Arms and The Man PDF
Arms and The Man PDF
Arms and The Man PDF
Man
Study Guide by Course Hero
engage in witty banter, and the plot tightly twists around British.
mistaken identities, romantic entanglements, and secrets "in
the family closet," all of which are resolved through love at the Another such play in the satiric comedy mode is Englishman
end. Above all, Wilde's drama satirizes British society and its Brandon Thomas's (1848–1914) Charley's Aunt (1893). Such
class hypocrisy as well as the institution of marriage. plays poke fun at the idea that marriage to someone within
one's class was the be-all and end-all of social success and,
Wilde's play includes a number of parallels to Arms and the indeed, happiness. They do so by emphasizing the shallowness
Man true to the genre of a Victorian romantic comedy. For of the players in the game of love. Often, a lie told between
example, one of Wilde's characters lies about his own name. In lovers is at the center of the plot. In Thomas's play, a male
Arms and the Man, a young lady lies to her love about an character masquerades as an elderly woman to help in a
encounter with another man while he lies to her about his friend's courtship.
feelings for her maid. While Shaw portrays various young
characters falling in love and living happily ever after, he also Shaw sets Arms and the Man in Bulgaria during the Serbo-
portrays the older characters, Catherine and Paul Petkoff, as Bulgarian War. This setting is at a remove from Britain, and
the logical end result of love and courtship. Catherine worries Britain had no involvement in the Serbo-Bulgarian War. Going
about whether Paul yells at the servants, and Paul dismisses into little detail about the war itself, Shaw uses the war to
Catherine's silly prattle about how the war should have been satirize the romantic ideas of heroism in battle. He also gently
handled. Both Petkoffs lie to one another just as Wilde's inserts references to his own socialist ideals through the
characters lie to the objects of their affections. Wilde's elderly romances between upper-class Sergius and the maid Louka
pair Miss Prism and the Rev. Canon Chasuble conclude The and upper-class Raina and the soldier-for-hire Bluntschli.
Importance of Being Earnest by declaring their love for one Shaw's later and best-known play, Pygmalion (1913), satirizes
another. both the class system in Britain and the inequality of the sexes
through the portrayal of protagonist Eliza Doolittle. In the play
Gilbert and Sullivan wrote a number of very popular operettas, Eliza is plucked off the streets of London where she was
beginning with Thespis in 1871 and ending with The Grand Duke selling flowers, taken into Henry Higgins's home to be taught
in 1896. All their works have some level of social commentary upper-class diction in the English language, and trained to
on subjects, including the legal system in Trial by Jury (1875), behave as a member of the upper class. However, she could
the royal navy in H.M.S. Pinafore (1878), and copyright laws in never be accepted as such due to her low birth.
The Pirates of Penzance (1879).
the beginning of Act 1. one of the ways in which Shaw, as a Fabian, tried to influence
his fellow Britons. Throughout the play, there are subtle
Prince Alexander I of Bulgaria (1857–93) was not quick to messages as to Shaw's feelings about class. For example, in
accept an armistice (a truce between warring parties). He Arms and the Man, the members of the Petkoff family and
accepted it only after Austria-Hungary threatened to enter the Sergius are portrayed as being upper-class society people. In
war in Serbia's defense. Because it is exactly what Prince contrast, the servants Louka and Nicola and the soldier
Alexander also wanted, Catherine's statement in Act 2 is Bluntschli are of a lower class. Though Bluntschli comes from a
humorous. She says the Bulgarians "could have annexed moneyed family, as a Swiss citizen he has no rank or title.
Servia and made Prince Alexander emperor of the Balkans. Raina and Sergius speak to each other in high-minded ways
That's what I would have done." and prance about acting as if they are special. However, both
Raina and Sergius find that they can only have real
The Treaty of Bucharest (1886) was entered on March 3, 1886.
conversations with the lower-class people: Raina with
This is the treaty about which the characters are speaking at
Bluntschli and Sergius with Louka. It is as if their upper-class
the beginning of Act 2.
happiness is no more than a façade they have to put on to
preserve appearances.
Shaw's Fabian Socialist Views Shaw also makes light of the idea that being a member of the
upper class conveys or is evidence of merit. For example,
George Bernard Shaw was an early and very active member of Sergius and even the older, more competent Major Petkoff are
the Fabian Society. It was named for a Roman general, Fabius at a loss as to how to write the necessary orders in Act 3. They
Cunctator (c. 280–03 BCE), who avoided pitched battles but have to enlist the lower-class (and, indeed, lower-ranking)
instead wore down his opponents. The Fabians were a middle- Bluntschli to help them. Sergius says of this, "He finds out what
class intellectual socialist group who aimed to transform British to do; draws up the orders; and I sign 'em. Division of labor."
society without revolution. Rather, they hoped to permeate the Later in the same act, Louka asks Sergius, "Did you find ... that
country's intellectual and political life. They attempted to the men whose fathers are poor ... were any less brave than
infiltrate the Liberal and Conservative political parties, the two the men who are rich like you?" Sergius responds in the
main political parties in England at that time, with their socialist negative. In the end, both Raina and Sergius realize they are
ideas. However, they eventually ended up helping to organize happier with someone who is not a member of their class.
the Labor Representation Committee, which in 1906 became Class is irrelevant. Shaw encodes such messages in a light,
the British Labor Party, one of the main political parties in romantic comedy, giving the audience food for thought long
Britain today. after the curtain has gone down.
alcoholic—all of which reduced the family to living in genteel from the 19th-century stereotype of the male-dominated,
poverty. His mother—the daughter of a well-to-do sweetly fragile, self-sacrificing female.
family—found escape from the family difficulties in music. A
professional singer and student of the conductor George
Vandeleur Lee, she eventually followed him to London to Career as a Playwright
pursue her own career and improve her situation. These life
events encouraged Shaw to be a lifelong teetotaler (person Shaw's career as a playwright began in 1891 when he met J.T.
who does not drink alcohol). They also imbued him with a Grein (1862–1935), the director of The Independent Theatre—a
strong interest in music and kindled his sensitivity to the plight new, progressive venue for "the theatre of ideas" inspired by
of women in Victorian society (1837–1901). the realistic "problem plays" of Norwegian dramatist Henrik
Ibsen (1828–1906). Grein offered to read Shaw's play
In 1876 Shaw joined his mother and Vandeleur Lee in London.
