Tribology in Industry: M. Belahcene, R. Mazouzi, M. Lounis
Tribology in Industry: M. Belahcene, R. Mazouzi, M. Lounis
Tribology in Industry: M. Belahcene, R. Mazouzi, M. Lounis
11
Tribology in Industry
RESEARCH
www.tribology.rs
Keywords: ABSTRACT
Friction
For the different operating regime of an internal combustion engine, the
Lubrication
compartment ‘Piston-Ring-Liner’ represents the largest share of frictional
Piston-Liner
power loss. This study presents a numerical analysis of
Thermohydrodynamic model
ThermoHydroDynamic (THD) lubrication of an internal combustion
Viscosity
engine piston to evaluate the thermal effect on the friction of piston-
cylinder contact by considering three thermal models: isothermal, Global
Corresponding author: Thermal (GT) and THD. The results show that the choice of the thermal
model has a great influence on the tribological characteristics of the
Maamar Belahcene
piston-cylinder contact. The transition from the isothermal model to the
FIMA Laboratory,
THD model will lead to a decrease of approximately 6% of the minimum
Faculty of Science and Technology,
oil film thickness and an increase of 4% of the hydrodynamic pressure, and
University of Djilali Bounaama
the transition from the GT model to the THD model will decrease 30% of
Khemis Miliana, Khemis Miliana,
the friction force in the piston-cylinder contact during an engine cycle.
44225, Algeria.
E-mail: [email protected] © 2018 Published by Faculty of Engineering
643
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
elasticity of the skirt, without taking into account with a new analytical thermal model. The
the thermal effects on the tribological generated contact temperatures, particularly at
characteristics of the contact. Gradually, some the inlet result in thinner films than the idealised
researchers recognized the importance of analyses. In 2011, Syed and Malik [15] present a
including thermal effects in hydrodynamic ThermoElastoHydroDynamic (TEHD) model
lubrication analysis. Two approaches have been which determines the effect of the variation of the
proposed to account for the thermal effect in lubricant viscosity and the piston displacement
lubrication. These are the GT study and THD velocity on the tribological characteristics of
study. The first is to assess, from isothermal piston-liner contacting. An increase in engine
theory, the energy dissipated in the film, which is velocity reduces the transverse displacements of
used to calculate an average operating piston and minimizes the risk of a physical
temperature. The second is to simultaneously contact between the skirt and the liner. Thermal
solve the energy equation and Reynolds equation effects play an important role in the functioning
that takes into account the variation of the of lubricated contacts.
viscosity through the film thickness.
In order to compare the different thermal
The variation of lubricant viscosity with approaches used in the tribological study of a
temperature is crucial insofar as it affects piston-cylinder contact. A mathematical model of
engine’s performance. Unfortunately, these a piston skirt of mixed lubrication is presented. It
effects are typically ignored in the models that are considers the thermal effects on the tribological
used to design engine components. Here the characteristics of contact as the hydrodynamic
viscosity of the oil film is generally assumed to be pressure, the oil film thickness and the frictional
constant over the cycle [2,4,5]. In recent years, to force. The hydrodynamic pressure field is
achieve the higher lubrication and cooling calculated by the finite difference method. The
demands of engineering design, research on resolution of the energy equation by the method
thermal effects has become meaningful and of Gauss Siedel with relaxation used to determine
important because of its great influence on the temperature field.
lubrication performance [6-9]. Richardson [10]
carried out a theoretical investigation into the
effects of viscosity variation and the effect of 2. THEORY
temperature gradient on lubrication. He
concluded that temperature of the oil film is In Fig. 1a, the piston position and velocity are
equivalent to the temperature of cylinder surface related to the crank angle ψ.
with the experimental results corresponding to
the theoretical results. On this basis, other
researchers have made tests with variable
viscosity depending on the skirt surface
temperature. Dowson et al. [11] and some other
researchers [12,13] found that the steady-state
THD condition includes three forms of thermal
effects: viscous dissipation produced by the
shear-rate within the oil film, conduction from or
to the metal surfaces, and convection within the
lubricant. In 2013, N. Morris [14] shows that the
power loss due to viscous friction under
isothermal condition throughout the engine cycle
a) b)
is actually larger than the losses of a thinner film
with quite similar effective viscosity due to the Fig. 1. Piston/cylinder system. a) Field of piston
lubrication, b) Forces and moments acting on the piston.
