Nguyễn Thị Thi
Nguyễn Thị Thi
(NGHIÊN CỨU VỀ VIỆC SỬ DỤNG CÁC THỦ PHÁP TRONG LÀM BÀI ĐỌC
TOEIC ĐỐI VỚI SINH VIÊN TRƯỜNG ĐẠI HỌC HÀNG HẢI VIỆT NAM)
HANOI - 2014
VIETNAM NATIONAL UNIVERSITY, HANOI
UNIVERSITY OF LANGUAGES AND INTERNATIONAL STUDIES
FACULTY OF POST-GRADUATE STUDIES
*********************
(NGHIÊN CỨU VỀ VIỆC SỬ DỤNG CÁC THỦ PHÁP TRONG LÀM BÀI ĐỌC
TOEIC ĐỐI VỚI SINH VIÊN TRƯỜNG ĐẠI HỌC HÀNG HẢI VIỆT NAM)
HANOI - 2014
DECLARATION
I truly certify that this thesis is the result of my personal study in fulfillment
of the requirement for the Degree Master of Arts and this thesis has not been
published or submitted for a degree to any other university or institution wholly or
partially.
i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This research has, in many senses, been accomplished with the help and
encouragement of many people. Therefore, I would like to express my deepest and
humblest gratitude also warmest appreciation to the following people.
First and foremost, I would like to send my deepest gratitude to my ever
supportive supervisor, Ms. Nguyễn Thị Ngọc Quỳnh, Ph.D. for her valuable
guidance, constructive advice, and unconditional support during the time I tried to
complete this thesis.
I would also express my huge thanks to all of my lecturers at Faculty of Post-
Graduate Studies, University of Languages and International Studies as their
invaluable lectures and guidance laid the foundation for the fulfillment of this
thesis.
I would also like to show my gratefulness to my colleagues who spent a great
deal of time discussing some of the issues related to my research, offering their
insights and perspectives as well as my students at Vietnam Maritime University in
data collection process using survey questionnaire and semi-structured interview.
Last but definitely not least, I would like to dedicate this thesis to my family
for their unconditional support and words of encouragement.
ii
ABSTRACT
This study was conducted at Vietnam Maritime University with a view to exploring
test-taking strategies relative to learners’ performance in TOEIC Reading
Comprehension as well as identifying differences in reading strategies among high
proficiency and low proficiency students at Vietnam Maritime University.
The subjects involved in the study are over 100 students of Vietnam Maritime
University (VMU) chosen randomly from 4 TOEIC classes. Two classes are at
Elementary Level (TOEIC Level 1), the other classes are at Intermediate Level
(TOEIC Level 2). The data was collected from survey questionnaires, interviews
and administration of two TOEIC tests for students. The results indicated that
students at VMU put more emphasis on using reading strategies when they attended
the TOEIC course. In addition, this study also revealed some differences in reading
strategy use among students of different proficiency levels. However, when looking
at the data, the researcher found some shared strategies between the two groups.
From the findings, the study suggested several pedagogical implications for
teachers, students and test-designers at VMU, acknowledged limitations of the
study and offered suggestions for further research.
iii
ABBREVIATIONS
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Declaration ................................................................................................................... i
Acknowledgements .....................................................................................................ii
Abstract ..................................................................................................................... iii
Lists of figures and tables .......................................................................................... iv
Table of contents ........................................................................................................ v
PART I: INTRODUCTION
1. Rationale for the study ............................................................................................ 1
2. Research aims and research question ...................................................................... 2
3. Scope of the study ................................................................................................... 2
4. Significance of the study ......................................................................................... 2
5. Method of the study ................................................................................................ 3
6. Organization of the study ........................................................................................ 3
PART II: DEVELOPMENT
CHAPTER 1: LITERATURE REVIEW
1.1. Reading ................................................................................................................ 5
1.1.1. Definition of reading ......................................................................................... 5
1.1.2. Purposes of reading ........................................................................................... 6
1.1.3. Reading process ................................................................................................ 6
1.2. Reading comprehension ....................................................................................... 7
1.3. Reading TOEIC Test ............................................................................................ 8
1.3.1. Test .................................................................................................................... 8
1.3.2. TOEIC Test ...................................................................................................... 9
1.4. TOEIC reading comprehension strategies ........................................................ 10
1.5. Study of cognitive process ................................................................................. 13
1.6. Summary ........................................................................................................... 15
CHAPTER 2: METHODOLOGY
2.1. Settings ............................................................................................................... 16
2.2. Participants ......................................................................................................... 16
v
2.3. Research method ............................................................................................... 17
2.3.1. Data collection instruments ............................................................................. 17
2.3.2. Data collection procedures .............................................................................. 18
2.3.3. Data analysis ................................................................................................... 19
CHAPTER 3: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1. Research question 1 ........................................................................................... 21
3.1.1. Types of Reading Passages and Topic texts often exploited ......................... 21
3.1.2. Reading Approach .......................................................................................... 24
3.1.3. Strategies to Deal with Reading Text ............................................................ 25
3.1.4. Reading strategies in taking TOEIC reading comprehension ......................... 26
3.2. Research question 2 ........................................................................................... 27
3.2.1. A comparison about the Priority of Reading Passage .................................... 27
3.2.2. Types of Topic Texts often exploited by Low Proficiency and High
Proficiency Students.................................................................................................. 28
3.2.3. A comparison about Reading Approach ........................................................ 29
3.2.4. A Comparison about reading strategies .......................................................... 30
PART III: CONCLUSION
1. Summaries of the major findings .......................................................................... 31
2. Pedagogical Implications ...................................................................................... 32
3. Limitations ............................................................................................................ 34
4. Recommendations for further study ...................................................................... 34
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................ 36
APPENDIX 1 ........................................................................................................................ I
APPENDIX 2 ....................................................................................................................VII
APPENDIX 3 .................................................................................................................. VIII
APPENDIX 4 .................................................................................................................. XVI
APPENDIX 5 .................................................................................................................XVII
vi
PART I: INTRODUCTION
In the age of economic growth and global integration, English obviously plays a
very important role. However, the criteria for evaluating one’s English competence
are more and more difficult. In today’s context, the A, B, C certificates used for
people wishing to find a job are out-of- date, and the so-called IELTS, TOEFL or
TOEIC have been the best choices. TOEIC, together with other requirements for job
seekers, is preferred by most companies in order to assess their employees’
qualifications. Therefore, a lot of people are trying hard to achieve the success in a
TOEIC Test.
