Notes Me 112 Concepts in Engineering Design Unit 3
Notes Me 112 Concepts in Engineering Design Unit 3
Unit-03/Lecture-01
Description of Design Process
Description of Design Process :
Morris Asimow was along with the first to give a detailed explanation of the complete design
process in what he called the morphology of design. It is defined by the phases and their
constituent steps. Design is succession from the abstract to the concrete. The various activities
that make up the first three phases of design: conceptual design, embodiment design, and
detail design & the remaining four phases belong to production, distribution, consumption &
retirement.
PRIMITIVE NEED
PHASE-1
CONCEPTUAL DESIGN
PHASE-2
EMBODIMENT DESIGN
PHASE-3
DETAILED DESIGN
PHASE-4
PLANNING FOR
PRODUCTION
PHASE-5
PLANNING FOR
DISTRIBUTION
PHASE-6
PLANNING FOR
CONSUMPTION
PHASE-7
PLANNING FOR
RETIREMENT
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
2
CONCEPTUAL DESIGN
happen and how the omissions can be mitigated, it is necessary to reflect on how customers
distinguish “needs.”
Physiological needs: such as thirst, hunger, sleep, shelter, and exercise. These constitute the
basic needs of the body, and until they are satisfied, they remain the prime influence on the
individual’s behavior.
Safety and security needs: which include protection against danger, deprivation (lack), and
threat (hazard)? When the bodily needs are satisfied, the safety and security needs become
dominant.
Social needs: for love and esteem (appreciate) by others. These needs include belonging to
groups, group identity, and social acceptance.
b) Problem definition: The goal of this activity is to create a statement that describes.
What has to be accomplished to satisfy the needs of the customer? This involves analysis
of competitive products, the establishment of target specifications, and the listing of
constraints and trade-offs. Quality function deployment (QFD) is a valuable tool for
linking customer needs with design requirements. A detailed listing of the product
requirements is called a product design specification (PDS). Problem definition, in its
full scope
c) Gathering information: The need for information can be crucial at many steps in a
design project. We will need to find these bits of information quickly, and validate them
as to their reliability
i) Data, information, knowledge: Data is a set of discrete, objective facts about events. These
data may be experimental observations about the testing of a new product, or data on sales that
are part Of a marketing study.
Information is data that has been treated in some way that it conveys a message. Information is
meant to change the way the receiver of the message perceives something, i.e., to have an impact
on his or her judgment and behavior. The word informs originally meant “to give shape to.”
Data becomes information when its creator adds meaning. This can be done in the following
ways.
Contextualized: we know for what purpose the data was gathered.
Categorized: we know the units of analysis or key components of the data.
Calculated: the data have been analyzed mathematically or statistically.
Corrected: errors have been removed from the data.
Condensed: the data have been summarized in a more concise form.
Knowledge is broader, deeper, and richer than data or information. Because of this it is harder to
define. It is a mix of experience, values, contextual information, and expert insight that provides
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
4
a framework for evaluating and incorporating new experiences and information. This
transformation occurs through the following processes:
Comparison: how does this situation compare to other situations we have known?
Consequence: what implications does the information have for decisions and
Actions?
Connections: how does this bit of knowledge relate to others?
Conversation: what do other people think about this information?
.
d) Conceptualization: Concept generation involves creating a broad set of concepts that
potentially satisfy the problem statement. Team-based creativity methods, combined with
efficient information gathering, are the key activities.
