Saudi Macroeconomic Forecast 2019 - 2023 - Samba
Saudi Macroeconomic Forecast 2019 - 2023 - Samba
Saudi Macroeconomic Forecast 2019 - 2023 - Samba
Despite the revival of animal spirits, the US-China trade dispute will not
be easily resolved. China’s economy is slowing sharply and this will have
spillovers, not just for other EMs, but the Eurozone as well.
The China outlook is also weighing on oil prices. Supply growth has
been partly restricted by OPEC and Russia, but US shale producers
appear more resilient to lower prices than during 2015-16. We still
expect the market to tighten somewhat as OPEC reductions begin to
bite, and there should be some uplift in prices. However, upside is
limited and we expect an average price for Brent this year of $65/b,
edging up to $67/b in 2020 as a weaker USD helps to support demand.
The medium term economic outlook for Saudi Arabia remains positive.
Structural reforms are continuing, albeit in less high-profile ways, and
the fiscal outlook is manageable given multiple financing options and a
low debt stock. Importantly, the current account is set to remain in
surplus, which removes the spectre of the “twin deficits”. The financial
account is more problematic, but it should be supported by increased
James Reeve capital inflows (both direct and portfolio) this year and beyond.
Chief Economist
Samba Financial Group Despite this, domestic activity remains weak. The local private sector is
P.O. Box 6038, Dubai gradually adapting to the withdrawal of state largesse, but it has not
U.A.E been easy and investment is still subdued. The departure of an
+971 (0) 547772151 estimated 1.7 million expatriates has also meant significant hits to both
the demand and supply sides of the economy. Real nonoil growth
[email protected] seems unlikely to exceed 2.5 percent this year, though firmer growth is
This and other publications can be likely inPUBLIC
the medium term as the Vision 2030 project spurs a better
Downloaded from www.samba.com allocation of capital and gradual productivity gains.
February 2019
PUBLIC
2
February 2019
PUBLIC
4
February 2019
climate goals are actively enforced, and the speed with which
Chinese consumers embrace electric (or possibly hydrogen-
fuelled) cars. But note that even if Chinese take up of EVs is
strong, oil demand is not about to fall away: it will still be a vital
ingredient for aviation, trucking and heating. While
acknowledging a great deal of uncertainty, we expect a gradual
increase in oil prices over the medium term, but capped at around
$70/b.
PUBLIC
5
February 2019
Saudi Arabia: Fiscal Developments and the 2019 Budget the oil price boom there was little meaningful budgetary
(SR bn) 2017 2018 2019
Total Revenues 691 894 974
oversight, and spending was often unaudited and wasteful. Since
% change 33.2 29.4 8.9 2016 spending has been rationalised and agencies must account
Taxes: 87 166 183 for their disbursements. Meanwhile, the revenue base is being
income & capital gains 14 16 16
diversified, though oil revenue is still the mainstay of the budget.
goods & services 39 113 132
international trade 19 16 17 Subsidies on petrol have also been reduced, helping to reverse
other 15 20 17 the tide of domestic consumption growth and free up more oil for
Grants 0 0 1 export.
Other Revenue 604 729 791
of which, oil * 436 611 673 The fiscal position improved markedly in 2018. Data released by
Total Expenditure 930 1032 1106
the Ministry of Finance (MoF) alongside the 2019 budget suggest
% change 11.7 11.0 7.2
Current 722 827 860 a deficit of 5.2 percent of our estimate of 2018 GDP (4.6 percent
employees' comp. 420 474 456 of the government’s GDP estimate). The deficit was some
goods & services 136 140 175 SR100bn smaller than that recorded in 2017.
