Edu 301 by VU

General Methods of Teaching (EDU 301)
“Concept of Teaching”
Lecture # 01
Lecture Objectives:
 Perceive teaching as a social, political and ethical activity.
 Describe teaching perceptions as culturally and socially embedded.
 Use different metaphors to define teaching and teachers.
Short interviews from three people were taken to know their perspectives about teaching and
teachers.
Interview 1:
Teachers are the future makers of young generation. Teaching is a very respectable
profession. Regarding this, teachers have some expectations that he will wear a hat of many
roles. The roles are of a good communicator, evaluator, decision maker, class manager and
member of a team or group. Teachers must play all these roles with complete responsibility. My
philosophy of choosing teaching as a profession is that I want to motivate my students to learn in
a way that has positive influence on what they think and act. I see teacher as a gardener and
teaching strategies as a fertilizer to grow the students just like a seed. At the end, I must say that
learning process in the classroom will never stop. Students learn from the teachers and teachers
learn from the students.
Interview 2:
Teaching is a noble profession. Teacher is the source to impart knowledge to the students.
The goal of teaching must be to provide the students with conceptual knowledge rather than
focusing them to rote learning or memorization, so that they should not face problems in their
practical lives. Teachers are the agents who can bring change to the society. Teacher is a path or
a road map on which the students travel to get their destination or goal.
Interview 3:
Teaching is a self-oriented profession which serves to guide nation to access successful
future. I adopted my career as a teacher because a teacher helps the students to become what they
want to become. It is expected from a teacher that he should act as a professional educator who
considers the needs of the students.
1
Assumptions about teaching:

 Teaching is a noble profession.
 It is an activity to impart knowledge.
 It is a way of developing certain desirable behaviors among students.
 Teaching is an activity. It is way to teach people discipline, to teach students discipline.
Different perspectives of education in history:

The important role is of the Prophets and saints who teach in informal settings.
Informal education is education that is not given in proper schools. And if we see, Buddha,
Pythagoras, Jesus Christ, Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W) and Karl Marx
They all did it in informal organizations.
Informal settings are important means of learning.
Apprentice ship model: is also a way of learning. A person who wants to learn a skill spends a
certain period of time with a skillful person. In this way, the person who doesn’t have the skill,
learn those skills.
It is based on Vygotsky’s work, which involves peers working closely together with a
teacher in joint problem solving. e.g. workshops and skill-learning centers.
Assumptions:
 To understand how things actually developed, and who the prominent people are, who
worked in this area?
 It was 16th century, actually which perceptions about education, teaching and learning
developed. In past, except Socrates, Plato and Aristotle, rest of the people thought
education as a means of status quo.
 Extra-curricular activities are always considered as extra.
What seems philosophy of education of Prophets?
 To equip people with basic literacy
 To give information
 To make them learn skills
 To bring societal change
2
If teaching is not bringing societal change. Then probably teaching is not fulfilling its spirit. If
we believe that teaching is about bringing societal change then we really need to reflect or
transform our actions so that we are able to bring change.
Discussion:
 How research takes/define teaching?
 How other people have taken/perceive teaching?
In opinion of Educationists or other people: (about role of the teacher)

Educationist: 1
There was a focus on functions or process of instructions and behavior, but now in
modern times, a role of a teacher and the expectations attached to it is completely different.
The fast and foremost is consideration of a teacher being an agent of change. The one who could
bring change to the society, one who would have some kind of outer box thinking. The role also
demands the teacher to be a collaborator. It is no more a one-way process in which empty
pitchers were filled up but its totally a two-way process of teaching and learning. And finally, the
role also demands not only of a facilitator but of a person who can trigger off higher order
critical thinking skills.
Educationist 2:
The role of a teacher is very important in building the character of the students and in
enhancing his natural skills. In old times, the role of the teacher was just to come, deliver a
lecture, give the students tests and quizzes, assignments and check them, give them grades and
that’s it. In modern times, the teacher is an agent of transformation of the students from less
skilled individuals to skilled individuals which have good skills for doing their work and are also
responsible citizens.
The role of a teacher is changed from a lecturer to an agent of transformation. Teachers
should interact with students more than they do in previous times. Now method of teaching is
called interactive teaching. Teachers involve the students in learning.
3
Teaching as a social, political and ethical activity:

 As social activity:
Man is a social animal because it lives with other people, it socializes with other
people. It is necessary for its existence and emotional strength to stay with other human
beings. When we say that teaching is a social activity, it means that teaching can’t be
done in isolation. It needs people with whom teaching can be done. So it is essentially a
social activity.
 As a political activity:
If we say that teaching is a political activity then teacher needs to have some
perception and teacher need to discuss those ideas with the students. Actually both of
them should work together for a social change. Because political ideas are important not
only in the sense of politics, politics means a set of ideas. Teacher must share ideas with
the students so that they can work for a change in society. If education is not serving this
purpose and teachers are just providing the students with the content knowledge then
essentially this teaching is not a political activity.
 As ethical activity:
It is a duty of a teacher to fulfill his responsibilities ethically. Ethics include that
teachers need to be committed to their profession, they need to be honest, and
dedicated. If teachers are not exhibiting the above then they are not taking it as an
ethical activity. It is also important because teachers are role model for students.
So if a role model is not performing these duties ethically, then definitely this role
model will not be a good example.
Teaching perceptions as culturally and socially embedded

Different cultures have different perceptions about education. The perceptions of
education in Pakistan are different from other countries. In Pakistan there are urban and rural
cultures and perceptions in both cultures are different.
Research says that the perceptions are socially and culturally embedded. Perceptions of
teachers in Pakistan are different from the teachers of other countries. Although in Pakistan,
4
there are different cultures and people living in those cultures hold different perceptions on
education and teaching.
A survey was conducted for the clarification of this concept. In this survey, some teachers
were selected from rural and urban areas, and some from the private and government schools.
Then the ideas of the teachers and parents of the students were analyzed to see weather they
differ or not.
 Firstly, the teachers from urban schools say that it is their responsibility to teach
discipline to the students. The same was the perception of parents, they say that teachers
are very respectable and must teach students discipline and behaviors. And students must
obey them.
 Secondly, the teachers from government schools of the city say that their role is to teach
the students how to read and write. Because these students come to school to learn how to
read and write so that they can get jobs in factories. The parents also respond the same,
they say that their sons may get jobs in factories or some other work that they can do
easily. The parents do not expect high potential jobs.
 Thirdly, the opinion of teachers from the private schools is that they are the facilitators.
Their responsibility is not only transmitting the content knowledge to the students but
finding their hidden potentials. Parents respond the same that they are paying fees and it
is the responsibility of the teacher to nurture the potentials of their children.
The important thing in the above survey is the “Cultural difference”. We are living in a status
stratified society, so the students studying in the government schools belong to low income
group, their parents and teachers also think the same. So we can say that perceptions on teaching
are culturally and socially embedded.
Metaphors on teaching and role of teachers:

There are different metaphors of teaching, actually what we think about teaching is our
metaphor. The metaphor is something that tells that how you take teaching?
If we think that teacher
 Is a source of light:
5
Imagine that teacher is a sun or a candle; it is a source of light. It is spreading its

light everywhere. The students don’t have light; the teacher is giving light to students i.e.
his knowledge.
 Is like a tree
Imagine if a teacher is a tree, it is giving his shadow to everyone. The one who
come to that tree will definitely get shadow and fruit of knowledge.
 Is a gardener
If teacher is a gardener, and use the teaching strategies as a fertilizer to grow the
students just like a seed.
Thoughts of these perceptions:
 Is there no knowledge gain, if there is no teacher?
 Teachers teach manners and behaviors.
 Who decides that certain behaviors are appropriate and others are not that appropriate?
 Do children really learn discipline in schools?
 A formal education comprises of a basic education that a person receives at school.
 Informal means unofficial and it takes place outside of the standard school setting.
6
“Teaching as a profession”
Lecture # 02
Lecture objectives:
 Identified and reflected upon common misconceptions in Education, Teaching and
Learning.
 Reflected upon the statement “Teaching is an Art and Science.”
 Reflected upon the criteria for professional and moral obligation of professionals.
Some misconceptions in teaching:

 Schools are isolated places.
Sometimes teachers ask students not to exhibit certain behavior in schools e.g.
sometimes they ask students not to shout but teachers themselves are shouting. It
is actually very disappointing that whenever teachers ask the students not to
shout, their own voice level is very high. Definitely, teachers are also the product
of society; they have also learnt those behaviors in their homes and schools. So it
is very important not to consider schools as isolated places. Teachers believe that
schools are isolated places that are totally detached from the society which is not
true.
 Education is about learning of different subjects:

This educational view has vocational orientation. The word “Vocational”
identifies use for job or utility for job market. It means that if we are sending the
students to schools to learn different subjects, we want them to get prepared to get
admissions in professional colleges. If they get admissions in professional
7
colleges they will become competent professionals. Education is serving the

purpose of getting jobs in the job market. Now how can we claim that teachers are
agents of social change? Most of the times we focus on teaching of different
subjects and we assess students on performance of these subjects. We are always
testing their knowledge but we just forget that purpose of education is much more
than teaching students these subjects.
 Learning is exploring different subjects:

According to Friere: “In fact knowledge is created, when we act and reflect.”
Knowledge about different facts is stratified knowledge. Your objective
knowledge has its own importance but that is called static facts. Subjective
knowledge is also very important. Subjective knowledge is something that is
learnt by reflecting, acting on something. Learning is not only about exploring the
static facts but it is to explore the knowledge.
 Drama or debates are extra or co-curricular activities:

These are neither extra nor co-curricular activities but these are all curricular
activities. These are actually means of holistic development of a child. Holistic
development means complete development; a child needs to develop physically,
intellectually, ethically, socially and spiritually. Unfortunately, when we say that
aim of schools is to teach only different subjects, we do not focus on the holistic
development of a child. So it is really important for us to understand that
participation in these kinds of activities is not something wasting time rather it is
very important for their holistic development. Holistic development of a child
requires participation in games, debates, dramas etc. we should provide these
opportunities where students perform in dramas, develop their speaking skills by
participating in debates or dramas. Similarly, essay writing competitions so that
they can develop writing abilities. We should actually allocate time for these
activities in their timetable so that they carry out such kind of activities.
 Silence promotes learning:
8
Teacher asks the students not to talk. They have a misconception that “Learning is
when there is silence rather complete silence”. Teachers do not go through
theories or research that is why this misconception is so dominant in our schools.
We know that learning is when there is sharing of ideas. There is a concept of
peer learning, children learn from their peers, they actually learn more from their
peers than they learn in schools by teachers.
Is teaching an art or science?

Idea of “Teaching is an Art”, was developed by William James in 1891.So, an
artist is able to create things. If we say that teaching is an art then we are expecting that
teacher needs to be very imaginative, innovative, teacher must have the skills that an
artist posses. There is also a drawback that when policy makers claim that teaching is an
art, they say that teachers are born teachers as artists are born artists. If teachers are born
artists then we actually deny the importance of professional organizations or professional
trainings. So if we say that teaching is an art we must not say that teaching is by birth, or
these are innate capabilities that could not be learnt.
Science is an organized body of knowledge. Organized body of knowledge means
that it is very systematic. It has some research underpinnings and theoretical
underpinnings. Research and science go side by side. The claim that teaching is a science;
it shows that there is research in teaching. All the theories of teaching are based upon
research, research in psychology and sociology. It is actually true that teaching is an art
and science.
The criteria for professional and moral obligation of professionals:
Like all professions, teaching also has some standards and criteria.
Criteria to be a professional:
 Learning a profession involves learning many concepts and principles of that
profession.
For example, if we consider medicine as a profession then there are number of
key concepts involved in it. The students learning medicine needs to understand
all the principles and concepts of that profession. We cannot compare a
compounder to a doctor because a compounder does not know all the basic
9
concepts and principles. The knowledge a compounder acquires is far less than
that of a doctor. So when we talk about a profession, we actually assume that the
professional has acquired the knowledge of that particular subject.
 A profession has a body of techniques and they may be transmitted:

Every profession has its own techniques. A cameraman knows the techniques to
handle camera, a doctor or surgeon knows how to handle medical instruments.
Knowledge of the skill gained must be practiced, as you know that “practice
makes the man perfect”. It is important for the professionals that they must know
the skills of their profession.
Transmission of skills
It is actually believed that in professions, if a senior person has acquired certain
skills than that person can transmit those skills to a junior person.
 A profession is internally organized and self-disciplined (code of ethics):

Internally organized means that there are different professional organizations
that tells the professionals that what they have to do. E.g. Pakistan Medical
Association, Engineering Council, Institute of Accountancy is also an
organization that tells the chartered accountants that how they have to practice
their profession.
Self-Disciplined: means that the professionals are ethically bound to follow some
norms and rules which are set by their organization. They develop their own code
of ethics and do not violate them.
 A profession has a social function:

We are living in a society where we need to follow law and order and if there is
any problem then we really need to go to court, so law profession is important as
social function. When we talk about social function, those occupations are called
professions which the people needs rather people cannot survive without that
profession. It should be the need of the people. So only that job is considered as
profession which is based on people’s need.
10
 A profession allows independence or Autonomy:

There are certain professions which have strong internal organizations where they
can take decisions. There autonomy is at individual level as well as collective
level. E.g. a doctor has the autonomy to prescribe medicines to patients. If there is
a serious patient, then a group of doctors to decide the treatment of that patient.
How can teaching be considered as profession?

 Concepts and principles in teaching profession:
The students who are enrolled in 4 years B.Ed program have the curriculum. This
is basically a content which is based on all the concepts and principles to be learnt
e.g. they will learn about how students learn? Philosophy of education, methods
of teaching, educational research, assessment & evaluation etc. so all these
subjects will provide them the knowledge which is a core requirement to be a
teaching professional.
 The techniques learnt by teachers:

Every profession has its own techniques. Some teaching techniques are: how to
motivate the students? What is its theoretical background? You can motivate
children by a motivational strategy, but the same strategy cannot motivate elders.
In the same way, a teacher must know the techniques to teach different subjects.
Because each subject have different demands or flavors and teacher needs to
know the difference between the teaching of English, science or mathematics and
other subjects.
 Is teaching internally organized and self-disciplined:

Every profession has its organizations; Teachers unions in Pakistan are serving
the purpose of protection of the teachers’ rights. There is a society named as
“Society for Pakistani English Language Teachers” (SPELT) which organizes
different workshops and other developmental programs for the teachers.
11
 Teaching as a social function:

We all believe that teachers have a very important social function. It is very
unfortunate especially in Pakistan that mostly teachers are teaching different
subjects, they are concerned about grades of students, they are not concerned
about their holistic development. It is obvious that teaching has a prime social
function but unfortunately, it is not been taken care of in Pakistani context.
 Teacher in Pakistan have individual autonomy or not?

In Pakistan, teachers don’t have the autonomy. He/she doesn’t have the powers of
decision making. There is no representative of schools who is involved in
educational policy making. Curriculum is formed under Ministry of Education
many times as in 2006, 2007, 2008 etc but when this curriculum is sent to schools,
teachers are supposed to teach that curricula. They neither are nor supposed to go
beyond those curricula. School management decides that which subjects must be
taught to the students. There is no autonomy given to the teachers.
What future teachers actually need to learn is:
You need to develop a belief that:
 We are living in a changing world, thus being professionals we constantly need to

upgrade our knowledge.
Being a teacher you really need to equip with every new research that is coming
on motivation, pedagogy or any other. It can’t be done unless you believe that you
need to learn and need to change. So it is said that “To Learn Is to Change”
 You need to acquire the knowledge of foundations of education, pedagogical knowledge,

pedagogical content knowledge, assessment and evaluation and teaching techniques and
skills.
12
- Foundation of education: you will learn in the 4 year program about philosophy
of education, psychology of education etc. these are actually the foundations of
education.
- Pedagogical knowledge: pedagogical knowledge means the knowledge about
how to teach the students.
- Pedagogical content knowledge: every subject has its own demands or flavors,
so there are different ways to teach different subjects.
- Assessment and Evaluation: being a teacher you should know that what to
assess? How to assess? Why to assess? Similarly, how to report results? How to
use data? All these things need to be acquired to be a good teacher.
- Teaching techniques and skills: you must know the teaching techniques and
skills that are expected from a good teacher.
Things you have to learn, when you want to be a professional:
 Teaching skills:
 General teaching skills:
- Planning lessons
- Classroom management:
- Assessing pupils learning
- Motivating pupils
- Managing pupils’ behavior
Develop professional values and practice:

Professional values for teachers are:
 Commitment
 Honesty
 Intellectual honesty
 Reflection in action. Reflection on action
13
There should not be gap in what teachers say and what do they do. Because if there is any gap
then they would not be able to present themselves as true role models. So, being professionals we
should have certain knowledge of the profession. We should have skills but at the same time, we
need to exhibit those dispositions which make us good role models.
“Professional behaviors and context of schools”

Lecture # 03 (301)
Lecture objectives:
 Reflected upon the principles for professional behaviors.
 Analyzed educational, social and collegial context of schools.
Principles for professional behaviors:

 Commitment to the students:
An educator needs to strive to help each student realize his/her potential as a

worthy and effective member of the society. A teacher needs to effort
individually that every student must realize his/her potentials and reach to the
maximum level. If we are not successful in realizing the potential of every
student, then actually we are not committed to the students. The level of
commitment to the profession must be to the range of every student. In most of
the cases, teacher really appreciates high achievers. At times, a teacher is very
much concerned about the learning of low achievers. So, the teacher mostly
focuses on the low achievers or the high achievers but the students with average
learning are ignored. They also need the attention of the teachers as other high
and low achievers.
14
Educators work to stimulate the spirit of inquiry and acquisition of

knowledge. We are inquisitive by nature. When a child grows up, he asks many
questions about his surroundings. He wants to know what and how is happening
around. But when he is sent to school, normally he asks many questions but those
questions are not answered properly. So, being educators, we need to keep that
spirit of inquiry in depth rather we need to stimulate that spirit e.g. if a student is
not habitual of questioning in class then we need to develop that habit in him. If
we do not develop that habit then ultimately, the students will not enjoy their
acquisition of knowledge. Everything seems a burden to them. Being educators, if
we say that we are very committed teachers then we really need to raise the
potential in each child in our class and we need to stimulate the spirit of inquiry
and acquisition of knowledge.
 Commitment to the profession:

1. Raising professional standards
2. Professional judgment
3. Influencing policies
4. Professional organization
The educators need to exert every effort to:

 Raise professional standards:
If teaching is a profession, then what are the standards for teaching? A teacher needs to know
- A pedagogical content knowledge: the subject a teacher is going to

teach to class 8th must know the content of that subject and the methods to
teach that particular subject.
- Communication skills: communication skills must be so clear that a

teacher can convey lecture to the students easily. A teacher must have a
good eye contact with the students. A teacher must be able to read their
verbal and nonverbal cues.
15
- Assessing skills: a teacher must know how to assess learning of the

students. A teacher must know different assessment methods.
- How students learn: a teacher must know how students learn e.g. if I am
a teacher of language, I must know how students learn their first language
and how they learn their second language. A teacher must know the
learning theories as well.
- Recent developments: a teacher must know the recent developments
related to the profession. Recent development means the recent research
on the profession. Different theories to teach and assess the students.
If I claim that I am a professional teacher, then I must come up to these standards. But the point
is to raise the standards not only to meet them. To meet the standards is a minimum requirement,
but a good professional is the one who go one step ahead to those standards. We educators really
need to raise the professional standards.
 Promote a climate that encourages the exercise of professional judgement:

A judgement that is given by a professional himself is a professional judgement
e.g. in education, if a teacher is giving a judgement about the students that he has
a good vocabulary but he is weak in grammar. This judgement is a professional
judgement because this judgement has evidence on which the judgement is made.
If a judgement is made by parents, they do not have direct involvement with the
education of the child as the teacher has. So we will say that is not a professional
judgement.
This professional standard demands from us to create a climate that promotes the
professional judgement. This climate can be created through parents-teachers
meetings where parents are told about the role of the teachers, teacher’s
expectations from the parents as well as students and the community. In this way,
we are going to educate teachers as well as the community. We cannot achieve
this standard by being indifferent.
16
 Achieve conditions that attract persons worthy of the trust to careers in education:
Unfortunately, our own self-image is that we could not get admissions in
engineering or medicine or computer science so that is why we have come into
teaching. So, we have to change our own self-image as well as of the others
regarding teaching as a career. We have to advocate that make teaching your first
career option. As far as our own image cannot be changed, we could not convince
others. Being teachers, we need to advocate teaching as a career.
 Assist in preventing the practice of the profession by unqualified persons:

Unqualified means that those people are teaching who do not have degrees in
education i.e. B.Ed or M.Ed but they are teaching and they are considered good
teachers. We must have to stop such practices that unqualified people must be
replaced by the qualified.
In government sectors, if you want to be teachers then you need to get a
degree in education. But unfortunately, in private sectors and specially in street
schools there are many teachers who are unqualified. They started teaching after
their matriculation or intermediate exams. As a result, there is no education, there
is just schooling.
So, if we say that we are professional teachers, then we need to show our commitment to the
students and we need to show our commitment to the profession. We need to raise professional
standards. We need to promote a climate that encourages exercise of professional judgement. We
need to advocate teaching career and we need to stop practices of unqualified people.
Key context of schooling:

Some interviews were taken from the people to know their views about schooling. The brief
view of those interviews is given below one by one.
Interview 1 (Parent):
We sent children to school to become a better human being. They may know what is right and
what is wrong. They can get better job opportunities. The more educated the child is the better
17
job he will get. There are lots of activities in school. The child learns the attitudes of winning and
losing. Students get self-confidence through schools.
Interview 2 (Student):
I like to go to school because there are number of activities like coloring and painting. I like my
teachers because they speak to me very politely. They do not scold the students and it must not
be allowed in schools.
Interview 3 (Teacher):
School is a platform where children’s moral, physical, emotional and ethical development takes
place. A teacher is responsible in the cognitive development of a child. A child considered
school as a new place and feel difficulty in adjustment. But it is the responsibility of a teacher to
provide him with such environment that his social development can take place. In schools, not
only different subjects must be taught but also there should be co-curricular activities.
Assumptions on schooling:
 Group orientation activity:
Schooling is not about a single person, it is a group orientation. A successful school is the one
whose group orientation is so strong.
 Schools are composed of many different types of people, sects, religion, classes and
economic beliefs:
It is very unfortunate that sometimes we think that wearing a same uniform will also make their
thoughts uniform. They are never alike; they are diverse people coming from different classes,
economic beliefs, and different religions.
 Schools follow a certain curriculum:
Educationist named the key context of schooling as:

 Educational
 Social
 Collegial (Professional)
18
 Schooling in educational context:

If we assume that teaching of different subjects is a part of schooling then these subjects are
called an important part of the schools. Then we should help the students to learn the content of
the subject at different levels. These are:
- Literal level: it means that whatever you teach the students, the students get it well. E.g.
If you teach them some definitions, they can learn them. If you taught them some facts,
they can understand them.
- Application level: whatever the content is taught to the students, they must know its
application as well. E.g. you teach the students about map reading, and then you ask them
to tell you what map reading is? They will tell definitely. But can they find any location
from the map? Can they use the map in their practical life? It is a teacher’s responsibility
to teach them in the way so that they can identify different locations using the map.
- Higher thinking levels: educational context is not about memorizing different facts and
concepts. It is not coping things from the board or books. Educational context is much
more than that. It is actually developing thinking skills among students. It is about
creating creativity. It is about developing questioning skills among students.
Social context of schooling:

A sign in the Singapore International Airport reads “Welcome to Singapore: where our
only National Resource is Our People.”
- What does this sign board indicates?
- What is the responsibility of a school in Singapore?
This statement shows that in schools the most valuable thing is not its building, computer labs or
multimedia rooms but the people. Teachers are bound to develop social capital of the people, not
only students but all of the people.
Social capital:
- Sum of interpersonal relationships: the person who has many contacts or relations is
considered as he has more social capital. Can we live in isolation in schools? Definitely,
19
no. because there is group orientation in schools. We need people. We live with people.
No one can actually live in isolation. So we have to increase the social capital of every
student. (It is the responsibility of a teacher to increase the social capital of every student.
Most of the times, teachers come to the class with lesson plan, teach the lesson to the
students. They expect from the students to listen to the lesson, they give them written
work and then leave. There is no time for the students to communicate with each other
except in break or after school. It is the responsibility of the teacher to increase the social
capital of students by organizing group activities. Instead of doing things alone, they may
communicate with each other. In this way, they will increase their thinking skills also.
We are not teaching in a school to an individual but it is actually a group oriented
activity. Students must know that how to resolve conflicts? How to solve problems? The
interpersonal skills of the students are improved when they work with their opponents
instead of their friends. We need to make the students learn that all students are diverse
and we need to learn how we communicate with different kinds of people.)
Collegial context of schooling:

Is “Characterized by or having power and authority vested equally among colleagues:"
Collegial context is something that emphasizes that power and decision-making should be shared
among some or all members of the organization (Bush, 2003).
Power is shared among some or all members of the organization who are thought to have a
shared understanding about the aims of the institution.
Reflect upon the following statements displayed in the school staffrooms:
- “School business is not discussed here” it means that the matters of schools are not
discussed in the staffroom. People don’t like to talk about textbooks, students,
performance of the students, examination papers, or issues of classroom management in
the staffroom. It means that in this school the collegial context is too weak. Colleagues
are not support of professional development. Whenever we go into profession, we always
have to learn from people, the seniors are our assets. If they do not discuss the things with
us how can we develop professionally? People in this school are not ready to grow as the
statement in their staffroom shows.
20
- “We believe in sharing ideas, work and food” the statement shows that the teachers in
this school are good colleagues. Because they want to share the ideas so that they can
learn from each other. They want to share the work habits so that they become the
support for their colleagues.
- “Let’s establish a learning community” it shows that the community working in a

school is a learning community. We all learn from each other. A teacher is the most
important learner in the class. Because he has to explore the realities of every student.
Their intellectual abilities and how he has to enhance them. A good teacher is the one
who actually strives to help each student achieve their maximum potential. At times, we
are unable to identify the realities of every student and we need the support of our
colleagues. And in a learning community we can get support of our colleagues very
easily.
- “My colleagues are my mentors” the statement shows that there is respect for the
mentors and we have to learn from them. It again indicates the sharing of ideas.
- “Relaxing time” this statement also indicates as the first statement that school business
is not discussed here. This is our time to relax. When we talk about profession we need to
raise professional standards. When we wrote in staffroom that it is a relaxing time, we are
not meeting the standards even how we can raise the professional standards.
So when we talk about the collegial context, we need to ensure that we are going to learn from
our colleagues. They should be our strength. We need to grow professionally.
Collegial context is not restricted to the schools rather now it has become web based.
So, when we say that we are professionals we need to ensure that we maximize this collegial
context we learn from each other.
21
“Incentives and responsibilities of teachers”
Lecture # 04 (301)
Lecture objectives:
 Analyzed teachers’ incentives and their level of functioning.
 Reflected upon the teachers’ decision making and responsibility.
 Analyzed the terms: Teachers’ efficacy and reflective practitioner.
Incentives for teachers:

According to research, following are the incentives for the teachers:
 Recognition as an excellent teacher (reflected in students’ warmth, enthusiasm,

appreciation). The question here is the recognition to the teachers should be given by
government of Pakistan? Or from the schools? According to research, the best
recognition is got from students and not from the government or the school
administrators. The warmth, respect and appreciation in the eyes of the students for the
teacher are the actual recognition. This recognition is so appreciating that the teachers get
energizes.
 Respect of colleagues: there was an organization, whose motive was the following
statement:
“The esteem of our colleague is the foundation of power” If you want to be powerful
and if you want to asset then you need to have respect and your esteem should be very
high. Actually when you are doing someone’s esteem high, then there is another feeling
of efficacy. Feeling of efficacy is very important for the teachers e.g. there are number of
activities in schools like morning assembly, debates, games, plays etc. teachers are very
competent in the school, they are teaching their subject very well but when they are asked
to organize such activities they feel that they can’t do it well. But if their colleagues start
motivating them and say that you are able to organize such activities. This is the feeling
22
of efficacy and there is a great role of the colleagues in developing this feeling. This
feeling is also an incentive. Teachers who do not get this incentive actually leave the
profession quite early.
 Working with other professionals: this is also an incentive that if you got an
opportunity to work with other professionals, you will feel energize. But if you are
working in such an organization where you are not allowed to work with other
professionals like if you are a math’s teacher, you have to work with other math’s
teachers or if you are a language teacher you have to work with other language teachers
but not with other professionals. So you may not be motivated.
What are different motivating factors and incentives for our Pakistani
teachers?
Some interviews are taken from the teachers in Pakistan to know their motivation factors. These
are discussed below:
Interview 1:
Money is only a motivating factor that insists you to go to your job in routine regularly. But the
incentives that are really important are the primary and secondary sources with which the
students interact with you in their every aspect of life. We feel affiliation motivation that we are
affiliated with the students in so many aspects. We get an opportunity to develop competence not
only in ourselves but the students as well. You are the source of motivation for the students not
only in terms of your profession rather you are also helping them in their daily life routines as
well. That is the biggest achievement for a teacher.
Interview 2:
As a teacher trainer, I feel that motivation factor is something when student gain positive change
in their thinking, behavior and attitude. By the end of the day, I feel happy that I help them in
bringing change in them.
23
Interview 3:
When there is no motivation, you cannot work properly at your working place. A teacher should
be self-motivated. If a person is not self-motivated, then he could not perform a variety of tasks.
By being in an organization, I have learned many things from many people. Besides that the
workshops and seminars also play a very important role in motivation of the teachers. These tell
us where we stand and what we can learn from others. Recognition as a teacher is also
motivating. Students come to you and they feel satisfied after you answer their questions. This
shows that you are there to help some body out. The students, the way they benefit from you, the
way they seek help from you is also a motivation.
Common assumptions from the above interviews:

 Recognition: recognition from the students is actually a motivating factor for the
teachers.
 Esteem: where the teachers think that their self esteem is becoming lower, they don’t
want to work at that place.
 Growth (working with other professionals): teachers want career growth. They want
growth in their learning. They want to learn the new methods of teaching, classroom
management and other new activities. E.g. in an educational institute, you may start your
career as a lecturer, then move to assistant professor, then associate professor and
professor. But unfortunately, in schools, there is no professional growth seen.
Teacher’s levels of functioning:

1. Intentionally Disinviting
2. Unintentionally Disinviting
3. Unintentionally Inviting
4. Intentionally Inviting
1. Intentionally Disinviting:
In this state of functioning, a teacher does not invite people to give you
suggestions. There is no sharing of ideas.
24
2. Unintentionally Disinviting:
When you are working at a place for a long time. You realize that it is not a good
norm, that you are not sharing your ideas. You must share your ideas and ask for
advice.
3. Unintentionally inviting:
In some cases, teachers start sharing their classroom management with other
teachers unintentionally. It means that they do not want to share but share the
things with others unintentionally. E.g. in a staffroom, a teacher is saying that I
could not finish the lesson on time which I have planned. You also become the
part of that conversation by saying that it happens to me sometimes also. Now
actually you invite suggestions on how to resolve this problem unintentionally.
4. Intentionally inviting:
This is the highest level of your teaching development. You come to realize that
you didn’t know everything and you need development. You are able to identify
your flows and mistakes. And you need help and advice from your colleagues.
You are intentionally inviting the people to advice you.
Teacher as a decision maker:

There are some common questions that will show that whether the teachers have the power of
decision making or not. These questions are discussed below one by one.
1. What to teach?(No autonomy)
Teachers have no autonomy when the content of the subject is decided or
selected. If a teacher is working in a school system, then the school decides that
what content should be taught to a particular class. If we talk about government
sector, the books published by the Punjab textbook board or the content which is
decided by the ministry of education will be taught. There is no autonomy of a
teacher.
2. How to teach?(Autonomy)
25
Teacher has the autonomy of how to teach in a class. He can decide which
teaching method should be used.
3. How to manage class?(Autonomy)
Teacher has the autonomy that he can manage the class in the way he feels
feasible.
4. How to assess pupil’s learning?(Autonomy)
Teacher has the autonomy in this context also. He can assess the students’
learning according to the methods he teaches.
5. How to give feedback?(Autonomy)

Teacher can give feedback about every student. Because he is the one who is
directly involved in his learning.
6. Which resources to be used in classroom learning?(Autonomy to certain extent)

Teacher here also have the autonomy to certain extent because resources are
provided by the school administration and now the teacher can use them
accordingly.
7. Which activities to be used?(Autonomy)

Teacher can manage different activities in the school for the moral, social and
ethical development of a child. A teacher must use only those activities which
maximize students’ learning.
Teacher’s responsibilities as a decision maker:

Being a teacher I need to:
1. Learn about learning styles of students and use strategies which match with learning
styles.
2. Manage classroom to maximize pupil’s learning.
3. Give constructive feedback to maximize learning.
4. Use different assessment strategies to maximize students’ learning.
5. Use relevant low cost resources.
26
Reflective practice:
To explain reflective practice, I will first explain the light of reflection. The light of
reflection is “bouncing back of light to create an image.” Teaching reflection is related with the
light reflection for better understanding, the definition of teaching reflection or reflective practice
is:
“Answering some key questions to create an image of the classroom teaching and learning.” The
definition means that there are certain questions that teacher must answer by himself. He must
notice his classroom environment that if there are 30 students in a class, how much students are
answering the questions asked at the end of the lesson. How many students participate in
discussion? How many students participate in activities? These questions must be answered by
the teacher himself. The answers to these questions will actually tell the teacher that what the
environment of his class was. So, reflective practice is very important for a teacher. Being a
professional, I need to raise standard of my profession and reflective practice is definitely one of
the standards of teaching profession.
Reflection is of two types:

1. Reflection in action
2. Reflection on action
1. Reflection on action means that you have to answer some questions so that you may
know what the environment of your class was.
2. Reflection in action comes from experience. Once a teacher is in class, she/he needs to
reflect on all his/her actions. The reflection on every action at the same moment when the
action is being taken is reflection in action.
Basically, reflection is the means of creating a dialogue. A teacher is creating dialogue to

himself and as a result he knows his strengths and weaknesses. Reflective practice is an
important thing which we need to develop. To be a reflective practitioner, means a lot of hard
work and attitude to learn.
27
“Conceptual change, learning theories and modeling process”
Lecture # 05
Lecture objectives:
By the end of the lecture, you will have reflected upon:
 The term conceptual change.
 The formula for teacher’s growth.
 Theories on how children learn.
 Social cognitivism and modeling.
Outline of the lecture:

 Conceptual change
 Teacher growth
 How do humans learn
 Beliefs on learning
 Modeling effects
 Modeling process
 Social cognitivism
Most of the times, teachers required memorization of the facts and concepts from students.
Howard Gardner is very famous because of his theory of multiple intelligences. He says,
“Even students who have been well trained and who exhibit all the signs of
success . . . typically do not display an adequate understanding of the materials
and concepts with which they have been working.”
28
Conceptual change:
What actually most of the teachers do is that they focus on the missing knowledge of the
students instead of conceptual change. Conceptual change is important but it does require time. It
is difficult to accomplish conceptual change. We must not provide the students with superficial
knowledge but the deep learning is a conceptual change.
(Teacher is more interested in covering the syllabus instead of bringing conceptual change in the
students)
Teacher growth:
Teacher growth is also a conceptual change:
Knowledge + Experience + Reflection = Growth
If any single element is eliminated or missed from the above statement then it is not growth. If
you have knowledge and experience, it is necessary for growth that whatever you have gained
from your experience you must reflect on that. E.g. if you teach mathematics to grade 2 students
a year and then you are supposed to teach mathematics again in the next year to grade 2. You
have same notes and textbooks that you used earlier. You teach mathematics to grade 2 for the
next 5 years in the same way then there is no growth. You are just using your experience but
there is no change. But if a teacher gains experience to teach mathematics to grade 2 students and
at the end, reflect upon his experience is actually growth. By the end of the year, he will think
that what techniques must be use to improve students learning. What motivational strategies
work and which motivational strategies do not work. These things are actually part of your
reflection. If you are reflecting on the things, it means that you will teach the students the next
year in a much improved way. It means that you are developing yourself professionally. So,
teacher growth is also a conceptual change and it requires three elements. These are: knowledge,
experience and reflection.
How do humans learn?
29
Before we discuss theories on how children learn, there are some questions that must be taken
into consideration. And there answers will be discussed through theories.
1. How does a child learn to talk?