small rise in lubricant temperature in the short
contact transition time. Analyses are often
For a constant crankshaft speed, the piston
idealised, such as isothermal condition and
position and velocity are given by [16,17]:
smooth surfaces, the former being particularly
contrary to practice. An analytic solution to the
average flow model is presented for this contact
s l r 2 Cp 2
0.5
r cos 2 B 2
0.5
(1)
644
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
moment. The equations of motion are derived The hydrodynamic friction force and its moment
based on the dynamic equilibrium of all the forces about the wrist pin may be calculated from the
and moments applied to the piston. The system shear stress:
equation can be expressed as the following: L
(14)
b a
F fh 2 R ddy
a b 0 0
m p 1 ma 1 m p ma
L L L L eh F FS F tan (4) L
b Ip b eb M M S M f (15)
Ip
L m p ( a b ) 1
L
m p ( a b )
L
M fh 2 R ( R cos C p )ddy
L 00
For the contact pressure, we used the
with
approximate solution given by Zhu [2] for an
FS ( FG FIa _ y FIP _ y )tg (5) aluminum piston:
M S Fg CP FIP _ xCg (6) Pc 5.464 1013 1.0552 (16)
The hydrodynamic pressure is governed by the with δ is the deformation of the wall.
Reynolds equation, which is written with the
assumption of an incompressible thin film and a The total contact force acting on the piston skirt
laminar flow [16,17]: and its moment about the wrist pin may be
calculated by:
h 3 ph h 3 ph
6U dh 12 h (7) L
x x y y t (17)
dy Fc 2 R Pc cosddy
00
In our case the forces and moments, Fh and M h
L
are due to the hydrodynamic pressure developed (18)
M c 2R Pc (a y) cosddy
in the oil film for the portions of surfaces limited 00
L
ph ph
Pc R cos C p ddy
0 (9) M fc 2c f R
U (20)
0 U
00
645
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
2.1. Equation of the viscosity with where is the viscous dissipation, it is expressed by:
temperature
U 2 U Ph (25)
h2 2 y
In the isothermal study, lubricant viscosity is
constant throughout the procedure The energy equation is discretized by the finite
hydrodynamic calculation. To determine the difference method and solved by Gauss Siedel
lubricant viscosity in the engine cycle of the GT method with relaxation coefficient. This
and THD study, we used the Vogel equation [18] resolution allows obtaining the temperature
which is most suited in the case studied: field in the oil film. The boundary conditions
𝑩 used to solving the energy equation are:
𝝁(𝑻) = 𝝆𝒂𝟎 𝐞𝐱𝐩[𝑪+𝑻] (22)
y 0 T T0
where a0, B and C are Vogel correlation (26)
T
parameters. For SAE-20 oil, ρ= 832 kg/m3, y L y
0
a0=0.058 cst, B=1028 °C and C=108 °C.
and
2.2. Temperature equations T for 0 and (27)
0
In the GT study, the oil temperature varies
The discretization of the energy equation by the
slightly between the top and bottom of the
finite difference method gives as:
piston skirt, and it varies quite substantially
between the position of Top Dead Centre (TDC) c pU K c 2K c 2K c c pU K
Ti , j c Ti 1, j
y y 2 Ti 1, j y 2 R 2 2 y y 2
and the position of Bottom Dead Centre (BDC)
on the liner. To set this variation, we use the K K U 2 U Ph
2 c 2 Ti , j 1 2 c 2 Ti , j 1 2
Woschni correlation [19]. R R h 2 y
x (23)
T(x) TTDC (TTDC TBDC ) 2.3. Resolution method
S
where T(x) is the liner temperature, presumed In order to approximate the lubricating
to be the same as the lubricant temperature [20, pressure field, we employ the finite difference
21], x is the liner location (measured downward method with a uniform grid, rectangular mesh
from TDC), TTDC and TBDC are the temperatures at elements is used for the film, with m elements
the TDC and BDC. The temperature profile is in the axial direction (y) and n elements in the
shown in Fig. 2. circumferential direction (θ). Only the area
where there is the lubricant film is considered.
The symmetrical nature of the piston in the
circumferential direction was adopted (Fig. 3).
Equation (4) and equation (7) are nonlinear in
P, et and eb, and are solved by the iterative
Newton-Raphson method after discretization
by finite differences.
646
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
engine cycles.
