031
031
Abstract: A thin layer chromatographicñdensitometric method has been developed for identification and quan-
titative determination of neomycin derivative with dabsyl chloride. The analysis of antibiotic was achieved on
the silica gel TLC plates with fluorescent indicator with n-butanol ñ 2-butanone ñ 25% ammonia ñ water (10 :
6 : 2 : 2, v/v/v/v) as the mobile phase. The densitometric measurements were made at 460 nm. Under these con-
ditions good separation of chosen aminoglycoside antibiotic from reagent used to make a complex was
obtained. The method is characterized by high sensitivity, LOD from 0.1953 µg per band and LOQ from 0.5918
µg per band, wide linearity range from 0.5918 to 2.1960 µg per band for neomycin. The precision of the method
was good; RSD varied from 1.17 to 2.05%. Satisfactory results of validation of the method were also confirmed
by determination of selected antibiotic in pharmaceutical commercial preparation. The results obtained by
TLCñdensitometric method were compared with those obtained by spectrophotometric method.
31
32 URSZULA HUBICKA et al.
bacitracin and methyl and propyl hydroxybenzoate in analytical grade and were purchased either from
ophthalmic ointment was described by Krzek et al. POCh (Gliwice, Poland) or Chempur (Piekary
(14). Hubicka et al. described the analysis of ålπskie, Poland).
amikacin, gentamicin, kanamicin, neomycin, Dabsyl chloride (DBS) ñ assay = 97.5% (AT)
netilmycin and tobramycin in pharmaceutical prepa- no. 39068 (Fluka, Chemie AG Buchs, Switzerland).
rations (tobramycin ampoules, amikacin vials, tablets Solutions of DBS in acetone were prepared at con-
containing 250 mg of neomycin and eye drops con- centrations 0.3238 mg/mL and 0.1619 mg/mL.
taining 3 mg/mL of gentamicin) (15). The densito-
metric measurements were made after detection with Standard solutions and substance
a 0.2% ninhydrin solution in ethanol (14, 15). The following pharmaceutical raw material of
Anionic capillary isotachophoresis (cITP) with neomycin sulfate was used: 25 g PPH Galfarm ñ no.
conductometric detection was used for indirect 011209. Neomycin met the requirements described
determination of neomycin trisulfate as sulfate anion in a monograph in Polish Pharmacopoeia (FP VIII)
in pharmaceutical preparations (16, 17). Capillary within the scope of identity, purity and biological
elektrophoresis with direct (18) and indirect (19, 20) activity. Standard solutions in water were prepared
UV detection for simultaneous determination of at concentrations from 1.8603 to 0.1970 mg/mL cal-
neomycin sulfate and such active substances as culated on neomycin.
hydrocortisone, polymyxin in various pharmaceuti-
cal preparations have been reported (18ñ20). Pharmaceutical preparation and solution
Since 1975, dabsyl chloride (DBS) has been Neomycinum ñ tablets (250 mg neomycin sul-
used for identification of N-terminal amino acid in fate, macrogol 4000, sodium starch glycolate type
polypeptide chain during analysis of compounds A, talc, magnesium stearate, saccharose about 260
containing amine group (21). The first step in the mg in one tablet). Polfa Tarchomin S.A., Poland,
process is condensation of DBS with polypeptide series No. 1010904.
through N-terminal amino acid. The second step is A solutions of Neomycinum ñ to prepare sam-
hydrolysis in acidic environment that results in a ple solution from powdered mass of 20 tablets,
product ñ sulfonamide derivative. The final third 50.10 mg corresponding to 15.52 mg of neomycin
step is chromatographic identification of obtained was accurately weighed. Then, 15.0 mL of water
product. This reaction is highly sensitive (10-9ñ10-10 was added into the sample and the solution was
mol/L). For example, biogenic amines, bisoprolol, shaken for 15 min. Then, the solution was filled up
labetalol, and propafenone as dabsyl derivatives with water to 25.0 mL. The suspension was filtered
were determined (22ñ25). directly into a 25.0 mL volumetric flask through
The quantitative determination of bacitracin qualitative filter paper. For testing by spectrophoto-
after condensation reaction with DBS was presented metric method, the solution of neomycin at a con-
by Krzek and Piotrowska. Modification in the centration of 1.8600 mg/mL was prepared similarly.
