EDTO Module 6 - Flight Operations Considerations PDF
EDTO Module 6 - Flight Operations Considerations PDF
Module 10
Assessment
Overview
1) Define EDTO routes that will be covered by application.
2) For each route, establish a list of Adequate En-route
Alternate Airports.
3) Determine EDTO diversion time required and EDTO
engine inoperative planning speed.
4) Establish EDTO Area of Operations.
5) Establish a system for obtaining EDTO flight plan data.
- EDTO en-route alternates, Equal Time Points,
Critical Fuel Scenario, Time Limited Systems.
6) Arrange to obtain weather data for EDTO en-route alternates.
7) Ensure there is a method of communication between the
airplane and the airline during the flight (flight following).
EDTO Flight Operations Program
Continued
Overview (cont’d)
8) Review EDTO provisions in the FAA approved MMEL
to establish the airline’s MEL.
9) Establish a method to check APU in-flight start reliability.
10) Designate an EDTO Check Airman.
11) Establish and document airline operating procedures for EDTO.
Note: If the airline plans to change Boeing FCOM procedures,
determine if changes need to be re-validated
12) Revise the airlines flight crew guidance material to include
EDTO practices and procedures.
13) Train flight dispatchers and flight crew on EDTO requirements,
performance data, MEL and airline unique EDTO processes.
EDTO Flight Operations Program*
Continued
Section 303 and 304 of FAA AC 120-42B
Conclusions
EDTO
Extended Diversion Time Operations
contains a point further than applicable threshold (e.g. 60 min flying time for
twins)
at the approved:
All Engine Operative (AEO) speed for airplanes with more than 2 engines
Adequate Airport
To be qualified as adequate an airport must be :
available,
compatible with the performance requirements for the expected landing weight,
have at least one let-down navigation aid (ILS, VOR, NDB, Radar),
Note : Other criteria should be taken into account (e.g. Hotel Capacity, Maintenance
facilities,…)
EDTO
Extended Diversion Time Operations
All Engine Operative (AEO) speed for airplanes with more than 2 engines
Diversion Speed
The approved one engine inoperative speed
A diversion speed could be an IAS, TAS or even a MACH number.
60 min
MMO
Increasing Speed
with decreasing weight
VMO
Max Speed
60 min
Which speed to follow ?
Diversion Speed
Choice of a Strategy
Diversion Speed
Choice of a Strategy
The chosen speed (which will be approved) will have an impact on the
diversion distance and the fuel consumption.
EDTO
Extended Diversion Time Operations
All Engine Operative (AEO) speed for airplanes with more than 2 engines
MMO
Increasing Speed
with decreasing weight
VMO
Max Speed
60 min
2. Get the threshold distance (e.g. for 60 min) from relevant aircraft
performance manual or tool.
Is EDTO required ?
What is the needed diversion time ?
IQALUIT
SONDRESTROM KEFLAVIK
SHANNON
GOOSE
GANDER
BANGOR SANTIAGO
IQALUIT
EDTO FLIGHT !
SONDRESTROM KEFLAVIK
SHANNON
GOOSE
IQALUIT
120 min diversion time covers
SONDRESTROM KEFLAVIK
the route.
SHANNON
GOOSE
GANDER
BANGOR SANTIAGO
2) Determining whether an
EDTO alternate is within
the maximum diversion
time authorized for an
EDTO flight
Zero Wind
*
(Typically a Mach/IAS Combination)
• VLO/MLO
Max Speed for Landing
Gear Operation
• VLE/MLE
Max Speed with Landing
Gear Extended
• VMO/MMO
Max Operating Limit
Speed
777-300ER / GE90-115BL
… beyond 240
Conclusions
ETP
CRUISE FL
To BOM
To SLL ? To BOM ?
Adverse Wind (Head), lower Favorable Wind (Tail), higher
diversion FL and colder diversion FL and hot
conditions (Reduced TAS) conditions (Increased TAS)
ETP takes into consideration Wind and Temperature effect at the engine-
out diversion flight level.
