Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 31 views

    Moreno Vs Bernabe

    Uploaded by

    Rachel Gee
    Marilou Nama Moreno filed a complaint against Judge Jose C. Bernabe for solemnizing her marriage to Marcelo Moreno without a marriage license. Judge Bernabe claims he acted in good faith as Moreno was pregnant. However, the Supreme Court ruled that a judge violates the law by solemnizing a marriage without a license, and good intentions do not justify legal violations. A judge must uphold the law as an example to others.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Moreno Vs Bernabe

    Uploaded by

    Rachel Gee
    31 views2 pages
    Marilou Nama Moreno filed a complaint against Judge Jose C. Bernabe for solemnizing her marriage to Marcelo Moreno without a marriage license. Judge Bernabe claims he acted in good faith as Moreno was pregnant. However, the Supreme Court ruled that a judge violates the law by solemnizing a marriage without a license, and good intentions do not justify legal violations. A judge must uphold the law as an example to others.

    Original Title

    Moreno vs Bernabe.docx

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Marilou Nama Moreno filed a complaint against Judge Jose C. Bernabe for solemnizing her marriage to Marcelo Moreno without a marriage license. Judge Bernabe claims he acted in good faith as Moreno was pregnant. However, the Supreme Court ruled that a judge violates the law by solemnizing a marriage without a license, and good intentions do not justify legal violations. A judge must uphold the law as an example to others.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    31 views2 pages

    Moreno Vs Bernabe

    Uploaded by

    Rachel Gee
    Marilou Nama Moreno filed a complaint against Judge Jose C. Bernabe for solemnizing her marriage to Marcelo Moreno without a marriage license. Judge Bernabe claims he acted in good faith as Moreno was pregnant. However, the Supreme Court ruled that a judge violates the law by solemnizing a marriage without a license, and good intentions do not justify legal violations. A judge must uphold the law as an example to others.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 2

    Moreno vs.

    Bernabe

    Facts:

    Marilou Nama Moreno filed this complaint against Judge Jose C. Bernabe of the Metropolitan Trial
    Court, Branch 72, Pasig, Metro Manila for grave misconduct and gross ignorance of law.

    October 4, 1993, she and Marcelo Moreno were married before respondent Judge Bernabe.
    She avers that respondent Judge assured her that the marriage contract will be released ten days after
    October 4, 1993. When she visited the office of the Judge, she found out that she could not get the
    marriage contract because the Office of the Local Civil Registrar failed to issue a marriage license. She
    claims that respondent Judge connived with the relatives of Marcelo Moreno to deceive her.

    Respondent denies that he conspired with the relatives of Marcelo Moreno to solemnize the marriage
    for the purpose of deceiving the complainant. Respondent contends that: 1) the Local Civil Registrar of
    Pasig actually prepared the marriage license but it was not released due to the subsequent objection of
    the father of Marcelo Moreno; 2) he, in good faith, solemnized the marriage as he was moved only by a
    desire to help a begging and pleading complainant who wanted some kind of assurance or security due
    to her pregnant condition; 3) in order to pacify complainant, Marcelo Moreno requested him to perform
    the marriage ceremony with the express assurance that the marriage license was definitely forthcoming;
    4) that the contracting parties were not known to him; and 5) that both parties, were fully appraised of
    the effects of a marriage performed without the required marriage license.

    Issue:

    Whether or not respondent be held liable for misconduct for solemnizing a marriage without a marriage
    license.

    Held:

    Respondent, by his own admission that he solemnized the marriage between complainant and Marcelo
    Moreno without the required marriage license, has dismally failed to live up to his commitment to be
    the “embodiment of competence, integrity and independence” and to his promise to be “faithful to the
    law.”

    Respondent cannot hide behind his claim of good faith and Christian motives which, at most, would
    serve only to mitigate his liability but not exonerate him completely. Good intentions could never justify
    violation of the law.

    Judges; Marriages; A judge who solemnizes a marriage without the required marriage license dismally
    fails to live up to his commitment to bethe embodiment of competence, integrity and independence.
    Good intentions could never justify violation of the law.
    The judge must be the first to abide by the law and weave an example for the others to follow.—
    The fact that complainant has lost interest in prosecuting the administrative case against
    a respondent judge will not necessarily warrant dismissal thereof The fact that complainant has lost
    interest in prosecuting the administrative case against herein respondent judge will not necessarily
    warrant a dismissal thereof. Once charges have been filed,the Supreme Court may not be divested of its
    jurisdiction to investigate and ascertain the truth of the matter alleged in the complaint. The Court has
    an interest in the conduct of members of the Judiciary and in improving the delivery of justice to the
    people, and its efforts in that direction may not be derailed by the complainant’s desistance from
    further prosecuting the case he or she initiated.

    You might also like