Abusag Bridge Project: Structural Calculation For The Proposed Sheet Pile
Abusag Bridge Project: Structural Calculation For The Proposed Sheet Pile
ABUSAG BRIDGE PROJECT
STRUCTURAL CALCULATION FOR THE
PROPOSED SHEET PILE
October 17, 2019
RAYMOND R. ESTO
STRUCTURAL ENGINEER
PRC NO. 0108100
ITEM: ABUSAG BRIDGE Design: LRP Date: 10/17/2019
PART: DESIGN OF RETAINING WALL WITH TIE BACK Check: RRE
1.0 Reference:
1.1 AASHTO
1.2 Principles of Geotechnical Engineering
Lateral Earth Pressure Surcharge (Earth) Surcharge (Live Load) Wall Inertia Earthquake
1.5 m 1.0 m
Tie Rod 1 2.1 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 2 2.1 m
8.20 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 3 2.1 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 4
1.5 m 1.0 m
3.1.5 Earthquake
a = 0.40 acceleration coefficient
kh = 0.38 horizontal seismic coefficient
kv = 0 vertical seismic coefficient
θ = 20.81
KAE = 0.70 dynamic soil pressure coefficient
PAE = 97.7 kPa , (1-kv)yKae (hsoil)
PAE(H) = 91.8 kPa , PAE cos δ yAE(H) = 2.73 m ywall =
PAE(V) = 33.4 kPa , PAE sin δ
3.2 Load Factors
Lateral Earth Pressure Surcharge (Earth) Surcharge (Live Load) Wall Inertia Earthquake
1.5 m 1.0 m
2.03333
Tie Rod 1 2.1 m
1.7 m
2.06667
Tie Rod 2 2.1 m
8.20 m
1.7 m
2.06667
Tie Rod 3 2.1 m
1.7 m
1.53333
Tie Rod 4
1.5 m 1.0 m
0.5
ground surface 29 kPa 4.3 kPa 5.2 kPa 7.8 kPa 91.8 kPa
Trod1 = 332.29 kN
req = 23.83 mm
Trod = 431.01 kN
req = 27.14 mm
Trod = 431.01 kN
req = 27.14 mm
3.4.4 Tie Rod4 Force Calculation
Trod = 273.89 kN
req = 21.63 mm
R = 18 kN/m
Qpass = 47 kPa
Dreq = 0.87 m
Lateral Earth Pressure Surcharge (Earth) Surcharge (Live Load) Wall Inertia Earthquake
1.0 m
1.5 m 1.0 m
0.5
Tie Rod 1 2.1 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 2 2.1 m
8.20 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 3 2.1 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 4
1.5 m 1.0 m
CASE 1: MOMENT BETWEEN TIE ROD 1 &2
Lateral Earth Pressure Surcharge (Earth) Surcharge (Live Load) Wall Inertia Earthquake
1.0 m
1.5 m 1.0 m
1.033
Tie Rod 1 2.1 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 2 2.1 m
8.20 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 3 2.1 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 4
1.5 m 1.0 m
CASE 2: MOMENT BETWEEN TIE ROD 2 &3
Lateral Earth Pressure Surcharge (Earth) Surcharge (Live Load) Wall Inertia Earthquake
1.0 m
1.5 m 1.0 m
Tie Rod 1 2.1 m
3.100
1.7 m
Tie Rod 2 2.1 m
8.20 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 3 2.1 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 4
1.5 m 1.0 m
CASE 3: MOMENT BETWEEN TIE ROD 3 & 4
Lateral Earth Pressure Surcharge (Earth) Surcharge (Live Load) Wall Inertia Earthquake
1.0 m
1.5 m 1.0 m
Tie Rod 1 2.1 m
1.7 m
5.167
Tie Rod 2 2.1 m
8.20 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 3 2.1 m
1.7 m
Tie Rod 4
1.5 m 1.0 m
Load Combination ES LS ACTIVE WALL INER. EQ Tie Rod1 Tie Rod2 Tie Rod3 Moment
STR Ia 121 kN-m/m 172 kN-m/m 1072 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m -623 kN-m/m -497 kN-m/m -203 kN-m/m 42 kN-m/m
STR Ib 121 kN-m/m 172 kN-m/m 1072 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m -623 kN-m/m -497 kN-m/m -203 kN-m/m 42 kN-m/m
STR IV 121 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m 1072 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m -537 kN-m/m -442 kN-m/m -181 kN-m/m 33 kN-m/m
EXT Ia 0 kN-m/m 49 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m 148 kN-m/m 1477 kN-m/m -755 kN-m/m -619 kN-m/m -253 kN-m/m 47 kN-m/m
EXT Ib 40 kN-m/m 49 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m 148 kN-m/m 1477 kN-m/m -775 kN-m/m -632 kN-m/m -259 kN-m/m 49 kN-m/m
SER I 81 kN-m/m 99 kN-m/m 472 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m 0 kN-m/m -299 kN-m/m -235 kN-m/m -96 kN-m/m 21 kN-m/m
∅
= 4.12
0.85 ′ 2
1 1 = 0.01076
0.85 ′
0.85 ′ 3
8 = 0.02156 SINGLY
As = 1291 mm2
N = 6.4192 pcs
S = 150 mm o.c.