Remark
The Time Window (period of suitability) is provided for the Estimated Time of
Departure and must be adjusted to the Actual Time of Departure should a delay occur.
- Fuel from DEP to ETP (furthest point from - Fuel from DEP to ETP (furthest point
the diversion Airport) from the diversion Airport)
- Fuel to diversion Airport (from ETP ) - Fuel to diversion Airport (from ETP )
ETP1
+ Approach and Go-around + Instrument Approach and landing
+ Circuit to land ETP2
+ Final reserve (15 minutes holding at + Final reserve (15 minutes holding at
1500ft) 1500ft)
+ Specific reserves (contingency fuel, ice + Specific reserves (contingency fuel, ice
accretion, APU…) accretion, APU…)
Scenario 3
Only Engine Failure
Optimum diversion FL (or MSA) at the approved speed strategy
EEP
ETP2 ETP1
Scenario 1 Scenario 2
Depressurization Depressurization + Engine failure
FL 100 (or MSA) at LRC cruise FL 100 (or MSA) at the approved speed strategy
EEP
ETP1
ETP2
Scenario 1 Scenario 2
Depressurization Depressurization + Engine failure
FL 100 (or MSA) at LRC cruise FL 100 (or MSA) at the Approved Speed Strategy
EEP
ETP1
ETP2
CP
4. Go-around
Critical Point
The point – among the equal time points (ETP) – on the route which is critical
regards to the ETOPS fuel requirements if a diversion has to be initiated from that
point .
Usually the last ETP within the EDTO segment
Descent to 1,500 ft
– Fuel for airframe icing+ wing and engine TAI
Critical
Critical fuel point
required
EDTO Alternates
ICAO EDTO Course - Flight Operations Page 57
EDTO Performance Data
Enroute
Traditional Boeing FPPM data for earlier models
• Altitude Capability
• Cruise Tables
• Diversion Fuel and
Time
• Holding
• ‘Fuel’ Strategy
– Best fuel burn performance
– Fixed speed descent to LRC cruise ceiling followed
by LRC cruise (QRH)
* EDTO speed (CO SPD) must be provided by operator for AMI load
ICAO EDTO Course - Flight Operations Page 62
EDTO Approval
Route Planning
EDTO Approval Route Planning*
E150 E165 E180 W165 W150 W135 W120 W105 W90 W75 W60 W45 W30 W15 E0
N60 N60
BOG-NRT
N45 N45
N30 N30
BOG-LHR
N15 N15
LIM-HNL GRU-LIS
N0 N0
S30 S30
SCL-IPC
SCL-AKL
S60
Typical Twin 60 Minute Area (400 nm) S60
E150 E165 E180 W165 W150 W135 W120 W105 W90 W75 W60 W45 W30 W15 E0
E150 E165 E180 W165 W150 W135 W120 W105 W90 W75 W60 W45 W30 W15 E0
N60 N60
N45 N45
N30 N30
N15 N15
N0 N0
S15 S15
S30 S30
EZE-CPT
SCL-AKL
S45 S45
S60 S60
Typical Quad 180 Minute Area (1500 nm)
E150 E165 E180 W165 W150 W135 W120 W105 W90 W75 W60 W45 W30 W15 E0
S15 S15
S30 S30
S45 S45
GREAT CIRCLE
S60 S60
SOUTH POLAR AREA
85% SUMMER WINDS
JUNE 25 WIND OPTIMIZED (WESTBOUND)
(WESTBOUND)
– FAA
* The EDTO Exit Point is the last point in the route that exceeds the EDTO
threshold
Lima
Apia
Port Vila Pago Pago Papeete Hao Island Tacna
Nadi Niue
Noumea Nuku'alofa Rarotonga Antofagasta
Easter Island
Santiago
Auckland Concepcion
Buenos Aires
Mar Del Plata
Wellington Puerto Montt
Christchurch
Comodoro Rivadavia
Invercargill
Rio Gallegos
GREAT CIRCLE
Lima
Apia
Port Vila Pago Pago Papeete Hao Island Tacna
Nadi Niue
Noumea Nuku'alofa Rarotonga Antofagasta
Easter Island
Santiago
Buenos Aires
Auckland Waypoint Constraint Concepcion
(S4352, W13745) Mar Del Plata
Wellington Puerto Montt