Previously, although much literature has been devoted to TOEIC related topics;
little was revealed about the cognitive processes underlying the performance of
Vietnamese candidates in the TOEIC Reading Test, except for the exploratory study
by Phạm Đức Long (2013) on “teaching and learning of TOEIC reading
comprehension skill”.
For all of the reasons stated, this paper is among the first attempts putting the
emphasis onto “test-taking techniques for TOEIC Reading Comprehension to
students at Vietnam Maritime University” so as being help to solve out their
problems.
1
2. Research aims and research questions
The original aim of this study is to gain an insight into how test-takers employ
different reading strategies in TOEIC Reading comprehension. As the first attempt
to explore the ongoing thinking processes during performing reading tasks, once
finished the paper could serve as a useful source for TOEIC candidates who are
planning to sit for the test as well as TOEIC trainers who want to have a closer look
at how their trainees would actually perform in the real test for better TOEIC
preparation instruction. To achieve this aim, the following research questions will
be addressed:
3. Scope of study
This study aimed to document the test-taking techniques of 100 students who are
taking TOEIC preparation course at Vietnam Maritime University in Haiphong. 50
students are at Elementary level, 50 students are at Intermediate level.
4. Significance of study
First of all, through the problems pointed out and the suggestions made, the students
may improve their performance in reading TOEIC test.
Similar to the students, the study would help TOEIC teachers to realize their
problems in guiding their students in sitting for a test in order to achieve the best
2
results. Moreover, by noticing the students’ difficulties in reading, teachers can
have their in-time consideration and correction in teaching reading effectively.
In addition to the benefits given to the two above subjects, the study may serve as
the foundation based on which further related research would be carried out.
Particularly, future research could be made better after the limitations of the study
are considered.
Firstly, apart from the surveyed 100 students, 15 students were chosen to participate
in the semi-interviews as soon as they finished taking TOEIC Test. With the aim of
making the responses more confident in the interview, all the questions are simple
and understandable for students to answer.
Secondly, questionnaires are delivered to the students after they take the TOEIC
test. They were offered to tick or circle the answer that best reflects their
viewpoints.
3
Chapter 2, Methodology, covers four major parts, namely, participants, instruments,
data collection, data collection procedures, and data analysis.
Chapter 3, Results and Discussions, presents, analyzes and discusses the findings in
order to answer the research questions of the study.
Part 3, Conclusion, provides summaries of the main findings, suggestions for better
results, limitations of the study, and lastly, recommendations for further related
researches.
4
In this chapter, relevant knowledge collected from various sources will be presented
so that it can suitably serve as a foundation for the research. The paper is divided
into two parts including theories on reading difficulties and TOEIC reading.
1.1. Reading
So far, many scholars have been working out the definition of reading. According to
Smith (1985), reading is to understand the author’s thought. Rumelhart (1997)
proposed a different view on reading which is, in his opinion, actually an interaction
between reader and text. This view was shared by a number of researchers
(Silberstein, 1994; Goodman, 1971; Alderson, 2003; Griffiths et. al., 2011; Falke,
1982). Goodman (1971) in his book titled Reading: A Psycholinguistic Guessing
Game put forward the definition that reading is a psycholinguistics process by
which the reader, a language user, reconstructs as well as he can, a message which
has been encoded by a writer as a graphic display, a cyclical process of sampling,
predicting, testing and confirming (p.135). As Falke (1982) defined, in English the
“graphic display” can be either printed or written.
Among the many definitions of reading that have arisen in recent decades, a
comprehensive view should account for the active process of using one’s won prior
5
language knowledge and experience and the cues found in the text to understand
what the writer has encoded (Saengpakdeejit, 2009), since reading is not simply a
cognitive skill, nor does it have a straightforward outcome as the same text can be
understood in different ways by different readers. For the recent study, however,
reading also refers to the active thinking process that TOEIC test-takers take so as
to understand and complete different reading tasks of the test.
The purposes of reading refer to readers’ aims and objectives. Therefore, different
readers may have different purposes in their mind with the reading text in their
hand. According to Ruiqi (2007), basically there are two main reading purposes
including reading for getting information and reading for pure fun or enjoyment.
Grabe and Stoller (2002), however, divided reading purposes into seven subtypes
which are more specific: reading for search for simple information, reading to skim
quickly, reading to learn from the text, reading to integrate information, reading to
write, reading to critique the text and reading for general comprehension.
In bottom-up model, reading is compelled by the text, proceeds from part to whole,
constructs meaning from letters, words, phrases, sentences. Readers process the text
in linear direction (Nunan, 1991). Therefore, in this model, readers are believed to
play a rather passive role. The basis of bottom-up reading model lies in the
linguistic knowledge of the reader (Samuel & Kamil, 1988).
6
In top-down model, the understanding of the text is constructed from whole to part.
The readers predict what come next, test their prediction and adjust or confirm. In
this model, readers actively use their background knowledge. Goodman (1967)
described reading using top-down model like a “psycholinguistic guessing game” in
which the “reader reconstructs, as best as he can, a message which has been
encoded by a writer as a graphic display” (p.135).
7
Figure1: A Heuristic for Thinking about Reading Comprehension (RAND
Reading Study Group, 2002)
1.3.1. Test
Towards the meaning of a test, many different authors have different definitions.
According to definition cited in Longman dictionary, a test is: “any procedure for
measuring ability, knowledge or performance”. Alphonse (2008), on the other hand
says that testing is one of the best ways to enable the teacher to monitor students’
performance and progress. However, the researcher finds that the definition made
by Rubayee (2008) is the most effective in which “tests are important in
determining the students’ learning achievements in the classroom; at the same time
they also help teachers to monitor his/her teaching methods in the classroom” (cited
in To and Nguyen, 2008).