method of N-terminal amino acid determination
with the use of DBS was done by exclusion of TLC method
hydrolysis and establishing reaction conditions to Preparation of neomycin derivative with dabsyl
enable direct spectrophotometric estimation of the chloride (NDC)
product of DBS reaction with the antibiotic (26). A product of reaction was formed when 0.5 mL
In this paper a new TLCñdensitometric method of neomycin solution was mixed with 1.0 mL of
was developed for the simultaneous identification DBS (0.1619 mg/mL) and 0.2 mL of carbonate
and quantitative determination of neomycin deriva- buffer (pH = 9.0). The samples and blank solution
tive with dabsyl chloride (NDC), directly without were heated up in water bath at 70OC for 15 min, and
the requirement of chromatogram visualization. The then cooled down and adjusted with acetone to the
developed method was validated and used for the final volume of 5.0 mL. A blank solution containing
quantitative determination of neomycin in pharma- identical volume of carbonate buffer (pH = 9.00)
ceutical preparation. and DBS concentration as in the study sample was
prepared.
EXPERIMENTAL
TLC analysis
Reagents TLC was performed on 10 ◊ 12 cm TLC plates
Acetone, sodium carbonate, sodium bicarbon- cut from 20 ◊ 20 cm aluminium foil-backed plates pre-
ate, 25% ammonia, butanol, 2-butanone were of coated with silica gel 60 F254 (Merck, Germany;
Determination of neomycin in the form of neomycin derivative... 33
#1.05548). Solutions of the NDC obtained for standard was described in ìTLC analysisî. Linearity was
solutions and for preparation solution (30 µL) were assessed in triplicate on the basis of the relationship
applied to the plates as 0.8 cm bands, 1.0 cm from the between mean peak area and amount of neomycin in
bottom edge, 1.0 cm from the sides and 0.8 cm apart, micrograms per band. Linearity was reported as
by use of a Linomat V sample applicator (Camag, regression equations, correlation coefficients (r) and
Switzerland). Chromatograms were developed to a dis- determination coefficient (r2).
tance of 12 cm with n-butanol ñ 2-butanone ñ 25%
ammonia ñ water (10 : 6 : 2 : 2, v/v/v/v) as a mobile The limit of detection (LOD) and quantification
phase in a chromatographic chamber (18 ◊ 9 ◊ 18 cm (LOQ)
Sigma-Aldrich, USA, #Z20,415-3). The mobile phase Solutions of neomycin in the form of derivative
was chosen experimentally by checking different sol- with DBS (0.1220 ñ 0.3660 mg/mL) were applied on
vent mixtures. Plates were dried at room temperature the plates. LOD and LOQ were calculated on the
for one hour. Bands on the chromatograms retain basis of the slope (a) of the calibration line and the
durable yellow color within 24 h. Color of bands con- standard error of the estimate (Se), using formulas:
trasts with a white background of chromatogram. LOD = 3.3 Se / a and LOQ = 10 Se / a.
Bands were visible and could be used for quantitative
densitometric determination. Detection was carried out Precision
by Camag TLC Scanner 3 with winCats 1.3.4 software The repeatability of the method was deter-
at λ = 460 nm; this wavelength was selected on the mined by analysis of five replicates of NDC
basis of the recorded absorption spectra. In addition to obtained for standard solutions from individual
the RF values, identification of analyzed substances weighings. Study was done for three concentration
were done. Peak areas of NDC obtained for standard levels, 50% (0.5918 µg per band of NDC), 100%
solutions and for preparation solution were recorded (1.0980 µg per band of NDC) and 150% (1.6470 µg
directly from the chromatograms and were used for per band of NDC). Intermediate precision was
quantitative analysis. obtained by analysis of solutions at the same con-
centration by a different analyst who performed the
Method validation analysis over a period of one week.
