A Review On Pharmaceutical Process Validation of Solid Dosage Form (Tablets)
A Review On Pharmaceutical Process Validation of Solid Dosage Form (Tablets)
A Review On Pharmaceutical Process Validation of Solid Dosage Form (Tablets)
net/publication/308302210
CITATIONS READS
4 445
4 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Laboratory for Vascular Medicine and Stem Cell Biology View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Rishi Ram Parajuli on 19 May 2018.
REVIEW ARTICLE
A REVIEW ON PHARMACEUTICAL PROCESS VALIDATION OF SOLID DOSAGE FORM [TABLETS]
Parajuli Rishi Ram1*, Shrestha Saroj1, Lamichane Shreekrishna1,Pokhrel Priyanka2.
1
Production Pharmacist, TIME Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd, Nepal
2
Dossier Pharmacist, TIME Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd, Nepal
*Corresponding Author’s Email: [email protected]
Received 02 July 2015; Review Completed 29 Aug 2015; Accepted 29 Aug 2015, Available online 15 Nov 2015
ABSTRACT:
The article gives an introduction and general overview on process validation of pharmaceutical tablet manufacturing process.
Process Validation is one of the important steps in achieving and maintaining the quality of final product. Process validation
emphasizes the role of statistical tools and analyses, knowledge, detection, and control of variability and thus gives assurance
on consistency of quality product. The validation study provides the accuracy, sensitivity, specificity and reproducibility of the
established and documented test methods employed by the manufacturer. Thus, validation is an essential part of the quality
assurance. This review examines the need for pharmaceutical validation, the various approaches, process and steps to be
monitored during tablet manufacturing process.
Key words: Process Validation, Types, Validation Stages, Guidelines and Process.
1. INTRODUCTION:
The concept of validation was first proposed by two production phase. Validation necessarily includes
Food and Drug Administration officers, Ted Byers and process qualification (the qualification of materials,
Bud Loftus, in the mid 1970’s in order to improve the equipment, system, building, personnel), but it also
quality of pharmaceuticals. Pharmaceutical Process includes the control on the entire process for repeated
Validation is the most important and recognized batches or runs”.
parameters of CGMPs.1 The requirement of process
European Commission - 1991 - Validation - “Act of
validation appears of the quality system (QS)
proving, in accordance of GMPs that Any” process
regulation. The goal of a quality system is to
actually leads to expected results.
consistently produce products that are fit for their
intended use. The process validation is standardization European Commission - 2000 - Validation -
of the validation documents that must be submitted with “Documented evidence that the process, operated within
the submission file for marketing authorization.2 The established parameters, can perform effectively and
process validation is intended to assist manufacturers in reproducibly to produce a medicinal product meeting its
understanding quality management system(QMS) predetermined specifications and quality attributes”.6
requirements concerning process validation and has
general applicability to manufacturing process.3 WHO guidelines define validation as Validation is
documented act of proving that any procedure, process,
Some Defination of Validation: equipment, material, activity or system actually leads to
the expected results. Validation act of proving, in
According to FDA, 4
accordance of GMPs that any process actually leads to
Assurance of product quality is derived from careful expected results. Documented evidence that the process,
and systemic attention to a number of importance operated with in established parameters, can perform
factors, including: selection of quality process through effectively reproducibly to produce a medicinal product
in-process and end-product testing. meeting its predetermined specifications and quality
attributes.
According to US FDA in 1978, 5
2. Types of Validation 7
“A validation manufacturing process is one which has
been proved to do what it purpose or is represented to 2.1 Analytical Validation
do. The proof of validation is obtained through the
Analytical validation is the evaluation of product
collection and evaluation of data, preferably, beginning
quality attributes through testing, to demonstrate
from the process development phase and continuing the
reliability is being maintained throughout the product
© 2011-15, JDDT. All Rights Reserved ISSN: 2250-1177 CODEN (USA): JDDTAO
Parajuli et al Journal of Drug Delivery & Therapeutics. 2015; 5(6):1-7 2
life cycle and that the precision, accuracy, specificity, (c) Concurrent validation
LOD, linearity, selectivity, strength, purity and
It is similar to prospective, except the operating firm
specification has not been compromised. The analytical
will sell the product during the qualification runs, to the
method gives the detail steps necessary to perform an
public at its market price. This validation involves in
analysis. This may include: preparation of samples,
process monitoring of critical processing steps and
standards and reagents, use of apparatus and use of
product testing. It is the repetition of a validation
formula for the calculation and many more.
