Coping With Health Anxiety
Coping With Health Anxiety
Coping With Health Anxiety
Dr Brenda Hogan
Clinical Psychologist
2004
Contents
Appendix
Additional forms 22
Evaluation form 24
About health anxiety
Most people worry about their health at some time. Usually people worry when they
experience physical symptoms, and most of the time, these worries go away. For
some people, though, the worries do not go away. These people worry that they may
have a serious medical condition. These worries may affect their lives in very
significant ways, leading to intense anxiety, panic attacks, feeling as though they
cannot cope, or sometimes even depression.
This booklet focuses on how health worries come about and what keeps them going.
It provides specific guidelines about what you can do to help decrease the anxiety
associated with your health and begin to take control over your thoughts and
behaviour related to your health.
Health anxiety – as one would expect – involves intense anxiety about one’s health,
usually to the point that it produces significant distress or interferes with one’s day-to-
day functioning. Health anxiety involves either the fear that one has a serious
physical illness or the belief that one has a serious physical illness.
People who experience health anxiety usually experience several of the symptoms
and exhibit many of the behaviours listed below:
• Checking behaviours and increased focus on the body. People with health
anxiety very often actively check their body for signs of illness. Focusing on the
physical symptom(s) and monitoring the body for any physical changes are
common.
• Reassurance-seeking from doctors. Motivated by their concern that their
health is seriously in danger, people with health anxiety often seek medical
consultations and examinations in hopes of easing their fears. Medical
appointments may be made with increasing frequency, and the opinions of
multiple doctors may be sought.
• Reassurance-seeking from family and friends. People with health anxiety will
often mention their symptoms to their family and friends and ask for opinions
about whether they are really all right.
• Spending a lot of time finding out about illness. Some people are so
concerned about the possibility of illness that hey read a lot about illnesses and
check out their symptoms, for example in a medical encyclopaedia, or in
magazine articles, or on the internet.
• Avoiding things to do with illness. Quite frequently, people with health anxiety
will stop watching programmes on TV that might mention their feared illness, or
stop reading newspapers or magazines, or even stop talking about the illness
they are worried about.
• Other avoidant behaviours. Many people stop engaging in activities that they
fear may put their health at further risk. Behaviours such as walking, sports, and
other forms of exercises are avoided. Other people may go to bed or sit down
whenever they notice a physical symptom.
To give you a better idea of what health anxiety is all about, here is a case
example:
Mary is a 36-year-old woman who works full-time as physiotherapist. She gave up smoking ten years
ago. Over the past six months, she has become increasingly concerned that she may have lung
cancer. The onset of her anxiety about her physical health seemed to coincide with an increase of
stress at work as her patient load was growing quite large.
Mary noticed that she was getting pains in her chest. Other times she noticed that it was becoming
more difficult to breathe easily. She went to her GP, who told her not to worry. When her symptoms
did not improve, she returned to her GP, who did some tests. When the results of the tests came
back, her GP told her that she was fine. She felt better for a few weeks, but then the pains and the
breathing difficulties returned. This worried Mary more, and she started to read about the symptoms of
lung cancer on the internet. She found that this increased her anxiety significantly, and that she could
not stop thinking about her chest pain and breathing difficulties, and spent a significant amount of time
worrying that she had cancer. She began to avoid reading about cancer in magazines, and would turn
off the television if she suspected that cancer might be discussed on a programme she was watching.
Mary returned to the doctor several times; this seemed to provide some immediate relief, but the
doubts would start to creep back a few days after the visits. She began to ask her husband whether
he thought she had lung cancer. She kept a very close eye on her symptoms. She would sit or lie
down whenever she noticed chest pain or breathing difficulties. She stopped exercising, and went out
less and less. Her level of distress increased as her worries about her health continued to plague her.
Mary had several of the above symptoms.
• She had physical symptoms (chest pain, difficulty breathing) and worried a lot
about them.
• She feared that her physical symptoms were an indication that she had a
serious medical problem – lung cancer.
• She focused on her physical symptoms and monitored them.
• She sought reassurance from her GP and from her husband.
• At first, she looked for information about lung cancer on the internet, but when
she discovered that this increased her anxiety, she started to avoid anything
to do with cancer at all.
• She stopped engaging in activities that she thought might risk her health or
aggravate her symptoms, and would sit or lie down every time she noticed the
physical symptoms.
Look again at the list of features of health anxiety. Put a tick beside any of the
symptoms you have experienced or behaviours that you engage in.