Christchurch
240 MINUTES - 5748 NM
Comodoro Rivadavia
Invercargill
Rio Gallegos
Ushuaia
* The Critical Point (CP) is the Equal *Adjust fuel load if required
Time Point at which the EDTO
diversion fuel is closest to, or
exceeds, the normal planned fuel on
board
Lima
Apia
Port Vila Pago Pago Papeete Hao Island Tacna
Nadi Niue
Noumea Nuku'alofa Rarotonga Antofagasta
Easter Island
Santiago
Auckland Concepcion
Buenos Aires
Mar Del Plata
Wellington ETP 1 Puerto Montt
AKL - PPT
Christchurch ETP 3
IPC - PMC Comodoro Rivadavia
Invercargill
ETP 2 Rio Gallegos
PPT - PPT
Punta Arenas Mount Pleasant
Ushuaia
*
• Determine Diversion Distances from
FPPM
data or PET Analysis
– Airframe/engine combination(s)
– Engine inoperative speed
– Reference weight
– Diversion time required
• Finalize list of adequate alternate airports
– Consider remote areas of route, EDTO entry/exit regions
– Establish backup alternates to allow for airports unavailable
at dispatch, potential routing variations
Approach Minimums
Published
Procedures
* IPC is also unavailable when LAN flights from Santiago are committed to land
ICAO EDTO Course - Flight Operations Page 80
EDTO Route Planning Example
240 Minute EDTO Area - Without IPC
Lima
Apia
Port Vila Pago Pago Papeete Hao Island Tacna
Nadi Niue
Noumea Nuku'alofa Rarotonga Antofagasta
Easter Island
Santiago
Auckland Concepcion
Buenos Aires
Mar Del Plata
Wellington Puerto Montt
Christchurch
Comodoro Rivadavia
Invercargill
Rio Gallegos
Ushuaia
1. Check at dispatch that these values do not exceed corresponding Time Limited system(s) capabilities
2. If one or both values are reduced (e.g. in case of MMEL) ► Select another route within the corrected
Time Limited system(s) capabilities
Manufacturer has to identify the time limited system(s) capabilities and to include the corresponding values in
the AFM and EDTO / ETOPS CMP Document
1. Check at dispatch that these values do not exceed corresponding Time Limited system(s) capabilities
2. If one or both values are reduced (e.g. in case of MMEL) ► Select another route within the corrected
Time Limited system(s) capabilities
Manufacturer has to identify the time limited system(s) capabilities and to include the corresponding values in
the AFM and EDTO / ETOPS CMP Document
EEP Ushuaia
S60 S60
ETP 1
USH - CHC
JUNE 25
WIND OPTIMIZED
For airports with at least one Add 400 ft to the MDA or DH as Add 1 sm or 1600m to the landing
operational navigational facility applicable. minimum.
providing a straight–in non-precision
approach procedure, or Category I
precision approach, or, when
applicable, a circling maneuver from
an instrument approach procedure.
For airports with at least two Add 200 ft to the higher DH or Add ½ sm or 800 m [4] to the higher
operational navigational facilities, MDA of the two approaches authorized landing minimum of the
each providing a straight-in approach used. two approaches used.
procedure to different suitable
runways. Separate runway surfaces no longer required
One useable authorized Category II 300 feet 3/4 sm (1200 m) or
ILS IAP. RVR 4000 (1200 m)
One useable authorized category III 200 feet 1/2 sm (800 m) [4] or
ILS Instrument Approach Procedure RVR 1800 feet (550 m)
(IAP).
