Derivative Suit
Derivative Suit
Derivative Suit
What is material in a derivative suit is that the right being vindicated is the right of the corporation
and the shareholders are only a nominal party representing the corporation.
The Requisites for a valid derivative suit are as follows:
1. The cause of action devolves from a right of the corporation, the harm or wrongdoing must
have been made against the corporation and not the individual shareholder/ or the
shareholders;
2. The lawsuit must be in the name of the corporation;
3. Intra-corporate remedies must have been exhausted and the issue remains to be unresolved;
4. The shareholder/shareholders bringing the suit must be shareholders at the time that they
initiate the action.
E.g.
1. A member of the board of director had committed fraudulent acts against the corporation by
forging the signatures of other members of the board and passing a board resolution on his own. If
intra-corporate remedies have been exhausted, the shareholders can file a case against the erring
director in behalf of or in representation of the corporation.
2. A foreign corporation had defrauded the corporation in a contract which they entered into by
delivering counterfeit products. Due to fear of the board of directors that other corporations from
that state wouldn’t want to do business with the corporation anymore if they filed a lawsuit, a
shareholder or some shareholders can file a derivative suit in behalf of the corporation against the
foreign corporation
A derivative suit should not be confused with a class suit. A class suit is a lawsuit filed in court be
anyone who is a member/part of a particular class or those who are similarly situated in vindication
of their own rights. A class suit is filed when the parties in a suit would be too numerous to include
every single interested party.
E.g. The students of a school who had fraudulent credentials. There were 2,000 defrauded students.
One or some of the students can file a lawsuit against the school in behalf of all the students as they
are all similarly situated or belong to the same class. Thus, even if only 20 of the students files a case,
if it is a class suit in behalf of all the 2,000 students, the judgment would benefit all of the students.
A derivative suit on the other hand, will only benefit the corporation itself.