financing 9 17 21
subsidies 5 12 32 Unsurprisingly, oil revenue played a key role, growing by 40
grants 6 3 3 percent. This reflects both the increase in prices and production,
social benefits 48 75 73
other expenses 98 106 100 and a slightly higher take from Saudi Aramco (we estimate 70
Capital 208 205 246 percent compared with 68 percent in 2017). The latter appears to
Balance -239 -138 -132 reflect a new tariff structure that sees the government’s marginal
% GDP ** -9.3 -4.6 -4.2
* Samba estimate
royalty rate increase whenever oil prices breach $70/barrel (and
** Govt. estimate of GDP the scope broadened to capture condensate production). This
Sources: Ministry of Finance; Samba
device helped to offset the impact of a reduced overall tax on
Aramco—50 percent from 85 percent. The measure is pro-cyclical
in that higher oil prices will generate a larger ratio for the
government, though our own oil price forecast suggests that
prices will not breach $70/barrel (in annual average terms).
Nonoil revenue surged last year
The most striking feature of the fiscal results was the big increase
in tax revenue, which almost doubled to SR166bn, or 19 percent
of the total. This is still below the Vision 2030 target for the year
(SR450bn) but it is nevertheless a welcome rise from less than 10
percent of the total in the early part of this decade. The drivers
were VAT, which accounted for a much-better-than-expected
SR45bn; the expat levy (SR28bn); and excise duties (SR12bn).
These taxes have economic consequences (see below) but their
fiscal value is clearly high.
The largest category of revenue is labelled simply “other revenue”
and would appear to include oil earnings, though we have
stripped out our estimate of these. The remainder presumably
includes the proceeds from the energy and electricity price
reforms. The IMF estimates that the removal of subsidies will
have generated SR30bn in 2018, and will rise to more than
SR50bn in 2019. Additional elements of the “other revenue”
PUBLIC
6
February 2019
Fuel and Electricy Price Reforms: Estimated Fiscal Savings account are likely to include fees and charges levied by
(SRbn)
government agencies for various services, and possibly
By Customer 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
Households 23 31 32 32 33 35 investment returns from SAMA, the PIF, and the Human
Non-Households 7 23 45 61 69 77 Resources Development Fund. PIF, for example, has plans to raise
Total 30 54 77 93 102 112 its total assets to SR1.5trn ($400bn) by 2020 and to offer total
shareholder returns of 4-5 percent. These targets could be judged
By Product
Fuel products 23 45 68 85 93 102 optimistic, but even if returns were, say, 3 percent from SR1trn,
Electricity 7 8 9 9 9 9 this would give the government a useful SR30bn a year.
Total 30 53 77 94 102 111
Source: IMF Current spending grew sharply
Current spending saw a sharp 15 percent increase last year (also
well above budget), driven by 13 percent growth in
compensation for public sector employees. This reflects the
Royal Order of January 2018, intended to offset the impact of
inflation on public sector salaries (an initiative that was also rolled
out in most large private sector firms). The order provides a
SR1,000/month payment to public sector employees (regardless
of salary), a reduced amount for public sector pensioners, and
bonus payments for military personnel serving on the Yemen
border. The precise cost of these measures has not been
revealed. Given that the Order was unveiled after the budget was
published, and given that the difference between budgeted and
actual spending on public sector remuneration was SR36bn, it
presumably cost around this mark.
The government has declared that the order will remain in place
for 2019 despite the fact that inflationary pressures are set to
subside (see below). This is contrary to the advice of the IMF,
which worries that outlays of this type can become embedded
and difficult to unwind in the event of a fall in oil prices.
Procurement spending rose for first time since 2014
One area of spending which is much easier to unwind is
procurement. While below budget, this item did actually increase
year-on-year for the first time since 2014. That said, spending on
this category was just SR140bn—some 60 percent below the 2014
figure (and lower still in real terms). Procurement spending is (or
was) one of the key ways by which the government distributes oil
revenue throughout society. In that sense it was a cornerstone of
the “old” Saudi economic model, which encouraged Saudi firms
to provide goods and services to the government for large
margins—thanks in part to abundant cheap labour—but with
little value added. The Vision 2030 project aims to replace this
model with one that puts productivity at the heart of private
sector development. The change is fundamental and has meant
difficult adjustments for many private sector firms (see below).
