2006 Bridge Bowmaker
2006 Bridge Bowmaker
Geoff has 35 years experience in Australia, Asia and the United Kingdom in the
design and construction of rail, road and bridge projects. He is a Technical Director
of Maunsell, currently based in Sydney.
Geoff was recently responsible for the tender and concept design for the 144 bridges
of the Westlink M7 Motorway in Sydney and subsequently was Technical Manager
for the design of the major precast segmental bridges.
SYNOPSIS
The Westlink M7 project is a 40km dual carriageway motorway in western Sydney,
connecting the M5 Motorway at Prestons to the M2 Motorway at Baulkham Hills. The
project includes the construction of 144 small to medium sized bridge structures,
which comprised a significant proportion of the overall project costs and their
construction was a critical programming constraint on the completion of the project
and the early opening of the motorway.
Conventional pretensioned precast beam designs using planks and super-Tees were
chosen for bridges with spans up to 35m and precast segmental box girder bridges
for the longer span bridges and motorway overbridges. Span by span box girder
designs incorporating dry joints and external tendons were adopted for the motorway
viaducts and overbridges. Balanced cantilever segmental boxes incorporating epoxy
joints and internal tendons were designed for the longer span bridges at the major
motorway interchanges and major road crossings.
A shared path for pedestrians and cyclists runs the full length of the project, and
designs for the shared path structures over environmentally sensitive areas used
precast "boardwalks" with spans to 20m. Major shared path bridges were designed
with special emphasis on urban design.
This paper discusses the design of the various bridges on the project. Issues include
the selection of the design criteria and construction specifications for the segmental
bridges, the significant urban design goals, and the standardisation of the designs to
enable rapid precasting and erection.
1. INTRODUCTION
The Westlink M7 project is a 40km dual carriageway motorway in western Sydney,
connecting the M5 Motorway at Prestons to the M2 Motorway at Baulkham Hills.
The two major interchanges with the M4 and M5 Motorways provided considerable
challenges. They involved the construction of more than 20 separate ramps at up to
five different levels over some of the busiest sections of motorway in Australia.
Minimising the impact on the existing motorways was a major factor in the selection
of the construction techniques for the bridges.
Conventional pretensioned precast beam designs using planks and super-Tees were
chosen for bridges with spans up to 35m and precast segmental box girder bridges
for the longer span bridges and motorway overbridges. Span by span box girder
A shared path for pedestrians and cyclists runs the full length of the project, and
designs for the shared path structures over environmentally sensitive areas used
precast "boardwalks" with spans to 20m. Major shared path bridges were designed
with special emphasis on urban design.
The project is a Build Own Operate and Transfer (BOOT) project between Roads and
Traffic Authority of NSW (RTA) and Westlink Motorway Limited (Westlink). Westlink
contracted Abigroup / Leighton Joint Venture as the Construction Joint Venture
(ALJV) for the design and construction of the M7. The Maunsell / SMEC Joint
Venture was lead consultant for the engineering design.
The contract for the works was signed in February 2003 with a contract construction
period of 42 months and a construction price of $1.5 billion. Construction
commenced in July 2003 and the motorway was opened in December 2005, over 8
months ahead of the original programme.
During the concept design stage, assessments were made of the capabilities of the
precast concrete and steel fabrication industries to supply the required number of
components, and to minimise the risk to the construction programme, a new
precasting facility was considered to be required. By adopting segmental precast box
girders instead of Super-T’s for the long viaducts, it was possible to reduce the
number of Super-T girders required on the project to manageable proportions that
could be handled by the existing industries. In addition, the PSC box girders could
be used for the ramp bridges and thus eliminate the need for fabricated curved steel
girders. The use of precast concrete segmental girders also reduced the amount of
in-situ concrete work.
The column shapes and the abutment treatments have been selected to achieve a
consistent family of bridges that will be readily identifiable as belonging to the M7.
The designers have worked closely with Coneybeare Morrison Partnership to achieve
the required urban design outcomes.
The slender box girders with long cantilevers have been considered to enhance the
appearance of the bridges, particularly the highly visible overbridges and ramp
bridges at the major interchanges.
The overbridges were of spans that generally would not be constructed using precast
segmental girders. By using this form of construction for the overbridges, however,
the larger depth Super-T bridges were virtually eliminated from the project, and the
appearance of the overbridges was considerably enhanced, particularly with respect
to treatment at the central piers.
