has 12 fire
stations with approximate 400 fire-fighters and rescuers who have to cover 16 million people living in the
city. Besides, the number of operational and rescue vehicles and equipment are not sufficient with the
increasing demand and most of them are obsolete. Setting up of new planned service stations are also being
delayed due to limited resource (FSCD, 2013).
The fire-fighting capacity of any fire station should conform to the national and international standards. The
location and the service area of the fire station, are important issues to reduce fire risk. Along with these
spatial requirements, a number of non-spatial issues, such as staff, equipment, vehicle, function, organization
and technology etc. are also related with efficient fire services (Hacıoğlu, 2010). Optimum level of staff in
accordance with the population demand is also important in order to effectively perform fire extinguishing
activities (Monday, 2000).
The average coverage area per station; average population served per stations; population staff ratio of the
stations of DMA has been explored and compared with different international standard as well as with
practicing standard of different countries collected from secondary sources. The travel time zones of the fire
stations of DMA indicating the standard service area have been generated using Network Analyst tool in Arc
GIS 10.1 showing the area that can be reached by the stations within the standard response time.
And to assess the non-spatial parameters; number of fire-fighting staff and fire-fighting equipment and
vehicles; data have been collected from the field survey at the fire stations and compared with different
standards.
Page | 612
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
Page | 613
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
Metropolitan Development Authority (HMDA, 2014) has been considered as the standard. Being part of the
same sub-continent, the socio-economic condition of Bangladesh resembles greatly with India having deep
historical linkage which results in similarity between the type of urban structures and inherited hazards of
Dhaka and the prime cities of India. So, this guideline has been considered as a standard. According to the
guidelines, there should be at least one fire station or a sub-fire station for a population of 0.2 million people,
within 1 to 3 kilometer (HMDA, 2014).
In DMA, overall 12 fire stations are responsible to serve around 340 sq.km. area and approximately 9 million
people of Dhaka. On an average, the coverage area per station is 25.17 sq.km. and the population size served
per station is 0.742 million which is almost four times than the standard.
In Figure 3, coverage area of the three selected stations has been prepared based on the information collected
from three selected fire stations. Then the population within these areas has been calculated from the
population data of the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS), 2011.
Page | 614
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
The Table 1 shows that, the coverage area and the number of served population differ in a long range from
one station to another. As in southern part, the number of the station is higher, their coverage area and size of
serving population is lower than that of a station of northern part. The coverage area of Sadarghat Fire Station
is about 17 times smaller than that of Mirpur Fire Station. As there is no more station to the north of the
Mirpur Fire Station, the designated coverage area of this station is higher than any others.
Table 2: Coverage area and serving population per station of different cities
Name of the City Average area coverage Average population /station
(sq.km)/station
Oklahoma city (TriData, 2014) 44.81 14,952
Delhi (Delhi Citizen Handbook, 2014) 36.19 33,600
Bangkok (Sripramai et. al. 44.82 16,290
Dhaka (BBS, 2011) 25.17 7,42,170
In Dhaka city, average area coverage per station is relatively lower than the others. But as the density of
population is very high in this city, average population severed by every station is very high which is around
22 times larger than average population served by every station of Delhi, 45 times larger than that of Bangkok
and 49 times larger than that of Oklahoma City.
Page | 615
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
Figure 4. Service areas of 12 fire stations of DMA using standard response time
Page | 616
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
within 10 minutes travel time the stations cover approximately 100 sq.km. area of DMA. Thus, about two-
third area of DMA (242 sq.km.) is out of standard service area. And about 4.13 million population is living
within the area. So, around half of DMA population is living out of the standard service area.
Capacity of staff
Efficient fire-fighting is only possible when the service is properly staffed. Total staff includes the officials
and the staffs involved in fire fighting activity. As a whole, there are 378 trained fire-fighter which include
officials and fire-fighting staffs in 12 fire stations within DMA. All the fire staff get 24 hour gap after a duty
of 48 hour. But the officials do not get any prescribed gap within their duty time. If necessary, they have to
take leave from their office duty.
