Predation by Rainbow Trout Oncorhynchus Mykiss On A Western Australian Icon Marron Cherax Cainii
Predation by Rainbow Trout Oncorhynchus Mykiss On A Western Australian Icon Marron Cherax Cainii
Predation by Rainbow Trout Oncorhynchus Mykiss On A Western Australian Icon Marron Cherax Cainii
com/loi/tnzm20
To cite this article: Michelle Y. Tay , Alan J. Lymbery , Stephen J. Beatty & David L. Morgan
(2007) Predation by rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus�mykiss) on a Western Australian icon: Marron
(Cherax�cainii) , , 41:2, 197-204, DOI: 10.1080/00288330709509908
Short communication
^VIA/
social value of the recreational marron fishery, it classes, i.e., (1) <200 mm TL, (2) 200-300 mm TL,
has recently been recommended that the species (3) >300 mm TL. Each stomach was removed and its
be nominated as a State freshwater faunal emblem contents examined under a dissecting microscope. All
(Department of Fisheries 2006). The aim of this animal matter was identified using Davis & Christidis
study was to determine the diet and trophic position (1997) to the lowest possible taxon (usually order or
of a wild, self-sustaining reservoir population of family) and classified as being terrestrial or aquatic.
O. mykiss in southwestern Australia via stomach Stomach contents were analysed using the percentage
content and stable isotope analyses. frequency of occurrence and the percentage of
volumetric contribution of each dietary item. The
percentage frequency of occurrence is the proportion
MATERIALS AND METHODS of the number of stomachs containing a particular
prey type to the total number of stomachs examined,
Study site and sampling regime whereas the percentage of volumetric contribution
Churchman Brook Reservoir is located c. 30 km is the proportion of each prey type to the overall
southeast of Perth in the Canning River (Fig. 1). stomach contents of each fish, or all fish combined
The earth-fill embankment dam has a catchment (Hynes 1950; Hyslop 1980). These two different
area of c. 16 km2, with a reservoir capacity of 2.16 methods were applied as they may show different
gigalitres stretching 1.4 km in length (Department trends if large prey items dominate the stomachs of
of Water 2007). Rainbow trout were sampled on particular individuals. Oncorhynchus mykiss with
four separate occasions during spring, 2004; once in no dietary items present in stomach contents were
September and October, and twice in November. On excluded from these analyses. Wherever possible
each sampling occasion, four gill nets (50,75,100, (i.e., measurable), each C. cainii present in the guts
and 125 mm stretched mesh) were set overnight (5 of O. mykiss was measured to the nearest 1 mm
pm - 9 am) within the reservoir. To obtain adequate orbital carapace length (OCL).
numbers of juvenile O. mykiss and C. cainii, they Similarities in dietary composition among
were collected from c. 100 m of stream immediately individual O. mykiss were estimated from square-
above the reservoir using a back-pack electrofisher root transformed percentage volumetric data
(Smith Root Model 12-A). using the Bray Curtis similarity coefficient (Bray
& Curtis 1957; PRIMER v5, Clarke & Gorley
Stomach contents analysis 2001). Patterns of similarity among different size
The total length (TL) of each fish was measured to classes of O. mykiss were assessed with non-metric
the nearest 1 mm and wet weight measured to the multidimensional scaling (MDS) of the Bray Curtis
nearest 10 mg. Fish were categorised into three size similarity matrix. Stress values, or the distortion
Tay et al.—Predation by rainbow trout on marron 199
between the original similarity rankings and similarity and conventional standards (Pee Dee Belemite
13
rankings in the ordination plot, were compared at carbonate for δ C and atmospheric nitrogen for
15
different dimensionalities of ordination to determine δ N). The precision of the analytical equipment was
13 15
the most suitable plot dimensions. A stress value ± 0.1‰ for δ C and ± 0.3‰ for δ N.
<0.2 indicates reasonable representation of rank 13
The mean and standard error of the δ C and δ N
15
similarities by the ordination plot (Clarke 1993). The ratios for each sample group (i.e., size categories,
significance of differences in dietary composition type of species, and sampling time) were calculated.
between size classes was tested by analysis of To infer the relative trophic positions of C. cainii
similarities (ANOSIM, PRIMER v5, Clarke & and O. mykiss, we assumed the mean δ N ratio
15
Gorley 2001). Where multiple statistical tests of fractionation rate of O. mykiss to be 3.36‰, which
the same hypothesis were applied, a Bonferroni was the difference in the signatures of O. mykiss fed
correction was used to maintain an experiment-wide solely on pelleted food over a period of 9 months
Type I error rate of 5% (Bland & Altman 1995). at an aquaculture facility (Tay 2004). The equation
The contribution of individual dietary items to the T
L = (δ 1 5 N O.mykiss- δ 1 5 N CcalJ 13.36 (adapted
similarity within size classes or the dissimilarity from Post 2002), was used to determine the trophic
among size classes was determined by averaging difference between predator and its prey, where T L
the Bray-Curtis similarity (or dissimilarity) term is the trophic level difference between O. mykiss and
for each item over all pairwise individual O. mykiss C. cainii, δ15NO. m ykiss is the mean stable δ 15 N ratio of
combinations, using SIMPER (PRIMER v5). To O. mykiss and O.mykssi „ . Nis the mean δ 15 N ratio of C.
