Cheung 2010
Cheung 2010
Cheung 2010
The present meta-analysis aimed to determine the outcomes and effect on right ventricular
(RV) function of surgical pulmonary valve replacement (PVR) in patients after repair of
tetralogy of Fallot. The reported outcomes of surgical PVR in children and adults after
tetralogy of Fallot repair were from relatively small observational studies. The PubMed
database was searched from its inception to April 2009. Observational studies reporting on
the following outcomes measures after surgical PVR were reviewed: early and late all-cause
mortalities, the redo-PVR rate, and changes in the indexed RV volumes, ejection fraction,
and QRS duration after PVR. Of the 305 citations screened, 15 met the criteria and were
analyzed. The pooled early mortality rate (n ⴝ 595) was 2.1% (95% confidence interval [CI]
1.1% to 4.0%). The late mortality rate was 0.5%/patient-year (95% CI 0.2% to 0.8%/patient-
year), and the redo-PVR rate was 1.9%/patient-year (95% CI 1.3% to 2.5%/patient-year).
Data on RV volumes and ejection fractions were available from 5 studies (n ⴝ 141). The
pooled mean difference in the indexed RV end-diastolic and end-systolic volume was ⴚ63
ml/m2 (95% CI ⴚ55 to ⴚ72) and ⴚ37 ml/m2 (95% CI ⴚ30 to ⴚ45), respectively. No
significant changes in the pooled mean difference of the RV ejection fraction (95% CI ⴚ1% to
3%) or QRS duration (95% CI ⴚ10 to 1 ms) were observed. In conclusion, surgical PVR in
patients after tetralogy of Fallot repair has been associated with low early and late mortality
and significant decreases in RV volumes but no changes in the RV ejection fraction or QRS
duration. © 2010 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. (Am J Cardiol 2010;106:552–557)
The present meta-analysis was conducted to determine resolved between the 2 reviewers. The full texts of all
the outcomes after surgical pulmonary valve replacement eligible articles were retrieved for detailed review. Addi-
(PVR) and its effect on right ventricular (RV) volumes and tionally, potential relevant studies were identified by a man-
ejection fraction and QRS duration in pediatric and adult ual search of the reference lists of all the eligible studies. If
patient populations after operative “repair” of tetralogy of required, the corresponding authors of the publications were
Fallot (TOF). queried for additional information. In the case of multiple
publications arising from the same patient cohort, the most
Methods recent report was selected.
We performed the present systematic review and meta- The extracted data included the study design, study pe-
analysis using the framework proposed by the Meta-analy- riod, patient demographics, surgical technique, follow-up
sis Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) duration, and outcomes. The outcome measures assessed
group.1 Relevant publications in English were identified by were early and late all-cause mortality, valve complications
searching PubMed (National Library of Medicine) from its and deterioration requiring redo-PVR, changes in QRS du-
inception to April 2009. The terms used for the search were ration, and changes in RV volumes and ejection fractions, as
“tetralogy of Fallot” and “pulmonary valve replacement” or determined by cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging
“homograft” or “autograft” or “Hancock” or “Contegra” or (CMRI). If an outcome parameter was not reported in an
“valved conduit.” Observational studies reporting the out- eligible study, the study was excluded from the analysis of
comes after PVR were included, and case reports and re- that particular parameter. The studies were divided into
view articles were excluded. Studies on percutaneous PVR pediatric (aged ⱕ18 years) and adult (aged ⬎18 years)
were also excluded from the present review because the data according to the mean age at PVR.