There are many ways to classify tests including basing on their uses and purposes,
the ways to mark them, or on the types of test tasks, etc. According to test purposes
as the grouping principle, we can classify tests into four common types as below:
Proficiency To see how good students are at language, or use of the language. The
8
tests contents of a proficiency tests are not chosen according to what has
been taught, but according to what is needed for a particular purpose.
Achievement To see how well students have learnt the language taught in class.
tests Achievement tests are often at the end of term or end of the year and
test the main points of what has been taught in that time.
Placement To identify a student’s level of language and find the best class for
tests them. These are essential in large institutions that frequently receive
new students.
Diagnostic To identify problems that students have with language. They help
tests teachers diagnose the language problems students have and to plan
what to teach in future.
9
The content of the TOEIC is not specialized; the vocabulary and content are
familiar to those individuals who use English in daily activities.
In TOEIC reading section, there are 100 multiple-choice questions which take 75
minutes. Reading score scale ranges from 5 to 495 (Examinee handbook – Listening
& Reading, 2012, p.2). TOEIC reading test is divided into three parts including
incomplete sentences, text completion, and the last one is reading comprehension.
Part 6- Text Completion consists of 12 questions in which there will be 4 texts and
3 questions for each text. In this part, test-takers are asked to select the best answer
to complete the text (type of questions and the way to do are as same as part 5).
10
Course, p.151). It might be inferred that when readers have a particular question in
their mind, they can read fast and purposefully. Furthermore, TOEIC examinees “do
not read the answer before they read the passage” (Lougheed, 2007a, p.151). It may
be understood that when test-takers master each reading question, they should find
the answer in the passage instead of looking for answer options (A), (B), (C), (D)
after each question. It can be seen that Lougheed (2007c) reveals that TOEIC
examinees should find not only direct answer but also “synonyms, paraphrases, and
implied answers” (p.170). It is not enough without mentioning four main question
types: “main idea questions, detail questions, inference questions and vocabulary
questions” (Lougheed, 2007a, p.151) which readers are highly recommended to
prepare for the new TOEIC test.
According to www.masterthetoeic.com, one of the most important skills readers
will need to develop for the TOEIC is Skimming - this will help readers with many
Questions in Part 6: Text Completion and Part 7: Reading Comprehension,
especially with Inference Questions. Skimming means to quickly look through a
Text, focusing only on certain words. These words give you an understanding of
the general information or ideas in the Text. The key to Skimming is to NOT READ
every word.
Instead, focus on the following kinds of Key Words:
Subject or Object of each sentence
Action Verbs (i.e., verb that describe a clear action, such as “delete”)
Helping Verbs (i.e., verbs such as “need to”, “can”, or “will”)
Strong Adjectives
Skimming will help readers: more quickly understand the General Ideas
of Texts, without having to read every word.
Skimming will also help readers: know the Location of different kinds of
information.
11
Another TOEIC skill you need to develop is the ability to quickly Scan Questions,
Answer Choices and Paragraphs for Words and Ideas. The key to Scanning is to
NOT READ. Instead, Look.
When readers scan, they look for specific words - Key Words -from an Answer
Choice or Question. These Key Words give the most important information or the
information that makes that answer choice unique (different from the other Answer
Choices).
After they have chosen Key Words from an Answer Choice, go to the Text. Take
their pencil and run it across the sentences of the Text, moving from one word to the
next in each sentence. Their eyes should follow just behind the pencil as it moves
over the words.
As they move the pencil, be looking for the Key Words, or synonyms of the Key
Words, from the Answer Choices. When you find a Key Word from an Answer
Choice, look for Key Words from the Question–are they nearby? If “Yes”, then
that is probably the correct answer.
Another strategy is time management (time limit strategy). Good time management
is essential when taking tests such as TOEFL, TEFL, etc. It is especially true of the
TOEIC test. The time limit strategy is the easiest way to improve TOEIC score. The
strategy involves planning how much time test-takers should spend on each
question and limiting yourself accordingly.
For example, if test-takers had a 10 minute test with a total of 10 questions and each
question was worth 1 point, they should spend about 1 minute on each question. If
they spent 9 minutes doing the first question, they would have less than 1 minute for
the other 9 questions!
By not wasting time on the hard questions, test-takers should have time at the end of
the test to come back and do the rest. It is possible that you may even find hints for
hard questions further on in the test. This strategy is best applied to the TOEIC
Reading section.
12
Forster et al. (1997, p.129) continue to reveal that reading the questions with
carefulness is the first step followed by predicting possible correct answers. The
second step comes to information-identifying skills. In “Strategies 1: Building
TOEIC/TOEFL test-taking skills”, it is pointed out that the questions asked may not
impose as the orderly information in the text. In addition to that, from my teaching
experience, I agree with such researchers in term of wrong answers in TOEIC
reading comprehension which may be resulted in by choosing “too general, too
vague or too specific” answers (p.129).
As Forster et al. (1997, p.9) recommend, answers B and C are the two most popular
answer to questions in TOEIC, so it is worthy to advise students to mark B or C
when they have no idea for the answer to a specific question. Moreover, these
researchers suggest that when students encounter a new word which they have not
seen before, it is better to depend on surrounding words in the sentences for
guessing the new word in the context.
1.5. Study of cognitive processes
Method Description
13
Dialogue This method can be applied for problem-solving tasks which
observation involve dialogue.
Nevertheless, this method has been utilized in a number of second language studies
to investigate students’ test-taking strategies (Wu, 1998; Weir, Hawkey, Green, &
Devi, 2006; Xiangdong & Chunyan, 2012). To lessen the negative points of the
method, in the current study, the researcher choose to conduct retrospective
interview immediately after the reading process along with the use of action
protocol which, in this case, would be the reading answer sheets, the immediate
products of the reading task, to help the subjects better recall their cognitive
processes while reading.
14
1.6 Summary
To sum up, this chapter provides different current theories of both reading and
sources of reading difficulty in order to give a clear overview on the matter of the
study. The following chapter will deal with the methodology with which the study
was conducted.
