Definitions: Novel - Ethical - Feasible - Interesting
Definitions: Novel - Ethical - Feasible - Interesting
What is “Research”?
A combination of most of the following:
Reading - Collecting Data - Interpretation of Data - Scientific investigation - Doing Experiments - Creative
process - Organized and systematic way to find answers to questions - Gaining some familiarity with a topic
- Discovering new knowledge.
1
What is a good research problem?
(From: C Zhai, Introduction to IR Research Methodology, University of Illinois)
• Well-defined: Would we be able to tell whether you’ve solved the problem?
• Highly important: Who would really care about the solution to the problem?
• Solvable: Is there any clue about how to solve it? Do you have a baseline approach? Do
you have the needed resources?
• Matching your strength: Are you good at solving this kind of problems?
• Do literature review
• Check that your idea is original
2
begin with a problem-an
unanswered question
interpret the meaning
clearly indicate the
of the data
goal of the research
develop a specific
plan for addressing Identify the
the problem and sub hypotheses and
problems assumptions
Leedy and Ormrod
Practical Research 2001
How to Start?
(From: C Zhai, Introduction to IR Research Methodology, University of Illinois)
- Scan most recently published papers to find papers that you like or can understand
- Read such papers
- Track down background papers to increase your understanding
- Brainstorm ideas of extending the work
- Can you think of questions that aren’t answered?
3
- Is there a better formulation of the problem؟
- Is there a better method for solving the problem؟
- Is the evaluation solid?
- Pick one new idea and work on it.
Formulate Hypotheses
(From: C Zhai, Introduction to IR Research Methodology, University of Illinois)
• Study existing literature to figure out where exactly you can make a new contribution
(what do you want others to cite your work as?).
• The more specialized a hypothesis is, the more likely it’s new, but a narrow hypothesis
has lower impact than a general one, so try to generalize as much as you can to increase
impact.
• Avoid over-generalize.
• Define the hypothesis to be tested (include any necessary conditions).
• Design the right experiments to test.
• Analyze results.
• Unless you’ve got a complete understanding of everything, always attempts to formulate
a further hypothesis to achieve better understanding.