on intermediate- and long-term outcomes remain limited. Fixed-effects meta-analyses were performed using the
One of us (EWYC) screened all the abstracts for eligibility, Mantel-Haenszel method. Odds ratios and weighted mean
and a second reviewer (YFC) independently assessed the differences with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were cal-
eligibility for inclusion and exclusion. Disagreements were culated for the binary and continuous variables, respec-
tively. The heterogeneity of the studies was assessed using
Cochran’s Q test and I2 statistic. Funnel plots were con-
Department of Paediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, Queen Mary
structed to evaluate study publication bias. All tests were
Hospital, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, People’s Republic of
China. Manuscript received February 12, 2010; manuscript received and
2-sided, and p ⬍0.05 was considered statistically signifi-
accepted March 22, 2010. cant. The data were analyzed using Review Manager, ver-
*Corresponding author: Tel: (852) 2255-4090; fax: (852) 2553-9491. sion 5.0.18 (Nordic Cochrane Centre, Cochrane Collabora-
E-mail address: [email protected] (Y.-F. Cheung). tion, Copenhagen, Denmark, 2008).
0002-9149/10/$ – see front matter © 2010 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. www.ajconline.org
doi:10.1016/j.amjcard.2010.03.065
Congenital Heart Disease/Meta-Analysis of PVR in Repaired TOF 553
Discussion
To our knowledge, this is the first review and meta-
analysis of the outcomes of surgical PVR in children and
Figure 1. Identification and screening of studies for inclusion in meta- adults after repair of TOF. The pooled data have confirmed
analysis. the low early and late mortality of PVR in both the pediatric
and the adult populations. Although earlier graft deteriora-
tion in younger patients has been an issue of concern,17 the
Results
pooled redo-PVR rate has been apparently lower in the pedi-
A total of 305 studies were identified and screened, of atric than in the adult patients (1.2% vs 2.2%). The interpre-
which 290 were excluded (Figure 1). The characteristics of tation has nonetheless been complicated by multiple types of
the 15 studies2–16 that met the criteria and were included in valved conduits used and the variable duration of follow-up
this review are summarized in Table 1. periods in the different studies.
Of these 15 studies, 13 reported early mortality data (n ⫽ Previous studies have implicated the presence of a
595), 11 reported late mortality data (n ⫽ 559, 2,415 pa- threshold for the RV size above which RV remodeling does
tient-years), 9 reported on patients undergoing redo-PVR not occur after PVR.9,12 Although the reduction of RV size
(n ⫽ 524, 2,283 patient-years), 5 reported on changes in was documented in all the adult2,3,8,9,11–14,16 and pedia-
CMRI-derived RV parameters (n ⫽ 142), and 4 reported on tric5–7,10,15 series, none reported on complete normalization
changes in QRS duration (n ⫽ 213). Because Oosterhof et of the RV end-systolic volume. In contrast, 2 of the 5
al11,12 reported the mortality data and CMRI parameters studies reported on the normalization of the RV end-dia-
separately in 2 publications, both of these studies were stolic volume; both were adult series and had patients with
included. Knirsch et al15 provided data only for RV end- a lower preoperative RV end-diastolic volume (⬍170 ml/
diastolic volume but not RV systolic volume or pulmonary m2).9,13 In a pediatric population, Buechel et al10 reported
regurgitant fraction. that RV remodeling occurred promptly when PVR is per-
Table 2 lists the pooled data on the early mortality, late formed when the RV end-diastolic volume is ⬍150 ml/m2.
mortality, and redo-PVR rates. The pooled early mortality However, the evidence from the present review is insuffi-
rate was 2.1% (95% CI 1.1% to 4.0%). The late mortality cient to suggest that PVR when performed at a younger age
rate was 0.5%/patient-year (95% CI 0.2% to 0.8%), and the guarantees complete RV remodeling.
