Chapter 3 Special Techniques: Z V y V X V
Chapter 3 Special Techniques: Z V y V X V
Chapter 3 Special Techniques: Z V y V X V
Laplace’s Equation in 1D
3.1 Laplace’s Equation: 3.1.1 Introduction
1 Suppose V depends on only one variable, x.
Poisson’s equation: ∇ V =−
2
ρ (r )
ε0 ∂ 2V
=0 ⇒ V ( x) = mx + b
Very often, we are interested in finding the potential in a ∂x 2
region where ρ =0. Two features of this solution:
There may be plenty of charge elsewhere, but we’re
confining our attention to places where there is no charge. 1. Laplace’s equation is a kind of averaging instruction.
1
V ( x) = (V ( x − a) + V ( x + a)) for any a
Laplace’s equation: ∇ V =0
2
2
∂ 2V ∂ 2V ∂ 2V 2. Laplace’s equation tolerates no local maxima or minima,
In Cartesian coordinate, + + =0
∂x 2 ∂y 2 ∂z 2 since the second derivative must be zero.
1 2
3 4
3.1.4. Laplace’s Equation in 3D No Local Maxima or Minima in 3D
2. V has no local maxima or minima; the extreme values
∂ 2V ∂ 2V ∂ 2V
+ + = 0 (partial differential equation (PDE)) must occur at the boundaries.
∂x 2 ∂y 2 ∂z 2
Ex. For a single point charge q located outside the sphere
In three dimensions we can neither provide you with an of radius R as shown in the figure, find the potential at the
explicit solution nor offer a suggestive physical example to origin.
guide your intuition. Sol: V =
1 q
=
1 q
4πε 0 r 4πε 0 ( z 2 + R 2 − 2 zR cos θ )1/ 2
Nevertheless, the same two properties remain true.
1 q R 2 sin θdθdφ
so Vave (r = 0) = ∫
4πR 4πε 0 ( z + R 2 − 2 zR cos θ )1/ 2
2 2
1. The value of V at a point r is the average value of V
over a spherical surface of radius R centered at r: 1 q − d cos θ
2 4πε 0 ∫ ( z 2 + R 2 − 2 zR cos θ )1/ 2
=
1
V (r ) = ∫ Vda
1 q π
= ( z 2 + R 2 − 2 zR cos θ )1/ 2
2 zR 4πε 0
4πR 2
0
sphere
1 q q
= (( z + R) − ( z − R)) =
5 2 zR 4πε 0 4πε 0 z 6
3.1.5. Boundary Conditions and Uniqueness Theorems Boundary Conditions and Uniqueness Theorems
Laplace’s equation does not by itself determine V; a First uniqueness theorem: the solution to Laplace’s
suitable set of boundary conditions must be supplied. equation in some volume is uniquely determined if V is
specified on the boundary surface.
Proof:
What are appropriate boundary conditions, sufficient to Suppose there were two solutions to
determine the answer and yet not so strong as to generate
Laplace's equation : ∇ 2V1 = 0 and ∇ 2V2 = 0
inconsistencies? It is not easy to see.
Their difference is : V3 ≡ V1 − V2 .
This obays Laplace's equation, ∇ 2V3 = 0
For a given set of boundary conditions, is V uniquely Since V3 is zero on all boundaries and
determined? Yes, it is. Î uniqueness theorem Laplace's equation suggests that all extrema
occur on the boundary, so V3 . ⇒ V1 = V2
7 8
3.1.6. Conductors and the Second Uniqueness
Uniqueness Theorems with Charge Inside
Theorems
ρ ρ
∇ 2V1 = and ∇ 2V2 = . Let V3 ≡ V1 − V2 ⇒ ∇ 2V3 = 0 The simplest way to set the boundary conditions for an
ε0 ε0
electrostatic problem is to specify the value of V on all
Since V3 is zero on all boundaries and Laplace's equation suggests surfaces surrounding the region of interest.
that all extrema occur on the boundary, so V3 = 0. ⇒ V1 = V2
However, in some case we don’t know the potential at the
Corollary: The potential in a volume is uniquely boundaries rather the charges on various conducting
determined if (a) the charge density throughout the region, surfaces. Is the electric field still uniquely determined?
and (b) the value of V on all boundaries, are specified. Î Second uniqueness theorem.