Widowers' Houses. He accepted it almost immediately, and it
He expanded his knowledge of music to include literature. He
was first publicly performed in 1892. Over the next six years,
read voraciously, attended socialist lectures and debates, and
Shaw completed a collection of dramas called Plays Pleasant
pursued a career in journalism and writing. His first attempts to
and Unpleasant. Each attacked with varied ferocity the social
write prose—a string of five novels—were rejected by
evils of the day. Arms and the Man was part of this collection
publishers. However, he did land a job as a freelance critic for
and satirized romantic ideas of war and heroism. It was first
an influential daily paper, the Pall Mall Gazette. The liberal
produced in 1894 and published in 1898. It was made into a
political leanings of the paper were in line with Shaw's growing
musical, The Chocolate Soldier (1908), which was successful
interest in socialism (social and economic practice where the
but in which Shaw did not cooperate.
government owns and controls property and resources). His
articles and critiques of art, music, and theater written for this Shaw's writing successes continued to the eve of World War I
and other publications brought him at last to the attention of (1914–18), when Pygmalion opened in Vienna in 1913 and in
London literary society. London in 1914. It was a hit. However, with the outbreak of war,
Shaw's plain-spoken antiwar views and pamphlets created
uproar. He was shunned by friends and ostracized by the
Socialism public. Nevertheless, he continued writing plays, and by 1923,
with the production of Saint Joan, he succeeded in reviving his
Shaw's interest in socialism had a profound effect on his career. In 1925, Shaw was the recipient of the Nobel Prize in
writing. In 1884 he joined the recently established Fabian Literature. He also won an Academy Award for screenwriting
Society, a British socialist organization intent on advancing the for the 1938 film adaptation of Pygmalion. A musical
principles of non-Marxist evolutionary socialism (peaceful adaptation, My Fair Lady, opened on Broadway in 1956.
transition from capitalism to socialism in contrast to the ideas
of German philosopher Karl Marx [1818–83]). He became one Shaw continued writing until his death on November 2, 1950, at
of its leading members and regularly wrote and lectured on age 94. At the time, he was working on yet another play.
experience with the idea that gray areas exist. Not all soldiers
are brave, not all cowards are bad, and not all lies are Louka
unforgivable.
Louka is very clever, and she sees everything. She is the one
who tells Raina that the shutters can be opened, and she
Bluntschli knows that someone can come in. Although she isn't Sergius's
equal in class, she is more than his equal in intelligence. She
feels she shouldn't be kept down by her low station. Moreover,
Bluntschli is a very practical sort of fellow. He wants to make
she is not willing to degrade herself.
money by being in the war, but he doesn't particularly want to
die. However, he isn't as cowardly as he would have Raina
believe, and he also isn't as mercenary. He doesn't want to hurt
anyone. Rather, he wants adventure and to live his life. Nicola
Nicola is a man who knows his place and wants to be safe. He
Sergius doesn't want to defy the Petkoffs, and he warns Louka against
doing so. However, in the end, he is willing to give up his claim
on her to see her rise in class. He is a capable servant and
Sergius is a very conflicted character. He has always believed
hopes to be rewarded for that in the end.
that he has to be a certain way—a brave soldier and a
worshipful admirer to Raina. The war and the servant Louka
challenge these beliefs. He comes across as sort of a
cardboard cutout of a man, but he wants to be more than that.
Catherine
Catherine is presented as a very typical woman of her era. She
can be bribed by her husband with pretty things, as with the
bet over a piece of jewelry. She sets a standard for Raina to be
a perfect woman who never lies or does anything wrong. In
fact, she does lie to her husband, as she is never really herself
around him. She is also very concerned about what people
think. She worries people will think the Petkoffs are low-class
for yelling for the servants or because Raina made a poor
marriage.
Petkoff
Petkoff is smarter than his family would believe. He sees what
is going on most of the time. He realizes Sergius is something
of a buffoon and also that Raina put a photograph in the coat
for someone to find. He also realizes the coat was missing in
the first place. He is not an expert on military tactics, but he
knows he isn't and is willing to delegate.
Character Map
Servant
Bluntschli
Swiss professional
soldier; fights with
the Servians
Nicola Sergius
Protector
Sensible manservant Bulgarian soldier
Engaged
Engaged
Raina
Sympathetic young woman
Servant
Father
Louka Petkoff
Mother
Coquettish servant girl Bulgarian major
Employer Married
Catherine
Haughty middle-aged
woman
Main Character
Minor Character
They get to talking about that day's battle. The man says he
k Plot Summary
was certainly fearful, as every soldier is once he's been in
battle for three days. He also comments the Bulgarian army
wasn't very professional, sending in soldiers they knew would
be killed. The only reason they weren't killed was that the
Preface Serbians had the wrong kind of cartridges for their guns. He
describes the man who led the cavalry charge in a way that
The preface was written at a later date for the publication of makes him sound not very heroic and somewhat buffoonish.
several of Shaw's plays in book form. In it Shaw mentions that Raina shows him Sergius's picture and asks if he was the
it is difficult to decide what to write. Although he wants to write cavalry leader. The man says it was and apologizes. Raina tells
something meaningful, it must also be something common him to leave. He says he can't climb the drainpipe again. He'd
people will want to see, so it can make a profit. In addition to just as soon die. In fact, dying would just be a long sleep, and
Arms and the Man, Shaw mentions other plays, including he's very tired. Raina takes pity on him and says he can take
Candida (1894) and Widowers' Houses (1892). refuge in their home. After all, he is a guest and the duties of a
Act 2, Section 1 military matter when Petkoff says he wants his coat, which he
cannot find. Catherine says it's in the closet and sends Nicola
to get it. While she is gone, Petkoff takes bets on whether or
Several months later, Sergius and Major Petkoff are coming
not the coat will be found. Nicola returns with the coat, which
home from war. Petkoff is pleased at having won, while Sergius
he found in the closet where it belongs. Bluntschli completes
announces he is going to resign from the military. They tell a
his work and Sergius, Petkoff, and Catherine go off to deliver
story they heard from a Swiss soldier, who said he had
the orders.
