Paper 02
Paper 02
Paper 02
Tendai Mangena,
Lecturer,
Faculty of Arts and Department of English and
Performing Arts at University of Great Zimbabwe.
ABSTRACT
One of the major challenges in the writing and analysis of African women’s literature has been
lack of an acceptable theoretical focus. So much of the writing and analysis of this literature has
been influenced by the Feminist paradigm, and which largely operates within the walls of
Western thinking. The need for an African – Centered paradigm and theoretical framework
prompted Hudson Clenora Weems to come up with an African – centered Africana Womanist
Theory to inform the writing and understanding of African – American and African women
literature. The theory responds to the inadequacies of both Feminism and Black Feminism and the
subsequent need for proper naming and defining of the woman of African descent. This paper,
then, intends to examine two issues – the relevance of the Africana Womanist Theory – to the
writing and analysis of Zimbabwean women’s literature. The relevance of the theory can be
located in its demonstration of women categorization not as a monolithic bloc, and is also quite
strong in its Afrocentric approach to the writing and analysis of Zimbabwean women’s literature.
This paper demonstrates that Zimbabwean women writers seek to rewrite official historiography
and contest the exclusion and misrepresentation of women experience, but they largely do so
within the context of the feminist theoretical focus. Subsequently Zimbabwean women’s
literature is also read and understood in the context of feminism and not just Africana Womanism.
INTRODUCTION:
One of the major challenges in the writing and analysis of African women’s literature has been lack of an
acceptable theoretical focus. So much of the writing and analysis of this literature has been influenced by the
Feminist paradigm, which largely operates within the walls of Western thinking. The need for an African –
Centered paradigm and theoretical framework prompted Hudson - Weems to come up with an African –
centered Africana Womanist Theory to inform the writing and understanding of African – American and
African women literature. The theory responds to the inadequacies of both Feminism and Black Feminism
and the subsequent need for proper naming and defining of the woman of African descent. In essence,
Africana Womanism is Africana women’s effort to ‘create their own criteria for assessing their realities, both
in thought and in action’. This paper, then, intends to examine two issues – the relevance of the Africana
Womanist Theory – to the writing and analysis of Zimbabwean literature
foster inequality and keep them languishing on the fringes of the white world” (Ntiri- Quenum 2007, 315).
The Africana Womanist theory has therefore the potential of effecting change and making meaningful
“contributions to the Afrocentric discourse on African women and men” (Hudson - Weems 2007, 294 -295)
Over and above referring to the oppressive elements that affect Africana women, the theory is strong in its
Afrocentric approach. African women are not only afforded an opportunity to talk about their lives in their
own terms but here is an opportunity for them to demonstrate all their positive qualities. In as much as they
are violated in various ways they are “the very foundation of life whether they know it or not” (Hudson -
Weems 2004, 66) and “the female gender is the center of life, the magnet that holds the center of the cosmos
in intact” (Sofola cited in Hudson - Weems 2004, 66). Africana womanists go back in history and retrieve
Africana women who are testimonies to the centrality of Africana women to human existence. In seeking
historical truth Africana women raise issues about the insights that history can provide into their struggles
against both racism and sexism (Wheeler 2007, 321)
But the major challenge remains that Africana Woman, just like the term woman is not a monolithic bloc.
What is particularly problematic is combining and having one approach that addresses the problems of one
category but two separate realities of the African continent and that of its diaspora. In as much as women in
the continent and its diaspora belong to the same category their realities are quite different. Whereas
Africana women in the diaspora may still be existing in racist societies, those in the continent may not
identify race as an immediate problem in their daily encounters because most of the African nations are
independent from political imperial rule. Maybe this is why most of the writings by black female writers
operate within the ideologically dominant culture of mainstream feminism. The racial aspect is not only
minimal in their writings but it is not always part of the everyday challenges for contemporary African
women of the African continent. Therefore, it would appear as if these African writers in the continent are
not operating within the walls of Africana Womanism; this can be discerned from the various literary works
written by Zimbabwean women.
film, as a novelist and a filmmaker. Her major publications include She No Longer Weeps (1987), Nervous
Conditions (1988) and The Book of Not (2006). She has also produced a number of films. She wrote a script
for the film Neria, a 1993 Zimbabwean film that highlights the disadvantaged positions in which women
find themselves in traditional inheritance systems. Dangarembga also directed a 1996 film, Everyone’s Child.