The calculation procedure is presented in fig. 4.
At each time step (or crankshaft angle), the
Reynolds equation (7) and the equations of
piston motion (4) are resolved. We start by
introducing all geometry and simulation data of
this mechanism as shown in table 1 and all
values of combustion gas pressure which
presented in Fig. 5.
647
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
rest of cycle. Once the oil film thickness h is slightly because of the temperature stability
calculated as given in equation (21), Reynolds against in the GT model, we can see the wide
equation (7) is resolved using a new value of Ph variation in viscosity caused by the large change
based on the available values of eh, eb, et and eb . of the lubricant temperature.
After, we calculate all forces and moments which
are located on the right side of equation (4). If
residues of equations (4) and (7) less than 10-5,
the convergence criterion is satisfied for Ph, et
and eb and we pass to the next time step. The
temperature field is calculated by equation (24).
The convergence criterion is satisfied for T when
δT/T<10-7 at each successive time step for the all
engine cycle. After that, the oil viscosity is
calculated after the determination of lubricant
temperature as written in equation (22).
Execution with one time step which
Fig. 6. Variation of lubricant temperature with crank angle.
corresponding to 5 degrees of crankshaft angle,
requires 20 to 80 iterations for the solution
convergence. For a four-stroke engine, with two
towers of crankshaft (720 degree crankshaft
angle) for each cycle, it is noted that during the
execution test, convergence of the periodic
solution is obtained from 3 to 4 engine cycles.
3. RESULTS
The results presented in this section focus on the Fig. 7. Variation of dynamic viscosity during the
engine cycle.
tribological characteristics of the contact
(viscosity, temperature, film thickness ...). The
The Fig. 8 shows the temperature distribution in
different operation models of the contact
the oil film at crank angle ψ = 285° of the THD
between the piston skirt and cylinder
model. In this figure, the temperature is uniform
(isothermal, GT and THD) has been considered.
and equal to 48 °C over the entire film, except for
an increase of temperature at the top side of the
The Fig. 6 shows the temperature variation as
skirt caused by a heat transfer by convection in
function of crank angle in the engine cycle. It is
right side of the combustion chamber from 59 to
observed that, the temperature ranges from 89
150 °C. However, at the bottom of the piston, the
°C to 115 °C during the engine cycle. In the THD
temperature is about 37 °C.
model, the variation is of around 1 °C, from 93 °C
to 94 °C. This difference is explained by the
model used, in the GT model, the average
temperature of the lubricant is determined from
the temperature of the solid (liner) shown in Fig.
2, which varies between the TDC and the BDC
positions but, in the THD model, these values are
obtained from the numerical solution of the
energy equation which is defined by the
boundary and initial conditions of real model of
Fig. 8. Temperature distribution in oil film at ψ = 285°.
heat transfer in the piston operation. The
temperature changes affect directly the lubricant
viscosity as shown in Fig. 7. In the isothermal Hydrodynamic pressure distribution in oil film
model, the values of viscosity are constant at a crank angle of 395° (just after the gas
during the engine cycle with a value that is 0,016 combustion) for the three models is presented
Pa.s. In the THD model, oil viscosity varies in Fig. 9.
648
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
649
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
region. The position of maximum friction differs It note that, the hydrodynamic friction force
according to the liner working temperature, reached a maximum value in the middle of each
which also affects the film thickness and the race because of the elevation of the piston sliding
lubricant viscosity. speed shown in Fig. 15 for the engine speeds of
1000 rpm, which generates a high shear rate in the
oil film and therefore a high hydrodynamic friction
force, against it vanishes with the change of piston
displacement direction with zero speed at TDC and
BDC. Throughout the engine cycle, the
hydrodynamic friction force is higher in the GT and
THD models comparing with the isothermal model
as can be seen in Fig. 16 due to the lubricant
viscosity that shown in Fig. 7, which is generally
higher in the model GT compared to isotherm and
THD models throughout the engine cycle.
Fig. 14. Hydrodynamic friction force in an engine Fig. 17. Average Total friction forces in an engine
cycle of the three models isothermal, GT and THD. cycle of the three models isothermal, GT and THD.
650
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
The average total friction force in an engine project, In IMechE seminar: a drive for fuel
cycle is shown in Fig. 17. efficiency, Loughborough, UK, September, 2011.