2. How did you learn different skills like cooking/ gardening/ stitching/ cycling/ using
dictionary?
3. How do people learn to debate?
4. How do people learn to perform in drama?
5. Did you learn multiplication before addition?
Nolan and Francis (1992) believe that:

- Knowledge is actively constructed by learners.
If you look at the question # 2, can you learn cooking without you cook? Can you learn stitching
without doing it? Can you learn to use dictionary without using it? Definitely, no. so it is true
that knowledge is actively constructed by learners. What do we teachers do in the classroom is
we start teaching concepts to the students. The students are just listening to the lecture; they are
not actively involved in learning.
If you look at the question # 1, that is how a child does learn to talk? If we do not allow a child to
talk or to explore different words of vocabulary, he cannot lean a language. It again shows that
knowledge is constructed by learners.
- Prior knowledge greatly influences learning.
Why is it necessary to learn addition before multiplication? Because multiplication is repeated

addition. If a child does not know addition, then he can’t learn multiplication. If a prior learning
of a student is good, then you can bring conceptual change very easily. It is important for a
teacher to know that what is the students’ existing knowledge or prior knowledge. Because it
actually influences learning. If a student has no prior knowledge about a concept, then he will
take more time in getting it. E.g. if a person has seen how to use injection, and you teach him to
use it. He will learn quickly as compare to the one who has never seen an injection. So prior
knowledge influences learning.
30
- Learning is there when teachers try to help learners change their cognitive
structures instead of focusing on their own teaching.
We have to judge the prior knowledge of the students and help them in learning new concepts by
recognizing their prior knowledge. So that they may have cognitive change and deep learning.
What do we teachers do that we focus on our own teaching e.g. a teacher is asked to cover the
syllabus in 2 weeks, his focus will be on covering the syllabus and not on the learning of the
students. So, good learning shift on focus to students.
- Learning is a social endeavor.
It is said that “Learning is social by nature.” It is because learning is enhanced when you are
learning in a group. We said in previous lectures that schools have group orientation. It is
because the learning in schools is in groups. There are many things that cannot be learnt
individually but in groups. In one in one process, a student made a mistake that is corrected by
the tutor individually. But when a student makes a mistake in a class, many students learn from
that mistake. Whether it was their mistake or not but they learn from them also. So students learn
in a social environment. And learning is definitely a social process.
Social cognitivism and modeling:

We will discuss the modeling process in social cognitivism. There are some questions to take
into consideration:
1. How does a child learn to hold spoon?
2. How does a child learn to wear clothes?
3. How does a child learn to play?
The answer to these questions can be formulated by a video in which a child is copying an adult
in studying, playing and praying. But according to assumptions and from books, the answer to
these questions is:
“Much human behavior is learnt by observing the behavior of others (Bandura 1978).”
There are few things that can be learnt by observing others. According to Bandura, there are
three things in modeling:
1. Observational learning.
31
2. Inhibitory effect.
3. Disinhibitory effect.
1. Observational learning:
Observational learning is something that we learn by observing others. There are

number of people who learn things by just observing other people. If someone is
cooking, you can observe them and learn how to cook food. You can learn cycling
by observing, you can learn using computers by observing others. It means that
we can learn many things by observation. Teachers are said to be role models
because whatever teachers do, students used to copy them and learn. E.g. a small
survey was conducted on impressions and it shows that the teacher whose hand
writing was very good on the board, his students’ handwriting was also very good
and clear. But a teacher with average or poor handwriting on board shows the
poor hand writing of the students as well. This is a new learning that is learnt by
observing others.
2. Inhibitory effect:
When you learn something, and then observe others, you think that it is not right.
So you left that thing. E.g. if a person is wearing new style clothes, you have
bought the same dress as well. When you observe the other person and feel that
the dress is not looking nice, you reflect on yourself and think that it might not
suits me as well so you stop doing it. This is not a new learning. It is what you
leave by observing others. To unlearn something that was learnt.
3. Disinhibitory effect:
Disinhibitory effect takes place when you think that whatever you have learnt is
right and you can carry on with it. That is not a new learning. E.g. when a child is
writing an alphabet wrong and his teacher is also writing it in the same way. The
child gets ensure that the way in which he is writing is right because the teacher is
also writing it in the same way. His learning gets strong in this way.
So we may claim that modeling does affect children’s learning.
32
Modeling processes:
There are 4 important modeling processes and research has established these modeling
processes. These are:
1. Attention
In order to learn, you need to be paying attention. Anything that detracts your
attention is going to have a negative effect on observational learning. If the model
interesting or there is a novel aspect to the situation, you are far more likely to dedicate
your full attention to learning.
2. Retention
The ability to store information is also an important part of the learning process.
Retention can be affected by a number of factors, but the ability to pull up information
later and act on it is vital to observational learning.
3. Production
Once you have paid attention to the model and retained the information, it is time
to actually perform the behavior you observed. Further practice of the learned behavior
leads to improvement and skill advancement.
4. Motivation
Finally, in order for observational learning to be successful, you have to be

motivated to imitate the behavior that has been
modeled. Reinforcement and punishment play an important role in motivation. While
experiencing these motivators can be highly effective, so can observing other experience
some type of reinforcement or punishment?
Modeling can be made very effective if you take care of these four things. These are attention,
retention, production and motivation. And motivation is the most important term or process
33
because attention and retention are the initial levels but motivation takes place through out the
learning process. There is not only a single way to motivate students. Different teachers use
different strategies to make children attentive in the class and make them motivated.
Social cognitivism:
We discuss in the learning theories that learning is an active process. Basically, students can get
involved actively alone but the social process is still necessary. Because we are social beings,
human beings are social animal and we live in groups. So when we live in groups, our learning
will be enhanced due to group orientation.
Comments:
 Social cognitive theory, used in psychology, education, and communication, posits that
portions of an individual's knowledge acquisition can be directly related
to observing others within the context of social interactions, experiences, and outside
media influences. In other words, people do not learn new behaviors solely by trying
them and either succeeding or failing, but rather, the survival of humanity is dependent
upon the replication of the actions of others. Depending on whether people are rewarded
or punished for their behavior and the outcome of the behavior, that behavior may be
modeled. Further, media provide models for a vast array of people in many different
environmental settings.
34
“Learning of children and perspectives on instructional decision making”

Lecture # 06
Lecture objectives:
 The prior knowledge and social context of learning as essential conditions of learning.
 Language, learning and development as interwoven areas.
 The three perspectives on instructional decision making:
- Developmental
- Behavioural
- Cognitive
Outline:
 Prior knowledge and social context of learning as essential conditions of learning.
 Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD)
 Active learning
 Perspectives on instructional decision making
- Developmental perspective
- Behavioural perspective
- Cognitive perspective
There is a video that shows the students learning. In this video the teachers ask the students to
make words using different sounds. We will relate this video to Vygotsky’s theory. Vygotsky
was a Russian psychologist. He worked a lot on the theories of social constructivism. Vygotsky’s
theory about prior learning and social context included four major ideas. They are:
1. Children construct their own knowledge.
Most of the time, teachers say the students that the knowledge is present in the
book, and you must acquire the knowledge by learning. But vygotsky says that
the students do not acquire knowledge in that way rather they construct their own
35
knowledge. Students can cram knowledge but they cannot construct knowledge.
Vygotsky put a question mark to the following statement: if there is no
construction of knowledge by the students, then can we say that students have
learnt?
2. Language plays an important role in child’s learning.
Language is an important medium for learning. When a child doesn’t understand
a language then how can he learn a concept? Vygotsky says that when a child
born; his ultimate purpose is that he wants to communicate with the people
around him. When he starts communicating, he used many words like mama,
baba etc. Before he can communicate, he only starts weeping when he is hungry,
when he wants to sleep etc. he communicates in weeping. But as the child grows
up, he needs to learn language for communication. So, vygotsky says that unless a
child learns a language, it is very difficult for him to learn anything. Language is
basically a developmental tool.
3. Learning can lead development:

Learning may be defined as behavioural change or any other change like thinking
change etc. Vygotsky says that learning is there only when there is development.
E.g. there are some people of the same age i.e. 60 years; you feel that one person
is more mature than the other. The one who is more developed seems more
mature. His learning or experiences are more than the other person. As a result of
those experiences, we think that this person is more mature. On the other hand, a
person with fewer experiences seems less mature.
There is a misconception in the Pakistani context, it is said that males are more
mature, experienced and developed as compare to the females. It does not mean
that females do not have intellect. They can also be more developed and
experienced if they are given an equal opportunity to experience learning, and
create their social capital. Their experiences will be equal to that of males and
they would be equally developed. So, learning leads to development.
36
4. Learning/ development cannot be separated from the social context in which it

occur:
In the video, you have observed that the students who do not know the English
language, don’t know what are words producing sound of “pla”. But when her
peer told her what are those words, she understood and respond well. So, social
context is very important. Prior knowledge is also very important. Teacher must
try to know the prior knowledge of his students. It is not necessary that if there are
30 students in the class, all of them have the same prior knowledge. So if a
teacher tries to teach all students with a same method then all students cannot
benefit from it.
Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD):

The gap between actual and potential level of a child is Zone of Proximal Development.
Vygotsky is very famous for this concept of his theory.
Actual level is the initial level of child’s learning and potential level is the level where a
child can stand. The potential level is usually one step ahead the actual level. If student is at the
actual level, he has the potential to come up to the potential level. The important role here is of
the teacher, if a teacher helps the student, he/she can reach to the potential level very easily. The
teacher helps the students at actual level of learning, or at the first level of any learning, it is
easier for the student to go one step ahead of that level. When a student is standing at his
potential level, he is one step ahead of the previous and needs the support of his adults or
teachers again to go ahead of that potential level as well. E.g. if you are teaching mathematics to
a student, you teaches him about one-digit addition. You cannot take him straight to the concept
of two-digit addition unless he is expert in one-digit addition by practicing it. You teach him the
concept of ones and tens here. After he has learned one-digit addition, he couldn’t start doing
two-digit addition by himself. He needs the help of his elders or teacher to help him. Now the
student has jumped from the actual level to the potential level i.e. from one-digit addition to two-
digit addition. After that you give him the concept of ones, tens and hundreds, and he can go to
the third level by himself i.e. three-digit addition.
Perspectives on Instructional Decision-making:
37
- Developmental perspective
- Behavioural perspective
- Cognitive perspective
If I am going to teach in a class, I have to decide that what I am going to teach and how it should
be taught? How should I assess the students? How can I manage the classroom? All these things
are the part of instructional decision-making. The perspectives beyond these decision-making are
developmental, behavioural and cognitive. Piaget and Vygotsky are the key people who
developed theories. These perspectives are important for the teachers because whatever they are
going to teach to the students they can make decisions accordingly. When teachers will take
decisions according to these perspectives, the students will be more important in their eyes.
Developmental perspective:
If we take decisions in the class according to the developmental perspective and notices the
theories of Piaget and vygotsky we will conclude the following.
Piaget’s theory:
If followed by his theory, we will say that a child learns by himself. He play with the things, get
into different experiences and as a result he learns. Piaget’s perspective is stage-wise i.e. a child
will learn essential concepts at the first level then moves to the second and learns some other
concepts like-wise. E.g. when a child born, he learns to sit at the first level. Then at the second
level, his muscles get strong and he starts crawling, after that when his muscles get stronger, he
starts walking. When his muscles get stronger then he starts running. These are linear stages of
learning that at a particular stage a child will learn this thing and the second at the next level.
Vygotsky’s theory:
Vygotsky also says that a child construct his own knowledge. But according to him, social
context is very important. He says that it is not a linear process that a child must learn stage-wise.
If a child’s social context is so enriched then he can learn many things through his social
environment. Whenever I will teach the students according to Vygotsky theory, I will first try to
38
judge their prior knowledge. Unless I don’t know that where the students stand I can’t help them
in development and learning.
Behavioral perspective:
Behavioural perspective means that students may get any change in their behaviour. The new
concept you are going to teach to a student must be measureable and can be seen from his
behaviour that the certain concept has been taught. E.g. you taught the students about rural and
urban life, after that their observable behaviour will be seen when you give them the task to
differentiate between urban and rural life. Whatever the difference a child will explain, it will
show his behavioural change. If a child doesn’t know the differences before, you will notice the
change that the child was not aware of the differences but now he is able to identify those
differences. It means that the child has learnt. If being a teacher, I will take decisions according
to the behavioural perspective then I will merely focus on the direct instruction. I will teach the
students in such a way that at the end they are able to show that particular behavior or change in
behavior. The preferred teaching methods in this perspective will be lecture method and direct
instruction. When you are going to teach to higher classes, then teacher’s decision-making comes
from behavioural perspective. At that time, it becomes difficult for us to take decisions at
developmental level. Lecturing is done with adults, if lecturing is done with children, it may not
be useful.
Cognitive perspective:
Cognitive perspective is to develop students’ academic and thinking skills from a novice level to
a more expert level. Cognitive perspective can be related to ZPD but in that an adult’s presence
is important. In cognitive perspective, presence on adult is not necessary but complexity of task
is important. If your target is to improve a child’s thinking skills, then your task will be of such
kind that a child will learn from them. E.g. if we write on board and ask the students to copy that
on copies, or if we say that these things are written in your books, learn them, both are very low
level tasks. If you want to improve their thinking skill then you need to have projects with them.
Thinking skills can never be improved, unless you do not put them in a situation where they are
39
supposed to think. If a person has high problem solving skill, it means that he has experienced
many situations where he has solved many problems and as a result, he has got this higher
problem solving skill. So, cognitive perspective says that if a teacher want to take his/her child to
a certain level of thinking then we need to provide that range of experience to those people. This
perspective include tasks like portfolios, projects, independent tasks, inquiry tasks etc. an
important perspective of cognitive development is Active learning.
Active learning:
Active learning is where human mind is actively involved in constructing meaning of the
experience. When a teacher is teaching in a class, this is not active learning unless there is no
questioning in the class. When questions are asked from the students, then actually students
construct meanings. A good teacher is the one who engages the students in active learning.
Summary:
- In order to make students learn something, teachers must first understand how
the students are representing a given concept or procedure.
When we understand that what is the existing knowledge of the students then we can
develop them easily.
- Children do have their prior conceptions and being teachers we should first
explore their prior conceptions.
- Speech is a powerful psychological tool that lays the foundation for basic
structures of thinking later in one’s development.
We have learnt from Vygotsky’s theory that speech is a tool as brick is the tool for the
foundation of the building; similarly, speech/language is a tool for higher level of
thinking.
- Speech initially arises out of the need for a child to communicate with others
who share his/her environment.
A child speaks by his need. He speaks with the people who are there in his immediate
environment. If a stranger comes to them, they usually do not talk in front of him.
40
- As a teacher, we should speak and we should use this speech as a tool for
learning. We should talk and we should let our children talk.
Learning can never happen in silence. Where there is silence, there is no learning.
According to Vygotsky’s theory, language, learning and environment is a social context.
They are interlinked
COMMENTS:
 Complexity of task means that you give student task independently. He will work
independently and will get cognition accordingly. If you give students easy tasks, he will
get cognitive development slowly. But if you give him complex tasks, he will ultimately
have higher thinking skills.
41
“Kinds of knowledge and assumptions of teachers”

Lecture # 07
Lecture objectives:
By the end of the lesson, you will have:
 Identified different kinds of knowledge i.e. declarative, procedural and metacognitive.
 Identified lecturing, direct instruction and cooperative learning methods as useful
teaching methods.
 Identified some key assumptions of teachers.
Outline:
 Declarative knowledge
 Procedural knowledge
 Metacognitive knowledge
 Teaching methods use to teach declarative, procedural and metacognitive
knowledge.
 Key assumptions of teachers
- If teachers do not teach, students do not learn.
- Learners learn best by working alone.
- Learners need feedback on everything they do.
- Students’ tests indicate their learning.
- Intelligence is a fixed capacity.
- People learn in the same way.
42
Look at the following learning and place them in three different categories:
1. Using dictionary
2. Types of pollution
3. Dissecting frog
4. History of Pakistan
5. Community service
6. Research on school pollutants
7. Solving problems
8. Working in teams
In category 1: While learning about pollution and types of pollution, you are using your brain
whether you are reading books or a teacher is telling you that these are different kinds of
pollutants and environmental pollution is caused by these things. These are different ways to stop
environmental pollution. These things that you are studying are becoming part of your memory.
In the same way, history of Pakistan. To learn different facts and concepts are part of your
knowledge. This kind of knowledge is called Lecturing – Declarative Knowledge. When you
are learning in such a way that you are declaring knowledge. Knowledge that has been declared
either in the form of facts or in the form of concepts.
In category 2: There are two things, dissection of frog and using dictionary. Knowledge of such
kind is Dir]ect instruction – Procedural knowledge. If you want to search any meaning from
the dictionary, you need to follow a certain procedure. In the same way, if you want to dissect a
frog then you have to follow instructions.
In category 3: There is problem solving, community service, working with others, research on
school pollutants. This is a knowledge or skill that if a problem has occurred in front of you then
you are able to solve that problem. Working with others doesn’t mean that you are working in a
group. But you have to solve the problems while working with new kind of people. Similarly,
when you are going for a community service, then you are working with the people. If you have
learnt to live with the people then you can handle community service. Research is not something
that is in your mind that you can conduct research in such a way. But it is actually practically
conducting research. This is Cooperative groups - metacognitive knowledge.
43
1. Lecturing – Declarative knowledge:

This is the knowledge that is declared in books, research papers, newspapers or you
acquired that knowledge from your elders/teachers. There are two parts in this
knowledge: facts and concepts. Facts are something that you memorize e.g. Pakistan
came into being on 14 august 1947, this is a fact and students learn it as it is. There are
many facts in general knowledge books of elementary level, and this is called declarative
knowledge because it is the collection of different facts and students memorize it.
Concepts are Newton’s law, rules of grammar, writing patterns, and we say that these are
also part of our declarative knowledge. Unfortunately, we very much focus on this
declarative knowledge. We think that this is the most important knowledge and we used
to test our students on this knowledge.
2. Direct Instruction – Procedural knowledge:
This knowledge is a step ahead from that declarative knowledge. In which you have
acquired the knowledge but still you need to know its procedures as well. E.g. you told a
student that a frog is dissected in such a way, and its steps as well. And then you ask him
about it by a written test that “what procedure is to be followed while dissecting a frog.”
A student gives the answer by stating all the steps of dissection. But procedural
knowledge doesn’t mean knowing the procedure, e.g. you know many recipes of baking,
may be you have read them in books or listened from anyone. It doesn’t mean that you
can cook them as well. Every student has different potential of learning. If you teach
them to use dictionary, all students may not use it in the same way. Some students may
find the word “Alter” by going through every page of alphabet A. But some will directly
browse to the page where words start by AL and will find the word. So, every student has
its own procedure to learn something and that is procedural knowledge peculiar to that
person. Procedural knowledge is not memorizing the procedures but which you have
acquired through doing that procedure. Another thing that is involved in it is practicing.
The more you practice, the stronger will be your procedural knowledge.
Teachers are just concentrating on covering the syllabus; they don’t take the students
towards procedural knowledge even. We do not allow the students to use the scientific
44
apparatus in the labs. We show them the things in the classroom by demonstrating we are
afraid that the students may not handle the apparatus carefully and it may broke. Unless
we do not allow them to use the apparatus, there is no procedural knowledge. All the
skills are part of the procedural knowledge and these can be learnt only by doing.
3. Cooperative groups – Metacognition:

According to Wikipedia:
“Metacognition is cognition about cognition.” E.g. a child does not know the concept of
evaporation, but he learns that what he should do to learn the concept of evaporation.
That is metacognition. We categorizes this knowledge and in that the first thing was
problem solving, having great declarative knowledge does not mean that you can be a
good problem solver. Problem solving is your part of metacognition and it means that in a
new situation, you can apply/use your declarative knowledge. You can transfer your
learning in a new situation. So this is also called as transferable skill. You may call it
application of application. Creativity is also a part of metacognition. Learning to learn is
metacognition. Metacognitive knowledge is actually of least focus in our schools. There
is no focus of metacognitive knowledge in schools rather we teachers are not aware of
that.
What are the methods to promote these three kinds of knowledge?
 Lecturing is the procedure to gain declarative knowledge. Because you just need to
deliver facts and concepts. There are some teachers who organizes group discussions in
the class, so declarative knowledge can be gained through discussion also. Through
discussion, you can take the students to metacognition as well.
 Procedural knowledge is gained through direct instruction. You have to tell the student
directly what he has to do. E.g. when students go into the schools, they learn to write
different alphabets. The teacher is telling them how to write different alphabets. A child
who is newly admission in the school could not follow the teacher, if the teacher writes
45
all alphabets on board and ask them to copy. But he has to tell them by holding hand that
how to write the alphabets. Hand writing is a skill and to teach this skill to students,
teachers need to give them direct instruction by holding their hand and teaching them. So,
direct instruction can be useful when you want to give procedural knowledge. You can
never give the procedural knowledge through lecturing. Equipment handling is also an
example of procedural knowledge. You have to guide every student that how to handle or
use the equipment. It is not only that teacher shows them to use the apparatus. Procedural
knowledge is acquired only through practice. So when we are expecting a child to do
something or his skills should be improve, then we need to give them direct instruction
and feedback.
 Metacognition is gained through problem solving. Definitely, if you do not give the
students problems, they can never learn to solve the problems. So we need to give
students such activities or tasks that involve their thinking and practical application as
well. Team work is an important skill/knowledge that is metacognitive knowledge and it
should be taught to the students. You can never give the students this knowledge unless
you do not allow the students to work in groups. So, through team work you learn how to
work in groups, how to resolve conflicts. Whenever you work in groups, there are many
conflicts and disagreements. Metacognition is based on metacognition of declarative
knowledge and metacognition of procedural knowledge.
Teacher’s assumptions:
1. If teachers do not teach, students do not learn.

Research says that students can learn by themselves, if there is no teacher. It is the
responsibility of the teacher to maximize their learning time. They must facilitate the
students so that they can reach to the maximum of their potential. This assumption is not
true and it is also a misconception, because every student has its prior knowledge and if
we do not test their prior knowledge, the students do not participate actively in learning.
We think that we are going to teach the students from the beginning but it seems
meaningless to them.
46
2. Learners learn best by working alone.

Whenever we assign students a task, we want them to do it individually. If a student does
not know something, we say that ask me, not your peers. We do not allow them to work
in groups. There are two attitudes of teachers; firstly, we know that students cannot learn
without a teacher, being a teacher we are in a superiority complex that we know
everything. Secondly, we say that students can learn individually or by working alone.
We should not hold this assumption; we should hold this assumption that learning takes
place best when there is some social or group orientation. As we study earlier that
learning is a social process, if learning is a social process then we need to believe that
learning takes place when children work in groups. If students are working alone and
they do not succeed. Their self esteem becomes very low; they think that they cannot
have the things done. If they can have a helping hand, their self esteem becomes higher.
3. Learners need feedback on everything they do.

We always try to give students feedback and that feedback is of very low level that has
no educational value. E.g. the words poor, good, excellent are the words used as
feedback. We assume that if we do not give feedback, the students cannot learn. We
develop attitude in students by feedback, students think that teacher will not check the
homework so why we do it. This is because we can not make learning enjoyable for
them. Learning itself is a pleasure process. If the students will do everything for getting
good feedback from the teacher, then definitely they will not develop habit of life long
learning. If we want them to be life long learners, we must make them self motivated.
4. Students’ tests indicate their learning.

What do we do in classes; there are tests on our mind every time i.e. weekly tests,
monthly tests, mid terms, final exams etc. unfortunately, every examination tests only the
factual and conceptual knowledge of the students. And we think that we know who the
brilliant students of our class are. It is not true because these tests are not associated with
their learning. To test the learning there are many other possible ways, if we want to
judge a student in art, we will ask him to draw something on the paper rather we ask him
47
to write down on the paper how to draw things. Similarly, if we want to know how good
a student can present, then we will ask him to present something and in this way, we will
judge his communication and presentation skill. It is said that English language teaching
focuses on four things; speaking, listening, reading and writing. But in our board exams,
students’ reading comprehension ability and writing is judged. We only judge their
writing skill and never allowed them to speak in English, then how they can have
command on English speaking skill. This is also a misconception that students’ learning
is always assessed by tests.
5. Intelligence is a fixed capacity.

Research says that IQ is not enough. There are multiple intelligence theories which say
that every student has his own intelligence. Some students have more special intelligence,
some students have interpersonal intelligence. There is a major focus on emotional
intelligence. It is expected from schools that teachers must develop the emotional
intelligence of the students as well. IQ is a redundant term these days. We make ranking
of the students that these students are brilliant, these are of average intelligence and the
others are low achievers. We mostly use the word in the schools and we feel satisfied by
the word and that is ‘slow learners’. Learning depends on prior learning; everyone can be
a slow learner in a new situation.
6. People learn in the same way.

People have different learning styles. But we teachers assume that all students learn in a
same way. We use the same teaching method in the class and assume that every student
has got the lesson according to our expectations. We are diverse people, we have diverse
learning styles. So being teachers it is our responsibility to use those teaching methods by
which all students can learn well. We are decision makers; we have the autonomy to
decide what we are going to teach and how we are going to teach. How to assess the
students. But we have to fulfill our responsibility also that we should teach every student
with justice.
48
So, these are some assumptions that need to be challenged. We have to develop ourselves
professionally and the necessary things for growth are knowledge, experience and
reflection.
“Educational Equity”
Lecture # 08
Lecture objectives:
By the end of the lecture you will have:
 Reflected upon the concept of ‘educational equity’
 Reflected upon dimensions of diversity, these dimensions are: socioeconomic, physical,
language, ability, and gender.
 Devised ways to promote socioeconomic, physical, language, ability and gender equity in
your school.
Outline of the lesson:

 Educational equity
 Kinds of diversity
- Socioeconomic diversity
- Physical diversity
- Ability diversity
 Categories of exceptionality
- Intellectual
- Communicative
- Sensory
- Behavioural
- Physical
- Multiple
 Language diversity
49
 Strategies to integrate address language diversity

 Gender diversity
- Gender equity – Stereotypes
- Research on language equity stereotypes
- Strategies to avoid gender-bias
 Encouraging equity in classrooms.
(Observe a moss ace in the video lecture that is made by 7 year old children. It was a 10/12 feet
moss ace; every student was given A4 size paper to draw different things. Every student draws
differently. You will observe that whole moss ace was made up of different components. In the
same way, society is made up of different components/people. All the components of the moss
ace were of the same size. Every student used the A4 size paper. They were same in the size but
the pattern of every component was different. So, we can say that children think differently, so
they came up with different designs. One thing more you will observe that the colouring of every
drawing is different. Some coloured the picture smoothly, while others have white spaces in their
drawing. So we can say that children of the same age may have different abilities).
Lessons learnt from the picture:
- The whole is made up of components
- Though components are of the same size but different in patterns and colours.
- Children think differently.
- Children vary in their colouring ability.
(Observe another picture in which the teacher is teaching the students some steps to do. This
picture is composed of different kinds of people. Try to identify diversity and multiplicity.)
Lesson learnt from the second picture:
Children vary in their:
- Height
- Colour
- Gender
- Responses
- Moods
- Dressing
50
- How can we expect them to think the same or perform same?
If there is such variation/diversity, how can we expect them to think the same or perform same?
When they are different, they are different in their height, colour, gender, dressing, moods etc. it
is definitely impossible to expect from them to perform alike. Being teachers, we need to know
this thing and we need to believe in diversity.
Educational Equity
Let’s discuss the purpose of schools in the view point of different educationists:
- Schools not only teach the students but also raise them. (Sausa,2003)
- What students are taught in schools affects the ways they will thereafter see and treat
others. (Schlesinger, 1993)
To learn the concept of equity, it is necessary to understand diversity first.

Equity means that all students are treated equally well and that all school resources are
shared equally. So, equity does not mean treating people equally by snubbing or scolding them.
But it means that we must treat them well. Similarly, sharing of resources is also necessary and it
must also be shared with every student.
Kinds of Diversity:
 Socioeconomic diversity
Socio means related to our society and economic means financially. So, socioeconomic
diversity is diversity in family income, parental education, parental occupation and social
status in the community.
 Physical diversity
Elements of physical diversity are:
- Age: children may vary in their ages.
- Physical attributes: children may vary physically i.e. in their height, weight, colour etc.
- Impairment and disabilities: some students may have weak eye sight; it means that they
have eye sight impairment. Some students are unable to walk appropriately or any other
impairment or disability. But being teachers, it is important for us to know that people are
different physically. Our full attention should not be to the students who are alike in some
51
way or the other but we must know that all students are not equal and provide them with
equal facilities in education. If we have some children who have physical impairments or
disabilities, then we really need to address their needs.
 Ability diversity
Ability diversity does not mean that some students have low IQ level or some have high
IQ level but it is also seem in the context of exceptionality. Something that is
exceptional. There are different definitions of exceptionality up to 27 categories of it. The
most important of them are:
Categories of exceptionality:
1. Intellectual
Being teachers, we assume that there is lot of intellectual diversity in our class. It is not
true because people have different experiences, IQ level is not much diverse. We say that
these students are of high IQ level and others are of low IQ level and we label the
students with the term ‘slow learners’. We accept that there is intellectual diversity, but
we need to know that how we are going to measure intellectual ability in our class.
2. Communicative
Communicative diversity means that students vary in communication skill as well. There
are some students who stemmer very fluently, but the teacher needs to know that the
students can’t do that. It is a responsibility of a teacher to some extent to do speech
therapy of the students. But it is not possible for a teacher in a great context. If a student
is feeling embraced in speaking while standing in the class then he should be allowed to
do written communication.
3. Sensory
Sensory diversity means that is related to your senses. There are some students, who
listen loud; some become threatened because of loud voice. We must know that there can
be sensory diversity in our class.
4. Behavioural
52
5. Physical
Physical diversity means that students vary physically i.e. in their height, weight, colour
etc. physical diversity also comes up with ability.
6. Multiple
In multiple diversity, dyslexia is included. It is a broader term, some students are more
dyslexic and some are less dyslexic. A common thing that is seen in dyslexic children
that some used to write ‘B’ instead of ‘D’ and some are confused with ‘P’ as ‘9’. If we
feel that these are the problems with students then we need to address these needs. If you
are teaching to grade 2 or grade 3, and students are doing such mistakes then it doesn’t
mean they are dyslexic. They are at their developmental stage. So information of right
and left brain is mixing up. This mixing can force them to do such mistakes. So it is
difficult to identify dyslexia before the age of 8 years. Being teachers we need to know
that there are certain children who have dyslexia.
Language diversity:
Every child has his own first language. Some have Punjabi as their first language, some have
Pashto, and some have balochi etc. then there comes a second language, some children learn
English as their second language while others learn it as a foreign language. So language
diversity is definitely present in our classrooms. If most of the books are written in a foreign
language then how it may be taught? Students are not able to understand science concepts; the
problem is that they do not understand the language in which those concepts are presented. To
teach the students language you need to be bilingual, (bilingual means that if you are teaching
them English and they know Urdu language, then you need to use both Urdu and English
language in class). The research says that this bilingual mood may be ineffective for young
children. So another model was presented. That is known as immersion model. It means that
you immerse the students in the new situation of language. This model says that if you are going
to teach the students Urdu language then you should not talk to them in their first language.
When you will use Urdu language in the class they will listen and try to speak in Urdu. As
Vygotsky says: “Language plays an important role in learning”. To know language diversity
is important and to address it is more important.
53
Strategies to integrate address language diversity:

1. Avoid forcing pupils to speak up immediately.
If you want to teach students a new language. Then you must not force them to get
immediately to that language. Give them time to think.
2. Give them some print material.

The second strategy that is used is to give them some written/print material. When a
child is going to learn a second language, then a child comprehends more on reading
material. So if you are providing them with reading material then actually you are
facilitating them to understand certain thing and also proving them with vocabulary.
3. Try to talk individually to the students.

There is language diversity in your class in terms of first language of the students and
their language ability. When you are addressing the class as a whole then probably
students are not going to develop their language ability. You must teach them on one to
one basis.
4. Start lesson with simple questions having ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer.

It doesn’t mean that students are learning only yes or no in the language but actually
when you are asking those questions, they are listening to the whole question and they are
focusing on its vocabulary. They will learn how to ask questions and secondly, they will
develop confidence in them.
5. If possible, use satisfactory or unsatisfactory grading.

Grade the students with satisfactory or unsatisfactory instead of ‘fail’ because the word
‘fail’ has a negative effect on the learning of the students. When children come up to a
certain level by improvement then use the grading by pass or fail or use the grades A, B
or C etc.
Gender diversity:
54
Gender diversity means difference in gender.

Gender Equity – Stereotypes:
1. Girls start speaking early than boys but later, boys become more sharp and intelligent.
2. Girls/women are gossipy.
3. Girls are less committed to carriers.
4. Girls perform poor in mathematics and science.
5. Girls lack in decision-making so they do not hold key positions in institutes, societies or
clubs.
Gender Equity – Research on the above stereotypes:

 A group of teachers and administrators in New Zealand were shown films of classroom
discussion and asked who was talking more, the teachers overwhelming response was
‘girls’. In reality, boys in the film ‘out talked’ girls at a ratio of 3:1.
 In a study, it was also shown that men speak more and fluently interrupt women.
 New scientist Magazine reports: ‘For the most part, the basic architecture of the brain,
and its fundamental workings were thought to be the same for both sexes.’
 Parts of frontal lobe, which houses decision making and problem solving, are
proportionally larger in women. (Research in Harvard Medical School)
Strategies to avoid gender-bias:

- Call on girls as often as you call boys.
- Pick those texts, pictures and movies which do not instill gender discrimination.
- Rotating responsibilities.
- Provide same learning opportunities to boys and girls.
Encouraging equity in classrooms:

- Observe carefully: If the student is performing a task, we must observe carefully about
his needs. We must identify his language diversity, physical ability and his behaviour.
- Set the tone: We say that teacher is a role model, he is promoting educational equity.
And others will learn from him.
- Involve others: you must involve others in learning. Unless you do not involve them
they will not feel the things. E.g. if you are working for the children who are visually
55
impaired, you will make enlarged photo copies for them and for this purpose you will
involve other people. They will also understand that it is to address the diverse needs.
- Promote autonomy: The more you make people independent; there will be more
educational equity. If you keep people dependent, it means that you are not promoting
equity.
- Organize support groups: If you are facing any issue of diversity, then you will find the
solution by support of other people.
- Celebrate learning: To celebrate different ideas and learning of the students and
appreciate them.
- Celebrate diversity: we have made uniform compulsory in the schools and expect that
the students will also be uniform in their thinking. But we need to celebrate diversity.
- Instill pride in workmanship: workmanship means that you must be competent in your
skill so that you can reach the level of excellence. So we have to take students towards
excellence with their diversity.
We are different beings, there is diversity. Being teachers, we need to celebrate diversity. So
that we can promote educational equity in our schools.
Comments:
 The term Dyslexia is used while explaining multiple diversity among people. But this
term is not explained clearly. Dyslexia means: Problems with reading, writing, spelling,
symbols and numbers, because the brain misinterprets what it sees (visual) and hears
(auditory). Dyslexia DOES NOT affect the intelligence of a person; in fact many
dyslexics are highly intelligent. Dyslexia is a disorder of the brain which causes the
person to have trouble reading and writing. Although the person is actually smart and can
comprehend basics, when it comes to reading, the letters look jumbled up and writing is
even worse. It is manageable and a lot of famous people have it and have gotten past it. If
someone has it they need help learning and eventually, they can overcome it.
CATEGORIES OF EXCEPTIONALITIES AND DEFINITIONS
56
BEHAVIOUR – A learning disorder characterized by specific behaviour problems over

such a period of time, and to such a marked degree, and of such a nature, as to adversely
affect educational performance, and that may be accompanied by one or more of the
Following: a) an inability to build or maintain interpersonal relationships; b) excessive
fears or anxieties; c) a tendency to compulsive reaction; or d) an inability to learn that
cannot be traced to intellectual, sensory, or other health factors, or any combination
thereof.
COMMUNICATION
Autism– a severe learning disorder that is characterized by” a) disturbances in rate of
educational development; ability to relate to the environment; mobility; perception;
speech and language; b) lack of the representational symbolic behaviour that precedes
language.
Deaf and Hard of Hearing – impairment characterized by deficits in language and
speech development because of a diminished or non-existent auditory response to sound.
Language Impairment – A learning disorder characterized by an impairment in

comprehension and/or use of verbal communication for the written or other symbol
system of communication, which may be associated with neurological, psychological,
physical, or sensory factors, and which may a) involve one or more of the form, content,
and function of language in communication; and b) include one or more of the following:
Language delay, disfluency, voice and articulation development, which may or may not
be organically or functionally based.
Speech Impairment – A disorder in language formulation that may be associated with

neurological, psychological, physical or sensory factors; that involves perceptual motor
aspects of transmitting oral messages; and that may be characterized by impairment in
articulation, rhythm, and stress.
INTELLECTUAL
57
Giftedness – An unusually advanced degree of general intellectual ability that required

differentiated learning experiences of a depth and breadth beyond those normally
provided in their regular school program to satisfy the level of educational potential
indicated.
Mild Intellectual Disability - A learning disorder characterized by: a) an ability to profit
educationally within a regular class with the aid of considerable curriculum modification
and supportive service; b) an ability to profit educationally within a regular class
Because of slow intellectual development; c) a potential for academic learning,
independent social adjustment, and economic self-support.
Developmental Disability – A severe learning disorder characterized by: a) an inability

to profit from a special education program for students with mild intellectual disabilities
because of slow intellectual develo0pment’ b) an ability to profit from a special education
program that is designed to accommodate slow intellectual development; c) a limited
potential for academic learning, independent social adjustment, and economic support.
PHYSICAL
Physical Disability – A condition of such severe physical limitation or deficiency as to
require special assistance in learning situation to provide the opportunity for educational
achievement equivalent to that of pupils without exceptionalities who are of the name and
age or developmental level.
Blind and Low Vision – A condition of partial or total impairment of sight or vision that
even with correction affects educational performance adversely.
MULTIPLE
Multiple Exceptionalities – A combination of learning disorders, impairments, or
physical disabilities, that is of such nature as to require, for educational achievement, the
services of one or more teachers holding qualification in special education and the
provision of support services appropriate for such disorders, impairments, or disabilities.
58
“Planning as a tool for successful instruction”

Lecture # 09
Lecture objectives:
 Reflected upon planning as a tool for successful instruction.
 Identified elements of planning
 Identified three domains of learning i.e. cognitive, psychomotor and affective.
Outline:
 Planning for successful instruction
 Key terms used in planning
- Goals
- Objectives
- Instructional objectives
- A strategy
 Is planning about decision making?
 Elements of planning
- Topic
- Grade level
- Goal
- Cognitive level check
- Students’ characteristics
- Resources
- Assignments or homework
- Assessments
- Additional learning needs
59
- Time allotted
 Domains of learning (CAP)
- Cognitive
- Affective
- Psychomotor
Planning for successful instruction:

- Why do we need to plan? Planning is important as there are three characteristics of
master teachers.
- Master teacher traits:
- They are well-organized in their planning.
- They communicate their instructional objectives effectively to the students.
- They have high expectations from their students.
- What to plan as a teacher?
- How to plan?
Key terms used in planning:

- Goals: Statement of intent stated in broad term. Goal of a teacher is “A teacher is
responsible to produce good citizen.” Can we produce good citizens in 40 or 45 minutes
lecture? Definitely no. but daily class lecture of 45 minutes can make a long time to
achieve a goal.
- Objectives: A series of small action steps which are needed to achieve desired goal.
These steps are not integrated, these are in series. When we talk about series, we could
not disturb the sequence of it. If any step is missed from it then ultimately we could not
achieve that goal.
- Instructional objectives: are those objectives which need to be achieved by the end
of the lesson.
- A strategy: to understand what strategy is, you need to know the difference between
method and a strategy; METHOD: To teach certain content to the students. Strategy: It
is method which helps to achieve your objective.
60
Is planning about decision making?