One way to increase the likelihood of positive outcomes is to apply methods found to be useful
for others. Following are some positive steps you can take to enhance your creative thinking
i) Develop a creative attitude: To be creative it is essential to develop confidence that you can
provide a creative solution to a problem. Although you may not visualize the complete path
through to the final solution at the time you first tackle a problem, you must have selfconfi
dence; you must believe that a solution will develop before you are finished. Of course, confi
dence comes with success, so start small and build your confidence up with small successes.
ii) Unlock your imagination: You must renew the glowing imagination you had as a child. One
way to do so is to begin to question again. Ask “why” and “what if,” even at the risk of
displaying a bit of inexperience. Scholars of the creative process have developed thought games
that are designed to provide practice in unlocking your imagination and sharpening creative
ability.
iii) Be persistent: We already have dispelled the myth that creativity occurs with a lightning
strike. On the contrary, it often requires hard work. Most problems will not submit to the first
attack. They must be pursued with persistence. After all, Edison tested over 6000 materials
before he discovered the species of bamboo that acted as a successful filament for the
incandescent light bulb. It was also Edison who made the famous comment, “Invention is
95 percent perspiration and 5 percent inspiration.”
iv) Develop an open mind: Having an open mind means being approachable to ideas from any
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
5
and all sources. The solutions to problems are not the property of a particular discipline, nor is
there any rule that solutions can come only from persons with college degrees..
v) Suspend your judgment : We have seen that creative ideas develop slowly, but nothing
Slow up the creative process more than critical judgment of an emerging idea. Engineers, by
nature, tend toward critical attitudes, so special patience is required to avoid judgment at an early
stage of conceptual design.
vi) Set problem boundaries : We place great emphasis on proper problem definition as a step
toward problem solution. Establishing the boundaries of the problem is an essential part of
problem definition. Experience shows that setting problem boundaries appropriately, not too
tight or not too open, is critical to achieving a creative solution.
e) Concept selection: Evaluation of the design concepts, modifying and evolving into a
single preferred concept, are the activities in this step. The process usually requires
several iterations. Theory for decision making is rooted in many different academic
disciplines, including pure mathematics, economics (macro and micro), psychology
(cognitive and behavioral), probability, and many others
Behavioral aspects of Decision making:
Behavioral psychology provides an understanding of the influence of risk taking in individuals
and teams. Making a decision is a stressful situation for most people because there is no way to
be certain about the information about the past or the predictions of the future. This
psychological stress arises from at least two sources. First, decision makers are concerned about
the material and social losses that will result from either course of action that is chosen. Second,
they recognize that their reputations and self-esteem as capable decision makers are at stake.
i) Unconflicted adherence: Decide to continue with current action and ignore information
About risk of losses.
ii) Unconflicted change: Uncritically adopt whichever course of action is most
Strongly recommended.
iii) Defensive avoidance: avoid conflict by delay, shifting responsibility to
Someone else, and remaining careless to corrective information.
iv) Hyper vigilance: Search madly for an immediate problem solution.
v) Vigilance: Search carefully for relevant information that is understand in an
Unbiased manner and evaluate carefully before a decision is made.
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
6
f) Refinement of the PDS: The product design specification is revisited after the concept
has been selected. The design team must commit to achieving certain critical values of
design parameters, usually called critical-to-quality (CTQ) parameters, and to living
with trade-offs between cost and performance.
g) Design review: Before committing funds to move to the next design phase, a design
review will be held. The design review will assure that the design is physically realizable
and that it is economically worthwhile. It will also look at a detailed product development
schedule. This is needed to devise a strategy to minimize product cycle time and to
identify the resources in people, equipment, and money needed to complete the project.
Unit-03/Lecture-02
EMBODIMENT DESIGN/ preliminary design:
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
7
The next phase of the design process is often called embodiment design. It is the phase where the
design concept is invested with physical form, where we “put meat on the bones.” Structured
development of the design concept occurs in this engineering design phase. An embodiment of
all the main functions that must be performed by the product must be undertaken. It is in this
design phase that decisions are made on strength, material selection, size, shape, and spatial
compatibility. Beyond this design phase, major changes become very expensive. This design
phase is sometimes called preliminary design.
Embodiment design is concerned with three major tasks—product architecture,
configuration design, and parametric design.
EMBODIMENT DESIGN
a) Product architecture: Product architecture is concerned with dividing the overall Design
system into subsystems or modules. In this step we decide how the physical components of the
design are to be arranged and combined to carry out the functional duties of the design.