Temp Bars
= 0.0018
At = 432 mm2
N = 3.8197 pcs
S = 250 mm o.c.
Shear
R = 83 kN
Vc = 91 kN
Vc/2 = 45 kN
Vs = 83 kN
Vbar = 25 kN
N = 4 pcs
S = 400 mm o.c.
Deflection
w = 104 kN/m
E = 27806 MPa
I = 315000000 mm3
= 1.016 mm
allow = 3.333 mm
ITEM: ABUSAG BRIDGE Design: LRP Date: 10/17/2019
PART: SHEET PILE DESIGN - PRESTRESSED (Hp= 2.1m) Check: RRE Date: 10/17/2019
1.1 Reference:
1.2 Geometry
Depth of embedment (Design) D = 4.56 m *Addt'l 15% to have 1.5 to 2 factor of safety
Sheet pile length (Design) SPL = 6.66 m
1.4 Stability
Static
1.4.1 ∑F=0
13.53 + 8.22 + 190.05 + 178.85Zp - 366.48 = 0
ZP = 0.86 m
1.4.2 ∑MF=0
78.88 + 56.37 + 159.13 + 44.60 - 488.64 + 147.31 = -2.36
Dynamic
1.4.3 ∑F=0
19.74 + 8.59 + 234.29 + 190.19Zp - 476.28 = 0
ZP = 1.12 m
1.4.4 ∑MF=0
114.75 + 60.40 + 206.81 + 80.01 - 723.94 + 218.24 = -43.73
Transverse bars:
Concrete shear capacity Vc = 339.76 kN Vdesign = 67.71 kNm
Ties spacing S = 75.00 mm
No. of legs N = 6.00
Shear reinf. Area Av = 471.24 mm2
Reinf. Shear capacity Vs = 682.51 kN
Shear capacity Vcap = 766.70 kN > Vdesign Okay
ITEM: ABUSAG BRIDGE Design: LRP Date: 10/17/2019
PART: SHEET PILE DESIGN - PRESTRESSED (Hp= 2.1m) Check: RRE Date: 10/17/2019
1.8.3 Minimum confinement
Minimum spacing at ductile region, s = 90.00 mm
hc = 700.00 mm
Ag = 360000.00 mm2
Ach = 255600.00 mm2
P = 65.56 kN
2
Ash1 = 467.87 mm > Vs Okay
2
Ash2 = 458.19 mm > Vs Okay
REFERENCES
1. National Structural Code of the Philippines 2010 6th Edition
2. PCI Design Handbook 6th Edition
3. Design of Prestressed Concrete Structures 3rd Edition Si Version by T.Y. Lin and Ned H. Burns
dp1,
Fp1
b h
np1 dp1 np2 dp2
dp2,
A 800 400 7 56 7 344
B 800 400 7 56 7 344
h,
C 800 400 7 56 7 344
D 800 400 7 56 7 344
E 800 400 7 56 7 344
MATERIAL PROPERTIES
Structural Concrete Reinforcing Steel Bar
Precast Beam ###### - ###### = Grade 40 or 276.00 MPa
after transfer of prestressing force (at release) ###### - ###### = Grade 60 or 414.00 MPa
compressive strength, f'ci = 27.60 MPa modulus of elasticity, Es = 200,000 MPa
modulus of elasticity, Eci = 27,606.25 MPa
during erection (construction stage) Prestressing Steel Strands
compressive strength, f'c1 = 34.50 MPa prestressing type: Grade 270 low-relaxation strand LR
modulus of elasticity, Ec1 = 27,606.25 MPa ultimate tensile strength, fpu = 1,860.00 MPa
at service condition yield strength, fpy = 0.9fpu = 1,674.00 MPa
compressive strength, f'c2 = 34.50 MPa modulus of elasticity, Eps = 195,000 MPa
modulus of elasticity, Ec2 = 27,606.25 MPa nominal area of strands, Aps = 98.71 mm2
In-situ deck jacking stress, fj = 1,395.00 MPa
compressive strength, f'c3 = 27.60 MPa
modulus of elasticity, Ec3 = 24,691.78 MPa
DESIGN PARAMETERS
Reinforcing Steel Bar
bar dia. main reinforcement, Øm = 25 mm Strength reduction factor, Φ