1. V = 0 when z = 0 (since the conducting plane is grounded). Can we use this potential to find out the electric field,
2. V → 0 far from the charge. surface charge distribution, and the force? Yes.
13 14
−1 qd −1 qd
σ= =
∂V ∂V 2π ( x + y + d )
2 2 2 3/ 2
2π (r + d 2 ) 3 / 2
2
σ = −ε 0 = − ε0
∂n ∂z ∞ 2π − 1 qd
Q = ∫ σda = ∫ ∫
z =0
rdrdφ
0 0 2π ( r + d 2 ) 3 / 2
2
−1 −1 2( z − d )q 2( z + d )q
= − 2 2 3/ 2
4π 2 ( x + y + ( z − d ) )
2 2 2 3/ 2
( x + y + ( z + d ) ) z =0
2
∞ − qd qd
∞
=∫ dr 2 = 2 = −q
−1 −1 − 4qd −1 qd 0 2(r + d )
2 2 3/ 2
(r + d 2 )1/ 2
= = 0
4π 2 ( x + y + d )
2 2 2 3/ 2
2π ( x + y 2 + d 2 )3 / 2
2
15 16
3.2.3 Force and Energy Work and Energy
Consider the work required to bring q in from infinity.
The charge q is attracted toward the plane, because of the
negative induced charge. d d 1q2 1 q2
W = ∫ Fdz = ∫ dz = −
The force and the energy of this system can be analogous ∞ ∞ 4πε 4 z 2 4πε 0 4d
0
to the case of two point charges.
which is half of that of the two point charge system.
17 18
3.2.4 The Grounded Spherical Conducting Shell Example 3.2 A point charge is situated a distance a from the
center of a grounded conducting sphere of radius R. Find the
Any stationary charge distribution near a grounded conducting potential outside the sphere.
plane can be treated in the same way, by introducing its mirror
image---method of images.
Can this method be applied to a curved surface? Yes. Sol : Assume the image charge q′ is placed at a distance b from
the center of the sphere.
Here is an examples. A point charge is situated in front of a It is equipotential on the surface of a grounded sphere.
grounded conducting sphere.
Using two boundary conditions at P1 and P2 .
19 20
1q′ q Ex. Two equal conducting spheres with radius R, each
At P1 : (+ ) = 0
4πε 0 R − b a − R carries a total charge Q and –Q at a distance d from each
1 q′ q two equations and two unknowns (q′ and b) other. Find the electric field outside the conducting spheres.
At P2 : ( + ) = 0
4πε 0 R + b a + R
Sol:
R2 R
b= , q′ = − q
a a
The force of attraction between charge and the sphere is
1 qq ′ −1 q 2 Ra
F= =
4πε 0 (a − b) 2 4πε 0 (a 2 − R 2 ) 2
Laplace’s equation: ∇ 2V = 0
Basic strategy: look for solutions that are products of
functions, each of which depends on only one of the
coordinates.
V ( x, y, z ) = X ( x)Y ( y ) Z ( z )
23 24
Boundary Condition Separation of Variables
The configuration is independent of z, so Laplace’s equation The first step is to look for solutions in the form of products:
reduces to two dimensions.
V ( x, y ) = X ( x)Y ( y )
∂V ∂V
2 2
+ =0 Substituting into Laplace’s equation, we obtain
∂x 2 ∂y 2 ∂2 X ∂ 2Y 1 1 ∂ 2 X 1 ∂ 2Y
(Y + X = 0) × ⇒ + =0
The potential inside is subject to the boundary conditions. ∂x 2 ∂y 2 XY X ∂x 2 Y ∂y 2
The first term depends only on x and the second only on y.