The product architecture begins to appear in the conceptual design
phase from such things as diagrams of functions, rough sketches of concepts, and perhaps a
proof-of-concept model. However, it is in the embodiment design phase that the layout and
architecture of the product must be established by defining the basic building blocks of the
product and their interfaces. a product’s architecture is related to its function structure, but it
does not have to match it. The physical building blocks that the product is organized into are
usually called modules. Other terms are subsystem, subassembly, cluster, or chunk. Each
module is made up of a collection of components that carry out functions. The architecture of the
product is given by the relationships among the components in the product and the functions the
product performs. There are two entirely opposite styles of product architecture, modular and
integral.
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
8
1) Modular architecture: each module implements only one or a few functions, and the
interactions between modules are well defined. An EXAMPLE would be an
oscilloscope, where different measurement functions are obtained by plugging in
different modules,
2) In an integral architecture: In integral product architectures, components perform
multiple functions. This reduces the number of components, generally decreasing cost
unless the integral architecture is obtained at the expense of extreme part complexity.
Integral product architecture is often adopted when constraints of weight, space, or cost
make
It difficult to achieve required performance. Propose a four-step process for establishing the
product Architecture.
Create a schematic diagram of the product.
Cluster the elements of the schematic.
Create a rough geometric layout.
Identify the interactions between modules.
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
9
● Is the material selected for the part the best one to prevent the likely failure modes in service?
● Is there a history of use for the material in this or similar applications?
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
10
● Can the form and features of the part be readily made on available production machines?
● Will material made to standard quality specifications be adequate for this part?
● Will the chosen material and manufacturing process meet the cost target for the part?
c) Parametric design of parts: Parametric design starts with information on the configuration of
the part and aims to establish its exact dimensions and tolerances. Final decisions on the material
and manufacturing processes are also established if this has not been done previously. An
important aspect of parametric design is to examine the part, assembly, and system for design
robustness. Robustness refers to how consistently a component performs under variable
conditions in its service environment. Robustness means achieving excellent performance under
the wide range of conditions that will be found in service. All products function reasonably well
under ideal (laboratory) conditions, but robust designs continue to function well when the
conditions to which they are exposed are far from ideal Dimensions and tolerances were set
tentatively, and while analysis was used to “size the parts” it generally was not highly detailed or
sophisticated. Now the design moves into parametric design, the latter part of embodiment
design.
This will involve some kind of analysis for stresses, or vibration, or heat transfer. In conceptual
design you used elementary physics and chemistry, and a “gut feel” for whether the concept
would work. In configuration design you used simple models from engineering science courses,
but in parametric design you will most likely use more detailed models, including finite-element
analysis on critical components. The deciding factors for the level of detail in analysis will be the
time, money, and available analysis tools, and whether, given these constraints, the expected
results are likely to have sufficient credibility and usefulness.
Step 2. Generate alternative designs:
Different values for the design variables are chosen to produce different candidate designs.
Remember, the alternative configurations were narrowed down to a single selection in confi
guration design. Now, we are determining the best dimensions or tolerances for the critical-to
quality aspects of that configuration. The values of the DVs come from your or the company’s
experience, or from industry standards or practice.
Step 3. Analyze the alternative designs:
Now we predict the performance of each of the alternative designs using either analytical or
experimental methods. Each of the designs is checked to see that it satisfies every performance
constraint and expectation. These designs are identified as feasible designs.
Step 4. Evaluate the results of the analyses.
All the feasible designs are evaluated to determine which one is best using the solution
evaluation parameters. Often, a key performance characteristic is chosen as an objective function,
and optimization methods are used to either maximize or minimize this value. Alternatively,
design variables are combined in some reasonable way to give a figure of merit, and this value is
used for deciding on the best design
Step 5. Refine/Optimize.
If none of the candidate designs are feasible designs, then it is necessary to determine a new set
of designs. If feasible designs exist, it may be possible to improve their rating by changing the
values of the design variables in an organized way so as to maximize or minimize the objective
function.
