CBN IT Guidelines
CBN IT Guidelines
IT Standards Blueprint
Version
1.2
May 2013
IT Standards Blueprint
PREAMBLE
This document is the property of the Central bank of Nigeria and its usage
is restricted to members of the Shared Services Unit, the IT Standards
Council, Nigerian Financial Services Industry and authorized accredited
third party agents or consultants as CBN deems fit.
Table of Contents
PREAMBLE ................................................................... 2
TABLE OF FIGURES ........................................................... 4
ABBREVIATIONS .............................................................. 5
1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................ 6
1.1 BACKGROUND ............................................................ 6
1.2 OBJECTIVES AND PURPOSE OF DOCUMENT ........................................ 7
1.3 DEFINITION OF STANDARD .................................................. 7
1.4 OVERVIEW AND SUMMARY IT STANDARDS FOR THE NIGERIAN FINANCIAL SERVICES I NDUSTRY .... 7
1.4.1 TARGET MATURITY LEVELS .................................................. 9
1.4.2 DATA CENTRE MATURITY .................................................. 11
1.5 EXPECTED IMPACTS AND BENEFITS ........................................... 12
2 IT STANDARDS BLUEPRINT ................................................. 13
2.1 STRATEGIC IT ALIGNMENT ................................................. 14
2.2 IT GOVERNANCE ........................................................ 16
2.3 ARCHITECTURE AND I NFORMATION MANAGEMENT ................................... 19
2.4 SOLUTIONS DELIVERY .................................................... 28
2.5 SERVICE MANAGEMENT AND O PERATIONS ........................................ 37
2.6 INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY SECURITY ........................................ 54
2.7 WORKFORCE & RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ......................................... 58
3 RE-PRIORITISED INDUSTRY IT STANDARDS ................................... 61
3.1 RE-PRIORITISED IT STANDARDS ............................................ 61
3.2 IT STANDARDS ADOPTION R OADMAP ........................................... 62
4 IT STANDARDS GOVERNANCE AND INTERACTION MODEL .......................... 64
4.1 GUIDING PRINCIPLES AND P OLICIES .......................................... 64
4.2 IT STANDARDS GOVERNANCE MODEL AND PROCESSES ............................... 64
4.2.1 GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE: IT STANDARDS COUNCIL ................................ 66
4.2.2 GOVERNANCE S TRUCTURE: C OMPLIANCE MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE ....................... 67
4.2.3 GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE: S TANDARDS REVIEW COMMITTEE ........................... 68
4.3 IT STANDARDS COMPLIANCE FRAMEWORK ........................................ 70
4.4 STAKEHOLDERS’ INTERACTION/ COMMUNICATION FRAMEWORK .......................... 73
5 FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ) ....................................... 75
Table of Figures
Figure 1 - IT Standards Prioritization ............................. 61
Figure 2 - IT Standards Implementation Roadmap ..................... 62
Figure 3 - Recommended Adoption Timeline ........................... 63
Figure 4- IT Standards Governance Structure ........................ 65
Figure 5 - IT Standards Council Organization Structure ............. 67
Figure 6 - Compliance Management Committee Organization Structure .. 68
Figure 7 - Standards Review Committee Governance Structure ......... 69
Figure 8 - IT Standards Compliance Framework ....................... 70
Figure 9 - Define/ Change Sub-framework ............................ 71
Figure 10 - Monitor Compliance/ Measure Maturity Sub-framework ..... 71
Figure 11 – Documentation/ Management Reporting Sub-framework ...... 72
Figure 12 - Enforce Compliance Sub-framework ....................... 72
Figure 13 - IT Standards Stakeholders' Interaction Framework ....... 73
Abbreviations
ITCMM IT Capability and Maturity Model
ITIL IT Infrastructure Library
COBIT Control Objectives for Information and Technology
ISACA Information Systems Audit and Control Association
XBRL eXtensible Business Reporting Language
TOGAF The Open Group Architecture Framework
CMMI Capability Maturity Model Integration
SPICE Software Process Improvement and Capability
Determination
SCAMPI Standard CMMI Appraisal Method for Process
Improvement
PMI Project Management Institute
PMBOK Project Management Body of Knowledge
PRINCE2 Projects IN Controlled Environments version 2
TIA Telecommunications Industry Association
OHSAS Occupational Health & Safety Advisory Services
BCI Business Continuity Institute
PCI DSS Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard
SFIA Skills Framework for the Information Age
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
Globally, Information Technology has fundamentally transformed the
business architecture of Banks resulting in the evolution of new
business architectures and approaches to customer service,
enterprise management and regulatory compliance.