escaped harm by hiding in a young lady's bedroom and then
snuck off, wearing the master of the house's coat. Catherine Left alone with Bluntschli, Raina tells him that Petkoff and
and Raina appear offended by this story. Meanwhile, Louka Sergius heard about him hiding in a lady's room but don't know
and her fellow servant, Nicola, to whom she is engaged, have that she is the lady. She says Sergius would challenge him to a
figured out that something is up. duel and kill him if he knew. What's more, she says it is hard for
her to lie to Sergius because she never lies. Bluntschli says he
Sergius and Raina dramatically declare their love for one
thinks she lies all the time, as does he. He also says he admires
another and plan an outing.
her. Raina tells Bluntschli that he is the first man not to take
her seriously, and he says he is the first man who has. She says
she puts on a noble attitude in front of everyone, implying it is
Act 2, Section 2 an act. They all believe her. Raina tells Bluntschli she left a
portrait of herself in the coat, for him to find. However, he didn't
After Raina leaves to get ready, Louka talks to Sergius. Sergius
see it and thinks it might still be in the coat. It might not be,
declares how tiring "higher love" is, meaning the type of love he
though, since he also pawned the coat for a while. Raina is
has with Raina. They always have to make dramatic
horrified because she wrote something on the portrait.
declarations of the other's perfection, and he is unable to be
himself. Louka says there was a man in Raina's bedroom. She Louka comes in with mail for Sergius, saying that his father is
heard enough of their conversation to know that if the man dead. She and Nicola discuss that she has ideas above her
returned, Raina would marry him. They had a real conversation, station.
unlike Raina and Sergius. This upsets Sergius, and he grabs
Louka's arm, bruising her. At the same time, though, they are
also flirting. Louka asks Sergius to cure the bruise. He Act 3, Section 2
apologizes and offers her money, but she wants a kiss, which
he will not give. Sergius and Louka argue about Sergius caring too much what
others think. She says if she were the empress of Russia, she
Raina and Catherine enter. After Sergius leaves the room to
would marry the man she loved even if he was beneath her. But
talk with Petkoff, they discuss how much trouble they'd be in if
Sergius doesn't have that kind of courage. Sergius says she is
the men knew about the man in Raina's room. Raina, however,
just jealous of Raina. Louka says she knows Raina really loves
still seems enamored with the man and says she'd stuff him
Bluntschli, not him. Sergius says that if he were to love Louka,
with chocolates if he came back. Just then, Bluntschli, the very
he would marry her in spite of what Bulgaria thinks. If he
same soldier, arrives to return Petkoff's jacket. Catherine begs
touches her again, it will be as his fiancée.
him to sneak out and plans to send back his duffel bag after
she extracts Petkoff's coat from it. But before he can go, Sergius challenges Bluntschli to a duel. Bluntschli protests
Petkoff and Sergius come into the room. Recognizing Raina only allowed him in her room because he held a pistol to
Bluntschli, whom they know, they invite him to stay at the her head. Raina realizes that it was Louka who told Sergius the
house. truth. She knows Sergius has been making love to Louka.
Plot Diagram
Climax
7
10 Falling Action
Rising Action
6
11
5
4 12
3 Resolution
2
1
Introduction
Introduction Climax
1. There is shooting outside, so Raina closes her shutters. 9. Sergius challenges Bluntschli to a duel.
2. A man (Bluntschli) breaks into Raina's room. 10. Bluntschli learns his father died and left him everything.
3. Raina protects the man from an officer looking for him. 11. Sergius bravely becomes engaged to Louka.
5. Months later, Petkoff and Sergius return home from the war.
Resolution
6. Bluntschli returns Petkoff's coat, which Raina gave him.
12. Bluntschli is deemed an acceptable match for Raina.
7. Bluntschli and Raina flirt; they are clearly in love.
Timeline of Events
Little later
Soon after
Afterward
Next
Minutes later
March 1886
Minutes later
Moments later
Then
Next
Little later
Moment later
Next
Then
Moment later
Next
Then
In the end
Preface would make a good comic opera to "try his hand" at it.
Next, he started A Man of Destiny (1897) and also wrote You It's interesting Shaw mentions comic opera because Arms and
Never Can Tell (1896). Shaw characterizes these as attempts the Man was indeed turned into a successful comic opera
to write something like Arms and the Man while keeping in mind called The Chocolate Soldier. When an Austrian composer
the needs of West End theater managers searching for approached Shaw about writing it, Shaw insisted that he was
fashionable comedies. not to use the play's original wording. Perhaps for that reason,
the comic opera is very unlike Arms and the Man. When he saw
Shaw says authors can't expect theater managers to invest
it, Shaw didn't like it at all. In fact, he said he would never allow
money in plays that "commonplace people"—as he calls
another comic opera to be based on one of his plays. Still, The
them—will not see. Playwriting and running theaters are
Chocolate Soldier was so popular with audiences in London
businesses. He speaks of unscrupulous managers who try to
and New York that MGM wanted to turn it into a movie with the
make the maximum profit with the minimum risk. Shaw believes
same title (1941). Shaw refused to allow them to use the plot of
theater managers should try to produce plays of the highest
Arms and the Man, so the movie is actually based on another worried she only thought he looked good because she had
comic opera entirely. romantic ideas from reading poetry and going to the opera.
The amount Shaw states that Arms and the Man made in its Raina's servant, Louka, enters and tells them they must close
first run is equivalent to £229.053.67 today (at this writing, the windows because there has been shooting in the streets.
2019)—almost $300,000.00 U.S. dollars. The Serbians are being chased back through the pass and may
run into town. The Bulgarian cavalry is chasing them. Raina and
In retrospect, the plays Shaw would have termed too Catherine are alarmed, and Raina says she wishes their people
controversial or unpleasant to attract a wide audience are weren't so cruel. "What glory is there in killing wretched
probably Shaw's most successful and well-remembered plays. fugitives?" Catherine goes downstairs, cautioning Raina to
They include Arms and the Man, Pygmalion, and Saint Joan. close the shutters. Louka tells Raina she can open the
Critical acclaim was given to his 1901 play Caesar and shutters. One of the bolts at the bottom is broken, so it doesn't
Cleopatra, specifically for the human rather than heroic close properly. Raina says they have to do as they're told.
portrayal of Caesar.
After Louka leaves, Raina ostentatiously admires the portrait of
Readers might wonder how Shaw would have responded to My Sergius, exclaiming about how he is her hero. Gunfire is heard
Fair Lady, the 1956 U.S. musical based on Pygmalion. Shaw had outside, and Raina blows out the candles. Immediately
died in 1950, so librettist Alan Jay Lerner (1918–86) and afterward, the shutters open, and a man sneaks in.
composer Frederick Loewe (1901–88) did not have to worry
about getting his permission. When My Fair Lady was first The person who entered is a soldier, about 35 years old, of
produced, it ran longer than any previous musical in both New average appearance, in the tattered uniform of a Serbian
York and London. It was translated into several other officer. The script identifies him as "man." He has climbed up
languages and performed around the world. Since then it has the balcony. He threatens Raina if she sounds the alarm,
undergone a number of revivals. My Fair Lady was also made saying he doesn't intend to get killed. She remarks haughtily
into an Academy Award–winning movie (1964) starring Rex that some soldiers are afraid of death. He says they all are. He
Harrison as Henry Higgins and Audrey Hepburn as Eliza. says if she calls for help and he doesn't shoot her, they'll all see
her in her nightgown. She goes to get her cloak, and he takes
it, saying it is a better weapon than a revolver. She says it's not
Act 1, Section 1 the weapon a gentleman would choose. He hears someone
approaching and gives her back her cloak. Impulsively, Raina
hides him behind the curtains then takes off the cloak, the
tells her of his heroism. However, she also feels guilty for exposure to young men to see them as real, flesh-and-blood
having doubted it. It is possible she also suspects Sergius isn't human beings. (After all, she has no brothers.) Instead, Raina
the brightest of bulbs, but she would rather not know it. sees men, such as Sergius, as larger-than-life idols to be
worshiped. Thus, she venerates Sergius's photograph, hoping
Her feelings are also complicated by her feelings about war in against hope that he will live up to the faith she has placed in
general. While her mother is more than ready to take a side, him.
Raina isn't as sure. In truth, she is something of a pacifist—a
person who is opposed to war or violence. She says that there The soldier, unlike her revered Sergius, is obviously bright and
is no glory "in killing wretched fugitives." This is at odds with quick on his feet. She is impressed with him, and this is part of
wanting her fiancée to be a war hero. However, this explains what motivates her to help him. Helping him hide may well be
why she helps the man when she could just as well sound the the bravest and most self-motivated thing Raina has ever done.
alarm when the Bulgarian officer shows up. It is likely that up until now she has acted based on her
understanding of what her parents and society expect from
Shaw is interested in pointing out the difference between her.
fanciful ideals and real life. Raina's love for Sergius and her
concern for his conduct in war are based on unrealistic Shaw's lengthy description of the scenery both here and later,
concepts of romance and heroism. When faced with the idea in the library, are worth noting. Playwrights do not always
of real people being chased down and killed, she has a describe every detail of the set, but Shaw does so here for a
completely different response. This ethical conflict is apparent reason. The characters who live in this house are upper class,
from the very first scene in the play. The absolute idealism of as Raina will take pains to tell the man later in the act.
the romantic couple in a satirical comedy is a common trope of They—especially Catherine—care very much about
the genre. In this particular play, the overpowering idea of love appearances. However, the décor in Raina's bedroom, a room
runs into the reality that people are far from ideal in either love few outsiders will enter, is both cheap and shabby. The shutter
or war. The collision of idealism and reality in battle serves as a is broken. Meanwhile, she wears expensive furs, as that is an
reflection of the title Arms and the Man, which is a phrase outer garment that will be seen by many. The family is,
taken from the Roman poet Virgil's (70–19 BCE) epic, the perhaps, not as wealthy as they would like people to believe
Aeneid (c. 30 BCE). Virgil had been requested (or coerced) into they are. It is possible they are looking to Raina's marriage to
writing it as a work praising the noble origins of the Romans by Sergius to improve their situation or, at least, hers.
the Emperor Augustus (63 BCE–14 CE), but Virgil embedded
the work with any number of subtle digs at this view. For
example, Aeneas and his followers have escaped the fall of Act 1, Section 2
Troy (during which he somehow manages to save his son and
father but loses his wife) and landed, exhausted, in Queen
Dido's realm, where he begs her for help. It is clear from his
Summary
description of his flight that Aeneas isn't much of a fighter, and
he relies on Dido very much as the Serbian soldier must rely on
After they all leave, Raina is again alone with the man. He tells
Raina's compassion.
her he is not Serbian but a Swiss mercenary, or a soldier for
hire. Her asks if he can wait a bit to leave, and Raina says she
It seems that this meeting with the Serbian soldier is the first
wishes he weren't in danger. She's shocked to notice his gun
time Raina has had anyone validate her secret feelings about
has been left on the ottoman. He says not to worry, as it isn't
war. It remains to be seen whether this is because she hasn't
loaded. He carries not cartridges but chocolate with him; he
met anyone who agrees or because no one has considered her
says many soldiers do so. Raina is "outraged in her most
an adult with valid opinions. However, it is likely a combination
cherished ideals of manhood" that he should stuff his pockets
of these reasons.
with chocolate "like a schoolboy." Still, she offers him some of
Raina is very surprised when the man says all soldiers fear her chocolate.
death. This is probably because no one has admitted that to
He eats it, saying he's not very brave, that no one is after
her before. It may also be because she hasn't had enough
they've been under fire for three days. But he didn't think the
Bulgarian soldiers were very professional. They sent in a mamma: the poor dear is worn out. Let him sleep."
cavalry, knowing that none of them would survive. They only
survived because the Serbian soldiers had the wrong
cartridges and couldn't fire on them. He describes the cavalry Analysis
charge as "slinging a handful of peas against a window pane."