Unit-03/Lecture-03
DETAIL DESIGN:
Detailed design is such a fundamental necessity to manufacturers that it exists at the intersection
of many product development processes. And given this broad influence, as well as the impact of
prevailing industry dynamics such as distributed product development, shortening product
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
12
development lifecycles and increased product complexity, companies are feeling immense
pressure to improve their detailed design process. Missing information is added on the
arrangement, form, dimensions, and tolerances, surface properties, materials, and manufacturing
processes of each part. This results in a specification for each special-purpose part and for each
standard part to be purchased from suppliers. In the detail design phase the following activities
are completed and documents are prepared:
Detail design
Engineering
Drawings
Finalize PDS
● Detailed engineering drawings suitable for manufacturing. Routinely these are computer-
generated drawings, and they often include three-dimensional CAD models.
● Verification testing of prototypes is successfully completed and verification data is submitted.
All critical-to-quality parameters are confirmed to be under control. Usually the building and
testing of several preproduction versions of the product will be accomplished.
● Assembly drawings and assembly instructions also will be completed. The bill of materials for
all assemblies will be completed.
● A detailed product specification, updated with all the changes made since the conceptual
Design phase will be prepared.
● Decisions on whether to make each part internally or to buy from an external supplier will be
made.
● With the preceding information, a detailed cost estimate for the product will be carried out.
● Finally, detail design concludes with a design review before the decision is made to pass the
design information on to manufacturing.
In many engineering organizations it is no longer correct to say that detail design is the phase of
design where all of the dimensions, tolerances, and details are finalized. However, detail design,
as the name implies, is the phase where all of the details are brought together, all decisions are
Finalized, and a decision is made by management to release the design for production. Poor
detail design can ruin a brilliant design concept and lead to manufacturing defects, high costs,
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
13
6) Final cost estimate: The detail drawings allow the determination of final cost estimates, since
knowledge of the material, the dimensions, tolerances, and finish of each part are needed to
determine manufacturing cost.
7) Prepare design project report: A design project report usually is written at the conclusion of
a project to describe the tasks undertaken and to discuss the design in detail. Also, a design
project report may be an important document if the product becomes involved in either product
liability or patent litigation.
8) Final design review: Many formal meetings or reviews will have preceded the fi nal design
review. These include an initial product concept meeting to begin the establishment of the PDS
The latter may take the form of detailed partial reviews (meetings) to decide important issues
like design for manufacturing, quality issues, reliability, safety, or preliminary cost estimates
9) Release design to manufacturing: The release of the product design to manufacturing ends
the main activity of the design personnel on that product. The increasing use of the concurrent
engineering approach to minimize the product development time blurs the boundary between
detail design and manufacturing. It is common to release the design to manufacturing in two
Or three “waves,” with those designs that have the longest lead time for designing and making
tooling being released first.
Unit-03/Lecture-04
Planning for Production/ Manufacturing
Plan the
Mfg Planning use of
And People
Control System Efficient use
Of our capacity
And that of our
Suppliers.
Possibly even
Our customers
Manage
the
Efficient
flow of
Materials
Driven by customer
Demand and other
Customer requirements
The process must be selected in such a way that the produced product will be acceptable
to the consumer functionally, economically and appearance-wise.
A great deal of detailed planning must be done to provide for
the production of the design. A method of manufacture must be established for each component
in the system. As a usual first step, a process sheet is created; it contains a sequential list of all
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
16
manufacturing operations that must be performed on the component. Also, it specifies the form
and condition of the material and the tooling and production machines that will be used. The
information on the process sheet makes possible the estimation of the production cost of the
component. High costs may indicate the need for a change in material or a basic change in the
design. Close interaction with manufacturing, industrial, materials, and mechanical engineers is
important at this step.