process or a specific part of it. This is carried out when
2.2 Equipment Validation there is any change or replacement in formulation,
equipment, and plant or site location. The justification
Validation of equipments is known as qualification.
or conducting concurrent validation must be
Equipment validation is divided into Installation
documented and the protocol must be approved by the
Qualification (IQ), Operational Qualification (OQ), and
Validation Team. A report should be prepared and
Performance Qualification (PQ). An IQ documents
approved prior to the sale of each batch and a final
specify static attributes of a facility or item to prove that
report should be prepared and approved after the
the installation of the unit has been correctly performed
completion of all concurrent batches. It is generally
and the installation specifications of the manufacturer
considered acceptable that a minimum of three
have been met. After installation it must be ensured that
consecutive batches within the finally agreed
the equipment can deliver operating ranges as specified
parameters, giving the product the desired quality
in the purchase order. This is called OQ. The PQ is
would constitute a proper validation of the process.
concerned with proving the process being done by the
machine as it is supposed to do. (d) Revalidation
2.3 Process Validation Re-validation is usually performed to the confirmation
of initial validation for a Periodic review. Re-validation
Process validation is “A documented procedure which
provides the evidence that changes in a process and /the
provides a high degree of assurance that a specific
process environment that are introduced do not
process will consistently produce a product meeting its
adversely affect process characteristics and product
predetermined specification and quality attributes”.
quality.
Process validation is divided into different types as
follows:- 2.4 Process/ Product Validation:
(a) Prospective validation Process Validation is establishing documented evidence
which provides a high degree of assurance that a
It is defined as the establishment of documented
specific system will consistently produce a product
evidence that a system does what it purpose to do based
meeting its predetermined specifications and quality
on preplanned protocol. This approach to validation is
attributes.
normally undertaken whenever a new formula, process
or facility must be validated before commercial routine Phases in Process Validation
pharmaceutical formulation commences. During the
Phase1: This is the Pre-validation Qualification Phase
product development phase the production process
which covers all activities relating to product research
should be broken down into individual steps. Each step
and development, formulation pilot batch studies, scale-
should be evaluated on the basis of experience or
up studies, transfer of technology to commercial scale
theoretical considerations to determine the critical
batches, establishing stability conditions and storage,
parameters that may affect the quality of the finished
and handling of in-process and finished dosage forms,
product. A series of experiments should be designed to
equipment qualification, installation qualification
determine the criticality of these factors. Each
master production document, operational qualification
experiment should be planned and documented fully in
and process capacity.
an authorized protocol.
Phase 2: This is the process validation phase. It is
(b) Retrospective validation
designed to verify that all established limits of the
It is defined as the establishment of documented critical process parameter are valid and that satisfactory.
evidence that a system does what it purpose to do based
Phase 3: Known as the validation maintenance Phase, it
on review and analysis of historical data. This is
requires frequent review of all process related
achieved by the review of the historical manufacturing
documents, including validation of audit reports, to
testing data to prove that the process has always
assure that there have been no changes, deviations
remained in control. For the purpose of retrospective
failures and modifications to the production process and
validation studies, it is considered acceptable that data
that all SOPs, including change control procedures,
from a minimum of ten consecutive batches produced
have been followed and all lots or batches produced will
be utilized. When less than ten batches are available, it
meet their intended specifications.
is considered that the data are not sufficient to
demonstrate retrospectively that the process is fully Various Approaches in Process Validation 8
under control. In such cases the study should be
supplemented with data generated with concurrent or Process Design: The goal of this stage is to design a
process suitable for routine commercial manufacturing
prospective validation.
that can consistently deliver a product that meets its
quality attributes.
© 2011-15, JDDT. All Rights Reserved ISSN: 2250-1177 CODEN (USA): JDDTAO
Parajuli et al Journal of Drug Delivery & Therapeutics. 2015; 5(6):1-7 3
management, accounting etc so they should have a designed product’s reliability, but can be used as a tool
commendable co-operation, focus and plan in order to maintain the consistency of how the product is made.
to get good team synergy.
