Edgewood Case Study
Edgewood Case Study
Can you help with the last two part (highlighted below).
Instruction: Based on case study from Edgewood Lake Hospital ( I will attach the case study
with email)
Outline:
1. Background
2. Introduction
What started off as a way to promote health in a rural community quickly turned to the
downfall of many. In a rural city in California, Edgewood Lake Hospital accompanies a 30-bed
independent, not-for-profit hospital that provides both inpatient and outpatient services.
Edgewood is considered the largest rural hospital within their region for quality of care. A few
years prior, CEO Richard Fuchs decided to implement a wellness center that was near $1.2
million to build. Shortly after the wellness center was established there was a major loss in
revenue for the hospital which concluded in the removal of the CEO, Fuchs. Upon arrival of the
new CEO, Shannon Johnson, there were many downfalls that stood in the way of encouraging
success for an organization besides the wellness center revenue loss. Edgewood was receiving
less government reimbursement due to the decreases in quality and following compliance
regulations. Edgewood was unable to keep up with the demands of maintaining compliance and
government program standards which resulted in many fines and denied claims. Edgewood is
also having a hard time retaining and recruiting their physicians which is increasing the financial
problems for the organization. Having inefficient staffing for the hospital increases operating
costs. Since the hospital is unable to retain physicians the organization has had to hire locum
tenens at a significantly higher cost. These financial losses are extremely detrimental to the
success of the organization as a whole. Lastly, Edgewood has experienced some competition in
a neighboring community called Creekside Trails. Creekside is a for-profit hospital that is locally
known for performing mass amounts of cardiac procedures. Creekside is only 15 years old and
the facilities are considerably grander than those of Edgewood and Creekside is able to perform
more specialty services than Edgewood. With a major loss in revenue, inability to recruit and
retain staff, and the competition of a neighboring facility, Johnson must come up with solutions
Analysis of Case Issues/Dilemmas: provide a clear analysis of the issues of concern in the case
The incoming CEO of Edgewood Lake Hospital has been tasked with several initiatives
in her new role: solving the current financial crisis of the hospital, achieving fiscal stability and
addressing physician recruitment. A directive from the board has been placed that she achieves
fiscal profitability of the hospital within the next two fiscal years. This will be a challenge,
considering the hospitals most recent financial shortcomings and ongoing national directives
driving up the cost of healthcare. Beginning in 2013 and through 2016, the hospital recorded
annual overall negative profit margins. In 2016, the net income was a loss of nearly $5 million
dollars (Archer, Cheung, Myrtle, & Pottenger, 2017). Edgewood Lake Hospital’s recent financial
represent a portion of the hospital’s financial struggles. The median household’s annual income
is lower than the national average and the average age is older than the national average. This
which have significantly decreased their reimbursement rates. In fact, Medicare encompasses
54% of Edgewood Lake Hospital’s payer mix as well as a rise in charity care spending $1.4
million over budget for 2016 (Archer, Cheung, Myrtle, & Pottenger, 2017). Closure of rural
hospitals is on the rise, and those with a negative operating income are at the most risk of
closure. Rural hospitals with negative operating incomes are more likely to occur in areas where
the resident demographics represent an older and poorer population (Kaufman et al, 2015). One
designated as a critical access hospital. Edgewood Lake Hospital is not eligible for this
designation due to it’s operating bed number. However, they do meet other benchmarks
including distance to neighboring hospitals and average length of stay. Improving reimbursement
Despite the hospital’s recent net negative income, the former CEO embarked on costly
initiatives during his tenure. The most glaring of which was establishing a $1.2 million wellness
center revolving around prevention and wellness (Archer, Cheung, Myrtle, & Pottenger, 2017).
While the venture was respected amongst community members, only 10% of the cost of the
center was raised from donations costing the already financially ailing hospital precious
resources. Revenue from the wellness center has not proven to be profitable since it’s opening in
2013. While the opening of the wellness center was met with enthusiasm by the community it
has underperformed since its inception. Continuing to fund this project will only worsen the
Rural hospitals such as Edgewood Lake Hospital face rising costs to answer the
increasing demands for quality and compliance regulations in healthcare. One such initiative is
the focus on quality services. Edgewood Lake Hospital has been previously recognized as a rural
region’s leader in quality care. They have received recognition for quality project interventions
such as discharge instruction delivery, and smoking cessation programs for patients with heart
failure (Archer, Cheung, Myrtle, & Pottenger, 2017). However, an increase in quality services
comes with an increase in hospital costs to accommodate staffing needs and implementation of
best practices. This will certainly continue for the foreseeable future. Also, rural hospitals such
as this one often struggle with the financial burden of costly electronic healthcare records and
coding software. The financial burden these technologies place on small rural hospitals is
significant and increases operating costs. These increases in cost must be managed in a setting
Edgewood Lake Hospital revels in a loyal local customer base with only 16% of patients
seeking care at outside hospitals (Archer, Cheung, Myrtle, & Pottenger, 2017). However, in most
recent years they have noticed increased competition from their closest competitor, Creekside
Trails, which touts superior facilities with more access to specialty care. Edgewood Lake
strategies to compete with Creekside Trails to increase patient volumes and decrease potential
Rural hospitals often struggle with adequate staffing. While the rural population makes
up approximately one fifth of the U.S. population, only approximately one tenth of U.S
physicians’ practice in rural hospitals (Macqueen, et al. 2017) Edgewood Lakewood Hospital is
no exception as it has struggled retaining their physicians. As a result, they have been forced to
rely on locum tenens which has resulted in an increase in cost for physicians staffing. They also
share similarities with other rural hospitals in terms of difficulty staffing specialty physicians.