When a teacher is planning something, is he taking decisions or not? The process of planning is
very much decision making process. Firstly, a teacher decides what to teach? What students will
be able to do at the end of the lesson? Secondly, he has to decide what resources are required to
achieve certain goal? Which methods will be followed to teach certain content? You need to
decide which strategies to be followed to achieve the objectives? And most importantly, you
need to decide how much time will be given to a certain step in the lesson? You need to decide
which homework should be given to the students? You need to decide how to assess students?
So, the process of planning is a decision making process. These decisions are taken by the
teacher, if the teacher is not taking such decisions then ultimately, students are going to suffer.
Because students will not achieve anything in the class. The 40 or 45 minutes period will not
serve the purpose and this time is not maximizing students’ learning. All these decisions are the
part of decision making.
Elements of planning:
1. Topic: What teacher is going to teach?
2. Grade level: methods to teach sentence making to primary level students will be
different from secondary level students. So it is important for a teacher to know the grade
level.
3. Goal: the specific subject you are going to teach, you must know its ultimate purpose?
What you expect from the students to be able to? Whatever the goals you have selected
must be student-oriented.
4. Instructional objectives: are those objectives that will be achieved at the end of the
lesson. E.g. at the end of the lesson student will be able to label a diagram, or label four
parts of a plant etc. Instructional objectives provide you a guideline for selecting teaching
method, teaching strategy and resources also. Instructional objectives should be very
specific, measureable, attainable, realistic and timed.
5. Cognitive level check: being teachers, when we plan a lesson we also decide the strategy
by which we can know that what students have learnt till a certain period of time. It is
important for the teacher to know that what prior knowledge the students have. Teacher
use many strategies to check the cognitive level of the students. Some teachers use
61
questioning method, some teachers go for brainstorming. In brainstorming, a teacher

writes some words or questions in a circle and asks the students to response. Students
come up with different responses. Teacher does not omit anything, he writes the
responses of every student. It is beneficial for the teachers to check the cognitive level of
the students. It is also encouraging for the students that whatever they speak, teacher
writes on board. In higher classes, questioning is frequently used for this purpose. So, it is
important for the teacher to identify the strategy to check the cognitive level of the
students.
6. Students’ characteristics: Students have their own characteristics, there are students
who are very good in doing things or they are kinesthetic learners. Some students can
learn only by observing. Some students love to listen to their peers; they learn from their
peers, they are auditory learners. So, teachers need to know the characteristics of the
students. Students’ characteristics are the important elements of planning. It means that
we need to decide what we teachers are going to provide for auditory learners, visual
learners or kinesthetic learners.
7. Resources: It is important for the teacher to identify the resources that will be used in
teaching. E.g. board, activity sheets or multimedia, any other natural resources or
classroom resources etc. if you do not plan a lesson and identify resources then
ultimately, when you are in class you will be in trouble. Your students will talk a lot and
you might face discipline problem.
8. Assignments or homework: teacher has to plan what assignments he/she is going to
give to his/her students. What actually happen in our classes, we teach certain things and
ask the students to complete the whole exercise in the class, but most of the students are
unable to do so. Being a teacher, I will ask them to complete the rest of the questions at
home. Homework should be a pre-planned thing; it should not cover the things that
students are unable to do in the class. If students are unable to finish the exercise in class
then it is a teacher’s duty to help them complete the exercise in the next lesson. We
should not expect from parents to help their children learn new things. Teachers are
responsible to teach the new things to the students.
9. Assessments: we also need to decide that how we will assess the students. What we do is
only test the students through questioning. We try to assess every kind of learning
62
through questioning. But it is not possible. E.g. if we want to assess how good your
students are at sketching, you cannot ask certain questions from them. You ask a student
that what the procedure of sketching is. If a student tells you accurate answer it doesn’t
mean that he is able to make a sketch. So, you cannot assess the students through
questioning, different kind of learning requires different assessment strategy. So when we
plan a lesson we must also plan the assessment strategy. The criteria of assessment
should be based on the objectives.
10. Additional learning needs: there are students who have additional learning needs; there
are some students who have weak eye sight, so you need to plan accordingly. You have
to make the font of the worksheets larger. If you will not notice his eye sight, he will not
be able to work in the class, readability is not there. It is not the fault of the student but of
the resources. Whenever we are planning lessons, we need to take care of additional
learning needs.
11. Time allotted: It means that if at the start of the class, we are doing brainstorming in the
class then we should decide its time. Will it be for 5 minutes or 10 minutes? Or if we
want to have some written task in the class, you have to decide that a written task will be
for 20 minutes in the class. So you have to allocate time for every activity in the class.
Time allocation should be flexible. If you feel that students need more time on a certain
task, you can always give them some more time to that task. But there should be some
kind of time allocation while planning lesson.
So, we need to know the key elements of planning, because if we do not know elements of
planning then probably we will not be able to plan good lessons. Sometimes we miss very
important elements of a lesson plan.
Domains of learning:
1. Cognitive (Intellectual development)
2. Affective (Feelings/attitudes or holistic development and metacognition also comes
under this category)
3. Psychomotor (Procedural knowledge)
63
So, being teachers we need to know these three learning domains. For simplicity we
may say we need to give a CAP to each child in our class.
CAP: Cognitive, Affective and Psychomotor.
Have a look at the following and try to put these different kinds of learning under these three
domains:
Riding a bicycle, stitching, Essay writing, Speaking, Cooperating, Accommodating different
ideas, Respecting each other, Using dictionary, Memorizing facts, solving mathematics sums.
Cognitive domain:
Use of dictionary, Memorizing facts, Solving mathematics sums, Essay writing. These are all
intellectual skills. And they are important for the students and teachers and most of our teaching
and learning goes in this domain.
Affective domain:
Cooperating, Accommodating different ideas, respecting each other. It is important for every
single being, related to any profession. Or in spending the life these things are really important.
We are not living in isolation, we work with others and if we do not have life skills, we will not
be able to interact with each other. If we are not able to communicate appropriately with them,
our learning is deficient.
Psychomotor domain:
Riding a bicycle, Stitching. These are very skill oriented things where our motor muscles are
involved. So, anything which involves our motor muscles is called as psychomotor domain.
Whatever we do, in all physical activities our mind is always working. This is the domain which
involves physical and mental work.
Comments:
 The term ‘Master Teacher’ is actually a teacher who has expertise on his subject and he
ensures the quality learning of the students.
64
 Kinesthetic learning (also known as tactile learning) is a learning style in

which learning takes place by the student carrying out a physical activity, rather than
listening to a lecture or watching a demonstration. People with a kinesthetic learning style
are also commonly known as "do-ers".
“Bloom’s Taxonomy”
Lecture # 10
Lecture objectives:
By the end of the lecture, you will have:
 Reflected upon 6 levels of Bloom’s Taxonomy of cognitive domain
 Come up with examples of learning at different levels of Bloom’s Taxonomy.
Outline:
 Bloom’s taxonomy
 Knowledge level learning
 Comprehension level learning
 Application level learning
 Analysis level
 Synthesis level
 Evaluation level
First, you have to understand what Bloom’s Taxonomy actually is? Here are 6 different types of
learnings below, try to identify the common thing in it.
 Recalling key names of Pakistan movement
 Defining noun
 Defining solubility
 Telling counting 1 – 20
 Naming 7 continents
 To tell Newton’s third law of motion
65
In all the above, the child has cram the things that he tells. It does not involve high level thinking
skill. These are the facts or principles that he has memorized by learning. If you ask a student
any definition and he is using the same words as in the book, there is no thinking involved. He is
telling what he has memorized. This level of learning in Bloom’s Taxonomy is called
“Knowledge level.”
Bloom’s Taxonomy:
Bloom was an educationist; he has a lot of contributions in learning. In identifying different
levels of learning. In 1956, he developed his taxonomy but after 55 years, no learning objectives
are forms without following his taxonomy. The word ‘Taxonomy’ shows classification. He says
that learning can take place at 6 different levels and these levels are hierarchical. So, the first
level of Bloom’s Taxonomy was knowledge level or recall level, where actually students recall
their knowledge. It is not about a new thing but what they have memorized, they recall it.
Knowledge level:
- It is about recalling of information.
- It is about knowledge of data, events and places.
- Knowledge of major ideas.
- Mastery of subject matter.
According to Bloom, this is the lowest level of learning. In schools we mostly focus on
testing of this level. A book is given to students by name of ‘General knowledge.’ It contains
facts and figures and we say to the students to memorize it. So, we do not deny the
importance of questions of knowledge level but teachers tend to over use it, and the student
who is not good at memorizing, does suffer.
Question cues:
Following are the words which indicate that the question is of knowledge level.
- List
- Define
- Tell
- Describe
66
- Identify
- Show
- Label
- Who, When, Where.
Comprehension:
Again here are some questions, try to identify the common in them.
 Describe two nation theory?
 State the differences between human eye and camera?
 What are functions of plant, root and stem?
 What did Goldilock do, when she went to bear’s house?
 What are our rights and responsibilities as Pakistani citizens?
The common thing in all the above is that the students are provided with the information about
certain things first, either the information is provided by the teacher or they are getting that from
the books or may be from any other source. And now they are asked to reproduce the given
information in their own words. If students do not use their own words, how can we know if
students have understood a certain concept or not? This is the level of understanding and in this
level, we expect from the students to use their own words. E.g. the translation from Urdu to
English or English to Urdu also comes in the comprehension level because we can check the
understanding of the students. If words are translated one by one then it is not a comprehension
level, comprehension level expects the students to read the text carefully, understand it and then
translate it into a new language.
(In knowledge level, we do not expect from the students to use their own words while explaining
anything. But in comprehension, first students get certain information and then something is
expected from them.)
Comprehension level:
Words often found in comprehension level questions:
- Describe
67
- Rephrase
- Put in your own words
- Contrast
- Explain the main idea
- - Compare
Application level:
Again here are certain questions; you are going to identify common things in these questions:
 Classify the following materials in transparent, translucent and opaque objects.
 Classify the given foods into vegetables, fruits and meat group.
 Use the formula.
Breadth x Length = Area (to find out area of your geometry box).
Children have learnt about transparent, translucent and opaque objects, teacher told them that the
objects through which light could not pass are opaque objects. The objects through which the
light can pass are transparent objects and the object which allows some light to pass through is
translucent object. A child has learnt these things, if he tells the teacher as it is then it is
knowledge level. If he tells by using his own words then it is comprehension level. But to use the
knowledge in a new situation is application level. Now you give five things to the students to
identify these three kinds of objects. These are: Cellophane sheet, paper, table, book, and wall.
Now, if the students are able to identify that what are opaque, transparent and translucent objects
then they are acquiring application level.
In second question, children are told about the food groups and then they are given different
examples of fruits, vegetables and meat and they are ask to classify them. If the children know
the exact difference between fruits and vegetables, then they will apply their knowledge and can
classify them. If he does not know then the child is not able to classify food items.
In third question, there is a formula to find area. If the students are asked to tell the formula to
find out the area, then it is knowledge level. The child knows the formula. But the teacher is
saying, children know the formula but it is not enough they must know how to calculate the area,
so he ass them to calculate the area of their geometry box. It is application level of learning. Only
knowing is not important but to apply it in a new situation.
68
Application level:
Words often found in application level questions:
- Apply
- Show
- Demonstrate
- Choose
- Illustrate
- Classify
- Use
- Write an example
- Draw diagram
- Observe and record
The three levels discussed above are usually called as lower levels of learning. Students feel
difficulty in mathematics because there is application level in it. But educationists say that
application level learning is also a lower level of learning. It is although advance from
knowledge and comprehension level but it is not so advance learning.
Analysis level:
1. What factors did influence Quaid-e-Azam to formulate fourteen points?
2. Why do we need balanced diet?
3. The footprints left by the astronauts, Neil Armstrong and Edwin Aldrin, on the
moon in 1969 are still there. Can you explain why?
4. After studying about developments in Malaysia, what can you conclude about the
various causes of developments in a country?
In the first three questions, we are asking about the reasons. The reason why Quaid-e-Azam
formulate fourteen points? The reason why balanced diet is important? The reason why the
footprints are still on the moon? But in the fourth question, reason is not asked. Here you are
asked to conclude after seeing the causes of development in Malaysia.
After reading this story how would you categorize the hero’s background?
69
Again here will be some conclusions about how the hero’s background influences him.
5. Vaccination cures body against various diseases. How?
6. Why do fish survive better in cool water?
7. Human beings are polluting air. How?
The above three questions are results. E.g. we all know that vaccination cures body against
diseases, but the students have to analyze its reasons. It is different from the first three
questions in the sense that in them you were asked to identify reasons and conclusions were
not given. And in last three questions, conclusions are given and students were asked to give
reasons to these conclusions. It is said that analysis is a higher level thinking. When we talk
about analysis, there is not one kind of analysis. It is said that analysis is about identifying
causes. There are causes but conclusions are also important and the reasons for those
conclusions. So, all these go to the analysis level.
Defining analysis level:

“Analysis level questions are higher-order questions that require students to think critically
and in depth. Several answers are possible to an analysis-question. Analysis-questions expect
from students to identify reasons, reach conclusions and analyze conclusions.”
To analyze means to set things apart. E.g. if you teach students about addition, subtraction,
multiplication and then division. And while teaching division, you ask them what
mathematical operations are involved in division? It is analysis level question, in which the
students will tell that both multiplication and subtraction are involved in division.
Word prompts used in analysis level:

- Identify motives
- Why
- Compare/ Contrast
- Draw conclusions
- How
- Investigate
- Analyze
70
- Summarize
- Deduce
- Support
Synthesis level:
1. Write an appropriate title for the text.
2. Draw a painting to show that pollution is a burning issue.
Here again we are expecting from the child that he will do something on his own. If you have
30 students in the class, you might get 30 different titles to the text. There will not be a single
title that you may say is wrong. Because if the title is related to the text then all the titles are
acceptable. This level is of the level of creativity. Similarly, in second question, each students
will come up with the different idea about pollution is a burning issue. There is not a single
right answer,
3. What would happen to our city in next 5 years if steps are not taken to stop air
pollution?
4. What would happen to raw milk if it is put in iron containers for a long time?
5. What will happen if stomach does not produce hydrochloric acid?
There is higher level of thinking involved in all the questions given at synthesis level. In the
first two questions, we asked the students to create something, weather it is a title of the text
or a painting. The next three questions are on prediction. The child is thinking about what
will happen to our city, if air pollution is not stopped? Or what will happen to milk, if it is put
in an iron container? Etc.
6. Summarize the story including its main idea.
How this summary is different from comprehension and analysis. It is because you ask the
students to write the overall summary including the main idea. So students are going to create
certain things. Now this question is also related to the first two, in which there is creativity of
the students.
7. How can a government solve a problem of narcotics?
71
8. Design an experiment to prove that light rays travel in straight lines?

9. How can we solve the problem of indoor and outdoor air pollution?
10. How can we remove energy crisis in Pakistan?
All these questions are related to problem solving, weather they are about suggestions, or
making designs etc. all students can never give the same solution to these problems. It is the
beauty of synthesis level that every student comes up with his own thinking. Important thing
in synthesis level is that students solve problems, predict future happenings and at the same
time they create certain things. It has a distinction with analysis level that analysis level says
to set apart the things and in synthesis level, things are put together. If you say the students to
solve a problem, the students will firstly analyze the problem and then solve it. Do
remember, problem solving is there in mathematics too, there is only a single right answer in
it while in synthesis you can have more than one right answer.
Word prompts used in synthesis level:

- Predict
- Construct
- How can we improve?
- Produce
- Invent
- Imagine
- Create
- What would happen if…?
- Design
- Can you devise..?
- Synthesize
- How can we solve?
Evaluation level:
1. Which Prime Minister of Pakistan was most successful? Why?
72
2. Discuss that we are not good citizens?

3. Do you agree that more finances would help to raise the literacy rate in Pakistan?
4. Prove that smoking is harmful?
5. Discuss that pollution is individual, national as well as global issue?
We need to teach our students how to argue? In first question, the student who has more
logical answer and can argue on it with others is the best one. If they do not develop the habit
to argue, then their higher order thinking skill will not be developed.in second question, we
say to the students that it is not a conclusion; it is an argument that we are not good citizens
and students have to discuss it. It is not a proven thing; it is different from analysis level. In
analysis we give conclusion and then students have to analyze that conclusion. But
evaluation level is different; here is an opinion on which you are going to generate a
discussion on opinions or on the basis of arguments. There are opinions in the rest of the
questions as well and we expect the students to discuss them and generate arguments.
Word prompts used in evaluation level:

- Judge
- Verify
- Give your opinion…?
- Do you agree
- Assess
- Would it be better..?
- Conclude
- Argue
- Evaluate
73
“Affective and psychomotor domain”

Lecture # 11
Lecture objectives:
 Revised Bloom’s taxonomy of Cognitive Domain
 Reflected upon Simpson’s taxonomy of Psychomotor Domain
 Reflected upon 5 levels of Krathwohl and Bloom’s taxonomy of Affected Domain.
 Reflected upon the use of taxonomies as a planning tool.
Outline:
 Bloom’s Taxonomy
 Psychomotor Domain
 Hierarchical levels of Simpson’s psychomotor domain
- Perception
- Set
- Guided Response
- Mechanism
- Complex overt response
- Adaptation
- Origination
 Affective Domain
 Hierarchical levels of Bloom’s and Krathwohl’s taxonomy of affective domain
- Receiving
- Responding
- Valuing
- Organization
- Characterization
74
 Using taxonomies as planning tools

Taxonomies may be used to:
- Formulate and sequence objectives
- Develop classroom questions and activities
- Constructing evaluating material
- Taxonomies provide a cognitive structure
Bloom’s taxonomy:
There are 6 levels of Bloom’s taxonomy of cognitive domain. Knowledge is the first level, then
comprehension, and then application. These three levels are categorized as lower level of
learning. The next three levels, i.e. analysis, synthesis and evaluation are categorized as the
higher level of learning. Bloom’s taxonomy is still teached to the students but there are many
adaptations of it. One of these is: the three levels, which are knowledge, comprehension and
application, are in hierarchy but the other levels: analysis, synthesis and evaluation are not
hierarchical. It is difficult to say which level is higher than the other. So, in a new adaptation,
these three levels are not placed at hierarchy but said that these are the higher order thinking
skills.
What we do in schools, we never focus on the higher level of learning. There are few teachers
who take their students to the level of higher level thinking. Mostly, what happens in schools is
that we are asked to memorize things. In mathematics, we are asked to apply learnt formulas and
solve problems. Analysis, synthesis and evaluation are never taken into consideration. We
teachers maximum want to make our tasks easier, so if all students will right the same answer,
copy checking will be easy for us. This is a major reason why teachers do not allow the students
to work on the higher level learning skills. But being a good teacher, my focus must be on
students learning and not on the easiness of us. We must take the students towards their
intellectual growth. Intellectual growth cannot take place unless we do not provide opportunities
to our students to think at high level.
“Psychomotor Domain”
Psychomotor domain is the domain where your body movements are involved. There is learning
also, if we are drawing a painting or writing something, our muscles are involved in it. Some
75
students are very good at writing but others are not, because we do not provide opportunities to
them so that they can learn in this domain.
Hierarchical levels of Simpson’s Psychomotor Domain:

1. Perception
2. Set
3. Guided Response
4. Mechanism
5. Complex overt Response
6. Adaptation
7. Origination
1. Perception:
Perception means attending to a stimulus. There is something happening in your
surrounding, and you are noticing that stimulus. E.g. if you are listening, it means that
you are actually attending to that stimulus. This is a very theoretical level because a
child is not applying knowledge. Simpson identified this level because a child first
see and then starts his body movement. E.g. if I want to learn to drive a car, I will
notice someone else driving, or I will ask someone how to drive? I will actually
attend to that stimulus by listening.
2. Set:
Set is a readiness for action. You show willingness to do a particular task. A child is
understanding and comprehending and also trying to demonstrate it in some way. E.g.
in a house, if there are people who are interested in studying, a child will notice them.
If his father is reading newspaper, he will notice him (Perception stage). He will try to
imitate, although he could not read the newspaper but he is trying to read. There is a
level in between perception and imitation that he takes the book or newspaper in his
hands. There is no action at this level but the readiness to do an action.
76
In the first two levels of Simpson’s hierarchy, you will notice that there is no physical
activity involved. But only the understanding of physical activity.
3. Guided Response/ Imitation:

The word ‘guided’ indicate something, a child is responding in the form of action but
this action is not an independent action. This action is a guided action. E.g. when a
child starts writing alphabets, he could not write them by himself. Sometimes a
teacher had to hold a child’s hand to teach him how to write alphabets in the
beginning. Unless you do not provide a child with guided response, he could not work
independently. So, this is a guided response where a child imitates, tries to perform an
action, may be in a very new way.
4. Mechanism:
There are different mechanics to do different things. Mechanism indicates that a child
is independent to do a task by following its mechanics. A child may not be able to
perform a task independently unless we are not providing that particular opportunity
to him.
5. Complex overt response:

Word ‘complex’ shows that here the child can do many things independently. In
mechanism, a child is independent to do a certain task by following its mechanics, but
in complex response, a child can work independently. He will work very smoothly
and swiftly to perform a particular task. E.g. a child can write alphabets by following
its mechanics independently, but in complex response, a child must be able to write
alphabets in joining writing very speedily and smoothly. Small children write words
in joining writing very slowly, because there is no complex response. To take a child
to complex response, we need to provide them with practicing. If we do not provide
them with practice they can never reach the complex response. As a result, children
may keep growing in age but they are unable to write quickly.
77
6. Adaptation:
Adaptation comes from the word ‘Adapt’ which means to set yourself in the given
situation. Altering motor activities to meet demands of problematic situations.
7. Origination:
Origination means something very original. This is the level where a child can
originate things on his own. He can create many things. If he is able to write at
mechanics level. Then he is able to write joining writing in complex response. He can
make changes in what he writes at the adaptation level. And now here in origination
level, e.g. if he knows calligraphy, he can create new style of calligraphy. This is the
highest level of Simpson’s hierarchy.
“Affective Domain”
Hierarchy of affective domain was developed by Bloom and Krathwohl in 1964. Affective
domain is about developing certain attitudes and dispositions. They both identified 5 levels that
are important in the learning of affective domain.
Hierarchical levels of Bloom’s and Krathwohl’s taxonomy:

1. Receiving
2. Responding
3. Valuing
4. Organization
5. Characterization
1. Receiving:
Being aware of or sensitive to the existence of certain ideas, material or phenomena and
being willing to tolerate them. E.g. a teacher told the students about balance diet and that
they should avoid junk food. It means that you have received this information from your
teacher. So, at this level you do not show anything rather you just receive that
information.
78
1. Responding:
When the teacher is telling you that you must take balanced diet, you need to develop a
healthy life style. So, what you will discuss with the teacher that why it is important to
have balanced diet? What are its benefits? Etc. will show that you have not only received
the information rather you are responding to that information through your discussion or
questioning.
2. Valuing:
Valuing means that the disposition or learning you are talking about, you must value that
disposition. You must value by showing certain action. E.g. if your students in a class are
taking lunch. Some students bring home make lunch while others are taking junk foods.
So you need to show them and appreciate those students who are taking home made
lunch. It means that you are practically applying and demonstrating that thing that you
value balanced diet and not the junk food.
3. Organization:
This is an advanced level. E.g. we know that honesty is the best policy. First we listen
from someone that honesty is a good thing, we discuss it with others as well. If we find a
person who is honest, we will appreciate him a lot. But now in organization level, you
need to develop honesty in your own. You try to be very honest and try to show honesty
in your behaviour also. Similarly, as we talk about balanced diet, if a teacher is
appreciating students on balanced diet then it means that he values healthy food. But if he
himself starts avoiding junk food and start taking healthy food then he has organized
himself and now he will prefer eating healthy food instead of junk food.
4. Characterization:
Characterization is different from organization. In organization, you start showing that
behaviour but that is not a consistent behavior. Characterization means that this
behaviour becomes the part of your life. You are recognized by this character. This is the
highest level of Bloom’s taxonomy of affective domain.
79
All these taxonomies are the learning tools. We all are planners. When we talk about elements of
planning, there is a selection of objectives, selection of activities, selection of resources etc. All
these selections depend upon your knowledge of these taxonomies.
“Using taxonomies as planning tools”
Taxonomy may be used to:
- Formulate and sequence objectives: When you are deciding your lesson objectives, you
need to decide that which objective needs to be set first and which objective needs to set
next. E.g. if I want the students to be at synthesis level, I must take students to the initial
level first and then to take them to the synthesis level. Sequencing is also important. We
must know that we have to take the students stage by stage in learning. So we must know
the taxonomies to create that sequence in learning.
- Develop classroom questions and activities: we take many questions into consideration
while studying about taxonomy of cognitive domain, but if we do not know about the
taxonomies then may be we will be asking knowledge level questions in the class very
much. But if we have knowledge of these taxonomies then we will try to ask higher level
questions in the class. Activities must also be planned according to the taxonomies or
according to the objectives set under those taxonomies.
- Constructing evaluating materials: how we can assess the students as well as our
teaching. We need evaluation instruments to assess students and teaching. Evaluation
instruments will always be developed when we have knowledge about these taxonomies.
E.g. if I want to evaluate the students in their sketching then I must know the taxonomies,
if I have decided to assess the students at mechanism level, then I must be having a
different check list to assess them. But if I want to assess them at origination level, then
my check list will be totally different. So if I do not know about the taxonomies, then I
80
will assess them as weather they have sketched something or not? Taxonomies are
important to learn because we will know the level of students learning.
- “Taxonomies may be used to decide what to teach, how to teach and how to evaluate
teaching.” (Marzano, Pickering, and Pollock 2001)
- Research shows that learning do not take place if presented in isolated items (Hohn
1995)
- Taxonomies provide a cognitive structure.

Here are two important things mentioned that learning cannot take place in isolation and
taxonomies give a cognitive structure.
There are some students who are studying grade level 6 but still they do not know the
basic mathematics, and now they are learning algebra. So, when we are trying to teach
them algebra, we do not identify the gaps. We try to give them a new learning. Unless
they do not learn their missing knowledge, we cannot teach them new things. We must
know assess them on their missing knowledge but we must try to identify the diagnostic
factors.
In most of the schools, English learning is done in isolation. Some idioms are taught,
some vocabulary or essay writing and other things are said to be memorized. So, as a
result, we are unable to write an argumentative essay in our graduation exams. If we have
knowledge of different taxonomies of learning, then at least we are going to provide
things in integrated way to our students. We can take the students into cognitive structure.
We cannot teach the students in isolation. We need to teach them in an integrated fashion.
These leaning domains see the things in sequence. They can relate things with each other.
If being teachers, we do not know about the taxonomies then we are making students
learn in bits and parts.
81
“Performance objectives”
Lecture # 12
Lecture objectives:
 Differentiated between measureable and non-measureable objectives.
 Identified three necessary elements of performance objectives i.e. performance
statement, condition and criterion measure.
 Reflected upon curriculum alignment as a rationale for performance objectives.
 Reflected upon limitations of objectives.
Outline:
 Performance objectives
- Objectives
 Elements of performance objectives
- Performance
- Condition
- Criterion measure
 Limitations of performance objectives
 Assumptions of performance objectives
 Curriculum alignment
(Before we look at performance objectives, Look at the following objectives and reflect upon
them if they are clear)
- The learners will draw a right angle triangle. (Not clear)
- The learners will use verbs in sentences. (Not clear)
- The learners will write a letter. (Clear to some extent)
82
- The learners will identify differences between Pakistan Constitution 1973 and
1956. (Clear)
- The learners will locate countries on world map. (Clear)
- The learners will draw and label human digestive system. (Clear)
(According to today’s lecture none of the above is clear objectives. You will come to know by
the end of the lesson, why?)
“Performance objectives”
Objectives:
Objectives are intent of teaching.
“The purpose of objective is to communicate the exact intent of a lesson.”
Performance objectives:
“They are precise statements of what you expect students to do.”
Precise statement means an exact statement which tells the teacher, what students will be able to
do. Here are three characteristics of performance objectives:
1. Performance
2. Condition
3. Criterion measure
Writing performance objectives:

They have 3 elements:
1. Performance: The statement of an observable behaviour, or performance, on the part of

the learner. They are stated with action verb.
(Here are two things to be taken into consideration. Firstly, these objectives must be student-
oriented and secondly, they should be precise. Action words are: write, classify etc. So,
83
whenever we are going to write performance objectives, we need to ensure that we use action
word to describe the performance).
2. Condition: Condition is a description of the conditions under which learner’s

performance is to occur. They determine how, when, where and with what of
performance.
3. Criterion measure: The prescription of a minimally acceptable level of performance or
criterion, on the part of the learner.
(Now we are going to compare the objectives discussed at the start of the lesson with those of
performance objectives.)
Differences between measureable and non- measureable objectives:

Look at the following objectives and reflect Performance objectives:
upon them if they are clear: ‘By the end of the lesson’:
- The learners will draw a right angle - The learners will draw a right angle
triangle. triangle with a protector meeting ratio
3, 4, 5
- The learners will write a letter. - The learners will write a (200- 250)
words letter with an appropriate format
to a friend independently.
- The learners will identify differences - The learners will identify at least 5
between Pakistan Constitution 1973 differences between Pakistan
and 1956. Constitution 1973 and 1956 by using
the textbook.
- The learners will locate countries on - The learners will locate any country on
world map. world map when latitude and longitude
values are given.
- The learners will draw and human - The learners will draw and label
digestive system label. accurately at least 5 parts in human
digestive system independently.
84
In all the above performance objectives, there are the three elements present i.e. performance,
condition and criterion. Performance objectives are the precise statements of our expectations.
Limitations of performance objectives:

- Objectives have a limited purpose; they are only a means to an end, not an end
themselves.
- Teachers can construct technically correct objectives but can fail completely in
classroom.
Assumptions of performance objectives:
1. Learning is change in behaviour. The second name of performance objectives is

behavioural objectives. While writing performance objectives, we have to use an action
word that exactly shows the behaviour. If we are seeing learning in behavioural forms
then it is not true that learning is change in behaviour. It can be an assumption because it
is said to be the limitation of performance objectives.
2. Learning can be measured. While writing performance objectives, we focus on the

action word because we can exactly measure that the learning has taken place or not? So,
we believe that learning can be measured. E.g. if a child is listening to a very good
discussion, but he did not utter even a single word. Its means that we are not measuring
the learning. To write performance objectives is necessary, especially when we are going
to start teaching. This is not true that if the learning cannot be measured then there is no
learning. If someone is reading a book, his learning is not measured, but you need to
appreciate him to do such activities. Though being a teacher, I am not able to measure
that.
3. Observed learning outcome is directly linked to the teaching strategy, the content or
media used. Here we assume that whatever a student is learning, actually that all depends
85
upon teacher’s teaching. The content that is going to be taught, the resources that are used
and the teaching strategy. We totally deny other factors that what is the prior knowledge
of the students. What is his background or how many siblings he had? All these things
have effect on students’ learning. While writing performance objectives, we eliminate all
these factors and assume that all learning depend upon the teaching strategy, teaching
content and the teaching resources. So, we started seeing classrooms in isolation.
Curriculum Alignment:
Firstly, we are going to have a look on the foundations of curriculum:
There are four steps in Taylor’s model of curriculum:
1. What is the purpose of the education?
2. Which educational experiences will attain the purposes?
3. How can these experiences be effectively organized?
4. How can we determine when the purposes are met?
Whenever we are going to write performance objectives, they must be aligned with the
curriculum. If your purpose of education is that the students should be empowered citizens. So,
the entire objective that you will construct, affective domain will be very important. You will
include something from affective domain in your lessons. So, we need to align our performance
objectives with the curriculum. Curriculum at different levels; curriculum of the year i.e. short
term goals, and to the broader goals that are school goals. Whenever we talk about curriculum
alignment, we need to align our performance objectives on these two levels.
It is important for the broader curriculum to identify educational experiences; similarly, it is also
important that what educational objectives will be attained at the end of a lesson. Relevant
educational experiences are important.
When we are planning a lesson, and we have performance objectives mentioned already, then we
have to organize those educational experiences that can fulfill the ultimate goal. You have to
provide the students with experiences. E.g. if you want the students to have experience of
recording something in the lawn. Then firstly, you will ask them to go in the lawn and observe.
You cannot give them the experience of recording directly, unless they do not observe the things.
You will organize the experience in such a way that you will ask them to first observe and then
record.
86
There is assessment in the fourth question, that is, have you attained those goals or not?
Whatever you want to assess, that must be against your performance objectives. In performance
objectives, all the three elements must be present and you should assess your students according
to those three elements.
“Levels of planning”
Lecture # 13
Lecture Objectives:
 Identified levels of planning.
 Reflected upon the scope of yearly, unit, and lesson planning.
 Determine link between different levels of planning.
Outline:
 Planning
- Horizontal dimension of planning
- Vertical dimension of planning
 Planning framework
 Components of planning
- Holistic vision
- Detailed implementation
 Instructional vs curriculum planning
 Link between formal curriculum and classroom
Planning:
Planning is essentially a nested process with horizontal and vertical dimensions.
If a teacher is going to teach in the class without planning a lesson, then he is not a part of
process of teaching. As a result, he can not teach appropriately in the class.
Horizontal dimension of planning:
87
In horizontal level, planning includes selection of activities, resources, assessment and

homework.
Vertical dimension of planning:

In vertical level, it includes link between standards, benchmarks, learning outcomes and
instructional objectives.
Planning framework:
L P Term Unit Lesson Plan

O L PLAN Plan
N A
G N Lesson Plan
N Unit
I Plan
TER
T N M Lesson Plan
E G PLAN Unit
R Plan
M
Lesson Plan
TER
Unit
M
Plan Lesson Plan
PLAN
Here in the figure, you can see that if we start from school’s yearly planning, there is written
‘Long term Planning’ that is a planning of one year of a school. Teacher is more related to long
term planning. The next is ‘Term Plan’, in some schools there are two terms while others have
three terms. So, you have to plan about every term separately. If we take one term plan into
consideration, then it will be consisted of all units of the subject. E.g. if you have to teach 10
units of a subject, then you have to make 10 unit plans. Every unit plan will consist of a number
of lesson plans. To achieve the learning outcomes of every unit, we have to construct some
instructional objectives. This planning framework is very important for the teachers to
88
understand, because teacher is directly involved in this kind of framework. Teacher is a person
who is making lesson plan, unit plan and term plan. Only long term plan is related to the
curriculum, the else is the responsibility of a teacher.
Why to write instructional objectives:

Good planning has two components:
- Holistic vision
- Detailed implementation
Holistic vision comes from curriculum planning while detailed implementation comes from
lesson planning. There are standards and benchmarks in curriculum document e.g. a student
will come up to certain standard after 12 years or after one year a student will achieve these
benchmarks. Your lesson plan makes visible those benchmarks.
What are the commonalities in instructional and curriculum planning?
Instructional vs Curriculum Planning:

Instructional planning Curriculum Planning
Identifying pupil’s needs Identifying societal needs
Writing and sequencing objectives Writing standards and benchmarks in a
sequence
Selecting methods/ strategies Benchmarks in sequence
Assessment procedures Assessment
Resources Resources
- Curriculum planning is done on the basis of needs of the society. There are three
foundations of curriculum: sociological, philosophical and psychological. So, your
societal needs are identified and on the basis of those needs curriculum is developed.
While in instructional planning, the needs are identified but these needs are of the
students. Firstly, the teachers identify students’ needs and then plan a lesson. Teacher
needs to differentiate a lesson in a way that he addresses pupil’s needs.
89
- Benchmarks and standards are written in a sequence in curriculum planning. E.g. there
are benchmarks of grade level 8th or 9th or 10th etc. benchmarks and standards are planned
according to the grade level of students. While in instructional planning we write
objectives. The instructional objectives must be derived from the standards and
benchmarks of curriculum. There should be a link between standards, benchmarks and
instructional objectives.
- Methods are also identified in instructional planning. We made sequence of those

methods or strategies to be used in the class. While in curriculum planning, we made
sequence of benchmarks.
- In curriculum planning, assessment is taken into consideration, it is thought, how to

assess the students that which standard is achieved and which is not? Or students reached
the level of benchmarks or not? Similarly, in class, the teacher identifies the assessment
procedures. Firstly, the teacher identifies assessment criteria. Secondly, he decides how
to assess. So, in both cases, the decision of assessment is taken.
- Decisions about resources are taken at both levels. In curriculum planning, you take
decision at broader level i.e. in twelve years, how many and what resources will be used
for a student? But at lesson planning, you decide what resources are needed to acquire a
particular objective.
So, planning is definitely a nested process, starting from curriculum to instructional planning.
There are number of things which are interlinked and whenever we are going to plan for a single
lesson, we need to look at the bigger picture.
(Here is a curriculum document in which there are different competencies of English.
These are reading competency, writing competency, listening competency and speaking
competency. In this document there are standards till grade level 12th. I have picked only
one standard from them for your understanding. Then one benchmark from grade level 1
& 2. And then learning outcomes from the same grade.)
90
Link between formal curriculum and classroom:
English
Competency: Reading & thinking skill
Standard:
“To discover and understand a variety of text types through tasks which require multiple
reading and thinking strategies for comprehension, fluency and enjoyment.”
If being teacher, I could not understand this standard, and then ultimately, my lesson plan would
suffer. So, if we say that a child is given with different texts of reading, then he could
differentiate them, understand and discover them as different reading texts. E.g. if you are
reading a newspaper, there is reporting in it, news or articles. It has a different text type then of
an essay. Or you are reading a narrative story; its text type would be different from that of a
newspaper. So, according to the curriculum document of grade level 12th, the first thing is that
students should be able to discover and understand different text types.
Multiple reading and thinking strategy means that students should know to comprehend a
complex task to a certain level. Or if there is a simple text, a student may read it and scan that
what was important in the text. So, a student must not only explore the multiple text types and
understand them but he should develop some reading strategies in himself. The strategies that are
related to comprehension and fluency. There are some students who are very fluent readers, but
others are not. So, we have to observe students that how they make fluency in their reading
through different ways. There is another important thing i.e. enjoyment. How students can
enjoy the reading and thinking. The standard is not only to know reading or you can think deeply
but you can read to the certain level where you can put questions, comprehend it, be fluent in
reading and also enjoy it thoroughly.
91
Benchmarks for grade level 1 & 2:

“Students recognize words and sentences as meaningful units of expression and paragraphs
as graphical units of expression.”
The important thing in this benchmark is that the student is able to know the difference between
a sentence and a paragraph. He must know that if he is going to say one thing, then it must be
used in a sentence. And if he wants to say more than one, then he should know that this thing
will go in a paragraph. So, paragraph is an expression of more than one thing that is in a same
context.
Learning outcomes:
Students should be able to:
1. Predict story by looking at picture (s) in texts.
2. Locate specific factual information to answer in a word or two or in simple
sentences.
3. Guess what follows in the story
4. Follow sequence in a simple procedure.
5. Express likes/ dislikes about the story.
6. Express understanding of story through simple role play.
(Now I have taken the first learning outcome and make possible instructional objectives. These
objectives must be attained after the lesson.)
1. Predict story by looking at picture(s) in texts.
Instructional objectives:
By the end of the lesson, the students will be able to:
- Describe first four pictures of Goldilock story with almost 70% accuracy by using
the picture cues.
- Read the sentences aloud with correct pronunciation of the words, with teacher’s
assistance.
The next day when teacher continues with the same lesson, his instructional objectives would be:
92
By the end of the lesson, the students will be able to:

- Answer simple question like was Goldilock a good girl? Whatever she did was that a
good thing?
When teacher will ask such questions in the class, then definitely the students’ analysis skill will
be developed and refined. All the above objectives have the three elements of performance
objectives i.e. performance, condition and criterion measure.
Summary:
Planning is a nested process. So, if we talk about grade level 1 to grade level 12, these are the
twelve stairs and a link should be maintained between them. Otherwise, if we are not able to
maintain this link, then its ultimate would be that teachers and students would be confused. And
after doing graduation even, our children will not be able to read, think or write accurately. So,
teachers’ responsibility starts from the benchmarks. If you are a mathematics teacher, you need
to have a curriculum document of mathematics. There are learning outcomes for unit plans given
in it. Observe the learning outcomes, and on the basis of these outcomes, try to identify
objectives for all possible lesson plans. When objectives are identified, then you start horizontal
planning. In horizontal planning, you have to decide which activities will be organized for the
students? What teaching methods will be used? What resources should be used? You have to
identify the focusing events i.e. how you will make the students attentive to you? Then you have
to identify the procedure of teaching in the class step by step. If you do not write all the above
mentioned things in your lesson plan, then it is not a detailed lesson plan. The next thing in
horizontal planning is that how will you assess the students in the class? So, my planning is
actually interlinked, starting from objectives and going to resources. We also try to know the
planning framework and especially the role of teacher in it. Planning has two very important
dimensions: one is holistic dimension and the other one is detailed implementation. So, it is said
that a teacher is the one who operationalizes the curriculum. Curriculum document is pre-
planned but the teacher gives life to this curriculum document. Teachers give it life when they
are planning and then implementing them in the class. So, teachers’ role is very important. They
have to maintain the standards of curriculum.
93
“Factors influencing planning”
Lecture # 14
Lecture objective:
 Identified factors affecting planning.
 These factors include Students, Time, School, Teachers and resources.
 Curriculum guides
 Identified instructional planning procedures like identifying:
- Pupil’s entry skills
- Planning learning activities
Outline:
 Factors affecting planning
- Students’ considerations
- Time considerations
- School considerations
- Teachers considerations
- Resource consideration
- Motivation consideration
 Textbooks and curriculum guide
 Characteristics of good textbooks
 Pre-planning
 Deciding on content and processes
94
 Identifying entry skills

 Identification of activities
‘Factors which influence planning’
Planning equation:
Less planning leads to less learning (Walsh, 1992)
Planning = Content + Method
This simple equation directly influences learning. If we ignore this equation then ultimately, we
are going to the way where there is no learning. When a teacher is going to teach a topic for the
first time, he needs to have a detailed and thorough plan. If a teacher had to teach a topic for the
second or third time, he doesn’t need to see the plan again and again. There is a common
assumption that teachers don’t need planning, these all are a theoretical point of views and there
is no practical importance of them. In fact, this assumption is very wrong. If a teacher is
experienced, he still needs planning. The difference is when you are a new teacher; you need to
make very detailed plans. When you become an experienced teacher, then actually you don’t
need to make detailed lesson plans, but still you need to plan your lessons.
What are the considerations of the teachers when they are planning for instruction?
(Here are the brief summary of the interviews from the teachers)
Interview: 1 (Slomiat - Teacher):

When I am going to teach the students, I first try to know their prior knowledge. If the students’
know how to write the alphabets ‘A’ and ‘B’, then I will focus on teaching them the alphabets
‘C’ and ‘D’. I had to check the foundation of the students first, and then I plan my lesson
according to their prior foundations.
Interview: 2 (Sehreen Rashid - Teacher)
95
When we are going to teach, we will plan the entire things first i.e. learning environment,
strength and weaknesses of the students, curriculum, allocated time, learning activities, our
content knowledge etc. we will plan according to all these factors. Our plan is actually based on
a process.
Whenever we talk about considerations, we do not consider them in isolation. One consideration
is affecting the other. There is a link in between them. So they are not isolated considerations.
So, there are certain factors which influence planning.
- Students’ consideration:
Being a teacher, you need to know your students. You need to know their level of motivation.
Does the class work as a group or not? These are all considerations that are important on behalf
of students. Most of the times we see that when teachers talk about students’ considerations,
they mostly focus on the learning styles of the students. Secondly, they focus on the prior
knowledge of the students. Teachers do not think more than these two factors but still there are
different factors that need to be taken into consideration while planning a lesson.
- Motivation:
A teacher needs to know the motivation level of the students as they need to know their entry
level skills. When you are going to teach in a class with lesson planning, you are not only to
cover the content. You have to teach them some processes and you need to plan some activities
as well. So if you do not know the motivational level of the students then you will not be able to
know plan appropriate learning activities for them.
- Content and process considerations:
While yearly planning, you have to see the curriculum framework. Ministry of education has
planned curriculum document and in it there are standards till grade level 12, but if you are
going to teach to grade 5, you refer to that curriculum document and decide what content you
are going to teach to the students. Similarly, you have to see the overall yearly plan for unit
planning and lesson planning. It is also important to know about the processes. If I am going to
teach the students addition in mathematics, then I must see what thinking processes are involved
96
in it. E.g. if I am teaching them essay writing, then I have to see what processes are also
involved while the students are learning to write an essay.
- Time considerations:
We have limited time to teach in a class, a 40 or 45 minutes period. We have to present the
content in such a way that if it is a necessary content, how we can complete it in a given time
frame.
- School considerations:
Some parents demands that their children must also be engaged in co-curricular activities as
well as learning the content. But schools’ policy is to cover the content as much as possible.
They are unable to provide the students such environment where actually they are participating
in co-curricular activities. So the schools want to come up to the demands of the parents but they
do not want to compromise on their policies. They must plan it integrated that students can have
the activities as well as they can learn the content. E.g. essay writing competitions, which is very
much co-curricular activity. But at the same time students are learning certain content through
that. For planning such kind of activities, teachers need to consider what are school policies?
- Resource considerations:
If a teacher plans to take the students for field trips, then he needs to consider schools’
resources. He needs to know, is there human resource in the school? Is there physical resource
present in the school? We have the facility or not? We have the transport or not? We have the
drivers or not? How many teachers can go with the students? So she must consider the overall
resources.
- Teachers’ considerations:
Whenever I am going to plan, whether it is a lesson plan, unit plan or yearly plan. I must know
the content selected to teach. If I myself do not know the content properly, then how will I be
97
able to teach that content to my students? If I do not know, then I must seek help from my
colleagues. Content knowledge is a very important competency of a teacher. I need to be very
truthful to myself. Processes are also very important in teachers’ considerations. E.g.
imagination, it is a thinking process. We want to develop the thinking skill of imagination in our
students, so that they learn how to imagine? A teacher must observe himself that how much
imagination thinking exists in him.
- Textbooks and curriculum guide:
Textbooks are the ultimate resource for most of the children. And they are the ultimate resource
for most of the teachers as well. Curriculum is a very broad term; it includes content, syllabus,
activities, assessments and textbooks also. Curriculum guides are planned by Ministry of
education in Pakistan. Curriculum guides actually give us a guide line about what to be taught in
different grade levels. They do not only focus on the content but also on the processes that must
be taught to the students. So, content and processes are there in our curriculum guides.
Whenever I am planning, I must use that curriculum document as a referred document.
Curriculum documents are not available in all schools. But all schools have textbooks.
Principally speaking, textbooks are written on curriculum guidelines. So we may say that ideal
textbooks are actually mirror image of curriculum guide lines. There are some characteristics of
good textbooks:
Good textbooks:
- Provide a structured sequence of lessons.
- To achieve students learning outcomes for different units of study.
- Includes supplementary reading material.
- Have assessment strategies as well
- Have mentioned some activities also.
So, you need to decide which textbooks need to be used for a particular instruction. And how
will you align them with the curriculum. These are different considerations which we need to
take into account whenever we are planning for our instruction.
98
Preplanning (Planning before unit and lesson planning):