In-process specifications establishment: In process
4) Experience: To get success in validation program specifications are established based on the previous
well experienced validation team are required. acceptable process average and process variability
5) Resources: Resources means personnel who will determined by the application statistical procedures
plan and execute equipment on which validations wherever appropriate. Samples must represent the batch
will be performed on materials with which to under analysis. Statistical quality control criteria as
conduct validations. condition of approval and release of batch must meet its
6) Budget: It is important to understand that a predetermined specifications.
successful validation must be done to completion
For Process validation of tablet, each and every step
and it should not be limited by a budget as
involved during formulation of tablet should be taken
validations cost money.
into consideration. Following are the steps and the
7) Standard Operating Procedures (SOP’s): The
parameter which should be considered during process
SOPs capture activities that routinely occur within
validation of tablet.
an organization so all the concerned department
must be trained about SOPs and its implementation. A. Raw Material Validation:
8) Quality Control lab support: During the
Active pharmaceutical ingredient
validations, some laboratory testing will be
required which are handled by the QC so well Excipients
facilitated qc lab is required to get results in
expected time. Variation in raw material is one of the major causes
9) Permission to conduct preliminary runs. of product variation or deviation from specification
10) Realistic completion dates. API may represent the most uncontrollable
Objective of Process Validation 13 component.
1. To reduce variation between various batches. State a good pre-formulation program at early
2. To provide a high degree of assurance of quality of phase of product
the product.
Critical steps in the development cycle
3. To decrease the risk of defect costs and regulatory
noncompliance. Chemical characteristics
4. To ensure the consistency of the manufacturing
Drug impurities, Impurity levels.
operation and reproducibility of the process.
5. To demonstrate the robustness of the process. Physical properties:
6. A fully validated process may require less in-
process controls and end product testing. Drug morphology, solubility, particle size/surface
7. To ensure the existence of all necessary quality area, shape, drug density, hygroscopic nature
assurance system within organization. B. Analytical method Validation:
14
Guidelines for process validation of tablets: Accuracy
Typical pharmaceutical manufacturing processes Precision
comprise a serious of unit operations which includes: Specificity
machinery, methods, people, material, measuring Intra / Inter day variance
systems and environmental conditions, etc. To assure
Between operator variation
batch uniformity and integrity of drug products, written
Between instrument variation
procedures need to be established and followed to test
for each batch. Such control procedures are established C. Process evaluation, selection and validation: 16
to monitor the output and to validate the performance of
the manufacturing processes that may be responsible for 1. Dispensing:
causing variability in the characteristics of in-process Dispensing is done prior to formulation. Ensure
material and the drug product.15. dispensing booth is clean and line clearance is given as
Process control[4] per SOPs. Ensure that balance is calibrated and ensure
that the expiry date of product to be released is later
Modern methods of process control in process than that of batch expiry date. Check and ensure that the
validation are all materials are issued as per BMR. And all the rooms
such as granulation room, Compression room, coating
➢ Six sigma
room, packing room etc are clean and line clearance has
➢ Process capability index been done prior to processing.
➢ Statistical process control (SPC) include: 2. Mixing or Blending
Sampling plan, experimental design, variation Materials that have similar physical properties will be
reduction, process capability analysis, process easier to form a uniform mix or blend and will not
improvement plans,SPC will not improve a poorly
© 2011-15, JDDT. All Rights Reserved ISSN: 2250-1177 CODEN (USA): JDDTAO
Parajuli et al Journal of Drug Delivery & Therapeutics. 2015; 5(6):1-7 5
© 2011-15, JDDT. All Rights Reserved ISSN: 2250-1177 CODEN (USA): JDDTAO
Parajuli et al Journal of Drug Delivery & Therapeutics. 2015; 5(6):1-7 6
be checked against the formulation order of the team must identify the product and process
validation batch processing records. characteristics that must be studied and incorporate
The environmental condition during batch specific validation tests to ensure that that product will
execution at each processing stage shall be checked meet all quality, manufacturing, and regulatory
against the formulation order of the validation requirements. The total program should begin with
batch processing records. validation of the active pharmaceutical ingredient (API)
Stage of process, details of process variables the characteristics so that this material will be uniform
respective observations and recommendations shall batch after batch, providing a solid pillar under which
be checked against the formulation order of the the dosage form will be built. The parameters chosen
validation batch processing records. must be relevant indicators of a controlled process.