(i) V = 0 when y = 0,
The sum of these two functions is zero, which implies these
(ii) V = 0 when y = a, two functions must both be constant.
(iii) V = V0 ( y ) when x = 0,
1 ∂2 X 1 ∂ 2Y
(iv) V → 0 as x → ∞. = C and = −C0
X ∂x 2 Y ∂y 2
0
25 26
1 ∂ X
2 =0 (iv) V ( x, y ) = ∑ Cn e − nπx a sin (nπy a)
= k 2 ⇒ X ( x) = Ae kx + Be − kx n =1
X ∂x 2
Can we use the remaining boundary condition (iii) to
1 ∂ 2Y =0 (i)
= − k 2
⇒ Y ( y ) = C sin ky + D cos ky determine the coefficients Cn? Yes.
Y ∂y 2 ∞
V ( x, y ) = ( Ae + Be
kx − kx
)(C sin ky + D cos ky ) V (0, y ) = ∑ Cn sin (nπy a) = V0 ( y )
n =1
The boundary condition (iv) require A equal zero, and (i) This is a Fourier sine series. Virtually any function V0(y)---
demands that D equal zero. can be expanded in such a series. 這麼神奇!
Meanwhile (ii) yields sin ka = 0, from which it follows that
We can use the so-called “Fourier’s trick” to find out the
nπ coefficients Cn.
k= , n = 1,2,3, … Why not n=0?
a
27 28
The Fourier Trick A Concrete Example
For a constant potential V0
∞
0, if n is even
∑C ∫
a a
sin (nπy a) sin (n′πy a )dy = ∫ V0 ( y ) sin (n′πy a)dy 2V0 a 2V0
n =1
n
0 0 Cn =
a ∫
0
sin (n′πy a)dy =
nπ
(1 − cos nπ ) = 4V0
nπ
, if n is odd
The integral on the left is
∞
4V0 1 − nπx a
∫0
a
sin (nπy a) sin (n′πy a)dy So V ( x, y ) = ∑
π n =1,3,5,... n
e sin (nπy a )
1 a πy πy 0, if n′ ≠ n
2 ∫0
= (cos(( n − n′) ) − cos(( n + n′) ) dy = a , if n′ = n
a a 2
2 a
Cn′ = ∫ V0 ( y ) sin (n′πy a)dy
a 0
29 30
31 32
Boundary Condition Separation of Variables
This is a genuinely three-dimensional problem,
The first step is to look for solutions in the form of products:
∂ 2V ∂ 2V ∂ 2V
+ + =0 V ( x, y, z ) = X ( x)Y ( y ) Z ( z )
∂x 2 ∂y 2 ∂z 2
Substituting into Laplace’s equation, we obtain
The potential inside is subject to the boundary conditions. 1 ∂ 2 X 1 ∂ 2Y 1 ∂ 2 Z
+ + =0
(i) V = 0 when y = 0, X ∂x 2 Y ∂y 2 Z ∂z 2
(ii) V = 0 when y = a,
It follows that
(iii) V = 0 when z = 0, 1 ∂2 X 1 ∂ 2Y 2 1 ∂ Z
2
(iv) V = 0 when z = b, = (k 2 + 2
), = −k , =− 2
X ∂x 2 Y ∂y 2 Z ∂y 2
(v) V = V0 ( y, z ) when x = 0,
How do we know? Any other possibility?
(vi) V → 0 as x → ∞.
33 34
X ∂x 2
−π ( an ) 2 + ( mb ) 2 x
V ( x, y, z ) = BCEe sin (nπy a) sin (mπz b),
1 ∂ 2Y =0 (i)
= − k 2 ⇒ Y ( y ) = C sin ky + D cos ky where n and m are unspecified integers.
Y ∂y 2
0 0
n =1 m =1
a b
=∫ ∫ V ( y, z ) sin (n′πy
0 a ) sin (m′πz a)dydz
0 0
4 a b
ab ∫0 ∫0
Cn ,m = V0 ( y, z ) sin (nπy a) sin (mπz b)dydz Problems: 10, 12, 15, 47
Rodrigues Formula
d 1 d ( x 2 − 1)
Prove: P ( x) = ) ( x 2 − 1) , x =cosθ
( Let k = and u = v ( ) = = P (cos θ )(2 !)
