Koch 2016
Koch 2016
Koch 2016
How to cite: Koch J, Modesitt T, Palmer M, Ward S, Martin B, Wyatt R, Thomas C. Review of pharmacologic treatment in cluster A personality disorders. Ment Health Clin
[Internet]. 2016;6(2):75-81. DOI: 10.9740/mhc.2016.03.75.
Abstract
Introduction: A personality disorder is a pervasive and enduring pattern of behaviors that impacts an
individual’s social, occupational, and overall functioning. Specifically, the cluster A personality disorders
include paranoid personality disorder, schizoid personality disorder, and schizotypal personality disorder.
Patients with cluster A personality disorders tend to be isolative and avoid relationships. The quality of life
may also be reduced in these individuals, which provokes the question of how to treat patients with these
personality disorders. The purpose of this review is to evaluate the current literature for pharmacologic
treatments for the cluster A personality disorders.
Methods: A Medline/PubMed and Ovid search was conducted to identify literature on the psychopharma-
cology of paranoid personality disorder, schizoid personality disorder, and schizotypal personality disorder.
There were no exclusions in terms of time frame from article publication or country of publication, in order
to provide a comprehensive analysis; however, only articles that contained information on the cluster A
disorders were included.
Results: Minimal evidence regarding pharmacotherapy in paranoid and schizoid personality disorders was
found. Literature was available for pharmacologic treatment of schizotypal personality disorder. Studies
evaluating the use of olanzapine, risperidone, haloperidol, fluoxetine, and thiothixene did yield beneficial
results; however, treatment with such agents should be considered on a case-by-case basis.
Discussion: Most of the literature analyzed in this review presented theoretical ideas of what may constitute
the neurobiologic factors of personality and what treatments may address these aspects. Further research is
needed to evaluate specific pharmacologic treatment in the cluster A personality disorders. At this time,
treatment with pharmacologic agents is based on theory rather than evidence.
Keywords: schizotypal personality disorder, schizoid personality disorder, paranoid personality disorder,
cluster A, pharmacotherapy
1
PGY-2 Psychiatric Pharmacy Resident, Chillicothe VA Medical Center,
Chillicothe, Ohio; 2 PGY-1 Pharmacy Practice Resident, Chillicothe VA
Introduction
Medical Center, Chillicothe, Ohio; 3 Clinical Pharmacy Specialist in
Psychiatry, Chillicothe VA Medical Center, Chillicothe, Ohio; 4 Staff
Personality disorders are said to exist when a person’s
Psychiatrist, Chillicothe VA Medical Center, Chillicothe, Ohio; Clinical pattern of perceiving, relating to, and thinking about the
Assistant Professor of Psychiatry, Ohio University Heritage College of environment and oneself results in maladaptive behavior
Osteopathic Medicine, Athens, Ohio; 5 (Corresponding author) Clinical
and significant impairment in interpersonal relationships
Pharmacy Specialist in Psychiatry, PGY-1 and PGY-2 Residency Program
Director, Chillicothe VA Medical Center, Chillicothe, Ohio, cthcal@aol. and interactions. These patterns of inner experience and
com behavior are inflexible and pervasive, causing clinically
Q 2016 CPNP. The Mental Health Clinician is a publication of the College of Psychiatric and Neurologic Pharmacists. This is an
open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 License, which
permits non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, Methods
or other important areas of functioning.1
A literature review on the psychopharmacology of
Personality disorders are often characterized by symp- paranoid personality disorder, schizoid personality disor-
der, and schizotypal personality disorder was conducted
toms (eg, psychoticism in schizotypal personality disorder)
through PubMed and Ovid searches using combinations of
that are similar or nearly identical to pharmacotherapy-
the following search terms: schizotypal personality disorder
responsive symptoms seen in other mental disorders (eg,
treatment, pharmacotherapy schizotypal, antipsychotic
auditory hallucinations in schizophrenia). However, symp-
schizotypal, risperidone schizotypal, olanzapine schizotypal,
tomatic similarity does not equal etiologic or pathophys- aripiprazole schizotypal, quetiapine schizotypal, paliperidone
iologic similarity; therefore, similarity in response and schizotypal, clozapine schizotypal, ziprasidone schizotypal,
tolerability of pharmacotherapy cannot be assumed. It lurasidone schizotypal, asenapine schizotypal, iloperidone
was this presumed difference in etiology between schizotypal, haloperidol schizotypal, amitriptyline schizoty-
historically axis I (more biologic in origin) and axis II pal, fluoxetine schizotypal, guanfacine schizotypal, pergolide
(more psychological in origin) disorders that contributed schizotypal, schizoid personality disorder pharmacotherapy,
to previous recommendations discouraging the use of pharmacotherapy of personality disorders, paranoid person-
pharmacotherapy for personality disorders.2 ality disorder, and cluster a personality disorders. Only
papers that contained information on the cluster A
However, for certain dimensions of personality, such as personality disorders were included. There were no
impulsive-aggression, schizotypy, and novelty seeking, exclusions in terms of time frame from article publication
neurobiologic correlates have been demonstrated, sug- or country of publication, in order to provide a
gesting that some aspects of personality disorders may be comprehensive analysis. Of note, many of the articles
amenable to pharmacologic intervention.3-5 Based on included were based on Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
these findings and the results of efficacy studies, recent of Mental Disorders, 4th edition (DSM-IV) diagnostic
guidelines now recommend the judicious use of pharma- criteria. There were no changes made between DSM-IV
cotherapy as an adjunctive treatment in the overall and DSM-5 regarding the criteria for the personality
management of patients with severe personality disor- disorders.