The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) and the International City Managers Association (ICMA)
recommend an ideal service ratio of one on-duty fire fighter per 2,000 population served (Orcutt Community
Plan EIR, 2014). In DMA, the ratio of population per on-duty fire fighter is approximately 34,250. In the
selected stations the number of fire-fighting staffs are given below:
Table 3: Number of manpower in selected fire Stations
Name of fire station Officials Leader Driver Fire-staff Total
Sadarghat Fire Stationa 2 3 5 15 25
Tejgaon Fire Station b 2 3 5 19 29
Mirpur Fire Stationc 2 3 5 22 32
Source: a.Sadarghat Fire Station, b.Tejgaon Fire Station, c. Mirpur Fire Station; 2014
Total number of fire fighters of Sadarghat Fire Station, Tejgaon Fire Station and Mirpur Fire Station is
respectively 25, 29 and 32. These stations are supposed to serve a population of about two lac, four lac and
seventeen lac respectively. So, with the different size of served population the number of fire-fighters does
not vary notably. In practical scenario of three selected stations, this ratio of population and fire fighter is
approximately 12,170 for Sadarghat Fire Station, 23,000 for Tejgaon Fire Station and 77,840 for Mirpur Fire
Station. Thus, for all selected fire stations this ratio is much larger than the standard ratio.
In DMA, population density is very high compared to other city. So, in Dhaka, the population staff ratio is
very high which is approximately 4 times larger than Delhi, 6 times larger than Bangkok, and 36 times larger
than Oklahoma city.
Page | 617
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
In written document, the designated type and number of vehicle and equipment did not consider the specific
land use characteristics. For example, in the areas with narrow road, there should have more water mist rather
than special water tender. Moreover, in the areas of high rise building, big turn table ladder is needed. But,
according to Newaz (2014), “In practical scenario, recently the vehicles are being distributed according to the
local requirements.”
Here, a comparative scenario has been depicted for the mentioned three stations.
To assess the requirement of fire-fighting vehicles in relation to landuse characteristics, firstly information
has been collected on structure type, storey of the structures, road width and broad land use of three thanas-
Kotwali thana, Tejgaon Industrial Area thana, Pallabi thana which are served by the selected stations.
From that analysis, it has been found that, in Kotwali Thana major land use is commercial use (30.84%) and
mixed use (32.72%). In this type of uses, probability of losses is higher than residential use in case of fire
incidents. But in Sadarghat Fire Station, there is only one Water Tender in this station. Maximum structures
of this thana are pucca and within four storied (80.58%). But, the maximum storied of buildings is 14. So,
fire vehicles should be ready to fight against fire up to 14 storied building. But, in Sadarghat Fire Station,
there is no Turn-table Ladder. According to Mohammad Belal Ahmed, Station officer of Sadarghat Fire
Station, for large scale fire having the fire origin of oil or chemical reaction in the mixed use buildings, the
station has to depend on the vehicles stored at head office. At the same time, in times of fire incidents at more
than fourth level of the buildings the head office gives them support with Turn-table Ladder. In this area,
most challenging issue is narrow roads. According to the fire officials, for the Water Tender more than 10ft
width of the road is required to get access. But, in this thana, around 65% roads are within 10 ft width. There
are four Water Mists in this station to give access to the narrow roads. But the number and capacity of Water
Mist is too low to cover a serious incident. There is no water hydrant and no fixed source of water. In case of
emergency the fighter has to join the hose pipes from the distant water source and carry it to the spot which
process is time consuming and results in greater loss.
