JC 1010
JC 1010
JC 1010
OCTOBER 2010
year 11 | number 10
01
02
*
04
05
06
07
08
09
*
03
10
Fax: +813-4496-6421
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
Sales ¥m Sales per sqm ¥m in the new store, but they have
www.japanconsuming.com *: Sales estimate. Source: Nikkei; JapanConsuming. adopted the Isetan Shinjuku »
2 | this month
SEPTEMBER SALES SNAPSHOT
YonY (%)
Focus, focus: hints of success
Company Total Comp 80% of specialty apparel retailers posted visuals, respectful but relaxed and knowledge-
Uniqlo -20.4 -24.7 lower sales during the last financial year. De- able staff, so entertaining customers in what is
Komeri 0.3 -2.0 spite this, the format still gained market share after all their principle leisure activity.
Shimamura -6.6 -9.9
from department stores and GMS chains. These All of which bodes surprisingly well for the
Honeys -17.4 -17.7
Nishimatsuya Chain -13.2 -18.6
figures reflect what was clear on the street, that newly opened Mitsukoshi Ginza. While it could
Right On -23.3 -24.1 FY2009 was one of the toughest years for ap- have gone further, the department store shows
Jeansmate -13.3 -19.6 parel retailing in the last two decades. Well doc- signs of the kind of innovation usually associ-
Point -2.9 -13.0 umented economic factors aside, the specialty ated with specialty chains, and a management
Workman 18.4 16.0 sector was also faced with further pressure on that has listened to its customers rather than its
Cox (includes Bluegrass) 95.5 -10.7 prices from the likes of GMS chains, and much suppliers. As well as unprecedented variety in
Uny -1.5 - slower rates of growth in new shopping centres, ranges and prices, the store includes product
Palemo -3.1 -6.4
closing off one of the easiest routes to expansion centred displays for key categories like accesso-
Mitsukoshi 1.9 -
Isetan -10.6 -
in the last decade. ries and jewellery, creating more fluid and dy-
Takashimaya -3.6 - Delivering product that customers want namic floors. For the first time, the east of To-
Matsuya (Ginza only) -2.8 - at prices that make sense are clearly factors in kyo now has a store to match Isetan Shinjuku.
Daimaru Matsuzakaya -3.9 - their success. What also distinguished success What both Mitsukoshi and the few specialty
Hankyu Hanshin -5.8 - from failure last year was investment in market- chain successes demonstrate is the growing
Askul -5.0 - ing, high levels of service, and sheer entertain- emphasis on focus and customer orientation.
G Foot -3.8 -8.6 ment at stores. While TV advertising is com- Aeon’s decision to discard Jusco and rebrand all
Tsuruha HD 4.7 1.1
mon for the biggest chains, spot prices have stores as Aeon, Parco’s split of building profile
Allied Hearts -2.5 -5.4
Nitori 2.9 -2.9
fallen enough for middle ranking retailers to by location, the relaunch of 109-2 as a Men’s
Kawachi Yakuhin -1.8 -3.4 afford, with great results. Their stores too are Kan and even the mergers in food wholesaling,
Nissen -8.4 - in contrast to the flat, municipal library like at- all demonstrate how focused distribution is be-
Megane Top 16.2 7.3 mosphere depressingly common at many fash- coming.
Genki 27.0 18.7 ion stores, offering more movement, dynamic Tokyo, October 2010
Kusuri no Aoki 14.7 3.5
Index
ABC Mart, 5, 7 Cocolulu, 14 Hankyu, 11 Lumine, 1, 6-8 Palemo, 15 Takashimaya, 6
Aeon Group, 4 Collect Point, 9-10 Haruyama Shoji, 9 Mac House, 13 Parco, 1, 7, 10-11 Tamaya, 13
Amazon Japan, 5 Cox, 13 Honeys, 15-16 Marc Jacobs, 9 Point, 6, 13-16 Thom Browne, 4
Anthropologie, 3 Credge, 14 I. T., 4, 11, 14 Marubeni, 1, 7-8 Rakuten, 5-6 TicTac, 11
Aoyama Shoji, 3, 10 Credit Saison, 3, 9 Isetan Mitsukoshi, 1 Maruetsu, 7-8 Reasterisk, 14 Tokyu Mall Developments, 8
Arcadia, 6 Cross Company, 1, 3-4, 7, Ito-Yokado, 5, 10, 17 Marui, 7 Reed Krakoff, 10-11 Tomorrowland, 7
Asahi Newspapers, 7 14, 16 Itochu Shoji, 7 Matsuya, 1, 10 Right On, 15 TopShop, 1, 6
Asics, 11 Daiei, 7-8 Itochu Shokuhin, 9 Matsuzakaya, 1, 5-7, 10 Ryoshoku, 9 Toys R Us, 5
Askul, 5 Daimaru, 5, 11 Iwataya, 10 Million Carats, 6, 9 Sagami, 13, 15 Trinity Arts, 14
Avail, 14, 16 E Hyphen, 3-4 Japan Tobacco, 9 Mitsubishi Estates, 8 San-ai Group, 13 Tutuanna, 9, 14
Axes Femme, 14 Earth, Music & Ecology, 3, 14 JBF Partners, 6 Mitsukoshi, 1-2, 6, 11 Sanei International, 5 Ufufu Girls, 5-6
Baroque, 8, 14 Exiv, 14 Jewelium, 6 Moncler, 10 Sazaby, 15 Undercover, 9
Baycrews, 14-15 ExxonMobil, 11 Jins, 6 Mori Building, 6 Seibu, 1, 7, 17 Uniqlo, 3, 8-9, 14-15
Beams, 14-15 Familymart, 9-10 Jusco, 1, 4 Mori Trust, 11 Seiyu, 3-4, 9 United Arrows, 5, 7, 11, 14-16
Bluegrass, 13, 15 Fast Retailing, 8, 11 Keio, 10 Moussy, 8 Seven Eleven, 9, 11 Urban Outfitters, 3
Candish, 8 Forever 21, 5, 15 Keizan, 14 Mycal, 4 Shimamura, 9, 13-16 Venus Fort, 11
Cath Kidston, 1, 5 Gap, 9, 12 Kokubu, 9 Niko and..., 14 Sly, 8 ViewCompany, 8
Cecil McBee, 6 Ginza Ins, 7 Konaka, 13 Nippon Access, 9 Spiral Girl, 14 Walmart, 3-5, 9, 12
Circle K Sunkus, 10 Ginza Maggy, 13 Leilian, 15 Nitori, 11 Start Today, 7, 9 Yamada Denki, 5, 7
Coach, 11 Hakuhodo, 4 Lowrys Farm, 10 Onitsuka Tiger, 1, 11 Suzutan, 13 Zozo Villa, 9