In all her creative works, Dangarembga protests against various forms of oppression as they affect black
women’s existence. This is also a lived reality for Dangarembga. When she joined politics and became a
member of the Mutambara MDC faction in 2010, she confirmed this by saying, “I have always been a vocal
critic of injustice, backwardness, intolerance, and brutality … all the things that are named in the bible as
deadly sins”vii. In Nervous Conditions, the battle for black women in a colonial state has two dimensions.
Like men, they suffer the colonial burden but over and above that, they have to deal with patriarchal
domination. Some of the beliefs contested in Nervous Conditions include the belief that did not prioritise the
educating girls. The animosity in the Tambudzai – Nhamo relationship is a result of this belief. Tambudzai
was not sorry when her brother Nhamo died because he was an impediment to her education. The novel is
generally “a stark critique of both the patriarchal beliefs of the black community and against the racist
structures under which this community must live”viii.
In She No Longer Weeps, Dangarembga interrogates what it means to become a woman in the Zimbabwean
post independent context. On the attainment of independence, women were promised emancipation,
especially in the passage of the Legal Age of Majority Act. This was meant to give women the right to
contract their own marriages, represent themselves in court, and be guardians of their children. Since most of
the promises were not seriously honored with the attainment of independence, in She No Longer Weeps we
witness a daughter's struggle to define her own identity as a woman, independent of her father and the
confines of constricted cultural codes. The struggle reflects the broader effort by women in the independent
Zimbabwean society to assert their own understanding of adulthood. In Neria the battle is against the abuse
of inheritance customs by black man. The abuse affects the widow and her children who are eventually
dispossessed materially. Everyone’s Child is slightly different in that it deals with the disadvantaged
positions of vulnerable orphaned children in an adult controlled post independent world.
After the publication of Nervous Conditions, other women writers complemented Dangarembga’s efforts,
and the most prominent among these is Vera, who was quite prolific. She published five literary works
between 1992 and 2004 when she died. Just like Dangarembga, Vera’s works are women narratives. Though
not well known, Masitera has written interesting works that belong to the woman tradition. In 1996, she
published Militant Shadow, a collection of poems that militate against emotional and physical exploitation of
black women as mothers, wives and children in a male dominated society. In Now I Can Play, Masitera
contests the various forms of women oppression. Masitera’s Start With Me (2011) highlights the daunting
experiences of women in old age.
There is a specific pattern to these Zimbabwean counter discursive narratives. Zimbabwean women have
peculiar elements of oppression that affect them and that the women writers are forced to protest against in
their writings. Primarily, Zimbabwean women writers write against patriarchal dominance and history that
glosses over women existence and sensibilities. Unacknowledged women experience is a result of silence
imposed upon them by patriarchal domination. The enforced silence is broken when women writers write
about issues that affect them and are particularly conceived as taboo. Nevertheless, in addition to this, they
protest against the oppressions that affect the generality of Zimbabwean people. This is mainly so with
literature of Zimbabwe’s post 2000 crisisix written by women. This kind of literature encompasses Gappah’s
An Elegy for Easterly, Tagwira’s The Uncertainty of Hope and the Women Writing Zimbabwe. What is
peculiar about this kind of writing is the presentation of the crisis as it affected women’s lives.
Like most male writers of the late 90s who revise unqualified glorification of the liberation war, Vera and
Nyamubaya, respond to an official recalling of the contribution of black women in the Zimbabwean
liberation struggle. They challenge the Joyce Mujuru image of a “heroine holding a baby in one arm and an
AK47 in the other”, as the super image of black women in war situations (Christiansen 2006, 92). It is such
a glorified role women played that Vera and Nyamubaya contest, showing that women’s contribution in the
liberation struggle was rather complex. The contribution that women made sometimes left them with painful
dents, as in the case of Marita in Without a Name and “That Special Place” (2003). Nyamubaya’s
“autobiographical return to a ‘special place’ is a retrospective contestation over narrative so as to redeem the
true stories of the revolution” (Muchemwa 2006: 14). Vera’s Nehanda (1993) exemplifies protest literature
by rewriting the First Chimurenga from a female perspective (Muchemwa 2005, 200). Contesting and
demythologizing the war historiography implies protest against the official nationalist narrative.