In order to minimise the effects on vegetation in the riparian zone, the precast girders
were constructed with transverse slots to allow light and water to penetrate, while at
the same time satisfying the ride criteria for cyclists on the shared path.
The open topped super-T (or Tee-Roff) bridges were used for spans of up to 35m.
5. SEGMENTAL BRIDGES
Segmental box girders were designed for 34 of the bridges, having a total deck area
of over 88,000m2. The maximum span length was 94 m, and the minimum radius of
curvature was 250m. Two different construction methods were adopted; externally
prestressed spans constructed using either erection beams or falsework, and
internally prestressed spans erected using the method of balanced cantilevering.
As the longer span bridges required a variable depth of section, the cross section
selected has vertical webs.
The depth of the boxes was selected to suit the various span lengths. The minimum
depth of box used was 2.0m, as this depth is considered the minimum practical depth
for access to the boxes for construction and future inspection. For balanced
The width of segments varies from a minimum of 8.15m for one of the ramp bridges
to a maximum of approximately 15m for Hoxton Park Viaduct. For the wide multi-box
overbridges, the maximum width of segment was maintained at 15m. To suit the
majority of the bridges, a width of box of 5.4m was adopted, which was reduced to
4.0m for the narrow ramp bridges.
The top flange dimensions were governed by the requirement to locate the top flange
prestressing anchorages for balanced cantilever bridges within the flange depth
adjacent to the webs. The top flange thus varies in depth from 225 mm to a
maximum of 450 mm adjacent to the webs. The bottom flange thickness is typically
200 mm for the span-by-span bridges and varies from 250 to 450 mm for the
balanced cantilever bridges.
Three web widths were used; 350, 450 and 550 mm.
SEGMENT
VARIES 11645 TO 15000
For the long viaducts, the spans are simply supported and erection is performed
using underslung erection beams. This form of construction allows rapid erection
and the box shapes are generally simple and quick to fabricate in the precasting
yard.
Span lengths are up to 35m and prestressing is applied using tendons of sizes up to
31/15.2 mm strands. The design can cater for up to 12 tendons per box though for
the simply supported spans there are generally no more than 8 tendons per box.
The tendons are anchored at each end diaphragm and deviators are located at
approximately third points of the span.
The architectural treatment of the piers for these bridges is very important. Typically
this type of deck has large pier heads to simplify construction. For the long viaducts
on M7 the piers consist of separate columns under each box web, elongated to allow
two bearings to be located in the longitudinal direction at each pier head.
The overbridges have spans up to a maximum of 38m, and are typically two span
structures with spill through abutments. The RTA requirements of the project deed
restricted the allowable width of the pier in the central median, and it was not possible
to use piers wide enough for two bearings longitudinally as used for the viaducts.
These structures were therefore built as continuous structures with single bearings at
the intermediate piers. The multiple span arrangement requires more prestressing,
some of which was placed axially, i.e. some tendons were not deviated at the
intermediate span deviator segments.
The overbridges range in width up to 60m, and the decks have been constructed
using multiple box cross sections, joined together using in-situ stitches connecting
the tips of adjacent cantilevers.
The balanced cantilever bridges are used for the longer spans over Old Windsor
Road and Cowpasture Road, and for the curved ramps at the major motorway
interchanges.
Segments are erected by crane and temporarily connected using VSL stressbar.
When corresponding segments have been erected on each end of the cantilever,
All stressing blisters for the continuity stressing and for the temporary erection bars
are cast as part of the concrete box section.
For the balanced cantilever bridges, the bottom flange thickness and web thickness
both vary, which increased the complexity of the temporary blister arrangements.
The shape of the piers varies depending on the site constraints. Typically the piers
are single columns supported on a pilecap and bored piles. For all bridges other than
the M4 ramps, temporary props supported on the pile caps resist the overturning of
the cantilever during erection. For the M4 ramp bridges, which are much higher (up
to 25m above the existing), the stability is achieved by two sets of ties that are
anchored in the pilecap.
For the precast segmental bridges, the following tolerances were adopted on the M7
project. These values obviously depend on the methods adopted in the casting yard
for controlling the match casting.
During construction load cases, the limits were set as zero tension at dry joints and
0.5 √(f’c ) tension for epoxy joints.
A minimum compressive stress of 0.15 MPa was applied across the joints on initial
erection of the segments.
There does not appear to be good reason for limiting stresses for transient
serviceability loads for structures with Type A epoxy joints.
