Applications of Accounting Software: An Empirical Study On The Private Universities of Bangladesh
Applications of Accounting Software: An Empirical Study On The Private Universities of Bangladesh
net/publication/301887537
CITATIONS READS
0 5,136
4 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Corporate Social Responsibility Reporting Practices by Listed Multinational Companies in Bangladesh View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohammad Afjalur Rahman on 05 May 2016.
1. Introduction
Accounting Information Systems has become a part and parcel of day today‟s life. For sound
management of an entity the use of accounting information has been increasing day by day.
Once it was possible to maintain only paper works of the transaction when the number of
transactions and users of accounting information was limited to the boundary that could be
managed manually. With rapid technological development, the nature of business and
transactions has become more complex than it was ever. Since accounting information is
repetitive in nature and high in volume it could not be maintained manually and cost-
effectively. The number of users of accounting information has also grown remarkably. In order
to communicate organization‟s information to the interested parties, there was a quest for such
a solution that can process and disclose data in more sophisticated ways (Carlton,1999). To
this, business fraternity found the solution in automation of the data recording process through
accounting software (Deshmmukh, 2006).From small shop to large companies accounting
software has become a solution to manual system of maintaining bulk amount of paper works
(Ryan, 2012). Simply Accounting Software (AS) is a kind of information systems. Accounting
software which has become an invaluable resource for modern business can be defined as
computer programs that allow detail tracking of financial transactions and provide instant
report and analysis of a firm (Wikipedia,2007; Investopedia, 2013). A good accounting
software can put a business in control. There are wide variety of accounting software
depending on the nature of business of the users of accounting software but common principle
here is that all of them are based on „Double Entry” principle of Accounting (SME Financial
Systems, 2010). When talking about advantages of accounting software, accountants admit
that uses of accounting software has freed them from manual recording and presentation of
transactions and it subsequently reduces time and cost (Musa, 2004). It has been showed in
(Carlton, 1999; Fisher and Fisher, 2001) that by improving the quantity and quality of
management information, use of accounting software has increased overall operational
effectiveness.
The present study is an endeavor to explore the extent to which private universities in
Bangladesh uses accounting software to record their transactions in an automated way.
Private universities in Bangladesh have shown a tremendous growth over the last decade
(Masum, Kabir and Bhuyan, 2013). Private universities in Bangladesh has passed more than
two decades by their own credentials and also it is playing a great role in the national economy
by saving 100 thousand crore taka every year in terms of foreign exchange which is almost 60
percent of our budget by attracting „O‟ and „A‟ level students (Billah,2013). In a private
university the accounts department has to keep an individual student‟s account for about 4
years in case of Bachelor program and 2 years in case of Masters program. Moreover, the
accounting system in a service organization like universities is quite different from other types
of organizations. Hence, it is of utmost importance to apply the right sort of accounting
technique. In this regard, well developed software can play an important role to keep proper
accounting record which motivated the authors to take an initiative to explore the applications
of accounting software in private universities and obstacles need to be overcome to make it a
success. The study also attempted to identify the problems and prospects of using accounting
software. The study used a five scale Likert technique to investigate the interviewees‟ opinions
about the application of accounting software in the respective universities as well as to find the
cause of differences between actual and expected level of use of accounting software. The
results of the study is different from other studies in the sense that researches have conducted
about the applications of computer aided technologies in different fields but no research has
been found in Bangladesh about the applications of accounting software. The study revealed
that almost 80% private universities are now using accounting software. It is revealed that
73
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
100% of the respondents think maintaining record in accounting software is easier than
manual systems, 97.87% of the respondents think chance of error and difficulties in identifying
errors is much less in accounting software and 100% of the respondents showed their opinion
in favor of accounting software that it is faster to apply. The remaining portions of this paper
are devised as follows: The next section includes review of relevant literatures. Section three
expresses the objectives of the study. Section four provides details of the research methods
applied in this study. Section five reveals details of findings and analysis of the study and
section six summarizes the findings and draw conclusion of the study.
2. Literature Review
Though use of accounting software has been increasing day by day, there are a few literatures
available in the research field concerning the application of accounting software among which
most of them related to technical discussion of different module of accounting software.
Deshmukh (2006) in his book “Digital Accounting: The Effects of the Internet and ERP on
Accounting” described the historical evolution of accounting software, where he argued that
difficulties in maintaining data manually and cost effectively forces the emergence of
accounting software. In different researches it is argued that accounting software packages
increase overall operational effectiveness by improving both the quantity and quality of
management information available (Collins, 1999; Fisher and Fisher, 2001; and Abu-Musa,
2004). Jones (2002) stated that as computers became more robust and integrated databases
are more standardized, accounting software developers are now adding more functions-
including cost accounting, manufacturing resource planning, customer resource management,
human resources, and payroll. Henry (1997) in his study “A Study of the Nature and Security
of Accounting Information Systems: The Case of Hampton Roads”, mentioned that, the steady
decline in the price of information technology and the increasing availability of off the shelf
accounting software have led more and more businesses of any size to automate all or part of
their accounting functions. Although accounting software provide many benefits, inherent
computer security issues are not often addressed by management as many organizations do
not realize the importance of computer security until some unauthorized modification to a
payroll file, or some other events, occur (West and Zoladz, 1993). In recent researches it is
evident that, nowadays, financial organizations are searching for accounting software as by
using accounting software organizations can achieve maximum throughput with minimum
resources because accounting software can accelerate business operations with great
performance (Shields, 2011). Gold Berg (2010) revealed in his study that uses of accounting
software over the paper ledger results in benefits for the organization such as ease of use,
backup, ready information, secure storage, and replication of records.