- Enterprise IT Architecture
- Process architecture
- Systems integration/ Interoperability
- Network/ Communications
- Data Centre Infrastructure
Processing
Service quality
Regulatory reporting
Business Continuity
Benefits
Reference
1
Formerly BS 25999 which was retired on September 1, 2012 and replaced by ISO 22301
improvement
• Quality management & continuous
improvement activities are embedded in
process management
• IT is leveraged in an integrated way to
automate the workflow, providing tools
to improve quality and effectiveness
The minimum target maturity level for IT Standards for the financial
services industry is Level 3 in respect of standards that align to
the maturity model
Level 3 maturity requires that IT standards are
Defined
Documented
Integrated into organizational practices via policy and
procedures
Communicated through training, and that
Automation and tools are used in a limited and fragmented way
2 IT Standards Blueprint
This section outlines the blueprint of the IT Standards and
includes the following in respect of each standard:
Benefits
Scope
References
Minimum Level 3
Acceptable
Maturity
Level
Rationale COBIT
for The Plan and Organize (PO) Domain of the COBIT
Selection Framework involves the definition of an IT Strategic
Plan and focuses on incorporating IT and business
management in the translation of business requirements
into service offerings, as well as the development of
strategies to deliver these services in a transparent
and effective manner
ITIL
The Service Strategy Volume of ITIL focuses on the
alignment of business and IT so that each brings out
the best in the other. It ensures that every stage of
the service lifecycle stays focused on the business
case and relates to all the companion process elements
that follow
Requirements Adoption of COBIT Plan and Organize (PO) Domain and the
for ITIL Service Strategy volume maturity level 3.
compliance Strategic IT Alignment policies and processes must be:
Defined
Documented
ITIL: http://www.itil-officialsite.com/
References
COBIT: http://www.isaca.org/Knowledge-Center/cobit
2.2 IT Governance
Rationale COBIT
for The COBIT Framework provides management and business
Selection process owners with an IT governance model that helps in
delivering value from IT as well as managing the risks
associated with IT.
ISO 38500
Documented
ISO 38500
Ref: http://www.isaca.org/Knowledge-Center/cobit
ISO 38500
ISO 38500 is a high level principle based advisory standard. In addition
to providing broad guidance on the role of a governing body, ISO 38500
2.3.1 Interfaces
Maturity
Not Applicable
Level
ISO 8583
Rationale
for Standard framework for systems that exchange electronic
Selection transactions that use payment cards, specifies a common
interface by which financial transaction card
originated messages may be interchanged between
acquirers and card issuers.
Most core Banking application vendors provide native
ISO 8583 interfaces and ISO 8583 is widely adopted
within the Nigerian Financial Services industry for
card based payment transactions.
ISO 20022
ISO 20022
Communication interoperability between financial institutions, market
Commercial payments
Cards
Securities
Trade
The ISO 20022 statement is organized as follows:
2.3.2 Reporting
Maturity
N/A
Level
XBRL Instance: The XBRL instance begins with the <xbrl> root
element and holds the following information:
o Business Facts which are divided into two categories
Standard
The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Maturity
Level 3
Level
Documented
ISO 15504
ISO 15504 also known as Software Process Improvement and
Capability Determination (SPICE) is a framework for the
assessment of processes that defines capability levels
for measuring the processes.
ISO 15504 provides objective measures that enables
assessors give an overall determination of the
organization's capabilities for delivering software
ISO 15504:
Implement the requirements of the ISO 15504 standard
ISO 15504:
ISO 15504 contains a reference model which defines processes and a
capability dimension for measuring the processes. The process dimension
defines processes divided into the six process categories of:
Processes
Customer supplier
Engineering
Supporting
Management
Organization
Capability levels include
5 - Optimizing Process
4 - Predictable Process
3 - Established Process
2 - Managed Process
1 - Performed Process
0 - Incomplete Process
Ref: http://www.iso.org/
Maturity
Level 3
Level
PMBOK
Rationale
for The PMBOK is a global standard which establishes best
Selection practices and principles for project management.