Physical sensations are very real. However, they may arise from a number of
different causes. One cause is illness. Other causes include normal changes in the
body, stress, and worry.
The human body undergoes lots of physical changes every day. Most people
experience aches and pains and unusual sensations at some point; these changes
are sometimes noticed, and sometimes not. When they are noticed, some people
attribute the change to the game of golf they played yesterday, or what they ate for
lunch. Or they brush it off as a normal change in their body that will probably
disappear in the near future. Sometimes physical changes and sensations that are
experienced are due to the effects of a relatively minor health problem, like a cold or
the flu - when people recognise this, they usually do not worry that these symptoms
are a sign of serious illness. However, some people interpret the physical changes
or sensations they experience as indicative of a serious health problem – this leads
them to focus on the symptom and to start to worry a lot about it.
When someone has been stressed or worried, they may experience symptoms that
are a direct result of the stress and worry. Some of the physical symptoms that are
caused by anxiety, stress, and worry are listed below:
Symptoms of anxiety
If we think back to Mary’s example, she experienced chest pain and difficulty
breathing. These symptoms may have been the product of anxiety, but they were
interpreted as signs of a serious illness (e.g., cancer) and Mary’s thoughts were
something like “I am very ill”. These thoughts led to more anxiety, which caused
more physical symptoms….and so on, in a vicious circle.
Illness
Normal body sensations
Stress
Worry
Physical symptoms
(eg, chest pain, headache)
Thoughts
Anxiety (“I have cancer”,
“I am ill”, “I may die”
“I will be unable to work”
Many of the things that people do to cope with health anxiety actually serve to keep
the anxiety going. Think back to the list of symptoms and behaviours associated with
health anxiety. Many of the behaviours listed there are really things that people who
worry excessively about their health do in an effort to cope with their anxiety. But do
these strategies work? Many, if not all, of these strategies are helpful in the short-
term - that’s why people do them. Unfortunately, they actually serve to keep the
problem going.
Checking behaviours and increased focus on the body. Constant monitoring and
checking of physical symptoms may seem like a good idea - that way, you notice
even the slightest twinge, and you will notice a small change in the severity or
intensity of a physical sensation. While it is wise to be aware of how you are doing
physically, it is actually not helpful to pay close attention to your body at all times.
This is because your body naturally fluctuates during the day and the night, and over
time. Thus, noticing every little change provides very little useful information. And
worse - any change that is noticed is worried about, and as worry increases, physical
changes and symptoms tend to get worse, and as this happens, checking and
monitoring increases even more. In other words, checking and monitoring your body
feeds into the vicious circle of health anxiety.
The more you think about something, the more you notice it. Think about buying a
new car. You decide on a make and a model. You may suddenly find that you notice
that kind of car everywhere. Has the number of that kind of car increased? Probably
not - you are now noticing these cars because you are thinking about them so often.
The same thing can happen with physical symptoms - the more you think about
them, the more you notice them, even though they have been there all along.
Another problem that some people run into is that they engage in more than a just
“mental scan” of their body - in addition, they may poke and prod themselves to
check for changes, or do things like swallow repeatedly to assess the severity of
throat pain. These kinds of behaviours can also make the health anxiety worse by
aggravating the symptom that is worried about. For example, imagine repeatedly
touching and pressing on one spot on your arm. After a while, your arm would start to
hurt - even if it didn’t hurt in the first place. Keep touching and prodding, and the skin
may turn red and it may feel swollen. In this case, you would have produced the
symptom that you feared!
A question for you to think about: How much reassurance would it take to make you
stop worrying about your health forever?
Spending a lot of time finding out about illness. Some people with health anxiety
read a lot about their feared illness (or illness in general) and check out their
symptoms, for example in a medical book, on the internet, or in magazines. This
kind of behaviour can be a problem for several reasons. First - it is another example
of paying too much attention to your health. Sooner or later you will find reference to
a symptom that you have - a symptom that is not due to you being ill, but due to a
normal body change or sensation, or a symptom that is produced by anxiety. The
more attention you pay to that symptom, the more you worry...and so on. In addition,
reading about illness can cause you to focus even more on your body, and notice
even more sensations. A second problem is that sometimes people read up on
illnesses as a way of seeking reassurance that they are not ill. And as we discussed
above, the benefits of reassurance are short-lived and tend to keep the anxiety
going.