In his study Deshmukh (2002) explored that business' accounting software can provide real-
time support for the creation of web-based storefronts and electronic data interchange. Real-
time connectivity with the accounting system can enhance forecasting, scheduling,
manufacturing, and procurement functions. Changes to inventory or pricing can be made
instantaneously. The back-end systems can check and approve credit for new customers, or
support an online service that does so. Gurton (2001) argued that power and ease of use are
no longer the only criteria for selecting an accounting system. Ease of use is still important but
compatibility has increased in importance, too. Mattingly (2001) stated that choosing the right
74
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
accounting software is becoming more difficult as the software market becomes increasingly
fragmented. In many cases, more product information makes decision-making more difficult
rather than less. Basile, Louis and Randy (2002) explored most business owners in USA know
little about the accounting software packages available and have only rudimentary ideas about
how to evaluate the alternatives. Many owners rely on advice from retail store clerks,
recommendations from resellers, or national marketing campaigns as the primary basis for
their selections. In Bangladesh some works have been done regarding the applications of
computer aided modern technology in different sectors. For example, Kabir (2013) explored
the applications of mobile technology in banking sector, Masum, Kabir and Bhuyan (2013)
identified the applications of HRIS in Private Universities in Bangladesh and revealed that it
plays an important role in recruitment and selection, training & development and payroll
administration in private universities. It also explored that there is a gap between the expected
and actual application of HRIS the main reasons of which are lack of infrastructural
development, high cost and insufficient training. It is important to mention that no such
research has been conducted about the applications of accounting software yet in
Bangladesh. Thus, the study aims at exploring the application of accounting software in
Bangladesh and the constraints in its application.
The conducted study is empirical in nature. It aimed at exploring the application of accounting
software in service oriented organization like universities.
The population of the study is the government and UGC (University Grants Commission)
approved private universities in Bangladesh. 47 universities out of 76 universities which is
61.84% of all private universities approved by UGC (University Grants Commission) up to
2013, has been considered for this study on a random basis.
The data for the study has been collected over the period from September 10, 2013 to
November 05, 2013. Data for the study were collected through structured questionnaire from
the accountants of the selected private universities. Thus, the nature of the data is primary.
75
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
The data collected for the study was analyzed by the statistical software called SPSS-20.
Simple statistical tools like, frequency distribution, percentile etc. were applied to highlight to
what extend accounting software is being practiced and the perceptions of accountants about
the necessity of accounting software and the factors behind making decisions whether to apply
accounting software.
The below frequency table shows that out of 47 private universities surveyed 38 (80.85%)
universities are applying accounting software in recording their transactions and only 9
universities are not using accounting software and the percentage is 19.15.
The following table represents the status of software training provided to accountants by the
organizations which applied accounting software for maintaining accounts.
76
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
The table 1(a) specifies that total 38 universities applied accounting software among which
26(68.42%) universities provide special training on accounting software for their account
personnel. On the other hand 12 (31.58%) universities do not provide any such training
although having accounting software.
The study results in table 2 show that all the respondents agreed about difficulties in recording
transactions in the traditional accounting system. 46 (97.87%) respondents think the chance of
error and difficulties in identifying error are more in recording transactions in manual/traditional
accounting systems and only 1 (2.13%) respondents think that chance of error and difficulties
in identifying errors is less in manual/traditional accounting systems of recording. 47 (100%)
respondents give their opinion in favor of accounting software that it is faster to apply. The
special utilities that accounting software provides are easy maintenance of accounts, chances
of error is less, easy to identify errors and faster to apply.
Table 3 reveals the main reasons why private universities still rely on manual accounting
systems are management‟s reluctance, employee‟s reluctance and initial cost. Among the
above causes the highest priority has been given on reluctance of management to apply
accounting software as 65.96% of the respondents think that the hindrance to implement
accounting software or automated accounting record systems is authority‟s negligence.53.19%
of the respondents think reluctance of employees is another barrier to apply accounting
77
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
software. Another influencing factor in deciding whether to apply accounting software is its
initial cost. 46.81% of the respondents think it will create huge cost to introduce accounting
software.
The table above shows the responses from the accountants about the question regarding
security concern in using accounting software in which 37 (78.72%) respondents showed their
response in favor of accounting software that it is secured to apply among which 4 (8.51%)
respondents think it is secured and 33 (70.21%) think it is fully secured, only 4.26 %
respondents think it is insecure and 17.02 % made no comment in this aspect.