The method was validated by checking the
specificity, linearity, precision, recovery, limits of Accuracy
detection and quantification and also robustness in Accuracy was assessed by determination of the
accordance with ICH guidelines (27). recovery (%) of the drug. Precisely known weighed
amounts of the neomycin standard (from 80 to 120%
Specificity of the declared content) were added to preparation
Specificity of the method was assessed by solutions and percentage recovery was calculated on
comparing chromatograms of NDC obtained for the basis of the determined amounts of added
standard solutions and for preparation solution, neomycin standard under conditions of developed
chromatogram of blank solution and blank chro- method in relation to the amount weighed. For each
matogram. level three determinations were done.
In obtained chromatograms, the retardation
factor (RF) values of analyzed substances, resolution Robustness
factor, peak areas, peak purity and spot color were Under conditions of the developed method,
taken into account. Resolution factor (Rs) was cal- comparison of results with change of stationary
culated according to the formula: phase from TLC (Merck, Germany) to TLC (poly-
Rs = 2 ◊ (distance between the centers of two ester sheets precoated with silica gel 60 F254
adjacent spots) / (sum of the two spots in the direc- Macherey-Nagel, Germany; #805023) plates was
tion of development). done.
The impact of small changes of 25% ammonia
Linearity in the composition of the mobile phase (± 5%) for
The calibration plot for the method was con- chromatographic separation was checked.
structed by analysis of seven solutions containing
different concentrations of neomycin in the range Determination of neomycin in pharmaceutical
0.1970 ñ 0.7320 mg/mL after reaction with dabsyl preparation
chloride. Preparation of samples working solutions Determination of neomycin in tested tablets
were described before. Further analytical procedure was carried out according to earlier described proce-
34 URSZULA HUBICKA et al.
dure. The amount of 0.9150 µg per band of NDC chloride was carried out according to earlier
obtained for standard solution and preparation solu- described procedure. For this purpose, a series of
tion were applied onto TLC plates for the determi- six solutions containing DBS with neomycin
nation of neomycin content. For each determination preparation solution at a concentration of 1.8600
three measurements were performed and the mean mg/mL were prepared. Then, the content of
value was taken for calculations. neomycin in pharmaceutical preparation was cal-
culated by comparing appropriate values of
Spectrophotometric method absorbance recorded at λmax = 492 nm for standard
In order to compare the test results obtained by and sample solutions.
TLC method for the determination of neomycin,
spectrophotometric method was performed (26). RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The method was validated in accordance with ICH
guidelines (27). The obtained results were used for Reaction of free amine groups with DBS was
statistical evaluation. used for the development of a new TLC method for
the determination of neomycin in pharmaceutical
Formation of neomycin derivative with dabsyl chlo- preparation. In the first stage of studies, conditions
ride for the separation of NDC and DBS were estab-
A product of reaction was formed when 0.2 mL lished (Fig. 1).
of neomycin solution (0.6100 mg/mL) in water was The mobile phase n-butanol ñ 2-butanone ñ
mixed with 1.2 mL of DBS solution (0.3238 mg/mL) 25% ammonia ñ water (10 : 6 : 2 : 2, v/v/v/v)
and 0.2 mL of carbonate buffer (pH = 9.0), heated up enables good resolution of analyzed substances.
at 70OC for 15 min, then cooled down to 25OC, 0.5 NDC on TLC chromatogram appeared as a compact
mL of distilled water added and adjusted with ace- yellow band, which contrasts with the white back-
tone to the final volume of 5.0 mL. A reference mate- ground of the plate and its RF value was 0.22. The
rial containing identical volume of carbonate buffer NDC bands were stable after application to the plate
(pH = 9.00) and DBS concentration as in the studied for 24 h. Next to the NDC, band of DBS (RF 0.53)
sample was prepared for each individual sample. appeared in chromatogram and didnít interfere with
Absorbance at 492 nm was measured by use of a the band of tested complex (Fig. 2).
UV/Vis spectrophotometer (Varian Cary 100 Conc.) The application of densitometric detection
in relation to appropriate reference material. demonstrated that peaks in the chromatograms were
well resolved, symmetrical and easy to identify and
Determination of neomycin in pharmaceutical determine. Registration of peak areas for NDC was
preparation carried out at λ = 460 nm. The analytical wavelength
Determination of neomycin in tested tablets chosen for densitometric registration corresponded
after formation of neomycin derivative with dabsyl to absorption maximum for NDC.