The other important tasks performed in phase IV are the following:
i) Detail process planning: is requiring for every part, subassembly, and final assembly. The
information is usually displayed on process sheets, one for each part of subassembly. The
process sheet contains a sequential list of operations which must be performed to produce a part
.it specifies raw material, clarify special instructions and indicates machines and tools required
.such difficulty can be minimized earlier by timely consultations between product designers and
tool designers.
ii) Designing specialized tools and fixtures(fittings)
iii) Specifying the production plant that will be used (or designing a new plant) and
laying out the production lines
iv)Planning for production control: Planning the work schedules and inventory controls
(production control)
v) Planning the quality assurance system
vi) Planning for production personnel: Establishing the standard time and labor costs for each
operation
vii) Planning for information flow system: Establishing the system of information flow
necessary to control the manufacturing Operation. Flow patterns and routines are established
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
17
Unit-03/Lecture-05
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
18
Order processing
Warehousing and storage
Finished goods management
Material handling and packaging
Shipping
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
19
Transportation
Distribution channels are formed to solve three critical distribution problems: functional
performance, reduced complexity, and specialization. The central focus of distribution is to
increase the efficiency of time, place, and delivery utility.
Following are the separate elements contained within the three critical functions of
distribution:
Selling and promoting. This function is very important to manufacturers. One strategy
involves the use of distribution channels to carry out the responsibilities of product
deployment. In addition to being marketing experts in their industry, distribution firms
usually have direct-selling organizations and a detailed knowledge of their customers and
their expectations. The manufacturer utilizing this distributor can then tap into these
resources. Also, because of the scale of the distributing firm's operations and its
specialized skill in channel management, it can significantly improve the time, place, and
possession utilities by housing inventory closer to the market. These advantages mean
that the manufacturer can reach many small, distant customers at a relatively low cost,
thus allowing the manufacturer to focus its expenditures on product development and its
core production processes.
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
20
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
21
Distribution Planning systems can address the following operational issues faced by a
supply chain manager
Unit-03/Lecture-06
Consumption is the sixth phase of morphological design, as a process it occurs naturally after
distribution. Its influence on design is thoughtful because it pass through all phases.therfore it is
for the most important diffused phase concerned with consumer needs and utility,and mingled
and attached to the earlier phases The use of the product by the consumer is all-important, and
considerations of how the consumer will react to the product pervade all steps of the design
process. The following specific topics can be identified as being important user-oriented
concerns in the design process: ease of maintenance, durability, reliability, product safety, and
convenience in use (human factors engineering), aesthetic appeal, and economy of operation.
Obviously, these consumer-oriented issues must be considered in the design process at its very
beginning. They are not issues to be treated as afterthoughts. Phase VI of design is less well
defined than the others, but it is becoming increasingly important with the growing concerns for
consumer protection and product Safety. More strict interpretation of product liability laws is
having a major impact on design. An important phase VI activity is the acquisition of reliable
data on failures, service lives, and consumer complaints and attitudes to provide a basis for
product improvement in the next design cycle. The purpose of this phase is to incorporate in the
design ,adequate service features and to provide a rational basis for product improvement and
redesign
Design for consumption must consider the following factors:
Unit-03/Lecture-07
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com
23
The final step in the design process is the disposal of the retired product when it has reached the
end of its useful life. Useful life may be determined by actual deterioration and wear to the point
at which the design can no longer function, or it may be determined by technological
obsolescence, in which a competing design performs the product’s functions either better or
cheaper. In consumer products, it may come about through changes in fashion or taste. In the
past, little attention has been given in the design process to product retirement. This is rapidly
changing, as people the world over are becoming concerned about environmental issues. There is
concern with depletion of mineral and energy resources, and with pollution of the air, water, and
land as a result of manufacturing and technology advancement. This has led to a formal area of
study called industrial ecology. Design for the environment, also called green design, has
become an important consideration in design. As a result, the design of a product should include
a plan for either its disposal in an environmentally safe way or, better, the recycling of its
materials or the remanufacture or reuse of its components.
When determine as to when an economic commodity in use has
reached an age at which it should be retired, the point at which it can no longer render adequate
service, then the need for replacement is clear because of either technical obsolescence or
physical deterioration
http://www.rgpvonline.com http://www.a2zsubjects.com