Attachment Sphread Sheet For Differential Relay Setting of Transformers 87T
Attachment Sphread Sheet For Differential Relay Setting of Transformers 87T
In33kV
(ICTsek33kV) CT Current at 33kVside = =
CT Ratio33kV
839.78
= 0.840 A (CT sekunder)
1000
MVA x 1000
(In11kV) Nominal Current at 11KV= =
√3 X LVside(inkV)
11 x 1000
= 2519.35 A (Primer)
√3 X 11
In11kV
(ICTsek11kV) CT Current at 11kVside = =
CT Ratio11kV
2519.35
= 0.630 A (CT sekunder)
4000
For sensitifity of differential relay at full load condition. Full load current in Transformer at Upstream HV side and Full
load current in Downstream side or LV Side shall be normalize to Nominal CT Current
therfore,
Idiff tresshold = 24.21%
Minimum I diff Treshold Setting = 24.210%
Recommended Idiff Setting 24.21% or 25% (selected)
The setting should be sufficient to compensate for measurement errors caused by current with low but
significant amplitude.
Id/It =
Ids max = maksimum Id (differential current)
It min = Minimum restraint
Id/It = 27.63%
therfore,
Recommended Id/It minimum = 27.63%
Selected Id/It = 30%
800%
700%
600%
500%
Idiff = Ia - ib
400%
Id(treshold)
300%
Id/It
200%
100%
0%
0% 200% 400% 600% 800% 1000% 1200% 1400%
Irestraint = (ia-ib)/2
Setting untuk Penghitungan
Rounding up To 2 Digit
500%
- ib
700%
Idiff = Ia - ib
39% 15%
40% 15% 400%
41% 15%
42% 15%
300%
43% 15%
44% 15%
45% 15% 200%
46% 15%
47% 15%
48% 15% 100%
49% 15%
50% 15%
0%
51% 15% 0% 200% 400%
52% 16%
53% 16%
54% 16%
55% 17%
56% 17%
57% 17%
58% 17%
59% 18%
60% 18%
61% 18%
62% 19%
63% 19%
64% 19%
65% 20%
66% 20%
67% 20%
68% 20%
69% 21%
70% 21%
71% 21%
72% 22%
73% 22% 40%
74% 22% 35%
75% 23%
30%
76% 23%
77% 23% 25%
78% 23% 20%
79% 24%
15%
10%
5%
25%
20%
15%
80% 24%
81% 24% 10%
82% 25% 5%
83% 25%
0%
84% 25% 0% 20% 40%
85% 26%
86% 26%
87% 26%
88% 26%
89% 27%
90% 27%
91% 27%
92% 28%
93% 28%
94% 28%
95% 29%
96% 29%
97% 29%
98% 29%
99% 30%
100% 30%
101% 30%
102% 31%
103% 31%
104% 31%
105% 32%
106% 32%
107% 32%
108% 32%
109% 33%
110% 33%
111% 33%
112% 34%
113% 34%
114% 34%
115% 35%
116% 35%
117% 35%
118% 35%
119% 36%
120% 36%
121% 36%
122% 37%
123% 37%
124% 37%
125% 38%
126% 38%
127% 38%
128% 38%
129% 39%
130% 39%
131% 39%
132% 40%
133% 40%
134% 40%
135% 41%
136% 41%
137% 41%
138% 41%
139% 42%
140% 42%
141% 42%
142% 43%
143% 43%
144% 43%
145% 44%
146% 44%
147% 44%
148% 44%
149% 45%
150% 45%
151% 45%
152% 46%
153% 46%
154% 46%
155% 47%
156% 47%
157% 47%
158% 47%
159% 48%
160% 48%
161% 48%
162% 49%
163% 49%
164% 49%
165% 50%
166% 50%
167% 50%
168% 50%
169% 51%
170% 51%
171% 51%
172% 52%
173% 52%
174% 52%
175% 53%
176% 53%
177% 53%
178% 53%
179% 54%
180% 54%
181% 54%
182% 55%
183% 55%
184% 55%
185% 56%
186% 56%
187% 56%
188% 56%
189% 57%
190% 57%
191% 57%
192% 58%
193% 58%
194% 58%
195% 59%
196% 59%
197% 59%
198% 59%
199% 60%
200% 60%
201% 60%
202% 61%
203% 61%
204% 61%
205% 62%
206% 62%
207% 62%
208% 62%
209% 63%
210% 63%
211% 63%
212% 64%
213% 64%
214% 64%
215% 65%
216% 65%
217% 65%
218% 65%
219% 66%
220% 66%
221% 66%
