ISSN XXXX XXXX © 2017 IJESC

Research Article Volume 7 Issue No.5

Thermal Analysis of Pin Fin with Different Shape Forms using

ANSYS
R. Sudheer kumar Reddy1, Dr .k. Govinda Rajulu 2, Dr. S.M. Jameel Basha 3, E. Vijay Gowd 4, P. Veera Prathap5,
C.N. Vishnu Vandhan.A6
Assistant Professor, Mechanical Engineering Department, SRIT, Anantapuramu, A.P India1
Professor and Principal of J.N.T.U.A, Pulivendula, Y.S.R Dist., A.P, India2
Professor and Head of Mechanical Engineering Department, SRIT, Anantapuramu, A.P India3
U.G Students, Mechanical Engineering Department, SRIT, Anantapuramu, A.P India4, 5, 6

Abstract:
Pin fins are most commonly used in heat exchanging microelectronic devices such as computer CPU heat sinks, and semiconductor
devices power transistors and optoelectronic devices such as lasers and light emitting diodes (LEDs). The objective of this study is to
examine the effects of the fin shape of the heat sink on the thermal performance. The various types of Perforation on pin fin are used
for effective heat transfer rate under constant heat flux condition. Cooling is done by forced convection utilizing fan. Air-based
cooling technologies have been widely employed for thermal management of electronics. For low power CPUs, aluminium heat sinks
are often capable of dissipating the heat. If better performance is required, copper heat sink may be used for higher heat sink
performance, but aluminium is used because of its lower weight and lower cost than copper. This numerical simulation is
accomplished by 3D modeling and analysis using CATIA and ANSYS, 12.0. This will help in finding out the new fin topologies with
heat transfer characteristics that will do better than conventional plane fin. The main goal is to increase the heat transfer rate through
the fin surface and to decrease material cost. The effect of different shape forms of pin fins on the overall performance of the heat sink
studied in this paper.

Keywords: pin fin apparatus, perforated pin fin, fin efficiency, fin effectiveness.

1. INTRODUCTION that the rectangular shaped extended surfaces shows the high
rate of heat transfer when compared to other extensions at same
The design of heat sink device is predicated upon optimizing the length. Kang Hiechan[4], has made many experiments to find
opposite demands of thermal dissipation rate. Rapid the fin efficiency and concluded that the efficiency of fin is
development in manufacturing technology and consumer useful when the value of NTU is zero otherwise the fin
demands has driven the electronic technology towards increasing efficiency is high when the NTU is high and is used in air
the functionality and compactness of the components. The conditioning systems. Shivdas S Kharche[5], explained that the
miniaturization of electronics results in higher rate of power when a notch is provided on the surface of fin with a rectangular
dissipation per unit volume. Thus effective thermal management shape the fin supports for much heat transfer and compared the
becomes ever more critical to maintain the operation temperature heat transfer rate of fins by changing the material from
which would ensure the efficiency and reliability of the Aluminum to copper and found that copper shows much heat
electronic components [1]. Pin fins are widely used to enhance transfer value than aluminum. Sandhya Mirapalli[6], had made
forced convection heat transfer across various industries, finding a conclusion that for a triangular fin when the length is increased
application in turbine blade trailing edges, electronics cooling, the heatflow percentage also increases at constant base
and broadly for compact heat exchange. Increasing temperature compared to rectangular fin. I.Lakshmi Anusha[7],
miniaturization of high speed multifunctional electronics concluded that total weight of the system made of splayed pin
demands ever more stringent thermal management [2]. The fins can be reduced to the minimum level by using the advanced
present work investigates analyses the use of perforated pin fins composite materials like polyphenylene sulphide (PPS), carbon
to enhance the rate of heat transfer in these devices. In particular, foam, graphite epoxy at the same thermal inputs. Zhang, H.S[8],
the effects of the number of perforations and the diameter of resulted that a fabric heat sink temperature distribution is so
perforation on each pin are studied. nearer to common pin fin heat sink but the temperature decreases
in axial direction by increasing the pin fin length. Sampath S
2. LITERATURE SURVEY S[9], compared the temperature distribution of a cylindrical
element at various points is carried out by providing the thermal
 Most studies that have demonstrated the beneficial conductivity and heat transfer coefficient and with prescribed
effects of perforations on the rate of heat transfer in pin fin boundary conditions and analyzed with the help of simulation
arrays have used only a single perforation per pin. The logical software and DOT NET software[12] and the results are almost
extremis of this parameter is the metallic foam-like porous pins. equal expect at the middle of the specimen it is just deviated.
Indeed, numerical simulations, e.g. by Pradeep singh[3], stated Amol B. Dhumne[10], resulted that to achieve high thermal