Avoiding things to do with illness. Avoiding information about illness can also be
a problem. Some people stop watching programmes on TV, or reading articles in
magazines or newspapers, about the illness they fear most. This can have the
immediate effect of stopping their worries. But what happens in the long term? The
worries persist. This is because they do not face what worries them and get the
worries into proportion.
Here is a model of the vicious circle of health anxiety that takes into account these
factors:
Trigger
(illness, normal body sensations, stress, worry)
Physical symptoms
(eg, chest pain, headache)
Apprehension
Leads to….
Physiological arousal
Preoccupation with perceived Increased focus on the body
alternation/abnormality of Checking and monitoring
bodily sensations Reassurance seeking
Seeking information
Avoidance behaviours
This model helps illustrate that your preoccupation and anxiety about your health is
aggravated by some of the things that you may be doing to cope (like reassurance
seeking and checking/monitoring your symptoms). Increasing your anxiety level can
increase your physical symptoms, which further convince you that you are seriously
ill…and the cycle continues.
What can you do to decrease health anxiety?
First and foremost, it is good idea to think about what it is that you want to change.
One very important thing to remember is that the aim of helping you cope with
your health anxiety is not to make the symptoms disappear. Remember that
changes in your body and a wide range of physical symptoms are perfectly normal.
In addition, anxiety produces a host of physical symptoms that can be misinterpreted
as an indication of serious illness. You cannot avoid the fact that is natural for your
body to undergo changes and for you to experience physical sensations, nor can you
completely eliminate anxiety from your life – as such, you will never be free of
symptoms. What is the aim, then? It is to help you become less worried about
your health. All kinds of symptoms may make you worry - and worrying may
produce lots of symptoms. If you can reduce the amount of worrying that you do, you
will very likely start to feel much better.
2.1 List the ways you have tried to help yourself and how effective these
methods have been
You have probably used many strategies in an effort to ease your anxiety about your
health. Make a list of things you have done to try and help yourself. After you have
made the list, think about how helpful what you have done was in terms of 1)
reducing your anxiety at the time, and 2) reducing your anxiety in the long-term. Give
each a rating between 0 and 10 for how effective the strategy was at the time, and in
the long-term (0 is not at all effective, and 10 is very effective.)
Ways I have tackled my How effective was this How helpful was this
worry that there is strategy at the time? strategy in the long
something wrong term?
Notice that most of the things Mary had done to try to help herself made her less
worried in the short term, but in the long term they didn’t seem to work at all. These
strategies did not really help her address her persistent worry about her symptoms.
Your list:
Ways I have tackled my How effective was this How helpful was this
worry that there is strategy at the time? strategy in the long
something wrong term?
Look again at the list and rankings you just made. Your efforts at proving there is
nothing wrong really aren’t working for you in the long term, are they? In fact, these
strategies actually help keep the problem going.
No one can say with absolute certainty that nothing is wrong with you. Your doctor
can tell you that you are definitely ill - medical exams and laboratory tests can prove
this. But can any doctor or any laboratory test avoid ever making a mistake?
Unlikely. Can they guarantee that you will never become ill? No. We all have some
chance of developing illness at some point in our lives. But the chance of this may
be much less than we think.
There will always be uncertainty about your heath. But just because something
might happen, does not mean that it will.
Take a pen or pencil and write down your answers to these questions:
What are your worries about your health? (For example: “I am worried that I
have cancer” or “I am worried that I will get heart disease and then be unable
to take care of my family”)
Do you know for certain that you have this illness? (Being certain means that
your doctor has told you so.)
Yes
No
If your answer is Yes: follow your doctor’s advice. If you want, keep
reading – some of the strategies here may still help you.
If your answer is No: (if you are uncertain or know that the answer is
no) then move on to the next question.
No
If your answer is Yes: then start now. Move on the next step.
If your answer is No: it’s time to work on reducing your worrying. Move
on to the next step.
A very important first step is to start thinking about other possible explanations for
your physical symptoms. Is it possible that these symptoms are a sign of something
other than illness? Remember – rather than there being something seriously wrong
with your health, the problem very well may be that you are very worried that
something is wrong. The worry in itself may be causing you a lot of problems. So - a
useful strategy may be to move the focus away from worrying about whether or not
you have a disease and toward the worry.
The symptoms you have may be a sign that you have a serious illness. More likely is
that they are not. Many symptoms can be caused by changes in your body that are
normal, not dangerous. Being worried and anxious can cause you to feel quite ill,
and cause you to experience lots of physical symptoms.
Try this exercise.