Any work done in addition to that specific in the Continued awareness of validation requirements and a
protocol or any deviation from the protocol should diligent application of validation principles will thus
be formally noted along with an explanation. help to ensure that pharmaceutical products will be able
All sampling location shall be specified. to be developed and produced with the quality and
The actual yield obtained at different stages shall reproducibility required from regulatory agencies across
be checked against the formulation order of the the world.
validation batch processing records.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT:
CONCLUSION:
The corresponding author expresses deep gratitude to
It is concluded that Process validation is a step to assure Phr. Prawan Dahal and friends for their co-operation
the identity, strength, purity, safety and efficacy of and guidance in searching various articles and journals
pharmaceutical drug products, and it is the most for completion of this review and also grateful to
common word in the drug development, manufacturing authors, editors & publishers of all those articles,
and specification of finished product. Process validation journals and books from where the literature for this
is major requirement of cGMPs regulation for the article has been reviewed and discussed.
process efficiency. The multidisciplinary validation
REFERENCES:
1. Aulton M.E, Pharmaceutics-The Science of Dosage Form 11. Note for Guidance on Process Validation The Europe Agency
Design. 2nd edition, Churchill Livingstone, Elsevier, 2006. for Evaluation of
2. Oechslein C, Lazar M. S – Process Validation from view MedicinalProducts;CPMP/QWP/848/96;EMEA/CVMP/598/9
report of the FDA, Maas & Peither AG – GMP Publishing, 9;
Logfile No. 3/ February 2012. 12. Mayer RJ. Validation of Product and Process, PPMA.
3. Quality Management System – Process Validation Guidance Seminar on Validation of solid Dosage form Processes.
GHTF/SG3/N99-10:2004 (Edition 2). Atlanata May – 1980.
4. Nash R. A and Wachter A. H, Pharmaceutical Process 13. A. Ojha, M. Bharkatiya and S. Kitawat, Pharmaceutical
Validation an International Third Edition. Revised and Process Validation Of Solid Dosage Forms: A Review, World
Expended, Marcel Dekkar, Inc., New York, 2003; 17 – 40. Journal Of Pharmacy And Pharmaceutical Sciences,Volume
5. Patel R. C, Bhuva C. K, singh R. P, Dadhich A,Sharma A, 3, Issue 6, 476-484.
Pharmaceutical Process Validation, Pharmatutor – ART – 14. S. Jena, G. Arjun, N. V. Anil Kumar Ravipati, D.Satish
1053. kumar, Vinod.K.R, David Banji Industrial Process Validation
6. Jatto, E., Okhamafe.O.A,.An overview of pharmaceutical Of Solid Dosage Forms – An Overview International Journal
validation and process controls in drug development. Tropical of Pharmaceutical Sciences Review and Research Vol 4, Issue
J pharm research. (2), 115-122. 2004. 2, 2010; 145-154
7. USA-FDA, Guidelines on General Principles of Process 15. Bankar GS, Anderson NR Tablets: The Theory and practice
Validation, CEDR, FDA-USA, 1987. of industrial pharmacy (3rd edn), Varghese publishing house,
8. Guidance for Industry, Process Validation General Principles Mumbai, India, (1987).
and Practices (2011). 16. http://whoguideline.blogspot.com/2008/ importance-of-master
9. Guide to Inspections Validation of Cleaning Processes, US manufacturing.
Food and Drug Administration, Washington Dc, 2005. 17. Quality Management System – Process Validation Guidance
10. Guide to Inspections of Oral Solid Dosage Forms pre/post GHTF/SG3/N99-10:2004 (2nd Edition).
Approval Issue for Development and Validation; issue (1/94);
January, 2010.
© 2011-15, JDDT. All Rights Reserved ISSN: 2250-1177 CODEN (USA): JDDTAO