International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, May 2017 11718 http://ijesc.org/
performance the cylindrical perforated pin fins are used they 6. Results
leads to high heat transfer than the cylindrical pin fins. M. P.
Shah[11], compared the study of cylindrical pin fin was done by 4.3.1 ENGINEERING DATA
changing the material conductivity and heat transfer coefficient Use the Engineering data cell with Mechanical systems or the
for copper ,AA1100,AA2011 materials[13] and concluded that Engineering data component system to define or access material
the heat transfer rate increases when thermal conductivity of models for use in an analysis. Double click the engineering data
material increases. cell, or right mouse click and choose EDIT from the context
menu to display the engineering data workspace to define
3. ANSYS material data. For more information see engineering data.

ANSYS stands for Analysis System. ANSYS Mechanical is a

finite element analysis tool for structural analysis, including
linear, nonlinear and dynamic studies. This computer simulation
product provides finite elements to model behaviour, and
supports material models and equation solvers for a wide range
of mechanical design problems.

3.1 USE OF ANSYS WORKBENCH

Ansys provide a cost effective way to explore the performance
of products or processes in a virtual environment. This type of
product development is termed virtual prototyping. The required material for the analysis is selected from the
With virtual prototyping techniques, users can iterate various options provided in the engineering data sources. There are
scenarios to optimize the product long before the manufacturing different categories of materials available in the engineering data
is started. This enables reduction in the level of risk, and in the sources for this steady state thermal analysis we are going to
cost of ineffective designs. consider the material as Aluminium. This material is available in
the general materials.
4. THE GRAPHICAL USER INTERFACE COMPONENTS
OF ANSYS WORKBENCH 4.3.2 REPLACE GEOMETRY:
Select browse to open a dialog box that allows you to navigate to
4.1 TOOLBOX an existing geometry file, or select a file from the list of recently
The ansys workbench toolbox presents the types of data that you viewed files to replace the currently specified file.
can add to your project. The toolbox in content sensitive, as you
select different items in the project schematic or the other UPDATE FROM CAD:
workspaces, the contents of the toolbox may change to reflect Generates an existing CAD Geometry using the parameter
the components and actions available to you. When working in values as defined in the cad system.
other workspaces, such as engineering data or parameters, you
can return to the project workspace by clicking the return to PROPERTIES:
project button on the toolbar. Displays a properties pane where you can select basic and
advanced geometry properties. For a detailed description of the
options available from the properties pane, see geometry
preferences in the Mechanical application help.

4.2 PROJECT SCHEMATIC

The project schematic captures the project and workflow of your
project, providing a visual representation of the objects in the
project and their relationship to each other. Analyses are shown The design modeller will be generated in a new window where
as systems, which are comprised of different individual cells. the geometric model can be imported according to our
requirement. Click on the import option so that the design
4.3 TYPES OF CELLS modeller imports the geometric created CAD model. The
1. Engineering data geometric model can be imported by right mouse click on the
2. Geometry import and then click on generate. This will generate the created
3. Model/Mesh CAD model into the design modeller window.
4. Setup
5. Solution

International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, May 2017 11719 http://ijesc.org/
 shown in the bottom left side box. The properties of the material
and the solid can be changed based on the results that are to be
attained. The meshing can be generated by right mouse click on
the mesh option in the left side toolbox Click on the generate
mesh option. The system takes a few seconds to generate the
required mesh.

The imported geometric model has to be converted or formed

into a single solid component Hence all the small parts of the
generated CAD model are selected and converted into a solid
part. To form a single solid part, right mouse click on the
selected solids and click on form new part The required CAD
model can be generated as a single solid part. The created model
can be used for further modelling or meshing based on the
requirement for the steady state thermal analysis.

The meshing of the created CAD model can be made by giving

the element size. There is a sizing option in the left side bottom
toolbox. Click on the sizing option, the element size is to be
defined. The smaller the element size the greater is the accuracy
in the results.