2 ! dx dx
1 ∂ ∂P (cos θ ) ∴ (1 − x 2 )u ′′ − 2 xu ′ + ( + 1)u = 0
where (sin θ ) = − ( + 1) P (cos θ )
sin θ ∂θ ∂θ d 2 P (cos θ ) dP (cos θ )
Sol: ⇒ (1 − cos θ )
2
2
− 2x + ( + 1) P (cos θ ) = 0
dx dx
Let v = ( x 2 − 1)
v′ = 2 x( x 2 − 1) −1 × ( x 2 -1) dP (cos θ ) dP (cos θ ) dθ 1 dP (cos θ )
⇒ (1 − x 2 )v′ + 2 xv = 0 = =−
dx dθ dx sin θ dθ
d 2 P (cos θ ) d 1 dP (cos θ ) 1
= (− )(− )
(1 − x 2 )v′′ − 2 xv′ + 2 xv′ + 2 v = 0 dx 2
dθ sin θ dθ sin θ
(1 − x 2 )v′′ + 2( − 1) xv′ + 2 v = 0 1 d 2 P (cos θ ) cos θ dP (cos θ )
= − 3
(1 − x 2 )v′′′ + 2( − 2) xv′′ + 2(2 − 1)v′ = 0 sin 2 θ dθ 2 sin θ dθ
(1 − x 2 )v ( k + 2) + 2( − k − 1) xv ( k +1) + (k + 1)(2 − k )v ( k ) = 0
43 44
Properties of Legendre Polynomials
1 d P (cos θ ) cos θ dP (cos θ )
2
(1 − cos 2 θ )[ − 3 ] The first few Legendre polynomials are listed
sin 2 θ dθ 2 sin θ dθ
1 dP (cos θ )
− 2 cos θ [− ] + ( + 1) P (cos θ ) P ( x) : an th - order polynomial in x
sin θ dθ
d 2 P (cos θ ) cos θ dP (cos θ )
= + + ( + 1) P (cos θ )
dθ 2 sin θ dθ
1 d dP (cos θ )
= (sin θ ) + ( + 1) P (cos θ ) = 0
sin θ dθ dθ Completeness: The Legendre polynomials constitute a
complete set of function, on the interval -1<x<1.
Orthogonality: The polynomials are orthogonal functions:
1 d (cos 2 θ − 1) 1 π
∴ P (cos θ ) =
2 ! dx
∫ −1
P ( x) P ′ ( x)dx = ∫ P (cos θ ) P ′ (cos θ ) sin θdθ
0
0 if ′ ≠
= 2
, if ′ =
45 2 + 1 46
A Complete Solution in Legendre Polynomials Example 3.6 The potential V0(θ)=V0sin2(θ/2) is specified on
the surface of a hollow sphere, of radius R. Find the potential
The Rodrigues formula generates only one solution. What inside the sphere.
and where are other solutions?
Sol: In this case Bι=0 for all ι---otherwise the potential would
These ”other solutions” blow up at θ=0 and/or θ=π, are
blow up at the origin. Thus,
therefore unacceptable on physical grounds.
∞ ∞
V (r ,θ ) = ∑ A r P (cosθ ) → V ( R,θ ) = ∑ A R P (cosθ )
=0 =0
1
V (r , θ ) = ( Ar + B ) P (cosθ ) 2 +1 1 π
r +1 A =
2 R ∫0
V ( R, θ ) P (cos θ ) sin θ dθ
The general solutions is the linear combination of separable 2 +1 1 π θ
solutions.