The writing of an alternative history by Zimbabwean women is not limited to literary writing. It also
characterizes the making of both fictional and documentary films. Women of Resilience (2000), Mother of
Revolution (1990) and Flame (1996) “were driven by a common political concern arising out of post
independence marginalization of certain voices. Taken together they therefore constituted a counter-
discursive movement toward the writing of an alternative history which otherwise would have remained
invisible and unarticulated” (Bryce 2005, 28).
Nyamubaya’s On the Road Again (1986) also relates to Marechera’s House of Hunger, Nyamfukudza’s Non-
Believer’s Journey and Chinodya’s A Harvest of Thorns that predict the failing Zimbabwean independent state.
Nyamubaya refers to a “defeated victory” and a “mysterious marriage” between “independence and victory”,
where “independence” was celebrated without “victory”. Her understanding of struggle entails that attainment
of independence did not mark the end of fighting, rather the struggle continues. Vera also participates in post
independence critique of the ugly moment of madness in the Gukurahundi epoch. Vera’s The Stone Virgins
(2002) was the first to break the imposed silence on the massacres of thousands of the Matabeleland residents
by government forces. Tagwira and Gappah also participate in the 1991-2009 crises rewriting of the official
truth in An Uncertainty of Hope (2006) and An Elegy for Easterly (2009) respectively.
would like to see more sisterhood among women this ideal unfortunately is not the norm” (2004, 70).
In as much as Zimbabwean women have to deal with other forces that work against them, enmity has always
existed amongst themselves. This is particularly visible in the “small house” concept, which is succinctly
explored by Masitera in Now I Can Play. In one of the stories, a man's wife and his mistress compete for
him, and both emerge out of the competition as the man’s "captives". In another story, a girl escapes an
attempted rape and is told by her mother to keep silent about it or she will "be ruined for life". The raped girl
stands accused of inviting the attempted rape. The second story clearly highlights moments of
unacknowledged women experiences that are a result irresponsible responses from the other women;
particularly in the mother – daughter, wife and mistress relations.
CONCLUSION:
In as much as Africana Womanism is global in its approach to an understanding of Africana women’s realities,
it is weakened because of the diversity of localized realities, particularly inherent in the African continent.
Addressing diverse realities of Zimbabwean women under a single rubric is always problematic. It can be
argued that there are no simple ways of representing the diverse struggles and histories that characterize
Zimbabwean women. However foregrounding Zimbabwean women as a category allows an exploration of the
links among the histories and struggles against various forms of violence inflicted on them. In any case, we
“must remember that women in general belong to different socioeconomic groups” and because “the majority
of black women are poor and illiterate, the process of reflection in language and naming their struggles is
reserved for the privileged in the academy” (Ntiri – Quenum 2007, 315). Such academic efforts “may have
little direct or immediate consequence for the woman trapped in the segregated ghettoes of America or the
resource less villages in Southern Africa” (Ntiri-Quenum 2007, 315). Other realities are also overshadowed by
approaches that insist on women as victims and even as the center and source of humanity. This approach
thrives on what Helen Washington has termed “the sacred cow attitude”. This attitude bars women writers and
critics alike from exploring the often-ignored side of women lives and qualities. Women are not only victims,
they also victimize. Women are not always sources of life, they destroy life and when they do that such actions
should not be justified. We have women who are very bad wives and mothers. On the other flip of the coin, a
sacred cow attitude would not appreciate the many good men around who also hate all forms of violence
against their women. The favorable position therefore is progressive merging of the existing women theories as
well as coming up with approaches that are local based.
REFERENCES:
[1] Asante, M. K. (1987), “The Afrocentric Idea”, Temple University Press: Philaldelphia.
[2] Christiansen, L. B. (2007), Mai Mujuru: Father of the Nation. In “Manning the nation: Father figures in
Zimbabwean literature and society”, eds. R. Muponde and K. Muchemwa, 88 – 101. Weaver Press: Harare.