This publication is provided without any representation or endorsement made and without warranty of any kind whether express or implied, including but not limited to the implied warranties of satisfactory quality, fitness for a particular
purpose, non-infringement, compatibility, security and accuracy. In no event will JapanConsuming or Sensu Limited or any of the contributors be liable for any damages including, without limitation, indirect or consequential damages, or
any damages whatsoever arising from use or loss of use, data, or profits, whether in action of contract, negligence or other action, arising out of or in connection with the use of the publication. No part of this publication may be reproduced
without prior written permission from the publisher. © Sensu Ltd. 2000–2010.
chain in 2015
Walmart announced the launch of the
Walmart Card last month, causing further
rumours that it may soon move towards
replacing the Seiyu name in other parts of
Cross Company is the fastest growing specialty retailer of the last decade, increasing its business too. The card is offered through
turnover by more than 3,500% since the late 1990s. It became a top 30 specialty apparel Credit Saison, Seiyu’s long time associate
firm last year and is comfortably profitable. If it fulfils its new medium term plan, Cross will company, and carries the Walmart name
become a top 10 apparel chain with sales triple last year, from some 670 stores. As well – Walmart Card Saison American Express
is the slightly unwieldy official name of the
as existing chains, Cross looks set to enter the select shop market too.
card. As with almost all Saison cards, sub-
scribers pay no sign-up or annual mem-
Cross Company is the creation of Yasuharu ented and experienced women staff – 90% of man- bership fee. Credit Saison and Seiyu were
Ishikawa, first set up in 1995 when he was just 25 agement staff are women – who would have been part of the same founding group at one
after a few years experience working at a branch either discarded by large corporates or unable to point, so Saison card holders have always
of Aoyama Shoji. He started with a select shop in work full time because of a wish to also be at home enjoyed 5% discounts on the 5th and 20th
of every month at Seiyu stores, a practice
his home town in Okayama, and then launched the with their children. Other company programmes,
common for other supermarket cards too.
SPA chain, Earth, Music & Ecology in 1999. Since such as its commitment to keeping the local town Unlike other chains’ cards, however, the
then the company has boomed, growing sales by clean through employee volunteer groups, and eco Walmart Card provides a permanent 1%
3,500% in just over a decade, and since 2003 sales programmes both here and in places like Mongolia discount to shoppers buying with the card
have increased nine times from ¥3 billion to ¥27 where it plants trees, help create a cohesive cor- at its stores. Once again, Walmart Seiyu
billion (see Chart). As of the end of FY2009, Cross porate structure and sense of mission beyond just CEO, Toru Noda emphasised the use of the
ran 217 stores with 1,350 employees, and for this selling nice clothes. Walmart name as proof of the US retailer’s
year it expects sales to hit ¥38.5 billion from 286 Above all, the clearly defined and thought out long term commitment to Japan. The name
already appears large on the HQ in Akabane
stores. Its key chains are Earth, Music & Ecology staff policies, its commitment to various causes,
and there have been several reports that
(EME), Green Parks, And E Hyphen. and the focus on its core business, show a strong Walmart may soon add its name to stores,
Along with nice stores, selling popular product company vision, clarity of purpose, efficient mar- with even Noda quoted in one Nikkei article
targeting mainstream women fashion consumers, shalling of resources and focus that are all too rare, saying Seiyu is a damaged brand.
Cross Company has something of a unique com- and these form the basis of the company’s confi-
pany organisation, at least for a company of its size dent execution of strategy and expansion.
today, and perhaps represents the future of more With a strong pool of talent, Cross has been H&M sales double
progressive Japanese companies. Ever since its able to grow consistently, develop new projects, H&M’s Japanese subsidiary saw sales
double for the first nine months of FY2010
launch for example, it has insisted on only employ- and still make decent profits. Improvements to the
according to a recent press release. Sales
ing full time staff despite the higher costs, entirely existing core chains are continuous and are reflect- rose from 634 million SEK (¥7.83 billion)
contrary to the preference in the apparel sector to ed in recent results. Same store sales for EME rose in FY2009 to 1.298 billion SEK (¥15.93 bil-
cut costs through the use of part timers. Ishikawa, 15% in January, 17% in February, 24% in March, lion) this year, a 105% increase and a 108%
however, sees a direct link between happy, well and then jumped 41% in April and more than 50% increase on a same currency basis. H&M
trained staff and satisfied customers, saying that in May. The growth was partly thanks to a major Japan now operates 10 stores in Japan.