First one comes, then a few more, then a clump. The first man Heroism in battle, or the want of heroism, is a major theme of
is always trying to pull his spooked horse back. No one actually Arms and the Man. Soldiers are supposed to be brave and,
wants to be first. Raina says she doesn't think the first man is a indeed, signing up to be a soldier, if one has other options, is a
coward. The man describes the first man in line today (which brave act. However, it is one thing to be brave when signing up
the audience knows was Sergius) as being like an operatic and another when actually going into battle. It is much the
tenor or Don Quixote. Don Quixote was the main character in a same with climbing the drainpipe. The man says he could climb
novel by the Spanish writer Miguel de Cervantes (1547–1616); it when someone was chasing him, but now, when there is no
the character is delusional and battles with windmills. Raina immediate threat, he can't do it.
shows the man the portrait of Sergius, saying he is her
The reader may well wonder if the man actually means it when
betrothed. She asks if he was the first man.
he says he'd rather die than go down the drainpipe. Perhaps he
The man says he was. He apologizes, saying that perhaps is toying with Raina, having recognized she has a kind heart
Sergius knew they wouldn't fire on him. Raina says this is just and will allow him to stay.
as bad, as it would make him a pretender and a coward. She
As a hired soldier, the man would likely be less concerned
says he can't stay after what he has said about Sergius.
about the outcome of the war or the nobility of the cause. (The
However, she will check and see if the coast is clear. The man
validity of the cause is not discussed in the play. It would likely
says he is too cowardly to climb down the drainpipe now that
not be a huge concern for the British audience for whom the
he isn't in fear of dying as he was while climbing up. He tells her
play was originally written.) Someone with real ties to the
to give the alarm.
country for which he was fighting might be more invested.
Pitying him now, Raina calls him a poor "chocolate cream Logically, the man would want to do a good enough job at
soldier." She says it is better to go down the drainpipe than to soldiering to continue to make a living at one. But he is unlikely
be captured. But the man says "capture only means death; and to want to lay down his life. The reader will learn, however, that
death is sleep—oh, sleep, sleep, sleep, undisturbed sleep!" this man had other choices when it came to a career. Indeed,
When she asks him if he's really that tired, he says he must get he mentions in this scene that his family owns several hotels.
down the drainpipe. This does not seem like the family background of someone
who became a soldier for want of other options. The audience
Now, Raina is concerned and decides to protect him. She says may wonder why he became a mercenary, since he has stated
he can take advantage of their hospitality because the he is not brave.
Petkoffs are the wealthiest family in town. Her father is a major
in the Bulgarian army, and their house is very elegant, boasting Shaw doesn't mention many specifics about the war itself, not
the only library in the city. She says he could throw himself as a even the name of the war. Perhaps he wished to tell a universal
fugitive on their hospitality, which she will offer though her story and so set it in a country whose politics would be a
father is out of town. The man says his own father owns mystery to his British audiences.
several hotels, implying they also understand hospitality.
Raina is deeply confused by the man's admission that he
Raina offers her hand to make a pledge. The man says he carries chocolates in his pocket, rather than replacement
daren't take it, as it has been a while since he last washed. cartridges for his pistol. Indeed, the stage directions state that
Raina says her family washes every day. However, she insists Raina is "outraged in her most cherished ideas of manhood" at
he take her hand, so he kisses it. She leaves him to tell her hearing this. Yet she wants to give the soldier more chocolate.
mother what she's doing. He says he'll remain standing, but as What he has said makes him into a human being rather than an
soon as Raina leaves, he climbs into her bed and falls asleep. unapproachable hero, as she views Sergius.
Catherine comes in and is scandalized, but Raina says, "Don't,
The term chocolate soldier came to mean a soldier who didn't
inspired him in war, and Raina bemoans that she had no such There is a marked contrast in the dialogue between Sergius
way to prove her worthiness of him. They hear Louka and Raina and the one between Nicola and Louka, the
approaching, and Raina excuses herself to dress to go out. servants. The servants talk about practical things in a practical
way. This is Shaw's way of pointing out the difference between
the different classes of people in the play. It also explains why
Analysis the man, like Louka, speaks candidly. He does not come from
old money as the Petkoffs do.
Catherine's statement that the Bulgarians should have been
allowed to force the other side to submit to their rule shows
her lack of knowledge about what is actually going on in the Act 2, Section 2
war. The fact that her husband doesn't even attempt to
discuss it with her may indicate that he doesn't take her
seriously. He may well see her as a silly woman who can't know
the truth. It also reflects common Victorian notions that women
Summary
needed to be protected from brutal truths and were not
Sergius asks Louka if she is familiar with "higher love," saying it
intellectually capable of dealing with political intricacies. This is
is a very tiring thing to practice. He says he is many different
in contrast to the way the man in Act 1 spoke to Raina, as if she
people, depending who he is with. There are about a half-
were an intelligent human being who could understand
dozen Sergiuses. He flirts with Louka, who warns Raina will be
complex ideas.
spying on him but that Raina has also flirted with someone
Meanwhile, Catherine also lies to her husband, not telling him else. Louka says she's heard the man and Raina talking and
what happened with the prisoner even when it is directly knows that, if the man returns, Raina will marry him. She says, "I
brought up. Despite years of marriage, Catherine and Paul know the difference between the sort of manner you and she
Petkoff do not—and perhaps cannot—speak candidly with one put on before one another and the real manner."
another.
Sergius gets angry and grasps Louka's arm. He scolds her for
In their first scene together, Raina and Sergius talk to each betraying her mistress and having the soul of a servant. She
other in elaborate terms. He calls her "my queen" while she says he can hurt her with his tongue as well as his hands. She
talks about how unworthy she is of him. It is difficult to believe says that Raina is a liar, and she is worth six of Raina. Sergius
that they believe these things. Moreover, they seem to hold apologizes for hurting her. She says that won't do, and he
each other to an impossibly high standard. Because of this, offers her money. She says no, she wants her hurt made well.
were Sergius to want to express some of the misgivings He asks how, and she shows him her bruised arm, which she
expressed by the man in the first act, he wouldn't be able to. wants him to kiss. He refuses, and she walks away, injured.
He would risk disappointing his worshipful fiancée. Raina returns, joking about whether Sergius has been flirting
with Louka.