The yearly plans are already made according to the curriculum guidelines. Curriculum guidelines
consist of learning outcomes but not the resources and other activities. We have to plan all these
at different levels i.e. yearly plans, unit plans and lesson plans. Every teacher is supposed to plan
unit and lessons, so the stage before planning unit and lesson is called pre-planning stage.
What teachers had to decide at the pre-planning stage is as follows:
- Which content to be covered?
- Which processes to be selected?
- Do students need pre-course instruction to acquire prerequisites?
- Which learning activities seem relevant to goals, content and students’ interests?
Deciding on content and processes:

We usually say that content must be taught and we try to get memorized that content to the
students. It is very much rote learning. Content is important but processes are also very
important. Processes like imagining, problem solving, analyzing, organizing and communicating
is actually critical to almost every subject and topic you teach. You must tell the students about
the thought processes they are learning. You must communicate your expectations to the
students and give them such tasks where actually they experience these processes. So, processes
are important, whenever we are teaching our students, we need to focus not only on the content
rather on processes also. You cannot isolate process from content. E.g. a child who is very good
in problem solving must also be very good in content also.
Identifying entry skills:

We have planned our lesson on writing skills and we are going to teach them how to write an
argumentative essay. I need to know if my students know how to write an essay or not? For this
purpose, I will give a task to the students to write an essay. I will judge them accordingly that
either the students are able to give their main thesis statement? Are they able to write the topic
sentence correctly? Can they write proper introduction or not? Can they write conclusion? What
is their choice of vocabulary? What are their ideas and sentence structure? I will make check list
of all these things to check the entry level skills of the students. We will do diagnostic
99
assessment to check the entry level skills of the students. So, for this purpose, I need to be very
clear that what I am going to assess. When we are assessing the students for entry level skills,
we must not give them marks rather we have to diagnose their skills. We are not supposed to
scold our students on the basis of that test. The goal of that diagnostic test is that how we can
support our students in developing their skills. We have to identify the weaknesses of the
students and give them remedial classes.
Identification of activities:
For the identification of resources, we need to plan activities. If we need some resources in
lesson 4th or 5th, so we can provide the administration with the list of resources at the beginning,
so that they can manage them until we reach to lesson 4th. So, it is important to know and think
about activities first.
100
“Unit planning”
Lecture # 15
Outline:
 Unit plan
 Importance of unit plan
 Components of a unit plan
- Subject/topic
- Rationale
- Content (Facts, Concepts and generalizations)
- Process
- Resources
- Learning activities
- Evaluation
“Unit Planning”
Unit planning is part of our planning framework. Most of the times, teachers divide their overall
content into some manageable instructional units. E.g. a teacher is going to teach mathematics to
grade level 6, there will be a yearly plan for grade 6 in which there is algebra, fraction, geometry,
percentage etc. concepts are given. Teachers divide the whole content into blocks of the same
type i.e. fraction in one block and percentages in the other. The planning of fraction would be
different from that of percentages. So, these blocks are called unit plans. Whenever we are
101
dividing our whole instruction into the small units, we need to know how to integrate them
altogether.
Importance of unit planning:

“Unit planning is the most important as well as the most time-consuming level of planning
for each teacher” (Walsh, 1992).
Unit planning is important because we need to know the reasons for dividing the whole thing
into components. Most of the times, teachers’ complaint for shortage of time. This problem can
be solved by making the detailed unit plans. You can observe all the topics given in the yearly
plan, and then identify the most important topics and the overlapping topics. You can omit the
overlapping topics whose level of difficulty is the same as taught previously. So, actually unit
planning helps you to go through whole yearly plans.
Components of a unit plan:
1. Subject/ topic
Unit subject is the title of the whole unit. E.g. in science, Human system is the unit; its
chapters would be digestive system, circulatory system, nervous system etc.
2. Rationale
Teacher has to decide which content have to be taught and which must be omitted.
Whenever you select a topic to teach, there are reasons of it. So, you need to give reasons
under the heading of rationale. E.g. a rationale is given in the book named ‘Teaching
strategies’ and that is:
“Understanding a scientific processes and principal is important for every student.
Helping students become interested in science at an early age will increase their
motivation to want more science as they get older. Additionally, doing science at an early
age is an excellent introduction to higher thinking processes as observing, classifying,
making inferences and withholding judgement until sufficient data has been gathered.
102
Thus these units on water besides having many informative interesting activities will help
prepare students mental for enjoying the observation of the world around them.”
3. Instructional objectives
Whenever you are planning a unit, you need to identify the major instructional objectives.
Though you are not supposed to give rationale over here.
4. Content (Facts, concepts and generalizations)

When you give the title of the topic, you have to identify the content also. Make sure
while writing the content that you isolate facts, concepts and generalizations clearly. You
have to tell exactly that the unit consists of these facts, concepts and generalizations.
5. Processes
You have to identify the processes which the students are going to learn from this unit.
6. Resources
You have to identify the resources which are to be used while teaching a lesson to the
students. You have to make a list of the resources and submit that to school
administration so that they can manage them properly.
7. Learning activities
Learning activities are different from teaching activities. Teaching activities are there to
teach content to the students. While learning activities are there so that pupils experience
processes. If you do not identify the learning activities, then students may not be able to
learn the identified processes. E.g. experimentation, when students perform experiments
then actually they goes through the process. That is a learning activity for them. If teacher
would demonstrate the experiment then it would be a teaching activity. Learning
activities are those where students are actively involved. And these activities are
important because we do not teach processes to our students unless we do not include
learning activities in our lessons.
103
8. Evaluation
You have to identify the criteria for evaluation. What to evaluate and how to evaluate
should be identified in unit planning.
(Here is an example of a unit plan where all the components are described. Observe this lesson
plan carefully for your better understanding.)
Unit Subject:
Unit of food (Topic)
Sub-topics: (Content)
i. Food as a right of every human being
ii. Concept of food and diet
iii. Variety of food
iv. Types of food including whole food, organic food, natural food.
v. Groups of food which includes carbohydrates, proteins, fat, water, fiber, vitamins and
minerals.
vi. Balanced diet
- Planning interdisciplinary thematic unit

- Such planning requires conscious effort to apply knowledge, principles and values to
science and English subjects simultaneously. (Rationale)
Processes:
Imagination, analyzing, recording, interviewing, questioning and then making generalizations
and problem solving also.
104
Learning activities:
1. Concept analysis model will be followed to teach students the concept of food.
2. Direct instruction will be used to teach students how to make custard, steam vegetables,
omelet and French fries.
3. Students will be asked to investigate food traditions in their families. They will interview
their family members and write a report on that and share it with the class.
Unit – Project learning:

Here the teacher divides the students into groups, and ask them to write their names and selected
items on the board so that all the students may know it.
1. Arrange a food carnival.
2. Prepare an estimate of the food budget.
3. Identify the place where you will hold carnival (work with your class fellows to decide
on it)
4. Divide responsibilities
5. Design and print a brochure to market your food stalls.
6. Prepare a report based on your experience and visitor’s impressions.
7. Present the report to the whole class.
8. Upload your reports on school website.
So, this one activity of food carnival is very useful activity in terms of giving opportunity to
the students to experience a range of processes. When we are planning our unit, learning
activities hold a very prominent position.
(Teacher has also given alternatives that if a food carnival is not possible in school then what
activities should be done)
Projects:
1. Growing organic food
2. Making a classroom cookbook
3. Making a cookbook for diabetics
4. Making a cookbook for high cholesterol patients
105
5. Making cookbooks for high blood pressure patients
Food – Inquiry:
Asking students to inquire dietary habits of 5-8 years old children, 9-15 years old children, 16-25
years old people and 55-70 years old people. Try to investigate the relationship between their
dietary habits and their weight.
Discussion:
So, whenever we are planning a unit, we really need to select these learning activities very
carefully. And we need to make a match between processes and learning activities. What do we
teachers do is that we focus on the completion of the syllabus. This is a wrong assumption
because when we plan a lesson, we need to decide on the content which we think is important to
teach. And also we have to give a rationale on the content selected.
We do not know that what different processes according to different subjects are. We are not
supposed to teach content to the students. Content may be same for all the subjects, subjects may
differ according to their processes. So, unit planning is very challenging and time consuming but
the most important thing is that good unit planning is a guarantee to effective instruction and
effective learning.
We have to identify the facts, concepts and generalizations while planning a unit. In unit plan
while writing content, a teacher writes some questions too. It is useful because you can design
the learning activities easily.
In evaluation, we discuss that there are two things; criteria and method. So when you are going
to assess the processes, you need to adopt alternate methods. E.g. if you want to check whether
the students can communicate well or not? You cannot assess them through paper pencil test.
Processes can never be assessed through paper and pencil tests. You have to create a check list
for assessing communication skills. If you want to assess the students in report writing, give
them the task to write a report then analyze it. Processes are usually assessed through analysis
method or through observation.
(Here are brief interviews of teachers on their opinion of unit planning)

Interview: 1
106
Firstly, I consider lesson planning very important and I usually focus on that. But I was failed to
develop co-ordination with the class. Then I discuss it with the mentor, he said that you must
plan units before lessons. Because that is a root towards lesson planning and you can never
develop coordination in the class. It is a bit time consuming activity but it is very important and
root towards success. It really helps teachers in adding certain things and in omitting certain
things.
Interview: 2
We must plan unit before lesson. All teachers must emphasize on unit planning because if we
take both lesson and unit side by side, we can teach the lesson well organized. We can provide
useful guidance to the students.
So, teachers most of the times say that it is a useful activity as discussed in the above interviews.
You can break the content into blocks but can’t integrate it. There must be a link between the
interdisciplinary thematic units. When we plan units integrated, we have to assess them
integrated as well.
107
“Lesson plan”
Lecture # 16
Outline:
 Lesson plan
 Components of a lesson plan
- Subject
- Rationale
- Content and process
- Instructional procedures
 Tyler’s rationale
 Bloom’s taxonomy
 Gagne’s plan
 Why to plan a lesson
 Templates of a lesson plan
 Unit plan vs lesson plan
Before we start with lesson planning, here is a task for the students that observe the lesson plan
given below and identify, if this is a lesson plan or not?
Task 1:
108
Read the following and decide if it is a lesson plan?

- Tuesday: 14th February, 2011.
1. Review spelling words (5 min)
2. Silent reading and underlining difficult words in chapter 15 (10 min)
3. Pronouncing difficult words (5 min)
4. Discussing meaning of difficult words (10 min)
5. Homework (5 min)
In fact, this is not a lesson plan. You might have seen lesson plans in such form. If seen, this may
be a plan that in 5 minutes what to do and in next 10 minutes what will be done in class. This
lesson plan can be an activity schedule, because activity schedule is something which indicates
division of time.
Lesson plan:
1. Lesson is a piece of a unit NOT a block of time. If you have decided to teach a unit of
light to the students, definitely a whole unit of light cannot be taught in one lesson. You
need to divide the whole unit in certain pieces. May be you decide to divide the whole
unit of light into 10 pieces, so each piece would require a plan. That plan is called lesson
plan. Lesson plan is part of the unit plan while activity schedule is part of the block
timetable.
2. A lesson plan is defined as “a systematic design for the development,

implementation and evaluation of instruction” (Chatel 2002)
It is basically “a rehearsal for delivering actual instruction” (Causton – Theohari’s
et al 2008) So, a lesson plan is a very important document because it tells you what you
are going to do in real classroom situation.
Components of a lesson plan:

1. Subject:
Lesson plan starts with the subject. Lesson plan is part of unit plan, so we need to know
what the unit title or unit topic is. So that we are able to identify the lesson title. E.g. if we
109
are teaching the unit of light, there can be a lesson, named ‘colours’ or ‘transparent or
translucent objects’ etc. so the name of the unit must be mentioned in lesson plan.
2. Instructional objectives:
You need to mention the instructional objectives that what the students will achieve after
reading the lesson.
3. Rationale:
Rationale means reasons that what the reason behind those specific instructional
objectives is?
4. Content and process:

It is very important that when you are identifying the content to teach to the students, you
need to identify what skills they are going to learn.
5. Instructional procedures:
While planning a lesson, you divide instructional procedures in 5 different units.
i. Focusing event
ii. Teaching procedures
iii. Student activities and participation
iv. Formative check
v. Closure
(Parallel resources)
Lesson planning may be based on different models. Tyler’s model is one of the very famous
models of curriculum development. As we know, lesson planning is a short term planning. It is
part of curriculum planning. So, it can also be based on Tyler’s rationale.
Tyler’s rationale:
1. What educational purposes should the school seek to attain? (Defining appropriate
learning objectives).
110
2. How can learning experiences be selected which are likely to be useful in attaining these
objectives? (Introducing useful learning experiences).
3. How can learning experiences be organized for effective instruction? (Organizing

experiences to maximize their effect).
4. How can the effectiveness of learning experiences be evaluated? (Evaluating the process
and revising the areas that were not effective). (Tyler 1969; John 2006, 484)
If we plan a lesson according to Tyler’s model, then the important things in it would be:
Lesson planning:
“A lesson plan defines objective, plans materials, resources and activities are mobilized for the
efficient attainment of the selected objectives; and finally, evaluation criteria is also identified.”
You actually identify objectives first, and then select activities for attaining them. Select
material and resources and go further to decide the criteria on which objectives need to be
evaluated. Interestingly, criteria remain the same. If we are going to evaluate the objectives, then
naturally, objectives are evaluated against objectives. Objectives actually provide you the
criteria for evaluating the lesson.
Bloom’s Taxonomy:
Six levels of taxonomy are important in his taxonomy. If you are planning your lesson on these
six levels then definitely they will be helpful in identifying your objectives. The important thing
in Tyler’s model and bloom’s taxonomy is that you observe the ultimate behaviors. At the end
of the lesson, the students are able to show the particular behaviour or not? In both the models,
you identify objectives and then plan activities. And eventually you assess them on objectives.
Gagne’s Plan:
111
Gagne expand the steps of introducing and organizing experience to include a sequence of nine
particular “Instructional events” – Events that begin with “gaining attention” and conclude with
“enhancing retention and transfer”
Gagne introduces nine different instructional events and nine different internal processes.
Internal process Instructional event
1. Reception Gaining attention
2. Expectancy Informing learners of the objectives
3. Retrieval to working memory Stimulating or recalling prior learning
4. Selective perception Presenting the stimulus
5. Semantic encoding Providing “Learning guidance”
6. Responding Eliciting performance
7. Reinforcement Providing feedback
8. Retrieval and reinforcement Assessing performance
9. Retrieval and generalization Enhancing retention and transfer
1. A teacher should gain attention of the students in the class. If a teacher is unable to gain
children’s attention, then definitely he will not be able to teach certain things. We need to
see what is the internal process that is involved when we are to gain attention of the students
i.e. Reception. A child starts receiving. If you do not gain attention of the students then the
internal process of reception will not start in them.
2. It is not about telling exact objectives, but it is about communicating expectations. In this
internal process, students come to know what the teacher is expecting from them.
3. What happens when actually teachers stimulate prior learning of children? Teachers ask
questions to judge their prior learning. Its internal process is “retrieval to working memory”.
Whatever we learn it becomes part of our long term memory. We are going to learn a new
thing, maybe there are number of things that are already in our mind but they are not part of
our working memory. If the teachers do not try to bring the prior knowledge into working
memory then there will not be a connection in new learning.
112
4. It is important to present the stimulus. In class, learning new thing will be a stimulus. You
must attract the students towards new learning by good presentation. When you present,
children cannot learn it all at once, there will be a selective perception.
5. When teacher provides guidance to the students, then there is semantic encoding. When you
present stimulus, there is selective perception. But when you guide children, there is
semantic encoding. Children understand meaning and their mind starts processing the
information.
6. Teachers have to identify the methods to monitor the progress of the students. When you ask
a question, you expect a response from the child. Here the internal process is to respond. If
we are not going to elicit performance, then definitely children will not respond.
7. Giving feedback is equally important. You need to provide feedback so that child improves
his/her performance. Its internal process is of reinforcement. When you provide feedback,
the students reinforce their learning in mind. Feedback is important to reinforce pupils’
learning.
8. Assessment of the students is important so that there will be reinforcement of learning in

them. As feedback is important to reinforce pupils’ learning, similarly, assessment is also
important for reinforcement of pupils’ learning. At the same time, assessment serves the
purpose of retrieving.
9. The summary you give at the end of the lesson. May be it is of 2 or 3 minutes, and it may
not be important for a teacher. But they are very important for the children. Because these
minutes actually again help child to transfer information from the working memory to long
term memory.
So, we can conclude that lesson plan based on Gagne’s model includes these nine essential
instructional events. Because it is assumed that these instructional events activates the internal
processes.
113
Why to plan a lesson?

Templates are designed with the intention of “scaffold[ing] the thinking, skills and attitudes of
pre-service (student) teachers. (2008, 385).
A lesson plan has a provisional purpose:
- It helps to develop thinking skills that will be useful in practical teaching

preparation. Lesson planning is essentially a reflective process. Reflective process
because you keep in mind that what students have learnt and what they are going to learn.
You keep in mind the strengths and weaknesses of the students and then plan a lesson.
Identification of objectives is a very difficult task. It really requires lot of thinking and
time. Lesson planning is actually a thinking job and lesson plans develop student teachers
or pre-service teachers thinking skills.
- It allows teacher trainer to understand the thought process of their student teacher.
From the lesson plans, it can be identified easily that which students are investing their
thinking skills more and which are not participating.
- It can be greatly simplified and abbreviated once these teachers are fully engaged in
their teaching practice. You can also predict that how well a student is going to perform
in future as a teacher.
Templates of a lesson plan:

Here are three templates presented and then analyzed them for better understanding.
Bases of lesson plan templates:
114
Hunter (USA) 1984 John (UK) 2004 Tru (Canada) 2008

1. Materials/Resources Resources Materials and resources
(including
behavioural/organizational
management strategies)
2. Anticipatory set (list specific Starter Introduction (anticipatory
statements or activities which are used set)
to attain students attention)
Objective/purpose(for the students Objectives Learning outcomes
benefit, explain what students will be
able to do by the end of the lesson and
why these objectives are important to
accomplish).
3. Input (what information is essential Vocabulary Preparation
for the student to know before
beginning and how will this skill be
communicated to students?)
1. In Hunter, John and Tru’s template, the first thing is the resources and material which is
common in all the three. Tru added organizational management strategies as resources
also.
2. In hunter’s template there is anticipatory set, John gives it the name starter and Tru says it
as introduction. But the focus of all the three is the same that is how to get the attention of
the students. Names are different but the purpose of all the three is the same.
3. Hunter uses the word objective/purposes in his template. John uses only objectives and
Tru uses learning outcomes. It is quite confusing for many people that if there is any
difference between learning outcomes or objectives. There are some educationists who
have tried to identify the difference between the two. But in this template the words
115
learning outcomes and objectives are used parallel. Only Hunter says that there must be a
rationale on identification of objectives but the other two did not mention rationale.
Hunter used the word input, John used the word vocabulary and Tru used preparation.
Here the role of the teacher is important. Input is basically content.

4. Model (if you will be
demonstrating the skill or
competence, how this will be
done?)
5. Check for understanding (Identify
strategies to be used to determine
if students have learned the
objectives)
6. Guided practice (List activities Main activity Student/ teacher
that will be used to guide student activity
practice and provide a time frame
for completing this practice)
Closure (What method of review Plenary/ Assessment Closure
and evaluation will be used to of outcomes
complete a lesson)
7. Independent practice (List
homework/seatwork assignment to
be given to students to ensure they
have mastered the skill without
teacher guidance.)
4. Here Hunter identifies model. But John and Tru are silent. They do not identify model in
their template.
5. Hunter present check for understanding and its details in template but John and Tru does
not define any.
116
6. Hunter’s model is based on Gagne’s model. He used guided practice as Gagne do. John
used the word main activity for it and Tru used Teacher/ student activity.
7. Hunter used closure in his template while John used Plenary/ assessment of outcomes and
Tru used closure.

8. Grouping Extension
9. Differentiation Adaptation
10. Difficulties/Successe Reflections
s
8. In these templates, John says that after closure, there is grouping, and Tru says that there
is Extension. Hunter is silent in this aspect.
9. John says that there is Differentiation and Tru says that there is adaptation. Hunter is
again silent.
10. John says that there are difficulties/ successes and Tru says there is a reflection. Hunter is
silent in this respect.
Unit plan vs Lesson plan:
Unit plan Lesson plan

Subject Subject
Unit topic
Lesson topic Unit topic
Rationale of the topic Instructional objectives
Instructional objectives Rationale
Content and processes Content and processes
Learning activities Instructional procedures
1. Focusing event
(Parallel resources) 2. Teaching procedures
3. Student activities and participation
4. Formative check
117
5. Closure
(Parallel resources)
Evaluation Assessment
Notes
So, there are many similarities because lesson plan is the part of unit plan. Overall we can say
that lesson plan is actually detailed form of unit plan. It originates from a unit but it is much in
detail.
118
“Lesson Plan Formats”

Lecture # 17
Individual Education Plans (IEP):
As the name shows that individual education plans are those which are made according to the
needs of the individuals. How IEP helps teachers to cater for the learning needs of diverse
learners?
IEP is basically an extended adaptation of a lesson plan. The focus in IEP will be on the
needs of the learners rather on the content to be taught. Teacher can write simple lesson
plans because they are not extended or in much detail. But IEP are written in extended form. E.g.
If a teacher writes a plan of a lesson for a whole class then it is a common lesson plan. But if a
teacher prepares activities in a lesson plan for the students who have visual or hearing
impairment, then it is essentially an individual education plan (IEP).
The individualized part of IEP means that the plan has to be tailored specifically to your child's special
needs -- not to the needs of the teacher, or the school, or the district. Goals, modifications,
accommodations, personnel, placement, all should be selected, enforced and maintained with the
particular needs of your child in mind.
Differentiated instruction: Instruction that is catering for various learning styles and
various learning needs.
Effective individual education plans (IEP) have key characteristics. They are:
- Individualized and child centered

- Inclusive
- Holistic
- Collaborative
- Accessible
The IEP must include:
a. Any needed specialized equipment or materials.

b. Instructional strategies fitted to the pupil's learning style.
119
c. Techniques and activities designed to support the personal and social

development of the pupil.
Post Lesson Activities: Most of the times, we teachers think that most important thing in
teaching is lesson planning and lesson execution. But post lesson activities must also be included
in the lesson plans. Post Lesson Activities are:
- Evaluating lesson plans

- Evaluating unit plans
- Record keeping
The evaluation should be in written form not oral evaluation. And teachers need to do that
evaluation on the format which is actually attached with the lesson plan. A good teacher is the
one who plans a lesson, implement it and evaluate it after implementation.
Evaluation of students’ learning:
We need to ask certain questions whenever we are evaluating. Whether we are evaluating our
teaching or the learning of our students. Here are certain questions that must be taken into
consideration while evaluating students’ learning:
- What did my students learn?

- What did students not learn?
- What was interesting for the students?
- What was difficult for the students?
- What evidence do I have for these findings?
- What will children learn in future?
Task 1:
Read the following statements and choose the most appropriate one for evaluation?
1. My students learnt to cooperate.

2. My students learnt to cooperate as they were made to work in groups.
120
3. My students learnt to cooperate as they resolved their conflicts.

4. My students learnt to resolve conflicts as when they were working in the group, they
initially had conflicts and asked me to intervene or change groups. When I denied
doing so, they in fact tried to resolve their conflicts at their own. All members were
smoothly working towards the end of the lesson.
No. 4 is definitely the best evaluation statement. Because evaluation means judgement. A
teacher could not give judgement unless she does not have evidence.
Evaluating Teaching:
There are also certain questions that need to be raised and answered while evaluating teaching.
These questions can be:
1. Did I achieve my objectives?

2. Did I build lessons on students’ responses?
3. Did I communicate clearly with the students?
4. Did I provide equal learning opportunities to all my students?
5. Did I keep eye contact with the students?
6. Did I give feedback to the pupils constructively?
7. Did I manage time and resources effectively?
Task 2:
Read the following statements and choose the most appropriate one for evaluation?
1. My teaching went very well.

2. My teaching went very well as all students seemed very happy.
3. I achieved my objectives as indicated by students’ responses.
4. I was able to achieve first two objectives as indicated by students’ performance on
two questions which were given to them towards the end of the lesson.
No. 4 is actually a good evaluative statement.
Do remember, whenever you are going to evaluate your teaching, come up with a judgement
but provide sufficient evidence to support your statement.
121
Post Lesson Activity: “Keeping Notes”
Teachers’ notes are different from that of the students, because students prepare notes for
preparation of exams. They prepare the notes and then memorize them but when teachers make
notes, they keep the detail of the content of the lesson to be taught in the class in those notes.
Some part of evaluation is also included in those notes. Keeping notes is a very important type of
post lesson activity because a teacher can have the record of his/her teaching.
Purpose of keeping notes:
- To keep record of teaching.

- To plan for future
- To learn from experience
- To communicate with the principal
- To write research report
(Action research is very effective research for teachers, because it aims at improvement.
Whenever you want to bring improvement there is always a need for action. When teachers
are conducting research, they need evidence.)
Record keeping serves the purpose of future planning and improvement.
Research on lesson planning:
Lesson planning is very important and it has been extensively researched.
1. Researchers have neither identified nor validated any widely accepted or

consistently practical planning model. (McBer 2000).
2. Teachers use a variety of lesson plan formats.
3. Planning serves a guide to action.
4. Teachers tend to do much of their planning in minds rather than on paper.
5. Teachers rarely plan in linear model as encouraged in textbooks.
6. The best teachers apply planning flexibly.
122
Components of a lesson plan:
1. Grade level
2. Topic
3. Instructional aims: Student-oriented
4. Instructional objectives (Instructional aims are broad while instructional objectives are
narrow which you have to achieve during a particular time span. The statement of
instructional objectives must always begin with: “By the end of the lesson, the students
will be able to …..” This includes objectives that are related to knowledge, skills and
attitudes.)
5. Rationale for objectives.
6. Lesson content (Outline of the lesson)
7. Instructional procedures
- Focusing event (It includes the ways to grab students’ attention e.g. games,
brainstorming etc.)
- Teaching procedures
- Students’ participation and activities
- Formative check (How will you assess the students in class and what feedback will
be given to them.)
- Closure (How will you close the lesson)
8. Assessment
9. Resources needed
10. Teaching notes
123
“Instructional sequencing”
Lecture # 18
Outline:
 Sequencing
 Why to sequence?
 How to sequence?
 Principles of sequencing
 Can we sequence a lesson in one concept?
 Hierarchy of students’ success
 Knowledge forms
- Content
- Process
 Content forms
- Facts
- Concepts
- Generalizations
 Facts vs Generalizations
Sequencing:
The art of developing logical plan for instructional activities is called ‘sequencing’. Such a
plan consists of interlink steps.
124
The steps are in progression. They start from simple and go to complex. So, if we start our
instruction with complex things and then we move to something simple. We will see that
sequencing is not a logical sequencing. It lacks logical plan.
Why to sequence?
- Helps to make learning more manageable.

When you are going to teach a child a complex concept or process, you need to isolate it
into pieces. You cannot teach a complex concept straight away to the children. You need
to divide it into bit and parts because after understanding bits and parts they can
understand big picture.
- Relate information to the bigger picture.

If we do not sequence the lesson, then student will not be able to understand that what he
is going to learn. What are the terminal objectives?
How to sequence?
- Sequence objectives: We need to sequence our learning objectives. Being teachers, we
are supposed to make lesson plans and unit plans. While making unit and lesson plan, we
have to sequence objectives. We should not make teacher-oriented objectives. Objectives
should be child centered; they should be student-oriented.
- Teaching prerequisites: there is prerequisite for everything you are going to learn. E.g.
if we want to teach children essay writing, then we need to know if children know how to
write a paragraph. Sentence formation is a prerequisite for paragraph writing and for
sentence formation, vocabulary is prerequisite. Whenever we are sequencing, we need to
know what a prerequisite for a particular terminal objective is.
125
- If possible, communicate sequenced objectives to the students to involve them more

in the learning process.
Principles of sequencing:
- Teacher needs to start lesson with simple steps. It means that teacher must come up
with at least one example so that the students can understand the concept easily. Ideally
there should be numerous examples, but to start with, there must be one example.
- Use concrete examples. The examples which the students can see and can relate to them
their learning.
- Add complexity to the lesson. If we are developing the whole lesson on very simple
things and we are teaching the basic things, it means that we are not teaching a sequenced
lesson. It is important in lesson plan but it should be taken into consideration while
planning units that there should be complexity in it. You may start it with simple things
but you need to add complexity to the unit.
- Introduce abstractions. (heart beat and B.P) Teacher needs to introduce abstractions.
Abstractions are something which is not tangible. Abstract thinking is very important.
Children should be able to recognize and relate those things which are abstract.
For example, when a teacher is going to teach human circulatory system. Teacher may relate that
with river system. The purpose of river system in a country is to supply water to the country.
You can relate the river system with human circulatory system because human circulatory
system is not visible. While rivers are concrete, children have seen rivers and canals. So if the
teacher teaches the students by relating this example then students can understand the human
126
circulatory system at basic level. You can take many other concrete examples like, electricity
system or telecommunication system etc. only one example is enough for giving students the
basic concept. But to develop the concept more firmly, you need to come up with some more
examples. Invite the students that they should also come up with some more examples. In this
way you are adding complexity in your lesson. You can add abstractions in this example of
circulatory system by telling the student about heart beat or blood pressure. A person who has
low or less heart beat can have dangers. So there are basically four principles of sequencing and
you have to address them whenever you are sequencing your lesson.
Can we sequence a lesson in one concept?
According to research:
- Total sequencing time may be 10 years. There are many concepts that can take years in
sequencing e.g. in mathematics, the concept of graphics. It takes at least ten years to
understand this concept. There are certain concepts which can be sequenced in one
lesson. There are concepts which can be sequence in a week. There are other concepts
which can be sequenced in a unit. There are other concepts which can only be sequence
in years. This time span is directly proportional to the complexity of a concept.
Hierarchy of students’ success:
Abstraction
If students fails
to learn Recycling mode
Complex
Concrete
Simple
127
Sequencing has different principles; these principles are the introduction of simple concepts.
Then concrete examples. Then adding complexity to the lesson and after that taking student to
abstraction. But if student fails to understand the abstraction concept, then there is a recycling
mode by which the concept can be taught to them through concrete examples.
Knowledge forms:
Knowledge may be simply divided into two forms; one is content and the other is process.
- Content is the information, you want your students to learn.
- Processes are the motor and thinking skills you want your students to learn.
Content: example
Kinds of landforms i.e. mountains, valleys, plateaus is content knowledge.
Process: example
- Carrying out an experiment.
- Doing mathematics sums
This kind of knowledge is procedural knowledge.
Content forms:
- Facts
- Concepts
- Generalizations
Facts:
1. Singular in accurance (describes something important)
2. Occurs or exists in present times
128
3. Does not help in predicting other facts

4. It is acquired solely through observations
Fact: examples
- Islamabad is capital of Pakistan
- Today sun set is 6 p.m.
- There are 5 provinces in Pakistan
Concept:
- They are “category” words which enable us to group many individual objects or ideas
under a common label. For example chair, desk, mammal, verb, bird, noun, mountain,
friendship, democracy, love etc. the highlighted are the abstract concepts. Some are
concrete concepts. Learning concepts is quite natural to all human beings.
- All concepts have five essential components: Name, definition, characteristics, examples
and place in hierarchy.
Generalization:
- A generalization is an inferential statement that expresses a relationship between two or
more concepts. It applies to more than one event and has a predictive and explanatory
value.
(When we talk about inferential statement, it means that this statement is derived from
somewhere and which is explaining the relationship between one to two concepts. It has a
predictive value and explanatory value.)
Example:
129
People who smoke have a higher incidence of lung cancer than those who don’t. it applies to
anyone who smokes and has a predictive value.
Facts vs Generalizations:
Facts and generalizations are not the same. Generalizations are basically a relationship
between concepts. While facts are singular in occurrence. The difference in both in discussed
below:
- Generalizations are inferences that condense a large amount of data while facts are
singular in occurrence. For example: Sunset occurs earlier everyday between June 21 and
December 21 is a generalization but the sunset at 6 p.m. today is a fact.
- Facts have past or future orientation but generalizations are statements about general
trends or patterns.
- Generalizations have predictive value but facts do not have that.
- We need to take our children from factual to conceptual knowledge and from conceptual
to generalizations.
Being teachers, we need to take students from facts to generalizations. Because factual
knowledge is very simple knowledge. In Bloom’s taxonomy, factual knowledge comes at the
lowest level of learning. As soon as we add complexity to our lessons, we need to take students
towards generalizations. Rather we need to ask our children to make generalizations. We should
provide them with the environment that they should be able to come up with generalizations.
130
“Modes of presentation and Task Analysis Model”

Lecture # 19
Outline:
 Modes of presentation
- Deductive reasoning (General to specific)
- Inductive reasoning (Specific to general)
 Gagne’s experience of teaching
 Task Analysis Model
 Individual Education Plan and Task Analysis Model
We know that knowledge is of three kinds; declarative knowledge, procedural knowledge and
metacognitive knowledge.
- Declarative knowledge: Facts and concepts are there in this kind of knowledge.
- Procedural knowledge: The processes are involved in such learning.
- Metacognition: is cognitive about cognition.
Being teachers, we need to give all these kinds of knowledge to our students. There are different
ways to deliver knowledge.
Modes of presentation:
- Deductive reasoning (General to specific)
- Inductive reasoning (Specific to general)
131
For example, human beings are mortal. This is a very general statement. All men are mortal, and
then we say that Ahmad is a man, so he is also mortal. This is deductive reasoning; that you gave
general statement first and then goes to specific i.e. Ahmad is mortal because he is also a man.
In inductive reasoning, we start with specific and goes to general. We say that Ahmad is a man
and he is mortal. There is another man named Umar, he is also mortal. There is another man; we
say he is also mortal. So, we can say that all men are mortal. Then we talk about women and say,
Ayesha is a women, she is mortal. Amna is women, she is also mortal. All women are mortal.
Now you say a general statement on all these men and women that is ‘All human beings are
mortal.’ This is known as inductive reasoning.
Here are two columns, try to identify the difference between two modes of presentation
Definition of noun Brainstorming on names

Characteristics of noun Examples of names
Examples of noun Characteristics/ Commonalities in names
Place in hierarchy Definition of nouns
Children can learn nouns by both the methods explained step by step in the above two coloumns.
But the difference is that the first coloumn is of deductive reasoning i.e. teacher has told a
definition and then they are proving the definition by characteristics, examples and place in
hierarchy. So, this is a sequence called deductive reasoning.
In second coloumn, inductive reasoning is followed. Teacher asks the students to tell the names
of different things. He starts with brainstorming of names of different things. Students may tell
the names of places, birds, flowers, animals etc. then he tells the students about what are
commonalities i.e. what names are of birds, or animals or places etc. he characterizes it. Then he
says that what we have learnt by telling the names is called noun. So noun is the name of a
person, place or thing.
- There is a drawback in deductive reasoning i.e. no fair observation. So, if you really want
your children to learn skill of observation then actually inductive mode of presentation is
better than deductive mode of presentation.
132
- An important thing in inductive mode of presentation is Process. In deductive mode,

children learn reasoning and concepts, but in inductive mode, there is also procedural
knowledge that is given to the students. They can learn to generalize facts. It is more
child-centered. So it is better to use inductive mode of presentation.
Teaching subtraction:
Here is an example, try to analyze if the following steps are sequenced or not?
Analysis to teach subtracting the whole numbers.

Teacher teaches them:
1. Subtracting in simple coloumns.
2. Subtracting when a “0” is understood.
3. Subtracting one digit number with borrowing.
4. Subtracting when single borrowing is required in any coloumn.
5. Subtracting when several borrowings are required in non-adjacent coloumns.
6. Subtracting when double borrowing is required (across zero)
7. Subtracting whole number of any size.
Most of the times, the teachers who are very good at sequencing lessons, they sequence their
lesson or unit on subtraction in this way. Teacher starts with simple subtraction of simple
coloumns and move to complex subtraction i.e. subtracting whole number of any size.
Gagne’s experience:
Gagne taught the students and he was very happy because the students’ responses were very
good, they were performing very well in class. But what happened in examination? Students did
not perform according to his expectations. After that, he observes that what the actual reasons
behind it were. Was there any weakness in his teaching? Or there was any problem with
students’ learning? Actually, his instruction was very much in sequence but not according to the
133
learning hierarchy. Learning hierarchy is that the terminal objectives and goals should be
interlinked with intermediate objectives. And those intermediate objectives should be interlinked
with the basic skills. This hierarchy was developed by Gagne after his own experience. Gagne
was a wonderful teacher in sense that he reflected on his own experience of teaching and then
developed a learning hierarchy.
*Task analysis is very important when you are going to give the students procedural knowledge.
You have to analyze the whole task which you are going to teach to the students. There are some
prerequisites and developed things. The most important prerequisite is simple subtraction in this
example. There is only one terminal objective i.e. subtract whole number of any size. The other
that comes under is intermediate objectives. And then there are basic skills. So, being teachers,
we are supposed to sequence our lesson but at the same time we need to analyze the whole task.
Task Analysis Model:
The most important thing in using task analysis model is that we need to:
1. Select an appropriate objective that is at the appropriate age level.

It means that whenever we are going to teach students, any lesson or topic, it should be
according to the age level of the students. We must know that the students of this age can
do a particular task. E.g. if we talk about addition, you can teach addition before
subtraction.
2. Identify the enabling skills students need to attain the objective.

There are two things very common; one is the content to be taught and second is enabling
skills. Enabling skills are those skills which are required to achieve a certain goal. E.g.
your terminal objective is: by the end of the year, students will be able to write a
persuasive essay. Then the enabling skills would be; the students should know how to
write an essay, they should know the structure of the paragraph, they should be able to
identify a topic sentence in a paragraph, they should be able to write a topic sentence,
they should be able to write a thesis statement in an essay etc. So, all these skills are
enabling skills.
134
3. Subdivide independent and dependent enabling skills.

Independent enabling skills are those which are prerequisite actually. They are not
dependent on anything. And dependent enabling skills are those which depend on
prerequisites. E.g. in English, you are teaching students writing. So, writing a sentence is
an independent enabling skill. While writing a paragraph is a dependent enabling skill. If
a child does not know how to write a sentence then definitely the child will not be able to
write a paragraph. So, paragraph writing is dependent on sentence writing. Similarly,
essay writing is dependent on paragraph writing. Enabling skills are divided into two
categories; one is independent skill and the other is dependent skill. Being teachers, when
we are analyzing a task, we need to know which skills are dependent and which are
independent.
4. Arrange the dependent and independent sequences in order.

It is our assumption that independent skills are prerequisites, so students know them
already. We do not need to teach those skills. Research says that if we know that a skill is
independent and students know it already we need to test them on their prerequisite.
Unless we do not establish their prerequisite, we will not be able to teach them any
dependent skill. There are many ways to test the prerequisites, i.e. diagnostic tests, close
test, gapping exercise etc. these are the ways to diagnose students reading comprehension
abilities. E.g. If the student is unable to read even very simple words then we could not
teach them complex reading skills i.e. comprehension. So it is important for the teacher to
arrange their sequence of instruction in this order.
5. Sequence specific tasks for the students.

