Speech Acts in Philippine TELEVISION TV
Speech Acts in Philippine TELEVISION TV
Speech Acts in Philippine TELEVISION TV
A Research Paper
MARLOWE B. INGLES
Don Bosco Technical Institute – Makati City
Abstract
Ten (10) Philippine TV commercials were analyzed using the Speech Acts Theory
(Searle, 1969). The main purpose is to know the dominant Speech Acts Classification in the
chosen commercials. The transcribed TV commercials were first segmented based on the
Utterance Theory (Bakhtin,1986). Data were analyzed using frequency and percentage statistical
tool. The findings reveal that there are three Speech Acts Classifications: Assertives, Directives,
and Expressives. that are present in the popular TV commercials. Among the three Speech Act
Classifications the widely used is the Assertives. The data also imply that the Philippine culture
is a high-context society. Thus, a ‘soft-sell approach’ would be advantageous to prospective
advertisers in the Philippines.
Key words: Speech Acts, Speech Acts Theory, Utterance Theory, High-context Society, Soft-sell
Approach
1
1. Introduction
Language plays a vital role in human existence (I Can, 2013; Dutta, 2013). It is used in
almost all facets of society: education, business, research, government, health, leisure, and
ordinary social interactions. With different societies come different forms of expressions. This
societal language difference produces cultural differences in how words and their intended
meanings are understood by the community (Gumperz, 1982). Thus, a study of each linguistic
culture may lead to greater understanding on how people of certain place use and receive
One of the language theories that can be used to understand the linguistic culture of a
society is the Speech Acts Theory (Austin, 1962; Searle, 1969). Speech Acts simply means
“actions performed via utterances” (Yule, 1996, p. 47). This theory suggests that any speech act
can be divided into three layers: Locutionary Act, Illocutionary Act, and Perlocutionary Act
(Austin, 1962). Locutionary act is the meaningful utterance; the illocutionary act is the speaker’s
intended meaning; the perlocutionary act is the effect upon the listener. These speech acts were
(1962), constatives are the utterances that include assertions or statements which may be true or
false; performatives are not true or false, but utterance that performs an action, like, “I pronounce
you man and wife” and “I promise to return”. However, Searle (1976) classified the speech acts
into five (5) categories: directives, assertives, commissives, expressives, and declarations.
Directives cause the hearer to do a particular action. Assertives represent the speaker’s belief
about the truth of a proposition. Commissives commit the speaker to some future action.
Expressives express the speaker’s attitude and emotions towards the proposition. Declarations
2
change the reality according to the proposition of the declaration. Although of different
terminologies, the essence is still the same - that an utterance performs a certain function.
Studying culture through its language may pose significant challenges to any researcher,
for there are numerous situations where language can be used. Different language situations
one genre of language may eventually fall on over-generalization. It is, therefore, much safer to
say that a study on a single register of discourse may add to the increasing knowledge on culture
because of “its cognitive features (Pateman, 1983; Redfern, 1982; Harris, 1983; in Simpson,
2001, p. 590), its cultural and anthropological dimensions (Aman, 1982; Goldman, 1992;
Schmidt et al, 1994; O’Barr, 1994; Ohmann, 1996) and its status as a genre or register of
discourse (Toolan, 1988; Bex, 1993)”(all cited in Simpson, 2001,p. 590). Moreover, because of
its dynamic and interactive properties, advertising “has been investigated within the parameters
of models in linguistic pragmatics” (Lakoff, 1982; Geis, 1982; Coleman, 1983, 1990; Tanaka,
1994; Short & Hu, 1997; all cited in Simpson, 2001, p. 590). As a well-planned medium of
Burnett & Moriarty, 1995, p. 422) principles. According to Winters et al (1986, cited in Kangira,
2009, p. 40), “advertising is a…method of influencing sales by sending a sponsored and paid
message through mass media to a mass of potential buyers.” Advertising, for it to be effective,
should have “carefully designed messages that aimed at eliciting specific behavior changes in
3
This present study focuses on TV commercials in the Philippines. According to Pennock-
Speck and Fuster-Marquez (2014), “ analysis of TV ads is a worthwhile task for researchers” (p.