4.3.3 MODEL/MESH:
The Model cell in the Mechanical application analysis systems
or the Mechanical model component system is associated with
the Model branch in the Mechanical application and affects the
definition of the geometry, coordinate systems, connections and
mesh branches of the model definition.
The Mesh cell in the Steady State Thermal analysis systems or
the Mesh component system is used to create a mesh using the
Meshing application. It can also be used to import an existing
mesh file.

EDIT:
Launches the appropriate Model or Mesh application (the
mechanical application, meshing etc).
4.3.4 SETUP:
Use the Setup cell to launch the appropriate application for that
system. You will define your loads, boundary conditions, and
otherwise configure your analysis in the application. The data
from the application will then be incorporated in the project in
ansys workbench, including connections between systems. For
the mechanical application systems, you will see the following
setup options, in addition to the common options.

EDIT:
Now the generated model has to be meshed in order to get Launches the mechanical application with the geometry loaded
appropriate results. The left side box outline is having options and with cells mapped to their respective tree locations in the
mainly geometry, mesh, steady state thermal etc. The material mechanical applications. In this module the boundary conditions
can be again selected at the geometry option. The aluminium are to be defined. We are considering the steady state thermal
material will be available at the geometry. The boundary analysis in which the temperature values are to be specified for
conditions can be given according to the required analysis. Now the thermal analysis There are two types of boundary conditions
right click on the geometry to get an option called part. Now in this thermal analysis. First one is the temperature boundary
click on the part so that the required material can be selected as condition and the second one is the convection boundary

International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, May 2017 11720 http://ijesc.org/
condition. Now right mouse click on the steady state thermal
option which is available in the left side toolbox. Click on insert
and then select the temperature.

The convection is applied on the surface of the fin. A tick mark

is displayed on the left side of the convection option. Convection
heat transfer coefficient depends on the surface area that is
considered for the calculation. A graph is shown below the solid
Now the initial boundary condition is given as 105°C. In this part which is straight along the length of the fin i.e., the
thermal analysis, the initial condition is given at the heater i.e., convection takes place linearly along the length of the fin. The
the maximum temperature at which the conduction of the fin value of heat transfer coefficient changes based on the surface
starts. The required temperature value can be given beside the area considered and the initial boundary conditions of
magnitude option. After giving the temperature value, select all temperature.
the faces of the solid body where the temperature is to be applied
Here the temperature is given to the source as an input i.e., the 4.3.5 SOLUTION:
initial boundary condition. A graph is shown in the below From the solution cell, you can access the solution branch of
graphic window which indicates the temperature variation along your application, and you can share solution data with other
the fin. downstream systems (for instance, you can specify the solution
from one analysis as input conditions to another analysis). If you
have an analysis running as a remote process, you will see the
solution cell in a pending state until the remote process
completes.

IMPORT SOLUTION:
Displays the open dialog, where you can specify the solver
results file to load. When the results file is loaded, the system
will display only the solution cell and the results cell.

The second boundary condition is the convection along the fin.

Now in the graphic window, right mouse click on the steady
state thermal and then click on insert, then click convection.
Here the value of heat transfer coefficient is given according to
the calculations.

The solution in the ansys workbench gives the temperature

distribution along the considered surface or fin. To get the
temperature distribution, right mouse click on the solution and
click on insert and then select thermal. Then click on the
temperature so that the temperature distribution can be measured
along the length of the fin. The maximum temperature will be at
the source and the temperature gradually decrease along the
length of the fin.
The convection is applied only to the fin surface. Hence the
value of heat transfer is to be calculated earlier based on the
attained temperature values. Now give the value of heat transfer
coefficient in the toolbox beside the film coefficient in the left
side bottom box. Select all the surfaces on the fin and then click
apply so that the convection is applied on the fin. The ambient
temperature can be defined based on the requirement. Generally
the ambient temperature refers to the temperature inside the duct
where the air flow takes place. In this case the ambient
temperature can be considered as the atmospheric temperature as
25°C.

International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, May 2017 11721 http://ijesc.org/
After inserting temperature, right click on it and select evaluate defining the path, insert temperature from the solution option
all results. The temperature distribution is shown from the source available in the left side toolbox. Right mouse click on the
to the tip of the fin. The minimum temperature at the end temperature and then select evaluate all results. The required
indicates the heat transfer rate that has been taken place. The path will be generated as shown in the graphic window below.
temperature of the fin decreases if the heat transfer increases.