In essay writing, if we set our objective that students will be able to write a persuasive
essay after 20 lessons, then we need to identify enabling skills for each lesson. Then we
need to identify the task according to those enabling skills. E.g. if your objective is to
write an argumentative essay, the first enabling skill for it would be logical reasoning, the
second is the difference between fallacy and logical argument, third is the writing skill,
fourth is appropriate vocabulary etc. All these skills should be in your mind, you have to
135
list down these things when using task analysis model. After doing this, you have to
sequence your instruction and then you will identify which tasks should be given to the
students in a sequence. You have to keep in mind your terminal objectives, prerequisites
and intermediate objectives. Do remember that intermediate objectives would be much
more than the terminal objectives and the prerequisites.
So, task analysis model is a very important model as it helps the teacher to identify prerequisites;
it helps the teachers to subdivide the whole unit into small pieces and see which dependent
enabling skills need to be developed in students.
Individual Educational Plan and Task Analysis:

Task analysis is important to cater for individual learning needs. Individual educational plans are
usually opposite to inclusion. In inclusion, we say that there is same learning for all the students.
Individual educational plans are basically constructed for the children who have additional
learning needs. There are students with different abilities in your class and you are teaching them
by using same strategies, so it means we are not going to do justice with the students who have
different learning needs. When we talk about individual learning needs and additional learning
needs, it is not necessary that it should be based on the IQ level of the students. There are
different students in your class with different prerequisites; you need to test those prerequisites
and if the students do not have them, it is the responsibility of the teacher to teach them those
independent skills. So in individual educational plan, there is frequent use of task analysis model.
Being teachers, we need to make individual educational plans for all the students who have
additional learning needs.
136
“Information processing Theory and Graphic Organization”

Lecture # 20
Outline:
 Information Processing Theory (IPT)
 Facts of IPT
 Elaboration
 Methods of elaboration
- Drawings
- Metaphors and analogies
 Summarizing in your own words
- Questioning
 Ways to use visual tools
- Brainstorming
- Suggestions for brainstorming
- Comparing and contrasting
- Classification
- Table thinking tool
Declarative knowledge is consists of facts, concepts and generalization. Now the question is how
to develop the deep understanding of the children. For deep understanding of children
information processing theory is very important.
Information Processing Theory (IPT)

Nothing is learnt unless it is in long term memory. Working memory is our conscious memory.
Stimuli hit Working memory if

information is Long term 137
sensory register memory
attended to
We have short term and long term memory. Between both of them there is working memory.
The interesting thing is that our emphasis is on working memory. Working memory is our
conscious memory. We do not know much about working memory and how it operates. This
theory says that every learning should be the part of long term memory. Automation is the
ultimate learning. Short term learning is named as sensory register in information processing
theory.
Facts of IPT
 Humans can keep only 5-9 unrelated pieces of information in their working memory at
one time.
 If most or all the space in working memory is taken up in lower level skills, higher level
thought such as analysis cannot take place. Space is limited in child’s mind, teacher have
to see this that how he can utilize this space.
 By organizing information into related ‘chunks’ much more information can be held in
working memory.
 Images are much economical and take less space in our working memory than ideas
expressed in words.
A picture is worth a thousand words.
A lot of information can be communicated through a picture. Its example is that if we
want to know the address of some place it will be easier to know through map than the
oral direction. Nowadays universities or organizations show their maps on their websites
for the comfort of the people. Visual tools are very important and significant in learning.
Teachers need to use visual tools very often in instruction to ensure learning.
Increase in the space of working memory
138
First thing is elaboration. It is very commonly used teaching strategy which helps in developing
space in working memory at the same time information in working memory goes into long term
memory.
Elaboration
 It is the form of rehearsal but different from maintenance rehearsal (cramming). The
former allows us to hold information in conscious working memory just long enough to
decide what to do with it. It is not suited for long term storage.
 Elaboration means adding on. It requires conscious and deliberate thought during which
we relate the new information with something already known and understood.
Elaboration is different from maintenance rehearsal. What is maintenance rehearsal? When we

learn something, we do some kind of drill to maintain it. When we do or cram something to
remember it is called maintenance rehearsal. It never becomes the part of long term memory.
When we put something in working memory through maintenance rehearsal it will last till the
time it needs.
Methods of Elaboration
Drawings
Children read some text, one situation is that teacher may ask some questions at the end and we
can assess the understanding level of children. Second situation is that teacher may ask them to
show the pictorial demonstration of the text. It is adding on. Adding on must not be confusing.
Same theme can be represented differently.
Metaphors and Analogies

There is an example of elaboration through metaphor. Teacher taught the concept of cell to
students and then ask them to find some metaphors. Below is the table on the left side there are
the parts of cell and on right side there are metaphors of football. Different groups gave their
different thoughts one group said that cell is like a football game. In the cell the central point is
139
nucleus which holds the whole activity. In football it is the referee who controls the game. Goal
keeper’s function is also like a cell wall. Mitochondria gives energy to cell. Sports drink also do
the same functions. Maybe the teacher have used the task analysis model but they asked the
students to elaborate. All the knowledge in working memory will become the part of long term
memory through elaboration.
Cell Football
Nucleus Referee
Ribosome’s Red and Yellow cards given by the referee for
infractions
Cell Wall Goal keeper
Cell Membrane Defensive player
Cytoplasm Game field
Mitochondria Sports drinks
Summarizing in own words
Questioning
Teacher may ask students to construct questions. Questions of students are more important than
the questions of teachers. For example teacher teaches the students a biology lesson and then ask
the students to construct four such questions which are not in the book and also not discussed in
the class.
Definitely children think a lot because they have to construct those questions which are not in
the book but related to the text. Asking question is a skill. It is a skill on student part also.
Questioning is very important tool for learning. It helps to take information from the working
memory to long term memory. Questioning has a lot of significance value. In elaboration it is an
effective strategy.
Ways to use Visual tools
Brainstorming
To describe a thing, a common tool is brainstorming. In brainstorming we write the central
information in the middle and than ask students to come up with their ideas, we write every thing
around that central place. The important thing in brainstorming is that you do not reject ideas.
140
We write every idea, the step of omission comes later. For example we take the central idea of a
Fish. And ask the children to come up with their ideas regarding Fish, maybe some children give
relevant or some give irrelevant thoughts. Teacher should remain relaxed while doing
brainstorming. In brainstorming we are inviting ideas from students. There will be noise at that
time, teacher must be relaxed.
Suggestions
1. Relax
2. Don’t worry about organization
3. Think quantity
4. Be positive, don’t criticize
5. Keep ideas simple
6. Develop all ideas
7. Keep working
8. Combine to improve each other’s ideas
Brainstorming is an effective strategy when you are going to gain ideas or describe something. It
maybe used for both purposes.
Comparing and Contrasting

Another visual tool is comparing and contrasting. There are a lot of similar or contrast things in
spring and summer season. A very important tool for comparing and contrasting is Venn
Diagram. Depending upon the concepts, if we have two concepts we use two circles to compare
and contrast. Overlapping area will be that area where we will write the similarities. And the
areas that are not overlap we will write different things in that.
Classification
This is the visual tool to classify something.
Living Things
Plants Animals
141
Non flowering Unicellular

Flowering Plants Multicellular
Plants
In description form we will have seven unrelated units. This whole information may be
presented in one unit in the form of a picture. Children will be able to learn many other things.
Images occupy less space in our working memory. Being a teache, it is always good to use
visual tools.
Table thinking tool.
This tool is for thinking skills. It will be easier to relate the things in the form of table. Below is
an example of table thinking tool.
Gas Liquid Solid

May be compressed Take shape Can not be compressed
Steam Water Ice
Cylinder, balloon Containers Independent structures
Average students can act like high achievers by using visual tools.
142
“Models of Lesson Organization”

Lecture # 21
Lecture objectives:
By the end of the lecture, you will have reflected upon:
 Presentation as a useful teaching method to teach concepts and procedures.
 Modes of presentation i.e. Inductive and deductive.
 Two models of lesson organization i.e. Concept analysis model and Advance
organizer.
 Identified the use of two models.
“Presentation is a teaching method where a teacher presents concepts and procedures. This
method is used when we are expecting from the students to learn concepts and procedures. In a
Task Analysis Model, the children learn procedures, but their conceptual understanding also
takes place.
The two methods, Concept Analysis Model and Advanced Organizer are used to teach different
concepts to the students. Concepts are basically ideas; they could be one word ideas, two
word ideas, any statements or generalizations. Some generalizations could be taught through
presentations.
Examples of one word concepts are: Beauty, food, energy etc.
“Modes of presentation: Deductive & Inductive”
1. Deductive mode (General to specific)

2. Inductive mode (Specific to general)
Example of deductive and inductive method:
143
Deductive method:
Teacher tells the students that ‘Water is necessary for plants to grow’. Now the teacher asks
them to prove it. He gives them a task to put two plants in the sunlight. Give water daily to one
of the plants, and observe them after 15 days and tell which plant grows and which one is
withered. Now the students are proving that plants really need water to grow.
Inductive Method:
Here the teacher does not tell the students that water is necessary for plants to grow. He directly
gives an experiment to the students; to put two plants in sunlight for 15 days, give water to one
of them and leave the other as it is in sun. Give a result after 15 days that what happen to the
plants. Now after experimenting, the students will give a conclusion that plants need water to
grow, if they give such conclusion then it is definitely an inductive mode of presentation.
Deductive and inductive are not only the modes of presentation but modes of experiments
also.
“Concept Analysis Model as a planning tool”

Concept Analysis Model is a very good model to teach different concepts to the students.
There are five components of a Concept Analysis Model:

Concepts have:
1. A Name
2. Definition
3. Characteristics/ Critical attributes
4. Examples and non-examples
5. Hierarchy: it means that some concepts are higher, lower or lies on that concept.
- Superordinate concepts: The concepts which are at upper level.
- Coordinate concepts: The concepts which come under that concept.
- Subordinate concepts: The concepts which are of lower level.
144
Example: Concept of Noun

Name: Noun
Definition: Name of a thing, place, person or abstract entities (Like
birth, happiness, magnetism)
Characteristics: Endings (painter, scientist, magnetism), most have plurals.
Examples: River, capitalism, capital, Kamran etc.
Non-examples: Eating, walking, standing, writing, reading etc.
Superordinate concepts: Noun comes in Parts of Speech; a Part Of Speech is itself a
concept. So, noun lies under this concept.
Coordinate concepts: All the concepts which lie in parts of speech are all parallel
to noun. E.g. adjectives, verbs or adverbs etc.
Subordinate concepts: The concepts which comes under noun are subordinate
concepts. So, the two types of nouns i.e. common noun and
proper noun are subordinate concepts of the concept
NOUN.
Example: Two teachers are going to teach a concept of noun, one is following deductive
mode of presentation and the other is using inductive mode.
1. Deductive mode teacher (example):

Teacher will tell definition of a noun to the students which is usually told in
schools is “a noun is a name of a person, place or thing”. Then he will give
examples to the students i.e. table, chair, book, board, school, river, Pakistan etc.
the students learn this information about a concept of noun. Some teachers will try
to give a better definition and will include abstract entities as well.
2. Inductive mode teacher (example):

The teacher who is following inductive mode of presentation will ask the students
to tell names of different things. He will write all the names on the board and ask
145
the students to identify the things which end with “ism” or “ist”. He will make
groups of both. The students will identify them and then the teacher will ask them
to tell the commonalities in them. Students will make a definition of a noun
together. This is inductive mode of presentation. The results which the students
gather from the discussion will help the students to create the definition. Teacher
will ask them the characteristics of those things. Teacher will ask the students
about the subordinate or coordinate concepts of noun instead of telling them.
Teachers can use either inductive mode or deductive mode, but the important thing is to include
all the things that are present in the Concept Analysis Model.
Why this model is called Concept Analysis Model?

A concept must be dealt with bits and parts. Every aspect of a concept must be addressed. E.g. its
definition, examples, critical attributes or superordinate, coordinate or subordinates etc. So, if
any concept is taught by only its definition and examples, it means that we are not doing justice
with that particular concept.
Example: Concept of Food

Name: Food
Definition: Food is any substance consumed to provide nutritional
support for the body. It is usually of plant or animal origin.
Characteristics: i. Most foods have taste. Though water is tasteless.
ii. Some food is cooked while other not.
iii. Sour foods contain organic acids.
Examples: Vegetables, fruits, milk, egg, fish, rice, water, wheat,

chewing gum, chocolate and many more.
Non-examples: Animal feed, live animals (unless being prepared for sale in
a market), plants prior to harvesting is not a food, medicinal
products, tobacco, narcotics, cosmetics etc.
Superordinate concepts: Health & nutrition, food science, food technology.
Coordinate concepts: Diet, dietary habits.
146
Subordinate concepts: Food pyramid, organic food, whole food, natural food, junk
food.
So, we have decided that whenever we are going to teach a concept to the students, we need to
analyze that thoroughly in terms of its definition, characteristics, examples, non-examples and
hierarchy. And we need to ensure that our students understand all these related things regarding a
concept so that they can understand that particular concept.
Advance Organizer Model with example:
This is a model which provides you the big picture completely. E.g. If students are going to learn
the concept of food, then teacher must have the complete picture of it. You can observe the
graphic picture below:
Fruits Oil
Grains Beans
Plants
Vegetables Seeds
FOOD
Fish Egg
Rea meat Milk
Animals
Yogurt
This picture must be presented to the students before teaching them the concept of food. i.e. in
advance you present the whole thing to the students. Graphic organizer is also known as concept
map. Advance organizer can be in the form of graphic organizer, tables and schemes.
147
Advance Organizer Model:
Advance graphic organizer has three major components or attributes.

- Advance organizer is a statement of those elements that the learner will be required to
master in a lesson. i.e. it may be a statement or word e.g. food, noun etc.
- Advance organizer presents ‘big picture’ to establish relationship between different
concepts.
- Advance organizer model is based upon deductive learning.
Advance organizer model is useful for the teachers to communicate their expectations to the
students that what actually they are going to learn.
Discussion:
Advance organizer model uses deductive approach but it is part of deduction that when things
are isolated, they need to be integrated also. E.g. food. In the example of food, all the things are
isolated in the big picture above. When we will integrate it we have to reinforce the concept of
food again to the students. After doing all this, a teacher can move to the other concepts to teach.
After integrating all the components of a concept, a teacher can ask the students to describe the
concept of food in their own words. It is very different from concept analysis model. The major
difference in advance organizer and concept analysis model is that when a teacher follows
concept analysis model. he has to tell the characteristics, examples, non-examples and hierarchy
of a concept. While following advance organizer model, a teacher don’t need to give
characteristics, examples, non-examples or hierarchy or even the definition of the concept as
well. A teacher only needs to present all those things and students have to understand it. So in
advance organizer model, teachers don’t need to follow all the things that are followed in
concept analysis model.
Advance organizer gives teachers a big picture; they have taught all the components of that big
picture to the students by isolating them. After teaching the concepts, the concepts need to be
148
integrated. Concept analysis model is the best model to integrate all the components of a
concept.
Advance Organizer Model can be used to teach:
- Any concept that has a big picture.
- In mathematics, only concepts are not important, procedures are also important.
Students need to learn procedures and logic. If students have got the concept but they
are unable to follow a certain procedure. Now here, advance organizer model cannot
be used such successfully. Task analysis model is a very good model to teach
mathematics.
- A teacher must know what are the concepts where advance organizer model can be
used and where it can’t.
- Advance organizer and Concept analysis model are very good models to teach
different themes in science, social studies, Islamiyat and even in languages.
Do remember that no method is always useful. Every model has its contextual importance.
149
Multi-Methodology as an Instructional Process

Lecture # 22
Outlines
1. Multi Methodology
2. Right vs. Left
3. Implications for teaching.
4. Creativity and Right- hemisphere Objectives
5. Learning Styles
6. Harvard Gardner’s Multiple Intelligence
Being teachers we must know how human mind perceive the classroom knowledge? How does
human mind work? And where the information store in the brain. We will talk about the
importance and use of multi methodology. Our mind works in a peculiar way, it has right and left
hemispheres. Childs mind is on developmental phase till the age of 8. By the age of 8 these sides
are well developed.
Multi Methodology
Different types of mental functions occur in the left and right hemisphere. Our brain is composed
of right and left hemisphere. And these are responsible for different kinds of functions. Below
are some functions carried out by right and left hemisphere.
Right vs. Left
Right Left
1.Visual 1.Verbal
2.Nonverbal 2.Logical
3.Spatial 3.Categorical
150
4.divergent thinking 4.Convergent thinking

5.Intuition 5.Detail
Divergent thinking is more creative. Divergent thinking is outside the box thinking. For
creativity divergent thinking is very important. We do not think in fixed manner. We can ask
some strange questions. Right hemisphere is responsible for this type of thinking.
Convergent thinking is more focused. For example we have a lot of different facts and ideas
and we carried out some results of them or logically converge them. Evaluative, analytical and
logical thinking includes in it. This type of thinking is done by left hemisphere.
Guessing is basically intuition. Some people have intuitive feeling. Their right brain is prominent
in this function.
When we see some one we recognize him by face this is the function of right brain. But to
associate the name with face is the responsibility of left part of brain. Some people can
remember both name and face it means that their both sides are working equally. Those who
remember the faces it means that their visual and spatial part is strong and verbal part is weak.
Implications for teaching.

 Teachers should plan instruction to enhance both hemispheres.
 Teachers persistently emphasis objectives and instruction that focus on the left side
of brain. We always talk about creative thing and synthesis in higher level of
Bloom’s taxonomy. What happens in actual classroom?
A research was conducted and it was reported that teachers mostly focus on left hemisphere of
children. In left hemisphere there is logical thinking, verbal intelligence, details and convergent
thinking. As a result of such instruction left brain function dominates. There is imbalance
between right and left brain. For teachers it is important to construct their instruction in such a
way that s suitable of the development of right as well as left brain. When we talk about right
side there is the function of creativity and divergent. The problem for the teacher is to construct
such objectives that can be measureable. There is a difficulty to measure the creativity.
151
Performance objectives are those objectives that are measureable. A teacher must work hard to
create these kind of objectives.
Creativity and Right- hemisphere Objectives
Create a story by using a story starter, in which all the physical elements of the story
starter are incorporated into the plot.
This is the function of divergent thinking. Objective must be in the form that it can be measured.
If we will ask the question Create a story of your own choice? It will not be the performance
objective. It is vague it can not be measured. Maybe a child writes a brief story or someone else
writes a skillful story. So our objective should measure the creativity of all kinds of children. But
we must give the space to the children for their divergent thinking.
Using only three primary colors, create a painting that includes all the elements of the
modern style.
Create a brochure to signify cell travel.
A teacher must create such objectives that help the students to develop both their right and left
side of brain. And even in their practical life after school the will be able to use both sides of
their brain.
Learning is not appropriate, if both sides of brain are not working appropriately.
Multimethodology
Multi means many and methodology means collection of different methods.
It provides instructionally rich classroom by making use of a variety of teaching methods and
techniques like:
1. Project learning
2. Inquiry/student research
3. Lecture
152
4. Demonstrations
5. Videos
When we plan a unit we must have arrange of different methods in our planning.
We can use techniques or different tool in classroom they will make up for multi methodology.
Maybe we start our lecture with brainstorming we will wind it up. Then we will give them 5
minutes lecture or we will demonstrate something to them. Maybe we will show them a video of
2 3 minutes. There are multiple intelligence in children. Attention time of small children is 10
minutes. For elder ones it maybe of 15 minutes. If we have a 40 minutes lecture time and we are
only lecturing to the student and there attention time is not more than 15 minutes. They will
distract after sometime. Variation is the quality of a good lesson. There must be some techniques
after short intervals that may address to various learning styles. We may use different strategies
in 30 seconds also. How it can be happens. Its example is that we can show a 30 second visual
clip to the students and we may ask them to see it for 30 second and identify the things in this
clip. This is also a strategy. To be a good teacher it is necessary to use different strategies.
Because it has a lot of benefits. And students also enjoy this type of learning.
Learning Styles:
Voice, Lectures,
pitch, Auditory discussions
speed
Learning Moving,
Teachers’ styles doing,
body touching
language
Diagrams Kinesthetic/t Get
and Visual actile distracted
illustration easily in
s lectures
There are three learning styles
153
1. Auditory
2. Visual
3. Tactile
Auditory is related to hearing. Children with auditory learning style enjoy lectures and
discussions. They enjoy listening. Voice pitch matters a lot for these children they do not
understand only visual tools. In every class we have auditory, visual and tactile learners. Teacher
will use its voice as a tool for the auditory learners. Fast speed of the voice of teacher will be
disturbing for this type of learners.
Demonstration method is a very good method for visual learners. It is said that good lecturers are
those who use audio visual aids with their lecturing. A lecture could be useful with the visual
learners only if they are accompanied with audio visual aids. Diagram illustration is also very
important for this type of children. Teacher’s facial expression also matters for these children.
Teacher’s body language does matter for these children.
Tactile learners are those who can learn by touching. Kinesthetic learners are those who are most
disadvantage learners in the classrooms. Doing is very important for these children. Teacher
must give the opportunity to the learners for experiment. We have students who have different
learning styles. Some children do not have predominant learning style they change themselves
according to the situations. Some learners have distinct learning styles. Being teachers we have
to be sensitive according to the needs of children. Multi methodology will be helpful for all kinds
of learners.
Harvard Gardner’s Multiple Intelligence
Intelligence is the ability to do a lot of mental work. Harvard Gardner challenges this thing that
ability is not of same kind. There are 8 different kinds of intelligence.
It is said that you get job because of your IQ and you sustain job because of your EQ (emotional
IQ).
Harvard Gardner’s multiple intelligences.
154
S# Intelligence Description
1. Visual/Spatial Ability to perceive the visual (puzzle building,
charts, graphs, painting etc.)
2. Verbal/Linguistics Ability to use words, Good auditory skills.
Generally elegant speakers.
3. Logical/Mathematical Ability to use logic, reason, classification, problem
solving
4. Bodily Kinesthetic Ability to control body movements and handle
objects carefully. Sports, dancers, artisans.
5. Musical/Rhythmic Ability to produce and appreciate music.
Remembering melodies, singing, whistling.
6. Interpersonal Ability to relate and understand others(it uses
verbal and nonverbal language)
7. Intrapersonal Ability to self-reflect and being aware of one’s
inner state. It is about recognizing own strengths
and weaknesses, evaluating own thinking patterns.
8. Naturalist The ability to explore nature
Some students are very good in interpreting the graphs. This is because of higher spatial
intelligence of the children. In childhood teachers have to work on all 8 types of intelligences.
Children with verbal ability are the elegant speakers. They know how to use the words. They
know how to speak.
Third type of children is very good in problem solving. They can reason. Their convergent
thinking is very good. They talk with logical sequence. They can classify the things.
Children in forth category are good sports persons. Dancers includes in this category. Control on
the body movements is the part of this intelligence.
Children who appreciate music have musical intelligence. They can recognize the melodies.
Some people can relate or communicate with the people easily. We feel happy to interact people
with smile. We can provide information in two ways happily or coldly. This is the interpersonal
skill. Communicate with out expression is another thing. Verbal communication is important but
nonverbal communication is also very important. Being teachers we need to develop the
interpersonal intelligence of our students. Because we are social beings we do not live in
isolation. We must know how to relate with other people.
155
Sometimes we do not know about our strengths and weaknesses. Intrapersonal skills mean
knowing our own selves. And accordingly we make our future. Philosophers have a lot of
intrapersonal intelligence. It is time consuming to develop intrapersonal intelligence.
Some people are very much concerned about nature and their surroundings. They love to be with
nature. They try to explore nature. Being teachers it is our duty to improve different intelligences
of all the students.
156
“Concept of Child”
Lecture # 23
Outlines
- Objectives
- What is a child?
- Some facts about child Development
- Developmental milestones
- Milestones in Early years
- General milestones in early childhood education
- Piaget’s stages of cognitive development
- Milestones for 4 year old Children
- Milestones for 5 years old child
Objectives
 By the end of the session, you will have:

 Reflected upon your own image of a Child.
 Reflected upon the concept of holistic Development of a child.
 Identified general milestones in early years.
World is full of the images of the children. There are a lot of images in advertisements and
pictures. These convey the message of the thought about children. Society is the extension of
school and school is the extension of society. Teacher is also the product of this society and he
also has some image about child. And he device his teaching methods accordingly. If the teacher
think a child as blank slate whatever he writes on it, it will be the part of his personality. Our
teaching method will be according to this thought.
157
What is a child?
Is a child a “tabula rasa” an empty vessel to be filled by knowledge? (John Locke)

In some journals there are very terrible images of children one image is that children are the
containers of poison. Thought is that teachers, parents and society all put their poison in the
child. We can debate on this image. If the child is an empty vessel then there will be poison if we
fill it with poison.
Child is a biologically learned being. What is learned by one organism may be transmitted
biologically to others. (Darwin)
Child has the capacity to learn and transmit that knowledge to others.
Child is a natural discoverer. (Bruner)
Are all children perfectly designed organisms, who are ready to learn from their
surroundings? (Rousseau)
It means that learning depends upon the environment. If the environment is rich for the learning
child will learn more and easily. For example a child lives in a jungle his learning will be
different from the child living in a village.
A child is people who can learn according to his/her own interests. (John Dewey)
It is necessary to discover our image because to reflect out teaching methods.
Some facts about child Development
 At birth, a baby’s brain already has 100,000,000,000 cells. This is about the same number
of stars in the Milky Way. It is very interesting fact.
 Unlike the rest of a new baby’s body. The brain is not complete at birth. In order to start
working, the cells need to communicate with each other. As a baby starts to experience
158
life, connections are made between cells- the more connections are there, the more the
brain can do. Brain development continues till the age of 8. Brain develop very fast in
the first year after birth. The process slowdown in the later years.
 A baby’s brain develops so fast that by age two a child who is developing normally has
the same number of connection as an adult has. By the three, a child has TWICE as many
brain connections as an adult.
Developmental milestones
Developmental milestones are set of functional skills or age-specific tasks that most children can
do at a certain age range.
All children are unique they have their own developmental milestones. For example some start
waling very soon some take a lot of time.
Milestones in Early years

In this topic we will talk about the developmental milestones of 30-36 months child who is ready
for pre schooling. In our government schools age for a child in first class is 4 years and in many
private schools, age is of 3 years. There are no hard and fast rules. Some parents sent their
children to school even before this age.
A 30 months old child who is in preschool can hold in mind a whole sequence of spatial maps
and know where things are in their environment. For example child knows the way to his
classroom. He knows the address of his house. If there is a park near to his house he can tell the
way to it. If we want the intellectual development of the child we must tell them to do their work
on their own.
A preschool child of 36 months can now hold two different emotions in his mind at the same
time, such as being sad that he spilled ice cream on his clothes but glad that he’s at a birthday
party.
General milestones in early childhood education
159
Gross motor:
It is using large group of muscles to sit, stand, walk, run, etc. keeping balance and changing
positions. Development of these skills is very important in preschool or early childhood
education. Its example is jumping exercises, stretching the arms. Its main purpose is to develop
their muscles.
Fine motor:
It is about using hands to be able to eat, draw, dress, play, write and do many other things.
Cognitive:
Cognitive development is related to thinking kills including learning, understanding, problem-
solving, reasoning and remembering. Child learns language out of the need. Language is
something which helps in development. Use of language is very important for thinking skills.
Language:
It is about speaking, using body language and gestures, communicating and understanding what
others say. In preschool focus is on speaking.
Social:
Interacting with others, having relationships with family, friends and teachers, cooperating and
responding to the feelings of the others.
In preschools our curriculum should not be subject oriented our focus must be to achieve these
milestones.
In social development very important thing is sharing. Some children make friends very easily
some cannot. It is all because of their opportunities in preschools.
Piaget’s stages of cognitive development

- Sensorimotor
- Preoperational
- Concrete operational
- Formal operational
160
In the context of preschool it includes two stages:
Sensorimotor stage
Preoperational stage
In our Pakistani schools we focus on only on the stage of preoperational.
Piaget’s stages of Cognitive development

Stage Age Major Features
Sensorimotor Birth to 2 years Infants use their bodies to
form cognitive structures.
Preoperational 2 to 7 years Use of symbols, rapid
language growth.
Concrete operational 7 to 11 years Can reason about physical
objects
Formal operational 11+ years Abstract thinking leads to
reasoning with symbols
Milestones for 4 year old Children
Physical development
It includes gross motor and fine motor development.

A four years child can skip on one foot, can draw “Man”, can cut with scissors (not well), can
wash and dry face, can dress self except ties, can stand broad jump, can throw ball and a child
can walk and run with high motor drive.
Cognitive and language development

A child who is 4 years old uses complete sentences, has 1540 words vocabulary, asks endless
questions, learning to generalize, highly imaginative, dramatic, can draw recognizable simple
objects.
Social development
 Cooperative
161
 Enjoys cooperative play

 Highly social
 May play loosely organized group games
 Emotional behavior of four year old child
 A four years old child seems sure of himself. At time a four years old child show out of
bounds behavior, often negative.
 We should give controlled freedom to four year old child.
Milestones for 5 years old child
Physical development
A five years old child hops and skips, dresses without help, has good balance and smoother
muscle action, skates, rides wagon and scooter, print simple letters, handedness established, ties
shoes and girls small muscle development is about 1 year ahead of boys.
Intellectual development
 Has almost vocabulary of 2,000 words.
 Tells long tables.
 Carries out directions well.
 Reads own name, counts to 10, asks endless different questions can do fiction-lying.
Social development
Highly cooperative
Has special “friends”.
Likes, enjoys simple table games.
Observes school rules
Feels pride in carrying out some responsibility.
Emotional Behaviors of 5 years old children

 Self-assured
162
 Stable
 Home centered
 Likes to associate with mother
 Capable, of some self-criticism
“Early Years Education”
163
Lecture # 24
Lecture objectives:
 Reflected upon the importance of knowing developmental milestones.
 Identified role of partnership education in early years.
 Reflected upon the use of play in early childhood education.
 Identified different kinds of play in ECE.
Outline:
 Pre-schooling
 The important things in pre-school education
 Pre-schooling research
 Importance of milestones
 Brain development milestones/ activities
- Morning greeting
- Fingerplay in preschool
- Story time
- Free play
- Snack and circle time activity
- Art activity
 Physical development milestones
- Jumping
- Finger play
- Art activity
 Social development milestones/ activities
- Seating arrangement of class
- Physical development
- Snack & circle time activity
164
Pre-school and infant educations are different from other education. Child’s rights convention of
1989 has mentioned that “Education is basic right of every child.” It is a basic right of every
child but it is usually considered as part of formal education. Different countries have different
age levels of formal education i.e. some countries provide it at age 6, some at 7 or 8 etc. The age
before formal education or proper schooling in which the child learns or gets basic education is
known as early childhood education.
Pre-schooling:
The names that different countries use for pre-schooling or early childhood education is:
- In British English, Nursery School or simply “nursery.”
- In the Unites States pre-school and pre K are used.
- In Pakistan, there are different names to be used in private sector. i.e. Montessori
education, kindergarten education, play group, toddler or kids’ education etc.
- In public sector, the term mostly used is “Kachi Class”
The names may be different but umbrella term for it is “Early Childhood Education.”
Developmental milestones of pre-school education are different from those of formal education.
The most important things in pre-school education:

- Physical development, in which cross motor development and fine motor development is
included.
- Cognitive development, mathematics and language development can be part of it or it can
be separated.
- Similarly, social and emotional development.
Pre-schooling research:
A study by Stanford University on 14,000 Kindergarteners revealed that while there is a
temporary cognitive boost in pre-reading and math, pre-school holds detrimental effects on
social development and cooperation.
Milestones in early years:
165
Here is a question, which will help in understanding.
1
By age 3 2 , the average child can balance on each foot for how long?
- 3 seconds
- 4 seconds Answer is: 3 seconds
- 6 seconds
- 2 minutes
At age 3 years, the average child can name how many colours?
- 0
- 1 Answer is: 1
- 4
- 8
By age 4 years, most children can ….

- Copy a square
- Copy a circle Answer is: copy a circle
- Copy a cross
- Draw a person with 6 body parts
What is learnt from the above questions?
If we are going to teach in early childhood school, what have we learnt?

Being a teacher, I need to know different milestones for early childhood education to:
1. Plan age appropriate teaching and learning activities.
2. Carry out fair assessment of young children.
3. Give useful feedback to children and their parents.
4. Ensure holistic development of children.
166
Being teachers, it is important for us to know early year milestones and we need to device our
activities; teaching as well as learning activities according to those identified early year
milestones.
Brain Development activities:

- Morning greeting: There are brain cells in the minds of the children, but the connection
between these cells are missing. This morning greeting provides the environment which
helps in building the connections. The important role in this regard is of language.
- Fingerplay in pre-school: By a couple of month of age, babies can process the

emotional colours of language (prosody).
- In fact, toddlers can memorize nursery rhymes because rhymes have prosody. Fingerplay
is important in developing connections in brain. As the preschool teacher raises her voice
an octaves draws out her vowels, the child’s brain responds by sending even more
chemical and electrical impulses across the synapses.
- Story time needs to be an integral part of early years of education. Because through
story, a child gets language development, social development and social interaction.
- Free play: It is not necessary that every school follows teacher-oriented activities i.e. the
teacher always tells a story. But a teacher must give the students free time so that they
can do something in groups either they could play together. Research says, “During free
play, pre-school children interact with one another. As they communicate, whether
through beginning language or more sophisticated use of words, the neurons in their
brains are making more connections, critical for reinforcing learning.”
- Snack & circle time activity: This activity is important because the children can interact
with one another more easily while having their snacks. Their social interaction is more
at this time and most importantly, they learn sharing here; sharing of ideas in adult life
comes only if someone experiences these things in early childhood. Sharing at early ages
starts with little things e.g. snacks, toffees, chips, biscuits, lunch etc. If the children do not
167
share these little things at early ages then they would not share their ideas in their future
lives. So, snack time activity is very helpful in learning of vocabulary, sentence
construction, and their social development.
- Circle time activity: As the early childhood teacher focuses her attention on each
individual child in the large group activity, the child must think about the topic for the
day. The child’s brain will be active as she/he retrieves from memory something special.
- Art activity: Art is very important in early childhood education as it helps in brain
development.
Physical Development Milestones:
- Jumping: A teacher must give the students the opportunity for jumping exercise. They
are not jumping alone; there are other students as well. So this activity is not only for
physical development but social interaction as well.
- Fingerplay: When the students are learning rhymes, they must always be taught through
actions. Its purpose is brain development and mortar development. When the children use
their mortar muscles and fin muscles, as a result their mortar development takes place.
- Art activities: All art activities are part of physical development. Art should be an
essential component in pre-school education because it is directly related to physical
development.
Social Development Activities:
- Seating arrangement of class: Seating arrangement of a class should be in such a

manner that the children can easily interact with one another and they could work
together. They could share ideas.
168
- Physical development: Through physical development activities, the children gets social
interaction as well.
- Snack time & circle activity: In snack time & circle activity, the children share their
ideas with each other. So it also results in social development.
- Vygotsky’s theory: Vygotsky’s theory included four major ideas. They are:
2. Language plays an important role in cognitive development.
3. Learning can lead development.
4. Development cannot be separated from the social context in which it occurs.
- It is very important for us to understand this theory and to use it in our teaching. Because
this theory is very much applicable in early childhood education. Teachers must focus on
language development. Because learning can lead to development. Teachers must
focus on social context because social interaction is helpful in social development of the
children. When social development takes place, then ultimately, children increase their
vocabulary and language development. Vygotsky’s theory provides us with an integrated
perspective that teachers must provide such opportunities to children in early childhood
education which leads to language development. Language cannot be developed in
isolation.
169
“Big ideas and core concepts”

Lecture # 25
Objectives:
By the end of this session, you will have reflected upon:
 The importance of focusing on big ideas to design instruction
 The importance of generating Core concepts
 Using Core Concepts
 The importance of Generative Concepts
 Essential Questions
Outline:
 Rethinking Curriculum
 Information Processing Theory
 Core concepts
 Generating Core Concepts
 Generative topics
 Essential questions
- Wiggin’s and Mctighe’s essential questions
Case of a Dedicated Teacher
Saima is a very dedicated teacher. She has been working as a Science teacher in elementary
school for last 6 years. However every year she struggles to finish the subject content.
This is not only Saima’s problem but also many teachers want to ensure learning in class room
and use different techniques also but their course is not covered.
What to be done by Saima?
Teachers get little assistance from textbook publishers who seem to simply add new concepts
rather than reorganize content to effectively integrate new ideas with older ideas.
170
(Schmidt & McKnight, 1997)

The missing thing in are textbook is disorganized material. There is no integration between
subjects or courses. All subjects are isolated. Because of these reasons teachers are unable to
cover the syllabus.
A brief survey was conducted in this regard and simple question was asked from 30 teachers.
The question and their response rates are given below:
Concern of 30 teachers from Lahore
What is your major concern regarding teaching?

A. To make children understand the concepts.
B. To cover the syllabus
C. Both A & B
D. Holistic learning of children regardless of time frame
24 teachers went for the choice “C” 6 chose option “D”.

Teacher mostly concern about the completion of syllabus. Administrators, school heads and
curriculum developers must help the teachers so that they must ensure learning and their syllabus
is also covered.
Lesson Learnt
- Teachers want to teach in depth but want to cover the syllabus too.
- Few teachers are not concerned about time frame. They want to ensure holistic learning
of children.
Is less really more?
US math textbooks include 175% more topics than do German textbooks and 350% more topics
than do Japanese textbooks.
171
US Science textbooks cover 930% more topics than do German textbooks and 433% more topics
than do Japanese textbooks
Yet both German and Japanese students outperform US students in math and Science
achievements.
(Schmidt, McKnight & Raizen 1997)
In American books there is a lot of information than Japanese and German books. But Japanese
and German students do well rather than American students. It is said that America is known for
its higher education. But schooling is better in other countries.
Three Core Beliefs
1. More is better
2. Exposing students only to information contains minimal risk.
3. Most students learn quickly, and once learning has been demonstrated further practice is
not necessary. Dempster, 1993
Rethinking Curriculum
Teachers are most important persons in the application of curriculum. Curriculum is a dead thing
teacher’s give life to it.
 A crowded curriculum makes distributed practice unlikely.

 Teachers must re-evaluate what they are teaching and attempting to cover.
 Less is more
 Deeper is better.
172
Information Processing Theory
1. Learners can learn only 5-9 chunks of information at a time.

2. Learner can process only about one new idea or concept every ten second.
3. But teachers generally expect more than this and textbook writers also include much
more than this in books.
4. Result is that teacher cover material and student try, often in vain, to retain,
understanding and using that material.
Bigger ideas are our assumptions and beliefs. We should think that what we are giving to our
students ultimately rather than giving them a bundle of information. What are the skills we want
to develop in our students?
Core concepts
 Core concepts are declarative knowledge.

They should be made quite clear to learners. Application in new level is important.
For example we teach addition to the students at lower level and they use it in their latter life.
Another example is that some people who don’t know about verb, adverb, noun and adjectives
but they are able to write very good essays. It means the information we are giving is important
in the context we are giving. In our schools the focus is on grammar. Students learn only
definitions and give the paper of definitions. Our teachers do not focus on core concepts.
Because of this reason even after the completion of BA students are unable to compose a single
letter.
Our students cannot interpret the short stories. Our students cannot summaries the novels.
Reason is again that our focus is not on the core concepts in schools. We are seeing at the given
picture and not focusing at the actual picture.
 They are central to a domain of knowledge.

 Re likely to stand the test of time.
173
The learning of core concepts is lifetime.
Generating core concepts
Its example is umbrella oenology. Our core concept is like big umbrella and there are small
umbrellas under it. Small umbrella is contextual. It’s another example is of addition. In small
umbrella may be we practice the students with two digit addition, than teachers take them to
complex addition it will be our medium umbrella, and our bigger umbrella is teaching of
multiplication. When we are teaching to the students our focus must not be the simple addition
but the multiplication. Just like this if you are teaching in the language class, you teaches them
the sentence structure not only that they can make the sentence but in long run they will be able
to write the concepts. Small umbrellas are the steps to reach the big one. Another example is that
if you are teaching social studies your ultimate goal is values. Core focus is that students can be
able to internalize these values in their characters.
Generative Topics
1. They are the topics which provide the opportunity to generate new information
from what you have just learned.
2. They are issues themes concepts ideas which provide depth, significance and
connections.
Generative topics are generated from the leant information. Students and teachers both are
interested in these topics. They are accessible and appropriate relevant. Generative topics
actually make connections.
Examples of generative topics
1. Rain forests, Global warming, endangered species

2. Concept of zero, patterns symbols size and scale
3. Conflict, power
174
4. Humour, multiple perspective, interpreting texts, folktales
Teachers need to think big generative topics need to be essential in each subject.
Generative topics need to be interesting for the teachers as well as for students.
Essential Questions
There are a lot of ways in questioning. Questions must be like this in which students are
compelled to think.
Wiggins and Mctighe’s essential questions
1. Is there enough to go around (e.g. food, clothes, water)?

2. Does art reflect culture or shape it?
3. Are mathematical ideas inventions or discoveries?
4. What do we fear?
5. Who owns what and why?
One belief is that children should have analytical mind they must know how to think.
They must know problem solving. They should know how to argue. There is another thinking
that if student have the analytical thinking and evaluative thinking, so there will not be any
change on our societal level. The reason is that if the thinking process is in isolation, it can
benefit the individual but not to the society. Analytical thinking and problem solving must be on
societal level. For this, in Wiggin’s view we should enable students to ask essential questions.
These essential questions are as given above. In his thinking we need to develop our instruction
and teaching under these questions. For example if we are teaching the topic of global warming
we can extend it by the question what do we fear regarding to our environment? Another
question is what do we own causing global warming? Do remember that every individual have a
role in controlling the global warming. We should not ignore these questions, because these
essential questions bring change in societies. If we claim that teachers are the changing agents,
than we need to address these questions. And we also need to help our children to answer these
175
questions or if not answering than at least thinking about these questions. These questions are
based on Bloom’s taxonomy, and are of higher level. These are collective questions and not for
individuals and we can debate on them.
“Essential Questions in Adolescent Teaching”
Lecture # 26
Outlines
 Objectives
 Characteristics of essential questions
 Essential questions
 Essential vs Unit question
 Adolescent brain changes
 What to teach and how to teach
 Integrated themes
Objectives
 Essential Questions
 How essential questions are different from Unit questions
 The way we learn, naturally.
 Integrated Themes
Characteristics of essential Questions

1. They go to the heart of a discipline: these questions are important as well as
controversial.
2. Recur naturally throughout one’s learning.
3. Raise other important questions.
4. Have no obvious right answer.
176
5. Are deliberately framed to provoke and sustain student interest.