∞
=
2 R ∫ V sin 2 ( ) P (cos θ ) sin θ dθ
0 0 2
1
V (r ,θ ) = ∑ ( Ar + B ) P (cosθ ) 2 +1 1 πV
=0 r +1 =
2 R ∫0 20 (1 − cos θ ) P (cos θ ) sin θ dθ
2 +1 1 πV
47
=
2 R ∫0 20 ( P0 (cos θ ) − P1 (cos θ )) P (cosθ ) sin θ dθ 48
Example 3.8 An uncharged metal
2 +1 1 π V0 sphere of radius R is placed in an
A =
2 R ∫
0 2
( P0 (cos θ ) − P1 (cos θ )) P (cos θ ) sin θ dθ otherwise uniform electric field E = E0 zˆ
Find the potential in the region outside
1 0 if ′ ≠ the sphere.
∫−1 P ( x ) P ′ ( x ) dx = 2
2 + 1
, if ′ =
Sol: The sphere is an equipotential---we may as well set it to
zero.
The potential is azimuthal symmetric and by symmetry the
entire xy plane is at potential zero.
V0
A0 = In addition, the potential is not zero at large z.
V0 r
2 ⇒ V (r ,θ ) = 1 − R cos θ Boundary conditions are:
V 2
A1 = − 0
2R (i) V = 0 when r = R,
(ii) V → − E0 r cos θ for r >> R.
49 50
1 ∞ r′
r′ r′
where ε = ( − 2 cos θ ′)
= ∑ ( ) P (cosθ ′)
r =0 r
Taylor’s expansion
r r 1 ∞
r′
1 1 1 3 5 V (r ) = ∫
4πε r
∑ ( r ) P (cosθ ′) ρ (r′)dτ ′ This is the desired result.
(1 + ε ) −1/ 2 = (1 − ε + ε 2 − ε 3 + …), if ε << 1 0 =0
r r 2 8 16 1 ∞
1
So
1 1
= (1 −
1 r′ r′ 3 r′ r′
( − 2 cos θ ′) + ( ( − 2 cos θ ′)) 2
=
4πε r
∑ r ∫ (r ′)
=0
P (cos θ ′) ρ (r′)dτ ′
r − r′ r
0
2r r 8 r r
1 1
5 r′ r′ 1 r ∫ ρ (r′)dτ ′ + 2 ∫ r ′ cos θ ′ρ (r′)dτ ′
− ( ( − 2 cos θ ′))3 + …) or more exolicity,V (r ) =
r
16 r r 4πε 0 1
(r ′) ( cos θ ′ − 1) ρ (r′)dτ ′ + …
3
r 3 ∫
+ 2 2
1 r′ r′ 2
= (1 + ( ) cos θ ′ + ( ) 2 ((3 cos 2 θ ′ − 1) / 2) + …)
r r r
53
The multiple expansion of V in power of 1/r. 54
55 56
Example 3.10 A electric dipole consists of
The Electric Field of a Dipole
two equal and opposite charges separated
1 qd cos θ 1 rˆ ⋅ p p cos θ Why?
by a distance d. Find the approximate V (r ) = = =
potential at points far from the dipole. 4πε 0 r 2
4πε 0 r 2
4πε 0 r 2 Just a convention.
where P = qd ↑ pointing form negative charge to the positive charge.
Sol:
q 1 1 q p 2 cos θ sin θ
V (r ) = ( − )= ((1 − ε ) −1/ 2 − (1 + ε ) −1/ 2 ) E = −∇V (r ) = (− rˆ + 2 θˆ + 0φˆ )
4πε 0 r− 2 z r+ 2 z
d ˆ d ˆ
4πε 0 r 4πε 0 r 3
r
r′ r′ d r′ =
p
(−2 cos θrˆ + r sin θθˆ )
where ε = ( − 2 cos θ ′) ≅ cos θ (if << 1, so θ ′ ≅ θ ) 4πε 0 r 3
r r r r
q
V (r ) = ((1 − ε ) −1/ 2 − (1 + ε ) −1/ 2 )
4πε 0 r
q d 1 qd cos θ
= ( cos θ ) =
4πε 0 r r 4πε 0 r2
57 58
Potential energy:
U = −p ⋅ E
59 60