222% 67%
223% 67%
224% 67%
225% 67%
226% 68%
227% 68%
228% 68%
229% 69%
230% 69%
231% 69%
232% 70%
233% 70%
234% 70%
235% 70%
236% 71%
237% 71%
238% 71%
239% 72%
240% 72%
241% 72%
242% 73%
243% 73%
244% 73%
245% 73%
246% 74%
247% 74%
248% 74%
249% 75%
250% 75%
251% 75%
252% 76%
253% 76%
254% 76%
255% 76%
256% 77%
257% 77%
258% 77%
259% 78%
260% 78%
261% 78%
262% 79%
263% 79%
264% 79%
265% 79%
266% 80%
267% 80%
268% 80%
269% 81%
270% 81%
271% 81%
272% 82%
273% 82%
274% 82%
275% 82%
276% 83%
277% 83%
278% 83%
279% 84%
280% 84%
281% 84%
282% 85%
283% 85%
284% 85%
285% 85%
286% 86%
287% 86%
288% 86%
289% 87%
290% 87%
291% 87%
292% 88%
293% 88%
294% 88%
295% 88%
296% 89%
297% 89%
298% 89%
299% 90%
300% 90%
301% 90%
302% 91%
303% 91%
304% 91%
305% 91%
306% 92%
307% 92%
308% 92%
309% 93%
310% 93%
311% 93%
312% 94%
313% 94%
314% 94%
315% 94%
316% 95%
317% 95%
318% 95%
319% 96%
320% 96%
321% 96%
322% 97%
323% 97%
324% 97%
325% 97%
326% 98%
327% 98%
328% 98%
329% 99%
330% 99%
331% 99%
332% 100%
333% 100%
334% 100%
335% 101%
336% 101%
337% 101%
338% 101%
339% 102%
340% 102%
341% 102%
342% 103%
343% 103%
344% 103%
345% 104%
346% 104%
347% 104%
348% 104%
349% 105%
350% 105%
351% 105%
352% 106%
353% 106%
354% 106%
355% 106%
356% 107%
357% 107%
358% 107%
359% 108%
360% 108%
361% 108%
362% 109%
363% 109%
364% 109%
365% 109%
366% 110%
367% 110%
368% 110%
369% 111%
370% 111%
371% 111%
372% 112%
373% 112%
374% 112%
375% 112%
376% 113%
377% 113%
378% 113%
379% 114%
380% 114%
381% 114%
382% 115%
383% 115%
384% 115%
385% 115%
386% 116%
387% 116%
388% 116%
389% 117%
390% 117%
391% 117%
392% 118%
393% 118%
394% 118%
395% 118%
396% 119%
397% 119%
398% 119%
399% 120%
400% 120%
401% 120%
402% 121%
403% 121%
404% 121%
405% 121%
406% 122%
407% 122%
408% 122%
409% 123%
410% 123%
411% 123%
412% 124%
413% 124%
414% 124%
415% 124%
416% 125%
417% 125%
418% 125%
419% 126%
420% 126%
421% 126%
422% 127%
423% 127%
424% 127%
425% 127%
426% 128%
427% 128%
428% 128%
429% 129%
430% 129%
431% 129%
432% 130%
433% 130%
434% 130%
435% 130%
436% 131%
437% 131%
438% 131%
439% 132%
440% 132%
441% 132%
442% 133%
443% 133%
444% 133%
445% 133%
446% 134%
447% 134%
448% 134%
449% 135%
450% 135%
451% 135%
452% 136%
453% 136%
454% 136%
455% 136%
456% 137%
457% 137%
458% 137%
459% 138%
460% 138%
461% 138%
462% 139%
463% 139%
464% 139%
465% 139%
466% 140%
467% 140%
468% 140%
469% 141%
470% 141%
471% 141%
472% 142%
473% 142%
474% 142%
475% 142%
476% 143%
477% 143%
478% 143%
479% 144%
480% 144%
481% 144%
482% 145%
483% 145%
484% 145%
485% 145%
486% 146%
487% 146%
488% 146%
489% 147%
490% 147%
491% 147%
492% 148%
493% 148%
494% 148%
495% 148%
496% 149%
497% 149%
498% 149%
499% 150%
500% 150%
501% 150%
502% 151%
503% 151%
504% 151%
505% 151%
506% 152%
507% 152%
508% 152%
509% 153%
510% 153%
511% 153%
512% 154%
513% 154%
514% 154%
515% 154%
516% 155%
517% 155%
518% 155%
519% 156%
520% 156%
521% 156%
522% 157%
523% 157%
524% 157%
525% 157%
526% 158%
527% 158%
528% 158%
529% 159%
530% 159%
531% 159%
532% 160%
533% 160%
534% 160%
535% 160%
536% 161%
537% 161%
538% 161%
539% 162%
540% 162%
541% 162%
542% 163%
543% 163%
544% 163%
545% 163%
546% 164%
547% 164%
548% 164%
549% 165%
550% 165%
551% 165%
552% 166%
553% 166%
554% 166%
555% 166%
556% 167%
557% 167%
558% 167%
559% 168%
560% 168%
561% 168%
562% 169%
563% 169%
564% 169%
565% 169%
566% 170%
567% 170%
568% 170%
569% 171%
570% 171%
571% 171%
572% 172%
573% 172%
574% 172%
575% 172%
576% 173%
577% 173%
578% 173%
579% 174%
580% 174%
581% 174%
582% 175%
583% 175%
584% 175%
585% 175%
586% 176%
587% 176%
588% 176%
589% 177%
590% 177%
591% 177%
592% 178%
593% 178%
594% 178%
595% 178%
596% 179%
597% 179%
598% 179%
599% 180%
600% 180%
601% 361%
602% 361%
603% 362%
604% 362%
605% 363%
606% 364%
607% 364%
608% 365%
609% 365%
610% 366%
611% 367%
612% 367%
613% 368%
614% 368%
615% 369%
616% 370%
617% 370%
618% 371%
619% 371%
620% 372%
621% 373%
622% 373%
623% 374%
624% 374%
625% 375%
626% 376%
627% 376%
628% 377%
629% 377%
630% 378%
631% 379%
632% 379%
633% 380%
634% 380%
635% 381%
636% 382%
637% 382%
638% 383%
639% 383%
640% 384%
641% 385%
642% 385%
643% 386%
644% 386%
645% 387%
646% 388%
647% 388%
648% 389%
649% 389%
650% 390%
651% 391%
652% 391%
653% 392%
654% 392%
655% 393%
656% 394%
657% 394%
658% 395%
659% 395%
660% 396%
661% 397%
662% 397%
663% 398%
664% 398%
665% 399%
666% 400%
667% 400%
668% 401%
669% 401%
670% 402%
671% 403%
672% 403%
673% 404%
674% 404%
675% 405%
676% 406%
677% 406%
678% 407%
679% 407%
680% 408%
681% 409%
682% 409%
683% 410%
684% 410%
685% 411%
686% 412%
687% 412%
688% 413%
689% 413%
690% 414%
691% 415%
692% 415%
693% 416%
694% 416%
695% 417%
696% 418%
697% 418%
698% 419%
699% 419%
700% 420%
701% 421%
702% 421%
703% 422%
704% 422%
705% 423%
706% 424%
707% 424%
708% 425%
709% 425%
710% 426%
711% 427%
712% 427%
713% 428%
714% 428%
715% 429%
716% 430%
717% 430%
718% 431%
719% 431%
720% 432%
721% 433%
722% 433%
723% 434%
724% 434%
725% 435%
726% 436%
727% 436%
728% 437%
729% 437%
730% 438%
731% 439%
732% 439%
733% 440%
734% 440%
735% 441%
736% 442%
737% 442%
738% 443%
739% 443%
740% 444%
741% 445%
742% 445%
743% 446%
744% 446%
745% 447%
746% 448%
747% 448%
748% 449%
749% 449%
750% 450%
751% 451%
752% 451%
753% 452%
754% 452%
755% 453%
756% 454%
757% 454%
758% 455%
759% 455%
760% 456%
761% 457%
762% 457%
763% 458%
764% 458%
765% 459%
766% 460%
767% 460%
768% 461%
769% 461%
770% 462%
771% 463%
772% 463%
773% 464%
774% 464%
775% 465%
776% 466%
777% 466%
778% 467%
779% 467%
780% 468%
781% 469%
782% 469%
783% 470%
784% 470%
785% 471%
786% 472%
787% 472%
788% 473%
789% 473%
790% 474%
791% 475%
792% 475%
793% 476%
794% 476%
795% 477%
796% 478%
797% 478%
798% 479%
799% 479%
800% 480%
801% 481%
802% 481%
803% 482%
804% 482%
805% 483%
806% 484%
807% 484%
808% 485%
809% 485%
810% 486%
811% 487%
812% 487%
813% 488%
814% 488%
815% 489%
816% 490%
817% 490%
818% 491%
819% 491%
820% 492%
821% 493%
822% 493%
823% 494%
824% 494%
825% 495%
826% 496%
827% 496%
828% 497%
829% 497%
830% 498%
831% 499%
832% 499%
833% 500%
834% 500%
835% 501%
836% 502%
837% 502%
838% 503%
839% 503%
840% 504%
841% 505%
842% 505%
843% 506%
844% 506%
845% 507%
846% 508%
847% 508%
848% 509%
849% 509%
850% 510%
851% 511%
852% 511%
853% 512%
854% 512%
855% 513%
856% 514%
857% 514%
858% 515%
859% 515%
860% 516%
861% 517%
862% 517%
863% 518%
864% 518%
865% 519%
866% 520%
867% 520%
868% 521%
869% 521%
870% 522%
871% 523%
872% 523%
873% 524%
874% 524%
875% 525%
876% 526%
877% 526%
878% 527%
879% 527%
880% 528%
881% 529%
882% 529%
883% 530%
884% 530%
885% 531%
886% 532%
887% 532%
888% 533%
889% 533%
890% 534%
891% 535%
892% 535%
893% 536%
894% 536%
895% 537%
896% 538%
897% 538%
898% 539%
899% 539%
900% 540%
901% 541%
902% 541%
903% 542%
904% 542%
905% 543%
906% 544%
907% 544%
908% 545%
909% 545%
910% 546%
911% 547%
912% 547%
913% 548%
914% 548%
915% 549%
916% 550%
917% 550%
918% 551%
919% 551%
920% 552%
921% 553%
922% 553%
923% 554%
924% 554%
925% 555%
926% 556%
927% 556%
928% 557%
929% 557%
930% 558%
931% 559%
932% 559%
933% 560%
934% 560%
935% 561%
936% 562%
937% 562%
938% 563%
939% 563%
940% 564%
941% 565%
942% 565%
943% 566%
944% 566%
945% 567%
946% 568%
947% 568%
948% 569%
949% 569%
950% 570%
951% 571%
952% 571%
953% 572%
954% 572%
955% 573%
956% 574%
957% 574%
958% 575%
959% 575%
960% 576%
961% 577%
962% 577%
963% 578%
964% 578%
965% 579%
966% 580%
967% 580%
968% 581%
969% 581%
970% 582%
971% 583%
972% 583%
973% 584%
974% 584%
975% 585%
976% 586%
977% 586%
978% 587%
979% 587%
980% 588%
981% 589%
982% 589%
983% 590%
984% 590%
985% 591%
986% 592%
987% 592%
988% 593%
989% 593%
990% 594%
991% 595%
992% 595%
993% 596%
994% 596%
995% 597%
996% 598%
997% 598%
998% 599%
999% 599%
1000% 600%
1001% 601%
1002% 601%
1003% 602%
1004% 602%
1005% 603%
1006% 604%
1007% 604%
1008% 605%
1009% 605%
1010% 606%
1011% 607%
1012% 607%
1013% 608%
1014% 608%
1015% 609%
1016% 610%
1017% 610%
1018% 611%
1019% 611%
1020% 612%
1021% 613%
1022% 613%
1023% 614%
1024% 614%
1025% 615%
1026% 616%
1027% 616%
1028% 617%
1029% 617%
1030% 618%
1031% 619%
1032% 619%
1033% 620%
1034% 620%
1035% 621%
1036% 622%
1037% 622%
1038% 623%
1039% 623%
1040% 624%
1041% 625%
1042% 625%
1043% 626%
1044% 626%
1045% 627%
1046% 628%
1047% 628%
1048% 629%
1049% 629%
1050% 630%
1051% 631%
1052% 631%
1053% 632%
1054% 632%
1055% 633%
1056% 634%
1057% 634%
1058% 635%
1059% 635%
1060% 636%
1061% 637%
1062% 637%
1063% 638%
1064% 638%
1065% 639%
1066% 640%
1067% 640%
1068% 641%
1069% 641%
1070% 642%
1071% 643%
1072% 643%
1073% 644%
1074% 644%
1075% 645%
1076% 646%
1077% 646%
1078% 647%
1079% 647%
1080% 648%
1081% 649%
1082% 649%
1083% 650%
1084% 650%
1085% 651%
1086% 652%
1087% 652%
1088% 653%
1089% 653%
1090% 654%
1091% 655%
1092% 655%
1093% 656%
1094% 656%
1095% 657%
1096% 658%
1097% 658%
1098% 659%
1099% 659%
1100% 660%
1101% 661%
1102% 661%
1103% 662%
1104% 662%
1105% 663%
1106% 664%
1107% 664%
1108% 665%
1109% 665%
1110% 666%
1111% 667%
1112% 667%
1113% 668%
1114% 668%
1115% 669%
1116% 670%
1117% 670%
1118% 671%
1119% 671%
1120% 672%
1121% 673%
1122% 673%
1123% 674%
1124% 674%
1125% 675%
1126% 676%
1127% 676%
1128% 677%
1129% 677%
1130% 678%
1131% 679%
1132% 679%
1133% 680%
1134% 680%
1135% 681%
1136% 682%
1137% 682%
1138% 683%
1139% 683%
1140% 684%
1141% 685%
1142% 685%
1143% 686%
1144% 686%
1145% 687%
1146% 688%
1147% 688%
1148% 689%
1149% 689%
1150% 690%
1151% 691%
1152% 691%
1153% 692%
1154% 692%
1155% 693%
1156% 694%
1157% 694%
1158% 695%
1159% 695%
1160% 696%
1161% 697%
1162% 697%
1163% 698%
1164% 698%
1165% 699%
1166% 700%
1167% 700%
1168% 701%
1169% 701%
1170% 702%
1171% 703%
1172% 703%
1173% 704%
1174% 704%
1175% 705%
1176% 706%
1177% 706%
1178% 707%
1179% 707%
1180% 708%
1181% 709%
1182% 709%
1183% 710%
1184% 710%
1185% 711%
1186% 712%
1187% 712%
1188% 713%
1189% 713%
1190% 714%
1191% 715%
1192% 715%
1193% 716%
1194% 716%
1195% 717%
1196% 718%
1197% 718%
1198% 719%
1199% 719%
1200% 720%
1201% 721%
1202% 721%
1203% 722%
1204% 722%
1205% 723%
1206% 724%
1207% 724%
1208% 725%
1209% 725%
1210% 726%
1211% 727%
1212% 727%
1213% 728%
1214% 728%
1215% 729%
1216% 730%
1217% 730%
1218% 731%
1219% 731%
1220% 732%
1221% 733%
1222% 733%
1223% 734%
1224% 734%
1225% 735%
1226% 736%
1227% 736%
1228% 737%
1229% 737%
1230% 738%
1231% 739%
1232% 739%
1233% 740%
1234% 740%
1235% 741%
1236% 742%
1237% 742%
1238% 743%
1239% 743%
1240% 744%
1241% 745%
1242% 745%
1243% 746%
1244% 746%
1245% 747%
1246% 748%
1247% 748%
1248% 749%
1249% 749%
1250% 750%
1251% 751%
1252% 751%
1253% 752%
1254% 752%
1255% 753%
1256% 754%
1257% 754%
1258% 755%
1259% 755%
1260% 756%
1261% 757%
1262% 757%
1263% 758%
1264% 758%
1265% 759%
1266% 760%
1267% 760%
1268% 761%
1269% 761%
1270% 762%
1271% 763%
1272% 763%
1273% 764%
1274% 764%
1275% 765%
1276% 766%
1277% 766%
1278% 767%
1279% 767%
1280% 768%
1281% 769%
1282% 769%
1283% 770%
1284% 770%
1285% 771%
1286% 772%
1287% 772%
1288% 773%
1289% 773%
1290% 774%
1291% 775%
1292% 775%
1293% 776%
1294% 776%
1295% 777%
1296% 778%
1297% 778%
1298% 779%
1299% 779%
1300% 780%
1
Irestraint = (ia-ib)/2
Idif
20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140%
0
0
No Detail
1 @article{Hartmann2009,
author = {Hartmann, Wayne},
doi = {10.1007/978-1-84882-499-7_5},
file = {:D$\backslash$:/References/Protection Relay/TransformerProtection{\_}
{\_}180306.pdf:pdf},
pages = {93--124},
title = {{Transformer Protection}},
year = {2009}
}
2 @article{Bhat1987,
author = {Bhat, P. U.},
file = {:D$\backslash$:/References/Protection Relay/User Guide Transformer
Differential 87T.pdf:pdf},
issn = {0013435X},
journal = {Electrical India},
number = {10},
pages = {23--26},
title = {{Transformer Differential Relaying.}},
volume = {26},
year = {1987}
}
3 @misc{Karyono,
author = {Karyono, Karyono},
file = {:D$\backslash$:/References/Protection Relay/11. Perhitungan Matching dan
Pengaruh OLTC pada Slope Rele Differensial Transformator.doc:doc},
title = {{11. Perhitungan Matching rele Differensial Transformator}}
}
2