determine the strength of the relationship between cainii.
size of O. mykiss and the ingestion of particular
dietary items, percentage volumetric data were
arcsine transformed before simple linear regression
analysis (Zar 1998). RESULTS
The size range for 123 O. mykiss captured in
Stable isotope analysis Churchman Brook Reservoir from September 2004
Stable isotope analysis (δ 1 3 C and δ 1 5 N) was to November 2004 was 23-392 mm TL: 16 were
also undertaken to further determine the trophic <200 mm TL, 48 were between 200-300 mm TL,
relationships of O. mykiss in the reservoir. Four and 59 were >300 mm TL. One-hundred-and-five
replicates of both small (224-305 mm TL) and large of these fish had distinguishable dietary items in
(334-380 mm TL) O. mykiss, each consisting of their stomach. Of the 21 food categories ingested
one randomly selected individual, were collected by O. mykiss, C. cainii comprised the bulk of the
in October and November 2004. A sample of dorsal diet (c. 60% by volume, c. 70% by occurrence)
tissue (wet weight of 2-5 g) from each O. mykiss (Table 1). Both whole juvenile marron (OCL 7-23
was removed and dried at 70°C for 48 h. Similarly, mm, n = 9 measurable OCLs) and the appendages
four replicates of both juvenile (<30 mm OCL) of adult marron were found in trout stomachs. The
and adult (>30 mm OCL) C. cainii were analysed next most important aquatic invertebrates ingested
in September, with three replicates per size class were dytiscids that were found in c. 30% of all O.
analysed in October for δ 13 C and δ 15 N. Between mykiss examined and contributed c. 10% of diet by
2 and 5 g wet weight of abdominal muscle tissue volume. Other aquatic invertebrates consumed were
(without carapace or digestive tract) was removed anisopteran larvae and amphipods, while the main
from each individual and placed in 1 mol/litre of terrestrial invertebrates ingested included formicids,
HCL for 24 h to remove inorganic carbonates. dipterans and diplopods (Table 1). Overall, terrestrial
Samples were then rinsed in distilled water and oven fauna comprised c. 19%, and aquatic invertebrates,
dried at 70°C for 48 h. Before being finely ground excluding C. cainii, comprised c. 18% by volume
to a powder with a mortar and pestle, all samples of O. mykiss diets.
were re-weighed to a dry weight of between 2 and Ordination analysis of dietary composition
3 mg. A tracermass iron ratio mass spectrometer showed marked differences between size classes
(Europa PDZ, Cambridge, United Kingdom) fitted (Fig. 2), which were confirmed by ANOSIM (R =
with a Roboprep combustion system was used for 0.38, P < 0.001). Pairwise tests found significant
oxidising samples. The ratios of carbon δ 13 C:δ 12 C differences in dietary composition between all
and nitrogen δ15N:δ14N were expressed as the relative size classes (1 and 2, R = 0.45, P < 0.001; 1 and
parts per thousand differences between the sample 3, R = 0.86, P < 0.001; 2 and 3, R = 0.10, P <
200 New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research, 2007, Vol. 41
50
Fig. 2 Multidimensional scaling (MDS) ordination of ° 150 200 250
the similarity matrix of dietary composition (calculated Total length (mm)
from % points data) of the different size classes of Onco-
rhynchus mykiss from Churchman Brook Reservoir. Size Fig. 3 Relationship between total length of Oncorhyn-
groups are: • , <200 mm TL; O, 200-300 mm TL; • , chus mykiss (mm) and % volumetric contribution of
>300 mm TL. Cherax cainii in the diet.
0.010), although the differences were most marked volume to the diets of fish of size class 1, 67.6%
between those fish <200 mm TL (size class 1) and by frequency of occurrence and 59.8% by volume
those 200 mm TL (size classes 2 and 3). SIMPER to the diets of fish of size class 2, and 70.2% by
analysis revealed that over 70% of the differences frequency of occurrence and 84.4% by volume to
in diet between fish <200 mm TL and those 200 the diets of fish of size class 3. Regression analysis
mm TL were explained by a preponderance of confirmed a significant relationship between fish
terrestrial fauna in small fish and a preponderance size and percentage volumetric contribution of C.
of C. cainii in larger fish. Cherax cainii contributed cainii (Fig. 3; r2 = 0.29; n = 104, F1 m = MAI, P
14.3% by frequency of occurrence and 5.7% by < 0.001).
