Global Journal of Finance and Management.

ISSN 0975-6477 Volume 6, Number 7 (2014), pp. 599-608

© Research India Publications
http://www.ripublication.com

Training and Development - Issues in the Indian Context

Dr. Aliya Sultana1, P. Naganandini Devi2 and Navyateja3

1
HOD, Vice - Principal, Dept of Management Studies, Dr. K.V. Subbareddy College
of Engg. for Women Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh, India
2
Associate, Prof, Dept of Management Studies, Dr.K.V. Subbareddy Institute of
Management Studies Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh, India
3
Asst. Prof, Dept of Management Studies, Dr.K.V. Subbareddy College of Engg. for
Women Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh, India
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected],
1
3
[email protected]

Abstract
In the present era of globalisation, there is an imperative need for
employee with extraordinary skills which adds potential to perform
better. Human beings are naturally gifted with the potential to learn. It
is up to us to leverage this inherent potential and achieve what we are
destined to. There has also been rapid transformation in organisation
structure and work practices. These changes would definitely have a
significant impact for training and development of the work place. As
training occupies a top spot in the HR agenda for many organisations,
but the impact on the bottom line does not fall in line with
expectations. The answer lies in better structure, sharp vision on the
end goals and a tighter focus on the cardinal rules of the game. This
paper deals with the present scenario and issues in the Indian context.
It analyses how these issues if resolved can lead to better productivity.

Keywords: Training Need Identification, Organisational

transformation, Evaluation, Development, Assessment.

1. Introduction
Since 1990’s the economy has been characterised by intense global competition and
rapid technological advance. Due to rapid changes in economy and constant
restructuring activities taking place in organisations, this brings forth significant
transformation in organisational structure and work practices. Due to these changes,
600 Dr. Aliya Sultana

there is a great demand for new job skills, greater level of workforce skills to match the
changing organisational structures and job profiles. This level of changes would have a
significant implication for training and development of the work force. Organisations
must make a continuous effort to upgrade the size and skill competition of the work
force. This is where the training and development aspect plays an important role. Due
to the competitive pressures, technological advancement and changes in organisational
and work structure, there is a need for expanded skills and continuous skill up
gradation to prevent obsolescence.
In the dynamic and contemporary business environment, organisations are faced
with several types of challenges in the environment caused by business dynamics, new
technologies, new competitors, fluctuating productivity, changing nature of jobs,
employee turnover. In order to manage these changes and developments, the managers
must make the right choice that they have the right type of human resources by hiring
people with the required skills and competencies.

2. Present scenario
Currently in India, there are only few organisations who are emphasizing on training
and development. Training is a planned and systematic attempt to alter or develop
knowledge, skill, attitude through learning experience so as to achieve effective
performance in an activity or a range of activities.
According to Flippo, training is the act of increasing the knowledge and skill of an
employee for doing a particular job. It is an opportunity to learn and depend on several
factors such as design and execution of training, the inspiration and learning style of
the trainees and also the environment for learning in the organisation. The importance
of corporate training should be visualized in the context of paradigm shift that is taking
place in Indian industry. The role of knowledge worker is increasing. The pace of
change is fast and the skills have to be enhanced. So training is one of the tools at
CEO’s disposal to achieve this end. The compelling need for training is also because of
three factors. The first is liberalization which has dismantled barriers and made the
entry easier for both domestic and overseas companies. The second is the demand and
supply of professional talent which has made employee retention a concern for CEO’s.
The third reason is growing expectation of employees regarding their professional and
personal development.
Most organisations in India have been allocating resources to training as an act of
faith for professionalism and strategic thinking. There are several kinds of training
methods used by trainers in organisations. The designer of training program needs to
be capable of matching the best method with the training objectives. In the Indian
corporate scenario, some renowned companies have used modern training techniques
and have made outstanding progress in terms of their training initiative resulting in
greater competition particularly resulting from the liberal entry of MNC’s in India. The
emerging scenario necessitates review of the existing skills and training system.
Training and Development - Issues in the Indian Context 601

