Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 29 views

    Investigation 1: A Study On The Effect of Smoke Water On The Germination and Growth of Eucalyptus Pilularis

    Uploaded by

    Hugh Janus
    This investigation studied the effect of smoke water on the germination and growth of Eucalyptus pilularis seeds. Seeds were placed on filter paper soaked with smoke water at different concentrations and a distilled water control. Germination rates and seedling heights were measured over time. The study found higher germination rates and growth in seeds exposed to low concentrations of smoke water compared to the control. Overall the methodology was well designed and the conclusions were supported by the data, though some uncertainties could be addressed in future studies.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Investigation 1: A Study On The Effect of Smoke Water On The Germination and Growth of Eucalyptus Pilularis

    Uploaded by

    Hugh Janus
    29 views5 pages
    This investigation studied the effect of smoke water on the germination and growth of Eucalyptus pilularis seeds. Seeds were placed on filter paper soaked with smoke water at different concentrations and a distilled water control. Germination rates and seedling heights were measured over time. The study found higher germination rates and growth in seeds exposed to low concentrations of smoke water compared to the control. Overall the methodology was well designed and the conclusions were supported by the data, though some uncertainties could be addressed in future studies.

    Original Title

    investigation_1

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    This investigation studied the effect of smoke water on the germination and growth of Eucalyptus pilularis seeds. Seeds were placed on filter paper soaked with smoke water at different concentrations and a distilled water control. Germination rates and seedling heights were measured over time. The study found higher germination rates and growth in seeds exposed to low concentrations of smoke water compared to the control. Overall the methodology was well designed and the conclusions were supported by the data, though some uncertainties could be addressed in future studies.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    29 views5 pages

    Investigation 1: A Study On The Effect of Smoke Water On The Germination and Growth of Eucalyptus Pilularis

    Uploaded by

    Hugh Janus
    This investigation studied the effect of smoke water on the germination and growth of Eucalyptus pilularis seeds. Seeds were placed on filter paper soaked with smoke water at different concentrations and a distilled water control. Germination rates and seedling heights were measured over time. The study found higher germination rates and growth in seeds exposed to low concentrations of smoke water compared to the control. Overall the methodology was well designed and the conclusions were supported by the data, though some uncertainties could be addressed in future studies.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 5

    Investigation 1: A study on the effect of smoke water on the

    germination and growth of Eucalyptus pilularis


    To view the various elements of this example, please use the icons at the side of the screen.

    Note: The comments in the annotated examples match the labelling on teacher forms.

    Investigation 1: Moderator comments

    Personal Exploration  Analysis  Evaluation  Communication  Total 


    engagement  x/6 x/6 x/6 x/4 x/24
    x/2

    2 5 5 5 4 21

    Personal engagement

    Mark Descriptor
    The justification given for choosing the research question and/or the topic under investigation demonstrates personal
    significance, interest or curiosity.
    2 There is evidence of personal input and initiative in the designing, implementation or presentation of the investigation. 2

    Moderator’s Moderator’s comment


    award 
    The research question is justified and there is clear indication of personal engagement. Though the experiment employs a standard
    2
    test for seed germination and the measurement of post germination growth, they have been used in an applied manner to solve the
    problem of a control. The experiment took place over an extended period of time requiring considerable personal input.

    Exploration

    Mark Descriptor

    The topic of the investigation is identified and a relevant and fully focused research question is clearly described. 6
    The background information provided for the investigation is entirely appropriate and relevant and enhances the
    5–6 understanding of the context of the investigation. 5
    The methodology of the investigation is highly appropriate to address the research question because it takes into
    consideration all, or nearly all, of the significant factors that may influence the relevance, reliability and sufficiency of the collect
    data. 5
    The report shows evidence of full awareness of the significant safety, ethical or environmental issues that are relevant to
    the methodology of the investigation. 6
    Moderator’s Moderator’s comment
    award 
    The research question is focused and relevant background information is provided, however, more information on the interaction
    5
    the minerals identified with germination would be needed.
    The methodology is highly appropriate to the research question providing sufficient control and data, though the pH of the smoke
    water ought to have been monitored.
    Safety issues are considered. The experiment presents no ethical or environmental issues.

    Analysis

    Mark Descriptor

    Appropriate and sufficient data processing is carried out that could lead to a broadly valid conclusion but there are significa
    inaccuracies and inconsistencies in the processing. 4
    3–4

    5–6 The report includes sufficient relevant quantitative and qualitative raw data that could support a detailed and valid conclusi
    to the research question. 6
    The report shows evidence of full and appropriate consideration of the impact of measurement uncertainty on the analysis.
    The processed data is correctly interpreted so that a completely valid and detailed conclusion to the research question can b
    deduced. 6
    Moderator’s Moderator’s comment
    award 
    Sufficient relevant quantitative and qualitative data is collected to support a detailed and valid conclusion. These data are
    5
    appropriately and successfully processed most of the time with consideration of the uncertainties. However, it is not certain that da
    for heights follows a normal distribution therefore the t-test may not be valid. The processed data are correctly interpreted.

    Evaluation

    Mark Descriptor
    A conclusion is described and justified which is relevant to the research question and supported by the data presented. 6
    A conclusion is correctly described and justified through relevant comparison to the accepted scientific context. 6
    5–6
    Strengths and weaknesses of the investigation, such as limitations of the data and sources of error, are discussed and provi
    evidence of a clear understanding of the methodological issues involved in establishing the conclusion. 5
    The student has discussed realistic and relevant suggestions for the improvement and extension of the investigation. 5
    Moderator’s Moderator’s comment
    award 
    A relevant conclusion, justified through comparison with scientific literature values, is drawn and is supported by the data.
    5
    The investigation is evaluated and there is some consideration of the uncertainties and the limitation of the data and the experimen
    However, there are some assumptions made that may not have a strong foundation, for example, the candidate assumes that the
    different seed masses will necessarily have different nutrient contents.
    The suggested improvements are generally sensible though selecting seeds of exactly the same mass is not realistic. Feasible
    extensions are proposed.

    Communication

    Mark Descriptor

    The report is well structured and clear: the necessary information on focus, process and outcomes is present and present
    in a coherent way. 4
    3–4 The report is relevant and concise thereby facilitating a ready understanding of the focus, process and outcomes of the
    investigation. 4
    The use of subject-specific terminology and conventions is appropriate and correct. Any errors do not hamper
    understanding. 4
    Moderator’s Moderator’s comment
    award 
    The report is coherent and complete. It is relevant and reasonably concise. There are no major or consistent errors in subject-
    4
    specific terminology or conventions.

    You might also like