shop staff are the face of the brand. The result is overhaul of product quality including switching to
that Cross Company’s shop staff are well known for Italian yarns as insufficient quality had held back
Urban Outfitters to open in
their attention to customers and a clear passion for the efforts of a strong design department. The huge
Japan
the company they work for. jump in April and May followed the first TV ad For the third time in a decade, US retailer
Employee satisfaction is also helped by flex- campaign in March, bringing new footfall to its Urban Outfitters has announced plans to
ible work plans. Mothers of young children are al- stores. launch in the Japanese market. The com-
lowed to work as few as four hours a day, not just The strong growth has given Cross Company pany said it expects to open a flagship for
in the early years, but until their kids are at least 10 the confidence to revise its five year plan which its Anthropologie chain here in 2012, and
years old. These are almost unheard of practices in began this financial year. The new plan now calls Urban Outfitters in other Asian markets.
corporate Japan, let alone in the world of apparel for sales of ¥93.6 billion by the end of FY2014, up
retailing where low pay and conditions are notori- from the previous forecast of ¥70 billion, produc-
Seiyu targets Uniqlo with new
ous. The pay back is that Cross has retained tal- ing pretax profits of ¥14 billion, up from ¥10.6 bil- pricing
lion. During the five years, Cross plans Cooler weather has seen crowds flock to
unbeatable growth: cross company to open as many as 450 stores taking the Uniqlo stores in the search of HeatTech
40,000 300 total to 677. products, but Seiyu is hoping to grab a
These are high targets but supported share of the market with new price cuts.
Shops
Sales by a coherent plan. As well as the core During October it will cut prices on its own
30,000 225 brands, Cross plans to expand into new cool weather lines called Eco Heat by 25%,
taking average price points down to around
consumer segments, turning itself from a
¥580-¥980, less than half of Uniqlo. While
young womenswear retailer into a diverse
Shop Nos
Sales ¥m
SOAKING UP THE COMPETITION: A SMALL SAMPLE OF AEON’S M&A ACTIVITY SINCE 1970 ABC divests United Arrows stake
Mycal
Aeon Hokkaido ABC Mart announced at the end of August
Posful 2007 27 Stores
Hokkaido
¥150.3bn
that it will sell the entire 24.3% stake it holds
2003 in United Arrows. The stake was originally
Aeon Kyushu
Kyushu Jusco Aeon Kyushu 45 Stores acquired through ABC’s parent company and
2007 ¥258.9bn UA was unenthusiastic about its new largest
Mycal Kyushu shareholder from the outset. Providing further
2002 Mycal proof that simply owning a large chunk of a
Nichii Mycal 91 Stores company is not enough to influence it, ABC
¥567.1bn
2001 Mart is giving up having entirely failed to get
Futagi UA to agree to partnership terms after a year
Aeon Retail Aeon Retail of negotiations – although many would argue
Okadaya Jusco Aeon 2008 248 Stores 345 Stores that, in this case, a partnership may well have
1970 ¥1.85trn ¥2.448trn
not improved UA as it is at present. The stake
2005
Aeon Marche will be sold back to UA, and ABC Mart is set
Shiro 1972 Carrefour
Japan
6 Stores to make a profit of around ¥3.4 billion on its
¥31.2bn
original purchase price.
Ogiya 1976
2007
Daiei
Isejin Group 1977 Daiei 133 Stores
¥781.0bn Toys R Us investigated by FTC
Ryukyu Jusco Toys R Us came under the scrutiny of the Fair
Okinawa
Jusco
5 Stores Trade Commission in September after allega-
¥60.1bn tions of forcibly requiring suppliers to provide
Source: Adapted from Nikkei; JapanConsuming. discounts and accept product returns – a US
retailer emulating its Japanese counterparts
in fact. The FTC is said to have visited the toy
Newspapers continue to worry about the grow- The figures come from Tsushin Shinbun, a Matsuzakaya Ginza the fashion
building
ing success and influence of the likes of Walmart, relatively minor trade journal, which puts Askul as
Daimaru is bringing its popular young wom-
Ikea and H&M, but in non-store retailing, an over- number two, more than ¥140 billion smaller than en’s fashion space, Ufufu Girls to Tokyo.
seas company has quietly but firmly taken the lead. the US book and general merchandise store. The Launched in the Kita Kan in Shinsaibashi last
In a recent report analysing how non-store retail newspaper omitted Rakuten, which had total con- year and then expanded to Daimaru Kyoto,
sales have trebled between 1990 and 2010, Amazon solidated turnover of ¥298 billion last year, but this the space will now be launched in Matsuza-
Japan is placed as the country’s number one non- includes various financial services, online auctions, kaya Ginza this month. Targeting customers
store retailer with sales in 2009 estimated at ¥320 and fees collected from retail clients. Rakuten says in their 20s, it will complement the existing XXI
billion, up from estimates of around ¥280 billion total gross merchandise sales were significantly at Ginza by Forever 21 when it opens October
the previous year. higher than Amazon, roughly ¥800 billion » »
McBee, Free’s Mart, Million Carats, Barbie, while the total online market was some ¥6.1 tril- Otsuka limits its ability to provide
Shokai 92,990
the same level of coordi-
Misumi Group 89,180
and eyewear brand Jins. Also opening will lion, so total non-store sales for department stores Belluna
nation and clarity that Amazon currently offers. JC
86,231
be the first shop for Point’s much hyped new of just ¥23.3 billion seem relatively insignificant.
brand Jewelium on the street level. Jewelium However, with growth of 23.3% in 2008 alone, AMAZON JAPAN: TOP ONLINE RETAILER
was first launched as a webstore last month Chart 1
following a jump of 26.4% in 2007, it is an unusu-
and is regarded as the next big brand for Point 350,000
in Japanese) 20s women with competitive small department store chains have been equally
active in developing digital channels too, with the
Sales ¥mn
210,000
price points (tops from ¥1,500, jackets from
¥10,000, dresses from ¥6,000, boots from big companies prominent in cutting edge media 140,000
¥7,000). channels like Social Networks and even on Twitter.