fym = 414.00 MPa for tension-controlled, Φt = 0.9
bar dia. stirrups, Øs = 10 mm for compression-controlled, Φc = 0.65
fys = 276.00 MPa for shear and torsion, Φs = 0.75
bar dia. web reinforcement, Øw = 10 mm
fyw = 276.00 MPa
Structural Concrete
unit weight of concrete, δc = 24.00 kN/m3
Ec3 / Ec2, nc = 0.894 L
C
β1 = 0.804
LOAD CASES
LOSSES IN PRESTRESS
Immediate losses
• due to elastic shortening of concrete, ES (immediate loss)
initial prestressing force, Po = (n p1 + n p2 ) f j A ps = 1,927,806.30 N
location of Pi from bottom, yp = h basic - (n p1 (d p1 - (h - h basic )) + n p2 (dp2 - (h - h basic )))/(n p1 + n p2 ) = 200.00 mm
eccentiricity, eb = h basic /2 - y = 0.00 mm Note: (+) if 'e' is below N.A. and (-) if 'e' is above N.A.
ES = K es f cir (E ps /E c1 )
2
fcir = K cir (P i /(bh basic ) + P i e b /I basic ) - M s e /I basic
Time-dependent losses
• due to shrinkage of concrete, SH (time-dependent loss)
V/S = bh/(2(b+h)) = 0.1333
-6
SH = 8.2x10 K sh E ps (1-0.06(V/S))(100-RH)
• due to creep of concrete, CR (time-dependent loss)
CR = K cr (E ps /E c1 )(f cir - f cds )
location of Pi from bottom, yf = h - (n p1 d p1 + n p2 d p2 )/(n p1 + n p2 ) = 200.00 mm
eccentiricity, ef = y tr,bot - y f = 0.00 mm
• due to relaxation of tendons, RE (time-dependent loss)
fpi = f j = 1,395.00 MPa
RE = (K re - J (SH + CR + ES)) C
value of C for stress-relieved strand or wire
1 + 9 (f pi /f pu - 0.7) for 0.75 ≥ f pi /f pu ≥ 0.70
(f pi /f pu ) (f pi /f pu )
C = - 0.55 for 0.70 > f pi /f pu ≥ 0.51 =
0.19 0.85
(f pi /f pu )/3.83 for f pi /f pu < 0.51
1.8 STRENGTH INTERACTION DIAGRAM
SECTION PROPERTIES
SECTION DIAGRAM
Section Dimension Steel Cover
b = 800.00mm SCb = 58.00mm
h = 450.00mm SCh = 58.00mm
Reinforcing Steel Bar
no. of steel bars along 'x' axis = 4
no. of steel bars along 'y' axis = 2
bar diameter, Øb = 16 mm
Prestressing Steel Strand
no. of prestressing steel = 14
prestressing strand diameter, Øps =
Minor Axis, y
12.70 mm
Hoop type Tied
MATERIAL PROPERTIES
Major Axis, x
Structural Concrete
min. compressive strength @ 28 days, f'c = 35.00 MPa
modulus of elasticity, Ec = 27,805.57 MPa
β = 0.8
Reinforcing Steel Bar
yield strength = 276.00 MPa ≤ 12
= 414.00 MPa ≥ 16
modulus of elasticity, Es = 200,000.00 MPa
min. yield strength, fy = 414.00 MPa
Prestressing Steel Strand
min. specified ultimate strength, fpu = 1,862.00 MPa
min. specified yield strength, fpy = 1,675.80 MPa
modulus of elasticity, Eps = 196,507.00 MPa
effective prestressing stress, fpe = 1,145.13 MPa
area of prestressing strand, Aps = 98.71 mm²
ITEM: ABUSAG BRIDGE Design: LRP Date: 10/17/2019
Reinforcing Steel Bar Details Prestressing Steel Strand Details
Rebar distance 'd' from extreme compression fiber Prestressing steel distance 'y' from extreme compression fiber
