Scribd
Upload
145 views

Comperision of Compressor: Make IR

The document compares three compressor options from different manufacturers. Option 1 is an Elgi centrifugal compressor with 1 unit, 1599 total capacity, and a total investment of $7.58 million. Option 2 is a Kaeser system with 2 screw compressors, 1515 total capacity, and a total investment of $7.17 million. Option 3 also from Kaeser has 3 screw compressors with 1584 total capacity and a total investment of $6.19 million.

Uploaded by

Ronak Joshi
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
145 views

Comperision of Compressor: Make IR

The document compares three compressor options from different manufacturers. Option 1 is an Elgi centrifugal compressor with 1 unit, 1599 total capacity, and a total investment of $7.58 million. Option 2 is a Kaeser system with 2 screw compressors, 1515 total capacity, and a total investment of $7.17 million. Option 3 also from Kaeser has 3 screw compressors with 1584 total capacity and a total investment of $6.19 million.

Uploaded by

Ronak Joshi
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 6

COMPERISION OF COMPRESSOR

MAKE IR
DISCRIPTION
Type centrifugle
Total Capacity 1599

NO OF COMPRESSOR
1 NO (turbo air -2000)

No VFD
STAND BY COMPRESSOR from existing
Working Pressure BAR at receiver 7.5
Maximum Pressure
Total Input Power 276
SPACIFIC POWER KW/CFM 0.1726
Working hours 8000
POWER SAVING KWH 55
Auxillary power saving KW ( pump,cooling tower) for
air cooling system
Capital Investment WITH STAND BY 7,650,000
Ducting cost
FABRICATION COST 200,000
CIVIL COST & LIGHTING 100,000
POWER COST(Cable,switch etc) 300,000
TOTAL INVESTMENT WITH STANDBY 8,250,000
TOTAL INVESTMENT WITHOUT STANDBY
SAVING 3,520,000
SAVING AMC COST 1,800,000
MAN POWER REDUCE (3 operator) 468,000
POWER SAVING IN CLEANING COMPRESSOR 1,176,000
SPACE SAVING 1,256,000
TOTAL SAVING 8,220,000
ROI ( Months )WITH SB 12
ROI ( Months )W/0 SB
Rs./Unit consider 8
Saving/Year( Based on power Data) 3520000

DRIVE NO DRIVE
COOLING water
AMC 1 YEAR INCLUDE

DRYER
(INLUDED 1no)
RECEIVER EXISTING
PRE FILTER&AFTER FILTER INCLUDE
SPARE COST/YEAR NOT PROVIDING
ELGI KAESER - 1

Screw compressor Screw compressor


1613 1615

1 no ( OF-275-8) 2 NO (DSD 205 SFC DSD 240)


891 CMH DSD 240 Without VFD,
No VFD 724 CMH DSD 205 with VFD
from existing from existing
8 8

286.17 271.7
0.1774 0.1682
8000 8000
44.83 59.3
16

6987000 6466000
100,000
200,000 200,000
100,000 100,000
300,000 300,000
7,587,000 7,166,000

2,869,120 4,819,200
1,800,000 1,800,000
468,000
1,176,000 1,176,000
1,256,000 1,256,000
7,569,120 9,051,200
12 10

8 8
2869120 4819200

NO DRIVE WITH DRIVE


water AIR
1 YEAR INCLUDE 1 YEAR INCLUDE
(INLUDED with
compressor1no) (INLUDED with compressor 2no)

EXISTING EXISTING

INCLUDE INCLUDE
NOT PROVIDING NOT PROVIDING
KAESER - 2

Screw compressor
1584

3 NO (CSD 105 SFC CSD 105 DSD 240)


891 CMH DSD 240 & 353 CMH CSD 105
Without VFD, 340 CMH DSD 105 with VFD
from existing
8

272.5
0.172
8000
58.5
16

5490000
100,000
200,000
100,000
300,000
6,190,000

4,768,000
1,800,000

1,176,000
1,256,000
9,000,000
8

8
4768000

WITH DRIVE
AIR
1 YEAR INCLUDE

(INLUDED with compressor 3no)

EXISTING

INCLUDE
NOT PROVIDING

You might also like