15
CHAPTER II: METHODOLOGY
After reviewing a theoretical basis for the study in the previous part, in this chapter,
the researcher will discuss the methodology used to implement the research. The
chapter will cover four major parts, namely, participants, data collection
instruments, data collection procedures, and data analysis procedures.
2.1. Settings
This study was conducted at the Center of Foreign Languages, VMU. At VMU,
students have to take sit for a TOEIC-test which includes Reading and Listening
comprehension for the final examination. Therefore, in each English class, normally
ranging from 25 to 30 students per class, there is a mixture of different students-
that means students came from different departments and levels of English. Often,
students coming from Maritime Economics Department are better in English than
the other Departments, and Navigation students are normally worse. To make the
situation better, CFL held the placement test to classify students into different
levels. Low proficiency students took part in TOEIC Level 1 that TOEIC score
ranged from 200 to 300, high proficiency ones did in TOEIC Level 2 that TOEIC
score ranged from 350 t0 450. At the end of 50 classes, they are asked to sit for a
full TOEIC- based test.
They must get scores of 450 as one of the conditions to graduate. To meet the
requirements for a TOEIC 450 course, students should be at intermediate level of
English in order to catch up with advanced curriculum. However, the English
abilities of students are different, using strategies is the most effective way to get
the score. The subject is mainly taught in formal settings according to the
nationwide course distribution.
2.2. Participants
The number of participants in the study was 100 who had been chosen from 4
TOEIC preparation classes at the CFL. Most of them were second year students in
the academic year 2013-2014 at VMU. They came from different departments at
16
different levels. Most of them were ranging their age from 19 to 20. Of the 100
students, 50 were at elementary level whose current TOEIC band scores ranged
from 200 to 300, attend TOEIC Level 1, the other 50 were at intermediate level
whose TOEIC band scores ranged from 350 to 450, attend TOEIC Level 2. The
band score 450 was then considered as the level border line.
Immediate retrospective interviews will be conducted and audio recorded with the
use of semi-structured guiding questions so that it encourage the participants
express their thoughts while performing reading tasks. The questions will be
changeable in advance but still flexible enough to encourage the participants to talk
of their thinking processes and they will be mostly “what” questions rather than
“why” to enable the participants recall more information relevant to their test-taking
processes (Xiangdong & Chunyan, 2012) and to collect a direct report rather than
just interpretation (Someren, Barnard & Sandberg, 1994).
2.3.1.2. Questionnaire
A questionnaire for students who had finished TOEIC courses (see Appendix 1)
with items relating to the subjects’ strategies , current level of English as well as
their English learning experience will be used to provide the researcher with a
comprehensive knowledge of the subjects’ experience in learning English and their
understanding of different reading strategies. In order to help the participants to
understand the questionnaire completely, Vietnamese was used.
The reading tests include one full TOEIC Reading Test administered by the center
which the researcher learn about the subjects’ current English reading proficiency
marked in accordance with the TOEIC marking scale and two other partial tests.
17
These two tests are carefully chosen from TOEIC Preparation materials so that they
include three parts: Incomplete Sentences, Text Completion, Reading
comprehension.
Also, the test paper with the marks that the subjects make during the reading
process would serve as useful data for further analysis. Every notes or marks on the
paper will be kept to help the researcher trace back the subjects’ cognitive process
as they perform the reading tasks.
The procedures of data collection went through three main phases in chronological
order: delivering questionnaires, holding semi-structured interviews and carrying
out the observations.
120 questionnaires for students were randomly distributed to four classes having
students from different levels in foreign language center at VMU. The reason to
deliver such number of questionnaires was to eliminate the invalid ones and get
back 100 most comprehensible ones, and to avoid losing the questionnaires made by
the students.
On the day of giving questionnaires, the researcher asked for the help of the
teachers teaching those periods to deliver the papers to the students after
introducing the purposes and explaining some necessary information in case of
having any problems. The reason to let the teachers send out the questionnaires was
that under the “authority” of the teachers, students would complete the papers
seriously.
One-by-one interviews for the students were done in their dormitory rooms. The
first part of the interviews was to introduce and establish the close rapport between
the interviewer and the interviewees. Then, the researcher started the interviews and
18
asked the permission to the use of tape-recording along with the confirmation of
confidentiality of the interviews. Under a friendly and open atmosphere, the
respondents were encouraged to express their views and share their opinions
towards the questions raised by the researcher. During the interviews, in addition to
asking for the respondents’ point of views, the researcher also let them chances to
clarify and explain what strategies they used. A part from the use of tape-recording,
the researcher took notes on some important information through the interviews for
the sake of later transcription.
The data collection procedure will include three phases. Firstly, the participants who
are asked to join the research will be informed of the purpose as well as instructed
on the procedure of the study. At this phase, they will also take some reading tasks
and perform pilot immediate retrospection afterwards. At the second phase, they
will do the reading and their immediate retrospection protocol will be collected.
Finally, the transcription phase of data will be conducted.
For the first category, the descriptive statistics of frequency method was employed
to illustrate the most strategically-planned strategies and the most popularly-
exploited practical experience among the students.
For the second category, the researcher also exploited the descriptive statistics
between the reading strategies by high proficiency and low proficiency students.
19
2.3.4. Summary
The second chapter gave a clear view on the methodology of the research including
participants, data collection instruments, data collection procedure and data analysis
procedure. Based on the aims of the study, using triangulation of questionnaires,
observations and semi-structured interviews was considered as the best choice to
collect the thorough and in-depth information from the respondents and can make
the data gained afterward reliable and comprehensive. All of those findings are as
follow in the next chapter.
20
CHAPTER III: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The data, after being collected from the questionnaires, the observations, and the
semi-structured interviews, would be analyzed and interpreted to answer the two
research questions.