412), simply because “millions of people are exposed to them” (p. 412). Vestergaard and
Schroder (1986, p.10) explained that “TV commercials extend in time and make use of the
combined effect of sound and picture.” Its main purpose is “to persuade viewers to acquire
Ohata, 2004, p. 198) found that TV commercials “reflect the essence of social and cultural values
in a particular society.” Schmidt, Shimura, Wang, and Jeong (1995, in Ohata, 2004, p. 198)
further explain that “TV commercials seem to be quite socially bound in nature, as the messages
accomplish the goal of getting consumers (the viewers) to buy a specific product.” Schmidt et all
(1995, in Ohata, 2004, p. 199) further mention that utterances in TV commercials have distinct
“illocutionary force of getting the viewers to buy a specific product or do some action.” This
illocutionary force can “be categorized as a kind of directive, either direct or indirect in its
representation (Banerjee & Carrell, 1988; Searle, 1976; in Ohata, 2004, p. 199). The speech act
(Ohata, 2004). Frazer (1983) specifies that although the forms or linguistic strategies of TV
commercials are more like request or orders, the intention is to suggest or recommend.
This paper aims to know the speech acts classifications of the utterances in the TV
commercials and the dominant speech act classification that is present in the selected Philippine
TV commercials. This study may add valuable information to the research on understanding
culture through linguistic analysis. The following questions are formulated to direct the
4
1. What are the Speech Acts Classification that the utterances in the selected popular Philippine
2. What is the dominant Speech Act Classification in the selected Philippine TV commercials?
3. What is the implication of the dominant Speech Act Classification to the culture of the society
Advertising has been playing important roles in society. It is not only means of knowing
available products and services in the market, but also a way to understand the culture of a
society.
According to van Enschot and Hoeken (2015), TV commercials employ rhetorical figures
to pose riddles for the audience to solve. These well-thought of “rhetorical figures can influence
ad liking because of the pleasure they provide”(p. 25) the audience. Advertisers also ensure the
commercials’ comprehensibility and liking. Through the use of tropes and visual and verbal
Theodorakis, Koritos, and Stathakopoulos (2015) study the effects of rhetorical figures in
controversial topics such as violence and eroticism. Their study confirms that “controversial
themes such as violence in advertising seem to fall within the range of what is considered
unacceptable” (Capella et al, 2010, in Theodorakis, 2015, p. 22). Their findings affirm the past
studies’ claim that using controversial advertisement attract negative attitude or acceptance from
the audience.
MATVA corpus (Multimodal Analysis of TV Ads). Their aim is to look at the prototypical
5
expression of directives, that is, imperatives. They found that not all British TV ads have
imperatives. Data reveal that “acquisition verb, like ‘buy’ is not the most common. Contact verbs
like ‘call’ and ‘visit’ receive the most frequent tokens. These contact verbs are used to lessen the
Simpson (2001) studies reason and tickle as pragmatic construct in the discourse of
advertising. He found that “the distribution of reason and tickle advertising is relative to
particular types of commodities but that that distribution is influenced by a host of interrelated
factors such as budgetary constraints, prospective audience, and in the context of TV advertising,
the availability of slots in broadcasting schedules” (p. 605). He further explains that reason is
used for regularly used commodities while tickle should be used for “the promotion of luxury or
that the “designers of adverts make use of linguistic theory, that is, they use their knowledge of
suggests that people should “treat adverts with critical mind” (p. 44).
Ohata (2004) studies the TV commercials from Japan and the USA. Data reveal that “TV
commercials are made in a socially desirable and appropriate manner, and that the speech acts
vary from one culture to another” (p. 197). Findings also reveal that Americans like to use
bare imperatives while Japanese prefer the linguistic forms typical of requests.