Write down all the evidence that indicates that you are seriously ill. Then ask
yourself whether the symptoms could be caused by something else (like worry or
anxiety). Write down all the other possible explanations of your symptoms. When
you are done, think about which explanation you think is the most likely. Give a
percentage rating of how like you think each explanation is.
Mary’s example:
(90%)
There is a chart for you to record your evidence at the back of this booklet.
What exactly are your worries about your health? Worries about health anxiety tend
to have certain characteristics.
For example, Mary might worry think that she was very likely to get cancer (in fact, in
her mind, it might be a certainty), that her symptoms were a sure indication that she
did have cancer, that that if she did get cancer, it would be the very worst and most
incurable form of cancer, and that the cancer would incapacitate her and she would
lead a lingering and painful death and be unable to take care of herself, both
emotionally and physically. Not surprisingly, extreme thoughts such as these cause
more anxiety - which can cause more symptoms - which makes the anxiety even
worse and more out of proportion.
You have had some practice looking at evidence for and against you having a
serious illness. Now you may want to try to challenge some of your thoughts about
illness.
There is a thought chart for you to complete at the back of this booklet. It is a very
good idea to keep a diary of your worrying thoughts and your alternative thoughts.
You should bring the diary with you wherever you go, and practice challenging your
worrisome thoughts as often as you can.
Need some proof that your physical symptoms may be due to something other
than a serious illness?
1. Give a physical symptom that is bothering you a severity rating from 0-100.
2. Spend five minutes focusing on nothing but the physical symptom that is
concerning you. Keep all your attention on the symptom.
3. At the end of five minutes, record what happened to the symptom. Did it get
worse? Better? Give it a rating from 0-100.
4. Spend five minutes doing something else completely different. For example, try
taking out a piece of paper and writing down, in detail, what the room you are
sitting in looks like.
5. At the end of five minutes, record what happened to the symptom. Did it get
worse? Better? Give it a rating from 0-100.
6. Compare the ratings. What happened when you were concentrating on your
symptom compared to when you concentrated on something else?
Many people find that their symptoms increase in severity and/or that they notice the
symptoms more when they are focusing on them. When they turn their attention to
something else, they stop noticing the symptom or it seems to feel less intense.
What does this tell you about focusing on your body sensations?
Stop asking for reassurance
We all need reassurance about our health sometimes. When people feel ill or notice
unusual changes in their body, it is appropriate to seek advice from a doctor or to
mention the symptoms to a friend or family member. Having a doctor tell you that
there is nothing to worry about, or talking over worries with friends and family can be
very reassuring. However, too much reassurance means:
In the long run, reassurance does not work for people with health anxiety. Most of
the time, it makes things even worse.
How do you stop? First of all, when you feel worried about your health, try not to ask
for help from anyone else. You might even want to talk to your friends and family
about this decision before you take action – let them know that if you do ask for
reassurance, they should help you by not “reassuring” you. Perhaps you could ask
them to change the subject if you ask, or remind you that you made an agreement
that they would not answer you. This may make you feel more anxious in the short-
term, so it may be important to plan for another way to deal with your worrying
thoughts. A good idea for distraction is to do something else: go for a walk, clean the
house, or read a book. Find something that works for you – something that you can
easily do when you re tempted to talk about your health.
It is a good idea to keep a record of how often you ask for reassurance or talk about
your health. If you are not given reassurance, you will discover that you gradually
stop asking for it less often, and start to feel less worried.
Keep a diary like this for several weeks, and review what happens to your level of
worry as you refrain from asking for reassurance.
Monitoring and checking your bodily state is sensible, as long as it is not done in
excess. For example, doing monthly (not daily!) checks for lumps in breasts is a
procedure recommended by doctors. It is not helpful to pay attention to your health
at all times. You have seen how worrying about your health can make you aware of
even the smallest change in your body and make you notice every sensation. It is
also not reasonable to check every lump and bump on your body multiple times a
day – remember, poking, touching, or squeezing a lump can make it swollen and
sore, and chances are that this will make you even more worried!
How to stop monitoring and checking your symptoms:
1. Decide how much checking is reasonable. Ask your doctor for some
advice, or check with friends or family to see how often they check or monitor
their bodies.
2. When you are tempted to check – DON’T! Not checking and monitoring
your body will probably make you more worried in the short-term. This is a
good time to use your distraction strategies, to help take your mind off your
worry.
1. Checking may be like a bad habit for you. If so, you may need some practice at
stopping. You may want to ask your family or friends for help – perhaps they can
remind you if they see you checking your symptom, or maybe that help distract
you when you find yourself starting to worry.