PRINCE2
Prince2 is a widely adopted structured method for
effective Project Management, which covers the
management, control and organization of a project
Documented
and procedures
Initiating
Planning
Executing
Closing
Simultaneously the project is also divided into nine knowledge areas a s
follows:
PRINCE2:
PRINCE2 defines 40 separate activities and organized into seven
processes:
ITIL
Rationale
for ITIL is a framework of best practices for IT service
Selection management which gives detailed descriptions of IT
processes and provides comprehensive checklists, tasks
and procedures that any IT organization can tailor to
its needs.
ISO 20000
This is an international standard that defines the
requirements for an organization to deliver services of
an acceptable quality to its customers. It aims to
promote the adoption of an integrated set of management
processes for the effective delivery of services to the
business and its customers
ITIL and ISO 20000 are complementary to one another –
implementing ITIL processes satisfy some of the
requirements towards attaining an ISO 20000
certification
Documented
ITIL:
Implement the requirements of the ITIL Standard to
maturity level 3 and submit to a compliance audit
ISO 20000
Implement the requirements of the ISO 20000 standard
2
Current ITIL version is ITIL 2011 is an update to the version 3 or ITIL 2007
ISO 20000
The ISO 20000 standard specifies a set of inter-related management
processes and is derived from ITIL. The Standard promotes an integrated
service management model comprising of the following:
Relationship Processes
o General requirements
o Business Relationship Management
o Supplier Management
Resolution Processes
o Background
o Incident Management
o Problem Management
Control Processes
o Configuration Management
o Change Management
Release Processes
o Release Management
ISO 20000: http://www.iso.org/
Acceptable
Tier 3
Tier
Data Centre Tier Standard
Rationale
for The Uptime Institute site infrastructure tier standard
Selection is a widely adopted global standard that was developed
as an objective basis for comparing the functionality,
capacity and expected availability of a data centre
site
Cabling infrastructure
Tiered reliability
Environmental considerations
TIA 942
Intended for use by data centre designers early in the building
development process, and covers the following:
Site space and layout: Proper space allocation for a data centre
starts with ensuring that space can be easily reallocated to
changing environments and growth. Designers must strike a balance
between acceptable initial deployment costs and anticip ated space
required in the future. The data centre should be designed with
plenty of flexible "white space," empty space that can accommodate
future racks or cabinets. The space surrounding the data centre
must also be considered for future growth and plan ned for easy
annexation. The standard also recommends specific functional areas,
which helps to define equipment placement based on the standard
hierarchical star topology design for regular commercial spaces.
The TIA-942 specifies that a data centre should include the
following key functional areas:
o One or More Entrance Rooms
o Main Distribution Area (MDA)
o One or More Horizontal Distribution Areas (HDA)
o Equipment Distribution Area (EDA)
o Zone Distribution Area (ZDA)
o Backbone and Horizontal Cabling
Minimum
Acceptable
Not Applicable
Maturity
Level
BS OHSAS 18001
Rationale
for BS OHSAS 18001 is one of the most recognized
Selection frameworks for occupational health and safety
management systems that allows an organization to
proactively control health and safety risks and
improve performance. It provides an assessment
specification for Occupational Health and Safety
Management Systems.
Planning
o Hazard identification, Risk Assessment and Determining
Controls
o Legal and Other Requirements: Procedure for describing how
legal information is identified and accessed.
o Objectives and Programs: Outlines the importance of a process
to manage OH&S programs with objectives & targets which are
consistent with the policy
Minimum
Acceptable
Not Applicable
Maturity
Level
BCI Good Practice Guidelines
Rationale
for The BCI GPG is a holistic set of guidelines
Selection developed by the Business Continuity Institute which
specifies six Professional Practices that cover all
six phases of a Business Continuity Management
Lifecycle:
o Policy and Programme Management
o Embedding BCM in the Organization’s Culture
o Understanding the Organization
o Determining BCM Strategies
o Developing and Implementing a BCM Response
o Exercising, Maintenance and Review of BCM
BS 25999 ( ISO22301)
Reduced downtime
BCI Good Practice Guidelines:
Requirements
for In order to be compliant to the industry standard the
guidelines of the BCI GPG must be implemented within
compliance the organization.