PUBLIC
7
February 2019
PUBLIC
8
February 2019
PUBLIC
9
February 2019
PUBLIC
10
February 2019
PUBLIC
11
February 2019
PUBLIC
12
February 2019
PUBLIC
13
February 2019
PUBLIC
14
February 2019
PUBLIC
15
February 2019
PUBLIC
16
February 2019
PUBLIC
18
February 2019
PUBLIC
19
February 2019
The financial account has been in deficit, but there is little clarity
on nature of flows
The financial account therefore warrants close inspection.
However, analysis is hampered by a lack of detail on the different
flows (SAMA’s balance of payments layout follows the IMF
template, but is not disaggregated beyond the basic divisions).
Three quarters of official data show that the financial account
recorded a cumulative deficit of $44bn. Given that the deficit was
a hefty $27bn in the third quarter alone, it could well be that the
full-year deficit will eclipse that of 2017, though full year net
foreign asset data point to stabilisation in the fourth quarter.
Most of the outflows have been through the “other investment”
channel, though net errors and omissions are likely to have been
around $38bn for the full year.
Saudi Arabia: Balance of Payments
($ billion) 2018e 2019f 2020f 2021f 2022f 2023f
Current account balance 83.8 53.3 67.2 82.6 93.9 96.4
Direct investment -19.0 -12.6 -10.2 -6.9 -4.6 -3.2
Abroad (net) -22.0 -17.6 -17.2 -16.9 -16.6 -16.2
in KSA (net) 3.0 5.0 7.0 10.0 12.0 13.0
Portfolio investment 2.0 43.3 23.7 27.4 32.8 21.7
Abroad (net) -13.0 -11.7 -11.3 -11.0 -10.7 -10.4
in KSA (net)* 15.0 55.0 35.0 38.4 43.5 32.1
Other investment -28.0 -33.7 -27.3 -27.4 -21.8 -17.0
Abroad (net) -45.0 -43.7 -39.3 -35.4 -31.8 -27.0
in KSA (net) 17.0 10.0 12.0 8.0 10.0 10.0
Financial account balance -45.0 -3.0 -13.9 -6.9 6.4 1.4
Net errors and omissions** -38.1 -34.5 -26.3 -22.1 -7.4 -8.6
Overall balance 0.7 15.8 27.0 53.6 93.0 89.2
Change in reserves (- = increase) -0.7 -15.8 -27.0 -53.6 -93.0 -89.2
Official NFA 489.6 505.4 532.4 586.0 678.9 768.2
percent GDP 70.1 71.6 72.0 75.4 83.3 89.7
import cover (months) 47.8 47.4 47.7 50.2 54.8 57.2
* includes sov debt inflows
** includes capital account, which is minor
Sources: SAMA, IMF, Samba
That said, there are reasons for optimism in the longer run
Prima facie, therefore, the financial account remains a problem;
but there are a number of caveats that suggest that the situation
is not as troubling as first seems. First, the current account is in
surplus and is likely to remain there for the next five years and
beyond. This removes the spectre of the “twin deficits” and
provides the momentum for NFA accumulation. Second, the
Tadawul’s full inclusion in the MSCI EM and FTSE Russell global
indices will see substantial portfolio inflows, this year at least.