5.5 Specifications
With the balanced cantilever method the prestressing is internal to the concrete
section and the ducting is therefore not continuous as opposed to the span by span
and continuous overbridges whereby the tendon ducts are continuous and external to
the concrete section. To provide an extra layer of protection to the prestressing
tendons within the balanced cantilever structures the joints are applied with an epoxy
to ‘seal” the joints and effectively provide continuous ducting for the prestressing
tendons.
The specification for the epoxy sealant was developed specifically for the M7 project.
The epoxy basically was required to have a minimum 30 minute pot life, 45 minute
open time, and achieve 8 MPa at 12 hours and 50 MPa at 28 days.
Once the prestressing tendons are installed they are protected with a cementitious
grout. Given the critical nature of the protection of the tendons the grout used on the
WM7 segmental bridges was developed under joint research with the RTA and VSL
to provided the highest possible performance grout and hence protection.
The holes in the deviator to deflect the tendons are formed in the concrete in a
“diabolo” shape. No additional linings of the formed holes are required. The
minimum radius of curvature is 3.8m.
The E segments also attach the link slabs / expansion joints as appropriate, and
downstands for the support bearings. The downstands are of sufficient width to allow
placement of the erection jacks adjacent to the bearings.
Additional anchorage blisters are also provided for the temporary prestressing bars
that are used to support each segment during erection. There are two blisters at the
top flange of the box adjacent to the webs, and one temporary blister located at the
centre of the bottom flange. These blisters have a number of holes to ensure exact
alignment of the bars when there are changes to the web or flange thicknesses.
The reinforcement slices are spaced at 200 mm centres for all segments. This was
found to be an optimum spacing, and it allowed inserts for lifting, and temporary
attachments during construction to be placed between the slices. This spacing also
allowed considerable flexibility is selection of bars sizes to minimise reinforcement
quantities.
In the precasting yard, the segments are lifted from beneath the cantilevers using
purpose made straddle carriers. The design of the segments allowed for the
handling of the segments at an early age.
The transverse prestressing allowed early stripping on the cantilever forms (a small
amount of prestress was applied after 12 hours). The transverse prestressing also
controls deflections under service loads.
This erection philosophy minimises the construction load effects on the columns,
although it does require care with setting and aligning the initial segments for each
cantilever to ensure accurate alignment.
For all balanced cantilever bridges except for the M4 ramps, concrete props are used
at each of the piers to take the out-of-balance moments.
For the M4 ramps, where piers are up to 25m in height and where there was often
very limited room at the pilecap level due to existing traffic, tension ties on each side
of the columns take the out-of-balance moments. The loads in the tension ties are
increased in stages only as the longitudinal cantilevering prestress increases so as
not to overload the webs adjacent to the piers.
The daily cycle relied on a concrete strength gain of 12 MPa in 12 hrs to enable the
forms to be demoulded 12 hrs after casting and providing a 12 hr window to
demould, clean, place reinforcement, seal, inspect the mould and place concrete.
Utilising the short line matching casting method, 50 to 55 segments per week were
produced from the 14 moulds in a 5 day casting week.
Once the segments were cast they were transported to the storage yard by
customised straddle carriers with hydraulic operated lifting frames.
By connecting the CRCP into the bridge deck, axial loads are carried through the
deck and all components (link slabs, approach slabs) are designed for a combination
of axial loads and bending.
7. CONCLUSION
The M7 is one of the largest single road infrastructure projects to be built in NSW.
The 144 bridges comprised a significant proportion of the overall project costs and
their successful completion was a major factor in the early opening of the motorway.
REFERENCES
AASHTO (2002), AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications
AUSTROADS (1992). Bridge Design Code, AUSTROADS, Sydney
Bowmaker, G.J. and Van der Wal, G (2005), Design and Construction of Segmental
Box Girder Bridges for the Westlink M7 Motorway, Concrete Institute of Australia,
22nd Conference, Melbourne, 2005
Griffiths, S., Bowmaker, G.J., Bridge, R.Q. (2006), Design of Seamless Pavement on
Westlink M7, Sydney, Australia. AUSTROADS 6th Bridge Conf, Perth
Standards Australia. (2004). Australian Standard. Bridge Design. Standards Australia
International, Sydney, AS 5100.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author wishes to thank Westlink Motorway Limited, Abigroup Leighton Joint
Venture, Maunsell-SMEC Joint Venture and the Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW
for permission to publish this paper. The views expressed in this paper are those of
the author.