Difference Between Strategic Alliance, Joint Venture and Strategic Alliance
Difference Between Strategic Alliance, Joint Venture and Strategic Alliance
Difference Between Strategic Alliance, Joint Venture and Strategic Alliance
The effects of forming a strategic alliance can include allowing each of the
businesses to achieve organic growth more quickly than if they had acted alone.
The partnership often entails sharing resources that only one of the companies
possesses. As an example, if a small printing company allied with another that
owned high-speed presses, the small business could capture more of the local
printing business at less cost.
Further advantages of strategic alliances[edit]
• Access to new technology, intellectual property rights
• Create critical mass, common standards, new businesses
• Diversification
• Improve agility, R&D, material flow, speed to market
• Reduce administrative costs, R&D costs, and cycle time
• Allowing each partner to concentrate on their competitive advantage
• Learning from partners and developing competencies that may be more widely
exploited elsewhere
• To reduce political risk while entering into a new market
• An alliance plan will provide the opportunity to manage and achieve defined
results from a corporate ecosystems
Disadvantages of strategic alliances include:[2]
• Sharing: In a strategic alliance the partners must share resources and
profits and often skills and know-how. This can be critical if business secrets are
included in this knowledge. Agreements can protect these secrets but the partner
might not be willing to stick to such an agreement.
• Creating a competitor: The partner in a strategic alliance might become a
competitor one day, if it profited enough from the alliance and grew enough to end
the partnership and then is able to operate on its own in the same market segment.
• Opportunity costs: Focusing and committing is necessary to run a Strategic
Alliance successfully but might discourage from taking other opportunities, which
might be beneficial as well.
• Uneven alliances: When the decision powers are distributed unevenly, the
weaker partner might be forced to act according to the will of the more powerful
partner(s), even if he or she is actually not willing to do so.
• Foreign confiscation: If a company is engaged in a foreign country, there is
the risk that the government of this country might try to seize this local business
so that the domestic company can have all the market on its own.
• Risk of losing control over proprietary information, especially regarding
complex transactions requiring extensive coordination and intensive information
sharing.
• Coordination difficulties due to informal cooperation settings and highly
costly dispute resolution.
Example of a Strategic Alliance
The deal between Starbucks and Barnes&Noble is a classic example of a strategic
alliance. Starbucks brews the coffee. Barnes&Noble stocks the books. Both companies
do what they do best while sharing the costs of space to the benefit of both
companies.
Special Considerations
Paying Taxes on a Joint Venture (JV)
When forming a JV, the most common thing the two parties can do is to set up a new
entity. But because the JV itself isn't recognized by the Internal Revenue Service
(IRS), the business form between the two parties helps determine how taxes are
paid. If the JV is a separate entity, it will pay taxes like any other business or
corporation does. So if it operates as an LLC, the LLC will then pay taxes.
The JV agreement will spell out how profits or losses are taxed. But if the
agreement is merely a contractual relationship between the two parties, then their
agreement will determine how the tax is divided up between them.
Using a Joint Venture (JV) to Enter Foreign Markets
A common use of JVs is to partner up with a local business to enter a foreign
market. A company that wants to expand its distribution network to new countries
can usefully enter into a JV agreement to supply products to a local business, thus
benefiting from an already existing distribution network.2 Some countries also have
restrictions on foreigners entering their market, making a JV with a local entity
almost the only way to do business in the country.
Requirements for Joint Ventures
The key elements to a joint venture may include (but are not limited to):
• The number of parties involved
• The scope in which the JV will operate (geography, product, technology)
• What and how much each party will contribute to the JV
• The structure of the JV itself
• Initial contributions and ownership split of each party
• The kind of arrangements to be made once the deal is complete
• How the JV is controlled and managed
• How the JV will be staffed
Dissolution[edit]
The JV is not a permanent structure. It can be dissolved when:
• Aims of original venture met
• Aims of original venture not met
• Either or both parties develop new goals
• Either or both parties no longer agree with joint venture aims
• Time agreed for joint venture has expired
• Legal or financial issues
• Evolving market conditions mean that joint venture is no longer appropriate
or relevant
• One party acquires the other