The table 5 shows the responses from accountants about easiness of the accounting software.
From the table we see that none of the respondents think it is difficult to use the functions of
accounting software. 42 respondents (89.36%) respondents think the functions of accounting
software is easy among which 61.70 % think it is very easy to use and 27.66% think it is easy
to use, while 10.64% remains away from giving any opinion.
78
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
The table 6 represents the perceptions of the accountants about the scope recovery of lost
data in using accounting software in which we see that 25 (53.19%) respondents think it is
very easy to recover the lost data and 14(29.79%) think it is easy to recover the lost data in
accounting software. Only 2 (4.26%) respondents think it is difficult to recover lost data among
which the percentage of respondents in both cases is 2.13 respectively.
The study table above shows mixed reaction from the respondents about possibilities of
fraudulence in using accounting software. Among the respondents 20 (42.55%) thinks
fraudulence is impossible in using accounting software. On the other hand 11 respondents
think there are possibilities of fraudulence. Among which 19.15% think there are possibilities
and 4.26% think there are highly possibilities of fraudulence in using accounting software.16
(34.04%) respondents did not give any comment.
79
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
The table 8 shows the responses of the accounting personnel about the un-employment threat
due to use of the accounting software. 27(57.44%) respondents disagreed on this aspect
among which 40.42% showed their responses as strongly disagree and 17.02% showed their
response as disagree. The percentage of respondents remained neutral on this matter is 21.28
and 10 (21.28%) respondents‟ think the use of accounting software is a threat to un-
employment among which 10.64% agreed with this factor and 10.64% strongly agreed with
this factor.
The present study aims at finding to what extent accounting software is being used by the
private universities in Bangladesh. The study revealed that almost 80% private universities are
now using accounting software. So we can say the level of application of accounting software
is satisfactory in private universities. Major influencing factors in consideration to decide on
going automated accounting systems are reluctance of management, reluctance of
employees‟ and initial cost. The result of the study shows that 100% of the respondents think
maintaining record in accounting software is easier than manual systems, 97.87% of the
respondents think chance of error and difficulties in identifying errors is much less in
accounting software and 100% of the respondents showed their opinion in favor of accounting
software that it is faster to apply. The study unfold some interesting findings which are different
from other studies in the sense that researches have conducted about the applications of
computer aided technologies in different fields but no research has been found in Bangladesh
about the applications of accounting software. It revealed that 78.72% accountants think it is
secured to apply accounting software, 89.36% of the respondents think functions of accounting
software is easily understandable, 82.98% of the respondents think recovery of lost data is
easy in accounting software. Mixed reactions have been shown regarding fraudulence
possibilities in using accounting software.42.55% of the respondents denied the fact that
fraudulence is possible in using accounting software whereas 23.41% of the respondents think
there are possibilities of fraudulence and 34.04% remained neutral about this. When we see
the following figures, the opinions of the accounting personnel regarding threat of employment
80
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
due to application of accounting software also represented a mixed reactions where 57.44%
disagreed with this statement, 21.28% remained neutral and 21.28% agreed with this
statement. The study also revealed a surprising matter that while having accounting software
in practice some of the universities do not provide any special training on accounting software
and almost 36% of the accounts personnel doesn‟t have academic background on accounting
discipline.
The authors have identified a few limitations which should be bear in mind in using the
findings of the study. Firstly, the study focuses on accounting software application of the
private universities only. Secondly, the study does not consider public and international
universities. Furthermore, it was mainly based on perceptions of the accounting personnel.
Considering the limitations mentioned above the study recommends the following areas of
application of accounting software for conducting further research such as, Application of
Accounting Software in both public and private universities, Application of Accounting Software
in different industries in Bangladesh. To get the real scenario further study also required to
observe comparative analysis of application of Accounting Software in different companies of
Bangladesh.
References
Basile, A, Louis, P& Randy, J 2002, „Leading High-End Accounting Software‟, The CPA
Journal, vol. 72, no. 5
Billah, M2013, Private Universities Now, The Daily Star, June 06, 2013.Available at
http://www.thedailystar.net/beta2/news/private-universities-now/(viewed on November
14,2013)
Carlton, CJ 1999,„How to Select the Right Accounting Software‟, Journal of Accountancy, vol.
188, no. 3,pp. 61-69
81
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
82
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
Appendix: Questionnaire
Questionnaire On:
1. Name: ………………………………………………….
Yes No
83
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
Yes No
Yes No
16. Why do you think using accounting software is a problem? (You may tick as many as you
think suitable)
17. Do you think that the use of accounting software is a threat to security? (Put a tick)
18. The functions of accounting software are easy to use. (Put a tick)
84
Kabir, Rahman, Yunus & Chowdhury
19. There are difficulties in recovery of lost data in accounting software. (Put a tick)
20. There are possibilities of fraudulence in using accounting software. (Put a tick)
85