The results collected from 100 students towards the first research question are
conveyed into figures and tables as follows:
13%
Single passages
Double passages
87%
The above figure is showing whether single passages or double passages should be
completed first. And as can be seen it shows that Single Passages are much more
paid attention. In 100%, 87% chose to work on single passages first. The most
convincing reason for students’ strategies of doing single passages before double
passages displayed in the 3rd figure. It was sad to say that the percentage got by the
21
Double Passages is only 13% because students do not give much more focus if there
are lots of passages to read. Thirteen of 100 students who chose double passage to
exploit first have the same opinion that “Double passages take more time to do than
single passages. However, we can answer effectively when we have strong interest
and careful attention”. The other part of students liked to do single passages which
are both shorter and easier. One student added to the interview “In order to get high
score and greater fulfillment of test, test-takers must follow the order of completion
and time allowed as they had experienced”.
15%
SP are short and easy
8%
SP are familiar
As seen from the figure 3, it further indicates that in a percentage of 100% students
top reason in reading single passages is that Single Passages are short and easy so
that is why it got a big part of this section with a percentage of 64%, second reason
is Single Passages are familiar so that is why it got a percentage of 15%, third
reason is Single Passages have fewer questions so in this part it got a percentage of
13%. And the very last reason is that Students can use reading strategies better so
that is why it only got a percentage of 8%.
22
In this case students’ comprehension ability can only fall under single passages and
that is why students give much more attention and focus in single passages than to
double passages.
23
seen in this table Memorandum is the lowest percentage in this table with a
percentage of 4%, and the last but definitely not the least in Type of Topic Texts is
the News and Article with a percentage of 14%.
39%
Bottom -up approach
Interactive approach
43%
The figure above is the “Reading Approach” it shows and indicates the different
approaches used in reading a particular text. The biggest part of this section got a
highest percentage of 43% and that is the Bottom-up Approach. This approach is
much used by the students is that because it was from part to whole meaning
students wants to read a certain text part by part before they go to whole story of the
text, next to that is Interactive Approach with a percentage of 39% and the second
to the highest percentage in this section. This approach means that students give sort
of focus using this approach maybe because there is some cases that the story that
they read is much needed to use both Top-down and Bottom-up approach. Lastly,
the lowest part of this section is the Top-down approach with a percentage of only
18% is that because some students cannot easily understand a certain text or story if
24
the teacher started to discuss the story from whole to part of a particular story or
text.
In this case teacher must be aware of the reading approach that they are going to use
in dealing with a certain texts or stories.
In section A, students always and often read questions before reading text. Being
interviewed, these students said that they could focus on what they needed to read
and save time to do the tasks. As you can see in section B, only six percent of
students always read instruction to know reading passage types and question
numbers first while 39 percent students never did. One student revealed that she had
25
known the instruction so it was waste of time doing that. The number of students
sometimes read the instruction to know reading passage types and question numbers
is 45%, they answered that it was not necessary to read because the instructions in
TOEIC tests are the same. In section C, half of students never adjust structures to
know the organization of reading texts, they said: “It’s no use adjusting structures to
know the organization of reading text”. Next, Section D are the same as C. Look at
section E, nearly three-forth often and always classify question types to arrange in
order of priority, only four percent of students never do this. One of the students
who belonged to category always answered: “Classify question types is extremely
necessary, it plays an important role in doing test. When you classify well, your
choice will be correct. And in our class, our teacher focused in this lesson”. In
contrast to section E, more than three-forth students never or sometimes watch out
too general, too vague or too specific answers. In fact, researcher observed in test
room, students had to control the time doing test and they had no time to evaluate
whether the answers were general, vague, specific or not. Finally, over a half of
students sometimes choose B or C if they can’t find the answer while one-forth
never do this. One student said: “In case of doing nothing, I choose B or C because
our teacher advised to do that”.
26
As can be seen in table 3, the most frequently used strategy is skimming the text for
general information, three interviewed students answered: “Our teachers advised us
to use all reading strategies and we think skimming and scanning are the most
important to all reading passages. In TOEIC class, we are taught all strategies but
some of them such as guessing new words in the context and summarizing the
content of the texts are too difficult for us to follow, that is the reason why these
strategies are rarely used”.
Are there any differences in reading strategies among high proficiency and low
proficiency students at Vietnam Maritime University?
94%
80%
Low proficiency
High Proficiency
20%
6%
27
passages. However, students who chose double passages are very good at English
and they didn’t mind any types of exercises.
80%
68%
70%
60%
60%
50%
40%
Low proficiency
30%
High Proficiency
20% 16% 14% 16%
10% 10%
10% 6%
0%
SP are short and SP have fewer Sts can use SP are familiar
easy questions reading strategies
better
It can be seen from the above figure, there’re only a few differences between two
groups. It further indicates the students top reasons is that SP are short and easy so it
gains a percentage of 60% as Low Proficiency and 68% as High Proficiency. The
lowest reason is Sts can use reading strategies better and this only gain a percentage
of 10% as Low Proficiency and 6% as High Proficiency.
3.2.2. Types of Topic Texts often exploited by Low Proficiency and High
Proficiency Students
28
Advertisement 30% 42%
Memorandum 6% 2%
News and Article 18% 10%
Table 4: Types of Topic Texts often exploited by Low Proficiency and High
Proficiency Students
The above table clearly indicates the different types of topic text, Letter is the
highest percentage in this table with 46% as Low Proficiency but the High
Proficiency got a percentage of 40% and it is second to the highest in High
Proficiency, the highest percentage in this table as high proficiency was
advertisement 42% and 30% as low Proficiency. Memorandum got a percentage of
6% as Low Proficiency and 2% as High Proficiency and the lowest percentage of all
the percent in High Proficiency.
50%
46%
44%
45% 42%
40%
35% 32%
30%
26%
25% Low proficiency
15%
10%
10%
5%
0%
Top-down approach Bottom-up apprach Interactive approach
29
comprehension. Nearly half of students at TOEIC Level 2 use interactive approach
because they said “It is complex skill and useful for doing reading comprehension.
Both groups share the common thing in Bottom-up Approach.
30
The previous chapters have already introduced the general introduction, provided
the theoretical background, justified the methods, and analyzed and discussed the
findings of the study. This chapter, serving as the conclusion of the whole research,
will cover summaries of the major findings, pedagogical suggestions for bettering
students’ TOEIC reading results, limitations of the study and recommendations for
further studies.