Baig (2013) studies the advertising discourse using approaches of Discourse Analysis and
Critical Discourse Analysis by reviewing relevant literature. Its primary aim is to examine the
“power relation struggles among product-producers and product-consumers, to gauge the level of
psychological dominance exercised through advertising discourse” (p. 216). The study reveals
6
that advertisement is “one-sided” because the advertisers have “more access to discourse” (p.
134). Those who have more access to discourse control the power.
Stone, Besser, and Lewis (2000) study three advertising effectiveness dimensions through
random telephone survey. The survey gathered the respondents’ most liked or disliked
commercial by describing the commercials, brand preference, television viewing hours, and
demographics. This study supports other research claim that people ‘carry a set’ of liked and
disliked commercials. Moreover, data in this paper add valuable insights on identifying
Lin (1993) compares American and Japanese television commercials in terms of style and
content. She found that Japanese commercials were less informative than the American
commercials. Japanese commercials focused more on product availability and packaging while
American ads were focused on giving details about price, quality and performance. Japanese
commercials used a “soft-sell approach” using short messages, songs, celebrities, female voice-
overs and still graphics. On the other hand, American commercials used a “hard-sell approach”
employing long messages, animation, male spokepersons and humor. These differences may be
attributed to cultural differences. Japan is a ‘high-context society’ where familiar symbols and
icons are used rather than detailed, logical explanations. However, the US is a ‘low-context
In a comparative content analysis of 659 TV commercials from the US, France, and
Taiwan, Zandpour, Chang, and Catalano (1992) found that US commercials are focused on
providing specific consumer needs and solving problems; utilize celebrities, credible sources,
and product users; provide data-based arguments and explicit conclusions; talk to consumers
directly in a friendly, conversational tone; display the product aggressively. On the other hand,
7
French commercials use symbolism, humor, and drama; does not focus on reason and argument;
provide information that the product sometimes cannot do. Taiwanese commercials connect the
product to traditional Chinese values; subtly present information through symbols, metaphors,
and drama related to family events; use abstract and lack specific consumer orientation.
Banwari (1994) surveyed 203 consumer panel to know their perceptions of television
advertising. Data reveal that consumers generally have a negative view of TV advertising. The
respondents view TV commercials as misleading, boring, irritating, silly, offensive, and trivial.
Moreover, consumers believe commercials promote unwholesome values and increase cost of
the product. However, the respondents also believe that TV commercials give valuable
These studies have shown some of the significant roles of advertisements in society.
Advertisements’ language use, although socially-governed discourse, are still within the
discretion of the advertisers. This power is carefully balanced by the acceptance of the viewers
and the approval of the designated government agency. This significant information sheds light
on how advertisers methodically choose the language that is used in TV commercials to avoid
Moreover, the above studies also pointed out significant differences in the content of TV
commercials in the countries compared. Some attributed the differences to the culture of the
country. The previous studies have shown that culture of the society plays a vital role on how TV
commercials are constructed and presented. This significant information reveals that society’s
However, this opportunity is less prioritize for studies of Speech Acts in Philippine TV
8
Theoretical Framework
Classifications Descriptions
With regard to the transcribed words of the TV commercials, they were segmented into
meaningful utterances following the Utterance Theory of Mikhail Bakhtin (1986). There are
9
According to Bakhtin (1986), a "word" or "utterance"--is the main unit of meaning (not
abstract sentences out of context), and is formed through a speaker's relation to Otherness (other
people, others' words and expressions, and the lived cultural world in time and place). A "word"
cultural and political moments. Spoken language relies on the context: common-sense reference
to experience and the relationship between the speaker and the audience to create and understand
Bakhtin, further, emphasizes that an utterance and a sentence are not the same thing.