Devising and innovative approach to training and skill development should be the
focus of management.
Since 2003, American Society for Training and Development (ASTD) has
recognised the training initiatives taken by organisations and preferred to honour them.
Indian organisations are achieving excellence in training and skill development have
been awarded by ASTD.
It is a pride for the nation that Indian organisations are participating and are
awarded every year by ASTD for achieving excellence in training function. In the year
2008, four organisations from India were able to get entry in the winner list of 40 best
organisations. These organisations were: Reliance Industries Ltd., Nagothane
Manufacturing division having strength of 2,157 employees, Infosys Technologies
Limited having 79,016 employees, Wipro Limited having 60,000 employee strength,
and ICICI Bank Limited with employee strength of 40,880. This is an encouraging
trend to note that Indian organisations operating in India are serious about their
learning and development initiatives. They are giving priority to this area and are able
to integrate it with their organisational goals. In fact, the top management is taking
interest in mentoring and leadership. For example, NarayanaMurthy of Infosys is now
acting as a chairman of the board as well as chief Mentor. In this way, they prepare the
next generation leaders for the company. Let us interview briefly the training structure
of some more companies including a bank.

3. Adithya Birla Group

The group is driven by performance ethics pegged on the value Creation for its
multiple stakeholders. Its core values are integrity, leading change, excellence, respect
for individual learning and sharing. To increase the knowledge and skills of
employees. This group has established a centre in Navi Mumbai known by the name
Gyanodaya. Gyanodaya has been envisioned as a hub, the group’s competitive edge.

Infosys
Infosys Technologies Ltd. headquartered in Bangalore, provides Information
Technology (IT) consulting and software services to clients globally as partners to
conceptualize and realize technology driven business transformation initiatives. It is
very essential for the company to upgrade its workforce regularly to compete in the
global market.
To overcome this challenge, Infosys provides training and development
opportunities to its employees right from the start. The company has bagged many
awards from ASTD as the world’s best company for providing best training and
development opportunities to the employees . The company is known best for its
global business foundation school which runs the program for all fresh engineering
graduates who join Infosys and prepare them for the technical and environmental
opportunities present in the market.
602 Dr. Aliya Sultana

Syndicate Bank
Training is one of the most important interventions for developing Human resources.
For this Syndicate banks first step is to analyse the training need of the employees. For
the analysis of training needs they adopt scientific methods. the second step is to make
a tailored training program for senior officials of the bank. The two institutes play a
major role i.e Syndicate Institute of Bank Management and The Apex Training
Institute of the Bank at Manipal.

Essar Corporate University(ECU)

Essar is a prestigious and renowned group ,awarded by ISTD in 2000 for its innovative
training practices. It is famous for its ECU, which is virtual learning organisation and
takes various steps for the training and development of employees. The main goals of
the programme are to emphasise in teams to develop networking bonding, develop
trust and explore risk taking. The company has also established Essar Learning centre
at Hazira which organises around 400 formal training programmes per year on subjects
ranging from industrialised operations, general management and logistics
management. E-modules are provided by Learning Management Systems regarding
technical and management aspects to employees to make them aware about latest
management and technical skills.

Accenture
Continual learning organisation process is essential for an organisation for its survival
in the present era of liberalisation, privatisation, globalisation. knowledge is the core
competence of organisations for copying with changes. With this the above philosophy
some institutional learning centres and divisions have introduced programme “Leaders
teaching Leaders” Under this programme, leaders share their past experiences for the
betterment of the working styles of present employees. Its education programmes have
been well known and appreciative around the business world.

IBM
IBM is a company that gives value to learning and development of employees since
1915.It has a separate and distinct IBM education department which was established to
train and develop employees.IBM is known for the use of E-learning programmes to
address its learning solutions. The learning approaches used in IBM programmes are
learning from interaction simulation or games, collaborative learning etc.IBM is also
well known for its programme” IBM connections.

4. Issues in Training and development

Though training is considered to be mandatory, but the very importance of it is being
misunderstood in term as a routine activity rather than providing it in a justified
manner. The issues are:
Training and Development - Issues in the Indian Context 603

 Trainers often neglect the content of the programme which needs to be well
structured into segments or sections. Most of the training programmes have
been inclusive of stories and management games and other videos on fish
tossing fish onto then fellow workers amusing and stirring but fails to grab the
attention of the participants for long as most of the content is found to be
irrelevant to the core job. Though many firms follow the training needs based
on the Training Need Identification Process, but the content of the programme
has almost no connection relevance to the job and their nominations were based
on training need identification process(TNI).
 Trainers should understand the basic need of their end customers. It is often felt
that training is a ritual conducted as a part of curriculum of the employees or it
is only to bring a change in the mood by breaking the monotony of the routine
work. Starting a programme without thinking that it can lead to a failure.
Treating it as an event or celebration can delineate from the strategic agenda.
According to Eduardosalas, a professor of organisational psychology of the
University of Central Florida and programme director at the Institute of
Simulation and Training ,who has studied corporate training programme for
more than 2 decades, says that company do not analyse well regarding the
training needs and after the programme there is no follow up.
 Most of the training imparted is based without judging the calibre and
customising the delivery mechanism to suit at best so that the learning
objective is the most important skill of the trainer. Often trainers conduct
training programmes in an un stimulating learning environment by not
considering certain facts like people who are being trained and who are not
well versed with the process. Trainers do not focus on fact, data and
behavioural indications of the participant. Employees have a self centred way
of accomplishment when going to training programme which is a destructive
mindset.
 Training sessions should not be solely focussed on lectures and texts in a
classroom environment rather they should have casual gatherings with
refreshments and discussions on the issues is far better. The pre-packaged
programmes always are structured ones which might not go well with all the
participants. Therefore, the one-size-fits-all solution can become a major misfit
in a training environment.
 Most of the trainers still prefer to adopt the same power point presentation or
gyan sessions which would fail to work. In contemporary world where mobiles,
tablets and the internet, learning has progressed to E-learning and M-learning
modules to stay in tune with the present needs.
 Training is considered as a short term initiative and there is often no effective
management tool to judge the effectiveness of training imparted to the
participant. The trainer should be an expert who can successfully deliver. It is
always better to entrust the responsibility of the programme to a trainer. Often
trainers overtake regarding checking validity of the programme.
604 Dr. Aliya Sultana

 Transfer of training: Though training has become more prevalent, it is not

always effective. Many organisations spend significant amount of time money
on training, still it is only 10% of learning transfers to job performance.
Transfer of training is most important aspect of measuring the effectiveness of
training programme. As Kircpatrick(1967) has also confirmed that the transfer
of training to the job is one of the key criteria for evaluating the effectiveness
of any formal training program. Keeping this in view of the issues invited,
Fig.1 displays a typical cycle for training & development.

Fig 1: The Training and Development CycleNeed for change.

As leadership is taking the centre stage of organisational transformation, the

importance of the training and development becomes one of the essential priorities for
business survival and sustenance of the momentum for building continued excellence.
Training may be incorrectly used as a solution to a performance problem when the
solution should deal with employee motivation, job design or a better communication
of performance expectations. Organisations must always consider the bigger picture to
address the situation or need appropriately. This is possible by improving performance,
going beyond training. By analysis of performance done from a holistic view, it is
assumed that training based on customised needs is not the only solution to bridge the
performance gap but it should also ensure the highest level of performance possible.
The content of the programs also needs to be customer-oriented or recipient- oriented.
It is also better to avoid creating experience which do not connect to real life situation
and work challenges.
Once the gap is determined, there has to be a good instructional design framework
to proceed. It’s suggested by the ASTD’s Human Performance Improvement (HPI)
Certificate Program Services, the performance gaps need to be diagnosed properly. An
Training and Development - Issues in the Indian Context 605

integration of essential E- learning components needs to be done which comprises of

motivation, learner interface, content structure and sequencing, navigation and
instructional interactivity. Though engaging an effective e-learning take significant
effort but is well worth it. It is also important to adopt a model for developing a
training session or model which is easy to apply.
The five step training model involves:
 Rationale
 Objective
 Activity
 Evaluation
 Feedback

It would prove to be a systematic and simple way to deliver training.