Tay et al.—Predation by rainbow trout on marron 201
The highly modified environment of Churchman a known predator of C. cainii in reservoirs (Morgan
Brook Reservoir may limit the extent to which we et al. 2002; Molony et al. 2004).
can generalise our results to more natural systems. This study demonstrates that C. cainii appears to
For example, there are considerable differences be a very important component of the diet of a feral
between the habitat complexity of natural systems O. mykiss population for at least part of the year.
and this impoundment reservoir, with natural rivers This level of prédation is of great concern given
generally having more refuge structures available the current status of C. cainii and the other endemic
owing to the greater amount of large wooden debris decapod crustacean populations in the southwest
input from the riparian zone. This greater habitat of Western Australia. Further assessments of the
complexity in more natural lotie systems may result predatory impact of O. mykiss in other freshwater
in lower prédation rates by O. mykiss on C. cainii in systems of the region need to be undertaken to better
those systems than was recorded in the present study. understand the ecological impacts caused by the
However, previous studies have also documented stocking regime of this species.
O. mykiss prédation on C. cainii and other decapod
crustaceans in Western Australia. Pusey & Morrison
(1989) showed that at Wungong Dam, C. tenuimanus ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
(now known as C. cainii) was the most important
prey by weight (c. 80%), occurring in over a third Thanks to Peter Chalmers for field assistance, the Water
of all O. mykiss stomachs examined. Jenkins Corporation of Western Australia for site access, Lydia
Bednarekfor assistance with stable isotope analyses, and
(1952) also found that C. tenuimanus made up a Drs Rob Doupé and Howard Gill for assistance invarious
considerable proportion of O. mykiss diets, occurring stages of the study.
in seven out of 10 O. mykiss caught in several rivers
in southwestern Australia. Morgan et al. (2004)
demonstrated that 23% of 92 O. mykiss collected REFERENCES
from numerous streams of southwestern Australia
ingested endemic fish and decapods. Morgan & Astbury C 2004. A draft policy for the translocation
Beatty (2003) also found decapods to be a major of brown trout (Salmo trulla) and rainbow
trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) into and within
food item in the dietary contents of 15 O. mykiss, Western Australia, for the purpose of recreational
captured from Bancell Brook, Western Australia. stocking, domestic stocking, commercial and non-
In recent years, there have been concerns that C. commercial aquaculture. Fisheries Management
cainii stocks in the southwest of Western Australia Paper No. 179, Department of Fisheries,
Government of Western Australia.
are declining through over-fishing and reduced
rainfall (Molony & Bird 2002). The results of the Beatty SJ, Morgan DL, Gill HS 2003. Reproductive
present study, combined with similar studies in the biology of the large freshwater crayfish Cherax
southwest of Western Australia, suggest that O. cainii in south-western Australia. Marine and
Freshwater Research 54: 597-608.
mykiss prédation may have a significant additional
impact on C. cainii populations in some habitats. Beatty SJ, Morgan DL, Gill HS 2005. Biology of a
However, the available data are not yet adequate translocated population of the large freshwater
crayfish, Cherax cainii Austin and Ryan, 2002
to quantify the extent of that impact, for a number in a Western Australian river. Crustaceana 77:
of reasons. First, our study, like previous studies 1329-1351.
in Western Australia, was limited to only three
Bland JM, Altaian DG 1995. Multiple significance tests:
months and did not include an analysis of density, the Bonferroni method. British Medical Journal
growth or recruitment rates of the marron population. 310: 170.
Second, our study may have over-estimated the
Bray JR, Curtis JT 1957. An ordination of the upland forest
dietary importance of C. cainii to O. mykiss, because communities of Southern Wisconsin. Ecological
our sampling period in spring coincided with the Monographs 27: 325-349.
recruitment of juvenile marron, which were most Cadwallader PL, EdenAK 1982. Observations on the food
susceptible to prédation by trout (OCL 7-23 mm). of rainbow trout, Salmo gairdneri Richardson,
Nevertheless, the finding that C. cainii are the most in Lake Purrumbete, Victoria. Bulletin of the
important food item to O. mykiss in this system Australian Society of Limnology 8: 17-21.
suggests that this large, actively introduced teleost Clarke KR 1993. Non-parametric multivariate analysis
represents a considerable additional impact to the of changes in community structure. Australian
feral (self-sustaining) redfin perch Perca fluviatilis, Journal of Ecology 18: 117-143.
Tay et al. — Prédation by rainbow trout on marron 203
Clarke KR, Gorley RN 2001. Primer v5: User manual/ the Species Survival Commission (SSC) of the
tutorial. Plymouth, United Kingdom, PRIMER- World Conservation Union (IUCN), Auckland,
E Ltd. New Zealand. 12 p.