Third, PIF activity is likely to mean “short term pain for long term
gain”. Thus, we see that foreign direct investment outflows were
a cumulative $17bn in the first three quarters of 2018,
presumably most of which was PIF-related. All being well, these
investments will yield significant inflows (captured on the current
account) in due course. Related to this, one would also expect
PUBLIC
20
February 2019
PUBLIC
21
February 2019
Saudi Arabia: Baseline Macroeconomic Forecast 2017 2018 2019f 2020f 2021f 2022f 2023f
Nominal GDP ($ bn) 684 698 706 740 777 816 856
GDP per capita ($ '000) 20,897 21,844 22,159 22,598 23,104 23,645 24,198
Real GDP (% change) -0.7 2.2 0.4 2.4 3.0 3.3 3.7
Hydrocarbon GDP -4.3 3.5 -2.7 1.5 1.0 1.5 1.5
Non-hydrocarbon GDP 1.1 1.3 2.5 3.0 4.2 4.4 4.9
Money supply, M2 (SR bn) 1791 1841 1951 2049 2192 2390 2605
% change 9.5 2.8 6.0 5.0 7.0 9.0 9.0
Commercial bank loans to private sector (SR bn) 1327 1366 1429 1514 1651 1849 2108
% change -0.7 2.9 4.6 6.0 9.0 12.0 14.0
3 month interbank rate (end year, percent) 1.9 3.0 3.0 2.5 2.3 2.2 2.4
CPI inflation (% change, average) -0.8 2.5 -0.4 2.5 3.0 3.1 3.1
Hydrocarbon exports ($ bn) 170.2 232.7 204.2 220.7 231.5 241.7 248.5
% change 25.0 36.7 -12.3 8.1 4.9 4.4 2.8
Current account balance ($ bn) 14.7 83.8 53.3 67.2 82.6 94.6 97.0
(% GDP) 2.1 12.0 7.5 9.1 10.6 11.6 11.3
Fiscal revenue (SR bn) 692.0 895.0 836.2 906.1 975.8 1061.7 1144.2
(% change) 33.2 29.3 -6.6 8.4 7.7 8.8 7.8
Fiscal spending (SR bn) 927.0 1032.0 1097.0 1147.4 1189.4 1222.4 1260.8
(% change) 11.7 11.3 6.3 4.6 3.7 2.8 3.1
of which, capital 205.0 205.0 221.4 230.3 239.5 249.0 261.5
(% change) 53.0 0.0 8.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 5.0
current 722.0 827.0 875.6 917.1 949.9 973.4 999.3
(% change) 3.7 14.5 5.9 4.7 3.6 2.5 2.7
Fiscal balance (SR bn) -235.0 -137.0 -260.8 -241.3 -213.6 -160.8 -116.6
(% GDP) -9.2 -5.2 -9.8 -8.7 -7.4 -5.4 -3.8
Public sector gross deposits with banking system (SR bn) 737.7 724.8 658.0 605.8 575.7 560.3 553.6
(% GDP) 28.8 27.7 24.8 21.8 20.0 18.9 18.2
Other public sector domestic deposits (SR bn) 1147.0 1225.7 1225.7 1225.7 1225.7 1225.7 1225.7
(% GDP) 44.7 46.8 46.3 44.2 42.5 41.3 40.3
Total public sector gross deposits with banking system (SR bn) 1884.7 1950.5 1883.7 1831.5 1801.4 1786.0 1779.3
(% GDP) 73.5 74.5 71.1 66.0 62.5 60.2 58.5
Memoranda:
Oil price (Brent; $/barrel) 54.0 71.0 64.5 67.3 69.0 70.0 70.0
Crude oil production ('000 b/d) 9,968 10,318 10,004 10,150 10,252 10,405 10,561
SAMA's net Foreign Assets ($ bn) 488.9 489.6 505.4 532.4 586.0 679.9 770.6
(% GDP) 71.5 70.1 71.6 72.0 75.4 83.4 90.0
Central government domestic debt (SR bn) 259.5 312.3 415.6 494.2 630.3 686.1 826.6
(% GDP) 10.1 11.9 15.7 17.8 21.9 23.1 27.2
Central government external debt ($ bn) 47.2 60.2 80.2 105.2 129.6 155.1 166.1
(% GDP) 6.9 8.6 11.4 14.2 16.9 19.6 20.5
Sources: SAMA; Ministry of Finance; General Statistics Authority; IMF; Samba.
PUBLIC
22
February 2019
James Reeve
[email protected]
Disclaimer
This publication is based on information generally available to the public
from sources believed to be reliable and up to date at the time of
publication. However, SAMBA is unable to accept any liability
whatsoever for the accuracy or completeness of its contents or for the
consequences of any reliance which may be place upon the information
it contains. Additionally, the information and opinions contained herein:
PUBLIC
23