554 The American Journal of Cardiology (www.ajconline.org)
Table 1
Overview of included retrospective publications
Publication Patients PVR Mean Mean Outcome Parameters Available for Analysis
(n) Types Follow-Up (y) Age (y)
Early Late Redo-PVR CMRI QRS
Mortality Mortality Data Duration
Table 2
Pooled outcomes estimates in adult and pediatric series
Publication Early Mortality (%) Late Mortality (%/patient-year) Redo-PVR (%/patient-year)
Adult series
Yemets et al,2 1997 1.2 (0.2–7.9) 0.6 (0.0–1.3) 1.6 (0.5–2.7)
Discigil et al,3 2001 2.4 (0.3–15.1) 1.8 (0.4–3.3) 2.4 (0.7–4.1)
Borowski et al,8 2004 5.6 (0.8–30.7) 2.1 (0.0–7.9) —
Therrien et al,9 2005 2.8 (0.2–32.2) 1.7 (0.0–6.2) 1.7 (0.0–6.2)
Oosterhof et al,11 2006 0.3 (0.0–4.8) 0.3 (0.0–0.7) 2.4 (1.2–3.6)
Ghez et al,13 2007 2.5 (0.2–29.8) 1.6 (0.0–6.1) 3.3 (0.0–9.7)
Graham et al,14 2008 0.5 (0.0–7.9) 0.7 (0.0–1.7) 3.6 (1.4–5.8)
Meijboom et al,16 2008 2.8 (0.2–32.2) 0.5 (0.0–1.7) —
Pooled adult series 1.8 (0.8–4.1) 0.5 (0.2–0.8) 2.2 (1.5–2.9)
Pediatric series
De Ruijter et al,5 2002 6.3 (0.8–33.5) 1.4 (0.0–4.0) 1.4 (0.0–4.0)
Warner et al,6 2003 1.4 (0.1–18.3) 0.4 (0.0–1.2) 0.8 (0.0–2.0)
Lim et al,7 2004 1.7 (0.0–11.2) 0.3 (0.0–1.3) 4.1 (0.8–7.4)
Buechel et al,10 2005 2.4 (0.2–28.7) — —
Knirsch et al,15 2008 2.9 (0.2–33.6) — —
Pooled pediatric series 2.7 (0.9–7.5) 0.4 (0.0–1.0) 1.2 (0.2–2.2)
Pooled total 2.1 (1.1–4.0) 0.5 (0.2–0.8) 1.9 (1.3–2.5)
Heterogeneity test
Chi-square 5.62 5.64 9.0
p Value NS NS NS
I2 0% 0% 0%
Despite a significant reduction in the RV systolic and Normalization of the ventricular volumes after PVR has
diastolic volumes, the RV ejection fraction remained similar commonly been used as a surrogate end point for improvement
after PVR. In the presence of significant pulmonary regur- in RV function.12 However, excision of the aneurysmal out-
gitation with or without concomitant tricuspid regurgitation, flow during PVR might significantly affect the measured RV
the CMRI-derived RV ejection fraction might overestimate volumes after surgery.19 Furthermore, the implication of fail-
the effective ejection fraction.10,18 By correcting for valvar ure of the normalization of RV volumes after PVR in patients
regurgitation, Vliegen et al18 showed that the RV ejection with TOF remains unclear. Despite the introduction of newer
fraction increased from 25.2% to 43.3% after PVR in 26 echocardiographic techniques such as tissue-Doppler imaging
adults with repaired TOF. Notwithstanding the correction and speckle tracking, which are relatively less load dependent
for valvar regurgitation, the usefulness of the ejection frac- and allow direct evaluation of RV myocardial velocities and
tion as an index of RV systolic function remains debatable deformation,20 –22 the data on the effect of surgical PVR on
given its sensitivity to preload and afterload. these parameters are virtually nonexistent.
Congenital Heart Disease/Meta-Analysis of PVR in Repaired TOF 555
Figure 2. Forest plots showing effect of PVR on (A) indexed RV end-diastolic volume (EDV), (B) indexed RV end-systolic volume (ESV), (C) RV ejection
fraction, (D) pulmonary regurgitant fraction, and (E) QRS duration. (A) ⫽ adult series; (P) ⫽ pediatric series.