Here the path can be generated based on the given boundary

conditions. The maximum and minimum temperatures are
defined based on the steady state thermal analysis. The variation
of temperature can be determined from point 1 to point 2.
The temperature distribution can be determined by using ansys
workbench. The maximum temperature will be at the source and
the minimum temperature will be at the end of the fin. The
temperature gradually decreases from one end to other end based
on the given heat transfer coefficient.

4.3.6 RESULTS:
After the evaluation of temperature distribution along the length
of the fin, a path can be defined to analyze the variation in the
temperature from source to the free end of the fin. Hence to
define the path, construction geometry is to be considered. Now
right mouse click on the model and then click insert. There select
the construction geometry option. 5. TEMPERATURE DISTRIBUTION FOR DIFFERENT
MATERIALS

Now in this graphic window, the required path can be defined Figure.1. Temperature Distribution for Copper
based on the given boundary conditions. Click on construction
geometry, then select the path option. Here we require a path
from the source to the free end of the fin. After the selection of
path, the graphic window shows options where the required path
can be defined.

Figure.2. Temperature Distribution for Aluminium

We need to define the path based on two points i.e., the source
and the end of the fin. Now select the first point at the source
and then click apply. Again select second point at the free end of
the pin fin and then click apply. To generate the required path,
we have to insert temperature in the solution option. After Figure.3. Temperature Distribution for Brass

International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, May 2017 11722 http://ijesc.org/
Figure.4. Temperature Distribution for Stainless Steel Figure.7. Temperature Distribution for plane solid

500
Thermal Conductivity w/m-k

400
300
200
100
0
copper aluminium brass stainless
steel
Figure.8. Temperature varying along length of plane solid
Different materials
6.2 SOLID WITH PERPENDICULAR HOLES (S2)
Figure.5. Thermal conductivity of different materials
From the above temperature distribution analysis of different
materials copper have highest heat sink performance than the
other materials, but aluminium heat sinks are often capable of
dissipating the heat, because of its lower weight and lower cost
than copper.

ALUMINIUM:
AluminIum is a chemical element in the group with symbol Al
and its atomic number is 13.It is a silvery white, soft,
nonmagnetic, ductile metal. AluminIum is the third most
abundant element (after oxygen and silicon).The chief ore of
Aluminum is Bauxite. Its low density, excellent corrosion
Figure.9. Cad model for solid with perpendicular holes (P.H)
resistance, good thermal and electrical conductivity etc are the
Description of Solid:
other good properties. In the present work an Aluminium pin fin
of diameter 12 mm and the length of 135 mm is used.
Length = 135mm
Diameter = 12mm
6. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
Diameter for perpendicular holes = 3mm
6.1 PURE SOLID (S1)
No. of Perpendicular Holes = 4

Fig 6: Cad model for pure solid

Description of Solid:
Figure.10. Temperature Distribution for solid with P.H
Length = 135mm
Diameter = 12mm

International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, May 2017 11723 http://ijesc.org/
 6.4 SOLID WITH PERPENDICULAR HOLES AND
THROUGH WHOLE OF ONE BY TWO LENGTH (S4)

Figure.11. Temperature linear graph along the length of

solid with P.H.

6.3 SOLID WITH PERPENDICULAR HOLES AND

THROUGH WHOLE OF ONE BY THIRD LENGTH (S3)

Figure.15. Cad model for solid with P.H and axial hole of
one by two length.

Description of Solid:
Length = 135mm
Diameter = 12mm
Diameter of the Perpendicular Holes = 3mm
No. of perpendicular holes = 4
Length of the Through Hole = 67.5mm
Figure.12. Cad model for solid with P.H and axial hole of one
Diameter of the Through Hole = 6mm
by third length.

Description of Solid:
Length = 135mm
Diameter = 12mm
Diameter of the Perpendicular holes = 3mm
No. of Perpendicular Holes = 4
Length of the Through Hole = 45mm
Diameter of the Through Hole = 6mm

Figure.16. Temperature Distribution for solid with P.H and

Figure.13. Temperature Distribution for solid with P.H and axial hole of one by two length.
axial hole of one by third length.

Figure.17. Temperature linear graph along the length of

solid with P.H and axial hole of one by two length.
Figure.14. Temperature linear graph along the length of
solid with P.H and axial hole of one by third length.