Much has been made in the press about the 70,000
Amazon Japan
Askul
JapaNet Takata
Nissen
Senshukai
Benesse
Rakuten*
Otsuka Shokai
Misumi Group
Belluna
to be hit with its biggest challenge yet. While commerce as a whole. A survey by METI found
mobile novellas have become a phenomenon that 1.1% of sales on Japan based e-commerce
in Japan, few industry pundits believed the sites came from the USA, 1.3% from Korea, and a
traditional and cosy relationship between significant 4% from China in 2009 alone. Written
publishers, wholesalers and retailers could Japanese presents a lower barrier to Chinese and Note: * Net physical goods retail sales only.
be broken, despite the efforts of some retail- Korean customers than does, for example, French Source: Tsushin Shinbun; JapanConsuming.
ers. As usual new technology has challenged
these assumptions. While some dismissed
Marubeni: dark horse of food will produce men’s, women’s and children’s
sports apparel and swimwear. Other product
distribution
to come will include sports sandals, shoes,
bags, socks, underwear, gloves, towels and
snow wear. Retail investment will be cautious
Marubeni is the smallest general trading house, but it has significant operations in food with just two directly operated stores by Nikki
wholesale and retail. Claiming the dominant share in some imports of some key foodstuffs, within five years, 13 corners in sports chains,
and five outlet stores. Sales of ¥5 billion are
the company is looking to build new own brands and may even consider overseas forecast by 2015.
expansion of its retail operations. Problem is, it must first sort out Daiei.
Ciggie wars: nicotine boosts conbinis Zozo portal, and now includes brands such as
Paul Smith, Undercover, Toga, Dover Street
Market and DSquared.
Convenience stores now saturate Japan and there’s not a lot of room for growth. Even so,
all the big chains enjoyed a nice boost this summer thanks, once again, to changes in the
Shimamura opens biggest store
way cigarettes are sold. From 1 October a new tax on tobacco pushed prices up by about Shimamura will open its largest ever Fash-
a third, leading to bulk purchasing over the previous few months. ion Shimamura store this month in Yoko-
hama. The 1,500 sqm shop will be located in
Convenience stores are bracing themselves for rettes to rise by a third. Although officially private, Kohoku New Town, the new residential area
a major slump in sales in October having enjoyed low cigarette taxes have been maintained to protect in Tsuzuki-ku, in the Kohoku Tokyu SC. Other
a buoyant summer. The upturn was thanks entirely Japan Tobacco (JT), the Finance Ministry-linked tenants will include Zara, Uniqlo, Gap, and
Global Work, making for a very competitive
to anticipation of the increase in tax on cigarettes monopoly, and smokers can think themselves
trial to the more fashion orientated format in
that came into force on 1 October. This nicotine lucky such a tax increase has been so long com- Shimamura’s portfolio. Shimamura plans to
fuelled windfall mimics that of two years ago when ing and remains as low as it is. For convenience use the bigger space to showcase its latest
the tobacco industry introduced ID cards (called store chains, however, the changes brought a huge, fashion offerings, its Fibre Heat competitor
Taspo) for people wanting to buy at vending ma- short-term boost in sales, with many stores enjoy- to HeatTech, as well as new lines of bedding
chines – far too much trouble for most smokers ing bulk buying by customers. and interior items.
who bought at convenience stores instead. With prices fixed, chains used a range of pro-
The new tax level caused the price of most ciga- motions such as offering free lighters to lure »
»
SINGLE USER SUBSCRIPTION © PLEASE DO NOT DISTRIBUTE 10.2010 | JapanConsuming
10 | news & analysis
» desperate smokers away from competitors. Some of sweets for people needing some alternative oral
Point in Shinjuku
even took advanced orders in order to properly stimulation. Japan being Japan, Sunkus is also pro-
Point will open a major new Collect Point meet demand. moting electronic alternatives to the traditional
store in Shinjuku this November. The 1,000 Circle K Sunkus took the logical step of then puff, with electronic cigarette products. While
sqm store will be its largest to date and will introducing campaigns aimed at people wanting these bypass the new tax increase, they probably
be located in a new shopping building being to give up the habit too, promoting Nicorette for shouldn’t. JC
developed by Keio near Isetan. Collect Point example, while Familymart has boosted its range
is the multi-brand format developed last year
by Point to showcase its key brands like
Moncler adds three stores Parco’s latest three year plan includes more shopping buildings at home and overseas,
Moncler opened three new womenswear investment in specialty retailing, e-commerce and entertainment ventures. While new
stores in September. All are located in depart- investment is long overdue, unfortunately Parco’s largest shareholder is trying to hobble
ment stores with the first in Matsuzakaya its independence.
Nagoya, followed by Matsuya Ginza and
Sogo Yokohama. The stores include the full
line including the new collection, Moncler S, Parco, one of the largest chains of fashion build- new to Fukuoka. Parco will also cut operating costs
designed by Chitose Abe, the designer of ings in the country, has announced a new, positive and staff overhead during the reorganisation.