556 The American Journal of Cardiology (www.ajconline.org)
Prolongation of the QRS duration has been linked to the 1. Stroup DF, Berlin JA, Morton SC, Olkin I, Williamson GD, Rennie D,
development of ventricular arrhythmias in long-term survi- Moher D, Becker BJ, Sipe TA, Thacker SB; Meta-analysis Of Obser-
vational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) Group. Meta-analysis of
vors of TOF repair23,24 and has been shown to correlate with observational studies in epidemiology: a proposal for reporting. JAMA
the severity of RV dilation.23 A significant reduction in RV 2000;283:2008 –2012.
volumes after PVR has not been associated with concurrent 2. Yemets IM, Williams WG, Webb GD, Harrison DA, McLaughlin PR,
shortening of the QRS duration. The QRS duration has been Trusler GA, Coles JG, Rebeyka IM, Freedom RM. Pulmonary valve
replacement late after repair of tetralogy of Fallot. Ann Thorac Surg
suggested to reflect mainly an abnormality of the RV out-
1997;64:526 –530.
flow rather than that of the RV body in patients with re- 3. Discigil B, Dearani JA, Puga FJ, Schaff HV, Hagler DJ, Warnes CA,
paired TOF.25 Hence, concomitant plication of an aneurysm Danielson GK. Late pulmonary valve replacement after repair of
or infundibulectomy during PVR might counteract the ef- tetralogy of Fallot. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2001;121:344 –351.
fect of the reduction of RV size on the QRS duration.4 4. Therrien J, Siu SC, Harris L, Dore A, Niwa K, Janousek J, Williams
WG, Webb G, Gatzoulis MA. Impact of pulmonary valve replacement
Additionally, RV remodeling after PVR might have in- on arrhythmia propensity late after repair of tetralogy of Fallot. Cir-
volved the body to a greater extent than the outflow, thus culation 2001;103:2489 –2494.
limiting its effect on the QRS duration. 5. de Ruijter FT, Weenink I, Hitchcock FJ, Meijboom EJ, Bennink GB.
It remains uncertain whether PVR per se would reduce Right ventricular dysfunction and pulmonary valve replacement after
the incidence of cardiac arrhythmias. The previously re- correction of tetralogy of Fallot. Ann Thorac Surg 2002;73:1794 –
1800.
ported reduction in the incidence of atrial and ventricular 6. Warner KG, O’Brien PK, Rhodes J, Kaur A, Robinson DA, Payne DD.
tachyarrhythmias after PVR might, in part, have been re- Expanding the indications for pulmonary valve replacement after re-
lated to concurrent intraoperative cryoablation.4 Although a pair of tetralogy of Fallot. Ann Thorac Surg 2003;76:1066 –1071.
reduction of RV volume, an improvement in RV function, 7. Lim C, Lee JY, Kim WH, Kim SC, Song JY, Kim SJ, Choh JH, Kim
surgical removal of scar tissue, and stabilization of the QRS CW. Early replacement of pulmonary valve after repair of tetralogy: is
it really beneficial? Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2004;25:728 –734.
duration after PVR might favorably reduce the propensity 8. Borowski A, Ghodsizad A, Litmathe J, Lawrenz W, Schmidt KG,
for arrhythmias after PVR, additional longitudinal studies Gams E. Severe pulmonary regurgitation late after total repair of
are required to confirm this speculation. Nonetheless, the tetralogy of Fallot: surgical considerations. Pediatr Cardiol 2004;25:
persistence of QRS prolongation despite PVR remains an 466 – 471.
9. Therrien J, Provost Y, Merchant N, Williams W, Colman J, Webb G.
issue of concern. It was shown in a recent study that PVR Optimal timing for pulmonary valve replacement in adults after tetral-
performed in a relatively young patient cohort at a mean age ogy of Fallot repair. Am J Cardiol 2005;95:779 –782.
of 25 years, about 20 years after TOF repair, did not reduce 10. Buechel ER, Dave HH, Kellenberger CJ, Dodge-Khatami A, Pretre R,
the incidence of ventricular tachycardia.26 Berger F, Bauersfeld U. Remodelling of the right ventricle after early
To date, the timing of PVR must still rely primarily on pulmonary valve replacement in children with repaired tetralogy of
Fallot: assessment by cardiovascular magnetic resonance. Eur Heart J
measurement of the RV parameters. Despite documented 2005;26:2721–2727.
left ventricular dysfunction and dyssynchrony secondary to 11. Oosterhof T, Meijboom FJ, Vliegen HW, Hazekamp MG, Zwinder-
RV dilation and ventricular–ventricular interaction in pa- man AH, Bouma BJ, van Dijk AP, Mulder BJ. Long-term follow-up of
tients with repaired TOF,27,28 the parameters of left ventric- homograft function after pulmonary valve replacement in patients with
ular function has not been included in the evaluation of the tetralogy of Fallot. Eur Heart J 2006;27:1478 –1484.