With an aim to find the answers for the two research questions set at the beginning
of the study, the data from questionnaires, observations, and semi-structure
interviews were involved to draw the conclusion.
1.1. Which test-taking techniques became more effective for TOEIC Reading
Comprehension test to the students at Vietnam Maritime University?
The first research question showed that the majority of TOEIC strategies that
students often exploit. The findings from the questionnaire demonstrated that the
TOEIC learners had habit of finishing single passages before double passages as a
consequence of the fact that single passages were short, easy and could bring the
sense of speedy completion.
Concerning the reading approach, bottom-up approach is the most frequently used.
In term of strategies towards the TOEIC reading texts, over 70% students “always”
or often read questions before looking at the texts and classifying question types to
arrange in order of priority. The other strategy got strong agreements among
students were to classify question types to arrange in order of priority.
Finally, skimming the text for general information and scanning the text for
specific information are the best regarded strategies.
31
1.2. What are differences in reading strategies among high proficiency and low
proficiency students at Vietnam Maritime University?
There are small differences in reading strategies among high proficiency and low
proficiency.
In terms of priority of reading passage, top priority in reading passages is fall under
the Single Passages with a percentage of 94% as Low Proficiency and 80% as High
Proficiency. Students are afraid of texts that have more passages. However, students
who chose double passages are very good at English and they did not mind any
types of exercises. The high proficiency students tend to choose long, complex
passages while the low ones like to do simple and easy passages.
The second comparison is types of topic texts often exploited, both groups shared
the common opinion, the difference is only a little bit.
The last but definitely not the least, the use of skimming and scanning, while high
proficiency group most frequently used skimming for general information, low level
group liked to use scanning for specific information.
2. Pedagogical implications
The previous parts showed that VMU students use strategies in reading TOEIC
tests; hence, this part was done to propose some implications for bettering the
situation. These implications fall into three categories, namely, implications for
teachers, implications for students, implications for test-designers.
32
2.1. Implications for teachers
The study found that most of the students were afraid of TOEIC reading test and
they normally did not have good strategies when doing such kind of test. Therefore,
in the period of studying English, teachers should guide students about the format of
the tests as well as the tactics to do the test well. Apart from helping students get
familiar with the test, teachers should spend time letting students practice it as much
as possible.
With the problems of fast speed during the reading, it is advised to let students
practice read as much as possible. Particularly, with the improvement of language
ability such as good grammar and rich vocabularies, the students can deal with the
problem of speed, which was also agreed by Buck (2001).
There is no doubt that the role of teachers in helping the students to overcome their
difficulties in achieving better TOEIC reading results is very important; however,
there will not have perfect results if the students themselves do nothing. Together
with teachers’ help, students should try their best to practice what teachers provide.
33
Moreover, for the purpose of familiarizing the students with a rich of variety of
reading text such as manual, memorandum, notice which were not popular to
students.
In addition to that, it is vital for them to self study effectively by seeking for
reliable references. It is great that there is a variety of hard references available as
learners can look for these following TOEIC sources to improve their skills.
Apart from the recommendations for the study, the TOEIC-based reading test itself
also needs adjustment. Since many of the students claimed for the difficult level of
the test, the teachers should make it easier for the students and raise the difficulty
level by level.
After completing the study, there still exist a number of limitations regardless of the
contribution of time and effort.
On the first place, the limited number of participants with only 100 students could
not best represent for the whole second students at VMU, hence the reliability and
validity of the general conclusion could be affected.
It is obvious that there are numerous factors that could influence the process of
TOEIC reading as well as the final reading result; therefore, it was hard to point out
all the elements contributed due to the time constraints.
Under the light of limitations exposed, some recommendations for further related
research could be made.
34
Being aware of the restriction on the number of participants, the future related
studies should involve a larger number of them to confirm the validity as well as
reliability. Moreover, if possible, further studies should focus on certain levels of
the students to find out their real difficulties and their needs for improving their
reading results. Apart from focusing on the 2nd students, these studies could widen
the scope of the research to the superior students of the third year, for example. In
addition, further research on strategies in TOEIC Listening could be a good idea.
35
REFERENCES
36
Harrison, A. (1983). A language Testing Handbook. Essential Language Teaching
Series. MacMillan Press Ltd.
http://www.masterthetoeic.com
Karbalaei, A. (2010). Comparison of Meta cognitive Reading Strategies Used by
EFL and ESL Readers. The Reading Matrix 2010. Vol. 10.
Kamijo, T. (n.d). TOEIC Reading comprehension: Analysis of the texts and
questions, practical application, and its implications. Retrieved 25th May,
2013 from
http://www.ritsumei.ac.jp/acd/ac/itl/outline/kiyo/kiyo10/11_kamijo.pdf
Karn, R&Forster, D. (1998). Teaching TOEIC, TOEFL test taking strategies.
Seattle, WA: TESOL 98:32nd Annual Convention and Exposition, p.3
Long, N.D. (2013). An exploratory study on the teaching and learning of TOEIC
reading comprehension skills at Equest Academy. Hanoi University of
Languages and International Studies.
Lougheed, L (2007a). Longman Prepared series for TOEIC Test – Introductory
Course. New York: Pearson Education, Inc.
Lougheed, L (2007b). Longman Prepared series for TOEIC Test – Intermediate
Course. New York: Pearson Education, Inc.
Lougheed, L (2012). Barron’s TOEIC , 5th Edition. Barron’s Educational Series Inc.
Compass Publishing
Mokhtari, K. & Reichard, C. A. (2002). Assessing Students’ Metacognitive
Awareness of Reading Strategies. Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol.
94, No. 2, 249-259.
Nunan, D. (1991). Language Teaching Methodology. Prentice Hall International
Ltd.
Oxford, R. L. (1990). Language Learning Strategies: What every teacher should
know. New York: Newbury House.
37
Ruiqi, Z. (2007). The impact of reading purposes on text processing strategies.
Selected papers from the 4th International Conference on ELT in China.
China: Foreign Language Teaching and Research Press.