Sentences do not indicate a change of speech subject, and thus do not automatically satisfy one
of the four properties of utterances. According to him, the sentence as a language unit is
grammatical in nature, while an utterance is "ethical". This idea must be considered when a
conversation is taking place in order to better understand its cultural and communicative
significance. A meaningful conversation largely depends on the sender’s and the receiver’s
perspective explains why differences are but natural among different societies (Baxter, 2006).
10
2. Methodology
This paper was done using Quantitative design and Descriptive Method.
The materials used in this paper came from Definitely Filipino: The Blog for Online
Filipinos’ Top 10 Most Memorable Lines From Pinoy TV Commercials. This site can be
lines-from-pinoy-tv-commercials/. The materials are the transcription of the ten (10) Philippine
TV commercials.
2.3. Procedure
The transcriptions of the TV commercials were taken from a blog site which tackles
almost anything about Philippine culture and society. The materials were analyzed and coded
using Utterance Theory (Bakhtin, 1986). The utterances were classified and marked according to
their Speech Acts Classification by two inter-raters based on Searle’s (1969) Taxonomy of
Speech Acts. The classified utterances in the chosen TV commercials were tabulated per
commercial. The frequency of Speech Acts in the ten TV commercials was then analyzed.
11
3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Results
This section presents the findings of the study. The points of emphasis in this part of the
paper include a comparison of the ten (10) TV commercials in terms of the number of utterances
In terms of the number of utterances in the ten (10) TV commercials and frequency count
Clearly, Table 1 shows that great majority of the utterances are in the category of
the highest number of utterances was 15 (Commercial #7) which majority of utterances did not
even talk about the product but the actions of the game the commercial talents were doing. On
12
the other hand, the lowest number of utterance in a commercial was 1 (commercial #8) which
The gathered data are significant in answering the three (3) research questions that direct
this paper:
1. What are the Speech Acts Classifications that are present in the selected popular Philippine
TV commercials?
The Speech Acts Classifications that are present in the selected popular Philippine TV
commercials are under Assertives, Directives, and Expressives. The findings reveal that
Assertives or utterances that convey belief in the truth of the expressed proposition (Bautista,
1988, cited in Dayag, 1997) surfaced as one of the speech acts in TV commercials. This is true in
the examples:
The above two examples show the speaker’s belief on the truthfulness of their words. The
speakers of the utterances were just mentioning the qualities of the product.
Also, Directives which means the speaker attempts to get the hearer/addressee to do
something places second in the speech acts in TV commercials. This speech acts classification
These sample utterances advise the viewers to do something and request an answer to a
question. The illocutionary force of the utterances in Directives makes the addressee to perform
and action.
13
Finally, the Expressives classification finds a place in Philippine TV commercials. This
classification express how the speaker feels about the situation. The speaker’s emotion was quite
In this classification, the speakers uttered thanking, apologizing, and welcoming words to
sooth the feeling of the interlocutor and to express his/her own emotion.
The three (3) Speech Acts Classifications evident in the ten TV commercials allow TV
advertisers to suggest and put forward products, to order and demand something from the
addressee, finally to express feelings about the product and convey emotions through dramatic
situations.
2. What is the dominant Speech Acts Classification in the selected Philippine TV commercials?
Unlike the previous findings that speech acts in TV commercials might be categorized as
a kind of directives (Banerjee & Carrell, 1988; Searle, 1976), data in this paper show that the
the utterances are about the speaker’s commitment on the truthfulness or falsity of the something.
This finding may have been caused by how the advertisement is presented. The chosen TV
commercials use story line and exposition that directly and implicitly talk about the products.
These advertisement strategies do not directly talk to the viewers, but only present what the
product is all about and how the product is part of everyday living.
14
3. What does the dominant Speech Act Classification imply on the culture of the society where
culture of the place. The ‘soft-sell approach’ using real life situations where the endorsed product
may be used only shows that Philippine may have exhibited high-context culture as seen by
advertisers. This means that consumers can understand the non-verbal part of the message
(Onkvisit & Shaw, 1999). The use of detailed explanations and logic may not be necessary.