Meanwhile, Sergius's statement that soldiering is "the coward's
art of attacking mercilessly when you are strong and keeping Catherine enters and tells Sergius that Petkoff won't listen to
out of harm's way when you are weak" sounds more likely to her ideas about his three regiments, and Sergius should speak
have come from Shaw's mind than his character's. Shaw, the to him. Raina makes him promise to hurry. After Sergius leaves,
playwright, was a pacifist—a person opposed to war and Catherine says she's upset that the man told the story of their
violence. However, Sergius's statement may actually arise from keeping him there. Petkoff asked for his coat as soon as he
post-traumatic stress disorder, PTSD, a psychological came home. Raina expresses anger but in affectionate terms,
condition that occurs when someone suffers extreme stress, saying if he was here, she'd cram him with chocolates so he
such as a near-death experience. An attack such as the couldn't speak. She asks Raina how long the man was there
cavalry charge described by the man in Act 1 (in which Sergius before Raina summoned Catherine. Raina says she doesn't
was the lead man) might well cause such symptoms. However, remember, and Catherine warns if Sergius finds out, he will
Sergius does not express any of this to Raina, wanting instead break off his engagement with Raina. Raina says she wishes
to keep up his perfect façade. her mother could marry Sergius, instead of her. She, Raina,
always wants to shock Sergius because he is so proper and love. She could tell that the man and Raina are really talking to
stuffy. She wishes he would find out. one another and in love. In contrast, Raina and Sergius just act
the way they think they're supposed to when they're in love.
Raina leaves, and Louka comes in, saying there is a Serbian This is what Sergius is referring to when he talks about "higher
soldier, Captain Bluntschli, there to see the lady of the house. love" and how tiring it is. He means it's tiring never to be
Catherine realizes this is the same soldier they harbored, there allowed to be a real person with normal emotions and normal
to return the coat. Catherine tells Louka to let him in, be sure to failings. Rather, he has to live his life as the valiant soldier in
close the library door, and bring his bag (which contains the Raina's portrait and subscribe to only an ideal of love rather
coat) to her. than genuine feelings. Were Sergius and Raina to have gotten
married, it is entirely likely they would end up like Raina's
Bluntschli—the script identifies him thus, whereas previously he
parents.
was identified only as the man—enters. Catherine warns there
will be horrible consequences if her husband finds out he was The bruise on Louka's arm is the result of a show of honest
there since he still has a terrible animosity toward the enemy. emotion. When Louka asks Sergius to kiss it away, his
He should leave the coat and sneak out the back. She'll have response is also passionate. His desire is clear, but he is also
his bag sent to him. As Bluntschli is writing his address so she committed to fidelity. Flirtation is acceptable, but to go further
can send the bag, Petkoff and Sergius come in. They would break the code of behavior he has chosen to live by.
immediately recognize Bluntschli and greet him warmly, belying Clearly, Sergius is a gentleman through and through—at least
Catherine's words. They say he should have been brought to with Raina. He would never dream of harming her and is
the library and ask his advice on the military matter they were shocked that his feelings for Louka have resulted in his
considering. As they are taking him to another room to discuss harming her. Shaw contrasts the fake love of Raina and
it, Raina enters. Seeing Bluntschli, who is not nearly the Sergius with the real, more passionate love between Louka
imposing figure that Sergius is, she exclaims, "Oh, the and Sergius. However, the raising of bruises goes too far.
chocolate cream soldier!" Somewhere between the blatantly artificial conduct between
Raina and Sergius and that sort of conduct is the ideal. This
Raina tries to cover up this error by saying that she made a
may be the respectful discussion between Raina and
chocolate cream soldier ornament for a pudding she was
Bluntschli.
making, but Nicola destroyed it. She didn't mean that Bluntschli
was a chocolate cream soldier. Flirtatiously, he says that he did The honesty between Louka and Sergius (and between Raina
think she meant that. Petkoff remarks that it is strange that and Bluntschli) reflect Shaw's socialist views. Shaw was deeply
Raina was cooking at all and wonders whether Nicola has involved in the Fabian socialist movement, a group that aimed
become clumsy because he is drinking. This suspicion seems to transform British society by infiltrating socialist ideals into
to be confirmed a moment later, when Nicola brings out the country's intellectual and political life. By writing a play
Bluntschli's bag. Catherine covers up having requested the bag showing love that transcends class boundaries, Shaw was
by making it seem like it was Nicola's mistake. The servant attempting to do that. He did not believe that class should be a
takes the bag away again, obedient but obviously annoyed. barrier to marriage or an argument for it.
Petkoff says that Bluntschli should stay with them while he's in Catherine is distressed when Bluntschli shows up in part
town. Raina and Sergius agree he should. Bluntschli, knowing because she worries that her husband is likely to find out about
Catherine wouldn't want him to, refuses, but Petkoff urges her their escapade in November. However, she may also suspect
to tell her it's okay. She does, and Bluntschli agrees to stay. As Raina's passionate feelings for Bluntschli—feelings that are
the curtain goes down, Catherine makes a "gesture of despair." stronger than those she has for her heroic Sergius. Catherine
wants Raina to marry Sergius to maintain the status quo.
Marrying Sergius can help Raina maintain or even better her
Analysis social position, which is very important to Catherine. If Raina
falls in love with Bluntschli and if Sergius finds out about it, that
When Louka tells Sergius she knows the different between his
will be the end of an advantageous match. This is more
manner with Raina and "the real manner," she is talking about
important, in Catherine's eyes, than real love. Based on her
relationship with her husband, it is likely that Catherine made She wants to be perfect with him because their relationship is
and has remained in a similar match herself. In this respect, the beautiful and noble. Also, she has only lied twice in her life. The
shabbiness of their home at the expense of their clothes first, which she should remember, was when she lied on
reflects their attitude on marriage relations. Bluntschli's behalf about his not being there when the officer
came looking for him.