The above criteria for precision approaches are only to be applied to Category 1 approaches. *
When determining the usability of an Instrument Approach (IAP), forecast wind plus any gusts should be within
operating limits, and within the operators maximum crosswind limitations taking into account the runway condition
(dry, wet or contaminated) plus any reduced visibility limits.
Conditional forecast elements need not be considered, except that a PROB 40 or TEMPO condition below the
lowest applicable operating minima should be taken into account.
When dispatching under the provisions of the MEL, those MEL limitations affecting instrument approach minima
should be considered in determining EDTO alternate minima.
* relief for advanced landing systems (Cat II/III) may also be approved
ETP 1
USH - CHC
JUNE 25
WIND OPTIMIZED
INCREMENTAL BURN PER 1000 LBS INCREASE/DECREASE IN TOW: 294 10% Trip Time
ATC CLRNC:.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. Contingency
-M084F320 DCT 44S070W/M084F340 55S080W 62S090W 65S100W 67S110W
67S120W 67S130W 66S140W 64S150W/M084F360 61S160W 57S170W 49S180W
DCT
FL 320/4470W 340/64W50 360
EDTO Flight Plan Example
Boeing ‘FLE’ Format (Cont)
Diversion Fuel Buildup
------- EQUAL TIME POINT DATA - ETP01 SAWH/USH - NZCH/CHC --------
Conclusions
• Dispatch
• Cockpit Preparation
• En-route
• Diversion Decision
• Diversion Strategies (Speed
Selection)
• Post Flight
SONDRE STROM
KEFLAVIK
EEP
ETP2 ETP1
ETP3
EXP
SHANNON
GANDER
NOTAMS
WEATHER
WEATHER CHARTS
Pre-Takeoff Checks
Specific pre-takeoff checks
Flight crew : e.g. fuel x-feed valve, CSM/G
Maintenance : e.g. engine oil level and DPI.
Checks may vary with aircraft model
DATA in FMGS
EEP, ETP, EXP, CRUISE WINDS
Entered as “FIX INFO” or “ABEAM”
- display these points on the ND
- no need to create additional waypoints in the F-PLN, to
avoid these points being transmitted via CPDLC or ADS
The ETP computed by the FMGS (AEO) is different from the EDTO ETP (OEI).
Computed at engine-out FL
Computed at cruise FL
SONDRE STROM
KEFLAVIK
EEP
ETP2 ETP1
ETP3
EXP
SHANNON
GANDER
Crew Notifications
Crew must be notified of any significant changes affecting:
Forecast weather
Aerodrome availability
Any other required services at EDTO alternate airports designated for the flight.
GANDER
SONDRE STROM
KEFLAVIK
ETOPS DIVERSION
EEP
ETP2 ETP1
ETP3
EXP
SHANNON
• Part A: General/Basic
– Introduction, Operations approval, Training &
checking, Operating procedures, flight
preparation & planning…
• Part B: Aeroplane Operating Matters
– Type specific operations, dispatch, flight
planning, enroute, fuel planning, MEL/CDL,
aeroplane systems…
• Part C: Route and Aerodrome Instructions
– EDTO area and routes, enroute alternates,
weather, CFP information, minimum altitudes,
aerodrome characteristics…
Definitions
• Part D: Training
EDTO Operational Concepts
– Operators initial/recurrent route and aerodrome
EDTO Fuel Requirements
training programs.
Diversion Strategies
Flight Crew Procedures
EDTO Training
• None of the following justify flying beyond the nearest suitable airport:
• Available fuel supply
• Passenger accommodation other than safety
• Maintenance/repair resources
L/D Max
Obstacle Strategy Altitude
Altitude
LRC Cruise
EDTO Strategy
Time
Distance
Conclusions
Module 6
EDTO Flight Operations considerations