Figure 2. Densitogram of neomycin derivative with dabsyl chloride (NDC) and dabsyl chloride (DBS)
In the available literature there were some For estimation of reliability of the developed
papers describing the determination of neomycin by method according to ICH recommendations, the fol-
thin-layer chromatography, where densitometric lowing parameters were determined: specificity, lin-
detection of neomycin was performed after previ- earity, limits of detection and quantitation, recovery
ously spraying with a ninhydrin solution (14, 15). and robustness (27).
Application of ninhydrin required complete evapo- The developed method was specific against the
ration of ammonia (mobile phase component) from studied components. There are no peaks in chro-
the stationary phase by heating plates at 100OC for matogram recorded for blank solution, chro-
about 1.5 h. The research presented in this paper matograms of NDC obtained for standard solutions
revealed that the developed method for the determi- and for preparation solution and blank chro-
nation of neomycin in the form of color derivative matogram where studied components occur. Good
with DBS may be an alternative to time consuming correlation between VIS spectra acquired from the
method using ninhydrin solution for the visualiza- standard and the pharmaceutical preparation indicat-
tion of chromatograms. ed that NDC spot was free of any interference that
36 URSZULA HUBICKA et al.
Table 2. The results of neomycin determination in pharmaceutical preparation with statistical evaluation.
Determined concentration
Declared
Preparation concentration Spectrophotometric
TLC method
method
xm = 253.15 xm = 254.70
SD = 5.2908 SD = 2.5145
Neomycinum RSD = 2.09% RSD = 2.47%
250 mg
(tablets) Fisher-Snedecor test:
Fobs = 4.43; F1-α = 5.05 for f = 5, α = 0.05
Fobs < F1-α statistically insignificant
f ñ number of degrees of freedom, α ñ significance level, SD ñ standard deviation, RSD ñ relative standard deviation, Fobs ñ calculated
experimental value; F1-α ñ critical value from the Snedecor law table.
might be present in the analysis. Resolution of the The regression equation of the calibration plot, val-
peaks appearing in the chromatograms was 3.94. ues of standard deviation of the slope (Sa), standard
A plot of concentration against mean peak area deviation of the intercept (Sb) and standard error of
of NDC was linear over the range from 0.5918 µg the estimate (Se) are presented in Table 1.
per band to 2.1960 µg per band. The correlation Based on parameters of the curve (P = ñ25.48
coefficient (r) and determination coefficient (r2) + 650.27C, r = 0.9846 and Se = 38.48), in low range
obtained for significance level 0.05 and n = 7 were of concentrations, the LOD and LOQ (µg per band)
close to 0.99 that proved a highly significant linear values were 0.1953 and 0.5918, respectively. These
correlation (Fig. 3). The y-intercept of the linear low values indicated satisfactory sensitivity of the
equation for NDC was statistically insignificant. method.
Determination of neomycin in the form of neomycin derivative... 37
Accuracy of the method expressed as % recov- 5. Amin A.S., Issa Y.M.: Spectrochim. Acta A 59,
ery at three concentration levels was from 100.97 to 663 (2003).
101.48%. Good precision and intermediate precision 6. El-Shabrawy V.: Spectrosc. Lett. 35, 99 (2002).
with % RSD less than 2.10% was observed. Detailed 7. Cruz SarraguÁa M., Oliveira Soares S., Almeida
results are presented in Table 1. In all the deliberate- Lopes J.: Vib. Spectrosc. 56, 184 (2011).
ly varied chromatographic conditions (composition 8. Confinop M., Bontchev V, P.: Microchim. Acta
of the mobile phase, change of stationary phase), the 102, 305 (1990).
retention parameters of NDC remained unchanged. 9. Marques M.R.C., Hackmann E.R.M., Saito T.:
The usefulness of the method was examined by Anal. Lett. 23, 1005 (1990).
determination of neomycin in the tablets. There was 10. Pendela M., Adams E., Hoogmartens J.: J.