International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, May 2017 11724 http://ijesc.org/
 Table 1: Heat transfer coefficient and Heat transfer rate for various pin fin configurations
Heat transfer
Velocity of air Heat transfer rate Maximum Temp.
Profile Heat Input (watts) coefficient, h
(m/s) 2 (watts) (oC)
(w/m k)
Plane solid 80 0.914 28.32 8.32 105
Solid with P.H 80 0.914 28.328 s8.40 103.8
Solid with P.H and
A.H of one by 80 0.914 28.334 9.12 102.6
third length
Solid with P.H and
A.H of one by two 80 0.914 28.428 9.89 101.2
length

7. CONCLUSION [6]. Pudiri Madhu, N. Sateesh, “Modeling and Simulation of

Fins for 150cc Engine”, Volume - 5 | Issue - 1 | Jan Special Issue
From the investigation the following conclusion were made: - 2015 | ISSN - 2249-555X
 It is found that the temperature drop along the
perforated fins length is consistently higher than that for [7]. Qusay R. Al-Hagag, Bassil M. Hadi, Mohammed Y. Al-
the non perforated fins. Janabi, “Optimum Design of Rectangular Plate Heat Sink”,
 It is found that the heat transfer rate is more for International Journal of Engineering Science and Technology,
different perforated fin compare to plane fin. Vol. 2(9), 2010, 4051- International Journal For Technological
 It is also concluded that from various perforated fins Research In Engineering Volume 3, Issue 3, November-2015
Plane solid have minimum heat transfer rate whereas ISSN (Online): 2347 - 4718 www.ijtre.com Copyright 2015.All
solid with perpendicular hole and axial hole of one by rights reserved. 397 4062.
two length have highest heat transfer rate.
 It is found that the Nusselt number, heat transfer [8]. Hussam Jouhara, “Modelling and Simulation Techniques for
andheat transfer coefficient is maximum in case of solid Forced Convection Heat Transfer in Heat Sinks with
with perpendicular hols and axial hole one by two Rectangular FinsSchool of Engineering and Design, Brunel
length fin. University, Uxbridge.
 Perforated fin leads to decreases the expenditure of the
fin material. [9]. Salila Ranjan Dixit, DrTarinicharana Panda, “Numerical
Analysis of Inverted Notched Fin Array Using Natural
7. REFERENCES Convection”, IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering
(IOSR-JMCE), Volume 6, Issue 4 (May. Jun. 2013), PP 47-56
[1]. R. Sam Sukumar, G.Sriharsha, S.Bala Arun, P.Dilip kumar,
Ch.Sanyasi Naidu,Modelling and Analysis of Heat Sink With [10]. Pratul Biswas, “Analytical Model for Performance
Rectangular Fins Having Through Holes”,Journal of Analysis of a Two dimensional Fin Assembly under
Engineering Research and Applications (IJERA), Vol. 3, Issue 2, Dehumidification Process: A Comparison of One and Two
March – April 2013, pp.1557-1561. Dimensional Investigation”, Jadavpur University.

[2]. Deepak Gupta, Vignesh Venkataraman, Rakesh Nimje, [11]. Y. Chung and K. Luo,‖ Unsteady heat transfer analysis of
“Thermal Analysis of Heat Sink and its application in CPU”, an impinging jet‖, J. Heat Transfer, 124 (2002) 1039-48.
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced
Engineering, ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, [12]. B.Sri Aravindh, “Heat Sink Performance Analysis through
Volume 4, Issue 8, August 2014). Numerical Technique”, IEEE Symposium (NSSP08), Bangalore,
2008.
[3]. Mr. N. Phani Raja Rao, Mr. T. Vishnu Vardhan, “Thermal
Analysis of Engine Cylinder Fins By Varying Its Geometry and [13]. Saitoh, T., Sajik, T., and Maruhara, K., 1993, “Benchmark
Material”, International Journal of Engineering Research & Solutions to Natural Convection Heat Transfer Problem Around
Technology (IJERT), Vol. 2 Issue 8, August – 2013 a Horizontal Circular Cylinder,” Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer, 36
pp. 1251-1259.
[4]. S.S. Sane, N. K. Sane, G.V.Parishwad, “Computational
Analysis of Horizontal Rectangular Notched Fin Arrays
Dissipating Heat by Natural Convection”, 5th Thermal-Sciences
Conference, The Netherlands, 2008

[5]. Nocedal J & Wright S. (1999), Numerical Optimization.

New York: Springer.

International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, May 2017 11725 http://ijesc.org/