[2] D. Zhu, H.S. Cheng, Y.Z. Hu, T. Arai, K. Hamai, A
Throughout the engine cycle, the total friction numerical analysis for piston skirt in mixed
forces of the THD and GT models are higher than lubrication, part ii: deformation considerations,
the isothermal model. The transition from the ASME Journal of Tribology, vol. 115, iss. 1, pp.
THD model to the GT model will lead to an 125–133, 1993, doi: 10.1115/1.2920965
increase of 6 % of the average total friction force [3] V.W. Wong, T. Tian, H. Lang, P. Ryan, Y. Sekia, Y.
in an engine cycle. The explanation for this Kobayashi, S. Aoyama, A numerical model of
increase directly related to the viscosity of the piston secondary motion and piston slap in
lubricant film. A low oil viscosity can reduce the partially flooded elastohydrodynamic skirt
hydrodynamic friction forces in THD model. lubrication, in Annual congress and exposition,
Detroit, MI, SAE paper 940696, 1994, doi:
doi.org/10.4271/940696
4. CONCLUSION [4] K. Liu, Y.B. Xie, C.L. Gui, A comprehensive study of
the friction and dynamic motion of the piston as-
This analysis shows that thermal effects should be sembly, Proceedings of the Institution of
included in the study of piston-cylinder contact. Mechanical Engineers, Part J: Journal of
The surface temperatures of the solids contact are Engineering Tribology, vol. 212, no. 3, pp. 221-
226, 1998, doi: 10.1243/1350650981542038
influenced by the combustion gasses and heat by
viscous shear of the lubricant film and more by the [5] S. Balakrishnan, H. Rahnejat, Isothermal
heat generated through contact friction. Therefore, transient analysis of piston skirt-to- cylinder wall
a realistic model should encompass boundary contacts under combined axial, lateral and tilting
interactions. The results confirm a viscous shear of motion, Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics,
vol. 38, no. 5, pp. 787-799, 2005.
the lubricant film under thermal mixed
hydrodynamic regime of lubrication. Three [6] F.M. Meng, Y.Y. Zhang, Y.Z. Hu, H. Wang, Thermo-
thermal models are presented to evaluate the elasto-hydrodynamic lubrication analysis of
thermal effects on the piston-cylinder contact. The piston skirt considering oil film inertia effect,
analysis shows that the transition from the Tribology International, vol. 40, iss. 7, pp. 1089-
Isothermal model to the THD model will lead to a 1099, 2007, doi: 10.1016/j.triboint.2006.10.006
decrease in the minimum oil film thickness and an [7] R. A.J. van Ostayen, A. van Beek, Thermal modelling
increase in the hydrodynamic pressure, and the of the lemon-bore hydrodynamic bearing, Tribology
transition from the GT model to the THD model International, vol. 42, iss. 1, pp. 23–32, 2009, doi:
will decrease 30 % of the contact friction force in 10.1016/j.triboint.2008.05.013
the contact. Three thermal models are presented [8] M.A. Ahmad, S. Kasolang, R.S. Dwyer-Joyce,
to evaluate the thermal effects on the piston- Experimental study on the effects of oil groove
cylinder contact. The comparison of the three location on temperature and pressure profiles in
models presented in this work can be used to journal bearing lubrication, Tribology
evaluate the contact friction of piston for improve International, vol. 74, pp. 79–86, 2014, doi:
the efficiency of the internal combustion engine. 10.1016/j.triboint.2014.02.012
[9] J. Durany, J. Pereira-Pérez, F. Varas, Some
aspects of lubrication in heavy regimes: Thermal
Abbreviation effects, stability and turbulence, Mathematics
and Computers in Simulation, vol. 102, pp. 90–
BDC Bottom Dead Centre 103, 2014, doi: 10.1016/j.matcom.2013.09.005
GT Global Thermal [10] D.E. Richardson, G.L. Borman, Theoretical and
TEHD ThermoElastoHydroDynamic experimental investigations of oil films for
THD ThermoHydroDynamic application to piston ring lubrication, SAE
TDC Top Dead Centre Technical Paper, No. SAE-922341, 1992, doi:
10.4271/922341
651
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
Engineers, Conference Proceedings, vol. 181, no. [22] F.P. Incropera, D.P. Dewitt, Fundamentals of heat
2, pp. 70–80, 1966, doi: and mass transfer, 5th edition, New York: Wiley,
10.1243/PIME_CONF_1966_181_034_02 2002.
