Homework 2 Solutions: Solution: (A) If A
Uploaded by
Fox JoshuaHomework 2 Solutions: Solution: (A) If A
Uploaded by
Fox JoshuaHomework 2 Solutions
Dedekind rings are introduced in Lang on page 88. Noetherian rings are dis-
cussed in Chapters 4 and 10. We will only need the de nitions of both.
Let R be a commutative ring. We recall that R is called a domain if xy = 0
for x; y 2 R implies that x = 0 or y = 0. A ring R is a domain if and only if it
can be embedded in a eld. If F is a eld containing R, then F is called the
eld of fractions of R if every element of F is of the form x/ y with x; y 2 R and
y=/ 0. The eld of fractions is uniquely determined up to isomorphism. We will
prove all these facts when we consider localization. But for example, the eld of
fractions of Z is Q.
If R is a domain and F its eld of fractions, then a fractional ideal a of R is
a nonzero, finitely-generated R-submodule of F . We can multiply fractional
ideals: ab is the additive subgroup of F generated by elements ab with a 2 a and
b 2 b. It is a fractional ideal.
A commutative ring R is called Noetherian if every ascending chain of ideals
terminates. That is, if a1 a2 a3 are ideals, then eventually an = an+1 =
an+2 = ::: for su ciently large n.
1. (a) Prove that a principal ideal domain is Noetherian.
p
(b) Prove that Z[ ¡5 ] is Noetherian.
Solution: (a) If S a1 a2 a3 is a chain of ideals of the principal ideal
domain R, then a = ai is an ideal. Indeed, to see that it is closed under addi-
tion, note that if x; y 2 a then x 2 ai and y 2 a j for some i; j. Without loss of
generality, i 6 j, so x; y 2 aj and so x + y 2 a j a. (It is also clear that Ra a.)
Since R is a principal ideal domain, a = R for some 2 a. If 2 ak then a ak
proving the ascending chain condition.
p p
(b) Note that Z[ ¡5 ] = Z 1 Z ¡5 ] is a nitely generated Z-module.
Since Z is Noetherian, every submodule
p of this finitely generated module is
nitely generated. Thus R = Z[ ¡5 ] is Noetherian as a Z-module, a fortiori as
an R-module. Alternative: Use the Hilbert Basis Theorem (Chapter IV, The-
orem 4.1) to see that the polynomial ring Z[X] is Noetherian. Let p: Z[X] ¡!
p p
Z[ ¡5 ] be p the map f (X) 7! f ( ¡5 ). If a1 a2 is an ascending chain of
ideals in Z[ ¡5 ] then p¡1(a1) p¡1(a2) is an ascending chain of ideals in
Z[X], hence it must terminate. This implies that the chain a1 a2 termi-
nates.
2. Assume that R is a Noetherian domain.
(a) Prove that a nonzero R-submodule of F is a fractional ideal if and only if
a cR for some c 2 F .
(b) Prove that a principal ideal domain is a Dedekind ring.
1
Solution: (a) First assume that a is a fractional ideal. By hypothesis Q it is
nitely generated. Let ai / bi (i = 1; ; n) be the generators, and let b = bi be
the common denominator. The ba R so a cR with c = 1 / b. Conversely, if
a cR then c¡1a is an ideal, nitely generated since R is Noetherian. Since a =
c¡1a as an R-module it is also nitely generated.
(b) Let F be the eld of fractions of the principal ideal domain R.
Lemma 1. Every fractional ideal of the principal ideal domain is of the form
dR for some d 2 F .
Proof. By part (a), a fractional ideal a is contained in cR for c 2 F . Write c =
a / b with a; b 2 R. Then ba aR, so ba is an ideal. Thus ba = tR for some t 2 R
because R is a PID. Thus a = dR with d = t/a.
Now a fractional ideal is invertible since d¡1R will serve as an inverse to dR.
The set P of fractional ideals thus forms a group. Since d 7! dR is a homomor-
phism from F ¡! P which is surjective (by the Lemma) with kernel R , the
multiplicative group of R, we see that P = F /R .
