Introduction To Model Coupling in Earth System Science and Recent Developments
Introduction To Model Coupling in Earth System Science and Recent Developments
1st Regional Earth System Modeling Summer School, 5-7 September 2016, ITU, Turkey
Air-sea Interaction
Ocean Modeling Challenges
Space-Time Scales
LOW-RES – FAST ( ~3º)
MID-RES – CLIMATE ( ~1º) O(+100 years/day)
O(10-100 years/day)
HIGH-RES ( ~0.1º)
O(1 year/day)
Processes with
various temporal and
spatial scales:
momentum
balance
heat
balance
The horizontal resolution needed to resolve the first baroclinic deformation radius with two grid points
Solid black line represent the regions that can be solved by 1 ○ – 1/8○ horizontal resolution
Parameterizations
• It is used to include physical effects of unresolved sub-
grid scale processes such as turbulence
• Lateral mixing of momentum and tracers by mesoscale and
sub-mesoscale eddies
• Vertical mixing of momentum and tracers (surface and
bottom boundary layers, interior)
• Tidal mixing
• Convection
• Diurnal cycle for shortwave heat flux and penetration through
water column (Jerlow Water Type, …)
• ...
• Physically based
• As simple as possible (computational overhead!)
• As few parameters as possible
Parameterizations in ROMS
• Vertical mixing (momentum and tracers)
• K-profile (LMD; Large et al., 1994)
• Surface Boundary Layer
• Interior
• Mellor-Yamada 2.5 (Mellor and Yamada, 1982)
• Generic Length Scale (GLS; Umlauf and Burchard, 2001;
Warner et al., 2005)
• k-kl
• k-epsilon
• k-omega
• k-generic
• Horizontal mixing of momentum and tracers
• Geopotential (const. depth) / isopycnic (const. density)
Why do we need regional models?
• We need higher spatial resolution to solve science
problems such as
• Climate variability and prediction (i.e. sea level change,
extreme events)
• Coastal processes and ecosystems (i.e. upwelling)
• Estuaries, interconnected basins (i.e. TSS)
• Marginal seas (Mediterranean / Black / Marmara Seas)
• …
• Information for impacts and adaptation purposes
• Investigating processes that are better represented
in higher spatial and temporal scales
Regional Modelling Approaches
• High resolution global models (not practical due to
requirement of extensive computational resources
and data management issues – post-processing)
• Dynamic and static grid refinement in global
models (it might help to reduce biases)
• Imbedded high resolution model with in a coarser
model (two-way interaction among models can be
tricky)
• Regional ocean models with/without open
boundary conditions (coming from observations or
global models)
ROMS imbedded in POP In this case, regional
ocean model
(ROMS) is used
together with global
ocean model (POP)
to improve global
model’s SST
non-uniform dimension
origin spacing
uniform
Ocean Model –
Horizontal Grids
• Curvilinear grid
• When the solution domain is not
rectangular Cartesian grids cannot
be used.
• Structured curvilinear grids are
based on mapping of the flow
domain onto a computational
domain
http://www.emg.cmar.csiro.au
Equally spaced
various ocean models
• Z-coordinate model has problem with
the regions of sloping topography such as
coastal regions. In here, the levels
intersect the bathymetry and
unrealistic vertical velocities near
Hres in surface
the bottom can result.
• Increasing the number of vertical levels
will improve the representation of the
near-bottom flow, but at a high
computational cost.
Ocean Model – Vertical Grids
• Sigma or S-coordinate (i.e. ROMS, POM):
• Help to keep same number of vertical layer in everywhere
independent from the depth of the water column. The layer
thickness vary with the depth
• The layers are more closely spaced
Equally spaced
near the surface and/or bottom than
in the interior, thus allowing the
boundary layers to be better resolved.
• This type of coordinate is most appropriate
for continental shelf and coastal regions,
where the bottom and surface boundary
layers may merge.
Hres in surface
• They have difficulty handling sharp
topographic changes from one grid
point to another. Pressure-gradient errors
can give rise to unrealistic flows.
• Smoothing might help !
Ocean Model – Vertical Grids
• Isopycnal coordinates:
• These models use the potential density
referenced to a given pressure as the
vertical coordinate.
• This system basically divides the water
column into distinct homogeneous layers,
whose thicknesses can vary from place
to place and from one time step to
the next.
• This choice of coordinate works well for modeling tracer (T, S)
transport, which tends to be along surfaces of constant density.
• The main advantage of these models is the computational cost.
They could run in higher horizontal resolution rather than vertical
one.
• Their applications are limited with the costal regions and boundary
layers (surface and bottom).
Black Sea Example
• A sensitivity study of NEMO ocean model with different
vertical grid configurations
Spurious zonal velocities
along 31º
E after 3.5 months of
simulation: (a) z-coordinate;
(b) s-coordinate; (c) s-
coordinate with enveloping
topography; (d) s-on-top-of-
z; (e) s-enveloped-top-of-z.
Due to sharp
bathymetry
gradient, the model
produces unrealistic
vertical mixing of
tracers
Sensitivity to horizontal resolution
1/12º
http://noc.ac.uk/science-
technology/climate-sea-
level/changing-circulation/high-
ORCA05
resolution-global-modelling
http://www.geomar.de/en/research/fb1/fb1-tm/ocean-models/
1/4º
ORCA025
1º
ORCA12
Ocean Motion –
Ekman Transport
• The Ekman spiral, named
after Swedish scientist Vagn
Walfrid Ekman (1874-1954)
who first theorized it in 1902,
is a consequence of the Coriolis
effect.
• As a result, each successively deeper layer of water moves
more slowly to the right or left, creating a spiral effect.
• Because the deeper layers of water move more slowly than
the shallower layers, they tend to “twist around” and flow
opposite to the surface current.
Ocean Motion –
Upwelling
• Where Ekman transport moves surface waters away from
the coast, surface waters are replaced by water that wells
up from below in the process known as upwelling. This
example is from the Northern Hemisphere.
• Where Ekman transport moves surface waters toward the
coast, the water piles up and sinks in the process known as
downwelling. This example is from the Northern
Hemisphere.
Ocean Motion –
Upwelling …
Ocean Motion –
Upwelling …
Ocean Motion –
Upwelling …
Regional examples: Caspian Sea, Black Sea
Input for Ocean Models
Input for Ocean Models …
• Definition of horizontal and vertical grid
• Interpolation of bathymetry (ETOPO, GEBCO etc.)
• Initial conditions (WOA, SODA, global ocean models).
MEDAR/MEDATLAS can be used for Mediterranean and
Black Seas.
• Atmospheric forcing (Reanalysis datasets such as ERA-
Interim, NCEP/NCAR, COARE, global and/or regional
atmosphere model)
• Open boundary conditions (T, S, SSH, U, V …; SODA, Global
ocean circulation model such as MOM)
• River input (freshwater) from GRDC, RivDis etc. It could be
also calculated using river routing or hydrological model.
Input for Ocean Models …