Sacai. This Autumn also sees the launch of a three year plan having spent the past decade tight- The community buildings may prove some-
new men’s line, Moncler V, designed by Vis-
ening control of its existing buildings, closing the thing of an innovation. Instead of being diluted
vim’s Hiro Nakamura.
worst and selling off peripheral businesses. The versions of the city centre fashion buildings, sub-
next three years will see new investment to create urban stores will offer both wider product ranges
Aoyama sells more suits again a more diversified group by FY2015, combining a such as sports, electronics, home and children’s
After some worrying months, Aoyama Shoji stronger, more efficient fashion building business stores, but also add more services such as cinemas,
management breathed a sigh of relief when both here and overseas, with new growth busi- restaurants, beauty and other forms of entertain-
stores reported August sales at suit stores nesses in specialty retailing and entertainment. ment and education. This has already worked in
rose 3% overall and 1.8% on a like for like The main thrust of the new plan is to reduce its de- the case of the Hibarigaoka Parco in west Tokyo,
basis. Aoyama said the fierce summer heat
pendence on fashion by repositioning Parco build- where new kid’s zones and other entertainment
helped it sell more light summer suits and
other formal clothing. ings as mixed merchandise and service buildings helped it become the only property other than
– less Fashion Buildings than Lifestyle Buildings. Shizuoka to post higher sales last year. City cen-
Parco hopes this will mean an increase in group tre properties too will see space reallocated. In
Ito-Yokado opens another new sales to ¥300 billion by the end of FY2012, up 15% the new Fukuoka building for example, just 30%
home centre on last year, producing operating profit of ¥12 bil- of space is devoted to apparel compared to 50% in
As part of its ongoing programme to revitalise lion, up 40%. While sales have risen and fallen in other urban buildings.
and replace poorer Ito-Yokado GMS loca- the last decade (see Chart), its has shown a capacity The split into two divisions with clear target
tions, the number two chain revamped its
to extract more profit, growing operating income markets makes a lot of sense, and Parco hopes
Kawaguchi store at the end of September.
The store is now rebranded as a The Price from ¥6 billion in 1999 to a peak of ¥10 billion in that it can then exploit the greater focus to add
discount food store on the ground floor with 2007. Growth is expected to come from expansion new buildings for each division. In particular it
a Seven Home Centre DIY store on floors 2 and improvement in sales at existing buildings, in sees further opportunities to take over failed de-
and 3. This is only the third store featuring the addition to a small new investment of ¥50 billion – partment stores, as it has already done in Fukuoka
Seven Home Centre format, the first opening although Parco points out it has already spent ¥30 and Shizuoka. Such is its pessimism about the de-
in 2008 in Katsushika-ku, and the second in billion of this in acquiring the land under Parco partment store market that it expects to be able to
Musashino in March 2010. As with the other Urawa in March. open at least two new buildings a year to FY2013.
converted stores, the Kawaguchi outlet is old.
Parco will split its buildings into urban (city It will also open smaller city centre buildings under
It opened back in 1967 as the chain’s No. 22
store, but as a city centre outlet was too small centre fashion buildings) and community (sub- a new name, in new locations and also to replace
and no longer maintained the right positioning urban) divisions. Each division will have central some buildings such as the Shinsaibashi Parco
for the footfall in the area. Kawaguchi Station management to coordinate the mix of tenants for which closes next year.
has daily commuter through flow of around each local market. Parco will refurbish 1.5 times the Overseas, Parco opened its second mall in Sin-
160,000 people, around half of which use number of tenancies than in the last three years to gapore in March and plans as many as 10 Parco »
the east exit where the store is located. The make this happen,
store now has sales space of 3,300 sqm and greatly increasing Parco: looking for growth again Chart 2
Ito-Yokado forecasts annual sales in the first
the uniqueness of 350,000 5.0
year of around ¥1.5 billion. The Seven Home Operarting Income Margin
Centre packs around 50,000 SKUs, including tenancies for each FY Sales
more general items like beauty products, but area. This more
262,500 3.8
it expects 90% of sales to come from home targeted approach
Operating Margin %
175,000 2.5
other converted stores, full-time employees mall in Fukuoka,
have been cut back, with just six people in the a location taken
home centre section, although it will employ
over from Iwataya, 87,500 1.3
30 part-timers and will see HQ employees
working in the store on an almost daily basis. where 30 of the
150 tenants are
new to Japan, and 0
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
0
result of the structural resistance in the mar- 32 Taka Q Mens 22,747 -3.8 974 47.1 259 6
33 Ships Select 22,536 1.7 - - 71 3
ket and partly generous funding and support
31 Zakkaya Bulldog General 21,406 -14.7 1,004 -39.6 294 -37
from land and mall developers. In the first 34 Yamato Womens 21,110 -12.4 -455 - 122 -
place, when specialty retailers expanded in the 35 Japan Imagination Womens 20,630 -8.7 1,384 9.1 114 6
1990s, other than sclerotic department stores 36 Bluegrass Womens 20,587 -19.5 -953 - 418 -96
and GMS chains, they found the retail market 37 Suzuya Womens 18,500 -9.8 321 221.0 65 -2