This necessitates referral of patients outside of the hospital system to receive the care they need
resulting in loss of revenue. Servicing an aging population, such as Edgewood County, typically
requires comprehensive medical care including assistance of specialty services, making outside
referrals for services even more commonplace. Shortage of medical staff, lack of specialty
physicians and need for costly locum tenens are all staffing inefficiencies that lead to loss of
revenue. Stabilizing the medical staff by improving recruitment and retainment of physicians and
considering alternatives to attaining specialized services can increase potential revenue, decrease
Obtaining status as a critical access hospital (CAH) is a key component of our turnaround
plan for Edgewood Lake Hospital. CAH designees receive higher Medicare reimbursement
rates, at the cost to provide services, plus 1%. To be designated as a critical access hospital,
acute care sites must be located at least 35 miles from the nearest hospital, have fewer than 25
licensed beds, maintain an average length of stay under 96 hours, and offer 24/7 emergency
Edgewood already meets most of these criteria, however they’re currently licensed for 30
beds. A review of their financials shows an average daily census for the last two years of 20.38
days. If they decommission 7 beds, it will bring their licensed bed count to 23, making them
average daily census of 27.2 patients and a salary expense of 25 million. In 2016, census was
down to 20.16, but they were still budgeting and staffing for 28.2 occupied beds. Executive
leaders need to develop a realistic budget, and cut staffing down to the appropriate levels using
the industry benchmark of 5.2 FTE’s per occupied bed. This, coupled with the higher
reimbursement rate from their CAH status will increase revenues and decrease expenses.
Another benefit of the CAH designation is access to federal grants for financial and
Health Information Hub, 2019) Edgewood has invested considerable money in the Edgewood
Lake Wellness Center. They can easily demonstrate their commitment to wellness and disease
prevention and their excellent quality scores to obtain additional funding through these grant
programs.
The emergence of new technologies for providing telemedicine services provides another
opportunity for Edgewood. Given the remote location of the facility and the rural setting of their
patient base, telemedicine is a natural fit for their patient population. They’ve already
established themselves as a brand leader in preventive services. While the Wellness Center has
never been profitable for Edgewood, they can leverage their existing infrastructure and launch
virtual primary care services. A recent study in the New England Journal of Medicine shows
that patient satisfaction with video visits is extremely strong, at 93%. (Ballard, et al., 2018)
Recruiting physicians to provide primary care services remotely will be much easier than
recruitment that requires physical relocation, and will reduce their reliance on expensive locum
tenens providers. Branching out to offer specialty telemedicine services like psychiatry and
dermatology would also allow them to meet the area needs for specialty care while keeping
The initial and most apparent issues to the outside eye is hospital profitable after 3 years
of losses. The issues includes time retaining and recruiting their physicians which is increasing
the financial problems for the organization, inefficient staffing for the hospital, and the
Conclusion:
Edgewood Hospital still has the ability to expand and Johnson has the ability to lead the
organization toward success. It will, however, take some time to build financial strain at
Edgewood Lake Hospital. The hospital can turn around to increase potential revenue and
decrease outside referrals Edgewood Lake Hospital by stabilizing the medical staff and
improving recruitment. It also taking time to obtaining CAH plan for the hospital. This CAH will
help improve higher reimbursement rate, the cost to provide service and plus 1%. While
Edgewood Lake Hospital serves a large population, thus, there is a lot at stake in ensuring that
these people do not lack a place to get healthcare. In additional, The hospital currently has done a
good job at ensuring that there is adequate preventative as well as diagnostic facilities. There is
just a little more research needed to ensure that these facilities become profitable to ensure the
sustainability of the hospital and to build a good reputation for the hospital.
REFERENCES:
Archer, D., Cheung, S., Myrtle, R. C., & Pottenger, B. C. (2017). Edgewood Lake Hospital - Leadership
Farnsworth, & R. C. Myrtle, Cases in Health Services Management - Sixth Edition (pp. 109-
Ballard, D. W., Barr, I., Huang, J., Parikh, R., Reed, M. E., & Wargon, C. (2018, October 11). Real-
Time Patient-Provider Video Telemedicine Integrated with Clinical Care. The New England
Kaufman, B. G., Thomas, S. R., Randolph, R. K., Perry, J. R., Thompson, K. W., Holmes, G. M., &
Pink, G. H. (2015). The Rising Rate of Rural Hospital Closures. The Journal of Rural Health,
Macqueen, I. T., Maggard-Gibbons, M., Capra, G., Raaen, L., Ulloa, J. G., Shekelle, P. G., … Hempel,
Rural Health Information Hub. (2019, August 20). Critical Access Hospitals (CAHs). Retrieved from
RuralHealthInfo.org: https://www.ruralhealthinfo.org/topics/critical-access-hospitals#benefits