Coy NJ 1979. Freshwater fishing in south-west Australia. Molony B, Bird C, 2002. Annual report on the monitoring
Perth, Western Australia, Jabiru Books. 216 p. of the recreational marron fishery in 2000, with
Crandall KA, Fetzner JW, Lawler SH, Kinnersley M, an analysis of changes in the long-term data from
Austin CM 1999. Phylogenetic relationships this fishery. Perth, WesternAustralia, Department
among the Australian and New Zealand genera of of Fisheries, Government of Western Australia,
freshwater crayfishes (Decapoda: Parastacidae). Fisheries Research Report No. 137.
Australian Journal of Zoology 47: 199-214. Molony BW, Bird C, Nguyen VP 2004. The relative
Crowl TA, Townsend CR, McIntosh AR 1992. The impact efficacy of stocking fry or yearling rainbow trout
of introduced brown and rainbow trout on native (Oncorhynchus mykiss) into a large impoundment
fish: the case of Australasia. Reviews in Fish dominated by redfin perch (Perca fluvialilis) in
Biology and Fisheries 2: 217-241. south-western Australia. Marine and Freshwater
Research 55: 781-785.
Davis J, Christidis F 1997. A guide to wetland invertebrates
of southwestern Australia. Western Australian Molony BW, Jones B, Lawrence CS, Gouteff VA 2006.
Museum, Perth, Western Australia. 177 p. Cherax tenuimanus Smith, 1912 (Crustacea,
Decapoda, Parastacidae): proposed conservation of
Department of Fisheries 2006. A five-year management usage of the specific name. Bulletin of Zoological
strategy for the recreational marron fishery. Final Nomenclature 63(4): 231-235.
report of the RFAC Recreational Freshwater
Fisheries Stakeholder Sub-Committee. Fisheries Morgan D, Beatty S 2003. Fish and decapod fauna of
Management Paper No. 213. Bancell Brook (Harvey River) and the impacts of
irrigation slot boards on migrations. Report to the
Department of Water, Government of Western Australia Southern Peel Partnership Landcare Group.
2007. Churchman Brook Catchment Area Drinking
Water Source Protection Plan. Water Resource Morgan DL, Gill HS, Potter IC 1998. Distribution,
Protection Series, No. 66. identification and biology of freshwater fishes in
south-western Australia. Records of the Western
Fuller PL, Nico LG, Williams JD 1999. Nonindigenous Australian Museum Supplement No. 56.
fishes introduced into inland waters of the United
States. American Fisheries Society Special Morgan DL, Hambleton SJ, Gill HS, Beatty SJ 2002,
Publication 27. Distribution, biology and likely impacts of
the introduced redfin perch (Perca fluvialilis)
Hynes HBN 1950. The food of sticklebacks with a review (Percidae) in Western Australia. Marine and
of methods used in studies of the food of fishes. Freshwater Research 53: 1211-1221.
Journal of Animal Ecology 19: 36-58.
Morgan DL, Gill HS, Maddern MG, Beatty SJ 2004
Hyslop EJ 1980. Stomach contents analysis—a review Distribution and impacts of introduced freshwater
of methods and their application. Journal of Fish fishes in Western Australia. New Zealand
Biology 17:411-429. Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 38:
Jenkins CFH 1952. The food of Oncorhynchus mykiss in 511-523.
WesternAustralia. The West Australian Naturalist Morrissy N, Hambleton S, Gill HS, Morgan, D, Cribb
3: 139-141. A, Davy B, Dibden C, Maguire G, Millington P,
Kerr SR 1971. Prediction of fish growth efficiency in Molony B, Chappell J, Thorne T, Chalmers C,
nature. Journal of Fisheries Research Board Astbury C 2002. The translocation of brown trout
Canada 28: 809-814. (Salmo trulla) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus
Leitritz E, Lewis RC 1980. Trout and salmon culture in mykiss) into and within WesternAustralia. Perth,
California. Fish Bulletin No. 164. Agricultural Western Australia, Department of Fisheries,
Science Publications, University of California, Government of Western Australia, Fisheries
Berkeley. Management Paper No. 156.
Lintermans M 2004 Human-assisted dispersal of alien Pidgeon RWJ 1981. Diet and growth of Oncorhynchus
freshwater fish in Australia. New Zealand mykiss, Salmo gairdneri Richardson in two
Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 38: streams on the New England Tableland, New
481-501. South Wales. Australian Journal of Marine and
Freshwater Research 32: 967-974.
Lowe S, Browne M, Boudjelas S, De Poorter M 2000.
100 of the world's worst invasive alien species — a Post DM 2002. Using stable isotopes to estimate trophic
selection from the global invasive species database. positions: models, methods, and assumptions.
The Invasive Species Specialist Group (ISSG) of Ecology 83(3): 703-718.
204 New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research, 2007, Vol. 41