[12] K.W. Kim, M. Tanaka, Y. Hori, A three
dimensional analysis of thermohydrodynamic
performance of sector-shaped, tilting-pad thrust NOMENCLATURE
bearings, Journal of Lubrication Technology, vol.
105, iss. 3, pp. 406-412, 1983, doi: a : Vertical distance from the top of piston skirt
10.1115/1.3254625 to the wrist-pin (m)
[13] T. Han, R.S. Paranjpe, Finite volume analysis of b : Vertical distance from the top of piston
the thermohydrodynamic performance of finite skirt to the piston center of gravity (m)
journal bearings, Journal of Tribology, vol. 112, c : Radial clearance between the piston and
iss. 3, pp. 557–565, 1990, doi: the cylinder (m)
10.1115/1.2920293
Cf : Boundary friction coefficient
[14] N. Morris, R. Rahmani, H. Rahnejat, P.D. King, B.
Fitzsimons, Tribology of piston compression ring Cp : Distance of the wrist-pin from the axis of
conjunction under transient thermal mixed piston (wrist pin offset) (m)
regime of lubrication, Tribology international, cp : Specific heat oil (j.k-1)
vol. 59, pp. 248–258, 2013, doi:
10.1016/j.triboint.2012.09.002 et , eb : Eccentricities of piston at the top and
[15] Q. Syed Adnan, M. Afzaal Malik, A. k. Mumtaz, bottom of the skirt respectively (m)
Riaz A. Mufti, Low viscosity shear heating in F : Total normal force acting on the skirts of
piston skirts ehl in the low initial engine start up both sides (N)
speeds, Tribology international, vol. 44, iss. 10,
pp. 1134–1143, 2011, doi: Fb : Connecting rod force (N)
10.1016/j.triboint.2011.04.018 Fc : Normal force due to solid-to-solid contacts (N)
[16] D. Zhu, H. S. Cheng, T. Arai, K. Hamai, A Fgaz : Combustion gas force acting on the top of
numerical analysis for piston skirt in mixed piston (N)
lubrication- part i: Basic Modelling, ASME
Journal of Tribology, vol. 114, iss. 3, pp. 553- Ff : Total friction force acting on the surfaces of
562, 1992, doi: 10.1115/1.2920917 skirts (N)
[17] R. Mazouzi, P. Maspeyrot, A. Kellaci, D.D. Rahal, Ffc : Friction force due to solid-to-solid contacts
Effet des parametres de conception du piston sur (N)
le frottement jupe-chemise, Mécanique & Ffh : Friction force due to hydrodynamic
Industries, vol. 10, iss. 2, pp. 91-101, 2009, doi: lubricant film (N)
10.1051/meca/2009037
Fh : Normal force due to hydrodynamic
[18] A. Cameron, Basic lubrication theory, Third pressure in the film (N)
edition. Ellis Horwood LTD., 1983.
Fia_x, Fia_y : Inertia forces due to wrist-pin mass (N)
[19] G. Woschni, K. Zeilinger, Vorausberechnung des
Kolbenringverhaltens, in FVV Workshop, Fip_x, Fip-y : Inertia forces due to piston mass (N)
Tribosystem Kolben – Kolbenring - h : Lubricant film thickness, (m)
Zylinderlaufflaeche, 10. Okt. 1989, VDMA-Haus
Frankfurt. Ip : Piston rotary inertia about its center of
[20] Z. Ma, N.A. Henein, W. Bryzik, A model for wear mass (kg.m2)
and friction in cylinder liners and piston rings,
Kc : Thermal conductivity (w.m-1.k-1)
Tribology Transactions, vol. 49, iss. 3, pp. 315-
327, 2006, doi: 10.1080/05698190600678630 L : Piston skirt length (m)
[21] R. Rahmani, H. Rahnejat, B. Fitzsimons, D. l : Connecting rod length (m)
Dowson, The effect of cylinder liner operating
M : Total moment about wrist-pin due to all
temperature on frictional loss and engine
the normal forces (N.m)
emissions in piston ring conjunction, Applied
Energy, vol. 191, pp. 568-581, 2017, doi: Mf : Moment about wrist-pin due to all the
10.1016/j.apenergy.2017.01.098 friction forces (N.m)
652
M. Belahcene et al., Tribology in Industry Vol. 40, No. 4 (2018) 643-653
653