no influence of additional components present in Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 36, 751 (2004).
tested preparation such as macrogol, sodium starch 11. Adams E., Schepers R., Gathu L.W., Kibaya R.,
glycolate type A, talc, magnesium stearate, sucrose Roets E., Hoogmartens J.: J. Pharm. Biomed.
and the components of the substrate on the determi- Anal. 15, 505 (1997).
nation results. Satisfactory results of the quantitative 12. Megoulas N.C., Koupparis M.A.: J.
determination were obtained, which were character- Chromatogr. A 1057, 125 (2004).
ized by good repeatability of measurements (RSD = 13. Hanko V.P., Rohrer J.S.: J. Pharm. Biomed.
2.09%). The concentration determined by the devel- Anal. 43, 131 (2007).
oped method was comparable to the results obtained 14. Krzek J., Starek M., KwiecieÒ A., Rzeszutko
by spectrophotometric method (Table 2). W.: J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 24, 629 (2001).
The results of determination of neomycin 15. Hubicka U., Krzek J., WoltyÒska H., Stachacz
obtained by TLC and spectrophotometric methods B.: J. AOAC Int. 92, 1068 (2009).
were analyzed statistically using Fisher-Snedecor test 16. Kurzawa M., JastrzÍbska A., Sz≥yk E.: Chem.
(Table 2). The calculated experimental value Fobs for Pap. 63, 255 (2009).
TLC and spectrophotometric methods were com- 17. Kurzawa M., JastrzÍbska A., Sz≥yk E.: Acta
pared with the critical value: F1-α (for f = 5, α = 0.05), Pol. Pharm. Drug Res. 62, 163 (2005).
extracted from the Snedecor law table. Based on the 18. Huidobro A.L., GarcÌa A., Barbas C.: J. Pharm.
results of statistical analysis (Fobs > F1-α) it was found Biomed. Anal. 49, 1303 (2009).
that the compared methods were not different consid- 19. Srisom P., Liawruangrath B., Liawruangrath S.,
ering precision in statistically significant way. Slater J.M., Wangkarn S.: J. Pharm. Biomed.
Anal. 43, 1013 (2007).
CONCLUSIONS 20. Ackermans M.T., Everaerts F.M., Beckers J.L.:
J. Chromatogr. 606, 229 (1992).
In reaction of neomycin with DBS a yellow 21. Lin J.-K., Chang J.-Y.: Anal. Chem. 47, 1634
complex of neomycin derivative was formed which (1975).
can be used in direct TLCñdensitometric analysis at 22. Romero R., Bagur M.G.; S·nchez-ViÒas M.,
λ = 460 nm. G·zquez D.: Chromatographia 51, 404 (2000).
The method meets the acceptance criteria for 23. Romero R., S·nchez-Viñas M., G·zquez D.,
validation and may be useful for the determination Bagur M.G., Cuadros-Rodriguez L.: Chromato-
of neomycin in the form of derivative with DBS in graphia 53, 481 (2001).
pharmaceutical products. 24. Castillo M.A., Castells R.C.: Chromatographia
54, 711 (2001).
REFERENCES 25. Witek A., Hopkala H., Matysik G.: Chromato-
graphia 50, 41 (1999).
1. Zejc A., Gorczyca M. Chemistry of Drugs 26. Krzek J., Piotrowska J.: Acta Pol. Pharm. Drug
(Polish), PZWL, Warszawa 2002. Res. 68, 853 (2011).
2. Bonomo R.A., Van Zile P.S., Li Q., Shermock 27. ICH-Q2 (R1) Validation and Analytical
K.M., McCormik W.G., Kohut B.: Expert Rev. Procedures: Text and Methodology, Interna-
Anti Infect. Ther. 5, 773 (2007). tional Conference on Harmonization, Geneva,
3. Sheth V.M., Weitzul S.: Dermatitis 19, 181 November 2005: http://www.ich.org.
(2008).
4. Gennaro A.R. Ed.: Remington`s Pharma- Received: 5, 11. 2013
ceutical Sciences, 17th edn., p. 1181, Mack
Publ., Easton, PA 1985.