6. Require divergent thinking.
When we talk about induction it means we are going from specific to generalization. We make
some hypothesis, do experiments and reach on some specific result. We do not know about the
answers of essential questions. Questions in induction also includes in essential questions.
Children need too think out of the box. The idea in divergent thinking is that no idea is a stupid
idea. Children can come up with different ideas and teachers must accept all ideas.
Essential questions are related to the lives of people.
Essential Questions
Essential question is a conceptual commitment. Selection of a question is a decision of
intent.
Teachers always identify their intent. Mainly concern of the teachers is to cover the syllabus on
time. The ask questions which are given at the end of the lessons in the books. These questions
are unit questions and not essential questions. Being effective and dedicated teachers we should
not be compromising on essential questions. Essential questions definitely ask for divergent
thinking.
Essential vs Unit Questions
Essential Question Unit Question

Must a story have a moral, hero and villain? What is the moral of story? Who is the hero in
the story?
Do we always mean what we say and say what What are sarcasm, irony and satire? How do
we mean? different genres help us in communicating
without saying what we mean?
Who is a friend? Are Pakistan and Iran good friends?
Essential questions are based on induction and unit questions are based on deduction. We need to
keep balance between both types of questions.
177
Adolescent brain Changes

 Research has now determined that remarkable changes occur in the brain during the
second decade of life.
 The understanding that adolescence is a time of profound brain growth and change is
contrary to long-held ideas that the brain was mostly fully “formed” by the end of
childhood.
 Like a computer, the maturing brain grows “circuits”-neural connections-that can
perform several tasks simultaneously and with ever-greater efficiency.
 Dopamine inputs to the PFC-a chemical messenger critical for focusing attention when
necessary to choose between conflicting options- grow dramatically during adolescence.
Children do not have attention span. Teenagers can focus on one topic for longer period of time.
Dopamine is the chemical of attention which develops in teenagers.
 Neuroanatomical evidence suggests that learning and positive experiences help build
complex, adaptive brains.
 By the end of adolescence, the human brain, the most complicated three-pound mass of
matter in the known universe, contains over 10 billion neurons and another 100 billion
support cells. The 10 billion neurons from over 100 trillion connections with each other-
more than all of the internet connections in the world.
 The brain procedures a large number of neural connections just before puberty. These
connections diminish in number throughout adolescence through a “use-it-or-lose-it”
pruning, which leads to a learner, more efficient brain.
If we will use the connections our efficiency of doing any task will increase. All children have
same structures but their growth in different areas is different. Some children go in the field of
medicine this is because the used their connections in this field. Children who do not go in the
medicine they have those connection but as they are not developed they diminish. So it means
that if we use our connections they will progress. If we will not use them they will automatically
diminish.
178
 Because of pruning, it is very important that parents do not complete academic tasks that
their children should be doing for themselves. A child’s brain will prune – or lose –
mental connections that it does not use. Therefore, it is important for pre-adolescents and
adolescents to solve academic problems themselves. Problem-solving skills will increase
in complexity with patience, and practice will strengthen neural connections.
Parents should let the children do their tasks on their own. It is common experience that poor
children have more problem solving skill than other children. Being teachers we should allow
children to solve the problems.
 Other dramatic changes occur within 10 to 15 year old children as well. These changes
impact all types of learning in the classroom and outside of it. Middle school students
tend to be energetic, enthusiastic and filled with questions and ideas. However, they also
can be disorganized, moody and filled with worry over the “smallest” slights.
At the age of adolescence children have hormonal as well as classroom changes. Because of thee
changes children start learning very fast. Children also have mood swings. They can be very
moody or disorganized inside or outside the classroom. They become angry on little things. This
can be of any age. At this age mood swings are related to brain development.
So what to teach and how to teach

 Problem solving
We teach them reflecting so that they reflect and assess their performance. And make their action
plans.
 Improving own performance
 Team work
 Experience
 Practice
These are all life skills, these are not tangible. Every person should learn these skills. If we will
learn these skills in our adolescence it will be practically helpful in our future. Practice and
experience are most important things to learn problem solving. Experiences are unique to every
179
individual. Teachers demonstrate some experience and children only observe. But observing is
not the whole thing for learning. In our schools this is a big misconception. Its example is that we
can not learn to ride bicycle or driving a car only by observing.
Integrated themes.
Our life is integrated. Through integration it will be easier for the children to ask essential
questions. We should encourage integration so that we can maximize the time. Being teachers we
must emphasis on integration. Primary school teacher should integrate two or three subjects so
that we can save the time. We must tell the students that “Subjects are not isolated entities”.
“Big Ideas & Essential Questions”

Lecture # 27
Topics:
180
1. What are different kinds of integrated Themes?

2. Forms of integration (Fogarty & Stoehr’s 1995)
Integration:
Integration means putting things together.
Definition of Integration:
“Only in education, never in the life of the farmer, sailor, merchant, physician or
laboratory experimenter, does knowledge means primarily a store of information aloof
from doing.”
JOHN DEWY
John dewy says that there is no such profession where knowledge is separable from doing or
practice. It is only education where knowledge is a set of information. We need to change this
orientation and being teachers, we need to integrate knowledge with practical skills. If students
do not get learning of skills, it means their knowledge is actually incomplete knowledge.
“The integrated curriculum is a great gift to experienced teachers. It’s like getting a new
pair of lenses that make teaching a lot more exciting and help us look forward into the next
century. It is helping students take control of their own learning.”
M. MARKUS (1991)
M. Markus’s said that although integration is “putting things together” but it is very helpful for
experienced teachers. They feel that he has provided them with extra pair of lenses and its
benefit was that their teaching becomes exciting. Teaching is very exciting for young and new
teachers because whenever we are going to do something new, so we are excited about that. But
if we do the same task or things again and again, it becomes part of our routine. But through
integration, teaching becomes excited of the experienced teachers.
There should be the reasons for integration or putting things together and there should be very
thin boundaries between different disciplines.
181
Why integration?
- Disconnection breeds apathy while integration thrives on connections.
- Integrated learning more accurately approximates the lives of human beings when
they are not in schools. We are spending a very integrated life as well. Because we are
connected with different shops, milkman, sweepers, different professions etc. There are
no disconnections or disintegration in that. But when we are going to school, there
everything is fragmented, there is no integration. There is a lot of isolation of concepts
and compartmentalization of subjects.
What is integration?
- Integration does not mean two teachers teaching their subjects simultaneously in
one classroom. If two teachers are teaching a same concept in a class, we cannot say that
it is an integrated teaching. More appropriate term for this matter is ‘team teaching.’
Team teaching is a very good teaching strategy but one must not be confused with
integration.
- A fully integrated curriculum combines disciplines in a synergistic manner that

makes the knowledge of one subject inseparable from that of another subject, with
division occurring only in the teaching of sophisticated content or vocabulary. You
cannot fully understand content of one subject if you are going to separate it from the
other subject. E.g. you cannot learn physic concepts or content unless you learn
mathematics. Similarly in chemistry, mathematics and some physics is involved.
Language is very important because it is a tool for different subjects. You cannot learn
chemistry in isolation; it needs to be there in a certain language.
Why teachers should teach in integration?
182
First reason is that we are living in the age of information technology. The knowledge in this
age of information technology is increasing exponentially. We are living in 21st century but
the structure of our schools is of 20th or even of 19th century, where there is a specific
timetable, in which the teachers have to teach everything to the students. Today, the only way
to teach the students is of integration because through integration you can save your time and
learning of the students will be contextualized.
We give the students information about a concept and they memorize it. But they are never
able to use that information. So, Teachers need to integrate knowledge with skills and
attitudes. At the same time, we need to integrate different subjects in a way that knowledge
of one subject comes inseparable from the other subject.
10 different methodologies of integration:

Fogarty and Stoehr’s (1995) ten views for integrating curriculum are the most
frequently used planning models in the field. These methods are actually models of
integration.
These 10 methodologies is divided into three forms.
Form- 1 – Fragmentation:
When a teacher list or rank topics, concepts and skills to systematically organize
curricular priorities within each subject.
183
The above are four circles which are associated with different subjects. There is no
connection in them. They are all different. They are together but not connected. These four
subjects are taught in a school timetable but at different times. So, if these four are not
connected then how fragmentation is a type of integration? Fragmentation is said to be the
very primary level of integration. This integration is done when a teacher list or rank
topics, concepts and skills to systematically organize curricular priorities within each
subject. Now a teacher is going to teach a lesson to the students, he has to decide which
lesson should be taught before it. What are the prerequisites of a lesson, and what to teach
after this lesson. So, we can say that a lesson has the integration with the previous lesson and
the upcoming lesson. A teacher must integrate knowledge and skills.
Form – 1 – Connection:
A connected methodology focuses on the details, subtitles, and interconnections within
an individual discipline. Teachers help students make connections by explicitly making
linkages between subject topics, skills, and concepts. Connection is a bit advance level
from that of fragmentation.
184
Form – 1 – Nested:
Nested integration takes advantage of natural combinations. Integration is performed by
overtly making connections or creating combinations. This could be accomplished in a
lesson on the circulatory system by having the lesson focus on both the circulatory system
and the concept of systems.
Form- 2 – Sequenced integration:

- Topics and units are taught independently, but they are arranged and sequenced to
provide a framework for related concepts.
- Teachers arrange topics so that similar units articulate. For example, graphing units
can coincide with data collection in a weather unit.
185
There are two subjects with colours green and yellow, they are with each other but not
connected. They are fragmented but sequenced. Sequenced integration is where different
subjects or disciplines are sequenced in the timetable. There is no overlapping but similar topics
are taught together. So these two subjects are not linked with each other but they are being taught
at the same time.
An important thing about sequenced integration was said by John Adams is:
“The textbook is not a moral contract that teachers are obliged to teach … teachers are
obliged to teach [students].”
JOHN ADAMS
The major concern of our teachers is to cover the syllabus, which means the textbook provided to
them must be taught completely to the students. But john Adams says that actually textbook is
not a moral contract that a teacher needs to carry out or obliged to teach. Teachers are not there
to provide students with a set of information but to teach them.
Form – 2 – Shared integration:
- The shared model brings two distinct disciplines together into a single focus. The
shared methodology overlaps concepts as the organizer.
- The teachers of the two disciplines plan their teaching, which will take place in the
individual classes together.
-
186
One subject is overlapping on the other in this integration. This teaching is not done by a single
teacher. E.g. one teacher is of physics and the other is of mathematics. They will plan their
teaching in a combined way but teach in individual classes. The aims of two teachers are same
but their subjects are different. It is not team teaching but a shared integration.
Form – 2 Webbed:
There are different subjects which are linked together as shown in the diagram below:
- Webbed curricula commonly use a thematic approach to integrate subject matter.

Broad themes such as change, cultures, discovery, environments, interactions, and
work provide a greater opportunity for teachers of various disciplines to find
common topics, concepts and skills.
For example:
Concepts Topics Categories

Change Community Adventure
187
Culture Partnership Biographies

Discovery Relationship Medieval times
Freedom Society Science fiction
One could not understand the concept of culture unless he/ she understand the concept of
change. They all are interconnected with each other. All the concepts must be presented in a
webbed way, when it is done, a teacher will be able to teach those concepts in a much better
way.
Form- 2 Threaded integration:

- The threaded approach to integration is a meta-curricular approach where big
ideas are enlarged. This methodology threads thinking skills, social skills, study
skills, graphic organizers, technology and multiple intelligences approach to
thinking throughout all disciplines.
Here a teacher needs to know what are the skills needed to be taught to students in science,
mathematics, English etc. Then a teachers needs to identify the common skills in all these
subjects. Those common skills must be taught in integrated way.
Form 2 – Integrated:
- This process blends the disciplines by finding overlapping skills, concepts and
attitudes found across the disciplines. Much like the shared methodology,
integration is the result of shifting related ideas out of the subject matter content.
188
Form 2 provides us with more integration than form 1.
Form 3 – Immersed integration:

It means that different disciplines are immersed under a certain umbrella.
- The immersed methodology focuses all curricular content on interest and expertise.
With this methodology, integration takes place within the learners, with little or no
outside intervention. Immersed learners continually make connections between
their chosen topic of interest and subjects.
Do remember, a teacher is going to integrate the lessons with child’s interest. It is not a
subject specified integration but it is integration of teaching content with child’s interest.
Form 3 – Networked integration:
- The network methodology is totally student-centered. It professes that only the

learner can direct the integration process. The methodology professes that the
learner knows their topic and can self-direct their focus on the necessary resources
both within and across subject areas.
- Networked are created between the learners.
189
Form 3 focuses on the integration of subject knowledge or content with children’s

interest.
“Integrated Themes”
Lecture # 28
Outlines
We have talked about:
Reasons for integration.
Planning integrated units.
Integrated project.
Ten reasons to teach an integrated curriculum.
190
1. Unless you have 50 hours a day to teach, you will never get it all in.
We can not teach the subjects to the students in isolation. We do not have enough time to
teach the students a single subject. So we have to integrate different subject.
2. An integrated curriculum allows science and social studies to frame your reading, writing
and math.
We can teach students writing, grammar, descriptive writings, argumentative essays
through social studies and science instead of English and Urdu. There should be good
integration not overlapping.
3. The brain thrives on connections.

We observe a lot of things in this world. But we try to reflect at the end of the day we can
remember only a few things. We can remember those things which are connected with
our prior learning. Our mind works on connection. Our mind can not capture the
information without connections. Human mind can hold 5 to 9 isolated chunks of
information. But more information can be saved in our mind through integration.
Integration is very important within the subject or with different subjects.
4. Life is not divided into neat little blocks of time called science, math, reading, writing,
social studies and history.
We do not teach interpersonal skills in schools. We need to re think our approach.
Because life is not divided into little blocks of subjects.
5. Problem solving skills soar when all of our knowledge and higher level thinking from all
curriculum areas are tapped.
We do not know problem solving skill because we do not practice it. It is the need of
every subject. Our problem solving skills decrease with the passage of time.
6. Real literature in real books provides an authentic diving board into learning all subjects.
Award winning literature provides models for problem solving, peer relationships,
191
character development, and skill building as students are captivated by exciting

adventures with realistic characters who go through problems very much like their own
problems.
Case method is a very good approach to know problem solving. It is the integration of
skills.
7. School’s got it backwards. In real life you are tested with a problem and then must
scramble for answers, but in traditional schools you are given the answers and asked to
…….. repeat them.
Children are very good problem solvers. Schools got it backward. In schools we do not
provide the opportunities to the students to show their capacities.
8. Group interaction and team building inherent in an integrated curriculum depend on using
various strengths and skills to create bridges to understanding.
team work is very important but we never get an opportunity to learn this skill. We do not
know how to share. Because we do not teach this to our students. We only want to give
them a lot of information. And the most important things group learning and team work is
always ignored.
When we make the groups of students of same interest. They will learn to work with a
group with different people. Integration is not only the integration of knowledge but at
the same time integration of content, skills and attitudes. We do not teach the negotiation
skills. It is a common observation that we have a lot of intelligent people around us who
can talk on every topic but they are not able to present an argument. When they argue it
seems that they are confronting others. Because these things are not in practice in our
schools.
9. Your standardized test scores will hit the top. By inspiring students to think, to love
learning, and put their learning to work in authentic ways, your kids will be equipped for
whatever curves they might be thrown….. on standardized tests and in life.
We emphasis on the marks of the students that’s the achievement. A lot of marks are not
the guarantee of job or of a good life. Enjoying the learning is the most important thing.
192
A child who enjoys his learning, improves his communication skills knows how to solve
the problem is more successful than the child who only learns the content and get full
marks in the examination. He has the skill for life long learning. The child who learns
social skills can communicate with anybody and solve every kind of problems.
10. Students LOVE a integrated curriculum and thrive on its challenges.

This is the least important reason. Children love integrated curriculum because it
provides the context for learning.
The Little Red Schoolhouse.2002
Getting to the Core Concepts

Core concept: Less is more.
Does focusing on big ideas help us design better instruction?
What are core concepts?
What are generative topics?
What are essential questions?
A lot of information is not important depth of information is important. In school we do not have
much time to deliver information so we must know the core concept. Which we want to deliver
too the students. Generative topics are those which are linked with core concepts. And at the last
there are essential questions. This thing is important before integration of the subjects or lesson.
Designing an Integrated curriculum unit.
193
Step 1. Identifying learning goals

1. List 5-15 learning goals, concepts, objectives, competencies or outcomes for your
particular discipline or course(s).
2. Creating learning goals maps: Draw a two-column grid on the paper. Enter subject title in
the left column and the corresponding learning goals in the right column.
3. Share learning goals with teachers.
Step 2. Identifying Generative theme

1. Identifying generative themes.
Generative themes
 Are the focal point of the integrated unit.
 Cut cross disciplines and may be addressed from a variety of disciplinary perspectives.
 Link with students interests.
 Lend themselves to student investigation and projects.
 Link with community issues and needs.
Sample generative themes

 The Environment: Love it or lose it?
 The Two-Edged Sword of Technology.
Next on step 2
Brainstorm and Agree on a Generative Theme and Sub-Themes.
Establish “Essential Questions”
Planning Backward: Set Goals and Objectives.
It may look like:
At the completion of the integrated unit, participants will be able to propose some solutions to
the problem.
Step 3. Decide on the Activities, Diagrams and Timeline.
194
There will be teaching as well as learning activities. Then there will be time frame to do these
activated. Then there will be assessment system.
The most important part of integration is assessment. We have listed 5 to 15 goals and we have
to assess the student against all the listed objectives. We have to assess the students learning
across those objectives. We need to use multiple strategies. We can not assess the students on
paper and pencil. It can assess their cognition but we can not observe their performance. We
need to identify assessment strategies and assessment tools very carefully while integrating t6he
subjects.
Step 4. Assessment of the integrated unit.
Sample integrated unit
Century week celebration(Project)

This project was done in America. There core concept was development.
Generative topic:
Forces
Essential question
What forces shaped the twentieth century?
Topic (forces):
Popular culture; mass media; science and the environment; medicine, health and nutrition;
politics, government and economics; war and peace; transportation; communication; arts, family
and society.
The project was done with 8th grade students and they were 51. The most important thing of the
project was that all the colleagues made this project with mutual cooperation. They all decided
that there will not be any class in the whole week rather we will celebrate century week.
Steps
1. The first task was to confirm the choice of forces.
2. The 51 students were divided into 10 groups.
195
3. Each of the 5 students in the group was assigned a 20-year time period and a specific
force to study.
4. The cooperative groups jigsawed into groups of 10 to plan and make a presentation of the
forces that guided each of the 20-year periods of the century.
5. Each team of teacher wrote guiding questions for each force using the core concept and
essential question as their guide.
6. Teachers designed assignments to helps facilitate the learning process and a variety of
authentic assessments were implemented.
7. Students were asked to rate the forces they preferred to study.
8. Then they asked to name a few students with whom they would like to work.
9. After that the teachers assigned students to groups and created booklets for the students.
10. That booklet included general schedule, group roster, guiding questions, assignments and
assessment rubrics.
11. The seven day schedule began on day 1 and 2 with a PBS film introducing the twentieth
century.
12. A keynote speaker.
In this way the students are learning problem solving. Communication skills , team work,
interpersonal communication. The important thing in jigsaw reading is what we know we
must share it with others. We can not share unless we have communication skills. In this
big project all subjects were integrated.
The other method that is very often used to teach integrated curriculum was inquiry
method or inquiry learning.
“Inquiry Teaching and Higher Level Thinking”

Lecture # 29
Objectives:
- Thinking skills
- Critical thinking
- Strategies to develop critical thinking
196
- Inquiry learning and critical thinking
Before talking about thinking, we must know what actually learning is?
What is learning?
- Is it memorizing facts?
- Is it understanding concepts?
- Is it acquiring skills?
- Is it all above?
In behaviorism, learning is defined as a permanent change in behaviour. In schools, most of

the teachers assume that memorizing a book is learning, but actually, it is rote memorization.
Some teachers assume that a good learning is that in which students understand the depth of
concepts.
- According to Kolb (1984), Learning is a process of a combination of grasping
experience and transforming it.
Thinking skills:
- Robinson notes that while the importance of cognitive development has become
widespread, students’ performance on measures of higher-order thinking ability has
displayed a critical need for students to develop the skills and attitudes of effective
thinking.
Glossary of Thinking skills terms:
Critical Thinking: The process of determining the authenticity, accuracy, or value of

something; characterized by the ability to seek reasons and alternatives, perceive the total
situation, and change one’s view based on evidence. Also called “logical” thinking and
“analytical” thinking.
197
Infusion: The process of planning, assessing and monitoring one’s own thinking; the pinnacle of
mental functioning. This term is used for correction and higher order thinking skills. Infusion is
more about disposition.
Metacognition: The set of basic and advanced skills and sub-skills that govern a person’s mental
processes. These skills consist of knowledge, dispositions, and cognitive and metacognitive
operations.
Transfer: The ability to apply thinking skills taught separately to any subject.
Bloom’s taxonomy: It is set of different skills. It has six levels from knowledge to evaluation.
Some are lower level thinking skills while others are higher order.
De Bono Six Thinking Hats: The term Six Thinking Hats is used to describe the tool for group
discussion and individual thinking. "Six Thinking Hats" and the associated idea parallel
thinking provide a means for groups to plan thinking processes in a detailed and cohesive way,
and in doing so to think together more effectively.
The Six Thinking Hats (or modes)
The White Hat
The White Hat calls for information known or needed.
The Red Hat
The Red Hat signifies feelings, hunches and intuition.
The Black Hat
The Black Hat is judgment -- the devil's advocate or why something may not
198
The Yellow Hat
The Yellow Hat symbolizes brightness and optimism.
The Green Hat
The Green Hat focuses on creativity: the possibilities, alternatives and new ideas.
The Blue Hat
The Blue Hat is used to manage the thinking process.
How these thinking skills can be incorporated in our classrooms?

We must change our assumptions first, that is “the more a teacher teaches, the more a student
learns.” This assumption can be changed by thinking that “the more a student experiences, the
more he learns” or “deeper is more.” There are different methods for deeper learning e.g.
generative topics, core concepts and more important we need to focus on big ideas.
Critical thinking:
- What it isn’t: Critical thinking is not necessarily being “critical” and negative. In
fact, a more accurate term would be evaluating thinking.
- According to Robert, “critical thinking is a disciplined manner of thought that a

person uses to assess the validity of something: a statement, news story, argument,
research.”
- Beyer says that “critical thinking has two important dimensions: it is both a frame
of mind and a number of specific mental operations.” Firstly, you should have
evaluative thinking, you could not evaluate a thing, unless you have evidence.
- Norris (1985) agrees, stating that: Having a critical spirit is as important as thinking
critically.
199
- The critical spirit requires one to think critically about all aspects of life, to think
critically about one’s own thinking, and to act on the basis of what one has
considered when using critical thinking skills.
Teaching Critical Thinking:

There are number of ways to develop critical thinking skills among students.
- Acting like a teacher
- Students as questioners
- Critical reading
1. While reading activities
2. Children’s literature
3. According to research, children’s literature is another powerful tool for teaching
skills. Somers and Worthington (1979) noted that “… literature offers children
more opportunities than any other area of the curriculum to consider ideas, values
and ethical questions.” Furthermore, literature that inspires and challenges helps
students learn how to engage and interact with a book.
- Writing to learn
Free writing
Controlled writing
- Classification games for young learners
- Thinking games
- Finding problems
- Proposing appropriate solutions
- Riddles
A riddle for reading and critical thinking:

- This is an unusual paragraph. I’m curious as to just how quickly you can find out what is
so unusual about it. It looks so ordinary and plain as you would think nothing was wrong
with it. In fact, nothing is wrong with it! It is highly unusual though. Study it and think
about it, but you still may not find anything odd. But if you work at it a bit, you might
find out. Try to find out the unusual thing in the paragraph quickly.
200
Answer: “E” is the vowel, which is most frequently used in our writing. But in this paragraph,
there is no “E”. Although it is interesting for a child. He will not only read the paragraph but his
critical thinking will also be improved.
Inquiry Learning:
Inquiry itself is a big discipline. It has its own place in education and constructivism. Inquiry is
actually investigation and it starts with questioning. Inquiry learning actually includes all the
three elements of dale’s cone of learning. These three elements help to determine the level of
critical thinking skills among students.
Dale’s Cone of Learning:

- Learning through doing, through observation, and through abstraction. Dale claims
that, by directly participating in the learning process, students are more motivated
and take greater interest in learning. (Abstraction is very higher level of learning.)
- If children are to develop higher-level abstract knowledge and so grasp the
significance of abstract descriptions of concrete things, they should be provided with
opportunities to use their senses to learn from empirical observation.
“Inquiry Processes and Constructivism”

Lecture # 30
Objectives
 Bruner’s stages
 Inquiry
 Five whys of inquiry
201
 Basic elements of inquiry teaching

 Inquiry processes
 Constructivism and inquiry teaching
Bruner’s stages
Bruner’s work was very much influenced by Piaget’s work. He made the stages like Piaget but
his later work was much influenced by Vygotsky. Under both influences he devised three stages.
 The first stage he termed “ Enactive”, when a person learns about the world
through actions on physical objects and the outcomes of these actions.
In this stage child makes relationships with concrete objects and learns from them.
 The second stage was called “Iconic” where learning can be obtained through using
models and pictures.
In pre schools pictures and model are not sufficient way of learning. This is the stage when child
makes relationships with real objects and want to learn. If a child has not seen a table he can not
comprehend the table only with the picture. It will be a superficial learning and not the learning
in depth. Pictures will be beneficial only when a child has seen something in reality or he has
seen the original thing. If we want to show the animals to the students we must take them to the
zoo. After a visit to the zoo when we show them the pictures of animals it will be easy to
understand for them. If we only show them the pictures they can memorize the names but can no
take the proper image.
 The final stage was “Symbolic” in which the learner develops the capacity to think
in abstract terms.
In this stage child can think abstractly. Algebra starts from grade six. It does not offer in earlier
classes because the main reason is that its expressions are abstract. Small children can not learn
this.
Bruner did not clearly divide these stages he kept them merged. Importance of Bruner’s stages
according to constructivism is that lesson plan should be according to the stages of children. If
the child is on first stage teacher must teach them through concrete objects. If they are on second
stage teacher can teach them through models and pictures. And if they are on the last stage
202
teachers must give them abstract ideas. If the teacher is giving concrete objects to the children at
the last stage it will waste their time and also the students will lose their interest in learning. Its
small example is that children in playgroup love to do coloring but when he learns how to write,
his interest in coloring becomes less.
The capacity of coloring of a playgroup child and grade one child is the same because when
child gets his expertize in writing, his coloring development stops there. Child loves to do the
tasks on his own. The main quality of constructivism is that it demands from the teachers to plan
activities according to the interests of children. When we talk about this that the child loves to
work on hos own it is directly linked with Inquiry method. When children destroy the toys they
actually want to inquire. Children ask a lot of questions it is also linked with inquiry. Basically a
child is an inquirer.
Inquiry
May involve a:
 Problem
 Procedure and
 Solution
It may happen that all three things are involved in an inquiry. In all above three topics question is
the most important thing.
Five whys in inquiry.

What are the five whys. Its example is that the techniques most used for this is “the five whys”
when giving students scaffolding guidance.
Why is the bread burnt?
Perhaps the dough was too close to the heat source at the top of the oven.
Why was the dough too close to the heat source at the top? Maybe the dough is too big.
Inquiry is not yet completed. Its just like that the police investigate. A lot of questioning is the
necessary thing for inquiry.
The next questions for the above example is:
Why is the dough too big?
203
Probably because we did not measure it when we made it.

Why did not you measure it?
Because we only measure the size of the finished product.
So why did the bread burn?
If we do not take into consideration the fact that the dough will rise in the oven, it becomes
bigger than the expected and might be burnt.
In inquiry the question must be based on the previous answer. The last answer will be different
from the first one. That will be the conclusion. First one was the simple answer and last answer
was given after inquiry. After inquiry we reach to a conclusion. In inquiry method every question
must be inter linked.
Basic elements of inquiry teaching

1. Inquiry method requires the learner to develop various processes associated with inquiry.
Processes which are involved in inquiry are interpretation, making conclusions, data
collection, doing and observation. Children need to master all these processes.
2. Teachers and principals must support the concept of inquiry teaching and learn how to
adapt their own teaching and administrative styles to the concepts. In our schools it is
necessary to introduce inquiry learning. It can be happen when teachers will know that
actual learning can be gained through inquiry method. We should not stuff the children
with facts and information rather we must make them independent and critical learners.
For this purpose we must learn inquiry methods and must implement them.
3. Students at all ages and levels have a genuine interest in discovering something new or in
providing solutions or alternatives to unsolved questions or problems. Research says that
we are learning beings.
4. The solutions, alternatives or responses provided by learners are not found in textbooks.
Students use reference material and textbooks during inquiry lessons just as a scientist
and professionals use books, articles and reference to conduct their work.
204
5. The objective of inquiry teaching is often as process, in many instances, the end product
of an inquiry activity is relatively unimportant compare to the processes used to create it.
Maybe the child comes up with the ideas that are present in many ways and there is
nothing new. End product is not important but the child has passed through every step
included observation. Data collection, data interpretation and conclusion is the main
thing. Objective of inquiry method is process and not the end product.
6. All conclusions must be considered relative or tentative, not final. Students must learn to
modify their conclusions as new data are discovered. We need to develop flexibility in
the children through inquiry. So inquiry teaching develops the spirit of learning.
7. Inquiry learning can not be gauged by the clock. In the real world, when people think or
create, it is not usually done in fifty-minute increments. The effect of inquiry method is
life long. Inquiry method can not be done in 30 minutes. It needs plenty of time.
8. Learners are responsible for planning, conducting and evaluating their own efforts. It is
essential that the teacher play only a supportive role, not an active one (that is, the teacher
should not do the work for the students). We need to active the students and teacher must
only support them.
9. Students have to be taught the processes associated with inquiry learning in a systematic
manner. Every time a “teachable moment” arrives, the teacher should capitalized on it to
further the building of inquiry processes. If the teacher himself give the answer of the
question so he will not allow the next inquiry task.
10. Inquiry learning complicates and expands the teacher’s work, owing to the many
interactions that may originate from inquiry teaching and learning.
Different children have different responses. Teachers have to tackle all the responses and
build the learning on their responses. Inquiry is itself a process but teacher guidance is the
most important thing in it.
205
Basic inquiry processes.

1. Observing
Identifying objects, object properties and changes in various systems; making controlled
observations; ordering series of observations. We actually learn from observation.
Observation leads to questions and learning. Observation can be controlled or free.
Controlled observation is the observation in which we are specific about the things we are
observation. In free observation we observe everything in our surrounding. Both types of
observation are important.
In inductive mode there is free observation. It can be controlled. In deductive mode there
is controlled observation.
2. Classifying
Making simple and complex classifications; tabulating and coding observations.
We can do these preschool children also.
3. Inferring
Drawing conclusions based on observations; constructing solutions to test these
conclusions.
4. Using numbers
Identifying sets and their numbers and then progressing to higher mathematical
processes.
Its example is labeling.
5. Measuring
Identifying and ordering lengths and then areas, volume, weights, temperature and
speeds.
6. Using space-time relationships

Identifying movements and direction; learning rules governing change in position.
206
7. Communicating
Communicating graphs and diagrams to describe simple and then more complex
phenomena ; presenting written and oral reports.
8. Predicting
Interpolating and extrapolating from data; formulating methods for testing
predictions.
9. Making operational definition

Distinguish between operational and non-operational definitions; constructing
operational definitions for new problems.
10. Formulating hypotheses.

Distinguish hypotheses from inferences, observations and predictions; constructing
and testing hypotheses.
A hypothesis is a tentative answer to every problem.
11. Interpreting data

Describing data and inferences based on them; constructing equations to represent
data; relating data to hypotheses; making generalizations supported by experimental
findings.
We must know how to communicate our data and interpret the data.
12. Experimenting
Interpreting account of scientific experiments; stating problems’ conducting
hypotheses; conducting experimental procedures.
We need to ensure that all these twelve process are integrated in our task so that
student learn and benefit from them.
Relationship between constructivism and inquiry teaching
1. The focus is on the students.
207
2. The pace of instruction is flexible, not fixed.

3. Students are encouraged to search for implications.
4. Students are encouraged to generate multiple conclusions.
“Guided Inductive Inquiry”
Lecture # 31
Objectives:
208
- What should be done by teachers?

- Reinforcement of the concept of inquiry.
- Aspects of Inquiry
- Assimilation in Inquiry
- Guided Inductive Inquiry
- General model of Guided Inductive Inquiry
What should we do as teachers?
A teacher should try to do the following in class:
- Focus on big ideas to design instruction. (We should not worry if we will be able to
teach a certain topic in a given time frame. So we should focus on big ideas. We should
know about the content of the lesson to be taught and what are our expectations from the
students regarding their learning. Teachers must know about the skills that are to be
developed among their students.)
- Generate core concepts. (Those concepts should be generated in the class which gave
birth to certain other concepts. Teachers are not supposed to teach dead concepts rather
teach the concepts by which students can explore other concepts for further studies.)
- Use core and generative concepts to ensure students’ understanding.
- Ask essential questions which are definitely different from unit questions. (Essential
questions are different from unit questions, unit questions are very technical questions,
and they address only a particular content. While essential questions are those which
actually widens students’ thinking and aims at developing students’ thinking skills.)
- Plan age appropriate tasks for different levels.
- Use different models of integration to develop deeper understanding and cater for
students’ interests.
209
- Apply inquiry teaching to develop higher level thinking.
Why inquiry?
We know that inquiry is not about memorizing facts. Inquiry is about investigating things. Why
is it important to teach students through inquiry? Because,
- Memorizing facts and information is not the most important skill in today’s world.
Facts change and information is readily available – what’s needed is an
understanding of how to get and make sense of the mass of the data.
Effective inquiry:
- Effective inquiry is more than just asking questions. A complex process is involved
when individuals attempt to convert information and data into useful knowledge.
Application of Inquiry learning:
- Useful application of inquiry learning involves several factors: a context for

question, a framework for questions, a focus for questions, and different levels of
questions. Well-designed inquiry learning produced knowledge formation that can
be widely applied.
Inquiry may involve:
- Problem
- Procedure and
- Solution
Aspects of Inquiry:
- We often jump all aspects of inquiry together. However each aspect of inquiry
requires specific skills, resources and tools.
210
Inquiry could be of:
- Information
- Critical inquiry
- Scientific inquiry
- Graphic inquiry
- Historical
- Personal
- Media
- Social/Democratic
Above all are the different aspects of inquiry. Some of them involve only problem. Some of them
involve problem and procedure and some involve problem, procedure as well as a solution. So
inquiry has different aspects and we need to deal with inquiry accordingly.
Information Inquiry:
- Information inquiry involves the processes of searching for information and

applying information to answer questions. We rise personally and questions that are
addressed to us. Techniques for gaining meaningful information may involve
reading, listening, viewing, observing, interviewing, surveying, testing and more.
- Information inquiry is very widely used in our school settings in which we ask the
students to gather information.
- The five interactive components of information inquiry are (Callison, 2006):
- Questioning
- Exploring
- Assimilation
- Inference
- Reflection
The most important component in information inquiry is assimilation because it brings change in
our belief system.
211
Graphic/Visual Inquiry:
- Use historical drawings and painting to stimulate questions. (Students will observe
the pictures and can acquire the following information through certain questioning.)
- Was this a real person or a myth?
- When did the event take place?
- Is the illustrator bias in some way?
- Is the image realistic or invented?
- How are these images alike and different?
- Which is most accurate?
Assimilation in inquiry:
- The process of assimilation involves reinforcing and confirming information that is

known, altering thinking based on new information, or rejecting information that
does not match the students’ belief system.
- Assimilation leads to consideration of new options and points of view. (Callison,
2006, p.7)
- As students explore, look for unique aspects of at least 3 pieces of evidence and
make comparisons.
Inductive Inquiry:
Inductive inquiry is of two types:
- Guided inductive inquiry

- Unguided inductive inquiry
Guided inductive inquiry:
Students investigate a teacher-presented question using student designed/selected procedures.
Unguided inductive inquiry:
212
Students investigate topic-related questions that are student formulated through student
designed/selected procedures. When an activity is evaluated for its level of inquiry, a simple
table establishing what is given to the learner determines at which level of inquiry the given
activity resides.
For further reading about inquiry processes…
Inquiry Processes
1. Observing. Identifying objects, object properties, and changes in various systems; making
controlled observations; ordering series of observations
2. Classifying. Making simple and complex classifications; tabulating and coding observations
3. Inferring. Drawing conclusions based on observations; constructing situations to test these
conclusions
4. Using numbers. Identifying sets and their members and then progressing to higher
mathematical processes
5. Measuring. Identifying and ordering lengths and then areas, volumes, weights, temperatures,
and speeds
6. Using space–time relationships. Identifying movement and direction; learning rules governing
changes in position
7. Communicating. Constructing graphs and diagrams to describe simple and then more complex
phenomena; presenting written and oral reports
8. Predicting. Interpolating and extrapolating from data; formulating methods for testing
predictions
9. Making operational definitions. Distinguishing between operational and nonoperational
definitions; constructing operational definitions for new problems
10. Formulating hypotheses. Distinguishing hypotheses from inferences, observations, and
predictions; constructing and testing hypotheses
11. Interpreting data. Describing data and inferences based on them; constructing equations to
represent data; relating data to hypotheses; making generalizations supported by experimental
findings
12. Controlling variables. Identifying independent and dependent variables; conducting
experiments; describing how variables are controlled
13. Experimenting. Interpreting accounts of scientific experiments; stating problems;
constructing hypotheses; conducting experimental procedures
213
“Models & Considerations in Guided Inductive Inquiry”

Lecture # 32
An inquiry is any process that has the aim of augmenting knowledge, resolving doubt,

or solving a problem. A theory of inquiry is an account of the various types of inquiry and a
treatment of the ways that each type of inquiry achieves its aim.
Inquiry is not mere questioning, it is much more than that. Inquiry is not a theoretical
technique only, it is very practical indeed.
Inquiry learning begins when students are presented with questions to be answered, problems to
be solved, or a set of observations to be explained.
If the method is implemented effectively, the students should learn to "formulate good
questions, identify and collect appropriate evidence, present results systematically, analyse and
interpret results, formulate conclusions, and evaluate the worth and importance of those
conclusions. Problem-based, learning, project-based learning, discovery learning, certain forms
of case based instruction, and student research.
Objectives:
 Steps for GII (Guided Inductive Inquiry)
 Model of GII
 Characteristics of GII
Steps for Guided Inductive Theory:

1. Decide on the generalizations students should make during a particular unit of
study.
2. Organize the learning activities and materials to expose strands and generalizations
to students.
214
3. Ask students to write summary of the content that will form basis of the
generalizations.
4. Ask students to identify sequences or patterns of events, objects, or other data in the
content.
5. Ask students to summarize these sequences or patterns in one sentence.
6. Ask students to offer proof that their statement is a generalization by applying it to
other events, objects or data.
Example of steps for Guided Inductive Theory:
Steps Examples:
1. Decide on the generalization(s)  Humans need balanced diet to keep good health.
students should make during a  Shortage of minerals can cause serious illness.
particular unit of study  Galileo was condemned by the inquisition because he
questioned the accepted facts.
2. Organize the learning activities  Cases representing different diseases caused by
and materials to expose strands imbalanced diet.
and generalizations to students.  Cases representing different diseases caused by
shortage of minerals.
 Analysis of Galileo’s work and the religious rule of
that time.
3. Ask students to write summary of Students summarize the read cases or texts.
the content that will form basis of
the generalizations.
4. Ask students to identify
sequences or patterns of events,
objects, or other data in the
content.
5. Ask students to summarize these
sequences or patterns in one
sentence.
6. Ask students to offer proof that
215
their statement is a generalization

by applying it to other events,
objects or data.
The most important thing in inquiry is evidence. You can never justify your statement without
evidence. Above are the six steps that will be used whenever you are planning a guided learning
inquiry.
A General Model of Guided learning Inquiry:
Identifying a problem (being aware of something)
Preparing a statement of research objectives (making

testable hypothesis)
Collecting data (gathering evidence, conducting

experiment, surveying)
Interpreting data (making meaningful statements, testing

hypothesis)
Developing tentative conclusions (Establishing relationship/

patterns)
Replication (Obtaining new data)

Characteristics of GII model:
216
1. Learners progress from specific observations to inferences or generalizations.

2. The objective is to learn (or reinforce) the process of examining events or objects
and then arriving at an appropriate generalization from the observations.
3. The teacher controls the specifics of the lesson--- the events, data, materials etc.
4. Each student structures a meaningful pattern based on his or her observations and
those of others in the class.
5. Classroom is a learning laboratory. Because knowledge is created here. The inferences
and generalizations at the end of the inquiry are actually knowledge.
6. Usually a fixed number of generalizations will be elicited from the learners.
7. The teacher encourages participation of each child to ensure collaborative learning.
Inquiry method cannot be applied on specified students.
Important considerations regarding inquiry:

- The inquiry learning cannot be rushed.
- Then how to cover the syllabus.
- Need to see the bigger picture. What is essential and need to be taught?
- Remember, less is actually more. More information does not guarantee high
performance of pupils’ on exams. It is their conceptual understanding and skills
which are important.
- Students must find the pattern. For example, students need to learn that inferences
cannot be drawn in absence of evidence.
Unguided inductive inquiry:

Here you will study what unguided inductive inquiry is? And how is it different from guided
inquiry.
- During guided inductive inquiry, the teacher plays the key role in asking questions,
prompting responses and structuring the material and situations.
- Once the class has mastered the techniques of guided inductive inquiry, teacher can
introduce or allow for student-initiated situations for examining data, objects and
events. Because the teacher’s role is minimized, the students’ activity increases.
217
What is Guided Inquiry?