Samuel, S. and Kamil, M. (1988). Models of the Reading Process. Interactive
Approaches to Second Language Reading. CUP.
Sedita, J. (2001). What every Educator and Parent Should Know about Reading
Instruction. The Journal, Vol.11, No. 4, LDAM of Massachusetts. Updated in
2008.
Sheorey R & Mokhtari, K. (2001). Differences in the metacognitive awareness of
reading strategies among native and nonnative readers.
Smith, F. (1973). Understanding Reading: A Psycholinguistic Analysis of Reading
and Learning to Read.
Someren, N. W., Barnard, Y. F. and Sandberg, J. A. (1994). The think aloud
method: A practical guide to modeling cognitive processes. Academic Press,
London.
Stanovich, K. E. (1980). Toward an Interactive-Compensatory Model of Individual
Differences in the Development of Reading Fluency. Reading Research
Quarterly 16 (1), p. 32-71.
Stathopoulou, M. & Nikaki, D. (2009). Test-taking strategies in the KPG Reading
Test: Instrument construction and investigation results. Journal of Applied
Linguistics 25
Tarone, E. (1983). Some thoughts on the notion of “communication strategy”. In C.
Faerch and G. Kasper (eds), Strategies in interlanguage communication.
London: Longman.
Taylor, A. (2006) TOEIC Analyst – 2nd Edition. Compass Publishing
38
Weinstein, C., and Mayer, R. (1986). The Teaching of learning strategies. In
Wittrock, M. C. (ed.). Handbook of research on teaching. Third edition. New
York: MacMillan.
Whitney, P. & Budd, D. (1996). Think aloud protocols and the study of
comprehension. Discourse Processes.
Widdowson, H. G. (1987). Teaching Language as Communication. OUP. 1983.
Learning Purpose and Language Use. OUP.
Wilson, M.K. (2000). An Exploratory Dimensionality Assessment of the TOEIC
Test. ETS Research Report, NJ: Educational Testing Service.
Xiangdong, G & Chunyan, S. (2012). A retrospective study on Test-takers’
cognitive and Metacognitive Processes in Taking a Compound Dictation
Test. Chinese Journal of Applied Linguistic. Vol. 35. No. 4.
39
APPENDIX 1: PHIẾU ĐIỀU TRA DÀNH CHO HỌC VIÊN
Tôi là Nguyễn Thị Thi, giáo viên Trung tâm Ngoại ngữ Hàng hải, Trường Đại học
Hàng hải Việt Nam. Tôi đang thực hiện một nghiên cứu về chiến lược đọc hiểu
TOEIC (Full-Test) dưới sự hướng dẫn của TS. Nguyễn Thị Ngọc Quỳnh. Mong
các em dành chút thời gian trả lời các câu hỏi trong phiếu điều tra này.
Hiện tại em đang học lớp nào: TOEIC Level 1 TOEIC Level 2
Cách sử dụng chiến lược trong việc làm bài thi đọc hiểu TOEIC và sự khác nhau
trong việc sử dụng chiến lược làm bài thi giữa các sinh viên trình độ Elementary
với các sinh viên trình độ Intermediate.
I
4. Tại sao em lại chọn làm những đoạn văn đơn trước?
A Ngắn, đơn giản
B Số câu hỏi ít nên trả lời nhanh
C Có thể dùng kĩ năng đọc tốt hơn
D Quen thuộc với em
5. Tại sao em lại chọn làm những đoạn văn đôi trước?
A Câu hỏi dễ hơn
B Nhiều câu hỏi nên được nhiều điểm
C Có thể dùng kĩ năng đọc tốt hơn
D Quen thuộc với em
6. Khi làm bài đọc hiểu, em:
Học viên vào 1 trong 4 cột bên cạnh tương ứng N S O A
A Đọc câu hỏi trước khi đọc bài đọc
B Phân loại câu hỏi từ dễ đến khó để đọc
C Đánh giá cấu trúc, bố cục bài đọc trước khi đọc
D Khoanh vùng từ đồng nghĩa với từ chính trong câu
để sàng lọc đáp án
E Sử dụng phương pháp loại trừ
F Cảnh giác với câu trả lời “quá chung chung”, “quá
cụ thể” đối với câu hỏi nội dung chung của đoạn
đọc hiểu
G Sẽ chọn đáp án B hoặc C nếu không biết chọn đáp
án nào
Ghi chú: N= chưa bao giờ (0%), S= đôi khi (30%), O= thường (70%), A= liên
tục (100%)
II
7. Các em thường sử dụng kĩ năng đọc nào dưới đây?
A Đọc lướt để lấy thông tin chung, hiểu chủ đề
B Đọc quét để lấy thông tin chi tiết
C Đoán từ mới trong văn cảnh
D Đoán nội dung của bài đọc
E Đọc nhanh để trả lời nhanh
F Tóm tắt nội dung bài đọc
III
APPENDIX 1: SURVEY QUESTIONAIRE FOR STUDENTS
I am Nguyễn Thị Thi, a teacher of English at Vietnam Maritime University. In
support of Dr. Nguyễn Thị Ngọc Quỳnh, I am conducting a research on TOEIC
Reading Comprehension Strategies. I would like to ask for your help in
participating in the interview.
You are in class: TOEIC Level 1 TOEIC Level 2
Regarding strategies in taking TOEIC reading comprehension and
differences between the reading strategies employed by high proficiency and
low proficiency students.
1. Which types of reading text below do you often read to practice TOEIC
reading comprehension?
A. Report E. Manual
B. Letter F. Advertisement
C. Form G. Memorandum
D. Notice H. News and Article
IV
4. What are your reasons of reading single passages first?
A Single passages are short and simple.
B There are fewer questions in single passages.
C I can use reading skills better.
D Single passages are familiar with me.
5. What are your reasons of reading double passages?
A Double passages’ questions are easier
B Double passages have more questions, it means more points.
C I can use reading skills better.
D Double passages are familiar with me.
6. When I practice reading comprehension, I:
Students mark in one of four columns N S O A
A Read questions before looking at the texts
B Read instruction to know reading passage types and
question numbers
C Adjust structures/patterns to know the organization
of reading texts.