largely empty of viable competition. That the 38 Rio Chain Womens 18,013 -12.8 161 - 260 -21
market place was quite so empty was the result 39 Cox Casual 17,813 -14.0 -190 - 212 -22
40 Jeansmate Casual 16,800 -9.6 -1,162 - 112 8
of Japan’s unusual capacity to prop up legacy
41 Suzutan Womens 16,013 -14.5 -672 - 284 -14
businesses – by not allowing natural forces to 42 Tutuanna Womens 15,443 17.7 - - 166 25
extinguish failing companies, competition was 43 Familia Childrens 15,041 -12.3 -116 - 164 -2
held back. This continued until the pressure on 44 Mimatsu Womens 15,008 -14.5 283 - 121 -11
the dam walls just became too much, and spe- 45 Sakazen Group Mens 14,342 -7.8 1,707 -11.9 24 0
cialty retailing suddenly poured through the 46 Tabio Socks 14,336 -6.7 1,029 -44.6 277 0
gap. As a result, the bounty came to all modern 47 Summit Colmo General 13,769 -6.4 35 -81.1 39 2
48 Brooks Brothers General 13,654 -3.7 - - 74 0
specialty chains and in a rush. And just as the
49 Eddie Bauer Japan Casual 13,654 -3.7 - - 55 -8
party started, developers turned up with the 50 San-ai Group Womens 12,794 -29.2 - - 98 -25
equivalent of a truck full of beer, opening more 51 Zaza Horaya Group Mens 12,920 -7.5 335 -22.1 74 -2
shopping centres in the years to 2006 than at 52 Tamaya Womens 11,921 -21.5 -934 - 121 -9
any other time in Japanese history. 53 Urban Research Casual 11,770 -7.0 680 - 60 7
Such beneficence doesn’t happen often and 54 Laura Ashley Japan Womens 11,603 -5.0 - - 111 16
55 Ginza Maggy Womens 10,880 -12.7 - - 75 -3
then comes with a price when it does. Un-
Source: JapanConsuming; Company data, Nikkei, Senken, Teikoku Databank. **Estimated retail operations
fortunately for the sector, the hangover was
30
Net End of Year Store Nos
1,200
-30
-60
600
-90
-120
0 -150
Shimamura
Sanei International
Honeys
Uniqlo
Aoyama Shoji
Nishimatsuya Chain
Workman
Point
Sazaby League
Pal
Palemo
Mac House
Aoki Holdings
Right On
Bluegrass
Haruyama Shoji
Leilian
Sagami
Konaka
Xebio
Zakkaya Bulldog
Suzutan
Rio Chain
Taka Q
Miki House
Cross Company
Baroque
Cox
Sanki
Tutuanna
Familia
Baycrews
Mimatsu
Tamaya
Japan Imagination
Jeansmate
Laura Ashley Japan
San-ai Group
Beams
Ginza Maggy
Zaza Horaya Group
Ships
Suzuya
Urban Research
Eddie Bauer Japan
Ryohin Keikaku
at many SCs. have defied this, expanding to contend for the comparable markets like the US and UK, and
With the number of new SCs again down top rankings too, with Cross Company grow- where a price war is being talked about next
on 2008, and existing SCs suffering along with ing 3,570%, Point 687%, Shimamura’s Avail Spring if production and cotton prices allow.
their tenants, opportunities for easy expansion 518%, Pal 467%, Honeys 428% and United Ar- Arguably, there is also plenty of room for ever
were few and demands for a better return were rows 307%. greater competition between firms, with the
many. While 2010 should show a continued Quite what the outlook is for this year and majority of leading firms positioned in very
enthusiasm for expansion for some, the new next remains unclear. Results since March differentiated segments at present, so that new
enthusiasm for closing poor stores looks set have been unstable with some good months entrants or new subsidiary brands could easily
to become more widespread. The good news followed by awful ones, although the better upset the balance and force prices to remain
is that rents are falling, with recent data from managed chains do look to have improved on relatively low.
Senken indicating that half of tenants have last year. What does seem to be clear is that There is also some sense that perhaps shop-
seen rents fall and fewer than 10% seeing rents one of the big issues for the industry in the last pers are tiring of buying so much volume, and
rise, while developers are proving more flex- decade – lower prices – may be coming to end. their wardrobes are groaning under the piles of
ible with easier and shorter contracts. Worldwide, apparel retailers are talking of ris- cheap clothing. But this is hard to quantify, and
ing prices as both production and raw material perhaps it is just too early to have an impact as
A great decade but a hard act to follow costs rise. The price of cotton has risen a re- yet. What is clear is that the appetite, funding
The poor results for FY2009 were caused ported 45% to a 15 year high, and higher man- and opportunity for very rapid store expansion
by a continuation of the same factors that hit ufacturing costs in China have led to a shift in is now over, providing yet another good reason
the market in FY2008, only more dramatic. production to Bangladesh, Laos and Cambo- to work on better return from existing assets.
These were a maturing sector, the downturn in dia – but even there, costs are reported to be JC
apparel consumption and continued pressure rising. Of course, unlike in the EU
on prices. Many specialty apparel chains have and US, Japanese retailers are buy- TUTUANA: THE PINK ONE
enjoyed a heady decade and while the format ing with a strong Yen which will
overall will continue to take share from depart- offset some price increases, but
ment stores and GMS chains, growth is harder even so the market is clearly gird-
to find and competition more intense. And be- ing itself for change, and pricier
ing big has clearly helped in taking advantage apparel for all.
of the best of times and avoid the worst effects While many pundits are pil-
of the downturn. ing in with their views on what
A recent report by Senken showed that the the effect will be, the reality is
combined growth of 84 specialty chains with that Japan, as elsewhere, hasn’t
comparable figures over a 10 year period was seen apparel prices rise for more
46.4%, while growth for the top 10 over that than 15 years, and no one really
period was 70%. During the last two years es- knows how customers will react.