Tejgaon Industrial Area Thana is mainly an industrial area (25.41% area). For industrial area Foam Tender,
Foam Canon and Chemical Tender are special fire fighting vehicle, as in such type of areas probability of
being the fire sources of oil or chemical reaction is high. So, it is important to have these vehicles in Tejgaon
Page | 618
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
Fire Station. But, as mentioned in Table 5, there is a Foam Trolly, which supplies foam, whose capacity is
not so high to act with big fire incidents. Besides, in Water Tender, Water Mist and Cold-cut, there is provision
of foam. According to, Nuruzzaman (2014),
“Maximum fire incidents can be controlled using the vehicles and instruments stored in the station as the
incidents are not always severe. But, in case of severe fire incidents having the fire source as oil or chemical
reaction, the station has to depend on Head quarter.”
In this thana, though 92.27% buildings are within four storied, the maximum storied of buildings is 23. But,
in Tejgaon Fire Station, there is no Turn-table Ladder to fight against the fire as upper level of the buildings.
Though maximum roads (76.35%) of this area are more than 10ft wide, there are some roads of less than 7ft
width (Figure 6.4). To get access to narrow roads there are four Water Mists to handle small size fire as their
capacity is low.
In Pallabi Thana, major land use is residential use (60.91%) and most of the structures are semi-pucca
(47.97%). In residential areas though average loss for fire is lower, number of fire incidents is highest. And
the coverage area of this station is higher than the others (Figure 3). So, there is one Water Tender and one
Special Water Tender in this station to put off fire. There is also a Foam Trolly to extinguish the fire created
from oil. In this thana, 92.69 % building are up to four storied. In this station, though there is no vehicle to
reach to 14 storied building, but there is a Snorkel to reach up to 8 storied building. Though, the width of the
roads mostly (54.2%) range from 10ft to 30ft, there is 33.48% road of less than 10ft width. To get access to
narrow roads there are two Water Mists whose capacity is very low.
Conclusions
It is seen from the research that, the stations are more concentrated in the southern part of the city not covering
some part of northern and eastern side. Besides, the 10 minutes service areas of 12 fire stations does not
cover approximately two third area of DMA (about 242 sq.km.) and approximately half of DMA population.
So, the authority should give importance to set new fire stations in these underserved areas with careful
planning for setting up new fire stations at appropriate location. Some stations can be relocated in other
demanding places. So that the optimum number of fire stations will be well distributed to serve maximum
population.
Besides, for covering the large population of DMA more fire-fighting staffs should be recruited according to
the requirement. Besides, the officers of the stations do not enjoy any weekend which is pitiful for their
personal and social life. For every stations more officers should be recruited so that shift duty can easily be
an effective solution in this regard. At the same time, recruitment process should be more efficient. Besides
in many countries, volunteer fire fighters play efficient role in times of emergency. In this context, volunteer
training in regular basis can be an effective solution to reduce the pressure of regular fire-fighters. So,
volunteer training should be arranged periodically to train the general people for fire-fighting.
The fire-fighting vehicles should be placed in every fire station depending on the requirement of that specific
station coverage area. Detail research is needed for every service area to understand the pattern of fire
incidents and provide vehicles and equipment according to the requirement.
If the government and the local community can work together to fight against the fire, it will reduce the risk
of destruction in times of incidents and ensure better safety.
Acknowledgments
The research work has been carried out with the fund of BUET to complete the degree of Master of Urban
and Regional Planning (MURP).
Appendix
List of Fire fighting vehicles of BFSCD:
Water Tender: Typical fire fighting vehicle which mainly store water to put off the fire. It can be of having
different capacity ranges from 4000 to 8000 liter.
Special Water Tender: One special type of water tender having higher capacity which ranges from 8000
to11000 liter of water. Basically used in severe fire incidents.
Page | 619
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
Toeing Vehicle: Actually a carrier vehicle which is used to carry different type of equipment including water
pump, foam can etc.
Turn-table Ladder: Special type of vehicle giving access to high rise building of different ranges up to 400m.
Photograph: Turn-table Ladder (up to 400m) Photograph: Turn-table Ladder (up to 300m)
Foam Tender, Foam Canon: Special type of vehicles which use foam to put off fire having the fire origin of
oil.