D Watch out synonyms or paraphrases and implied
answers
E Classify question types to arrange in order of
priority
F Watch out too general, too vague or too specific
answers
G Choose B/C if I can’t find the answer.
Note: N= never (0%), S= sometimes (30%), O= Often (70%), A= always
(100%)
V
7. What reading strategies do you use in taking test?
A Skimming the text for general information
B Scanning the text for specific information
C Guessing new words in the context
D Predicting the content of the texts
E Reading quickly to answer quickly
F Summarizing the content of the texts.
VI
APPENDIX 2: SEMI-STRUCTURED INTERVIEW QUESTIONS
A. Brief Introduction
VII
APPENDIX 3: SAMPLE OF TOEIC READING COMPREHENSION
FOCUS ADVERTISEMENT
Skimming and scanning are good strategies for reading
advertisements. You will quickly look for the answers to these
questions:
What is being advertised?
Who is it for?
Reading fast is a very important skill to develop. Reading every
word in an advertisement is not necessary. When you skim
advertisements for the general idea and scan them for specific
information, you will learn to read faster.
Advertisement 1
Sale! Sale! Sale!
McGruder’s Department Store announces its biggest sale of the
year. You’ll find fantastic savings throughout the store.
VIII
SCANNING Mark the words that appear in the ad, and circle them in the ad
3. (A) bathing suit (B) business suit
4. (A) summer (B) winter
5. (A) department (B) apartment
6. Find and circle these days in the ad. Some may appear more than once.
Monday Saturday Sunday
CONTEXT Find these words and phrases, and guess their meanings in this advertisement.
7. What does “25% off” mean?
(A) It costs $25
(B) It costs one quarter less than the usual price.
8. What does “Now through Saturday” mean?
(A) Beginning today and ending on Saturday
(B) Beginning on Saturday
READING COMPREHENSION Mark the best answer.
9. What is not on sale? 10. What is the first day of the sale?
(A) Men’s shoes (A) Today
(B) Women’s business suits (B) On Saturday
(C) Men’s summer clothes (C) On Sunday
(D) Women’s shoes (D) Next week
11. How much do women’s summer clothes 12. The word “Mall” in the line 12 is closest
cost? in meaning to
(A) $50 each (A) Shopping area
(B) $50 less than the usual price (B) Parking lot
(C) Half the usual price (C) Food stall
(D) One quarter of the usual price (D) Pedestrian track
TYPES OF ADVERTISEMENTS
Products
Job openings
Events
TYPES OF QUESTIONS
GENERAL QUESTIONS
DETAILED QUESTIONS
IX
TACTIC PRACTICE
For your convenience,
There will be food, music, and a variety of entertainment activities for the whole family.
Representatives of local TV station WXYZ will be there to report on the event. So come on by and
bring the whole family. Customer service specialists will be on hand to explain all the services our
bank has to offer.
Find out about:
The special benefits of opening a State Street checking or savings account
How to qualify for our special low-interest loans.
State Street’s custom-designed financial planning services.
Prizes! Prizes! Prizes!
There will be prizes for the first 50 customers to open a checking or savings account at the new
branch. In addition, all Grand Opening guests will be automatically entered in our Grand Prize
Drawing. You could win a Caribbean Cruise for two!
See you there!
SKIMMING Look quickly at the advertisement to answer this question.
1. What kind of information does this advertisement give?
(A) A list of things for sale
(B) An explanation of an event
SCANNING Look quickly at the advertisement to answer these questions.
2. What is the name of the bank?
(A) State Street Bank
(B) City Bank
3. What is the name of the airport?
(A) City Airport
(B) Bank Street Airport
4. What hours do you see in the advertisement?
X
(A) 1:00-4:00 A.M.
(B) 1:00-4:00 P.M.
CONTEXT Find these words and phrases and guess their meanings in this advertisement.
5.Branch 6. Grand opening
(A) Part of a tree (A) A special celebration for a new business
(B) A business location (B) The hours that a bank does business
XI
READING COMPREHENSION
Mark the best answer
1. What kind of position is advertised?
(A) Director of Human Resources
(B) Lawyer
(C) Administrative assistant
(D) Computer programmer
2. What is one skill required for this job?
(A) The ability to talk pleasantly on the telephone
(B) The ability to write legal documents
(C) The ability to develop computer programs
(D) The ability to find new clients
3. What is a benefit of this job?
(A) They will pay for your vacation expenses.
(B) You can make all the phone calls you want.
(C) You only have to work from 10-4.
(D) They will pay for your health insurance.
4. The word “Duties” in line 8 is closest in meaning to
(A) Taxes
(B) Benefits
(C) Classes
(D) Responsibilities
EXTRA PRACTICE
XII
2. How can you get a free notebook?
(A) Pay one dollar
(B) spend $25 on computer paper
(C) buy colored envelopes
(D) Buy five notebooks
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. When is the sale?
(A) All weekend
(B) On Sunday only
(C) All week
4. On Saturday only What is this ad for?
(A) an airline
(B) a travel agency
(C) a vacation place
(D) a sports club
5. What is one thing you cannot do at
Sea Island Resort?
(A) swim
(B) play tennis
(C) eat
(D) play golf
6. The word “private” in line 5 is closest in meaning to
(A) not public
(B) large
(C) sandy
(D) personal
7. How can you make reservations for Sea Island Resort?
(A) Call a travel agent
(B) Write a letter to the resort owner
(C) Call the airport
(D)
Identifying the passage that contains the keywords/ the information needed
XV
APPENDIX 4: THÔNG BÁO TUYỂN SINH LỚP TOEIC
*Mức học phí phụ thuộc vào trình độ đầu vào của sinh viên:
Khóa học Trình độ đầu vào Thời gian Điểm đầu ra Học phí
TOEIC Level 1 Elementary 100h 350+ 2.900.000đ
TOEIC Level 2 Pre-Intermediate 100h 450+ 2.900.000đ
TOEIC S
XVI
APPENDIX 5: READING STRATEGIES
XVII