pecially, the better performance of the top 10 The only caveat to this is perhaps
versus that of the rest has become ever more the t-shirt market where retail
pronounced. But the smaller, nimbler firms prices in Japan remain higher than
consumption
Medical care
Net increase
Expenditure
Expenditure
expenditure
expenditure
Transport &
Disposable
Furniture &
Clothing &
deposits &
household
recreation
Education
insurance
Culture &
footwear
Housing
utensils
Utilities
Income
income
Other
Food
Total
2003 524,810 410,709 326,566 71,394 22,222 20,718 10,427 15,444 11,603 44,730 17,857 32,181 79,991 84,143 440,667 73,327
2004 531,690 417,038 331,636 71,935 20,877 20,950 10,392 14,867 11,545 47,356 19,482 33,549 80,683 85,402 446,288 75,584
2005 524,585 412,928 329,499 70,947 21,839 21,328 10,313 14,971 12,035 46,986 18,561 32,847 79,671 83,429 441,156 71,798
2006 525,719 404,502 320,231 69,403 20,292 21,998 9,954 14,430 11,463 45,769 18,713 31,421 76,786 84,271 441,448 82,158
2007 528,762 409,716 323,459 70,352 20,207 21,555 9,914 14,846 11,697 46,259 19,090 33,166 76,372 86,257 442,504 80,900
2008 534,235 416,415 324,929 71,051 19,156 22,666 10,501 14,263 11,593 48,259 18,789 33,390 75,260 91,486 442,749 81,213
2009 518,226 409,374 319,060 70,135 19,614 21,466 10,152 13,773 12,036 47,093 19,493 33,243 72,055 40,878 427,912 77,853
2009. 07 573,821 420,874 316,623 69,830 21,387 17,503 12,216 13,508 11,181 50,090 14,385 34,223 72,301 48,335 469,571 97,157
2009. 08 466,393 394,961 318,067 72,243 20,529 18,643 12,178 10,092 12,289 49,477 12,739 39,559 70,319 33,259 389,498 35,094
2009. 09 422,120 375,131 301,796 68,121 17,674 17,617 9,562 10,978 12,060 46,432 21,907 31,622 65,823 30,801 348,785 7,288
2009. 10 459,704 379,055 306,399 69,540 18,342 17,570 9,285 13,196 12,394 47,510 23,571 28,921 66,071 30,507 387,048 53,654
2009. 11 428,219 377,029 303,564 67,629 20,579 18,984 10,262 15,280 12,510 44,529 15,892 31,482 66,417 31,131 354,753 28,287
2009. 12 906,884 497,751 359,254 81,158 20,341 21,639 12,512 16,353 13,218 53,727 16,230 40,327 83,752 54,251 768,386 345,613
2010. 01 434,344 393,749 321,633 67,140 20,145 25,663 9,335 15,660 11,134 49,254 16,576 31,768 74,958 72,116 362,227 22,908
2010. 02 464,866 359,036 285,211 63,085 17,231 26,204 8,747 11,042 10,743 40,796 17,292 29,783 60,288 73,825 391,042 58,285
2010. 03 439,410 429,495 352,552 69,088 21,290 25,805 10,091 15,745 11,682 56,364 25,585 37,018 79,882 76,944 362,466 -7,788
2010. 04 474,616 422,257 331,621 66,194 21,323 23,515 8,743 12,602 10,520 45,632 35,433 31,934 75,725 90,636 383,980 15,691
2010. 05 421,413 404,197 303,326 71,054 21,053 21,206 8,502 13,659 10,323 45,403 14,552 33,936 63,638 100,872 320,542 -7,281
2010. 06 733,886 432,025 297,809 66,926 22,666 19,038 11,523 13,150 11,235 43,511 11,785 31,485 66,490 134,217 599,669 258,511
2010. 07 562,094 415,306 316,659 70,593 17,225 17,993 13,902 14,894 12,241 51,129 13,060 34,481 71,141 98,647 463,447 99,106
2010. 08 470,717 405,997 323,758 72,256 23,554 19,642 11,564 10,412 10,479 57,305 11,408 38,472 68,666 82,239 388,478 31,795
Notes: JC uses figures for working households of two or more people, including primary industry workers. Annual figures indicate 12 month averages. Source: Household Accounts; JapanConsuming.
Kintetsu Abeno & 6 others 18,171 -5.2 21.3 Other 62,440 -3.7 6.0 -0.8
Takashimaya Osaka & 3 others 14,940 0.8 29.1 Total 1,040,425 -3.5 100.0 -0.9
Daimaru Shinsaibashi, Umeda 13,944 14.3 47.3 Note: Department store categories updated May 2010 to match JDSA statistics.
Source: JDSA, JCSA, JapanConsuming.