[3] Christiansen, L. B. (2012), “What Would Vera Write?”: Reflections on Zimbabwean Feminist
Discourses on Gender – Power. In Emerging Perspectives on Yvonne Vera, eds. H. Cousins and P.
Dogson-Katiyo, 203 - 222. Africa World Press: London.
[4] Dangarembga, T. (1988), “Nervous Conditions”, Zimbabwe Publishing House: Harare.
[5] Dangarmbga, T. (1987), “She No Longer Weeps”, College Press: Harare.
[6] Dobrota, P. (2012), Desire, Pleasure, and Freedom in Butterfly Burning. In “Emerging Perspectives on
Yvonne Vera”, eds. H. Cousins and P. Dogson-Katiyo, 185 – 202. Africa World Press: London
[7] Gappah, P. (2009), “An Elegy for Easterly”, Faber: London.
[8] Hudson - Weems, C. (2007), “Africana Womanist Literary Theory” (A Sequel to Africana Womanism:
Reclaiming Ourselves), Africa World Press: Trenton.
[9] Hudson - Weems, C. (2007), Nommo/Self-Naming, Self Definition and the History of Africana
Womanism. In “Contemporary Africana Theory, Thought and Action: A Guide to Africana Studies”, ed.
C. Hudson - Weeems 289 -308, Africa World Press: Asmara.
[10] Lara, M. P. (1998), “Moral Textures: Feminist Narratives in the Public Sphere”, University of
California Press: California.
[11] Lyons, T. (2004), “Guns and Guerillas Girls: Women in the Zimbabwean Liberation Struggle”, Africa
World Press: Asmara.
[12] Muchemwa, K. (2005), Some Thoughts on Historical Memory and Writing in Zimbabwe. In
“Versions of Zimbabwe, New Approaches to Literature and Culture”, eds. R. Muponde and R.
Primorac 195 – 202. Weaver Press: Harare.
[13] Muchemwa, K. (2010), “Old and New Fictions: Rearranging the Geographies of Urban Space and
Identities in Post – 2006 Zimbabwean Fiction”, English Academy Review: Southern African Journal
of English Studies, 27(2): 134 – 145.
[14] Ntiri- Quenum, D. (2007), Africana Womanism: The Coming of Age. In “Contemporary Africana
Theory, Thought and Action: A Guide to Africana Studies”, ed. C. Hudson - Weems 309 – 318 Africa
World Press: Asmara.
[15] Nyamubaya, F. (1988), “On the Road Again”, Mambo Press: Gweru.
[16] Primorac, R. (2006), “The Place of Tears: The Novel and Politics in Zimbabwe”, Tauris Academic
Books: New York.
[17] Tagwira, V. (2006), “The Uncertainty of Hope”, Weaver Press: Harare.
[18] Vera, Y. (2002), “The Stone Virgins”, Weaver Press: Harare.
[19] Wheeler, B. A. (2007), Africana Womanism- An African Legacy: It Ain’t Easy Being a Queen. In
“Contemporary Africana Theory, Thought and Action: A Guide to Africana Studies”, ed. C. Hudson –
Weeems, 319 -331, Africa World Press: Asmara.
[20] Wild – Veit, F. (1992), “Teachers, Preachers, Non – Believers: A Social History of Zimbabwean
Literature”, Baobab Books: Harare.
----
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.–IV, Issue–1(1), January 2013[13]
ResearchersWorld -Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
i
Nomno is an African term that Asante has defined as “the generative and productive power of the word” (Asante 1987, 17)
ii
This part of the discussion is a component taken from ongoing PHD research.
iii
http://www.jstor.org/pss
iv
ibid
v
The same theme is explored in the film Neria, which is based on a script written by Tsitsi Dangarembga. The
protagonist of this film struggles after the death of her husband. The late husband’s relatives are prepared to disinherit
and victimize the widow
vi
The same theme is explored in the film Neria, which is based on a script written by Tsitsi Dangarembga. The
protagonist of this film struggles after the death of her husband. The late husband’s relatives are prepared to disinherit
and victimize the widow.
vii
newZimbabweSituation.com, 3 June 2010
viii
Lene Bull, www.od.dk
ix
Also named the ‘lost decade’