Guided Inquiry is carefully planned, closely supervised targeted intervention of an instructional
team of school librarians and teachers to guide students through curriculum based inquiry units
that build deep knowledge and deep understanding of a curriculum topic, and gradually lead
towards independent learning.
Guided Inquiry is grounded in a constructivist approach to learning, based on the Information
Search Process developed by Kuhlthau, for developing students’ competence with learning from
a variety of sources while enhancing their understanding of the content areas of the curriculum.
Key ideas of unguided inquiry:

1. Learners progress from making specific observations to making inference or
generalizations.
2. The objective is to learn (or reinforce) the processes of examining events, objects,
and data and then to arrive at appropriate sets of generalizations.
3. The difference from guided inductive inquiry is that, The teacher may control only the
materials provided or encourage student-initiated materials. Teacher may pose
questions, such as “what can you generalize from ..?” or “Tell me everything that
you can do about X after examining these…”
4. The students without further teacher guidance ask all the questions that come to
mind.
Unguided inquiry and the teacher:

- A teacher is a classroom clarifier, guiding students to develop logical thinking skills.
- Students will make generalizations that are too broad, infer single cause –and-effect
relationships where there are several, and perceive cause-and-effect relationships
where none exist.
- If errors exist in the student’s logics or inferences, teacher needs to point them out.
But teacher should not tell the student what the correct inference is. As there is
much less direct teacher probing in unguided learning inquiry.
- Under unguided inductive inquiry, during initial stage teacher should ask students
to work alone. When students work alone, they tend to do most of the work
themselves. If at initial stage, Teacher divides the students in pair or groups, one in
218
the group usually takes the leadership role and dominates the group’s thinking, so
that there are really only one participant and two observers.
- When students demonstrate the necessary aptitude to use the inductive method
successfully in an unguided fashion, teacher can assign small groups to work
together.
Unguided learning is important as well but teacher’s role is very passive in the sense that teacher
is not the active participant in the inquiry process. But to make students actively participate in
the process, teacher needs to be there in the form of a prompter. If students do not tell the correct
inference, then teacher must not tell them the correct inference. They are there to just guide the
students.
“Scientific Method”
Lecture # 33
Objectives
 Deductive method
219
 Scientific method
 Brief history of scientific method
 Variables
In inductive method we move from specific to general. Deductive method is just opposite. When
we talk about prove we deduce.
Deduction
Theory
Hypothesis
Experimentation & Observation
Confirmation
The statement is generalization. Generalization consists of two or more concepts. Confirmation

stage is the complication of deduction process.
Induction
Observation
Pattern
Tentative Hypothesis
220
Theory
In mathematics mostly deduction is being used.

The scientific method
Science is an attitude basically. Its method can not be defined on skill level. It is a step by step
process which guides towards inquiry. Very often we say that we must research. Its min purpose
The scientific method is a tool that helps scientists and the rest of us to solve problems and
determine answers to questions in a logical format.
History of scientific method.

This method is not invented by someone. Work on scientific method was started by Aristotle to
Galileo. It is said that Galileo is the father of scientific method. Aristotle talked about logics and
he was one of the pioneers. He promoted deduction. Scientific methods were basically
developed. Greeks, Muslim scientists and many others were also involved in this development.
But Galileo was the man who had contributed much for the development of scientific method.
In our modern culture, Galileo (1564-1642) is generally credited with being the father of the
scientific method. The Encyclopedia Britannica (1970) says: “ Even while Bacon was
philosophizing, the true method was being practiced by Galileo, who, with a combination of
observation, hypothesis, mathematical deduction and confirmatory experiment founded the
science of dynamics.
Name
Originally the scientific method was called the experimental method and the method of science.
When the word scientific was devised in the 19th century, the most widespread term applied to
the method became the scientific method or science method.
When we started using it with technology its importance increased.
The most important thing of scientific method is that any theory can be falsified. Nothing is a
static truth. If we do not falsify development can not be possible. Advancement of technology is
also based on this point. Scientific method is an attitude also. It means that when we accept
challenges and gather arguments about it, it shows that we are very much open minded.
Scientific method cab be used in social sciences also. Psychology is also a science because it
221
uses scientific methods to its researches. Roots of the research of all social sciences is based on
scientific method. Because of the scientific method these researches are authentic. Its small
example is that when we say that something is traditional and it is truth. It means that we are not
ready falsify that thing. It also mean that our attitude is not scientific. Main thing is that we
should be open. Usually we do not question our tradition and authority. Scientific method can
not be used without scientific attitude.
Example
Identify a problem
You are faced with the problem of not being able to read because of your emergency light does
not work, and you are not happy about it.
Research the problem

You think back to the last time your light does not work, and you remember that it was because
of worn-out batteries.
Formulate a hypothesis
You guess that worn-out batteries is the reason your emergency light is not working.
Conduct an experiment
Now, so you get some new batteries from the drawer next to your bed and replace the ones in
your light.
Reach a conclusion
Oh! Your emergency light works.
The interesting thing is that this method is very often used by the young children. For example
while playing with their toys they come across with many problems, they hypothesize the
problem experiment and try to solve the problem. Scientific method is applied in every day
222
situation. Teachers need to teach the students importance of this method and how they can use it
in their lives.
Information theory is that human mind can take 5 to 9 chunks of isolated information at one time
but when we take it in picture form it takes much less space.
How does scientific method looks like:
 It starts with asking the questions.

 Doing background research
 Constructing hypothesis
 Testing the hypothesis
 Analyzing Results
 Drawing conclusions
 If hypothesis turns true then results are reported
 If hypothesis turns false then a new hypothesis is constructed and same steps are
tried out.
 Communicating results
Edison had done minimum 1800 efforts to make a bulb. Somebody asked him why don’t you
give up? He said that every time I learnt that this method is not right to make a bulb. He rejected
so many hypotheses and at the end he reported the method, many people experimented on that .
so the main thing in scientific method is openness, we should be able to accept the rejection of
our hypothesis. It is a step by step process.
The scientific method
It starts with asking the questions. Questioning starts with observation. We hear things but we do
not listen them. We see the things but we do not observe them.
Observation
Curious observation is the start of the inductive process. Discovery of new problems, ideas,
theories, and decisions needed and problem prevention usually begins with curious observation
using the five senses: smelling, tasting, hearing, feeling, seeing. Instruments and tools can be
223
used to extend these senses. Use your sense perceptions and projections visually and mentally.we
should believe that nothing is fact. Curious attitude is about question. We observe the thing but
do not quest them so it is not curious observation.
Identifying the problem

See if there is any problem.
Look at the problem as challenges and opportunities

An idea, problem, decision or tentative theory should be presented in the form of a question
because:
It encourages you to keep an open mind, and thus seek the “truth” and not to prove a statement.
A question is a tool and a guide for productive thinking about problem solving and investigation
of a new subject. Any challenge is an opportunity. Problem should be stated in the question
form. We will try to get the experts opinion. Then we will make the hypothesis , experiment on
the problem them communicate the result.
Example
A child sees his mother making a cake. He sees that after completion of cake it becomes bigger
in size. Because of his curious observation he asks the question that why it has become bigger in
size? Mother answers that we have added baking powder in it, because of carbon dioxide it has
increased in size. The next question is that what is the process of fermentation.
Problem/Question
Hassan wonders if the amount of sugar used in the recipe will affect the size of cake?
Observation/ Research
Hassan researches the areas of baking and fermentation and tries to come up with a way to test
his question.
He keeps all of his information on this topic in a journal.
224
Hassan talks with his teacher and she gives him an Experimental Design Diagram to help him set
up his investigation.
Experimental sheet
Title
The effect of sugar on the size of cake.
Hypothesis
If sugar is increased then size of the cake will increase.
Observations: (Variables and Constants)
Hypothesis
The hypothesis is an educated guess about the relationship between the independent and
dependent variables.
Reading is involved behind the educated guess. Experts opinions are also involved in it.
Variables
Variables are much important in scientific method. We can not apply scientific method without
variables. Variables are those things that can be changed. Constant things do not change. In the
above example size of cake or quantity of sugar would be variables and oven would be a
constant. Temperature would be constant.
Collect and Analyze Results

Hassan examines his data and notices that his control worked the best in this experiment, but not
significantly better than 100g. of sugar.
Conclusion
Hassan rejects his hypothesis, but decides to re-test using sugar amounts between 50g. and 100g.
225
Problem-Based Learning (PBL)

Lecture # 34
Outlines
 Problem based learning
 Difference between project and problem based learning
226
 Learners outcome for PBL

 Special features of PBL
 Theoretical support
 Planning PBL
 Managing PBL
 Assessing PBL
 Obstacle of PBL
 Approaches of PBL
Being teachers we must identify the problems of the children and help them to solve the
problems. Teachers also have the problems. At times we are unable to solve the problems, the
reason is that we do not learn to identify and solve the problems in our schools and homes.
Problem solving is very useful learner centered teaching and learning strategy. Good teachers are
those who help children to learn. Children learn a lot from this method.
Problem-based learning (PBL) overview

The essence of problem-based learning consist of presenting students with authentic and
meaningful problem situations that can serve as springboards for investigation and inquiry.
PBL is designed primarily to help students develop their thinking, problem solving and
intellectual skills and they actually learn through autonomous learners opportunity.
What is Problem-Based Learning?

The “flow” of problem-based learning:
1. Problem based learning starts from problem engagement.
2. Inquiry and investigation
3. Problem resolution
4. Problem debriefing
Basically teachers give certain problem to the students. Students engage themselves in the
problems. They carry out inquiry and investigation. They define the problem. When we talk
227
about the problem, there is some relevant and irrelevant information. If we focus on irrelevant
problem we will not be able to identify the exact problem and solve the problem. To define the
problem is very important. In problem based learning students try to clarify the problem.
Difference between Project Learning and Problem Based Learning

In problem base learning the focus is on process. In project learning the focus is on ultimate
outcome and product. Inquiry base learning and project learning are the learning approaches.
When we talk about learning approaches it has a lot of importance of process rather than product.
If we talk about factories, at one time we assess them on the basis of product. Later on it is
assessed on the basis of process. Now both process and product are important.
Learner Outcomes for Problem-Based Learning
Adult role
behaviors and
social skills
Skills for Inquiry and

independent Problem Based Problem solving
learning Learning skills
Usually problem base learning is done on groups. In groups naturally they will be able to
communicate with each other and learn from each other. Cooperative learning is very important.
For example a child spend six hours in thinking and comes up with two brilliant ideas. While if
we make the groups of children and they brainstorm for one hour and come up with six brilliant
ideas. Group learning will be more efficient for developing the ideas. Group learning lso
develops the social skills of the learners.
228
Special features of problem based learning

 Driving question or problem
 Focusing on interdisciplinary integration.
 Authentic investigation
 Production of artifacts and exhibits.
 Collaboration
For curious observation, curious attributes are required. Problem based learning also starts from
questions. Questions are based on reason and then investigate them.
Integrate learning with particular topic.

After identifying the problem we integrate it with different factors. Problem based learning is not
based on one discipline its focus must be interdisciplinary. We need to integrate with different
areas. There is authentic investigation because we apply scientific method in it. In scientific
method we ask the question, make hypothesis in the light of red literature. Then we test the
hypothesis, if it is accepted we draw our results if it is rejected we make another hypothesis.
Children work is very important. They produce their original work after problem based learning.
Cooperation is another important thing in this approach.
Theoretical support
- Problem Based Learning has its intellectual roots in the Socratic Method dating back to
the early Greeks but has been expanded by ideas stemming from twentieth-century
cognitive psychology. Socratic Method is based on dialogue generation. We can solve
many problems through dialogue. Roots of problem based learning are in dialogue. Its
roots are also linked with cognitive psychology. In cognitive psychology higher order
skills are involved.
- The knowledge base on problem- based learning is rich and complex. Several studies
done in the last few years provide strong evidence about some of the model’s
instructional effects. However, other studies lead to the conclusion that effects are
cloudy.
- Over the past three decades, considerable attention has been devoted to teaching
approaches known by various names-discovery learning, inquiry training, higher-level
229
thinking- all of which focus on helping students become independent, autonomous

learners capable of figuring things out for themselves.
Its ultimate outcome is that students become autonomous learners.
Theoretical and empirical Support

- Problem based learning will be traced through three main streem of twentieth-century
thought.
1. Dewey and problem-oriented classroom
2. Piaget, Vygotsky and constructivism
3. Burner and Discovery learning
John Dewey said that classroom is just like a laboratory. Laboratory for the students to have
experiences and applicant them in their real life. In real life there are many problems, these
problems must also be presented in laboratory so that the children will be able to solve them.
Piaget spend actually 50 years to work on constructivism. His approach was also that we must
give opportunities to the students to identify and solve the problems. Its examples are puzzles.
Our focus needs to be interdisciplinary.
Vygotsky was a Russian Psychologist and his work was not translated very later. His work was
based on the concept that our social environment also helps us to solve the problems. In this
approach we ask the children to work in group and with cooperation. Another important thing of
this approach is that teacher is not the central figure. Teacher only plan this. This is not the
teaching method, it is a learning method.
Planning for PBL
- As its most fundamental level, problem-based learning is characterized by students
working in pairs or small group to investigate puzzling, real-life problems.
- Because of Interactive nature, PBL requires as much, if not more, planning as compared
to more teacher-centered models.
It is difficult to manage problem based learning. There might be problem in resource

management. There might be problems to handle the students.
Managing for PBL
230
- Dealing with Multitask Situation

- Adjusting to differing Finishing Rates
- Monitoring and Managing Student work
- Managing Material and Equipment
- Regulating Movement and Behavior outside the classroom
Assessing PBL
- Assessment tasks for problem-based lessons cannot consist solely of paper-and-pencil
tests.
- Rather the work products created by students lend themselves nicely to performance
assessment using scoring rubrics or checklist and rating scales.
- Performance assessment can be used to measure students’ problem solving potential as
well as group work.
- We must assess the students in all three (cognitive, affective and psychomotor) domains.
How can problem based learning be assessed?

By using multiple means to measure acquisition of knowledge, skills and dispositions.
To assess Product Method

Knowledge :Interrelationship Concept map, Unit product, Expert map based scheme,
among facts, concepts written/oral responses, Rubrics, SOLO taxonomy,
(Relational understanding) traditional tests scoring guides
Skills: critical thinking, Unit products and/or Rubrics, SOLO taxonomy,
creative thinking, effective performance, written/oral self reports
collaboration, versatile responses, observations, self
communication ratings, peer ratings
Dispositions: intentional Problem logs Observation Content analysis, Rubrics
learning
Knowledge can be assessed through written tests. But skills can be assessed through direct
observation. Any presentation or display of some product are its simple examples. It needs to be
assessed with diverse techniques.
231
Obstacle for PBL

The first and the most important thing is training. If we do not have proper training we will not
be able to apply this method.
Another obstacle is school time table. Some times it will be difficult to complete the task in
short period of time. Teacher may have the break time or extra class to do the task, if he may do
that.
Finishing the syllabus is another big hurdle. Content is not important but process is the main
thing.
Lack of resources is another obstacle. For this reason teacher needs to be innovative. He should
not be the burden on the parents. Try to use the simple and available resources. Teacher can
recycle the natural resources.
Approaches for Problem Based Learning

- Modeling
- Guiding
- Fade out
These are three things to apply the problem based learning. In the first step teacher displays
himself as a model. In second step he provides guidelines to them to do the tasks. And in final
step he fades out and provides the opportunity to the students to experience and solve the
problems to their own.
“Cooperative Learning”
Lecture # 35
Cooperative learning is a learning method. Cooperative learning is a umbrella term which covers
many other methods. Cooperative learning methods are those in which more than one person
work together.
232
“Cooperative learning is a method of instruction that has students working together in

groups, usually with the goal of completing a specific task. This method can help students
develop leadership skills and the ability to work with others as a team. ”
Cooperative learning should have cooperative tasks, cooperative goals and cooperative
rewards.
Objectives:
- Cooperative learning
- Overview
- Monitoring and Managing Student Work
- Planning Cooperative Learning Tasks
Let us consider some situations where you are present but could not work unless there are
people around you.
- Family
- Market: You need people to buy something
- Farming
- Sports: There are some games which are individual games while others are group games.
In team games, effort of all the players in included.
Cooperative learning:
- Goal structure: It is a way that goals specify the degree of interdependence sought
among students. There are three different types of goal structures: individualistic,
competitive and cooperative.
233
- Individualistic goal structure: It occurs when achievement of the goal by one student is
unrelated to the achievement of the goal by other students. The achievement of one
student should not be compared with the achievement of other student. Students are asked
to perform individually.
- Competitive goal structure: It occurs when students perceive that they can obtain their
goal if, and only if, the other students with whom they work fail to obtain their goals. E.g.
grading on curve.
- Cooperative goal structure: It occurs when students perceive that they can obtain their
goal if, and only if, the other students with whom they work also obtain their goals. E.g.
group games.
Why cooperative learning is essential?

There are many reasons behind providing the students with cooperative learning. A lot of
research is being done on it. We human beings are social animals and we are dependent on each
other. A research was conducted in which 45 already conducted researches were analyzed about
cooperative learning. 37 out of 45 researches say that if students work in groups than their
academic achievement is higher. Other remaining 8 researches concluded that if students work in
groups or individually, their achievement remains the same. This was an experimental research
in which one was control group and the other was experimental group. Control group was given
individual tasks while experimental group was provided with cooperative learning tasks. And at
the end, 37 researches shows that the experimental group, who worked using cooperative
learning styles performed much better than the controlled group. The other remaining 8
researches concluded that if students work in groups or individually, their achievement remains
the same.
There is no research which says that cooperative learning has a negative effect. If more than 80%
of the researches say that cooperative learning helps in academic achievement of a student than
essentially cooperative learning tasks must be provided to them.
Cooperative learning:
234
- It is a model which requires student cooperation and interdependence in its task,

goal and reward structure.
- The cooperative learning model is characterized by cooperative task, goal and

reward structures. Further students in cooperative learning situations are
encouraged and/or required to work together on a common task, and they must
coordinate their efforts to complete the task.
- Cooperative learning lessons can be characterized by the following features:
1. Students work in teams to master learning goal.

2. Teams are made up of high, average and low achieving students.
3. Whenever possible, teams include a racial, cultural and gender mix.
4. Reward systems are oriented to the group as well as the individual.
Many classrooms are observed where seating arrangement is in such a way where students
can cooperate with each other. In fact, the students are not doing cooperative tasks. They are
performing individually. They are sitting in groups but they are not cooperating with each
other. Tasks must be cooperative in which each student should actively participate. Make
sure that cooperative learning is challenging enough and could not be done individually.
Goals/Learning outcomes for cooperative learning:

Academic
Academic
achievement Tolerance and
Social acceptance of
skills diversity
Cooperat 235
ive
The cooperative learning model was developed to achieve at least three important
instructional goals: academic achievement, tolerance and acceptance of diversity, and
social skill development.
- Social skills: Communication is the most important skill.
Theoretical and Empirical support:

- The cooperative learning model did not evolve from one individual’s theory or from a
single approach to learning. Its roots go back to the early Greeks, but its contemporary
developments can be traced to the work of educational psychologists and pedagogical
theories at the beginning of the twentieth century, as well as more recent information
processing theories of learning and cognitive and developmental theorists such as Piaget
and Vygotsky.
What are group skills?

- Group skills are the skills with which students participate effectively in a group. E.g.
readiness for action, sequencing a task, managing tasks, negotiation skills,
communication skills, assessing skills or managing skills etc.
Group/Interdependence tasks:
- A situation where a learning task can be accomplished by groups and cannot be
accomplished by individuals who are working alone.
Group Investigation:
236
- It is an approach to cooperative learning in which students help define topics for

study and then work together to complete their investigations.
Planning and conducting cooperative learning lessons:

- Syntax for cooperative learning model relies on small-group work rather than whole
class teaching. (In large groups, there is no measure for gaging the participation of the
students. But in cooperative learning, there must be small groups so that every individual
can play an active role.)
How to plan cooperative learning tasks?

Firstly, you need to identify learning outcomes in the light of academic achievement, social
skills as well as tolerance and acceptance of diversity. Once you have identified the
outcomes, you need to identify the course content, which you are going to teach or you think
that students need to learn or master. Then you need to think about the tasks. The tasks must
be interdependent that could not be achieved by working alone. You need to identify the goal
structure and plan reward system.
- Reward systems are oriented to the group as well as the individual.
- Cooperative learning environment is very important and it needs to be cooperative.

There should be no abuse from the participants or in the classroom.
- Planning tasks associated with cooperative learning puts less emphasis on

organizing academic content and more emphasis on organizing students for small-
group work and collecting a variety of learning materials to be used during group
work.
- Cooperative learning requires deciding on the cooperative methods also. For

example:
237
1. Jigsaw
2. Students Team Achievement Divisions (STAD)
3. Academic controversy
4. Think Pair share
Cooperative Learning Strategies

Lecture # 36
Objectives:
- Cooperative learning for diverse learners

- Cooperative learning strategies: Jigsaw reading, Think, Pair Share(TPS), number
heads, STAD, Academic controversy.
238
Diversity could be of various types’ e.g. linguistic diversity, cultural diversity etc. All the
students sitting in the class could never be same. They may speak different languages; they may
belong to different cultures, their height, weight, and colour may vary as well.
Another word is “disability”. There could be some disabilities in your classroom. There could be
some children who are hard to listening but sometimes teacher don’t come to know and children
also don’t tell because of their shyness. As a result, their performance in class starts to suffer.
If a student has a weak eye sight, it can be removed with the use of spectacles. Similarly hearing
disability can also be removed by using hearing aid. Some students have the disability to
stammer a lot, but if teacher helps them in motivating to speak slowly and help them in speech
therapy it can be overcomed. Actually different students in our class have different needs.
Disability could be minor or swear but if any disability is in our class, we must try to
accommodate it. These diversities or disability can be addressed through cooperative learning.
Cooperative learning for diverse learners:

- The teachers who use cooperative learning must find ways to adapt lessons to meet
the needs of a diverse group of students.
- The most important opportunity inherent in cooperative learning is the chance for
students with special needs and from diverse backgrounds to work together in
cooperative groups and on special projects.
- Teacher must adapt cooperative learning lesson to meet diversity in their classroom.
Before you divide the students into groups for group work, children needs to learn about each
other. They must know the strengths and weaknesses of each other. Once they know about
strengths and weaknesses of each other, then they will be able to cooperate more effectively.
They would be able to communicate more effectively. And ultimately they will be able to
produce something very effectively.
Another thing regarding diverse groups is that teacher’s role is not minimized. Many a times, it
has been observed that when students are placed in different group works, they are not monitored
carefully or give feedback. Specially when there are diverse groups, teacher needs to give them
feedback regularly and constantly. So that students can improve themselves.
- Teacher needs to help regular students understand how their peers with disabilities
differ and what they expect as they work together in learning groups.
- Help all the students understand cultural norms of various ethnic and racial groups
and how these might effect group interaction and cooperation.
Cooperative learning strategies:

- Cooperative learning strategies are:
1. Think-pair-share
239
2. Number heads together

3. Jigsaw reading
4. STAD
5. Academic controversy
1. Jigsaw reading:
Explanation:
In jigsaw puzzle, a picture is divided into many small pieces and students are asked to join these
pieces and make the picture again. Same is the case with jigsaw reading; a teacher has the topic
to teach in the class and he asks to a student to read the text aloud. The text is read aloud by
different students, one paragraph by one student, second by another, third by other and so on.
When a child is reading the passage, half of the class is not listening, most of the times half class
is feeling sleepy or not listening. In this case, teacher randomly asks the students to tell where the
student is reading, on which line or paragraph. If a child tells correct, sometimes teacher get
embarrassed and when child is unable to tell, he feels embarrassed. So, we need to make these
tasks in class interesting. We may use jigsaw reading for this purpose.
In jigsaw reading, you have the text for teaching. Make that text photocopied and then divide it
into 4 or 3 different parts and label them with “A, B, C or D” etc. Give the text to each group of
students to read it carefully. Once they have read the text, you will ask them to close their texts
and discuss these texts with each other for 1 minute. Arrange the students into groups. They will
share their reading with each other. Then the teacher will give certain questions to them in
problem form. You may also ask them to present their answers as well. The groups formed after
the reading are said to be jigsaw groups. The first group formed is simple groups.
These groups are called jigsaw groups because different parts of the texts read by individual
students are put together in one group.
Jigsaw reading include:
- First students will read the text

- Then share with each other
- Speaking and listening
- Then writing
- Writing also have problem solving
2. Think-pair-share:
240
Students are not allowed to come up with individual responses. When two students share
their views with each other and then they share it with the whole class. This activity is called
think-pair-share because the student first thinks individually, then he pairs it with the other
group fellow and at the end it is shared with the whole class. Students look excited in such
activity. Think-pair- share can be effectively used in the revision week at schools. These
activities make revision much easier and effective.
3. Number head together:

- Number heads together is an approach developed by Spencer Kagan (1998) to
involve more students in the review of material covered in a lesson and to check
their understanding of a lesson’s content.
This activity has a direct focus on lesson content. Jigsaw and TPS also involves content but
there is more process. It is very content-oriented cooperative strategy.
Teacher use the following four-step structure in this strategy:
1. Numbering: Teacher divides the students into three-to-five member teams and have
them number off so each student on the team has a different number between 1 and
5.
2. Questioning: teacher asks student a question. Those questions can be very specific
and in question form like “how many provinces are there in Pakistan?”.
3. Heads together? Students put their heads together to figure out and make sure
everyone knows the answer.
4. Rewards: teacher will reward the students and the winning team at the end.
Student Teams Achievement Division (STAD):
In this strategy, there is no issue of discipline.
- STAD was developed by Robert Slavin and his colleague at the John Hopkins
University and is perhaps the simplest and most straight forwards of the cooperative
learning approach.
- In this strategy, students are divided into four or five member learning teams
without any gender or race discrimination.
- Team members use worksheets or other study devices to master the academic
material and then help each other learn the material through tutoring, quizzing one
another, or carrying on team discussions.
- Individually students take weekly or biweekly quizzes on the academic materials.
These quizzes are scored and each individual is given an “improvement score”.
241
- This student’s score is based on the degree to which the score exceeds a students’
past average.
5. Academic controversy: This activity involves teams of students and these students are
given the topic for and against anything. They discuss with each other that how the topic
is controverse.
Organizing Cooperative Learning
242
Lecture # 37
Lecture objectives
 Syntax of Cooperative learning
 Managing cooperative learning
 Assessing cooperative learning
 Advantages and limitations of activity and cooperative method
Syntax of cooperative learning

Syntax means structure. Syntax of cooperative learning includes six phases.
Phase 1: Clarify the goals
In this phase teacher tells the students what are they going to achieve.
Phase 2. Present information
There are different types of cooperative methods. In many techniques teachers present the
information. For example in jigsaw technique teacher is one who select the text. For better
management teacher may present the information.
Phase 3. Organize students into learning teams.
Phase 4. Assist teamwork.
When the children are doing some activity teacher must facilitate the students. his work is not to
control to the students and only informing to the students.
Phase 5. Test on the materials/content
Phase 6. Provide recognition
Concerns in cooperative learning

- What should be the seating arrangement?
- How to make the use of effective resources?
- How to keep noise level normal?
- How to ensure fair share of all group members?
- How to assess individual input and achievement?
- How to resolve conflicts?
- How to ensure group self-assessment?
243
Managing cooperative learning

- Cooperative learning environment requires attention to a unique set of rather difficult
management tasks. e.g. describing students how to accomplish a complex group project is
much more difficult than assigning them problems at the end of a textbook chapter.
- Management tasks unique to cooperative learning help students make the transition from
whole-class to cooperative learning groups, assist students as they work in groups and
teach students social skills and cooperative behavior.
Group Roles
Kagan (1994) roles have been adapted by Arends.
- Task oriented role
- Process oriented role
Task oriented roles are those roles which are needed to complete a task.
Process oriented roles are those roles which smoothens a process.
Under the Task oriented role there are 4 sub roles:

1. Taskmaster: he keep group members on task
2. Material monitor: picks up and returns materials
3. Coach: helps members with lesson content
4. Recorder: records ideas and plans
Under the process oriented role there are 4 sub points:

1. Gatekeeper: equalizes participation
2. Encourager: encourages members
3. Checker : helps members to check for understanding
4. Timekeeper: reminds members of progress and lack of
The difference between the role of a coach and checker is that a coach tells the group what is the
content and how to understand it and checker asks the group whether they have understood this
or not and if not he tells the coach of the existing situation.
244
Common situations
Miss Amna is concerned about her eighth-graders’ performance in jigsaw. Some home groups
consistently do very well, while others fail to learn essential information. She believes that some
students, especially the lower achievers, have difficulty presenting their material well. How
might she address this concern?
In jigsaw reading student select the text. Those students who select the same text are called home
group.
1. Should she provide each expert group with study guides to help them identify key
information?
2. Should she develop some additional roles in the home groups so students who have
trouble presenting material effectively can play other roles?
3. Should she form a teacher-led expert group and assign slower students who have trouble
presenting material to that group?
4. Have each home group present to the whole class so all students have the same
opportunities to learn the material?
Jigsaw technique has two parts in first part children read the same text they are called
home groups. In second part children of different home groups share their information.
Problem in jigsaw technique is that when children do not understand the text in home
groups they will not be able to present it in jigsaw groups. Understanding in home group
is very much important.
Assigning different roles is a good thing in jigsaw technique a coach and a checker can be
helpful in understanding the text. We should go for the second option. In management the most
important thing is assigning the tasks.
Quiz
- Miss Ayesha introduces a rule in her group discussions that the students really enjoy.
Each student is given three tokens that are worth 15 seconds of talk time. When the
245
tokens are gone, the student is no longer be able to participate in the discussion. She most
likely instituted this rule to control --------.
a. Noise level.
b. The amount of time that dominant students take up in such activities.
c. The lack of participation of quite or shy students.
d. Both b and c.
Its correct answer is b. it is an interesting way to manage group activity.
Assessment of Cooperative Learning Strategy

- The cooperative learning model changes the reward system and consequently, requires a
different approach to evaluation and recognition of achievement.
- A special challenge for cooperative learning teaching is how to grade for both team and
individual efforts.
- For STAD and some version of jigsaw the teacher requires student to take quizzes on the
learning material.
- Test item on these quizzes must be of an objective type, so they can be scored in class or
soon after.
- The primary goal of cooperative learning is social skill development. These skills are not
as easy to assess as academic skills are.
Students collaborative skills can be assessed through a Rubric designed so. Rubrics are of
two types it can be rating scale and it can be of checklist. Rubrics are actually instruments to
assess.
- In cooperative learning teachers have to be careful about their reward structure. It is
important for teachers to reward the group product both the end result and the cooperative
behavior that produced it.
- Students should be assessed both in a group form and on individual basis. For this
purpose teacher may do two evaluations for students. one for the group’s effort and one
for each person’s individual contribution.
246
Quiz
- Which of the following are the ways team achievements can be recognized?
1. Displaying group work in the halls.
2. Publishing teams’ names in a class newsletter.
3. Giving certificates to team members.
4. All of the above.
These are all suitable ways to recognize the group efforts.
“Project Learning”
Lecture # 38
Lecture objectives:
247
 Reinforcement of Assessing group task

 Essentials of group learning
 Project learning
 Project learning and thinking skills
 Essential components of learning projects
 Kinds of projects
Assessment: It is always a concern for teachers that how to assess group work. Most of the
teachers claim that in group learning, they could not identify individual’s learning. Individual
performance is hidden in group tasks and as a result the students who do not work, never tries to
work, and those who work always continue to participate in cooperative tasks. So the reward
structure should be individualistic as well as group oriented. E.g. in a cricket match, when a team
wins there is a recognition of team and also at individual performance basis, there is a title given
as ‘man of the match’. So group effort and recognition is there but you need to know what
individual’s contribution in that is.
Here is a situation for understanding:

- Whenever Miss Amna uses jigsaw in her social studies classes she gives three
grades: a quiz grade that assesses individual knowledge of the material, an
individual grade for contribution to the group, and a group grade that reflects the
group’s accomplishments. Is her grading congruent with the cooperative learning
system?
1. No, the grading system penalizes students if their teammates do not perform well.
2. Yes, the grades reflect a balanced assessment of individual and group achievement.
3. Yes, the grades will reward motivated students who exhibit independence.
4. No, the grading system overemphasizes individual accountability.
“No. 2 is the correct option”
So, being teachers we are concerned about assessment of group work that’s why we are reluctant
to use group activities in our class. But after learning about how to assess group activities in
248
different ways teachers must try to include them in their routine lessons, so that we can ensure
students’ knowledge development, skill development as well as attitude development.
Project Based Learning:
Project Based Learning is an instructional approach built upon authentic learning activities that

engage student interest and motivation. These activities are designed to answer a question or
solve a problem and generally reflect the types of learning and work people do in the everyday
world outside the classroom.
Project Based Learning is synonymous with learning in depth. A well-designed project provokes
students to encounter (and struggle with) the central concepts and principles of a discipline.
Project Based Learning teaches students 21st century skills as well as content. These skills
include communication and presentation skills, organization and time management skills,
research and inquiry skills, self-assessment and reflection skills, and group participation and
leadership skills.
Project Based Learning is generally done by groups of students working together toward a
common goal. Performance is assessed on an individual basis, and takes into account the quality
of the product produced, the depth of content understanding demonstrated, and the contributions
made to the ongoing process of project realization.
Finally, Project Based Learning allows students to reflect upon their own ideas and opinions,
exercise voice and choice, and make decisions that affect project outcomes and the learning
process in general.
Essentials of cooperative learning:

Four essential features of group work MUST be planned. If we do not plan these four features
than our group work would be disaster. We will not be able to hold a meaningful activity in
class. They are:
249
1. How to form heterogeneous groups? Do remember, heterogeneous groups are spirit of

cooperative learning. Make groups randomly so that all high achievers may not get into
one group. Or all low achievers in one group.
2. How students are to work in their groups? It means that a teachers needs to note down
all the steps and these steps to do a particular task must be shared with the students.
Teachers must provide clear and well-structured instructions to the students to perform a
particular task.
3. How rewards are to be distributed? Teacher must tell the students about rewards that
will be given to them at the end of the tasks.
4. How much time is required? Teacher must communicate budgeted time of the task to
the students.
Limitations of Cooperative Learning:

- The biggest limitation is the mindset. We assume that cooperating learning strategies or
group learning activities are ‘all play and no work’. Only memorizing the books is
learning. We have to change this mindset.
- Fear of management and assessment: many students, particularly those who excel in
the more traditional, individualistic rewards structure, will likewise object to approaches
in which interdependent activities are valued and rewards as shared.
Project Learning:
- According to research, if projects are structured properly, they allow the learner or groups
of learners to be immersed in one big idea, or to work towards one common goal.
250
- The project challenges learners to use a variety of skills and intelligence and allows them
to be involved in meaningful activity.
- Projects tend to be multidimensional and they encourage learners to extend their
understanding of the content beyond the classroom and into real world.
- It is important for the teacher to consider students’ developmental level when designing
projects.
-
Project Learning and Thinking Skills:
- Skills needed to accomplish the project will usually include problem solving, critical
and creative thought and the ability to present information to others.
- According to Chapman and Freeman (1996), there are two factors that need to be
considered:
1. The students’ ability to process information and
2. The way in which the project will be used to extend the learning experience in
any particular content area.
(Project learning definitely enhances thinking skills of the students.)
Skills developed through projects:
They may be classified under three coloumns,
Critical thinking skills Creative thinking skills Social skills

1. Attributing 1. Brainstorming Respecting others
2. Compare/contrast 2. Visualizing Working independently
3. Classifying 3. Personifying Managing time
4. Sequencing 4. Inventing Cooperating
5. Prioritizing 5. Associating Sharing
6. Draw conclusions 6. Inferring Using resources effectively
7. Determining cause/Effect 7. Generalizing Making choices/decisions
251
8. Analyzing for bias 8. Predicting

9. Analyzing for assumptions 9. Hypothesizing
10. Solving analogies 10. Making Analogies
11. Evaluating 11. Dealing with
ambiguity and paradox
12. Decision making 12. Problem solving
Essential Components of Learning Projects:

- Teachers allow time for meeting with students to discuss project criteria. (It is very
important that there should be a project criteria. If students do not create project criteria
then they will not be able to keep record of their pace and performance. Teacher may
give time to the students to make their own group criteria after giving them directions.)
- The “Mini-conferences” should take place, on person, as often as possible because

these students will be working independently, e-mail communication should be
encouraged, if available.
- Projects provide perfect opportunities for teachers to plan mini conferences. They
should provide structure for sharing of students’ work.
- Classmates and students from other classroom could be invited to view students
presentations, as well as to evaluate them.
- Carefully constructed questions (lower and higher order) could provide valuable
learning opportunities for students attending the “projects/conference”.
Kinds of projects:
Projects may simply be classified under three categories. These are:
- Exploratory Projects
- Research Projects
252
- Product focused Projects
Usually it is said that projects are product focused i.e. at the end of the project, we ultimately get
a product and that is a product which may be used by some people. But actually, the projects are
not limited to product. They may be exploratory projects or research projects. Whichever the
project may be, either it is research or exploratory, the information it provide will be highly
valuable for other people.
Example of food – Project Learning:
- You have learnt how to cook different foods, now explore foods of different regions
of Pakistan and plan a food carnival.
Projects: Possible projects that can be given to students on food areas follows:
- Adventure projects may last for weeks
- Making a classroom cookbook
- Making a cookbook for diabetics
- Making science/Geography Math Room
- Establishing a language lab
All these projects are product focused because the ultimate product will be used by some
other users/people.
Exploratory projects:
Exploratory projects are those where children explore something. E.g. Adventure projects,
they may last for a week or more than a week. Girl guide and scouts’ projects are all
adventure projects. Teachers may ask the students to visit places and to explore them. The
report of adventure project will be very useful for others. So, whenever you send the students
to such trips, ask them to make reports at the end of the project.
Research Projects:
253
Scientific method is often used in research. In research, you actually raise some questions
and try to answer those questions whose answers are not there. Teachers can ask the students
to conduct researches at very lower levels. The findings of those researches or the outcome
may be used by other people. Research for young children can be:
- To study a phenomenon.
- To make a record of all activities which are done in one week in school assembly?
Any inquiry task can be given to the students. Teachers can make them learn the application of
scientific method. Teachers need to ask the students to apply scientific method to carry out
certain research projects. And definitely when they will be working on a research project, their
critical thinking skills, creative abilities and social skills will be developed.
Comments:
Teacher role in project-based learning:
Project-based learning is only possible in classrooms where teachers support students by giving
sufficient guidance and feedback. The teacher must thoroughly explain all tasks that are to be
completed, provide detailed directions for how to develop the project, and circulate within the
classroom in order to answer questions and encourage student motivation. In order to create
successful units focused on project-based learning, teachers must plan well and be flexible. In
this approach to instruction, teachers often find themselves in the role of learner and peer with
the students. Teachers can assess project-based learning with a combination of objective tests,
checklists, and rubrics; however, these often only measure task completion. The inclusion of a
reflective writing component provides for self-evaluation of student learning.
Student role in project-based learning:
254
Students generally work in small, collaborative groups in the project-based learning model. They
find sources, conduct research, and hold each other responsible for learning and the completion
of tasks. Essentially, students must be “self-managers” in this approach to instruction.6
Results of project-based learning research are mixed. Some studies suggest that it is an
engaging instructional approach, but numerous studies have also claimed that students are not
motivated by this type of learning, and that it places a great amount of stress on teachers.
Discussion Method
255
Lecture # 39
Lecture Content
- Overview of classroom Discussion

- Wait time
- Planning and conducting discussion lessons
- Types of Classroom discussion
- Managing classroom discussion
- Assessment & Evaluation of classroom discussions
- Syntax of classroom discussion
What is Discussion?
The word discussion very often used with the word discourse. If we will see its dictionary
meanings, they both are considered as ways of exchanging ideas. But these both terms are quite
different.
Discussion – Key Term
- Discourse The larger patterns of verbal exchange and communication that occur in the
classrooms.
- Discussion A teaching method that relies on verbal exchange of ideas among students
and the teachers.
- Researchers usually talk about discourse and teachers usually talk about discussion.
- Discourse is overall pattern and discussion is the exchange of ideas.
Overview of Classroom Discussion
256
- When experienced teachers refer to classroom discussions, they characterize them by

students and teachers talking about academic materials and by students willingly
displaying their thinking processes publicly.
- The primary instructional goals of a discussion lesson are to improve student thinking, to
promote involvement and engagement in academic materials and to learn important
communication and thinking skills.
Theoretical Foundations
Conceptual
understanding
Classroom
Discussion
involvement and Communication and

engagement thinking
Theoretical Foundations
Every theory is based on research.
- Most classroom discourse proceeds at too rapid a pace. Teachers can obtain better
classroom discourse by slowing down the pace and giving themselves and their students
opportunities to think before they respond. Researcher used the word discourse for
discussion method.
257
Learning environment for a useful discussion
- In general, discussion and classroom discourse patterns can be improved if teachers slow
the pace and use methods to broaden participation and if they teach students to try to
understand one another and have high interpersonal regard for each other’s ideas and
feelings.
- Teaching students four specific interpersonal communication skills (paraphrasing,
behavior description, feeling description and impression checking) can enhance the
quality of classroom discourse and students’ regard for each other.
In communication there is paraphrasing (the showing of understanding on some communication.