12. Oosterhof T, van Straten A, Vliegen HW, Meijboom FJ, van Dijk AP,
timing and effects of PVR. Recently, an increase in left Spijkerboer AM, Bouma BJ, Zwinderman AH, Hazekamp MG, de
ventricular effective stroke volume was shown after surgical Roos A, Mulder BJ. Preoperative thresholds for pulmonary valve
or percutaneous PVR for predominantly pulmonary regur- replacement in patients with corrected tetralogy of Fallot using car-
gitation and has been suggested as a useful index to assess diovascular magnetic resonance. Circulation 2007;116:545–551.
13. Ghez O, Tsang VT, Frigiola A, Coats L, Taylor A, Van Doorn C,
the success of the procedure.19 Bonhoeffer P, De Leval M. Right ventricular outflow tract reconstruc-
Although the present review focused on surgical PVR, tion for pulmonary regurgitation after repair of tetralogy of Fallot.
the number of patients with congenital heart disease with Preliminary results. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2007;31:654 – 658.
varying degrees of pulmonary regurgitation and/or RV out- 14. Graham TP Jr, Bernard Y, Arbogast P, Thapa S, Cetta F, Child J,
flow obstruction undergoing percutaneous pulmonary valve Chugh R, Davidson W, Hurwitz R, Kay J, Sanders S, Schaufelberger
M. Outcome of pulmonary valve replacements in adults after tetralogy
implantation has been increasing since its introduction.29,30 repair: a multi-institutional study. Congenit Heart Dis 2008;3:162–
Improvement in RV systolic and diastolic function30 has 167.
been reported in these heterogeneous groups of patients. 15. Knirsch W, Dodge-Khatami A, Kadner A, Kretschmar O, Steiner J,
Because the reported series varied in the types of underlying Bottler P, Kececioglu D, Harpes P, Valsangiacomo Buechel ER. As-
sessment of myocardial function in pediatric patients with operated
heart lesions and nature of RV loading, we did not include
tetralogy of Fallot: preliminary results with 2D strain echocardiogra-
them in the present meta-analysis. phy. Pediatr Cardiol 2008;29:718 –725.
The diversity in study designs and differences in the 16. Meijboom FJ, Roos-Hesselink JW, McGhie JS, Spitaels SE, van Dom-
quality of studies is inevitable. Variable indications for PVR burg RT, Utens LM, Simoons ML, Bogers AJ. Consequences of a
and differences in surgical experience at different centers selective approach toward pulmonary valve replacement in adult pa-
tients with tetralogy of Fallot and pulmonary regurgitation. J Thorac
were the major sources of heterogeneity in the present Cardiovasc Surg 2008;135:50 –55.
review. Also, publication bias could not be excluded. All the 17. van der Wall EE, Mulder BJ. Pulmonary valve replacement in patients
studies reporting on CMRI-derived RV volumes and pul- with tetralogy of Fallot and pulmonary regurgitation: early surgery
monary regurgitant fraction showed favorable effects after similar to optimal timing of surgery? Eur Heart J 2005;26:2614 –2615.
PVR. Because only the mid-term outcomes after PVR were 18. Vliegen HW, van Straten A, de Roos A, Roest AA, Schoof PH,
Zwinderman AH, Ottenkamp J, van der Wall EE, Hazekamp MG.
reported in the studies published to date, the long-term Magnetic resonance imaging to assess the hemodynamic effects of
effect of PVR, in particular with regard to the late mortality pulmonary valve replacement in adults late after repair of tetralogy of
and redo-PVR rates, remains to be determined. Fallot. Circulation 2002;106:1703–1707.