Daimaru Motomachi & 3 others 10,529 7.1 37.9
Hanshin Umeda 10,076 15.6 29.0
Takashimaya Kyoto, Rakunishi 8,193 -4.3 22.5
Daimaru Kyoto, Yamaka 7,288 5.2 31.9 GMS chains
GMs Sales and supermarkets
Isetan JR Kyoto 5,925 0.1 26.3 July
Sogo Kobe 4,608 4.1 5.3 Sales Jul/ Jul/
Keihan Moriguchi & 3 others 4,429 -2.8 7.0 Space Jun Jun Sales/ Sales/
Seibu Takatsuki, Hachio, Otsu 4,213 -2.3 -4.6 Sales YonY 1,000 1,000 Store Store sqm Store
Company ¥mn % sqm sqm Nos Nos ¥ ¥m
Other Regions
Takashimaya Yokohama, Konandai 14,070 -1.8 17.0 1 Aeon Retail † 136,995 -4.4 3,295 - 494 - 41,577 277
Matsuzakaya Nagoya 11,198 -4.8 30.4 2 Ito-Yokado 95,698 1.5 1,724 0 174 0 55,509 550
3 Uny 63,298 -2.6 1,778 -1 233 -1 35,601 272
Takashimaya JR Nagoya 9,277 4.4 30.2
4 Daiei 58,353 -1.7 1,124 -1 220 -1 51,915 265
Sogo Yokohama 9,168 0.6 5.1
5 Life Corporation 40,176 3.5 539 0 211 0 74,538 190
Iwataya A Side 7,344 -0.9 34.8 6 Izumi 36,821 5.1 1,085 1 77 -1 33,936 478
Mitsukoshi Sakae 7,230 -6.7 33.1 8 Maruetsu 28,221 1.3 326 1 249 0 86,567 113
Fukuya Hiroshima 6,178 -2.3 69.6 7 York Benimaru 27,832 1.1 494 0 167 2 56,340 167
Sogo Chiba 5,942 -1.4 5.7 10 Izumiya 25,443 -1.6 553 1 87 0 46,009 292
Meitetsu Nagoya 5,701 -6.0 28.1 11 Heiwado 25,203 0.2 722 0 124 0 34,907 203
Daimaru Hakata & Nagasaki 5,015 -3.1 -0.3 9 Fuji 25,106 2.8 668 0 95 0 37,584 264
Daimaru Sapporo 5,009 10.8 29.3 12 Beisia 23,397 3.8 653 5 98 0 35,830 239
13 Coop Kobe 20,542 -7.9 220 0 145 0 93,373 142
Yamagataya Kagoshima 4,848 -0.1 50.6
14 Tokyu Store 19,082 -1.6 237 0 97 0 80,515 197
Sogo Hiroshima 4,780 -1.2 15.1 17 Okuwa 18,248 -1.7 363 0 147 0 50,270 124
Tenmaya Okayama, Kurashiki, Hiroshima 4,471 -3.6 8.8 15 Summit 18,240 0.1 166 0 98 0 109,880 186
Izutsuya Kokura, Kurozaki 4,377 -8.5 -14.7 16 Kasumi 17,760 0.1 231 0 138 0 76,883 129
Fujisaki Sendai 4,338 -1.8 45.3 18 Inageya 13,662 -4.9 194 0 126 0 70,423 108
Saikaya Kawasaki, Yokotsuka, Fujisawa 4,202 -21.5 24.2 19 Tobu Store 6,776 -1.5 108 1 56 1 62,741 121
Tobu Funabashi 4,060 -3.1 20.3 Total 700,853 -1.9 14,480 - 3,036 0 48,401 231
Marui Imai Sapporo 3,743 -14.9 19.4 Notes: From March 2010, Aeon stopped releasing sales figures for all stores. The numbers here are estimated based on same store sales
change compared to overall sales in the previous year and should be treated with caution. Sales space and store numbers accurate to
Takashimaya Iyotetsu Matsuyama 3,721 -3.5 45.5 February 2010 only. In March 2010, Uny changed its method of accounting for sales space, increasing space by 159,000 sqm. Sales
Mitsukoshi Fukuoka 3,417 -9.8 37.7 space and store numbers not updated monthly by all companies.
Source: NMJ; Japan Chain Store Association; JapanConsuming.
Mitsukoshi Sapporo & Sapporo Alta 3,028 -6.5 23.8
Source: Nikkei & Japan Department Store Association: JapanConsuming.
Leading city shopping centre sales retail sales year on year for major formats
Retail Sales Year on Year: Major Formats 2009-2010
August YonY %
Kanto Total H’hold Apparel Food 10.0
Lumine Shinjuku -4.1 4.5 -6.4 -9.6 SCs DpS
Lumine Est 0.7 1.7 1.6 -4.0
GMS CVS
Shinjuku MyLord -2.2 -2.2 -4.2 -2.9
Ikebukuro Parco -3.5 - - -
Retail Overall
Lumine Ikebukuro -2.3 3.0 9.0 -8.3 5.0
Shibuya Parco -11.1 - - -
Shibuya 109 -6.0 - - -
Atre Ebisu 4.0 4.8 5.0 4.0
YonY Change %
Subscription Information: Send me an annual subscription of 11 issues (Jul/Aug is a double issue) of JapanConsuming as follows:
Currencies in brackets for guidance only; if you pay by card, payments will be converted at the rate on the date of payment, and invoice payments are in yen.
Electronic PDF format (PDF sent by email for printing by one user)
Single Subscription
(License covers readership of 1 or 2 people) ¥110,000 (approx: £750 €850 $1,100)
Corporate PDF format (PDF sent by email which allows email/intranet distribution within your company)
Corporate Subscription
(License for company wide readership) ¥250,000 (approx: £1,700 €2,000 $2,700)
Payment Details
Please invoice my company at the above address for payment within 30 days OR
Please charge ¥_________________ to my VISA Mastercard
(PLEASE NOTE THAT CARD STATEMENTS WILL SHOW PAYMENT TO SENSU LTD, THE PUBLISHER OF JAPANCONSUMING)
Signature
Money Back Guarantee: Should your requirements change at any time, you may cancel your subscription and JapanConsuming will refund the unexpired portion
of your subscription. Discounts for academic subscribers and small companies employing fewer than 20 employees that have a proven record of export. Please
contact us for details at [email protected]