This also ensures that the training imparted is high in terms of consistency,
engagement and meets the highest standards of professionalism. Increased training
effectiveness would lead to better performance outcomes.
The model is highly imperative and critical part of the training and development
process. It helps in tracking the progress and measurement success. As a learning
professional, one needs to be proactive showing results which are reliable.
Though there are several ways benefitted by using the best practices, but the
important thing is there has to be awareness of the role of every function as it helps to
not only maximise human talent but optimally utilising the potential .Also by having a
holistic view, the work team can identify and solve performance gaps which can save
the organisation a considerable amount of time and money. Then Analysis, Design,
Development, Implementation, Evaluation (ADDIE) is described by American Society
for Training and Development (ASTD) which is the most widely known and used
instructional design framework helping the professional to design and deliver the most
effective training solutions .
The e-learning design components of learning also play an important role in
reaching a wide audience and developing new training quickly and cost effectively as
it saves time on travel, time out of office etc. Organisations need to take decisions to
analyze where the effort and energy will have significant impact and implement such a
strategy that ensures effective training. Globalisation, demographic changes, new
technologies and economic changes are several of the forces that influence all aspects
of our lives like how we learn, communicate and what we value in our lives and
on the job. These are forces which are affecting individuals, communities, business
and society. In order to sustain, companies need to address these forces with training
playing an important role. Today, more and more companies are interested in
intangible assets and human capital as a way to gain an advantage over competitors.
Training and development plays a major role in contributing to companies,
competitiveness by directly increasing their value through contributing intangible
assets. For example IBM has adopted an on demand business strategy that requires the
company to quickly respond to customer’s needs and help them do the same for their
606 Dr. Aliya Sultana

clients. IBM had to transform itself to be competitive and convince potential clients
that its technology would make their business more successful. IBM requires its
training to be more personalized, collaborative, work based and integrated.

5. Suggestions
 It is essential that the management philosophy should include, inter alia, the
importance of training and development on a continual basis in its vision. It is
not possible to achieve the benefit of training and development without a
serious attention of the management.
 The management should set out its goal towards improving the productivity,
efficiency of its workforce with ease and contentment based on the rules of the
management. The training and development program should be structured with
clarity and lucid interpretations. The components of the training and
development program should be listed in the flow chart model and each
component should be described with its details and assigning the individual
responsibility to the trainers team.
 The employees undergoing the T & D program should be sensitized for a
serious effort to learn. The job for efficient performance and delivering the
output with enhanced productivity and efficiency should be set out at the initial
stage of the program.
 The employees should be made clear the purpose of the program and the output
expected from them which could be quantified for the betterment and education
of their status.
 At the end of the programme, the assessment and evaluation of the individual
employees is essential to gauge the depth of learning and desire to apply at
their normal workplace.
 The process of evaluation and assessment should continue to confirm the
effectiveness of the programme. A feedback from the workforce and the
management should be placed in a structured form for further improvement of
the design and delivery of the programme. The trainers should design the
feedback which could eventually quantify the benefits of the programme and
the contribution of the employees who have undergone training

References

[1] Tanuja Aggarwala ,”Strategic Human Resource Management”,Oxford

University Press,2007.
[2] Dr, B, Rattan Reddy, “Effective Human Resource Training and Development
Strategy”,Himalaya Publishing House, Edition (2009).
Training and Development - Issues in the Indian Context 607

[3] R.Krishnaveni, “Human Resource Development-A researcher’s

Perspective”,Excel books, 2008.
[4] Ravi Mishra, “Is Training only meant to entertain”,Human capital,Vol.16
No.9,Feb,2009.
[5] Donald L. Kirkpatrick and James D. Kirkpatrick “Evaluating training
Programs”, Tata Mc Graw Hill,Edition 2008,pp42.
[6] “The Ten Commandments of Training”,Human Capital, Sep.2013.
[7] Alok S Bhattacharya, “The Mantra in Strategic Training: Learner-centred,
Performance-Based”, Indian Journal of Training and Development, Vol
XXXVIII No.4, October- December, 2008.
[8] P.N.Sing, “Training for management Development” ,Indian society for
Training and development,Sixth Edition,1999.
608 Dr. Aliya Sultana