Congenital Heart Disease/Meta-Analysis of PVR in Repaired TOF 557
19. Frigiola A, Tsang V, Nordmeyer J, Lurz P, van Doorn C, Taylor AM, repaired tetralogy of Fallot: implications of infundibular disease.
Bonhoeffer P, de Leval M. Current approaches to pulmonary regurgi- Circulation 2007;116:1532–1539.
tation. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2008;34:576 –580. 26. Harrild DM, Berul CI, Cecchin F, Geva T, Gauvreau K, Pigula F,
20. D’Andrea A, Caso P, Sarubbi B, Russo MG, Ascione L, Scherillo M, Walsh EP. Pulmonary valve replacement in tetralogy of Fallot: impact
Cobrufo M, Calabro R. Right ventricular myocardial dysfunction in on survival and ventricular tachycardia. Circulation 2009;119:445–
adult patients late after repair of tetralogy of Fallot. Int J Cardiol 451.
2004;94:213–220. 27. Liang XC, Cheung EW, Wong SJ, Cheung YF. Impact of right ven-
21. Brili S, Alexopoulos N, Latsios G, Aggeli C, Barbetseas J, Pitsavos C, tricular volume overload on three-dimensional global left ventricular
Vyssoulis G, Stefanadis C. Tissue Doppler imaging and brain natri- mechanical dyssynchrony after surgical repair of tetralogy of Fallot.
uretic peptide levels in adults with repaired tetralogy of Fallot. J Am Am J Cardiol 2008;102:1731–1736.
Soc Echocardiogr 2005;18:1149 –1154. 28. Cheung EW, Liang XC, Lam WW, Cheung YF. Impact of right
22. Scherptong RW, Mollema SA, Blom NA, Kroft LJ, de Roos A,
ventricular dilation on left ventricular myocardial deformation in pa-
Vliegen HW, van der Wall EE, Bax JJ, Holman ER. Right ventricular
tients after surgical repair of tetralogy of Fallot. Am J Cardiol 2009;
peak systolic longitudinal strain is a sensitive marker for right ven-
104:1264 –1270.
tricular deterioration in adult patients with tetralogy of Fallot. Int
J Cardiovasc Imaging 2009;25:669 – 676. 29. Lurz P, Coats L, Khambadkone S, Nordmeyer J, Boudjemline Y,
23. Gatzoulis MA, Clark AL, Cullen S, Newman CG, Redington AN. Schievano S, Muthurangu V, Lee TY, Parenzan G, Derrick G, Cullen
Right ventricular diastolic function 15 to 35 years after repair of S, Walker F, Tsang V, Deanfield J, Taylor AM, Bonhoeffer P. Percu-
tetralogy of Fallot: restrictive physiology predicts superior exercise taneous pulmonary valve implantation: impact of evolving technology
performance. Circulation 1995;91:1775–1781. and learning curve on clinical outcome. Circulation 2008;117:1964 –
24. Balaji S, Lau YR, Case CL, Gillette PC. QRS prolongation is associ- 1972.
ated with inducible ventricular tachycardia after repair of tetralogy of 30. Romeih S, Kroft LJ, Bokenkamp R, Schalij MJ, Grotenhuis H,
Fallot. Am J Cardiol 1997;80:160 –163. Hazekamp MG, Groenink M, de Roos A, Blom NA. Delayed improve-
25. Uebing A, Gibson DG, Babu-Narayan SV, Diller GP, Dimopoulos K, ment of right ventricular diastolic function and regression of right
Goktekin O, Spence MS, Andersen K, Henein MY, Gatzoulis MA, Li ventricular mass after percutaneous pulmonary valve implantation in
W. Right ventricular mechanics and QRS duration in patients with patients with congenital heart disease. Am Heart J 2009;158:40 – 46.