Comparison of wp2 Submission Draft wp2 Final
Comparison of wp2 Submission Draft wp2 Final
Smith
Writing 2
Smith¶
April 19 2020¶
Barred from their loved ones who are barely surviving poverty.¶
There’s this lack of community and need for mass scrutiny on the American System.¶
And NEVER look them in the eyes because that just might make them lose it
You see when they look at you they don’t see a life,
Or feel
George Floyd, Ahmaud Arbery, Brionna Taylor, Eric Gardener, Philando Castile
Stolen from their loved ones who are barely surviving poverty.
There’s this lack of community and need for mass scrutiny on the American System.
Because why does it take 7 YEARS to become a lawyer but a few months to become an officer
Black:
Black or White.
The blood of Ahmad Arberyour Black Brothers and sisters is of the same tone as John F.
Racism depicts blackness as a weapon and those who brandish it are prosecuted;
For when a black man puts on his show it's his only claim to relevance.
It'sAs if letting jackie robinson ball was supposed to cover up the years of oppression and
suffering;
To grow up as the indecent, crime seeking stereotypes they are painted to be.
Because when I say “Black Man” paint a picture of what you see;¶
And deeply analyze his features and reflect on how your personal depiction came to be. ¶
Ethan George¶
Writing 2¶
Smith¶
April 19 2020¶
Self-Reflective Essay¶
My inspiration behind this poem came from my black studies class. We went over an
abundance of topicsIf it wasn't recorded that white cop would still be walking free
NO JUSTICE, NO PEACE
Ethan George
Writing 2
Smith
April 19 2020
Self-Reflective Essay
My inspiration behind this poem came from the abundance of issues the America has
been facing in these past few weeks.There is absolutely no way that I could sit and be indifferent
to the injustices brought among the black community. The recent murder of George Floyd was
the tip of the ice berg for African Americans in the sense that our call to be heard has not been
respected. The list of black bodies murdered unarmed or without clear reason is continuing to
grow as families continue to suffer and beg for change in this country. It is evident that our
current president uses black tragedy as a publicity stunt while setting in motion to support the
criminalization and murder of African American protestors. I am personally disgusted at the fact
that the country we live in doesn’t accept people who look like me solely because of our skin
color. There is no way that I could sit back and stay silent during a time where our voices need to
be heard the most. People need to be educated on black history and learn about the important
ideas that traditional history classes failedfail to cover. Although the poem was originally based
on a peer reviewed article in the black studies department on how white reporters address
controversial black injustices in the media, it has grown to be much more than that. The poem
has become a voice to the hundred of thousands of black people affected by the wrongs of police
brutality. Although my original intent was to uphold the boundaries of the translation
assignment, my passion drove me to do more and create a piece that could be felt by those who
The peer reviewed article addressed the different ways that news outlets depict racial
conflicts. It explained how large news companies often undermine the gravity of serious racial
issues. The journal analyzed how undermining subjects like police brutality and other white on
black crime is a form of disenfranchisement of the black community. It emphasizes how the
media depicted the war on drugs as necessary for a safer nation when, in reality, it
disproportionately convicted African Americans. Problems like this one are the reason I want to
be more educated on black history. I want to be able to identify passive oppression and express it
in an educated way. Although I didn’t translate the exact examples used in the journal, I took the
theme and added my own references to it. The goal was to expose a blunt reality of the racial
inequality that the news media tried to suppress. I used poetry as a medium to redirect the
educational article into a piece that evokes real feelings and encourages deep introspection
The poem circulates around America’s history of police brutality and unjustified
MURDER of unarmed black men and women who, in most cases, hardly committed any crime. I
added the origins of the American police force to shed light on how the organization was never
truly to protect and promote equality. I learned in my black studies class that the first constables
were appointed to look over and punish slaves in their attempts to escape their masters or form
revolution. These constables had no problem exerting brute force on slaves or even hanging them
or burning them alive to use them as examples for the rest of the slave community. I see no
difference today. Black people are being KILLED for standing up for their own rights. I truly
believe that police officers are using black bodies as examples because it seems as if those who
stand up and fight against this crooked system are beat down or slaughtered. Martin Luther King
Jr. was assassinated under this same ideology. They killed him for his attempts to create equality
and peace among the people. I don’t justify the violent acts that are being done to innocent cities
and small businesses, however, the rioting and violence have worked historically. After MLK
was assassinated, there was a massive revolt. Rioting and destroying of property all across the
South was a reflection of the anger built up in the black community. On the sixth day of those
riots, the Civil rights act was passed. I see complete resemblance with what is going on today.
Although there are definitely people taking advantage of our movement, those who are truly
affected by the wrongs of police brutality and racism are completely justified in their hatred
towards the American system. I can also say that this form of protest has the potential to be very
effective being that America values its economy more than it values human lives. We saw this in
president Trump’s efforts to invalidate the threat of the coronavirus and reopen the country much
too quickly. Protestors are making a point to put a dent in the American economy, forcing the
I believe that spoken word poetry is one of the most powerful forms of writing in the
sense that each word is cleverly chosen to hold weight. In this case, the audience was white
America. This poem is a call for those who aren’t even aware of their personal microaggressions
or their role in the modern racism black people are victims of. It's a call for the reader to hold
themselves accountable rather than feel badIt is also a call to community. Those who were under
my voice in protest felt the same pain I was feeling. Though my audience was extremely diverse,
the art of spoken word poetry allowed people from every background to be able to feel my
message and hear my voice. It's a call for EVERYONE to hold themselves and this country
accountable.
The primary document I drew information from used Trayvon Martin and Laquan
McDonald as examples of the recent injustices done against the black community and
downplayed by the media. Instead of using these same examples, I used the killing of Ahmad
Arbery. It is akillings of George Floyd and Ahmaud Arbery and referenced the abundance of
other black lives stolen at the hands of racist police and citizens.These are very recent
exampleexamples of how the racist American culture still exists to this day. The original title of
the poem was the title of theheading of a New York Times article about the killing of Ahmaud
Arbery. Not once in the article did it emphasize the significance of Arbery being a middle aged
black man stalked, provoked, and killed by two white men nor that the reason given for calling
the police on him was that Ahmad was “a black man running through our neighborhood.” This is
a perfect example of how the media takes away the gravity of the bigger picture. How it
undermines racial issues and almost supports the antiblack culture. I changed the title to the
trending hashtag #NoJusticeNoPeace in light of the even more recent murder of George Floyd.
The fact that I started this assignment prioritizing one controversial injustice against the black
community and must update it to add even more recent injustices is the very reason I felt like this
I chose this conflict because it hits very close to me. I felt like I could take the formal
message that was presented to an audience of academic researchers and put it into something that
can have an affect on anyone who reads it. I left out a lot of the specific historical context and
included more general conflicts that I felt the general body of America could have knowledge
offrom the article and included content that would move the people and promote the protest. For
example, I didn’t need to mention the civil rights activists fighting for racial equality even
though the article goes into deep historical context about the Black Panther movement. Instead I
referenced that “racism depicts blackness as a weapon”. This refers to the hundreds of black
activists killed or jailed for expressing their disbelief in the American government to provide
racial equality. I triedused words like “body cam” and made multiple references to police to
emphasize their role in this mayhem. I added the word “disenfranchisement” allude to the ideas
presented by, black activist, W.E.B. Du Bois. I used this specific language and word choice to
paint as vivid of a picture as possible because spoken word poetry is supposed to make
individuals feel something. It's hard to empathize with things that you don’t see or understand.
Providing general trends and situations that areas well as aggressive descriptions of sensitive
topics make the theme easy to understand and allow the reader to havecreate their own personal
The main challenge of the genre translation was finding a genre that could reproduce the
theme of the original work in its entirety. It is quite obvious that a comedy piece or a science
fiction story would be difficult genres to preach the ideas of social injustice on a serious note.
Poetry was the perfect outlet to me in the sense that it could be generalized to any audience who
One thing I figured out about the genre of academic writing in black history is that, as a
black man who can sympathize with the social injustices brought up in a lot of these writings, it's
hard to keep my personal feelings away from the academics of a subject. When reading the
original text, I could feel the sensitivity of the subject and I wasn’t sure that I could translate the
article without including my personal feelings and biases toward it. However, poetry is a place
where you find new ways to express your feelings and say what you need to say. I I was able to
address the social issues brought up in the article and add some of my own thoughts and feelings
through the poetic structuregive my all and empty as much feeling and thought into the work to
I also learned that even though different genres have different principles or expectations,
the beauty of writing comes with creativity. You can write whatever you want and feel however
you want to feel. No one can tell you what hurts you and what doesn’t. No one can tell you how
to feel or interpret situations. When I was writing this poem, I didn’t try to supress my thoughts.
I portrayed my thoughts and feelings in a way I felt was necessary. It's my writing therefore it's
under my influence and stems from my own personal experiences. The poem is a compilation
of view points I feel like I have observed and experienced and it was written the way it was
written to promote empathy and shared pain as well as evoke anger and discomfort with the
situation. However, it is my feelings and interpretation coming from my experiences which are
The main thing I had to keep in mind was keeping the information in the poem relevant
to the information in the article. Because this is a topic I know a lot about, I found myself
veering in different directions and bringing up other themes that were not presented in the
original article. Because of this, I often had to go back and reflect on if I was translating
information or adding my own thoughts. This happened multiple times. In the revised poem, I let
loose of the main ties to the article and went in on the true injustices and problems going on
today. I felt like these issues were far more presently relevant than those of the article. I couldn’t
focus on solely the ideas in the original journal without bringing up the conflicts affecting
EVERYONE today.
Because the original journal article was NOT a poem, I had to find ways to take the main
points of the article and rephrase it in a way that wasn’t as informative but sought to appeal to
emotion. For example, the original text references Ronald Reagans’s war on drugs and explained
how it led to the mass incarceration of many African Americans, leaving families devastated. In
brought up how these criminalizations affect the ability to find a decent job. This cycle leaves
people unemployed and back on the streets. I used phrases like “BarredStolen from their loved
ones” and “kids grow up in the streets” to paint a picture of the injustice the article was
addressing. The phrase makes you imagine kids whose fathers were killed or locked up for years
following in their footsteps selling drugs because they can’t afford school andor can’t find a job.
Instead of just educating the reader on the situation, this makes them feel it directly. This form of
rephrasing and manipulation of words adds feelings to the work. The poem feels like it was
written by someone who cares deeply about the conflict whereas the article was written as more
In its entirety, this poem came from me and my personal feelings. I couldn’t focus on
anything these past couple of weeks while being constantly reminded of the hell that this country
is breaking into. I can’t focus on chemistry or math when my people are being murdered. When
my own mother fears for my life every time I go to a grocery store. I shouldn’t have to protest
for my rights as a black man in America and I shouldn’t have to risk not coming home to my