LONDON CITY HALL |A Holistic

Design Approach

Architect: Foster + Partners

Location: London, England
Completed: 2002
Size: 130,000 sq ft
Structural Engineer: Arup
Owner: More London Development Ltd.
Current Tenants: Greater London Authority

THE ENVIRONMENTAL CRISIS

Since the turn of the millennium, a heightened

awareness of the world’s environmental issues has
surfaced. Studies done around the world have
concluded that buildings are responsible for
consuming half of the total amount of energy
consumed in the developed world. In addition, few
people are aware that buildings are responsible for
producing half of the world’s carbon dioxide
emissions.

With this rising knowledge, it is apparent that

architecture and the incorporation of innovative
design strategies have the potential to dramatically
influence the earth’s well being. As technology
continues to develop, the ability to explore

1.

Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez

innovative methods of utilizing alternative and
renewable resources comes with greater ease. In
addition, the development of advanced digital
design tools allows architects to explore
environmentally responsible strategies, while
simultaneously analyzing their success.
Overall, greater access to these innovative design
technologies has, and will continue to allow
architects to take on a more holistic approach to
design, just as Foster and Partners did with London
City Hall (Fig 1)(4).

BACKGROUND 2.

In the 1980s, London’s local government had been DESIGN LAUNCH

dissolved and the old government building was
transformed into a hotel and aquarium. With Prime The design for London City Hall was part of a
Minister, Tony Blair’s commitment to bringing back a developer-led competition, which asked for
London-wide government in 1997, the election of a submissions according to a design brief that
new Mayor and Greater London Authority called for required the promotion of transparency and
a new government building (7). democracy (9). In addition to these requirements,
Foster and Partners incorporated their own
The City Hall project was an opportunity to express environmental goals for the project. In order to
the values of the newly formed governing body and produce an energy-conscious design, architects
act as a symbol of change for London (11). The began to collaborate with engineers, Arup, early on
project brief called for a building to house the in the design process. Together, Foster and Partners
Greater London Authority (GLA), which consists of and Arup worked to design the initial London City
the Mayor, London Assembly and their support staff Hall submission, which took the form of a
(8). conventional office block with a debate chamber
positioned at the end (Fig 2)(4).

Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez

After selecting Foster and Partners to take on the DESIGN CONCEPT
project, the jury, consisting of political and
professional representatives, described the desire for London City Hall’s building form is justified according
a more iconic building form. With this direction in to two main design criteria that consist of
mind, the design team took the sketch that democratic and environmental ideals (1).
appealed to the jurors and began to reassess the
presence of the brief requirements (Fig 3). At this Democratic criteria
point, volumetric studies were done by manipulating City Hall begins to respond to the necessity for
and altering the weight of the brief (9). As the design democracy by drawing the public in with its iconic
sequence progressed, the building began to take building form. The ground level consists of a sunken
the form of a more dynamic shape that was outdoor amphitheater that draws the public into an
conceptually underground café and exhibition space located
driven by the directly beneath
detailed brief the assembly
requirements. chamber (Fig 7)(4).
Advanced A central winding
computer- ramp allows
modeling patrons to
techniques symbolically
helped to ascend through all
create iterative ten stories of the
3. studies of 3D building and
models above the debate
throughout the chamber of their
design process elected
(Fig 4)(8). representatives (Fig
5)(1). The ramp
eventually leads
past the mayor’s

4. 5.

Emerging
  Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez
office to what is known as “London’s Living Room”.
This space provides an excellent exhibition space
with its naturally lit spaces, as well as an outdoor
terrace that can accommodate up to 200 guests
(4).

The transparent glass exterior allows the citizens of

London to feel like they are a greater part of their
governing body. The transparent façade allows
Londoners to see directly into the operating
chamber, symbolizing an open system of
government. This idea is enhanced by the building’s
views over the Thames River, Tower Bridge and
cityscape abroad that serve as a reminder of
London’s role as a historically rooted and ever-
developing world-class city. The chamber also
contains 250 seats for public and press viewing of
the GLA’s meetings and debates (8).

Along with the democratic concept, the working

atmosphere created inside of the building is
admittedly not the spacious office type found in a
luxurious office building.
Instead, the inside is more
of a local-government-
style office, where the
workspace is pushed to
the center and open-
plan areas line the
perimeter (Fig 6).
6. 7.

Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez

 Environmental Criteria
Designed to set the standard for environmentally
conscious buildings in London, London City Hall
incorporates several passive and active design
features to achieve its sustainable merit.

Position
Located on the edge of the Thames, London City
Hall takes full advantage of its seclusion from traffic
noise and fumes (Fig 8). In addition, the building is
positioned to receive the fresh air of the Thames and
optimize energy performance according to its
position on site and orientation to the sun (4).

Form
The exterior formal moves are derived from the
desire to reduce the total glass surface area of the
building. In general, a spherical building consumes
25% less energy than cubic building of the same
volume. Therefore, the solar heat gain and heat loss
through London City Hall’s building envelope is
minimized (9).

Envelope
Experimental building simulations showed that the
energy consumption of an office building could be
drastically reduced with the incorporation of
thermally efficient cladding. Consequently, the
amount of cooling and heating loads would
immediately be limited.
8.

Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez

The building envelope also responds to thermal For the creation of these
mapping results, which were derived using three- panels, vector points were
dimensional lighting analyses and a daylight individually fixed according
simulation technique. This to computer coordinates.
technique calculated the For each panel of glazing,
incident solar radiation by four vector points were
calculated the chosen and the planning
illuminance for each contractor then created
panel and converting it offsets, which allowed a
into a heat gain value. machine to measure and
cut the exact size and
In locations along the shape of each panel (9).
façade where the Each panel is composed of
greatest solar impacts high-performance solar-
occur, the ratio of glazing control glazing, insulated
9. 10.
to cladding is reduced opaque panels and
and an operable louver system is used (Fig 9)(4). operable vents.

The angles of the stepping floor plate overhang on Ventilation

the southern façade are calculated to take London City Hall’s
advantage of sunlight during winter and provide environmental strategies
natural shading during summer (Fig 10)(1). In also begin to incorporate
contrast, along the Northern façade, where direct passive control systems that
sun exposure is minimal, the assembly chamber is allow the building to
completely glazed and unshaded (Fig 11). operate more efficiently.
Amongst these systems are
The spherical geometry of the structure required the displacement floor grills
exact measurements of 654 unique panels that were placed below windows that
set at different angles. supply fresh air to the office
spaces. Operable vents

11.

Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez

along the edge of the building also allow for natural Heating and Cooling
ventilation (Fig 12). Displacement ventilation systems Chilled beams along with low-level air supply serve
are used to cool the committee rooms and debate as the main forms of cooling.
chamber.
Borehole cooling allows cool groundwater to be
During winter, a hygroscopic thermal wheel extracts pumped up from the ground to chiller beams in the
heat and moisture from the air and is used to ceilings (Fig 13). After cooling the building, the
preheat the air supply. During the summer, the same borehole water is recycled and used for flushing
system is used to cool the incoming air supply. toilets.

During the winter, mass amounts of heat are lost

through the exposed external wall of the chamber.
In order to heat the chamber, the diagrid façade
structure is used as a large radiator and convector
heater.

The combination of these energy-saving cooling

strategies eliminates the need for mechanical
chillers and
reduces the
annual energy
consumption of
the building’s
mechanical
systems by
approximately
25% that of a
typical office
building (4).

12. 13.

Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez

PERFORMANCE CHECK created more heat that the cooling loads could
compete with. In addition, lights were generally kept
After a year of operation, London City Hall was on all day, producing extra heat loads. David
consuming a reported 50% more energy than it had Kong’s final response emphasized that despite what
been predicted to consume (Fig 14). Prior to reports may say, London City Hall was a
construction, the building was predicted to use groundbreaking office building that implemented
236kWh/sq m, while the recorded consumption in sustainable technologies, which had never been
2003 was 376kWh/sq m. Because the many were entirely incorporated into one London building
persuaded of the building’s form due to its before. He added that all included technologies,
environmental merits, this news was startling to such as borehole cooling, a high performance
officials. A Greater London Authority spokesman façade and photovoltaics, will undoubtedly
commented that the building program was used produce less carbon emissions in the end (9).
differently than initially intended, while it also acted
as a conference center and tourist attraction (2).
David Kong explained that in addition to this, many RETROFITTING
factors out of the architect’s hands had an
influence. This included the tenant housing more By August 2007, a solar photovoltaic system was
employees in the building than predicted, which installed on the roof of London City Hall (Fig 15)(2).
Because photovoltaics did not adhere with the
initial construction program, special measures were
taken to ensure that the roof structure had the
ability to be retrofitted with photovoltaics when
government funding was available (9). Benefits of
solar photovoltaics include providing clean,
inexhaustible energy from the sun while producing
zero carbon emissions (8).

14.

Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez

 CONCLUSION

Standing monumentally as a part of the “More

London” development, London City Hall,
successfully uses innovative practices to declare
itself visibly and functionally as a technologically
groundbreaking building.

With Foster and Partners’ holistic design approach,

the architects were able to deliver not only a
transparent and democratic building, but a building
that incorporated the most groundbreaking and
sustainable technologies of its time.

Today, the building stands proudly, with success

radiating visibly from its transparent façade and
literally from its functioning chiller beams. Marked by
its success, London City Hall will continue to act as a
role model and precedent for many iconic,
environmentally responsible buildings to come.

15. 16.

Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS <http://www.galinsky.com/buildings/cityhall/inde
x.htm>.
I would like to specially thank David Kong of Foster (7) "Greater London Authority." Wikipedia. Web. 20
and Partners for generously donating his time and June 2011.
knowledge to my research efforts. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_London_A
uthority>.
REFERENCES (8) Inside City Hall: Home of London's Government.
Greater London Authority, 2008. Print.
(1) Barker, Don. "Foster's New City Hall." Architecture (9) Kong, David. "Foster and Partners and London
Week. 26 Feb. 2003. Web. 4 June 2011. City Hall." Personal interview. 6 June 2011.
<http://www.architectureweek.com/2003/0226/ (10) "London City Hall: The Queen's Walk, London,
design_1-3.html>. England, SE1." Architecture of London and the
(2) Bennett, Ellen. "Ken's Gas Guzzler." Building Rest of Britain: London Architecture .co.uk. Web.
Design 29 July 2005: 1. Print. 5 June 2011.
(3) Catalogue: Foster and Partners. Munich: Prestel, <http://www.londonarchitecture.co.uk/Building/
2005. 10-11+. Print. 660/London-City-Hall.php>.
(4) Foster, Norman Bürogebäude in ökologischer (11) Shuttleworth, Ken Ein Symbol für die Zukunft / A
Verantwortung / Office Buildings and Symbol for the Future, in "Detail - Zeitschrift für
Environmental Responsibility, in "Detail - Zeitschrift Architektur + Baudetail", September 2002, n. 9 v.
für Architektur + Baudetail", September 2002, n. 9 42 .
v. 42 . (12) Thonger, James Ein schrittweiser Prozess -
(5) Gabriel, Andreas Die Arbeitsweise von Foster und Zusammenarbeit zwischen Architekt und
Partner –ein Interviewein Interview mit Ken Ingenieru / Collaboration Between Architects
Shuttleworth und Max Neal / Foster and Partners' and Engineers - An Iterative Process, in "Detail -
Working Methods - An Interview with Ken Zeitschrift für Architektur + Baudetail", September
Shuttleworth and Max Neal, in "Detail - Zeitschrift 2002, n. 9 v. 42 .
für Architektur + Baudetail", September 2002, n. 9 (13) Vom städtebaulichen Konzept zum Detail / From
v. 42 . the Urban Planning Concept to the Details, in
(6) Glynn, Simon. "City Hall London by Foster and "Detail - Zeitschrift für Architektur + Baudetail",
Partners." Galinsky. 2004. Web. 5 June 2011. September 2002, n. 9 v. 42 .

Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez

Image Credits

1, © 2009 Philipp Klinger; 2, 3, 6, 9-13, 17, Detail

Magazine; 4, 16, © Foster + Partners; 5,
http://www.photoradar.com/photos/80998/amckel
vie/city-hall-london-0; 7,
http://www.london.gov.uk/learning/docs/inside_city
_hall.pdf; 8, James O Jenkins; 14, Building Design; 15,
© Nigel Young, Foster + Partners

17.
Emerging Technologies 2011 Andrea Gonzalez