der.6 There are currently no medications with US Food
and Drug Administration approval for use in personality
Paranoid Personality Disorder
disorders. All use of medications for symptoms of
personality disorders is considered off-label. This review Paranoid personality disorder is described as a pervasive
will focus on available evidence regarding the use of suspicion of others’ motives and behaviors in a variety of
pharmacotherapy for paranoid, schizoid, and schizotypal contexts. Individuals with this disorder may be considered
personality disorders, collectively known as the cluster A ‘‘odd’’ or ‘‘eccentric’’ by others and have a lack of close
personality disorders. relationships. The Table more thoroughly defines this
disorder and diagnostic criteria per DSM-5. The prevalence
Pharmacotherapy for personality disorders tends to be of paranoid personality disorder is not exactly known, but
symptom specific, focusing on dimensions of personality is estimated to be between 2% and 4% of the population.1
believed most likely to be responsive to pharmacotherapy This review intends to summarize the literature regarding
treatment for paranoid personality disorder, specifically
and that typically warrant the most clinical attention.
pharmacotherapy.
These dimensions include affective dysregulation (eg,
angry, anxious, depressed, labile mood), cognitive-per-
Overall, a review of the literature yields very little research
ceptual symptoms (eg, auditory, visual hallucinations), and
regarding pharmacotherapy options for the treatment of
impulsive aggression (eg, self-cutting, suicidality).2,6 The
paranoid personality disorder. The reason for this has been
use of pharmacotherapy is adjunctive, with the goal of theorized by multiple authors. The belief is that a paucity
providing enough stabilization to make it easier or of research exists because of the general lack of trust
possible for the patient to engage in psychosocial patients with paranoid personality disorder have for
interventions. The risks and benefits of pharmacotherapy others, with psychiatric providers being no exception.7,8
must be carefully considered, especially in a situation In reference to paranoid personality disorder, Angstman
where expected benefits may be modest.2,6 It is the goal and Rasmussen7 wrote, ‘‘These patients are difficult to
of this review to provide answers to questions regarding engage in a therapeutic relationship for medical or mental
the use of pharmacotherapy for cluster A personality health issues. . . Physicians should expect belittling com-
disorders and bring the reader up to date regarding what ments, accusations, and potentially litigious threats from
is known and unknown about the effectiveness of this these patients. . .’’ This behavior not only limits the
practice. likelihood of the patient seeking medical attention but
Personality
Disorder Definition Diagnostic Criteria
also detracts from the collaborative therapeutic relation- Of the few articles written, a case series by Birkeland9
ship between provider and patient. Triebwasser et al8 retrospectively analyzed the psychiatric hospitalization
suggest that ambivalence in the diagnosis itself contrib- course of 15 patients in Denmark with paranoid person-
utes to the lack of research. Because the predominant ality disorder. Clinical Global Impression was rated at first
characteristic of paranoid personality disorder is paranoia admission and the last psychiatric visit in order to assess
itself—a common feature of numerous other psychiatric any clinical improvement. Birkeland9 found that a total of
conditions, such as posttraumatic stress disorder and 7 patients received an antipsychotic; the most commonly
schizophrenia—clinicians may be more apt to give prescribed one was flupentixol. Other antipsychotic
patients a diagnosis of a comorbid condition rather than medications prescribed included bromperidol and proma-
the personality disorder. Overall, the characteristics of zine. The median duration of treatment was 15 weeks. Of
paranoid personality disorder (ie, bearing grudges) likely the 15 patients, only 4 who received antipsychotic
have contributed to the dearth of research into the medication therapy were present for the 6-week follow-
treatment of this disorder. up. All 4 of these patients demonstrated improvement as