Bundled Bundled
## 1 d1 = 392.00 N = Ø = 16 ## 1 y1 = 392.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 2 d2 = 392.00 N = Ø = 16 ## 2 y2 = 392.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 3 d3 = 392.00 N = Ø = 16 ## 3 y3 = 392.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 4 d4 = 392.00 N = Ø = 16 ## 4 y4 = 392.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 5 d5 = 58.00 N = Ø = 16 ## 5 y5 = 392.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 6 d6 = 58.00 N = Ø = 16 ## 6 y6 = 392.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 7 d7 = 58.00 N = Ø = 16 ## 7 y7 = 392.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 8 d8 = 58.00 N = Ø = 16 ## 8 y8 = 108.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 9 d9 = N = Ø = ## 9 y9 = 108.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 10 d10 = N = Ø = ## 10 y10 = 108.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 11 d11 = N = Ø = ## 11 y11 = 108.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 12 d12 = N = Ø = ## 12 y12 = 108.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 13 d13 = N = Ø = ## 13 y13 = 108.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 14 d14 = N = Ø = ## 14 y14 = 108.00 N = Ø = 12.7
Bundled Bundled
## 15 d15 = N = Ø = ## 15 y15 = N = Ø =
Bundled Bundled
## 16 d16 = N = Ø = ## 16 y16 = N = Ø =
Bundled Bundled
## 17 d17 = N = Ø = ## 17 y17 = N = Ø =
Bundled Bundled
## 18 d18 = N = Ø = ## 18 y18 = N = Ø =
Bundled Bundled
## 19 d19 = N = Ø = ## 19 y19 = N = Ø =
Bundled Bundled
## 20 d20 = N = Ø = ## 20 y20 = N = Ø =
Bundled Bundled
## 21 d21 = N = Ø = ## 21 y21 = N = Ø =
Bundled Bundled
## 22 d22 = N = Ø = ## 22 y22 = N = Ø =
Bundled Bundled
## 23 d23 = N = Ø = ## 23 y23 = N = Ø =
Bundled Bundled
## 24 d24 = N = Ø = ## 24 y24 = N = Ø =
Area of reinforcement steel bar, mm² Area of prestressing steel strand, mm²
1 As1 = 201.06 1 Aps1 = 98.71
2 As2 = 201.06 2 Aps2 = 98.71
3 As3 = 201.06 3 Aps3 = 98.71
4 As4 = 201.06 4 Aps4 = 98.71
5 As5 = 201.06 5 Aps5 = 98.71
6 As6 = 201.06 6 Aps6 = 98.71
7 As7 = 201.06 7 Aps7 = 98.71
8 As8 = 201.06 8 Aps8 = 98.71
9 As9 = 9 Aps9 = 98.71
10 As10 = 10 Aps10 = 98.71
11 As11 = 11 Aps11 = 98.71
12 As12 = 12 Aps12 = 98.71
13 As13 = 13 Aps13 = 98.71
14 As14 = 14 Aps14 = 98.71
15 As15 = 15 Aps15 =
16 As16 = 16 Aps16 =
17 As17 = 17 Aps17 =
18 As18 = 18 Aps18 =
19 As19 = 19 Aps19 =
20 As20 = 20 Aps20 =
21 As21 = 21 Aps21 =
22 As22 = 22 Aps22 =
ITEM: ABUSAG BRIDGE Design: LRP Date: 10/17/2019
POINTS ON INTERACTION CURVE
• Pure Axial Load Capacity, Po
Pn = 0.85f' c (A ‐ A psT ‐ A sT ) ‐ A psT (f pe ‐ 0.003E ps ) + A sT f y Po = 6,837.43 kN Φ = 0.65
= 10,519.13 kN
Design Axial Load, Pu cap
Pcap = S.F. Po = 5,469.94 kN
• Design Axial Force and Moment at any given value of 'c'