The data also reveal that the creators of these TV commercials have done their research
on the nature and culture of the Philippine society. The drama or storyline related to family
events and the use of familiar symbols are not unique characteristics of Philippine TV
commercials, but also of other Asian countries like Japan (Lin, 1993) and Taiwan (Zandpour,
4. Conclusion
Speech Act Theory (Austin, 1962; Searle, 1976) states that certain act can be performed
through words or utterance. This theory is used in this paper to analyze the utterances in
Philippine TV commercials.
After the findings have been gathered, it can be said that how commercials are presented
affect the speech acts of the utterances. It is safe to say that the most preferred style in Philippine
TV commercials are not the one giving directives, but those that simply present information
about a certain product. This allows the viewers to discern which among the products are
15
The popularity of the chosen TV commercials may have also been caused by its
This study may be beneficial to the students and teachers of English for Specific Purposes.
The findings of this study show that culture affects advertising practice, that utterances in
assertives classification are prepared in Philippine advertising, and that familiarity with the
common symbols, family event/gathering, and presentation style in a specific community has
16
Appendix 1
1. Seiko Wallet –
4. Dragon Katol
17
5. Mc Donalds
6. PLDT
18
8. Sprite
“He loves me..he loves me not…he loves me…he loves me not….HE LOVES ME!“
19
References:
Austin, J. (1962). How to do things with words. Oxford, England: Calderon Press.
Baig, M. (2013). Analyzing the advertising discourse – A journey from sight to mind.
International Journal of Applied Linguistics & English Literature, 2 (1), 126-135.
Banwari, M. (Jan. – Feb. 1994). Public assessment of TV advertising: Faint praise and harsh
criticism. Journal of Advertising Research.
Bakhtin, M. (1986). Speech Genres and Other Late Essays. Trans. Vern W. McGee. Austin, TX:
University of Texas Press.
Bakhtin, M. (1990). Art and Answerability: Early Philosophical Essays. 1st ed. Austin:
University of Texas Press.
Baxter, Leslie (2006). Communication as...:Perspectives on theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE
Publishing, Inc. p. 102.
Dutta, S. (2013). Business communication. Delhi, India: PHI Learning Private Ltd. p. 112.
Retrieved from Amazon.com.
Nielsen. (2014). Advertising and audiences: State of the Media. Retrieved from
http://www.nielsen.com/content/dam/nielsenglobal/jp/docs/report/2014/Nielsen_Advertis
ing_and_%20Audiences%20Report-FINAL.pdf
Ohata,K. (2004). Different realizations of suggestions in TV commercials from japan and the
USA. Journal of Language and Linguistics, 3 (2), 197-212.
20
Onkvisit, S. & Shaw, J. (2009). Standardized international advertising: Some research issues and
implications. Journal of Advertising Research, 19-24.
Simpson, P. (2001). ‘Reason’ and ‘tickle’ as pragmatic construct in the discourse of advertising.
Journal of Prgamatics, 33, 589-607.
Stone, G., Besser, D., & Lewis, L. (2000). Recall, liking, creativity in TV commercials: A new
approach. Journal of Advertising Research, 40 (3).
Tannen, D. (1982). Spoken and written language: exploring orality and literacy. Norwood, N.J.:
ABLEX Pub. Corp.
van Enschot, R. & Hoeken, H. (2015). The occurrence and effects of verbal and visual
anchoring of tropes on the perceived comprehensibility and liking of TV commercials.
Journal of Advertising, 44 (1), 25-36.
Wells, W., Burnett, J., & Moriarty, S. (1995). Advertising: Principles and practice. New Jersey:
Prentice hall Publishers.
Zandpour, F., Chang, C., & Catalano, J. (Jan – Feb. 1992). Stories, symbols, and straight talk: A
comparative analysis of French, Taiwanese, and U.S. TV commercials. Journal of
Advertising Research, 32 (1), 25 – 38.
21