Comparative Research Overview
Comparative Research Overview
Learning Objectives:
Comparative researchers study cases looking for patterns of similarities and differences.
Typically a comparative study will examine anywhere from a handful to fifty or more cases that
the researchers study in depth. The design of a comparative research study is relatively simple.
The specimens or cases will be different in some regards and similar in other regards. The
comparative method is design to focus on the differences and explore why the cases are different.
It is a commonly used method in social science research when there are relatively few cases, but
many variables in each case. It is method that often chosen when researchers are looking for
patterns of diversity or differences among cases.
To a certain extent, all research is comparative in nature. However, the comparative method is
different than the qualitative and quantitative methods previously discussed in other modules.
The qualitative method focuses on the commonalities and similarities between the cases. The
researcher may use the similarities to classify the cases into categories. Quantitative researchers
are similar to comparative researchers in that the focus is on the differences among the cases. In
quantitative research, though, the emphasis is on the differences in one of more variables across
the cases. The comparative method focuses on the differences and variances between the cases
themselves and seeks to explain those differences. Therefore, it is a considered to be a method
that focuses on the diversity of the cases. The comparative method is sometimes described as
falling between qualitative and quantitative research.
The goals of comparative research are to explore diversity, interpret cultural or historical
significance and to advance theory. Following are some examples of comparatives studies with
these goals in mind:
Exploring Diversity:
Advancing Theory:
Examining the number of government welfare programs and comparing it among the
states only to find there are more type of programs than originally anticipated.
Studying the differences among cases in an effort to find the cause of the differences and
thereby, advance understanding of a particular concept.
There are two main styles of comparative studies – descriptive comparisons and normative
comparisons. The majority of studies are descriptive comparisons that are designed to describe,
and often explain, the cases and the differences among them. Normative comparison studies are
a special style of research that goes beyond simply describing the cases by using at least one
“evaluative” criterion. The goal is to be able to provide the basis for change or improvement the
cases or objects. Both of these styles compare cases by emphasizing the differences among the
cases.
There are several types of comparative research studies. The upcoming modules will focus on
three of the most common types including cross-national comparisons, historical comparisons,
and causal comparisons. The Resource Links on this page contain additional information about
types of comparative research.