In classroom discussion there is a lot of opportunity of paraphrasing. Behavior description is
another important skill in communication. Teachers need to exhibit the correct behavior of the
student. We must be able to exhibit our feeling in the classroom. For example if some student is
not agree on some point to a person. He can show his feelings in a good way. Describing one’s
feeling is very important.
How to plan and use Classroom Discussion
- An important planning task for a discussion lesson is deciding on which approach to use.
There are several kinds of discussions. Major approaches include using discussion in
conjunction with other teaching models; recitation discussions; discovery or inquiry
discussions and discussions to clarify values and share personal experiences.
- Other important planning tasks for teachers to consider include determining the purposes
of the discussion; and determining the type of questions to ask.
- Placing students in circles or using U-shaped seating arrangements facilitates classroom
discussions. Socratic method is basically a discussion method. It is also called dialogic
method. We can develop knowledge through this method.
- Primary tasks for teachers as they conduct a discussion consists of focusing the
discussion; keeping the discussion on track; keeping a record of the discussion; listening
to students ideas and providing appropriate wait time. Wait time is thinking time.
258
Question should be directive to the whole class. Than teacher should take a pause and
indicate a student to answer the question. Teacher must give his feedback before moving
on to the next student or question. The purpose of discussion is not only giving the
information but to generate the thinking skills. The most important thing in thinking skills
is to provide the wait time.
- Teacher should respond with dignity to the students’ ideas. They should help the students
extend their ideas by seeking clarification, getting students to consider alternative ideas
and labeling students’ thinking processes. Channelizing students responses are very
important. Teacher role is like a facilitator.
- Teacher must be aware of gender discourse differences as well as those that stem from
race and class. To be effective, they must adapt discussion to meet the diverse language
patterns of their students. Teacher needs to know about the diversity in the class.
Types of Discussion
Excerpt 1
- Teacher: What are the sources of water pollution?

- Student A: People……
- Student B: The litter thrown in water.
- Student C: Oil from oil tankers.
- Teacher: Any other source of water pollution?
(Silence in the class)
- Teacher: What about the pesticides sprayed on plants?
- Student D: Pesticides are necessary to kill the pests which cause harm to the plants.
Excerpt 2
- Teacher: I think there are many sources of water pollution.

- Student A: People……..
- Student B: The litter thrown in water.
- Student C: Oil from oil tanker.
259
- Teacher: May be factory waste also.

- Student D: I think Pesticides also pollute water but they are necessary to kill the pests
which cause harm to the plants.
- Teacher: Yes I agree but can there be some other way of doing something instead of
using pesticides.
- Student E: I do not know exactly but we may use biological measures to reduce the use
of insecticides.
- Teacher: I think all unnatural habits and things cause water pollution.
- Student A: It means people are the source of water pollution, in fact.
In both excerpt there is discussion.
IRE or Recitation Script
- Initiate – Respond – Evaluate (IRE) discourse pattern.

- The IRE pattern has been labeled a “ monologic discourse pattern” (Alexander, 2006), in
which teachers take turns at will decide on what topics are important to discuss, decide
who will talk and for how long, and interject their responses and interpretations
controlling the pace and direction of the discussion. This is known as teacher centered
discussion.
- Teacher’s talk time is more than 50% of students talk time.
Dialogic Discussion
- Dialogic discussion also called as interactive discussion. This has come from Socrates
method. In second script there was dialogue. First script is monologic because there was a
lot of teacher control.
- In this interaction, students produce a “chain of utterances” (Nystrand, 2006) where they
are able to talk without interruption or re-direction from the teacher. Students listen and
respond to one another as well as the teacher. In addition, the teacher responds to the
students’ ideas rather than the students simply answering a series of questions asked by
260
the teacher. Dialogic discussion promote divergent thinking. Monologic discussion

promotes convergent thinking.
Assessing classroom discussion
- Classroom discussion is assessed on four skills communication, thinking skills, active

engagement and conceptual understanding. We can not assess all these skills on papper
pencil test we need different techniques to assess different skills.
Syntax of classroom discussion
- Phase 1: clarify aims and establish set

- Phase 2: focus the discussion (rules, issue, situation)
- Phase 3: hold the discussion
- Phase 4: end the discussion
- Phase 5: debrief the discussion (examining own thinking processes)
261
Direct Instruction
Lecture # 40
Lesson content
 Syntax of classroom discussions
 Direct instruction
 Theoretical and empirical support
 Planning and Conducting Direct Instruction Lessons
 Managing direct instruction
 Assessing direct instruction
Syntax for holding Classroom Discussion

Phase 1. Clarify aims and establish set.
Phase 2. Focus the discussion (rules, issue, situation)
Phase 3. Hold the discussion.
Phase 4. End the discussion.
Phase 5. Debrief the discussion (examining own thinking processes)
In the first step teacher need to tell the students what they are going to achieve at the end of the
lesson before the discussion. Second phase is about the rules of discussion. For example what
language and expressions should be used. In third step we will see what type of discussion will
be held. There are two types of discussions 1. Monologic 2. Dialogic. Monologic discussion is
teacher centered discussion. In dialogic discussion teacher is also just like another participant.
Next step is about the timeframe of discussion. At the end teacher actually sums up the
262
discussion. In debriefing teacher tells the students to reflect what they have learnt through this
process. It can develop thinking skills of the students. Reflective thinking will be developed
through debriefing.
Example questions
- Which of the following is not a primary instructional outcome for discussion?
a. Increased retention of basic knowledge.
b. Improve communication skills.
c. Greater student engagement.
d. Higher-level thinking.
Correct answer is a. in discussion method the purpose is not that students will memorize the
content. Its basic purpose is to develop the higher level thinking skills of the children.
- Which of the following is the best learning environment for a discussion?
a. Highly structured with active student roles.
b. Active teacher role
c. Moderately structured with active student roles.
d. It depends upon the topic being discussed.
The correct answer is d. the most important thing in discussion is that if the topic is convergent
teacher should be active. And if the topic is divergent then the teacher must have less talk time.
While planning discussion we should keep it in mind not to plan discussion on abstract topics.
Direct Instruction.
It is very much teacher controlled method. It is not exactly lecture. Difference between lecture
and direct instruction is that lecture only gives declarative knowledge. In direct instruction just
gives declarative as well as procedural knowledge to the students. direct instruction is a broder
term. It also develops the skills of the students.
- The instructional effects of the direct instruction model are to promote mastery of simple
and complex skills and declarative knowledge that can be carefully defined and taught in
a step-by-step fashion.
263
- The direct instruction model draws its theoretical support from behavioral theory, social
learning theory and teacher effectiveness research.
A lot of examples are there which involves procedural knowledge. For example in math there are
facts and concepts but it has procedural knowledge also. Teacher tells about a formula and a
step- by-step procedure to use that formula. Art work is also its example. Task analysis model is
used under the domain of direct instruction.
Planning direct instruction

- The five phases of a direct instruction model are:
1. Providing objectives and establishing set.
2. Demonstrating or explaining the materials to be learned.
3. Providing guided practice.
4. Checking for the student understanding and providing feedback.
5. Providing for extended practice and transfer.
Key Terms
Guided practice
Practice assigned to the students to be completed under the guidance or watchful eye of the
teacher.
Distributed Practice
Practice assigned to the students to be done for brief periods spread over several sessions or
periods of time.
Massed practice
Practice assigned to students to be done during a single extended period of time.
Independent practice
264
Practice given to the students to accomplish on their own without the teachers’ guidance.
Homework
Independent practice and academic work performed outside the classroom. Homework is very
important in direct instruction.
Overlearning
Working or practicing a task or skill until it is learned completely and can be performed
automatically.
Daily drill of anything is distributed practice. Automation is the example of overlearning.
Automation is very important in direct instruction. If the child is not reached to the level of
automation it means that we are not using direct instruction properly.
Conducting Direct Instruction

- Conducting a direct instruction lesson requires teachers to explain things clearly; to
demonstrate and model practice behaviors; and to provide for practice, monitoring of
performance and feedback.
- The use of practice should be guided by several principles; assigning short, meaningful
amounts of practice; assigning practice to increase overlearning; and making appropriate
use of massed and distributed practice.
Meaningful practice is very important in direct instruction. Just like practice feedback is also
very important. Modeling is a way to present certain behavior and learning. In modeling
feedback is very important. Feedback should be appropriate and constructive. For example if we
say very good to the student this will not be an appropriate feedback because child will not
understand about the areas of improvement.
Environment for conducive Direct Instruction

Direct instruction lessons require the unique classroom management skill of gaining students’
attention in a whole-group setting and sustaining this attention for extended periods of time.
Particular classroom management concerns include organizing the classroom setting for
maximum effect; maintaining appropriate pace, flow and momentum; sustaining engagement,
265
involvement and participation; and dealing with student behavior quickly and firmly. Declarative
knowledge can be assessed through paper and pencil.
Assessment of learning through direct instruction

- Assessment tasks associated with the model put emphasis on practice and on developing
and using appropriate basic knowledge and performance tests that can accurately measure
simple and complex skills and provide feedback.
Limitations
- Too teacher centered.
- Keeps students in passive roles.
- However, it remains a very popular teaching model because it allows a teacher to
accomplish major goals of education as expressed by the larger society.
- Rosenshine (1987) came up with a conclusion that, ”Teaching mathematical procedures,
computation, reading, explicit reading procedures(distinguishing between fact and
opinion, science concepts, rules, foreign language and grammar can be easily done
through direct instruction”.
266
“Discovery Learning Vs Presentation”

Lecture # 41
Discovery learning is a learner-centered method. Presentation is a teacher-centered

method. For learning activities, we prefer students-centered learning methods.
Sometimes people tend to use word discovery learning for activity based learning. All activities
are not discoveries.
- Discovery learning is a method which employs spirit of discovery.
What is discovery learning?

- Discovery learning is “an approach to instruction through which students interact
with their environment-by exploring and manipulating objects, wrestling with
questions and controversies, or performing experiments”
(Ormrod, 1995, p. 442)
- Discovery learning encompasses an instructional model and strategies that focus on

active, hands-on learning opportunities for students.
(Dewey, 1916/1997; Piaget, 1954, 1973).
Discovery learning is a teaching method in which a student interacts with the environment and
tries to learn something. A child discovers knowledge for himself/herself.
267
For example, a teacher takes her students in a lawn or in a ground and asks them to observe the
things very carefully. She can ask the students to identify how many kinds of flowers are there in
the lawn. Or the flowers in the lawn are of how many colours? Students will try discovering the
flowers. Similarly, children play a variety of games which comes under discovery learning i.e.
jigsaw puzzles, it means that a child is trying to discover the parts of the puzzle and then try to
fix them.
Attributes of Discovery Learning:

Tracy Bicknell-Homes and Paul Hoffman explain that discovery learning has three main
characteristics:
- Exploration and problem solving;
- Student-centered activities based on students interest; and
- Scaffolding new information into students’ funds of knowledge (scaffolding:
Providing an outside support)
Types of Discovery Learning: Category 1.

- Experiments: Definitely in experiments the students are discovering, not only at the end
but in the process of experiment as well. E.g. sometimes students may discover that the
material used in the experiment is not of a good quality. Students discover knowledge for
themselves.
- Exploration: The action of traveling in or through an unfamiliar area in order to

learn about it. Exploration can be in jigsaw puzzles or in treasure hunt games etc.
Exploration of any type is discovery learning.
- Simulation-based learning: A simulation-based learning environment is a setting for learning

that includes a controlled, shielded and often simplified copy of a real world process or system to
be studied. Simulations are done in the virtual environments and are computer based. A
child engaged in simulation based learning is again discovery.
268
- Problem-based learning
- Inquiry-based learning
- Webquests
The above underlines types of learning are all students-centered.
Types of Discovery Learning: Category 2.
1. Case-based learning:
- Groups of students are given a case to read and examine. The class then discusses
possible solutions to the problem described. Teachers must provide the students with
opportunities to discover things. Case method or case-based learning activities are in fact
very engaging.
2. Incidental learning:
- Game-like activities
- Crossword puzzles
3. Learning by exploring/Conversing:
- Students asking questions
- What’s in the bag? Game
4. Learning by reflection:
- Learning to ask better questions
- Teacher answers a students’ questions with additional questions for the students to
answer (Socratic method)
5. Simulation-based learning:
- Experimenting in an artificial environment
269
- Allows for trials without fear of failing

- Planning and taking a space mission
Syntax of discovery learning: (Steps)

There are 9 steps of discovery learning, and discovery learning should be done according to these
nine steps:
1. Select an activity. Choose an activity that does not have just one correct answer. Role-
playing, creating sculptures, observing characteristics of subjects, or searching for or
classifying similar items all work well. (Select an activity that ensures discovery learning
in it.)
2. Gather material. Plan enough materials for each learner to repeat the activity at least
once.
3. Stay focused. Avoid learning tangents that may be interesting but will keep the learner
away from finishing the project. (Whenever discovery learning is planned, there are many
interesting tasks for the students. Sometimes students attention is diverted, it should not
happen. Teacher needs to ensure that students are focused.)
4. Use caution. While the idea of discovery learning is for the instructor to step back and
observe allowing the child to work independently, be sure that safety is observed.
5. Plan extra time. Understand that children working on their own will most likely take
longer than they would with an adult moving them from step to step. Also be sure to plan
time for repeated activities in case there is a failure or other reason to repeat the activity.
6. Record process and results. Include in the activity a requirement for older children to
record their procedure and results. For young children guide, assist, or model record
keeping.
270
7. Feedback and review. After an activity is completed and before it is repeated a second
time (if needed), discuss the activity and its outcome with the child. Use the records
which were kept to assist during this step.
8. Try again. Have the child repeat the activity if necessary. Give assistance and guidance
as necessary.
9. Plan for more discovery learning activities. Think over how this activity worked for
the child. As you plan more discovery activities take the answers to these questions into
consideration. What went well? What could have gone better? How can any problem
areas be corrected or alleviated?
Examples of Discovery Learning:

- Are all oak leaves of the same shape? Make children aware of the diversity within
leaf structure. Introduce, or reinforce, simple recording skills, and practice basic
counting skills too.
- Treasure hunt
- Underground plant exploration
- Look at pictures and describe Harappa Civilization.
“Presentation- A Teacher-centered Method”
It is sometimes called as lecture method.
- It is an approach to teaching wherein the primary emphasis is on explaining new

information and ideas to students where information is about knowledge of facts,
concepts or principles.
271
- Presentations, explanations, and lectures by teachers comprise a large portion of

classroom time primarily because curricula in schools have been structured around
bodies of information that students are expected to learn.
Syntax for presentation:

- Need to present objectives and establish set.
- Presenting an advance organizer
- Using processes to monitor student understanding and to help extend and
strengthen student thinking.
- Effective presentations are those presentations which follow rule-example-rule
technique
Rule-example-rule technique:
- A technique used when explaining something whereby the general principle or rule
is given first, then elaborated on with specific examples, and finally summarized by
a restatement of the rule.
Quiz:
Which of the following lesson objectives will be more appropriate for a lesson using the
presentation model?
1. Students will be able to dissect a frog.
2. Students will describe the anatomy of the frog.
3. Students will prepare a slide for microscopic view.
4. Students will examine frog cells under a microscope.
Because the primary purpose of presentation model is to give information. Information could be
of facts, concepts or generalizations. So, presentation method is generally used for giving
information to the students. But students will not gather information unless a teacher do not
employ the technique of rule-example-rule.
272
“Motivation for Learning”

Lecture # 42
Outline:
 Motivation
 Motivational theories
- Reinforcement theory
- Need theory
- Maslow’s hierarchy of needs
- Cognitive theories of motivation
- Social learning theories
 Intrinsic vs Extrinsic motivation
 Productive learning community
 Features for classroom motivation
Motivation:
It is a driving force which helps someone to perform a task. So, motivation can be named as a
force which keeps the person moving on.
- The concept of human motivation is defined as the processes within individuals that
arouse them to action. It is what gets individuals “moving” towards specified
activities and tasks.
It is a complex process which is made up of different processes. These are processes which helps
the person to act.
273
Motivation theories:
Do remember, that no concept is authentic or it can be debated unless it is not backed up with
support of theories. There are four distinct categories of motivation:
- Many theories of motivation exist. For that are particularly relevant to education
include reinforcement theory, needs theories, cognitive theories and social learning
theories.
1. Reinforcement theory:
Reinforcement theory emphasizes the importance of individuals responding
to environmental events and extrinsic reinforcements.
Environmental factors are important to reinforce certain behaviour. E.g. if you want to reinforce
a behaviour among your students that they must do their homework. You can reinforce this
behavior among students by giving them rewards. To inforce behaviour positively among
students is a positive reinforcement.
Negative reinforcement occurs when something already present is removed (taken away) as a
result of a person's behaviour, creating a favorable outcome for that person. Basically, when a
person's behaviour leads to the removal of something that was unpleasant to that person then
negative reinforcement is occurring.
Reinforcement theory of motivation says that children’s behaviour can be modified through
positive or negative reinforce.
 Positive reinforcement: the adding of an appetitive stimulus to increase a certain behavior or

response.
Example: Father gives candy to his daughter when she picks up her toys. If the frequency of picking
up the toys increases or stays the same, the candy is a positive reinforcer.
 Positive punishment: the adding of an aversive stimulus to decrease a certain behavior or
response.
Example: Mother yells at a child when running into the street. If the child stops running into the street
the yelling is positive punishment.
 Negative reinforcement: the taking away of an aversive stimulus to increase certain behavior or
response.
274
Example: Putting ointment on a bug bite to soothe an itch. If using ointment on bug bites increases,
the removal of an itch is a negative reinforcer.
 Negative punishment (omission training): the taking away of an appetitive stimulus to
decrease a certain behavior.
Example: A teenager comes home an hour after curfew and the parents take away the teen's cell
phone for two days. If the frequency of coming home after curfew decreases, the removal of the
phone is negative punishment.
Quiz:
Fatima is a student who has been suspended for cheating in class. The act of suspension is
best called -----------.
A. A positive reinforce
B. A negative reinforce
C. A punishment
D. Intrinsic motivation
What would you do as a future teacher to enhance intrinsic motivation in

your students?
Motivating students to become intrinsically motivated is no easy task for teachers. To some students, they
enjoy learning. But for the others, this is where is the challenge really comes in. To facilitate material to
students "dry" would totally be out of my agenda. I would try to teach to my students to the point where
the material becomes alive within them. I to make their minds grow in curiosity of the subject so continual
learning can take place. I would do this by means of relating material to what interests the students. I
would also put as much energy into my teaching whether it be in my tone of voice, body language,
appearance, or all of the above. One thing that I'd like to do also is at the end of my class period, I would
try to always close my lessons leaving my students with a question to ponder on dealing with the subject
material that was taught. That way in their spare time, their minds will continue to ponder on the lesson
and question at hand.
Need theory:
275
- There are several different need theories. In general, these theories hold that
individuals strive to satisfy internal needs such as self-fulfillment, achievement,
affiliation, influence, and self-determination.
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs:

Maslow says that there are five basic needs, he made a pyramid of those needs and categorizes
them as:
1. Biological and physiological needs.
2. Safety needs
3. Belongingness and love needs
4. Esteem needs
276
5. Self-actualization needs
Physiological needs:
277
The definition of physiological needs is quite obvious; they are the physical requirements for
human survival. If these requirements are not met, the human body cannot function properly, and
will ultimately fail. Physiological needs are thought to be the most important; they should be met
first. Therefore, a human lacking food, love, esteem, or safety would consider the greatest of
his/her needs to be food.
Safety needs:
With their physical needs relatively satisfied, the individual's safety needs take precedence and
dominate behavior. In the absence of physical safety – due to war, natural disaster etc. – people
may (re-)experience stress disorder. In the absence of economic safety – due to economic crisis
and lack of work opportunities – these safety needs manifest themselves in ways such as a
preference for job security,
Love and belonging:

After physiological and safety needs are fulfilled, the third level of human needs is interpersonal
and involves feelings of belongingness. According to Maslow, humans need to feel a sense of
belonging and acceptance among their social groups, regardless if these groups are large or
small. Some examples of small social connections include family members, intimate partners,
mentors, colleagues, and confidants. Humans need to love and be loved - both sexually and non-
sexually - by others.
Esteem:
All humans have a need to feel respected; this includes the need to have self-esteem and self-
respect. Esteem presents the typical human desire to be accepted and valued by others. People
often engage in a profession or hobby to gain recognition. These activities give the person a
sense of contribution or value. Low self-esteem or an inferiority complex may result from
imbalances during this level in the hierarchy. People with low self-esteem often need respect
from others; they may feel the need to seek fame or glory. However, fame or glory will not help
the person to build their self-esteem until they accept who they are internally.
278
Self-actualization:
This level of need refers to what a person's full potential is and the realization of that potential.
Maslow describes this level as the desire to accomplish everything that one can, to become the
most that one can be. However, this is a broad definition of the need for self-actualization; when
applied to individuals, the need is specific. For example, one individual may have the strong
desire to become an ideal parent. In another, the desire may be expressed athletically.
Cognitive theories of motivation:

Cognition means to know or to proceed. Cognitive theories do not address much about
motivation. But there are few who address motivation, these are:
- Cognitive theories of motivation stress the importance of the way people think and
the beliefs and attributes they have about life’s situations.
- Learners actively construct their own understandings. Because they are active
learners and they actively construct their knowledge and understanding. So, teachers may
help them to understand any expectation at cognitive level. Cognitive theories focuses on
‘whatever we teachers do, that needs to bring change in consciousness’. So our focus will
be on consciousness and not only about observing the behaviour. And this is the major
difference between cognitive theories and reinforcement theories.
Social Learning theories:

- Social learning theory hypothesizes that individual’s actions are influenced by the
value particular goals hold for them and their expectations for success.
- These theories help us to understand how modeling and reinforcement work in a
social context.
- Important sources for motivation for social learning theorists include learner
expectations and personal goals. (Bandura, 1986)
Here our social context is very important. It tells us which behaviour needs to be exhibited.
There are two important factors i.e. personal goals and external expectations.
279
- Bandura renamed social learning theory as social cognitive theory as it involves on a

number of ideas drawn from cognitive science.
- Bandura worked on modeling process which was his great contribution. Let us
revise that. Modeling involves: attention, retention, production and motivation.
Quiz:
Faiza initiates a program that rewards students who hand in completing assignments on
time for one full month by allowing them to have a pizza party. Homework completion rate
increases substantially. The theory that best explains this student behaviour is -----------.
A). Need Theory
B). Social Learning Theory
C). Reinforcement Theory
D). Cognitive theory
Extrinsic vs Intrinsic motivation:

- Expectations based upon consequences have extrinsic rewards.
- Intrinsic motivation may be defined as what motivates us to do something when we
don’t have to do anything. (Raffini, 1996)
- Extrinsic and intrinsic motivations are two opposing ways to motivate people. Extrinsic
motivation deals with motivations that are outside of your passions, and personal self-
esteem. Extrinsic motivation examples would be money, bonuses, nice cars, expensive
houses, high grades in school, gold stars for athletics, etc. Extrinsic motivation is
anything outside of yourself that you need to obtain or acquire to increase
motivation. Intrinsic motivation is the opposite. You get paid for doing what you truly
enjoy doing, nice cars and houses don’t motivate you as much as your joy in work,
learning, and the things that truly motivate you internally.
What research says about extrinsic and intrinsic motivation?

- Kohn (1993) findings:
280
- Young children do not need to be rewarded to learn. He says that children are
intrinsically motivated
- At any stage, rewards are less effective than intrinsic motivation.
- Rewards for learning undermine intrinsic motivation.
Productive Learning Community:

Teachers must not motivate individual students rather there should be collective motivation, so
that the whole class becomes the learning community. Productive learning community is
something where children are producing some good processes and ultimately processing some
good results.
- A productive learning community is characterized by an overall climate in which
students feel positive about themselves and their peers, individual needs are satisfied
so students persist in academic tasks and work cooperatively with the teacher, and
students have the requisite interpersonal and group skills to meet the demands of
classroom life.
Features of classrooms for students’ motivation:

- Three important features that help us understand classroom communities include
classroom processes, and classroom structures.
- Classroom properties are distinctive features of classrooms that help shape
behaviour. These include six important properties: multidimensionality,
simultaneity, immediacy, unpredictability, publicness, and history. These properties
influence classroom life.
- Classroom processes define interpersonal and group features of classrooms and
include friendship, expectations, leadership, norms, communication, and
cohesiveness.
- Classroom structures are the foundations that shape particular lessons and
behaviors during those lessons. Three important structures include task, goal, and
participation structure.
281
Motivation strategies:
Teachers use a variety of motivational strategies in their classes. It includes behavior
modification strategies, Teachers identify individual learning needs, teachers model them,
sometimes case studies are given to them so that they can reflect on them and their cognition is
improved.
Teaching Models for Motivation

Lecture # 43
Lesson Content
 Motivation for learning
 Teacher as a decision maker
 Planning instruction
 Addressing diverse learning needs
 4 MAT model for learning
 Assessing students’ learning
We will start with a small question on motivation

Quiz
Teachers are most likely to build productive learning communities by --------.
a) Using a variety of motivational and group development strategies
b) Relying on positive and negative reinforcement to motivate students
c) Avoiding overemphasis of intrinsic rewards
d) Focusing on individual needs
“A” option is the correct option.
Features of classrooms for students’ motivation

- Some classroom features can be altered by the teacher; others cannot.
Multidimensionality and immediacy cannot be influenced readily by the teacher.
Classroom is a multidimensional place.
282
- Group processes and the classroom goal, task, reward and participation structures are
more directly under the teachers’ control. Teacher’s expectations are extrinsic.
Expectations are external while personal goals are internal.
- Studies have uncovered important relationships among teacher practices, student
engagement, and academic achievement. In general, students react more positively and
persist in academic tasks in classrooms characterized by democratic as opposed to
authoritarian processes, in classrooms where learning activities are interesting and
challenging. Teacher control is authoritative process. In democratic process children are
involved. Children work together to solve the problems. In this process every child has
his own role. In schools teacher may involve the students in the process. For example
while making timetable teacher may involve the students by taking their suggestions.
- Influence in classrooms does not flow just from the teacher. Studies show that students
influence each other and the behavior of their teachers also. Peers can be great
motivational support.
- Effective teachers create productive learning communities by focusing on things that can
be altered, such as increasing student motivation and encouraging group development.
there is a range of motivation strategies. To make productive learning communities is
itself a motivational strategy. Peer tutoring is another motivational strategy. We provide
the option of creativity to the students. External rewards lose their significance after
sometime.
Teaching cycle
Planning Implementation
Evaluation
Planning
283
- Planning and making decisions about instruction are among the most important aspects of
teaching because they are major determinants of what is taught in schools and how it is
taught.
- The traditional perspective of planning is based on rational-linear models characterized
by setting goals and taking specific actions to accomplish desired outcomes. Success of
instruction depends upon planning. Traditional model is being very much in use in
Pakistan and other countries.
- The knowledge base suggests that teacher planning and decision making do not always
conform to rational-linear planning models. Newer perspectives on planning put more
emphasis on planners’ nonlinear actions and reflections. Linear fashion focus on goals.
Nonlinear fashion focus on process.
- A third form of teacher planning called mental planning, is based on reflective thinking
prior to the construction of more formal plans and imaging and mental rehearsal prior to
presenting particular lessons. Mental process needs to be their while planning.
Planning phases
- Teacher planning is multifaceted but relates to three phases of teaching:
- Prior to instruction
- During instruction
- And after instruction
Teacher planning is not only confined to the planning stage only. It is also in implementation and
evaluation stage. Teacher not only makes the decisions on copy pencil tests. He also makes the
decisions in implementation process. He makes vigorous decision while he is teaching in the
class.
Diversity of students
All the students in the class have different needs. McCarthy makes a 4MAT model on the
diversity of students.
This model has four parts.
Meaning (Why)
284
In meaning there are functions of connect and attend. There should be connection of current
knowledge with the prior knowledge of students. In attend part we will see that what are the
individual experiences of students.
Concepts (What)
Its functions are image and inform. In this step we will tell the students imagine what new
expressions look like. In this part teacher can tell the students to brainstorm. Teacher may ask
them to come up with new ideas. Then the part of giving information comes.
Skills (How)
Its functions are practice and extent. We know that practice is of different kinds. In this step we
provide the opportunity to the students to practice the known information. For example we have
told about grammar rules to the students and then we will tell them to apply and practice those
rules. Extent is also a skill. Skill should be automatic. In extent teacher give the opportunity of
extended practice. Extended practice leads to overlearning.
Adaptation (If)
Its functions are refine and problem. One a skill is achieved students should be able to relate or
refine that skill to their practical life. Performance includes find connections and innovations.
4 MAT model is very much comprehensive. Problem solving skill is the function of right brain.
Planning of lesson must be based on the above four points.
Assessing students learning
To assess the students according to the define objectives is the simple method. But if we use 4
MAT model, we have to assess the students on all four points(meaning, concepts, skills and
adaptation). We have to assess the students according to our teaching models that we are using.
285
“Teaching Tools”
Lecture # 44
Outline:
- Teaching tools
- Visual aids
- Audio aids
What are these objects?
- Textbook
- Supplementary Readers
- Computer programmes
- Multimedia
- Worksheets
- Visual charts
- Videos
- Audios
- Models
Definition of tools:
Purpose of tools is to get things done easily, swiftly and quickly. So, teaching tools means that
all those things which help the teacher in planning instruction and ensure students learning. The
most important teaching tool or teaching resource is the teacher himself. The tool which is
mostly present in every classroom is textbook.
1. Textbook as a tool:
The textbooks serve the following purpose:
- Information through text and pictures

- Questions for thinking
286
There are some books which are based on very good information but the missing element in
these books is thinking questions. A teacher must try to construct questions on their own to
ensure students learning.
2. Supplementary readers:
Supplementary readings are those which supplement your textbook knowledge. If children use to
read some books other than textbooks, parents usually discourage them. Supplementary readings
are very important tool for learning. Benefits of supplementary readings are:
- Extend already learnt knowledge

- Extend vocabulary
- Extend imagination
- Extend and develop higher order thinking
- They make children autonomous learners
Supplementary readings provide extensive information on a topic. All these things depend on the
quality of your supplement material. These also help in making the students “independent
learners.” Purpose of it is to enhance students reading. We need to use all these things to develop
our students thinking to make them autonomous learners.
3. Computer Programmes:
- Power point
- Word
- Excel
- Internet
These all programmes can serve as teaching tool. Students are using internet for surfing and
information they get is very vast. If teacher is using these things to prepare a lesson with pictures
etc and using multimedia technology, these are also serving as a teaching tool. Graphic
organizers are very good teaching methods teachers use because they store more information to
mind rather than information provided in words.
4. Videos:
Videos are very often used by teachers. Experienced teachers mostly used videos because
they know the classroom management problems and how to handle them.
- Teacher’s lectures
- Expert’s talks/ interviews
- Classroom discussions
287
- Cartoons
- Children films
- Art work videos
- Science experiments videos
- Virtual experiment videos
A teacher must ask questions to the students by giving pauses in the video or prepare a
worksheet in the sequence of video and ask the students to solve it. If teacher is presenting these
things during video, then he is making effective use of teaching tool.
5. Audios:
- Children’s own recording to identify their strengths and weaknesses in speech.
- Pronunciation lessons
- Rhymes
-
Video tapes can be used mostly in English and Urdu lessons where you want to enhance
students speaking skills. you can record the voice of the students and ask them to identify
their own mistakes. This can enhance their evaluation skills.
6. Classrooms and schools as a teaching tool:

- Human resource
- Teaching kits (water bottles, books, pencil box, bags, teacher’s bag)
- School lawn plants
The material present in children’s bags or geometry boxes are very helpful because they are of
different colours and shapes. You can ask the students to use them for descriptive writing.
How to make learning tools?

There are four steps to make effective learning tools:
- Identify the purpose

- Identify the strategy
- Select or make a tool
- Evaluate the success of tool.
- Use waste material or cheap material to make teaching tools
Technology as a tool:
We are living in the age of information. We teachers today have very limited information. How
can we enhance our own and students’ information? There are many internet sources e.g. one is
given for reference:
288
http://www.khanacademy.org
This website has 2700 videos and these are easily downloadable. These videos are of every
subject and comprises of very simple to complex mathematics, chemistry problem etc. So,
technology has brought revolution.
Tools for students’ learning:

All the tools discussed above are selected according to the purpose. If the purpose is to give
information to the students then textbooks and technology are the best tools to use in class.
Tools for teacher’s learning:
Tool Purpose
Reflective logs To plan for instruction
DART exercises To diagnose students reading skills
Spelling error analysis Spellings
Students’ notebooks Formative
Observational checklists Psychomotor skills assessment
Students’ feedback To plan for instruction
Students’ work Formative assessment
Technology New learning
Reflective log: A teacher will write the reflective log of his/her teaching that how the lesson
goes on, what and how the students learn etc. If the teacher do no reflect on his present lesson, he
could not plan effectively for the next lesson.
DART exercises: these exercises are very often used by teachers to diagnose students’ reading
skills.
If you want to assess student’s spellings then we have to check that what type of spellings errors
they make. So we have to go for spelling error analysis.
If we want to learn about students’ learning on a particular topic then we will analyze the tests of
our students. And we will also analyze their notebooks.
If I want to plan for effective instruction, I may ask the students to give me feedback.
289
Effective teaching
Lecture no 45
This is the last lecture of the course of general method of teaching. People cannot help us always
we must help ourselves. And for this purpose the best thing is to keep record of everything.
Teaching is about growth (growth of teacher as well as of learner). For the growth it is necessary
to reflect all those things we do. Never say we can go without planning. Always plan before
going to the classroom and always reflect on your practices. Today’s lesson is the recap of all the
previous lectures.
Session content
- Teacher’s assumptions
- Learning as motivation
- Learning as fun
- Learning theories
- IPT
- Lesson planning
- Taxonomies
- Teaching vs learning activities
- Essential question
- Image of child
What is teaching?
- Is it about teaching subjects?
290
- Is it about developing certain behaviors?

- Is it about helping pupils get jobs in their later life?
- Is it about enlightenment?
These are all secondary purposes, basic purpose is to produce good citizens.
Assumptions of teaching
- Classrooms are isolated places

- Education is about learning content of subjects.
- Discovery learning means exploring static facts and concepts.
- Physical education, debates, music, art, community etc are essentially not main
curriculum.
- Silence promotes learning.
Whatever we are teaching to the students it must constructively reflect to the students houses or
communities. Because classrooms and schools are the part of society.
Education is not about teaching the subjects but it is the method of developing the skills. It is
developing the responsible attitudes towards society.
We mostly focus on activity base learning or discovery learning. Discovery learning is about
exploring the static facts which are already exist in the society. Teaching is much more than that,
it is about knowledge creation.
Education should focus on the holistic development of child. All these things are not the part of
the curriculum but the essential of curriculum.
Active learning promotes actual learning. Silence does not promotes learning. We need to
promote the students learning.
Vygotsky’s theory
- Vygotsky’s theory included four major ideas. They are:

2. Language plays an important role in cognitive development.
3. Learning can lead development.
4. Learning cannot be separated from the social context in which it occurs.
Zone of Proximal development
- This concept was also established by Vygotsky.

- The gap between actual and potential level of a child is Zone of Proximal Development.
Diversity
291
Children think different, they very in their abilities. Teacher is same but the students are all
different. We cannot expect the same thing of all students. We can have a minimum expectation
from the students but we cannot expect the same thing to measure.
Educational equity
Social context is a wide concept and it also includes equity.
- Schools not only teach children, but they also raise them. (Sousa, 2003)
- What students are taught in the schools affect the ways they will thereafter see and treat
others. (Schlesinger, 1993)
- Equity means that all students are treated equally well and that all school resources are
shared equally.
- Schools have diverse learners and they must celebrate equity.
Facts of IPT
- Images are much economical and take less space in our working memory than ideas
expressed in words.
- A picture is worth a thousand words. Perhaps an overstatement but pictures and images
can represent a great deal of information in a very efficient way.
Taxonomies
We have talked about taxonomies. The most important taxonomy is Bloom’s taxonomy. This
taxonomy is about cognitive domain.
Levels of Bloom’s cognitive domain
1. Knowledge
2. Comprehension
3. Application
4. Analysis
5. Synthesis
6. Evaluation
Psychomotor domain
This is about the physical movements .
292
Hierarchical levels of Simpson’s taxonomy
1. Perception
2. Set
3. Guided response
4. Mechanism
5. Complex overt response
6. Adaptation
7. Origination
Affective domain
This is about the attitudes and behaviors.
Hierarchical levels of Bloom’s and Krathwohl’s taxonomy.
1. Receiving
2. Responding
3. Valuing
4. Organization
5. Characterization
Planning
Planning equation
- Less planning leads to less learning. (Walsh, 1992)

- Planning = Content + Method
- Example of a driver going to a new place who refers to the map more often as
comparedto the one who has been there for quite many times.
Post lesson activities
These activities includes:
- Evaluating lesson plans

- Evaluation unit plans
Evaluation of student’s learning
- What did my students learn?

- What did my student not learn?
- What was interesting to the students?
- What was difficult to the students?
293
- What evidence do I have for three findings?

- What will they learn in future?
Learning activities always involves the learners.
Essential vs unit questions
Essential questions Unit questions

Must a story have a moral, hero and villain? What is the moral of story?
Who is the hero in the story?
Who is a friend? Are Pakistan and Iran good friends?
Do we always mean what we say and say what What are sarcasm, irony, and satire?
we mean? How do different genres help us in
c0mmunicating without saying what we mean?
What is a child?
- Is child a “tabula rasa” an empty vessel to be filled by knowledge. ( John Locke)

- Is a child biologically learned being? What is learned by one organism may be
transmitted biologically to others. (Darwin)
- Is a child natural discoverer? (Bruner)
- Are all children perfectly designed organisms, ready to learn from their surroundings so
as to grow into various adults, but due to the malign influence of corrupt society. They
often fail to do so. (Rousseau)
- Does a child learn according to his/her interests? (John Dewey)
- We select our activities according to our own image of child.
- We end our lesson on “Less is more”.
294

Edu 301 by VU

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Edu 301 by VU

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Edu 301 by VU

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

General Methods of Teaching (EDU 301)

Assumptions about teaching:

Different perspectives of education in history:

In opinion of Educationists or other people: (about role of the teacher)

Teaching as a social, political and ethical activity:

Teaching perceptions as culturally and socially embedded

Metaphors on teaching and role of teachers:

Imagine that teacher is a sun or a candle; it is a source of light. It is spreading its

Some misconceptions in teaching:

 Education is about learning of different subjects:

colleges they will become competent professionals. Education is serving the

 Learning is exploring different subjects:

 Drama or debates are extra or co-curricular activities:

Is teaching an art or science?

 A profession has a body of techniques and they may be transmitted:

 A profession is internally organized and self-disciplined (code of ethics):

 A profession has a social function:

 A profession allows independence or Autonomy:

How can teaching be considered as profession?

 The techniques learnt by teachers:

 Is teaching internally organized and self-disciplined:

 Teaching as a social function:

 Teacher in Pakistan have individual autonomy or not?

What future teachers actually need to learn is:

You need to develop a belief that:

 We are living in a changing world, thus being professionals we constantly need to

 You need to acquire the knowledge of foundations of education, pedagogical knowledge,

Things you have to learn, when you want to be a professional:

Develop professional values and practice:

“Professional behaviors and context of schools”

Principles for professional behaviors:

An educator needs to strive to help each student realize his/her potential as a

Educators work to stimulate the spirit of inquiry and acquisition of

 Commitment to the profession:

The educators need to exert every effort to:

- A pedagogical content knowledge: the subject a teacher is going to

- Communication skills: communication skills must be so clear that a

- Assessing skills: a teacher must know how to assess learning of the

 Promote a climate that encourages the exercise of professional judgement:

 Assist in preventing the practice of the profession by unqualified persons:

Key context of schooling:

Educationist named the key context of schooling as:

 Schooling in educational context:

Social context of schooling:

Collegial context of schooling:

- “Let’s establish a learning community” it shows that the community working in a

“Incentives and responsibilities of teachers”

Incentives for teachers:

 Recognition as an excellent teacher (reflected in students’ warmth, enthusiasm,

Common assumptions from the above interviews:

Teacher’s levels of functioning:

Teacher as a decision maker:

5. How to give feedback?(Autonomy)

6. Which resources to be used in classroom learning?(Autonomy to certain extent)

7. Which activities to be used?(Autonomy)

Teacher’s responsibilities as a decision maker:

Reflection is of two types:

Basically, reflection is the means of creating a dialogue. A teacher is creating dialogue to

“Conceptual change, learning theories and modeling process”

Outline of the lecture: