Liquid Level Measurement

WHITE PAPER
Level Measurement
Lee Hamlett, Charles Pate, Gaku Okazaki
Yokogawa Corporation of America
Level Measurement
Level measurement is one of the more essential measurements in a process. Incorrect measurements
can cause tanks to overflow creating potential safety or environmental problems; or, low levels can
cause pump damage. Even incorrect intermediate levels can result in an inferior quality product.
Whether the application is for monitoring or control, the level measurement needs to be accurate and
repeatable. Today there is a host of different measurement technologies designed to track the level
in a tank. There are direct measurement technologies such as ultrasonic, radar, or float; and indirect
measurement technologies such as weight and differential pressure. All of these technology groups have
contact and non-contact devices. There is not one ‘silver bullet’ technology; all have their advantages and
disadvantages. So, there is a lot to consider when selecting a level measurement device.
by Lee Hamlett, Charles Pate, Gaku Okazaki

Yokogawa Corporation of America
Introduction transmitter can measure the height from a reference

This paper covers one of those technologies: differential surface to the boundary surface if the density of
pressure (DP) level transmitters. A DP level transmitter the liquid remains constant. The relationship can be
uses the head pressure and specific gravity of the media expressed mathematically using the formula:
to infer the level in the vessel. It is a widely-used level
Level = pressure measured / specific gravity of the liquid
technology having the advantage of being based on a
well-understood principle. It is an excellent selection
for clean liquids but also works well with viscous liquids Diaphragm Seal System
and slurry/sludge; but, is not recommended for solids. One solution for the installation and corrosive questions
The disadvantage is the limited temperature operating is to add a diaphragm seal system to the transmitter.
envelope of the transmitter. Adding a remote diaphragm This system introduces different wetted materials that
seal system to the DP transmitter overcomes this are more resistant to a corrosive liquid. The system can
limitation. also help with installation with large tanks. However,
diaphragm seals attached via capillaries use fill fluid to
DP Level Measurement transmit the pressure from the process to the sensor; the
fill fluid causes ambient and process temperature effects
Level is a measure of the position of the boundary
to be higher. Ambient and process temperature drift are
surface between a liquid and gas. The DP level pressure
two ways temperature changes can affect the unit.
Fig. 1: A simple open tank configuration. However, in practice, there are many application characteristics to consider when designing a DP level system. How will it be
installed? Is the liquid corrosive? What is the temperature of the liquid? Process temperature? Ambient temperature?
www.yokogawa.com
Ambient Temperature Drift
Ambient temperature is
the temperature around
the process. With a tank
located outdoors, the transmitter
and capillary system could see
temperature swings day-to-night,
season-to-season, or even
shady-to-sunny. This change
in temperature affects the fill
fluid just like any liquid. The fluid
contracts and expands within
the capillary with the change
causing inaccuracy in the Fig. 2: An example of a
reading. The reading reflects a tank with direct sun on
the top connection point
change in the fill fluid instead of
and the transmitter in
an actual change in the level. shade (Sunny-to-Shady).
This causes a temperature
imbalance yielding what
Process Temperature Drift appears to be drift in the
level measurement.
Process temperature drift
is similar to the ambient
temperature drift except that temperature influence
comes from the process itself. The temperature of Dual Compensating Capillary Design
the process conducts through the metal diaphragm
This design balances the volume and ambient
into the fill fluid, thus, causing the same contraction/
temperature of the fill fluids between high and low-
expansion as ambient temperature changes - again
pressure side capillaries just like the design mentioned
causing inaccuracy in the reading. The reading reflects a
above; but, the compensation capillaries also connect
change in the fill fluid instead of an actual change in the
into a compensation chamber that is the same
level. This effect is especially prevalent with unbalanced
volume as the main chamber in each diaphragm seal.
systems (one capillary is longer than the other). The
A temperature conductive plate between the main
longer capillary equalizes to a specific temperature, while
chamber and compensation chamber exposes the
the shorter would not be able to equalize at the same
same process temperature changes to both chambers
temperature. The unbalanced temperature causes level
balancing the entire system - reducing the influence of
measurement inaccuracy.
process temperature in the level measurement.
Yokogawa Solutions This solution reduces the influence of ambient

temperature drift and process temperature drift. Apply
Compensating Capillary Design this design to applications where the influence of both
Much like a compensation leg of a 3-wire RTD, this design impacts the ability of the DP pressure transmitter to
has a compensating capillary ‘leg’ to help balance the measure level accurately.
volume and temperature of the fill fluids between the
high-pressure and low-pressure side in an unbalanced
design.
This design is unbalanced because the high-pressure

side seal is directly mounted to the transmitter and the
low-pressure side seal is mounted to the transmitter via
a capillary. The compensation capillary is attached to
the high-pressure side of the transmitter and bundled
along with the low-pressure capillary. The compensation
capillary equalizes the volume of fill fluid between the
two sides of the transmitter; thus, allowing for ambient
temperature balance between them.
This solution reduces the influence of ambient

temperature drifts whether caused by swings day-to-
night, season-to-season, or shady-to-sunny; but, where
the influence of process temperature drift would not
exist or is at a minimum.
www.yokogawa.com
Conclusion
Whether the application is for monitoring or for control, Although the explanation of the technology was
the level measurement needs to be accurate and simplified here, these designs and manufacturing
repeatable. Differential pressure level transmitters are techniques make the Yokogawa compensating capillary
a well-understood technology for getting this done. level transmitters a distinctive solution in the market.
However, temperature influence can make the reading
seem to drift. At Yokogawa we continue to listen to customers’
concerns to strengthen and develop our ability to
Yokogawa has introduced two compensating capillary respond to their diversifying application needs.
designs to minimize this influence in extreme conditions.
Yokogawa Corporation of America Yokogawa Canada, Inc. Yokogawa de Mexico, SA de CV

12530 W. Airport Blvd., Bay 4, 11133 40th Street SE, Urbina No. 18
Sugar Land, TX 77478 Calgary, AB T2C 2Z4 Parque Industrial Naucalpan
Naucalpan de Juarez, Estado de México
C.P. 53370
yokogawa.com/us yokogawa.com/ca yokogawa.com/mx
The contents of this document are subject to change without prior notice. All rights reserved. Copyright © 2017 Yokogawa Corporation of America.
[Ed:02] PROD#:2018-01-2360 Printed in USA
www.yokogawa.com

Liquid Level Measurement

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Liquid Level Measurement

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Liquid Level Measurement

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

WHITE PAPER

by Lee Hamlett, Charles Pate, Gaku Okazaki

Introduction transmitter can measure the height from a reference

Yokogawa Solutions This solution reduces the influence of ambient

This design is unbalanced because the high-pressure

This solution reduces the influence of ambient

Yokogawa Corporation of America Yokogawa Canada, Inc. Yokogawa de Mexico, SA de CV

You might also like