• Do something else. Physical activity may be helpful – try going for a walk or a swim, or do
some gardening or cooking. Whatever you like to do! Reading a book or listening to the
radio may also be helpful.
• Pay attention to something else. Notice what is around you, either in the room or outside.
Describe the picture in great detail, or try something like counting how many green things
that you see. The more detailed the task, the more distracting it will be.
• Do a mental exercise. Mental arithmetic works for some people – try counting backwards
from 500 by sevens. Think of a fun holiday you have had, or imagine your favourite place.
• Talk to someone else. Get them to help distract you! If you need to, call a friend or family
member. You don’t need to tell them that you want them to distract you – as long as you talk
about something other than your health, it may help take your mind off your worries.
2.6 STOP FINDING OUT AS MUCH AS YOU CAN ABOUT ILLNESS
Too much information about your health can make you more aware of every
symptom and change in your body. Most symptoms can be caused by many
different things – and many symptoms are nothing to worry about at all. Trying to
diagnose yourself can be incorrect and very worrying.
Again, keeping a diary can be helpful. As you spend less time finding out about
illness, you will find that you worry less about your health.
Try keeping this diary for a few weeks, and watch what happens to your anxiety as
you stop spending so much time finding out about illness.
While some people spend too much time finding out about illness, other people avoid
any information at all about health (or their feared illness) because it increases their
anxiety. You may find that you avoid TV programmes about your feared illness, or
avoid reading articles in the newspapers or magazines. Again, this decreases
anxiety in the short-term, but increases it in the long-term. So what can you do?
Make a list of the ways in which you have been avoiding information about your
feared illness. Rate for each how strong your avoidance has been (0 = not very
strong at all, 100 = very strong avoidance). Start with the one you have avoided the
least, and plan to spend a little bit of time doing just this. When this one feels more
manageable, move on to the next one, and gradually work your way up the list.
Mary would start this exercise by not walking away when she hears other people
talking about cancer. For example, at first, she might try to stay in the conversation
for five minutes, then move up to five minutes. When this feels manageable, she
might try to read a short article on cancer in the newspaper, and then try a longer
one. And so on. When she finds a task to be anxiety provoking, she may have to
challenge her worrisome thoughts about anxiety (see section C).
Make your own list here:
It is a good idea to keep a record of your anxiety levels as you tackle each of these
activities.
Are you avoiding physical activity or exerting yourself? Are you sitting or lying down
whenever you notice a particular symptom? The trouble with stopping your normal
activities is that it decreases your fitness level – this can make you feel unwell, tired,
and aching. When you try to exert yourself, you will feel even worse. This is not due
to illness, but do to you becoming less fit – but when you notice these things (eg,
fatigue, breathlessness when you increase your activity level), you may misinterpret
them as signs of illness. This may make you slow down even more – and the vicious
circle continues.
• Resume physical activities slowly. If you have been inactive for a while, you
won’t be able to as much as you once could. You will have to ease back into it.
• Make a list of the things you used to do that you would like to do again. Put them
in order, with the one requiring the least energy first, and finish with the one that
requires the most effort.
___________________________________________________________________
This booklet has provided you with information about health anxiety, and what
you can do to help reduce this anxiety. Getting over health anxiety takes a lot of
work. It is a good idea to work through these exercises slowly – at your own
pace. Keep a record of your progress (for example, a record of your daily anxiety
levels) – this way, you can look back at what has happened as you complete
more and more of the exercises. Challenging your thoughts about illness can be
very helpful – this is a skill you can use when you are trying the other practice
exercises. Remember that you are not trying to get rid of the physical symptoms
– the goal is to reduce your anxiety about these symptoms.
___________________________________________________________________
Evidence that I am seriously ill Evidence that I am not seriously ill
Worrying thought How worried was I? ( 0- Alternate, more rational, thought New rating
100) of worry
(0-100)
Manual evaluation
We would be very grateful to hear about what you think of this manual. It is an
evolving document and we will attempt to incorporate people’s suggestions.
Are there any parts of the manual that are unclear or difficult to understand?
Are there any parts that were very useful for you?
Do you have any suggestions that would make the manual more effective?
Thank you.
The Patient Advice and Liaison Service (PALS) provides service users, their carers and
families with help, information and support to resolve concerns quickly and efficiently.
T 01223 726789
F 01480 398501
www.cpft.nhs.uk
Reprinted January 2010