Chemical Tender: Special type of vehicle having four type of fire extinguishing agent- water, foam, carbon-
di-oxide, dry chemical powder, which is useful in any type of fire incidents.
Water Mist: Special type of motor cycle used in giving access to narrow roads having water and foam in its
reserve chamber. According to the fire officials, for the water tender more than 10ft wide road is required to
get access. Where the road width is lower, this Water Mist can be used to extinguish fire which gets easy
access to narrow roads. But, their capacity (40 liter) is very low to fight against severe fire.
Page | 620
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
Cold-cut: Special type of equipment carried by toeing vehicle having high pressure hose. It is also used to
cut iron sheet in times of fire incident and rescue event.
Ground Monitor: Useful in severe fire incidents to through large volume of water in longer distance.
References
BBS. Population and Housing Census 2011, Community Report: Dhaka. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics,
Statistics and Informatics Division. Ministry of Planning, Government of Bangladesh, Dhaka, 2011.
Delhi Citizen Handbook, Centre for Civil Society, New Delhi, 2006, Retrieved from
ccs.in/sites/all/books/com_books/book_dch_2006.pdf on April 23, 2014.
DTCB, “Preparatory Survey Report On Dhaka Urban Transport Network Development Study (DHUTS) in
Bangladesh”, Dhaka Transport Coordination Board, Ministry of Communications, Government of
The People’s Republic of Bangladesh, March, 2010.
FSCD Directorate, “Stakeholder’s workshop on finalizing strategic management plan,” Fire Service and Civil
Defense Directorate, Ministry of home affairs, Bangladesh, 2013.
Hacıoğlu Ç., Spatial requirements of fire stations in urban areas: a case study of Ankara, M.Sc. thesis in Urban
Design, Department of City and Regional Planning, Middle East Technical University, Turkey,
2010.
HMDA, “An abridged manual on environmental building guidelines for Hyderabad Metropolitan
Development Authority”, New Delhi, India: TERI Press, 2009. Retrieved from
http://www.hmda.gov.in/ebgh/the%20guidelines/calculators/HMDA-Abridged%20
Building%20Guidelines-english.pdf on April 22, 2014.
Monday C. C., “Optimal staffing levels for firefighter effectiveness and mitigation of firefighter injuries,” An
applied research project submitted to the National Fire Academy, Martinsville Fire Department,
Martinsville, Virginia, 2000.
NFPA, Fire Protection Handbook (20th edition). Quincy, Massachusetts USA: NFPA, 2008. Retrieved from
https://www.inkling.com/read/fire-protection-handbook-2008-edition-volume-ii/chapter-
13/responsetravel-time-standards on May 12, 2014.
NDMA, “National Disaster Management Guidelines—Scaling, Type of Equipment and Training of Fire
Services”, National Disaster Management Authority, Government of India, New Delhi, April 2012.
Newaz, AKM S., Director (Operation and Maintenance), Fire Service and Civil Defence, (2014, September).
Personal interview
Nuruzzaman M., Station officer of Tejgaon Fire Station, (2014, September). Personal interview
Orcutt Community Plan EIR, Long Range Planning Division, Country of Santa Barbara, (n.d.). Retrieved
Page | 621
Proceedings on International Conference on Disaster Risk Management,
Dhaka, Bangladesh, January 12-14, 2019
from http://longrange.sbcountyplanning.org/planareas/
orcutt/documents/OCP%20EIR/OCP%20EIR%20Volume%201/5.14%20Public%20Services.pdf
on 17 May, 2014.
Sripramai K., Oikawa Y., Kanai M., and Katada T. “The Relationship between Local Government and
Residents in Disaster Prevention Activity”, (n.d.), Retrieved from dsel.ce.gunma-
u.ac.jp/doc/n200.pdf on 13 March, 2014.
TriData, “Oklahoma City Fire Department Fire Station Location Study”, TriData, A Division of System
Planning Corporation, Arlington, 2006. Retrieved from http://www.okc. gov/fire/fire_report.pdf on
April 23, 2014.
Page | 622