BS 25999 ( ISO22301):
In order to be compliant, the organization must
implement a BCM System based on the requirements of
Specification Section (Part 2) of the standard
Process for compliance
BCI Good Practice Guidelines
Risk Assessment
o Determining BCM Strategies: determining and selecting BCM
Strategies to be used to maintain the organization’s business
activities and processes through an interruption. It
includes:
Corporate Strategies
includes
BS 25999
BS 25999-1 establishes processes, principles and terminology for Business
Continuity Management. It covers the following key areas:
BS 25999-2 (ISO22301)
Part 2 of the standard is predicated on the established Plan -Do-Check-Act
model of continuous improvement and covers the following:
Monitoring and Reviewing the BCMS (CHECK): To ensure that the BCMS
is continually monitored the Check stage covers internal audit and
management review of the BCMS.
Maintaining and Improving the BCMS (ACT): To ensure that the BCMS
is both maintained and improved on an ongoing basis this section
looks at preventative and corrective action
Ref: http://www.bsigroup.com/
Acceptable
Maturity Not Applicable
Level
ISO 27001/27002
Rationale
for ISO 27001 enables organizations establish and
Selection maintain an information security management system
(ISMS). It focuses on how to implement, monitor,
maintain, and continually improve the Information
Security Management System
ISO 27002 provides established guidelines and
general principles for initiating, implementing,
maintaining, and improving information security
management within an organization. It contains
guidance on implementation of individual security
controls, which may be selected and applied as part
of an ISMS
PCI DSS
PCI DSS:
Requirements
for In order to be found compliant, the organization must
implement the specified controls within the agreed
compliance timelines and be ascertained by a Qualified Security
Assessor (QSA) to have met the requirements for
compliance.
ISO 27001:
An organization must implement the necessary controls
to meet the requirements of the standard and be
certified by an accredited certification body as such.
Process for compliance
PCI DSS
Establish an ISMS
Security Policy
Asset Management
Physical Security
Access Control
Business Continuity
Compliance
ISO 27001: http://www.iso.org/
Purpose
Framework for defining ICT Skills required in an
organization.
Minimum
Acceptable
Not Applicable
Maturity
Level
SFIA
Rationale
for SFIA provides a common reference model for the
Selection identification of the skills and competencies
required by ICT professionals and maps out 101
identifiable skills, categorized into 6 main areas:
o Strategy and architecture
o Business change
o Solutions development and implementation
o Service management
o Procurement and management support
o Client interface
The standard is freely available for download and
use
Improved deployment of IT skills within the
Benefits
organization
Information strategy
Relationship management
o Solutions development and implementation
Systems development
Human factors
Service Strategy
Service Design
Service transition
Service Operation
o Procurement and management support
Supply management
Quality Management
Resource management
o Client interface
Client Support
Service Management
Interfaces
IT Security
Application Reporting
Priority 2 Standards
IT Governance
Strategic IT Alignment
Project Management
Data Centre
Enterprise Architecture
Application Development
Priority 2:
COBIT ISO 38500
PMBOK / PRINCE2 PMBOK / PRINCE2
Level 3 Level 5
SFIA Continuous
SFIA Improvement
Priority 3:
Data Centre Tier 3 Data Centre Tier 4
CMMI
Service Management ITIL
& Operations SFIA
DC Tier Standards (Target Maturity: Tier 3)
BCI GPGs / BS25999 / ISO 22301
OHSAS 18001
Figure 3 - Recommended Adoption Timeline
Bankers Committee
Sub-Committee on
Shared Services
IT Standards
Council
IT Standards
Council
Compliance Standards
Management Review
Committee Committee
I T St andar ds
Counc i l
1 Will CBN certify Banks The Council will not certify banks.
that are compliant with Certification will be left for the Certificate
respect to the IT Authorities
Standards?
5 How many Standards per Banks are required to implement only one
capability area are standard per area of IT concern. Banks that
required by the Banks want to implement more than one standard are
to implement? welcomed.
7 Can the Banks extend Banks can extend the current standards as long
the scope of new and as the minimum features / requirements of the
already implemented standards defined for the Industry are met
standards?
8 Are Banks with foreign Yes. Standards defined for the local industry
affiliation required to are expected to be adopted by every Bank
adopt the se IT
12 How would new, excluded All new/ additional standards will be reviewed
or obsolete IT during the annual IT standards review and
Standards e.g. risk recommendations made to the IT standards Council
management, PA-DSS etc.
be reviewed?