One may wonder why Bluntschli returned at all. It has been
four months since he was in the Petkoffs' house, and he's been Bluntschli says as a soldier, he is used to hearing people
at war. Returning the coat seems of low importance. What's lie—and to having his life saved. Raina says this makes him
more, returning it is more likely to expose the Petkoff women's incapable of gratitude. He asks if she likes gratitude. He says,
hiding him than if the coat had simply gone missing. Therefore, "If pity is akin to love, gratitude is akin to the other thing." She
the audience can presume Bluntschli was willing to risk coming says he doesn't respect women. He says he thinks two lies in
back because he wanted to see Raina again. an entire lifetime is too few. Two lies wouldn't last him a
morning. He says, "When you get into that noble attitude and
speak in that thrilling voice, I admire you; but I find it impossible
Act 3, Section 1 to believe a single word you say."
spite of what Bulgaria thinks. If he touches her again, it will be Catherine enters, angry at Louka, but Louka says she knew
as his fiancée. Raina was in love with Bluntschli. Bluntschli says he knows
Raina would never want to marry someone like him. He has
Sergius goes to Bluntschli and challenges him to a duel in the spoiled all his chances in life through an incurably romantic
morning with sabres, a type of sword. Raina comes in and asks disposition. That's why he ran away to become a soldier
what they're fighting about. Bluntschli promises that he has instead of taking over his father's hotel business. He also
often acted as a sword instructor, so Sergius won't be able to believes she is too young for him, thinking she is only 17 when
hurt him, and he won't hurt Sergius. Rather, he will leave, and he is 34. When he finds out she is 23, he says he will become a
she and Sergius can live happily ever after. Sergius realizes by suitor for her hand.
her reaction that she is in love with Bluntschli and accuses her.
Bluntschli says Raina only allowed him in her room because he Catherine protests that Raina needs a man like Sergius, who is
held a pistol to her head. He orders Sergius to apologize. upper class and keeps 20 horses. Bluntschli says he has 200
horses and 70 carriages. He also has (in his hotel business)
Raina says it is Bluntschli's friend who told the story. He is to thousands of tablecloths, sheets, and quilts. He also is also an
blame. Bluntschli says he is dead, senselessly burned alive. officer and a gentleman and speaks three languages. Finally,
Sergius declares that it is ridiculous. "Oh, war! war! The dream he has the highest rank known in Switzerland; he is a free
of patriots and heroes! A fraud, Bluntschli, a hollow sham, like citizen. Petkoff and Catherine are convinced. Raina, however,
love." Raina is offended, but Sergius doesn't believe there is protests that she is not "to be sold to the highest bidder." She
nothing between her and Bluntschli. Raina realizes Louka was didn't give her hand to kiss, her bed to sleep in, or her roof to
his real informant and says she knows that he has been making shelter to the emperor of Switzerland. She gave them to her
love to Louka. chocolate cream soldier. Bluntschli tells Petkoff to send the
infantry home and Sergius not to get married until Bluntschli
Sergius calls off his duel with Bluntschli. Raina, angry that
returns in two weeks.
Sergius has had Louka spy on her, reminds Sergius that Louka
is engaged to Nicola. They discover Louka listening at the
door. Louka says she isn't ashamed of her behavior. Her love
for Sergius is stronger than anything Raina can feel for her
Analysis
chocolate cream soldier.
In his conversation with Louka, Sergius says that he found he
Just then, Petkoff enters, complaining that his coat was big on was brave in battle. However, he says that a brave man is one
him, as if it were stretched by someone with broader "who will defy to the death any power on earth or in heaven
shoulders. Catherine is altering it. He sends Louka to get the that sets itself up against his own will and conscience."
coat when, just then, Nicola enters with the coat. Raina offers Although Bluntschli says soldiers are never brave, Sergius
to help him put it on, using the opportunity to sneak the seems sincere in his belief that he was. Perhaps he didn't have
photograph out of the pocket and to Bluntschli. Petkoff, time to think about being otherwise, just as Bluntschli was able
however, has already seen the photograph and remarks that it to shimmy up a drainpipe on an adrenaline rush. But by this
is missing. He assumes that Sergius is the intended recipient of statement, he means that bravery in battle isn't true bravery,
the photograph, which was inscribed from Raina "to her merely adrenaline. It is harder to defy societal norms (by, for
Chocolate Cream Solider, a souvenir." example, marrying a maid) than it is to fight in the adrenaline
rush of battle.
Finally, Bluntschli tells Petkoff what happened. Petkoff asks
which of the gentlemen she is engaged to. Raina says that It is clear, here, that he is struggling with this point. Raina is a
Louka is the object of Sergius's affections. Petkoff says that's pleasant girl and pretty. But marrying her will mean a lifetime of
impossible because Louka is engaged to Nicola. Nicola says having to lie about who he really is and be half a dozen
she isn't. He was only covering for her because he knew she different Sergiuses. This may be more difficult than doing what
wanted to marry above her station. Louka demands an apology he wants and being himself. The idea that Raina has cheated
from Sergius. He apologizes and kisses her hand. She declares on him actually gives him an out. If Raina doesn't want to be
they are engaged. with him either, he is off the hook. Thus, he challenges
Bluntschli to a duel, possibly hoping to bring the whole matter
to a head. He has already said, of course, that he possesses Here, Raina tries to make a comparison between Sergius,
the type of bravery necessary to fight a duel. The other kind, whom she believes to be perfect and fearless, and other, more
however, is more difficult for him. mortal men. That she does not see Sergius as a person
capable of human fear seems complimentary to him but, in
Shaw's socialist sensibilities are again revealed in Louka's fact, it shows that she doesn't really know him at all.
question: "Did you find ... that the men whose fathers are poor
... were any less brave than the men who are rich?" Sergius
responds in the negative to this because, of course, social
"All of them, dear lady, all of them,
class and money have little to do with bravery, a point Shaw
wanted to make. believe me. It is our duty to live as
Catherine is appalled at the idea that Raina would marry long as we can."
someone who is merely a soldier for hire. She is only
concerned with what people will think. Of course, this is all — Bluntschli, Act 1, Section 1
cured when she realizes that Bluntschli is rich—very likely
richer than Sergius—now that his father is dead. However,
Here, the man assures Raina that all soldiers fear death. This is
Raina wished to marry him before she found this out.
deeply relatable to Raina because, of course, she is a normal
In the end, both Raina and Sergius realize that they are happier human being with normal fears. But all the military people she
not putting on the false personality necessary to marry each has met have refused to acknowledge fear, so she is shocked
other. Each is happier with someone else. Sergius is happier by it. Shaw didn't mean this acknowledgment of fear to be an
with an intelligent and witty servant. Raina is happier with a admission of weakness on the part of the soldier, but rather, an
capable and straightforward businessman. Thus, class is admission of humanity.
irrelevant. These messages are encoded into a light, romantic
comedy, giving the audience something to think about long
after the curtain has gone down. "It's like slinging a handful of peas
against a window pane. First one
g Quotes comes ... and then all the rest in a
lump."