3. An pexample of an ideal in a Dedekind ring that is not principal.
Let R = Z[ ¡5 ]. It may be shown that R is a Dedekind ring. Let
p
I = fa + b ¡5 ja; b 2 Z; a b mod 2g:
The exercise will show that this ideal is not principal.
(a) Let R = R ¡ f0g and I = I ¡ f0g. (Some authors use R for the multi-
plicative group of units of a ring R, but I will use
p R for2 that.)2 Observe that if
N : R ¡! Z is the map N (z) = jz j , so N (a + b ¡5 ) = a + 5b , then N (zw) =
2
N (z) N (w). So N (R) and N (I ) are multiplicative monoids contained in Z.
Show that the smallest two nonzero elements of N (I ) are 4 and 6, while the
smallest nonzero elements of N (R) are 1 and 4.
(b) Use (a) to show that I is not a principal ideal.
(c) Prove that I is a maximal ideal. (Hint: what is the index [R: I] as
abelian groups?)
(d) To prove that R is a Dedekind domain we need to know that every frac-
tional ideal is invertible. We will not prove this right now, but show that I 2 =
2R and deduce that I is invertible.
p p
Solution. (a) Since N (a + b ¡5 ) = a2 + 5b2 we have N (a + b ¡5 ) > 4 if
b=/ 0. Therefore 1 = N (1) and 4 = N (2) are the smallest possible norms of ele-
p
ments of R. On the other hand if a + b ¡5 is known to be in I then a and b
are either both even or both odd,pso 1 is not a norm; the smallest norms in this
case are 4 = N (2) and 6 = N (1 + ¡5 ).
(b) If the ideal I were principal, say I = R , then the norms of elements of I
would be A = N ( ) times the norms of elements of R, and the two smallest
norms would be A and 4A. No choice of A makes these into 4 and 6.
(c) Observe that I has index two in R. Indeed if x 2 / I then x ¡ 1 2 I and so
R / I has only two cosets. If J is an ideal between I and R, that is R J I
then 2 = [R: I] = [R: J][J: I] so either [R: J] = 1 or [J: I] = 1, i.e. J = R or I. This
shows that I is maximal. Alternative: Since [R: I] = 2, the quotient ring R / I
has only two elements and p is clearly ap eld. Since R/I is a eld, I is maximal.
(d) Note that 2 = (1 + ¡5 )(1 ¡ ¡5 ) ¡ 2 2 2 I I. Therefore 2R I 2. On
the other hand, I 2 is generated by elements of the form
p p p
(a + b ¡5 )(c + d ¡5 ) = A + B ¡5 ; A = ac ¡ 5bd; B = ac + bd
where a b mod 2 and c d mod 2. We claim that A and B are both even. If a
and b are both even or if c and d are both even, this is obvious, so assume a; b;
c; d are all odd. Then a c and 5b d are odd so A is even, and similarly B. This
proves the converse inequality I 2 2R.
4. An example of an ideal that is projective but not free. Notations
will be as in the last problem.
(a) Prove that I is not a free module.
(b) De ne f : R R ¡! I I be multiplication by the matrix
p !
1 + ¡5 2
M= p :
2 1 ¡ ¡5
Show that f is an isomorphism R R ¡! I I. Conclude that I is a projective
module.
Solution. For (a), note that any two elements x; ypof I cannot be linearly
independent over R since their ratio lies in the eld Q( ¡5 ) of fractions, so x /
y = / with ; 2 R and so x ¡ y = 0. This means that if I is free, it is free
of rank one. Thus as an ideal, it is principal, contradicting Problem 3.
(b) Since the entries of M are in I, the map f takes R R into I I. As for
the inverse map, !
p
1 1 ¡ ¡5 ¡2
M ¡1 = p :
2 ¡2 1 + ¡5
1
Note that the coe cients are in 2 I. So applying this to I I produces elements
1 1
of 2 I 2 2 I 2 = R R by Problem 3(d). Hence f : I I ¡! R R is a bijection.
We see that I I is free. Since it is a summand in a free module, it is projec-
tive.