23 c = 397.00 mm a = 317.60 mm
Steel Strain
when d < c when d > c
c ‐ d d ‐ c
Єs = 0.003 Єs = 0.003
c c
Prestressing Steel Strain
when y < c when y > c
f pe c ‐ d f pe c ‐ d
Єs = ‐ 0.003 Єs = + 0.003
E ps c E ps c
Nominal Axial Load and Moment Capacity (Pn, Mn)
P n = 0.85f' c (A comp ‐ A' s ‐ A' ps ) + A' s f' s ‐ A' ps f' ps ‐ A s f s ‐ A ps f ps
= 6,572.51 kN
M n = 0.85f' c (A comp ‐ A' s ‐ A' ps ) e 1 + A' s f' s e 2 ‐ A' ps f' ps e 3 ‐ A s f s e 4 ‐ A ps f ps e 5
= 621.98 kN‐m
Ultimate Axial Load and Moment Capacity (Pu, Mu)
Єst = ‐0.000038
Φ = 0.65
13.2.7 Contour Points on Interaction Curve
depth of comp. depth of comp. Unfactored Loads Factored Loads eccentricity, e
β ɸ
curve, c (mm) block, a (mm) Pn (kN) Mn (kN‐m) Pu (kN) Mu (kN‐m) (mm)
1 1 0.8 0.80 0.900 ‐3206.43 68.27 ‐2885.79 61.44 ‐21.29
2 19 0.8 15.20 0.900 ‐2855.72 143.57 ‐2570.15 129.21 ‐50.27
3 37 0.8 29.60 0.900 ‐2427.09 225.98 ‐2184.38 203.38 ‐93.11
4 55 0.8 44.00 0.900 ‐1763.30 339.24 ‐1586.97 305.32 ‐192.39
5 73 0.8 58.40 0.900 ‐1125.08 437.07 ‐1012.57 393.36 ‐388.48
6 91 0.8 72.80 0.900 ‐581.41 517.35 ‐523.27 465.62 ‐889.83
7 109 0.8 87.20 0.900 ‐101.00 583.70 ‐90.90 525.33 ‐5779.21
8 127 0.8 101.60 0.900 343.90 639.77 309.51 575.79 1860.33
9 145 0.8 116.00 0.900 747.38 684.97 672.64 616.47 916.49
10 163 0.8 130.40 0.833 1159.28 724.97 965.68 603.90 625.36
11 181 0.8 144.80 0.772 1565.25 757.70 1208.37 584.94 484.07
12 199 0.8 159.20 0.722 1962.56 781.47 1416.97 564.22 398.19
13 217 0.8 173.60 0.680 2380.71 794.16 1618.88 540.03 333.58
14 235 0.8 188.00 0.650 2806.01 799.95 1823.91 519.97 285.09
15 253 0.8 202.40 0.650 3267.63 794.09 2123.96 516.16 243.02
16 271 0.8 216.80 0.650 3713.55 785.41 2413.81 510.52 211.5
17 289 0.8 231.20 0.650 4146.41 773.55 2695.17 502.81 186.56
18 307 0.8 245.60 0.650 4568.83 758.20 2969.74 492.83 165.95
19 325 0.8 260.00 0.650 4982.61 739.08 3238.70 480.40 148.33
20 343 0.8 274.40 0.650 5388.58 716.06 3502.58 465.44 132.88
21 361 0.8 288.80 0.650 5788.40 688.94 3762.46 447.81 119.02
22 379 0.8 303.20 0.650 6182.94 657.61 4018.91 427.45 106.36
23 397 0.8 317.60 0.650 6572.51 621.98 4272.13 404.29 94.63
24 415 0.8 332.00 0.650 6958.22 581.99 4522.84 378.29 83.64
25 433 0.8 346.40 0.650 7340.29 537.51 4771.19 349.38 73.23
26 451 0.8 360.80 0.650 7719.12 488.56 5017.43 317.56 63.29
27 469 0.8 375.20 0.650 8095.47 435.02 5262.06 282.76 53.74
28 487 0.8 389.60 0.650 8469.01 376.89 5504.86 244.98 44.5
ITEM: ABUSAG BRIDGE Design: LRP Date: 10/17/2019
13.2.8 Strength Interaction Curve
10,000
8,000
6,000 5,469.94 kN
Φ Pn, kN
4,000
2,000
64.73 kN‐m, 67.71 kN
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900
‐2,000
‐4,000
Φ Mn, kN‐m
Design Moment and Axial Tension Design Moment and Axial Compression
M = M = 64.73 kN‐m
Pt = Pc = 67.71 kN