"What glory is there in killing
— Bluntschli, Act 1, Section 1
wretched fugitives?"
The man describes the cavalry charge, which the audience first
— Raina, Act 1, Section 1
heard described by Catherine in very gallant terms. The terms
in which the man describes it are definitely not gallant. Rather,
Raina's question is in marked contrast to her previous concern they convey the very real fear the man at the head of the
that her fiancée, Sergius, will find glory in battle. Indeed, it charge might feel, wishing his horse had not gotten in front.
seems as if she would not find his victory glorious in any case.
This shows that her feelings are conflicted, between what she
knows she should want and what she actually wants. "Death is sleep—oh, sleep, sleep,
sleep, undisturbed sleep!"
"Some soldiers, I know, are afraid
— Bluntschli, Act 1, Section 2
of death."
— Raina, Act 1, Section 1
The man tells Raina that he might as well die if he has to leave. Here, again, Sergius talks about the reasons he is quitting the
Dying, in his estimation, is easy or, at least, quick. Living, army. He wants to be strong and noble and good, but he found
climbing down a drainpipe and sneaking around, would be far that for a soldier this was not the route to success. He wanted
more difficult. After three days in combat, he simply isn't up to a fair fight, like the duel to which he will later challenge
it. It is eye-opening for Raina to learn that soldiers suffer for Bluntschli. But war isn't fair. It's about trying to get an unfair
lack of everyday needs, such as sleep and food. advantage.
"Don't, mamma: the poor dear is "I know the difference between
worn out. Let him sleep." the sort of manner you and she
put on before one another and the
— Raina, Act 1, Section 2
real manner."
When Catherine sees the man asleep in Raina's bed, she is
appalled. What if anyone found out? But Raina takes a more — Louka, Act 2, Section 1
realistic tack. There are hints of her sympathy early in the act,
when she says that there is no glory in killing wretched Louka, a pragmatist, tells Sergius, a romantic, the truth. He and
fugitives. Even if Raina believes in the cause of the war, she Raina act out a pantomime of love, but they don't really talk to
doesn't believe in killing for its own sake. In the man, she or value each other. What Louka heard between Raina and
doesn't see a dangerous fugitive, but a human being in need. Bluntschli was "the real manner." She also knows that the way
Sergius treats her is honest and real.
were losing it the right way." pity is akin to love, gratitude is akin
to the other thing."
— Sergius, Act 2, Section 1
— Bluntschli, Act 3, Section 1
"I am a brave man. My heart with social rules, not speak honestly.
The Petkoffs' Library betrayal of their cause. They are just desperate for the relief of
uninterrupted sleep.
Just as Shaw portrays soldiers lying about their heroism in war, Shaw was an avowed socialist and believed that the class
he portrays the young lovers lying about love. They lie both to system in Britain at his time was wrong. Birth should not
themselves and to each other. Raina tells herself that she loves determine one's success. Rather, merit should. Shaw was a
Sergius, she adores him, she admires him. However, she barely member of the Fabian Society, whose goal was to take over
knows him and hasn't had a real conversation with him. When not through violence but through gradually changing people's
her mother tells her he was heroic in battle, she is pleased but minds. To help change minds, Shaw inserted socialist ideals,
also relieved. She's never discussed the upcoming battle with such as the ideal of a classless society, into his plays.
him. She's never discussed what it entails, what risk it will pose
to him, or whether he is scared. Rather, she is like a knight's This point is mostly revealed through the character of Louka, a
lady, giving her hero a ribbon and happily waving as he goes off clever, pretty girl who deserves to be rewarded for her
to get run through with a sword. intelligence. Louka is initially described as "so defiant that her
servility to Raina is almost insolent," but she does what she
When Sergius and Raina reunite after the war, he drops to one needs to do. She also knows what's going on in the house. She
knee and kisses her hand. Sergius has just announced he is knows Raina's shutter is broken, she knows Raina has a man in
quitting the army—something that troubles him but which he her room, and she knows Raina loves that man more than she
says anyone who knew him would understand. However, he loves Sergius.
doesn't discuss this with Raina. Rather, they call one another
"my queen" and "my king," and Raina talks about being While Nicola, her fellow servant, knows his place, Louka
unworthy of him. Raina says she thinks they have found a doesn't want to know hers. She considers it cowardly to cling
"higher love." to old beliefs about class. She says if she were queen, she'd be
brave and marry the person she loved even if he were a
When Raina leaves the room, Sergius repeats this phrase to common man. Of course, this is easy for her to say because
Louka, saying he finds "higher love" tiring. But he is not blaming she isn't queen and, if she were, she'd be the one making the
Raina. Rather, he blames himself for not being able to live up to rules. However, this statement has an effect on Sergius. He
her impossible expectations of him. In fact, they both have realizes it is more important to marry someone for whom he
impossible expectations of themselves and of each other. feels true affection than someone of the same class.
Raina believes she can never lie to Sergius but also that to be
worthy of him, she must be perfect in thought, word, and deed. Perhaps part of what persuades him is Louka's question: "Did
Barring that, she must never allow him to realize she is you find ... that the men whose fathers are poor ... were any
imperfect. less brave than the men who are rich?" Sergius responds, "Not
a bit." Shaw's point is that social class and money have little to
She cannot live up to this standard, and neither can Sergius. do with bravery.
Rather, he must be "Sergius, the hero of Slivnitza ... Sergius,
the apostle of higher love." He wonders what those Sergiuses What's more, class has little to do with intelligence. Bluntschli is
would think if they saw him now, imperfect as he is. Swiss, a nationality that doesn't recognize ranks of nobility. He
states that he has the highest rank known in Switzerland, that
But both Raina and Sergius can be their real selves with other of a free citizen. However, he is also a soldier for hire. This
people. Raina tells Bluntschli that he is the first man who hasn't implies that he is of a lower class than Sergius, and Catherine
taken her seriously, but he knows she is mistaken. He is the is horrified that her daughter might marry someone like him.
first man who has taken her seriously. He is the first man who Yet both Sergius and Petkoff sit in awe while Bluntschli drafts
has really talked to her. Indeed, he is the first man who loves orders they were at a loss to draft.
her for herself rather than for the façade she puts on.
In the end, both Sergius and Raina realize that the military
ranks and social classes of their sweethearts are irrelevant.